The Return of the Taliban: Afghanistan After the Americans Left | Dr. Hassan Abbas & Pervez Hoodbhoy

[@TheBlackHoleOfficial]

Note: This session took place on 6th May, 2023.

[@karamjitsinghnannar7408]

Internal contradictions of Islamic world are sufficient to destroy it .

[@dr.pawankumararyan4892]

Salute to Parvez for sensitivity and care for humanity...

[@adarshkumar8777]

Hi Dr. Parvez Hoodbhoy ji, I welcome your Black hole you tube channel. I am very happy that you are educating children in different fields. Please keep helping these children. I am sure one day a child will take Pakistan to new heights in the world.

[@sherozgill2334]

Sir Kya Pakistan Taliban ko protect krty krty khud hi Afghanistan ni banta ja raha?

[@Anti-corruptionNetwork-s9q]

Dear Dr. Hassan, Given that your book's readers primarily consist of the younger generation, it's crucial to ensure accurate terminology for the warriors who have played significant roles in the past four decades. Following the Soviet Union's invasion, it's important to note that the resistance forces who valiantly opposed the Russians and their backed government in Afghanistan were referred to as Afghan Mujahideen, not the Taliban. The distinction becomes particularly important in understanding the historical context. After the Russian withdrawal in 1987 and the subsequent collapse of the supported Afghan government in 1992, the nation endured a tumultuous period marked by looting. During this time, a fresh wave of individuals took up arms against the Mujahideen - these fighters were recognized as the Taliban. In essence, clarifying these terminologies is pivotal for the accurate portrayal of the events that unfolded during this complex period. By addressing these nuances, your book will provide a comprehensive and clear understanding of the historical narrative to your readers. Sincerely, Khan Zaman

[@vinodkhanduri2214]

As you sow so will you reap.

[@muhammadikram6452]

when ghani govt used to say Pakistan act against questa shura or karachi shura then Pakistan said give evidence. Now taliban saying give evidence of TTP presence in Afg.

[@dinabandhumudi46]

Great conversation Lots of knowledge gain Love from India

[@gosliglitzho]

Pakistan looks at Afghanistan as some object they can use for personal benifit to have "strategic depth" and what not. Pakistan looks down on Taliban as a terrorist organisation which they can use as a tool to manipulate world powers. India views Afganistan as brotherly nation who is in need of support. India builds infra, educates its people, tries to make Afghanistan self reliant, Wishes Afghanistan to return to its glorious days, no matter which government is in power in Afghanistan.

[@tariqaziz783]

Good to see, many people still think critically.

[@rajkhosla8513]

Parvez saab Awesomeness 👌

[@amaruddin974]

Dr Hussain Abbas sahib, please include the role of war lords in formation of Taliban government and the absence of political parties in Afghanistan.

[@mikesheth5370]

Dr. Hassan wants full involvement of West in Afghanistan!

[@nasirmustafa2492]

Pakistan should not have interfered in the internal affairs of Afghanistan.

[@mohsinafzaal7159]

Excellent discussion ❤

[@muhammadikram6452]

A very good platform

[@zararajputbhatti7374]

Questions were good in the end

[@VimalKumar-lj3vu]

Brother you are assets of human beings ❤

[@shishirtamotia3992]

How and what right any nation or institution has to discuss anything with Taliban until they guarantee equal rights to women?

[@alimohtashimkhan2711]

Beautiful discussion.

[@sharjeeljawaid]

Excellent session

[@uttamdey455]

Afganistan people are .main responseble for the full history. They are wanted to use other but they are used for other.

[@KabirSingh-kg9dd]

Strategic depth is becoming strategic death'

[@gkwithafan3939]

I used to appreciate your video perveez sir. But jab sir ne pashtoono ki baat shoro ki tu ap ne jan boj k osy cut kiya... 27:55 pe... Moje buhat afsos huwa

[@muhammadikram6452]

when muhsin dawar and Ali wazir manzoor Pashteen said the same don't support Afghan Taliban then some so called patriotic were blaming them for anti Pakistan

[@haroonrashid7463]

Appreciations for the good discussions to see the way of better Pakistan in the light of previous decades,although we remained disturbed

[@aqeelanwar7571]

Very informative

[@ameeralishah9352]

A humble suggestion to your honor,Dr sahib, what a great if you could have titled it (A light in a black hole)

[@kpdwivedi1672]

Very interesting

[@uttamdey455]

Please read the history properly Go to bacck. And why Pakistan are. Marking teririsism. That is not solutions

[@uttamdey455]

General people of afganistan are really don't know how much full they're..

[@nasirmustafa2492]

Millions of Pathans live in Punjab. They have properties and run businesses and even then they speak I'll of the Punjab.

[@AmjadAli-xl6mq]

Please call Afrasyab KHATTAK sometime in your next program

[@sprinkleroilfish]

Hum first, hum first! 😂

[@shishirtamotia3992]

Violent methods can not be accepted under any circumstances?

[@rebasingh258]

Pakistan trained the Taliban and gave tgem shelter in Pakistan. Then the Pakistan army helped the Taliban to conquer Afghanistan. Now Taliban is paying back gratitude to Pakistan by attacking them.

[@aniruddha453]

Invite raza rumi, mirtaza solangi, anwar maksood, najim sethi. In next program

[@dinabandhumudi46]

Ali wazir zindabad

[@naveenbangalore362]

Your Majority of common ppl and state with establishment celebrated the return, so why r u cribbing now?

[@MuhammadaliAli-yg5qq]

Assalam Walekum bhai aapko Maloom Hona chahie aapke bahut se log aap ka program KZbin per Dekh Kar Maloom pad Hasil karte hain is Silsile mein aapka yah kam bahut hi like 27

[@sumitabose-US]

Strangely many of your guests/intellectuals talk as if they are in a “chai ki adda”, answers are never succinct or to the point and thoughts are presented with too much rambling. Yet the topics and ramifications are so important for the future of Pakistan and it’s people.

[@aniruddha453]

First time Disappointed with guest .

[@MuhammadaliAli-yg5qq]

Assalam walekum professor Hote Sahab aapko Maloom Hona chahie ke aapke bahut se followers FIR KZbin per aap ka program dekhte hain aur isase Humko bahut kuch Jaan ka Milta Hai Hamari knowledge mein data her Shah Jafar hota hai aur iske liye mein aapko Mubarak baad deta hun ke Aise dudh Mein Bhi Jab Ke Har Taraf pabandi lagi ho aur aap science ke bare mein physics ke bare mein politics ke bare mein Mai Pakistan ke bare mein se 4:30 se Jim Pakistan ke

[@saeedr7863]

کوئی حکومت جو عوام کی مرضی اور ووٹ کے بغیر بنے ناجائز ہے۔

[@khkarandoyzazai]

Modern Muslim Intellectual is profoundly portrayed by Dr. Mohammed Iqbal ترا وجود سراپا تجلی افرنگ کہ تو وھاں کے عمارتگروں کی ھے تعمیر مگر یہ پیکر خاکی خودی سے ھے خالی فقط نیام ھے تو زرنگار و بے شمشیر۔۔۔

[@muaznazir7474]

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

[@dinabandhumudi46]

PTM zindabad

[@haroonrashid7463]

Pakistan 🇵🇰 zindabad :how will we get the justice and democracy in Pakistan for the public

[@mian_G37]

American supported isk and daish

[@dinabandhumudi46]

Imran Riaz Khan zindabad

[@sudhanshujha1325]

Hi I am Sudhanshu I am from India

[@aniruddha453]

Plz one program on Mk Gandhi and BR Ambedkar.

[@zararajputbhatti7374]

Pathetic and boring criticism.. waste of time