The SB19 and ShowBT Situation is WORSE than you think...

[@shamhere414]

Ginawa na namang content ang problem/issue ng 1Z. Tahimik Lumalaban yung Mahalima pero sinasamantala ng mga expert na clout chaser.

[@CashualChuck]

Edi wag kang manood 😂 parang hindi din content yung mga pinopost nyo sa twitter ah! 😂 At least eto my effort. Iyaken amp hahahahha

[@saimatiban9944]

@@CashualChuck ang sama ng reply mo nagmumukhang guilty ka parang ang basura A’TIN kaba Talaga? Mga ganyang reply sayu hindi nagkakalayu sa mga basurang humarap sa watawat ng pilipinas pero binabash ang kapwa pilipino

[@skizo.frenia7021]

The issues are out in the open and many vloggers have given different opinions about it.. I’m glad I get privy of the BTS and confirmed that they are not being treated well and why they decided to be free from their previous management.. praying for a speedy and successful resolution to this problem..thanks Chuck

[@iam_bear05]

Jusko ante Ang Dami nang mga sentemyento about this issue, wag ka manood!!!!simple lang my god!!!!

[@shamhere414]

@@iam_bear05 Di ako nanood. Nagcomment lang ako.

[@user-wr9dx7ed7d]

Base in your content seems like the boys went through a lot of hard times not treated well by their old company, let's keep fighting for them!!

[@wanderwonder2104]

How to boycot that Mr. Charles Kim??!! Don't let that foreigners mistreat any of Filipinos in our own land. Damn him!!

[@vybzalways5293]

Easily said thank done.aren't there Filipino companies mistreating filipinos themselves.if they were being mistreated ,i think they would have taken it to court when they left the company and made theres.what fans see as mistreatment may be different from what the law considers mistreatment

[@ariesrobdiamond1794]

There are a lot of Filipino companies mistreating Filipino workers too, morally and legally.

[@CharitoBano-gu8jo]

​@@ariesrobdiamond1794n so.. u mean ok lng un Sayo?

[@missppop]

Yes, may karapatan yung shwbt in terms of law sa trademark issue, but meron din silang mali na ginawa, yung mistreating ng employees nila at may parusa din yun ...sana ..di ba pwede iakyan yan sa human rights violation?

[@josephinerosales8935]

Ang sarap kulamin ni 😅ck bwesit cya pinahirapan nila ang Mahalima

[@user-hs2tf6pu8o]

I’m watching from the US and find how the manager manhandled Josh, horrifying. Here, CK can be sued for battery. SB19 should look into this and if any kind of abuse happened behind closed doors, file a case. A’tin should also petition for an investigation regarding how a foreign company is treating Filipino citizens. Not just SB19 but the other groups under the management as well. A’tin, unite and let your voice be heard!

[@sassyfangirl23]

Ipa trend Sana to.

[@ChristineMPL]

Sana may lumabas pang ibang resibo for maltreatment. Siguro pwede iyong ipanglaban sa kabila, at maging dahilan kung bakit sila umalis.

[@hgc0220]

May nakita nga ako video ng kpop girl group na kumakanta tapos ung isang member nagka seizure daw. Tuloy pa rin cla sa pagsasayaw at pagkanta. Kawawa ung isang member nila.

[@ChristineMPL]

@@hgc0220 grabe naman

[@user-mf2tr3bl1o]

@@hgc0220 yes! Napanood q un, kc sabi dw pg mgstop silang mgperform (other members) malalamn na ng lilip sync sila.. Kya may pumunta sa stage na mga staff taz saka xa binuhat palabas

[@nicelann2606]

now we're talking. 🔥🔥🔥 i guess this is more than just greed then, it's also what seems to be a betrayal on the management's side. but as they say, "a boss has a title, a leader has the people," and clearly everyone has sided on the boys. great content as always, chuck...❤

[@introvertedoldsoul9146]

I’ve been an ESL Teacher for Korean students with ages ranging from 15-50. Also worked in a 5-star hotel with mostly korean guests in Cebu before. So I’ll speak from my experience. The attitude and character of CK shown here in the video is not surprising kasi tbh, in general, Koreans look down on Filipinos. This is a reality, a lot of Filipinos can speak the same based from experience. A lot of them are rude especially to service workers, e.g., waiters, employees My point here is, never ever let any foreigner of this land make you feel inferior, mistreat you in any way, just because they have white & nice skin, have more money, speaks English well, etc. In this case, SB19 clearly must have ALL the Filipino people’s support. I hope this serves as a lesson to everyone to start appreciating what our very own can offer, especially if they’re 💯 worthy of supporting naman. To Mahalima, rest assured we’ve got your back! We will support you in this fight. As cliche as it sounds, LABAN LANG. Pagpatuloy ang pagwagayway ng watawat! 💪🏻🇵🇭

[@cresenciavalero5223]

True, I have worked with Korean businessmen and expats, the office is affilliated with Korean embassy. They love to gossip and they look down to all pinoy as big joke. Every hankook gatherings you can hear them making fun of whatever they can see to all pinoys.

[@joyang4630]

It's about time siguro matigil na pag maltrato o abused na ginagawa ng ibang music company sa kanilang mga talents. Baka ginamit lang ng Panginoon ang Mahalima para masilip ang kasamaang ito. Hindii lang sa Filipino.

[@SightseeingwithNoelda]

Totoo yan. Nakikita ko mga Korean blogger sa kanila mismo nanggalung yang ganyang attitude ng kapwa nila Korean.

[@lizbecs]

I have 2 incidents with Koreans which were both unpleasant. I was waiting for a queue to check in Korean airlines in Paris. I was called by the ground steward to check in in the first class when a couple minutes later, 3 Korean men in suits demanded they be treated first. The ground steward just shooed them off and told them to wait for their turn. Also happened during a lay-over in Frankfurt airport. You have lanes for ECC and non ECC. This Korean woman approached me and said: I think you are in the wrong lane. In my anger, I flashed her my European passport that it almost hit her face. Namumula yung face niya but didn't even apologized.

[@queendaenerys6583]

Agree 101%

[@urbanlioness]

Hoping and praying that the " issue" can be settled AMICABLY as soon as possible .🙏✌️💞

[@impoprice]

Great video, Chuck! I'm glad you include videos addressing the maltreatment SB19 has experienced. I'm really hoping for a positive outcome for them. And thank you for always using my video too. I appreciate it, man.

[@CashualChuck]

You're the best bro. You're killing it!

[@dinasahagun4049]

My opinion is that the entertainment industry is a cut throat industry. You’re right to say that legally SBT is on the upper hand but morally the boys has the upper hand. They say you have to be tough to survive in the industry. I hope the boys don’t develop bitterness in their hearts. I am with you on this I want all this BS to be done with and let the boys create and perform their music. With the last part about how CK treated the boys, definitely no respect for the boys!!!

[@missppop]

Sana talaga may isang tao or group na mag save sa mga boys sa lahat ng mga ito...SANA LANG TALAGA IPAGPRAY NATIN....MARAMI NAMANG MATITINONG TAO SA INDUSTRY NA KABABAYAN NATIN...

[@fambamny]

I will continue to pray na sana matapos na din ang pagsubok na ito for Our Mahalima. It hurts me the most nang makita ko sa video how CK treated the boys before. CLEARLY, WALANG RESPETO. For me, Parang puppet talaga ang turing niya. Kahit naman sino if that’s how you got treated, mapapagud ka din. Sending my LOVE and SUPPORT TO OUR MAHALIMA ALWAYS AND FOREVER 💙💙💙💙💙 Salamat Chuck for this video.

[@teammakafuture8242]

Superb! Wala talaga yang respeto si CK sa mga boys, eh bakit ganun nalang comment niya kahit simpatya na nga lang eh. Kinamote!

[@chrissantiago2355]

That is why human rights violation on company here should be establish regardless if its.pinoy or foreign companies. Specialy owned by foreigners. In fact its a question about this company, i dont believe they have right to operatr 100 , company shld be co owned by filipino

[@dinasahagun4049]

@@chrissantiago2355 I am not knowledgeable about the Philippines' law. I know there are stipulated labour law and business law clauses. If there is is not covered then the government should do something about it. I know that the Philippines also thrive on getting foreign investors, however, we should also protect the rights of employees or contractors.

[@rexymorales1135]

We also hope the Philippine Government will help our AMBASSADORS OF YOUTH!.

[@lalalunaaa14]

not surprised with K beauty standards. They let people believe that they value talent over visuals. Pablo, Stell, Josh, Ken and Justin were more than just a visual and they prove them wrong by dominating the world with their talents and charismatic auras. Don't let them drag you down Mahalima. Take your time to recharge and come back stronger 💙

[@MARISSAFEHERRADURA]

We are all waiting to exhale.

[@venithomas201]

The way Mr. Kim behaved towards the boys showed how he thought about them. He thought of them as property, the way they treat their talents in Korea. Sometimes to the point of humiliating them. Is that how we want to be treated in our own land??

[@SB19_fanaticforever]

Baka nga siguro kaya madaming suicide cases ng mga artists sa Korea.

[@adnylgodrallag0411]

This what "Sulli" mentioned in her documentary. Talents in Korean industry were perceived as commodity.

[@lovetheday23]

i think the President of OPM should investigate this to our FIlipino Boy group MAhalima abt the treatment of CK. THIs is PHIlippines and not KOrea. THe congress should be part of this trnasaction when handling or putting a business in PH esp in music its abt time they take action on it.

[@nollymogato955]

CK is so rude to the boys bad attitude 😢

[@MARISSAFEHERRADURA]

I think this maltreatment is the reason the boys chose to break up with the firm and risked cancelling the concerts rather than comply with their demands to pay up more for the use of the tradename. Its not worth their mental health, creative growth and the promising bright future ahead going it alone.

[@stephanieallangarman5598]

I’m coming from a Non-Asian perspective.. I love Pop genres from other Countries. However, I’ve noticed in the last several years Kpop Fans DO NOT support Pop from other Countries. I’ve responded to a lot of hateful comments and I couldn’t understand the HYPOCRISY that they promote heavily everywhere else but if they feel threatened by other countries POP … to me of course this is to be expected…. I now only listen to Independent Artists and I avoid the TOXICITY of that specific genre. I’m praying for SB19 and asking that they wisely get out of this situation. Charles Kim is a jerk and that’s my personal opinion. 🙆🏻‍♀️❤️‍🔥🙏🏽🇺🇸

[@rachellara9067]

I beg to disagree that the boys overlooked the usage of the name. It took them months to confirm they are self managed, and more time has passed before they formally launched 1Z. They have a legal team behind them. Surely they are doing their work. During the media launch of Pagtatag, Stell mentioned that they know they will have a hard time using the name. They are paying royalties. They were able to complete the US and Canada Tour without a hitch. Then all of a sudden this happened? The boys are not greedy. They have paid their dues and much more. Lahat ng naitulong ng ShowBt sa kanila, naibalik na nila. So who is greedy now?

[@hualian5339]

I think the same thing... it's impossible that they don't know.... but the difference is that the more sb19 publicize themselves the more popular they get. it is possible that there's already a talk between these parties before since they made a US tour and launched their company without a hitch, it might be bcoz the negotiations have failed and the asking price for their name and songs must be higher than expected. that's why they're having a problem. And one more thing is that maybe they don't want sb19 be more popular than those kpop acts.... their concerts are being cancelled in asia then there's that AAA what name would they bring...it seems like everything is too timely in my opinion.

[@missppop]

Yes true but the thing is wala kasi silang official announcement, kaya lahat speculation. Kung ano kasunduan nila before parting ways. Tapos biglang parang ambigat gamitin ng name nila parang napaka bawal na...and malinaw lang yung nasa IPO na trademark ng name na nasa shwbt parin, kaya lahat yun ang starting point ng problem.

[@LukasJose-tk7go]

Its about legalities. Keep ur opinion to yourself. We are all against how they trwat the boys but the law says everything.

[@rachellara9067]

What other official announcement would you need from them? If there's an on going case, hindi sila pwdeng magsalita about it. May narinig ba kayo galing from the other party? They might have been given a gag order so lalo ng mahirap mag comment. Tas hinahanapan nyo pa ng announcement? It's just plain panggigipit ang ginagawa sa kanila. Kumita ng husto yung world tour nila so malamang mas malaki ang hinihingi. They've been milking the boys for all they're worth. If I were them, I would give up the name. They are better of without it. It would cease to exist without the boys. Kahit ipagamit pa nila sa iba, it would never be the same.

[@mytubeaccount143]

Nagmadali din kasi mga bata mag leave ng showbt kasi di talaga marunong mag manage si Charles Kim. Pero sana di nila dinaan sa yamot at dinaan sa magandang pag uusap. Atsaka bakit nila pagkatiwalaan Ang BlackStar na mag produce ng concert sa Asia, eh bata ni Charles Kim yang si Jon Pinto. I'm sure Alam nila yang trademark law pero kung hihiwalay sila sa ShowBt sana nag isip muna ng bagong pangalan bago nag schedule ng concerts. Pero pagnag iba sila ng name baka mag give up yung sponsors nila.

[@rhodavillos751]

As a former data analyst, I believe in Pablo's strategies, a 13-hour company meeting means every minute details and angles had been tackled in their transition for being self-managed, including legal issues. As a proof, it's all in the Crimzone lyrics in Pablo's part - "Had to cut ties With do-double crossers Just to thread the needle Weasel shoo! Don't need you Kase ngayon alam ko na what to do I sneeze achoo Para mawala na ang flu Coz I got lot of things to do, ooh" ... Their Plan B is ongoing, and thanks to all their endorsements and Ninangs, as of the moment, one by one they're reclaiming what they deserve as "gem" artists Pablo, Josh, Stell, Ken and Justin, as MAHALIMA who's well-loved by everyone because of their authenticity, level-up creativity, and humility.

[@angelynelpedes9876]

Galingggg, lyrics unlocked nanaman

[@yhanie9185]

I feel better with this. Thank you

[@Sorscha09]

Wow, that makes sense. Thanks.

[@madelynempaces9430]

CK CLEARLY shoved Josh. CK ,it seems is not a very patient man. And with the hats, that wasn't nice to say the least. Imagine if CK can treat the boys with in front of people , I can deduce now on how they are treated behind the curtains. My POV.

[@cheritanarag1301]

baka may verbal abuse pa na natanggap ang mga boys sa taong to... or baka may physical abuse pa pero di lang nagsasalita ang mga boys... POV ko din yan

[@catttt1224]

The boys have the right to choose who will manage them. They have all the rights to build their own company and it’s not greed, that’s GROWTH. I know SBT has invested a lot for them but I think the boys have paid and served them with several endorsements, concerts, events, vlogs, etc. Their 3 years training was not even paid. Yes, it is SBT who’s the main reason why there is SB19, but it is the boys’ talents and dedication why they made it this far. And I don’t think the boys overlooked or didn’t think any trademark issues before they left the company. They are not dumb to not even think of this. I think they have an internal agreement with SBT as they would not be able to use that name for more than a year now if there’s no such agreement. Stell even mentioned during the IWY media launch that they’ve gone thru a lot even with their name SB19 itself. I trust that they already have a plan or been working on this for a long time so let’s just support them no matter what. 💙

[@SB19_fanaticforever]

🙏🙏🙏

[@missppop]

yung maalala mo na wala silang makain halos nung training nila mapapaisip ka talaga kung naginvest ba or inalagaan ba talaga sila ng maayos ng showbt, ni mas pinapaboran yung bgyo mas pogi daw, ano ba naman yun klase sila.....jusko..

[@ma.rouhiehtominaga7158]

​@@missppop Kasi Po sa Korea mataas discrimination pagdating sa itsura kaya madami nahihikayat magpa retoke. Saka sa industry na yan madami karimarimarim sinapit ng kpop groups. Ganon na din sa ibang artists, been mistreated and harassed kaya madami na rin nag suicide.

[@angelogumnad8206]

We also have to keep in mind that we Filipinos are generally loyal. The boys loyalty (I think) was more to Tatang Robin and less to SBT, when SBT was acquired by CK, he did not work to get their loyalty. We can see the relationship b/w tatang Robin and Mahalima was genuine. Maybe CK feels betrayed by the boys, but we as a people develop ties to other people and less with institutions.

[@bargainhuntermama]

Didn't Tatang Robin take them on mall and campus tours to promote the company? Do you think those events were without costs? Doesn't the company have paid employees that helped the boys? A lease payment for the building where they trained? I get it that we're not happy with ShowBT but do not discount what they did for the boys, especially before the pandemic. Unless you're in the inner circle and have seen the books, we really have no right to make these type of accusations. I know it's easy to get emotional and I too am angry for SB19 and what they are going through. Let's not also get too emotional and spread things that are conjecture, speculation, etc. These could sometimes be more harmful rather than helpful to the boys.

[@jungsky5469]

Nice analysis Bro Chuck... ngayon may katibayan na tayo bakit gusto nila mag self manage 😔

[@annete-que414]

HE WAS NOT ENTIRELY sure of SB19’s making it, but when these 5 Gentlemen proved that they will be successful despite his lack of confidence in their visuals, he now wants a portion of the fruits of their labor!!! Gusto ko patalsikin ang Banyaga na to…

[@joyang4630]

Balikan ninyo ang ending ng gento. Naghirap at sikap ang Mahalima at nakuha nila ang tagumpay(ginto). pero nakabox parin sila sa mga alien/banyagang gustong kamkamin ang gintong pinaghirapan nila. #Freedom

[@babebibobooo]

​@@joyang4630yhupp. Everything make sense sa MV ng song. And then ung rapline ni Pablo sa Crimzone "Had to cut ties With do-double crossers Just to thread the needle Weasel shoo! Don't need you Kase ngayon alam ko na what to do" Sa "double crossers" na line parang sinsbi ng mahalima na natraydor sila so baka may initial agreement s pag gamit ng name/trademark na SB19 pero baka biglang binawi ng kabila. Speculations lang to ha, ngsheshare lng ako. Lahat tayo haka2 lang talaga unless may VERIFIED inside info kayo.😢

[@princedanielgerona7375]

@@joyang4630 so sad....

[@SB19_fanaticforever]

Nakakapanggigil. Ang liit ng tingin niya sa lima . 😡🤬

[@joyang4630]

Hindi tamang mangmaltrato o mang api ng kapuwa. Bagabagin nawa sila ng Panginoon ng malagay sila sa katuwiran.

[@suilujtv3762]

Welcome back Chuck... I felt sad for mahalima they were mistreated by their former company. I hope they can settle this issue very soon and I hope the result will be much favorable for them. Let's just pray A'tin that this end soon.

[@5hy_for_Mahalima]

But you know what, Tatang Robin never treated them that way.. I saw it with my own eyes. Lahat ng events nila malaki man or maliit, Tatang ang Ms. Hong Ganda were always with them. Remember the accident of Stell during their performance in PUP? That's how they were treated. Ibang iba kay CK. That's why I have so much respect for Tatang Robin.😢

[@mya_xo]

thank you for clearing this up, as an international fan i was really confused on what's been going on.. in my opinion, it's the boys hard work, dedication and talent that make them who they are - SB19. and its so wrong of charles kim to say that other group is 'more' handsome, its just weird behaviour. i hope this issue gets resolved so the boys can keep doing what they love

[@joyang4630]

Ang lakas ng loob ng ibang sabihing pangit ang kapuwa nila. Di muna tignan ang sarili nila. #StopBullying

[@angelogumnad8206]

He was trying to promote the other group and create a rivalry. It doesn't work that way in the OPM/PPOP setting, rivalries do exist but its more of a friendly rivalry. With each artist or group having their unique style. No Filipino artist would want to be labelled as the ones who tear down others just to get ahead. Thats a guarantee that you'll lose your fanbase since the Filipino "crab mentality" attitude is severely looked down upon.

[@SB19_fanaticforever]

Let's pray for the mental health of our MAHALIMA. Di basta-basta pinagdadaan nila. Ang sakit sa dibdib at nakakapressure tong pinagdadaanan nila. Sana madadaan pa sa pakiusap yang si CK.

[@fecabaya2350]

I've waited so long for this legit info from Chuck. This is it. Praying for our MAHALIMA 🙏

[@Feysbuk_]

OMG! What a revelation! Seeing those clips of CK's treatment to the boys in front of their fans? Very disgusting and unprofessional! Good thing that they left him and that company already! I feel sorry for our boys that they had experienced such treatment from that greedy man!

[@darrensdiary]

Good job chuck. Honest and brutal docu. I'm enjoying your open minded options. Salute

[@CashualChuck]

Thanks Darren

[@mavicpulmano6574]

​@@CashualChuckhi Chuck...maybe there's another angle of breach ..as you mentioned, during the time of pandemic, they were left on their own, that is a breach, hence, it is not fully true that the company fully invested on the boys since the boys took it upon themselves to make their group going wo d expected support during the lowest period - the pandemic....that is a breach of agreement ...that is my view on this ..the law may state provisions that appears to favor one party Bec of some DEFINITIONS but everything is DISPUTABLE in court down to the very definition of a word and all that is attached to it that evens criminal can be acquitted depending on how they argue their case. Nothing is conclusive just bec there were written provisions Bec it is a case to case basis. In writing the company may own the trademark but in practice they have not done their part by fully supporting the boys most esp when the pandemic happend. The pandemic is not expected but legally it is NOT AN EXCUSE to just leave and drop support to their talents. For me, that is a breach. Even employees have rights before they accept terms and conditions laid down. They have rights not to do work beyond their scope..etc etc

[@glennbarbado4664]

Very good Casual Chuck maraming butas ang batas natin na pwedeng hindi nila na anticipate but then tama na iayos nila muna ito ng naaayun sa batas.A'tin si more mature and patient konting tiis lang para sa Mahalima never forgot na pangarap at buhay nila ang nilalaban nila.

[@mariejhomortega9873]

Best Attorney lng ang need ng Mahalima, Need din nila maka hanap ng butas sa SHOWBT. Need din BOYCOTT ang mga talents galing sa kanila , Sorry na lng sa mga talents nila , Hindi ako ipokrita kaya sinasabi ko ang nasa puso ko .And ayaw ko na umasa na matutuloy Concert nila dito sa Japan kc alam ko Mahaba proseso niyan .At alam ko yung mga ka kaps ko dito sa Japan mauunawaan yan .Stay safe and strong Mahalima , God bless💙💙💙💙💙

[@Reggiemind]

Thanks for this video! Really sad about whats happening with the boys and missing their presence..in Gods time everything will be okay 🙏❤️

[@thedapilar-pineda6239]

Chuck, thanks for this. It's not that we don't think about this issue, you just said it out loud and knowing that we are all in the same boat is a consolation. Yes, at this point we just hope that this legal issue with our boys gets resolved soon so that we can go back to listening to great music and going to their concerts.

[@user-cw2ju5db7r]

Namiss ka namin Chuck ❤

[@yhanie9185]

Sana may mas matibay na batas naman na kayang protektahan ang mga artists. Lalo na against abusive alien companies

[@missppop]

TAMA ITO RIN NAISIP KO..BAKIT BA KASI NAPAKATAGAL NG CONTRACT NG GANYAN DI BA PWEDE 2-3YEARS NALNG PEDE NAMAN MAG RENEW OR HINDI KUNG MAAYOS NAMUMUNO....

[@mayogracias2389]

Korek na korek Lalo na sa mga Dayuhang na abusado sa artists NILA at Dito pa sa atin bansa ha nagagawa.. Ang talento Ng mga Pinoy artist Ang nakikita Hindi sila.. naway maayos at matulungan Ng magagaling na lawyers Ang ating kababayan

[@MAHALIMAKOH19]

Salamat naman kahit papano maiibsan ang pangungulila sa Mahalima. You save our night Chuck!😊❤

[@m.c.miller1581]

I hope Pablo, Stell, Josh, Ken & Justin will come out of this as the victors!🙏🏼

[@sarahgrace9018]

Prayerfully...

[@ma.rouhiehtominaga7158]

They will..

[@stephenlam3536]

they won’t win

[@ysagamboa4407]

they will win, claiming it now

[@stephenlam3536]

I bet you $1 million they won win

[@mamitaSB82523]

Thank you Chuck, yours is the voice i have been wanting to hear. Power on, ignore your bashers ❤❤❤MAHALIMA, boys keep safe and healthy. God bless always😊😊😊

[@itsyazzypoo]

As usual Chuck, you approached it as objective as you possibly and humanly can. I hope this video reaches out to the farthest A'tin and casuals out there

[@cynderellaparcs3751]

Sadly those so called lumang tao are mad again telling everyone not to watch this video😔😔😔

[@readizon5607]

Sa true, feeling pag - aari ang lima. mukha nio uy😂

[@Halcyuni]

I totally agree! I don't know why some A'tin find this video offensive. For me, chuck only lay all the cards on the table. He was being rational and objective. It also opened the eyes of everyone what the boys have been through from their former company.

[@arbinacabiloque4071]

Yes they didn't know all along

[@seyah4ever23.ATINJP]

We Japan A’TIN praying na matuloy ang con nila dito. If hindi naman nakaka sad pero kung sa ikakabuti ng Mahalima makakapag wait kami sa pagbabalik nila stonger. Sana malagpasan nila eto.

[@littlesugarme9496]

I was shocked to what he did to Josh. I remeber from his personal vlog during What? MV BTS he brought some snacks for the boys like Cream bread, banana milk and gummy bear candies. I’m trying to imagine how tired they were during the shoot and yet that’s the only food they’ve got. Hope not. The boys were really patient and persevered.

[@gerrydiza4103]

Thank you for your insights. Overlooking IPP rules is a negligence for any business wanting to have a trademark, copyrights and patents for keeps. ❤ For sure our Mahalima had grown wiser, moreso, that they are entering into the world of business and entrepreneurship.

[@kmeade6205]

Let's be honest, the kind of company where nearly EVERY trainee quits at least once because the conditions are so harsh probably does not have a healthy or fair working environment. I am glad they are fighting to be in control of their own lives, careers, and create a company that values artists. I hope ShowBT does the right thing and sells the trademark. Mahalima should be allowed that, no matter their motives.

[@carmelitafloirendo26]

Glad to hear from you again Chuck..alam ko d mo matitiis ang mga boys! Waiting!🥰

[@joyang4630]

Ilang taon ding nagtiis ang Mahalima sa kanila. For sure malaki narin ang kinita ng SBTPH sa kanila.

[@DANDJREACT]

Awesome video man! We will be reacting to this soon. Thanks for all the work you do. Give casual chuck a like and follow everyone!

[@angiesaile1976]

Thank you D&J for always supporting our boys and choosing casual chuck video for your RV. It's really heart breaking knowing all this kind of treatment that our MAHALIMA suffered from this greedy people...

[@DANDJREACT]

@@angiesaile1976 You’re welcome ☺️ We feel the same way. Hopefully they get it fixed soon.

[@allimaj]

1Z will not keep using the name without any agreement. Stell emphasized during Pagtatag media launch that keeping the name was one of their adversary before releasing Pagtatag. There could be an agreed amount to use the name. And as blessings poured to SB19, SBT could have demanded for additional amount base on their current market value and 1Z entertainment was not having it.

[@emeritacamaclang282]

yan din ang unang pumasok sa isip ko, sbt is demanding more than what was previously agreed upon

[@Martin-yh7vi]

Tingin ko tama ka, meron silang agreement on how much they can use the name/logo. I don't believe yun legal team nila would have forgotten of the most important things before sila umalis sa ShowBT completely. So whether tama man ako o mali, I seriously doubt may rights silang na-infringe.

[@catheriner7703]

That is really possible yan din po hinala ko nung nagstart itong issue na ito, kasi wala naman naging prob sa US tour nila pero yung Asia tour na recently lang nila pinlano yun yung nagka problem so I feel iba na yung asking price nila for Asia Tour especially since naging matagumpay US tour nila nakilala pa sila lalo sa ibang bansa and naging cover pa ng billboard ph. Baka nga pati yung sa billboard eh sinisingil sila about dun since yun yung name na gamit nila.

[@notyourordinarybird]

it pains me to watch how that Korean was treating the boys -- shoving them around, treating them like puppets in front of other people -- how much more if nobody's around? Pablo, in one of his interviews said, when they finally have their own talents, they will not let them experience what they had... This speaks volumes! 😢 I just pray that things will be settled soon...

[@lingling5636]

All I can say is Pablo, Josh , Stell, Ken and Justin are never greedy. With their character traits, it is very ovbious, that they are very , very generous and the most patient, kind , loving, respectful and God fearing persons.(btw, during the What MV, not a single centavo was spent by showbt, everything was spent by the mahalima boys, they said it during Darla’s interview with them).And showbt got his share of course. And when the US TOUR was successful, again, he got his enormous share, now knowing that there’s an ASIA tour, this time , they may be asking not only more, but more more some more.I guess CK is the greedy one, typical koreano agency.

[@user-mz9wn8mp4h]

I trust our mahalima kuya.😢 I know they will get through this and will finally get the freedom they deserve. I miss them sm😢

[@jacolyn12]

Medyo ibang labanan talaga if you own your own business or company. As someone with business experience, the legal battles can be never ending. BIR, labor etc..... I am really hoping talaga na maayos ito as soon as possible. Although common ang trademark issues sa music industry, it is almost unheard of na hindi makuha ng artist ang kanilang pangalan. Kaya kung ito talaga ang issue, ShowBT, release the name na please. I also hope na mag release ng kahit anong klaseng statement man lang ang ating mahalima, or kahit anong klaseng reassurance to their fans, so that people can understand better. Lalo na, na may pending pa silang Dubai and Japan concert. Love you Mahalima, will be patiently waiting for your return.

[@genamarie358]

They might be tied up by a non-disclosure agreement. We never know. Let us hope and pray for them.

[@missppop]

We will understand naman lahat ng sasabihin nila. At gagawin kung ano ang dapat nating gawin para sa kanila Mahalima..

[@jampy3214]

Hays, agree sa statement. Lalong gumugulo habang nananhimil sila sa totoo lang

[@noor-zn4qc]

Pag legal na po talaga ma's mabuti manahimik sila di sa ayaw nila but for more safety reason dito ma test ang fans how much they really understand and care for the situation of the boys malalim po ang ugat ng battle nila kaya sa mga fans A'tin taasan nyo pa ang pang unwa at pagmamahal iyong ang kailangan nila ngayon nasa rorok sila ng pagsubok katulad din ng kanilang kasikatan ... virtual hug po sa lahat proud ako sa mga A'tin for your undying support sana matapos na nila ang ano mang pagsubok at babalik na ma's matatag with their new songs ❤❤❤

[@user-mf2tr3bl1o]

As for Dubai concert, pag tomorrow d p.a. sila mkaalis ng ba sa for.sure cancelled nanamn yan. 9 hrs flight taz rest, day after concert. Aq na po gumawa ng sked😂

[@mulancruz9028]

SBT & Blackstar probably allowed esbi to use their name after the 5 left the company. There must have been some arrangement made cuz blackstar (jpinto) was apparently the producer of the pagtatag shows. It's unthinkable that esbi didnt know about the trademark issue. That they continued to use it must have some kind of agreement or approval between the former mgmt and themselves. Why this turned sour is still the mystery; somehow, somewhere trust must have been breached leaving esbi to a greater legal and financial disadvantage because sbt holds the trademark contract.

[@missppop]

Unless the previous company desperately needs money, also their talent is not producing at all..

[@smurfetteph2767]

@@missppop They didn't expect SB19 to grow so big, and now that they are getting bigger and bigger, and they want A BIGGER PIECE OF THE as without SB19, they are nothing.

[@nelsadolit9874]

Generally speaking, mababa ang tingin ng mga koreano sa Pilipino. Hindi ito hakahaka, ito''y personal na experience at inamin naman ng iba. Kailangan din siguro ma masilip sila sa mga technicalities o legitimacy ng business nila dito sa Pinas.

[@user-pp1zv6hp8z]

I pa tulfo na Yan para ma band sila Sa pinas.kung umas ta Sa MGA pinoy parang sino.

[@morena_0318]

😭🙏

[@shineshine177]

Yup.at mga benepisyo ng artist

[@shineshine177]

True..isang employee ng korean..200 kada araw libre meal..hindi ko alam kung makatao yun ha..tapos halos lahat yung employee yung gumawa ng work tapos itong si boss naghihintay lng ng clients😅

[@angelabaro8187]

"They're legally right, but morally wrong" - This hits me the hardest. When you know they're in deep trouble but can't do something about it 😥💔 To my fellow A'tin, let's not make any more issues that would affect them, let's just do what we can do to SUPPORT our #MAHALIMA Thanks Chuck for being objective in this matter ❤

[@angelish_titirak2717]

💯😭🥺💙

[@josephinerosales8935]

Ang sakit Lang ....😢

[@angelabaro8187]

@@josephinerosales8935 masakit talaga kaps! Pero kung ganito ka heavy satin, just imagine what they're going through right now 😢

[@reenolem7872]

Well expected na yan na cancelled na lahat ng concerts nila... let us wait for a stronger, bigger & brighter mahalima! 💙💙💙💙💙

[@avatarroku7955]

this one is the most honest take on this issue. kudos to you Chuck.

[@CashualChuck]

Thank you for keeping an open mind

[@missppop]

trueeeee...sana sobra po itong mapansin ...

[@kitkittykatkath]

Oh! Now it makes sense why they are in a box, and there are aliens in their GENTO music video. 🤯

[@riaconradt2554]

BTW, Chuck, I love the thumbnail for your video with the puppeteer and puppets. It’s so appropriate.

[@minyoung823]

You didn't even mention abt the issue of not naming Pablo in songs he has written but instead it was under ShowBT to which the fans objected and ShowBT was forced to acknowledge Pablo as the composer. I believe that was also one of the reasons the boys didn't renew their contracts but instead built their own company bec they know, Pablo, maybe especially, from that experience that if they want recognition from their creations they must break ties from ShowBT.

[@CashualChuck]

I do remember that. Thanks for pointing it out.

[@minyoung823]

​​@@CashualChuckbut if there is maltreatment and there are video evidences like you have, hopefully Mahalima will open up abt it in court, and hopefully it will help their case. Praying for the boys. ShowBT might have their name but it doesn't own their talents and skills so if they need to let go of that name, so be it. Keep making music under 1Z, under a different name, the fans will still be here. What's in a name? The fans first and foremost love their music, their talents, perseverance, patience, them, not their name. I mean, the name SB19 is not as precious as them as the musicians, artists that we the fans love so whatever their new name will be, we will still be here. Keep going, Mahalima.👊👊👊 We will wait. ❤❤❤

[@missppop]

@@CashualChuck sana magamit nila ito as proof. Andito naman tayo sa Pilipinas sana panigan sila ng ating gobyerno manlang...Shoutout sa malapit sa atin Presidente na a'tin jan...

[@jungsky5469]

@@missppop pag umabot sa Senado to lagot talaga yang Koreano na yan...

[@gigicalub]

Pablo alluded to unfair treatment or hardships under the Korean management in an interview. He said he hoped other groups like them would not endure the same.

[@noexcuses5524]

Not only that but every music videos is their money. The company really did not invest on the boys except to let them sign contract. On each sb19 mv we saw on KZbin the membets pitch in. Thats why at one point on their interview. They said that they nvr rlly save money cus most of it goes to the production team, music videos and showbt company. The showbt did not took money from out of their pocket. So really there is maltreatment financially, physically and emotionally. So sad for them.

[@SB19_fanaticforever]

Sana mailaban nila yan sa korte. 😢😢😢

[@doriscalingasan1173]

Ito dapat mailabas, pera ng 5,ginagastos

[@noexcuses5524]

@@SB19_fanaticforever yep they have to take leap of faith and take this sa court cus I dont think ma reoslve ng smoothly pag sila lng lima.. Baka they get to keep their name magpatulong sila sa malalaking star Like Vice Ganda, etc na magaling na lawyer.

[@laiTVExplorer]

Now it's clear. The story is clear. Spread this video. Thanks Cashual Chuck for always making a narrative story of sb19 and making it clear to is A'tin.

[@taktak1798]

The issue is over. They settled and the boys got their name back. Thank you, Chuck, for your analysis. Looking forward to your next vlog or podcast

[@carobs35]

Full support for Pablo, Josh, Stell, Justin and Ken.

[@Vsjf_31]

Finally!You're back!You are one of the reason kung paano ko sila mas nakilala.Thank you for this 💙

[@breakout4347]

Yes!!! At work right now, will watch later!! Thanks Casual Chuck!😊

[@justine_chase]

If SB19 is going to disband, I will lose my shit. If they decide to change their group name, I'll miss the group name SB19, but if it's for the better, then go ahead. We'll still support them!

[@user-iy3qv9tr8e]

Thank you Chuck, for this truthful documentary, we will unite in prayers and support for our Mahalima, more blessing Chuck, keep doing your intelligent creations for educating and enlightening us your fellow A'tin, i hope the Boys will surpass this great challenge in their career with solid and united A'tin and all the good people surrounding them they and we can overcome this, thank you, God Bless

[@susansotto4134]

Thank you so much Chuck for supporting the boyz MAHALUMA❤❤❤

[@zhelortaliz4210]

I will always support Mahalima 💙💙💙💙👍

[@peepoidshih]

This is where I would have liked for the government to at least intervene. I mean, these boys bring honor and pride to our country, why not at least look into and help bring both sides to the negotiating table? This is just my opinion, many may not agree, but sometimes the government may at least provide needed support as the boys are newbies in this business? This cannot go on for long. Sayang ng pinagpaguran ng mahalima.

[@janstar07]

I couldn't agree more to your statement. I don't live in the Philippines, so I have no idea who / what Department Secretary or Office of the President to call for help / assistance.

[@user-mf2tr3bl1o]

Agree, and to expidite the process.

[@rkdo9554]

unfortunately, ang PInas ay hindi Sounth Korea na malaki ang suporta sa ent industry. Further, SB19 in Pinas is no BTS or EXO or even SVT in SK who have a great contrib to their economy. The pride and honor they bring to the country is minuscule compared to other OPM artists. Let's not be delulus. The boys have fame and they sure do have talents but their fame is nothing for the government.

[@peepoidshih]

@@rkdo9554 i'm not delusiunal. There is nothing wrong in wishful thinking.

[@peepoidshih]

Kung delulu nga sya, it's okay. That's just me. Don't mind me

[@taktak1798]

Thanks. I have been waiting for this because I know yours will be more than speculation. I hope they can resolve this soon.

[@gelr6848]

This PAGTATAG era is now making total sense. Tatagan pa natin A’tin! Kaya natin to with Mahalima 🫶

[@nenaignish5136]

Thank you sir chuck for this video, I really appreciated,, and please keep posting, thank you, GOD bless you

[@MelkyMelks]

Hey! Finally! Been waiting for your take on the issue, and it didn't disappoint! I love how you've done it objectively and laid out all the things we know so far, and added points that would allow for a more intelligent discussion. After all that's said and done, as A'tin, we all want what's best for our Mahalima. All we can do right now is to pray for things to go well for everyone involved. Thanks Chuck! 💖

[@Trendmebeauty]

What makes it really sad is that I feel they were taken advantage of. Mistreated because they were young and naive just grateful for the opportunity. But like what others have said, Filipinos are looked down upon especially by other Asian countries. So, the timing could not be more suspicious. The boys are going global and they are competition for other Asian groups which is probably scary for some of these management groups. Stay strong, rise up MAHALIMA we'll be fans no matter what the name is. ❤❤

[@stephanieallangarman5598]

I’ll be praying for the boys. They are definitely seen as COMPETITION and I’ve also seen TOXIC and XENOPHOBIC comments for other POP Groups who are not part of S. KOREA. It’s SAD 😢. I guess it was just a matter of time that this came out,

[@roderickcruz1751]

Hello Chuck. May I just share my own two cents. I've became a fan of these young men just recently and like others, I'm totally dismayed at what's happening to the group given all the forbearance, hard work, sacrifice and dedication each and every one of them gave to finally establish themselves as they are now. I'm trying not to care nor dare to speculate on what's happening since I know nothing of the group's internal affairs. However, I can't help noticing something that might have been overlooked by people. I've read so many comments about this current difficulty being faced by our favorite group. Curiously enough, I didn't find anybody mention how "suspiciously" coincidental the occurrence is of this seemingly chaotic mess the group fell into, especially since their popularity is literally on the verge of skyrocketing in the world scene. There seemed to be no problem using the name "SB19" when the group announced that they have left ShowBT before the release of their Pagtatag EP, when they informed the fans of the establishment of their very own 1Z management group, when they launched their Pagtatag World Tour and all the way up to the time of their half a decade concert. The boys were their lively selves then. Suddenly, everything changed on that TM concert and everything came to a standstill afterwards, a screeching stop to their performances and total silence (except for the notification for concert cancellations). IF the issue is with the trademark infringement on the use of the "SB19" name or whatever else that has something to do with ShowBT, shouldn't it have cropped up when the release of the Pagtatag album was made or even after the establishment of 1Z Entertainment, etc? Why only now? This is why I said this to be something "suspiciously" coincidental. Isn't it more likely a deliberate attempt to slow down or derail the rising popularity of our boys in the international stage instead of royalty issues? Lest we forget or fail to consider, there are politics as well in the music industry like in ALL industries. Finally, sorry but I can't agree with what you said that wouldn't the boys be greedy themselves as well by leaving ShowBT in the lurch. From the videos of their interviews I've seen on the hardships they underwent where they mostly and basically fended off for themselves, I think they have paid their dues to their former management.

[@renatinacu8673]

true....some hearsay is circulating that a big company is behind these attacks and there PM/DM that has misleading content that throw the blame to the boys for their cancelled concerts when theyre not the producer of the con....as far as i know the producer is the one to have a contract with the artist and the venue and all thats why they have they are the one to issue the refund because they are rhe ones to pay the arrist...correct me if im wrong😊 i think big companies is behind these...they dont want Mahalima to stop but its obvious what they want is the A'TIN FANDOM even if they pour all their money to thwir artist if theres no fans its useless. They want A'TIN and THE BUYING POWER OF THE FANDOM..pera lang ang habol nila sa fandom kaya gusto nila pabagsakin Maha5...well they are not expecting that the fandom is a solid fandom so they cant take A'tin away from Maha5

[@MARISSAFEHERRADURA]

The first thought that came to me when the news came out about the tradename issue was that maybe iniipit ang Mahalima at gusto singilin ng malaki nung foreigner dahil sa nakita niyang biglaan at taas ng trajectory ng pagsikat nila base sa sobrang init at sigla ng reception sa mga concerts nila at sa laki ng attendance nito. Tsaka yung timing prang sinadya na wag bigyan ang boys ng wiggle room para magresist sa demands ng kumpanya.

[@fonzichrist]

What I noticed was, ShowBT just allowed them to go on their own cuz the Korean director thought they won't go anywhere far. But things started to fall on his face when the boys became a hit after breaking free from the Korean box. So Charles Kim's ego was hurt and he realized he should still maje money out of the group. He is now making sure that when the timELe the boys conquer the world, his company still gets a portion of the income. The real greedy here is the Korean. In fact, all big labels in Korea are greedy.

[@shannelschannel4937]

Casualchuck salute u.. ikaw pinaka magaling sa lahat na nagpopoZT nagrereport ever... from presentation to effort and all. God bless

[@marycindelllynn3543]

i am noticing that koreans handle their idols like this. i remember BTS jungkook mistreated by a staff (too), and i remember how YG's CEO called 2ne1 uglyy. that kind of management may some how work in korea but not in the philippines.

[@shielamaezayas7187]

Our boys doesnt deserve to be maltreated,...ano kayo HIBANGGGG?! mahal na mahal naman yan mga Ati'n tas gaganyanin lang.. daserb iwanan ang ganyang boss! tse... We became fans coz of their talent and attitude. We will be waiting whatever new name pa ang ilalapag nila! #fighting! #mahalima #1ZfortheWin

[@gelvivfajardo7761]

How sad to know maybe some bits of the whole situation... I hope masulbad og makabalik sila usab... They've been such a great group and an inspiration to many...

[@SisiWinn]

Thanks so much Chuck. I've been waiting for this. Nicely done as always.❤

[@noelppizana9620]

We pray na sana maging ok ns ang lahat brother👉🙏🙏

[@Unknown-ch7fg]

In Korean industry kasi idols are not allowed to get near their fans or was sometimes just told not to wave back. This happens also when Dream Makers aspirants were not allowed by their Korean mentors to wave back to their fans. Lastly, mas importante sa kanila yung visuals kahit waley ka talent in singing kasi pwede dn nmn sila mag lipsync kaya ok na. That's the harsh part of being in Kpop at minsan yung mga idols ginagawa na lng cash cows ng mga management nila.

[@shineshine177]

Kya idols tawag sa kanila..not artist or performer.

[@Unknown-ch7fg]

@@shineshine177 same lang dn yun..

[@shineshine177]

@@Unknown-ch7fg alin ang same?

[@Mahalima12]

Hi Chuck, so sad na madaming negative people around. Keep doing what you do best. Huwag na pansinin mga bashers at insecure lang yan. Have peace of mind. Thanks for your support sa Mahalima. Lalo ko silang nakilala dahil sa content mo. Looking forward to watch more content. Love your Filipinos who made Pinoys proud content mo. 😀😀

[@meriamjetajobe2627]

Yn matuto na ang mga Filipino kng sino dapat ang suportahan ng tudo

[@creativehaydee]

Hello Chuck, it's been a month, I hope you are doing well 🙂. Ito lang masasabi ko....We really don't know what is happening; there's no official statement. But I am praying. I always include them in my prayers, as well as their families, 1Z Entertainment, and even SBT, so they can settle everything amicably. Also, I have been thinking about this for days now. I think they already know what will happen. If you read their lyrics again, you will see that some of it makes sense now. Remember, the EP is a trilogy: 'Pagsibol,' 'Pagtatag,' and 'Simula and 'Wakas.' Pagtatag is patatagan ng wallet in the beginning since the EP release, concerts, shows, merch and etc. And now Patatagan ng loob dahil sa nangyayari sa kanila. I am positive they will rise like a phoenix after this. 'Simula' marks the start of something new, and 'Wakas' signifies the end of this chaos. I believe in them. We need to be patient.💙

[@user-bk9qt3xz3p]

❤❤❤😊

[@potleyagits]

I just learned about SB19 when they had the Pagtatag tour leg here in Chicago. And I became an instant fan. The talent, humility, passion and charisma they have are unprecedented in my opinion. But I immediately found it weird that they did not consider renaming their group since they became self-managed (under their 1Z company). Or have their legal team look into options. So i just assumed they made the legal settlement about the name/trademark. They should fixed that way before and now they are in bigger trouble coz their name SB19 is now internationally known. Anyway, just rename already and cut their association with anything SB/ShowBT coz it seems to have bad management now…. Stay strong Mahalima!!! ❤❤❤

[@fangirl_7n5]

Yung may sarili kang artist pero iba ung mas pinuri mo dahil lang sa mas handsome sila kesa sa SB19 hellooo! eh di dapat hindi talent pina-audition mo kundi looks 🙄 para samin A'TIN napakagwapo ng SB19 sa lahat ng aspect sa looks, sa attitude at sa higit sa lahat sa talent mahal na mahal namin sila hangang sa huli 💙 Mahalima 🤝 A'TIN

[@user-lx5ht4nk9i]

Tama...don sila SA kanila Pauwein nayan sakanila

[@angelamarizego9137]

mas proud ako sa talents over visuals.. noong first time ko sila napanood sa yt noong 2020 hindi ko ginawang basehan yung itsura. ang una kong nagustuhan ay yung talent nila, na amazed ako sa husky nila sa pag kanta at pag sayaw kaya naging su of sunod na yung pag support ko sa mga nilalabas nilang mga bagong kanta.. as of now idol ko pa rin sila 3 yrs.na akong avid fans ng SB19(Mahalima) mas lalu ko silang nagugustuhan at sinusuportahan at palagi ako naka update sa mga happenings nila, achievements at recognition.. ang laban ng SB19 ay laban din natin mga co A'tin ko, palagi lang natin sila isupport at ipag dasal kailangan natin maging brave dahil sa atin din sila kumukuha ng lakas at ti ay ng loob🙂🙂 mag stay positive lang tayo mga co A'tin ko💙💙

[@user-lx5ht4nk9i]

Prang Kung sino ..

[@vybzalways5293]

Am sure if the company wasn't looking for talents ,they would have never debuted SB19

[@GADELYNMAYA]

Nagustuhan ko sila dahil napakagaling at very humble nila...

[@anitagubalane7510]

We are here for you Sb19. Keep on fighting. 🇵🇭🙏

[@angelcolumna7291]

Kuya Chuck I salute you for this. I've never had the time to thoroughly get updated of the recent happenings and to be honest, mas nakampante ako now that you made a video about this 'cause I trust your channel and opinion. Pati ba naman ikaw nadadalaw ng mga mahaligno hahahaha keep it up and thanks for doing this to stand for Mahalima💙

[@liliamancera4530]

Naaawa ako sa Boys! Natuloy man o hindi ang mga concert nila magbabayad pa rin sila sa venue na Pina reserve nila at sa mga taong nagpunta doon sa venue ay hati ang damdamin! Meron nakakaunawa at meron naiinis! Mas inagapan daw sana ang pagsasabi na cancelled ang concert para daw hindi na sila napagod at nagastusan!..I still keep praying na haplosin ng Ama ang puso ng SBT management at mag give way na sila sa Mahalima, tutal naman Christmas is giving.. Hindi man nila mabawi ang trademark na SB19! At least makapagpatuloy sila sa kanilang mga pangarap.

[@noexcuses5524]

Abosado ang mga Koreans..what do u expect. Power trips yan sila kaya ate ko nvr nag Stan ng kpop

[@Mj_Strawberry]

Magdasal na lng tlaga tayo, tsaka kung may puso ba talaga yang mga yan

[@missppop]

pARANG walang pusong yan showbt kala ko totally wala na silang string attached meron parin pala..yung jon pinto..

[@Titatet]

​@@missppoppag last minute cancel din ang dubai & japan ay alam na this. Ang goal talaga nila lumabas na unprofessional ang mahalima & 1Z, iniipit nila eh

[@maggieeugenio9848]

If they understand hindi lang 1z ang may hawak sa lahat Black Star is also in it kaya they cannot decide on their own otherwise mas lalo pa sila mapapahamak they'd better follow to smoothly resolve their issues together rather than to decide everything on their own it's easier said than done mga co A'TIN kaya let us all be patient and wait for Mahalima and 1z to give us signal. I just hope everything will be over soon.🙏🙏 A'TIN let us all be strong together.💠💙💪💪💪

[@giotiongsonvlog4442]

Please assist in spreading this video. People should be aware of what happened and what is going with SB19. We must safeguard the guys in whatever manner possible.

[@MomiLove25]

Prayer is the most powerful weapon..hoping for the best results for Mahalima...but should i say, everything happens with a reason...dont you worry "hindi natutulog ang Diyos"....all will fall into proper place...thanks chuck😊

[@Maria-xe2tr]

While this may be out of topic, i hope Ken understands the gravity by now of why the long meetings were being held and why his absolute presence of mind is needed to tackle all these possible issues during the said grueling hours. This is the why. Im a fan of him and always rooting for his growth. I hope he will take this as a serious lesson that its not always everything about stage, but also everything behind it. Punctual ethics and papers must not be taken lightly. I hope everything will be okay and settled soon. Praying to all of you Mahalima. ❤

[@Che178-j1z]

Toxic naisingit mona nman SI ken.. sinasapuso nman ni ken Yan and he's getting better now.

[@Kemedochorva]

I think makakahelp talaga tong video sa mga taong wala naman sa x or walang oras magtagni tagni ng mga pangyayari. Hindi man natin sure kung ano ang mga nagaganap sa likod ng camera at ano talaga ang pinagdadaanan ng boys ngayon, dalangin ko malagpasan nila to and maresolba na at mgakasundo ang bawat panig. We know the boys just want to do music sana ibinigay na sa kanila yon.

[@jsmnogdc97]

Charles Kim’s treatment to SB19 is getting through my veins grrrr THANK YOU FOR THIS CHUCK! ✨

[@user-lx5ht4nk9i]

Paalisin nayan dito SA bansa natin

[@SB19_fanaticforever]

At parang sinasabi niya pang pangit ang SB19

[@SB19_fanaticforever]

BGYO is better nga daw

[@whonskatt]

Nanggigil ako kay CK 🤬

[@jsmnogdc97]

ANG KAPAL TALAGAAAAA

[@mhaimagat9845]

Worth the wait… uulit ulitin ko to…sana maabutan ko mamayang 7 kc medyo busy pg ganyang oras

[@markjhon-sj8rm]

Tigilan na yung pagkahumaling sa mga Kpop, at wag panoorin yung mga korean drama, suportahan natin ang Mahalima #Atinto

[@Mj_Strawberry]

Korek! Kasi parang liit ng tingin nila sa mga pinoy

[@blissful94]

may preference ang mga tao. remember we are also pushing esbi to be known internationally pano kung in the future makakita ka din ng ganitong comment sa kanila? instead na unahin mo sabihin sa kanila na itigil nila ang ganito ang ganyan. bat di mo na lang i-promote ng husto mahalima para mareach yung other audience. hindi nakakamakabayan ang ganitong mindset

[@babyrebornpinay]

Grabe tingin nila satin mga pinoy. Sa mismo nating bansa inaalipin nila mga pinoy.. akala nila kng cno cla eh di nmn cla taga dto

[@vybzalways5293]

😂😂😂😂😅😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😅😅😅😅ok,good luck

[@missppop]

isampal natin sa mukha nila puro naman sila autotune..pwe

[@solci4004]

No creo que se trate de “ser codiciosos” sino como bien lo explico aquí, no eran LIBRES (frEEEdoOM🗣🎶) , será que “Gento” iba a existir estando bajo esa compañía? Nunca lo sabremos. Pero si mis chicos hicieron las cosas bien tengo Fe que saldrán de esta tarde o temprano 🙌🏻💛

[@jackievav3217]

Por favor contexto que esta pasando con mis chicos ..soy nueva

[@solci4004]

@@jackievav3217 Olii, ellos pertenecían a una empresa (coreana) que los formó como grupo y así. Hace no se cuanto tiempo (creo que ya pasó un año) se hicieron independientes de esa empresa, ahora son 1Z (donde Pablo es el CEO!) y lo demás miembros la administran. ahora si el contexto jsjssj .. No sacaron ningún comunicado pero últimamente no están usando su nombre, “SB19”, hasta el logo, están evitándolo y cancelando conciertos. Suponemos que la empresa coreana como ahora están teniendo fama le quieren sacar dinero y como el nombre SB19 salió de esA empresa, pues se están agarrando de eso ✨mucho texto jsjsjsjs

[@jackievav3217]

@@solci4004 muchas gracias ya estaba preocupada.. ojalá y todo se solucione paro el bien de los chicos

[@Ver0_Cat]

I'm so FIRED UP. To be frank, I only started liking SB19 after Cashual Chuck's in depth focus on each of the members. I first saw them on Fox channel on YT last year and got curious because I learnt they are a Pinoy group. So I tried watching SB19 under ShowBT. I didn't like their k-pop sounding songs at all, but I enjoyed their OPM sounding ballads esp Hanggang. K-pop is definitely NOT my cup of tea, so I got utterly disappointed when true OPM died around the 2000s and people started patronizing K everything. I'm very patriotic, so imagine my horreur when I found out that Korean companies started setting up in PH to exploit Filipino talent! I mean, haven't Filipinos figured it out already? WE MADE K-POP DRAMA ETC TREND! What the heck!!! Let's get our power back, Pinoys! They already infested Makati through the years where I lived. I mean, we've had many settlers since the ancient times, such as the Chinese, Indians, Arabs and Malays, so Filipinos have dealt with that. And then, the colonizers came. That's another story the Alamat boys are now covering. But of all the cultures I've come across as an FA, I find Korean culture to be the MOST bizarre. My parents had a Korean renting their condo in the 90s, and it also wasn't a good experience. To this day, the smell of kimchi traumatizes me lol. I live in Switzerland, and guess what? Same story. Koreans like you when you wear a genuine Swiss watch or carry a doctorate degree. Shallow, shallow, shallow. A Swiss friend who does events around the world hates doing events in Korea. She says they are the worst people to deal with. And to think, she's a tough Swiss cookie. She wasn't having their rotten attitude. This is my PERSONAL opinion and experience, so don't you blast me on the comment section, because I am not one of the few who's ever had a nicey-dicey Korean experience. Korean colleages shocked me in ways unimaginable and I was NOT HAVING IT. When I saw how Tatang Robin hit the boys 'playfully' using a plastic hammer, I found this SO BIZARRE. CRINGE. Like, come on! And on camera? No shame because to them, it's normal. But haven't we all passed that crazy generation when old comedians would hit their sidekicks on the head? That's soooo last century and totally unacceptable NOW. Nobody should ever, EVER touch the crown of your head, kids! I can't believe NOBODY said anything about this. But then again, of course not, coz they act like they "own" Filipinos because of money. And now this Charles Kim? Who the hell is he, playing god? He can't even pass as a sewer rat, imo. This low-life should be deported for his notorious behaviour towards Filipino citizens, tbh. If he could do that to the boys, imagine the staff. We've come across many rude foreigners, and they end up being deported. This shouldn't be tolerated, esp with proof on social media. This guy will get served one day. Then again, I'm not shocked to see this is still happening because these people are taking advantage of poor Filipinos. UNLESS WE SPEAK UP. Now seeing that Koreans are still doing this on a daily basis, acting like gods in Manila, is getting me all fired up. So yeah, Chuck. This is how I feel. Abusive and rude people should be called out, whoever they are, fellow Filipinos or foreigners. We should stand up for every Filipino, not only the boys. Every Filipino. 🤎 I've been so busy minding my own life until I heard about this just now, thanks to you again! Hope you're doing well, Chuck. Another hot topic you've covered to get us all fired up! Keep it up. Hugs from Switzerland.

[@kinfairliecinder5297]

Thank you. As a former active A'tin whose not active anymore, your video helped answer most of my questions and I agree with your speculations. Please keep making videos like this, some of us appreciate this video.

[@raquelbuenaagua9433]

Grabe ha. Sensitive ang mahalima when it comes sa bashing about their visuals like what happened before sa presscon. And all this time pala, their No. 1 Bully is this man. No wonder hindi magtatagal mga talents sa agency nya. I remember Pablo said, one of the reason na tinayo ang 1Z ay pra di na pagdaanan ng ibang mga talents to be ung pinagdaanan nila. So obviously, may abuse at mistreatment talaga. No to abusive and oppressive foreigners that will ruin the dreams of Filipinos.

[@riennek.4989]

I know its difficult to solve the problem sooner but for me the only solution for the case is to negotiate and draft clear and thorough contracts that outline each partys rights and responsibilities,to specify precise and careful terms for payments and other frequent areas of despute.

[@MARISSAFEHERRADURA]

As I see it, the parties are at a point of no return , at least on the part of the boys who have nothing to gain by entering into contract again, since it is only the foreigner who would profit from the boys.

[@hargonz87]

The explanation is very clear on point you saved our day chuck🙏🙏💪💪💪

[@ruruanimations]

i agree with this video.. and it is common for the companies to look down on their talents... its been an issue in Korea too, its every common for koreans to look down on anyone whos not above them or at the same level. Even with fellow koreans (just look at the facts told by rotten mango in her video " 2006 Cheongju Curling Iron Case - Real Story Behind "The Glory") bullying is almost about looking down on people..... sadly this is a thing in Korea... and well I have been wondering about what you discussed here.. and sadly, the law is black and white.

[@gsi29]

SB19 our P-pop is a threat to KPop. I am praying for the boys and I hope our kababayans will support our own. We have to wake up and don’t let these foreigners discriminate us