The Settlements | Gershom Gorenberg | Part I

Three ways to support!
Paypal: www.paypal.me/transliminal
Patreon (main channel): / transliminalmedia
Patreon (Zionism channel): / zionaninvestigation
Zion--an investigation: / @zionaninvestigation3051
Main channel: / transliminal
***
Gerhom Goernberg is a widely acclaimed, highly accomplished journalist, author and historian of Israel and Zionism.
His latest books include:
The Accidental Empire: Israel and the Birth of the Settlements, 1967-1977 |
www.amazon.com/gp/product/080...
The Unmaking of Israel |
www.amazon.com/Unmaking-Israe...
The End of Days: Fundamentalism and the Struggle for the Temple Mount |
www.amazon.com/gp/product/019...

[@philosophicaltrainer2610]

Mate, your interviews are unbelievably good. It's such a shame your channel doesn't have more views and subscribers.

[@Transliminal]

Thanks so much... words of encouragement help motivate me to carve out time to release this stuff... Part II coming shortly..,.

[@SvalbardSleeperDistrict]

@@Transliminal Your focus on the really interesting and underexplored questions involving important details - compared to the tired, dead-end questions posed to interviewees on these subjects - is a breath of fresh air.

[@e.k4393]

Your voice and voices like yours are needed to stop the insanity and safe people on both sides for generations to come....!!!! I admire your courage and sense of humanity...One country one vote all citizens are equal under the law....! ❤

[@shaygahweh]

You're doing spectacular work.

[@Transliminal]

Thank you so much... the words of encouragement mean a lot

[@brendafiander9055]

Excellent interview , thank you for your channel .

[@Transliminal]

Thank you for your kind words... greatly appreciated... hold tight for Part II, available imminently

[@JustanothaGuy]

Yes, I love Gorenberg's books, great writer, descriptive, poetic, and skilful. Thank you for this wonderful interview.

[@Transliminal]

Thanks, Cameron... my pleasure. ... Stay tuned for Part II, nearly ready...

[@Mas_Tun]

Interesting interview. Can't wait for pt 2!

[@Transliminal]

Almost ready! Stay tuned

[@paintballthieupwns]

I know i knew only a little about the middle east. but jeesh even the internal politics in Israel are far more complicated than i could have guessed

[@paintballthieupwns]

@ - Does that not apply to any nation?

[@JustanothaGuy]

@ That literally applies to all countries.

[@SeekersofUnity]

Interesting

[@mattwraith6937]

Interesting guy, but terrible interrupter

[@Transliminal]

Sorry you feel that way -- maybe it was an editing issue

[@mattwraith6937]

@@Transliminal I meant the interviewee not the interviewer.

[@NoName-cu4gr]

Hitler's children.

[@JoseAngelFlores]

Jewish people lived in Judea and Samaria for thousands of years, and were never bereft of the land, in spite of invasions after invasions. So it's logical that they consider this their land and therefore have a claim, regardless of what whoever else, international law or otherwise, may say, they have a claim to the land, it is not "occupied land" but rather "disputed land".

[@thomaslang7616]

No, it is not, every country is to respect international law and apart from that the few Jewish people who stayed there in spite of the ethnic cleansing by the Romans later converted to Christianity and later mostly (but not entirely) to Islam. Except for some Bedouins the Palestinians of today are the descendants of the population of Judea, but as aforementioned, this does not even matter because if it did, we would also have to reloate Bulgaria kinto southern Russia and triple its size and many similar things.

[@NoName-cu4gr]

Bullshit - all the jews with any right to be in Palestine were already in Palestine, alongside all the Christians and above all Arab muslims. The modern US sponsored eastern European colonial imposters land thieves and liars have invented an abomination in a region they have no right to be. The Z cult criminals have assimilated Judaism and taken ownership of the religion and related historic suffering, real and imagined, to serve their own purpose and nefarious plans.

[@nadavmeron4491]

@@thomaslang7616Wrong. The surnames of the Arabs families points towards their geographical origin. “El-masri” family is from Egypt. El-hurani family is from Syria. Lubnani family is from Lebanon and the list is long. Very long.

[@Sandcrackattack]

​@@nadavmeron4491Arabs native to North Africa are not evidence that Arabs were not native to Palestine. In fact, both DNA and historical evidence show Arabs are more relative to the Jewish natives. There are Arab Jews. And at the end of the day, after the UN charter, displacing any peoples from their established place of living violates international law. How you do it... Genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid, displacement, sterilizing black Ethiopian Jews, deporting Arab and antizionist Jews as well.... It is still illegal and determined war crimes. We can dispute the details but either way, Zionists not Jews, did these actions and they violate international law.

[@nilskp]

It's logical that the Jews *who lived there* (Mizrahi) would consider it their land. Just like anyone else living there. It's not logical that European Jews (Ashkenazi) would.