The Top 5 Tiran Porter Bass Lines (w/ The Doobie Brothers)

#bass #basshistory #popbass #rockbass #tutorial #analysis #transcription #doobies #paulthompson
Do you know the Doobie Brothers?! How about classic songs like "Long Train Runnin'" and "What A Fool Believes"? Well, meet the incredible bassist that laid down those iconic tracks along with a ton of other popular Doobie songs. I've been a fan of Tiran since I was young and have been wanting to feature him on this channel for some time. Let's dig into his best bass lines from his first tenure with the Doobies (1972-1980) and what makes them so special!
Special thanks to my buddy ‪@toddhamby‬ for the inspiration to do this one! If you search "Tiran Porter" on KZbin, you will most certainly find him playing amazing versions of Tiran's lines!
00:00 Intro
00:52 #5
02:28 #4
03:29 #3
04:27 #2
05:42 Honorable Mention #1
06:11 Honorable Mention #2
06:44 Honorable Mention #3
07:32 #1
08:48 Influence and Outro
Website: www.paulthompson.us
Instagram @pdbass74
Twitter @pdbass74

[@mikestillwagon5675]

For years I have felt that his parts were so incredibly underappreciated and that he really was the secret sauce in the Doobies' recipe.

[@peterknaust7424]

I remember an interview from years ago with Jeff Baxter where he said Tiran’s bass playing blew his mind

[@Jpeterson7]

I saw that too. Made me glad that a great like Baxter thought what I was thinking.

[@robwilson7324]

YES! Finally someone is saying it! Tiran Porter is one of the best bass players ever and rarely gets talked about. I also grew up on the Doobies. The Captain and Me, Takin’ It To The Streets and Minute By Minute all showcase Tiran’s brilliance. Funky and melodic and he knew when not to play. His playing very much did hold the Doobies music together and made it uniquely beautiful! Thank you for this video. It feels so good to know someone else shares my admiration of this amazingly overlooked musician!

[@halcop]

I felt the same way about Tiran Porter. He showed us that its okay to play pop music and still groove. My favorite is "It Keeps You Runnin'." His interplay with Michael McDonald is classic.

[@richardgudino7630]

You do great service to bassdom by showing Tiran some much overdue love. Absolultely brilliant basswork!

[@crystalwaters8852]

Agreed! 100%👑😁

[@chrisanderson6928]

I third this comment. I've always thought his bass playing was top notch and think he needs to be in the conversation of best, or at least most influential, bass players

[@ethanlancaster76]

Yes, he always pulls out a gem from deep down inside the bag of bass goodness and does an amazing job of breaking them down.

[@djtut_clt5236]

Tiran’s Bass work was a definite departure from the norm because of the rising popularity of slap Bass during the height of the Doobie’s ascension. He was well aware of what he was great at and he stayed true to it. That is a great life lesson in general, even more so for a musician. Kudos to the great Mr. Porter! Bravo to you for the wonderful tribute!

[@lekubes]

The solo bass line in the middle of Wheel of Fortune still blows me away….over 40 years later. Always thought Tiran was underrated and one of the best out there.

[@bassfacekillah]

same here, one of my favorite basslines -- so damn funky

[@rgsudusky]

I taught myself bass by learning every song on "What Were Once Vices are now Habits" note for note. Huge influence on my playing. So happy to see I'm not the only Tiran Porter fan!

[@jeffwolinski2659]

Ha, me too! My mother had all the old Doobie albums and Vices was my favorite, I played along with those over and over.

[@bkkersey93]

That album is way to underrated! All the songs are great, but my favorite has to be Down In The Track.

[@jameswood3977]

A great album to learn from too, it’s always been one of my fab favs, used to play Road Angel back in mid 1970’s along with the usual Long Train Running & China Grove, you had to know the later for any auditions back then lol

[@chrishollingsworth9296]

For Someone Special is my favorite but I Love all of his baselines. Great player and the key to their sound

[@TheTones10]

100%

[@starlight1126]

Most definitely. Usually play that tune several times. His voice, the music, beautiful

[@jameswood3977]

Tiran wrote that for Tom Johnson around the time he became unwell and left the Doobies, I never knew that until I watched a documentary few years ago

[@tinyrick2921]

I just learned about Tiran Porter from this video (a 90's kid). What amazes me is the spaces: when NOT to play as well as when to play. I believe that's a very underlooked aspect in music. The silence brings anticipation and excitement, and exudes taste. Sometimes you don't want to hear an instrument all the time in a song; you want to miss it. Porter has a deep understanding of his instrument, as well as obvious talent. Will check him out right away 👏

[@franklehouillier8865]

I always love that the bass line from Black Water actually somehow sounds like a river.

[@musclecarmitch908]

I've always loved Tiran's bass playing, especially awesome in "Listen to the music " his backing vocals are just as awesome! The Doobies were the greatest with him! To me he was never with those guy's, he was one of those guys!

[@inthebeast]

Yes. His vocals hold up their sound as well as his bass playing.

[@bassvibasics479]

Nice to see Mr Porter getting some attention! Always loved his playing.

[@sitizenkanemusic]

Tiran Porter was one of the big reasons for the Doobie Brothers' success. His sound and grooves were very unique. And with Michael McDonald's vocals, the band was destined to be awesome.

[@tuliothx]

My favorite bass lines is from "For Someone Special". He sets the mood in the intro with syncopated patterns, driving the whole song from there to the end. To me is the most ingenious bass line of any rock song, rivaling Miles' intro in "So What".

[@timfurnier7061]

He's a major talent! His solo album is amazing! It made me realize just how much of the Doobie Brothers sound was attributable to him.

[@Hendrix.]

He was very important to their sound..Miss him in the lineup.

[@purtis99]

Very very very under rated and never talked about bass player

[@dirkdodd4723]

Always thought this guy was under-recognized. A solid, solid bassman. Favorite groove of his, for me, has to be on It Keeps You Runnin' (...Minute By Minute second fav.) It was very smart for the producer of those Doobie records to produce Tiran 'out front.' I think that's part of why most times when I'm humming a Doobie Brothers song, I find myself humming the bass line. Thanks for the video.

[@scotthsmith64]

Your a beast. The bass Rick Beato!

[@samsonwoods5448]

Yes!!!!!!!! One of the most GREAT but underrated Bassist of All Time, "BRAVO" And 🎩 Hat's off to you Tiran Porter!!!!!!!, and my favorite bass line by him is Another Park Another Sunday!!!!!!!

[@johnfay5399]

He is one hell of a bass player but I don't see anyone mentioning the fact that his backing vocals was a great contribution to the doobies sound

[@jonandrecarter4881]

My favorite Tiran Porter bassline is Neal’s Fandango!

[@OmarCrz06]

man this is amazing I am 16 years old, and I am learning to play the bass and the Doobie Brothers are my favorite band I appreciate this video, I love Tiran's way of playing so I really enjoyed the video

[@syvsinger1]

'For Someone Special' still remains one of my favorite Tiran songs while with the Doobie Brothers. ❤

[@toddhamby]

Wow what an amazing job Paul!! Mr. Porter is one of my biggest inspirations ever. Right up there with Chuck Rainey, John Paul Jones, and Bernard Edwards. From the moment I saw them on the two episodes of What’s Happening. Also, in time that it was common the fact that he and the Doobies were breaking down rock racial barriers is dear to me as well. Thanks again as always for a fantastic tribute to someone that is a huge influence to all us bassist. And thanks for the shoutout

[@jazzpunk]

Same influences for me. JPJ was "my" guy early on...then Ti Porter. Rainey! Bernard, too.

[@stonedog23]

Omg Rerun and the piracy episodes is also when I first noticed this brother.

[@nembleu3840]

Great series Dude. Thanks for acknowledging all the bassists you cover. They are just as much a part of music history as the folks who are commonly celebrated.

[@JoshuaTanzer]

I think you're right. I'm not a bass player and I have to be honest - bass players and drummers are often the names I've noticed least when I look at band members. I didn't even know Tiran Porter's name. Shame on me! But PDBass's videos are really making me understand how much the bass has been at the essence of the music I've been listening to all my life. These videos are terrific.

[@toddhamby]

Another Park Another Sunday Jesus Is Just Alright It Keeps You Running Minute by Minute Wheels of Fortune My top 5. It’s really amazing how Tiran evolved as the members and and direction of the band changed. Bass Royalty

[@jazzpunk]

"Another Park..." is one of my favorites. Hands down.

[@stephenferracioli6116]

Tiran Porter’s bass solo on Wheels Of Fortune is the bomb. He really spanks it!

[@trk327]

The man is so underrated!! The man carries every song, but the fact that Wheels of Fortune isn't on this list hurts lol

[@apileofrocks5142]

Seeing 8th Avenue Shuffle get #1 makes absolute sense. That lick in the second verse is the epitome of smooth. Tiran deserves more attention than he gets as a bass player.

[@MGTS24]

One of my favourite bass lines is For Someone Special, from Takin' it to the Streets, which I believe is also a Porter.composition

[@kirkwishowski7471]

Thank you so much for giving Tiran Porter his due. Eyes of Silver is my favorite.

[@htimsr101]

I absolutely love his bass lines in “It keeps you running”. With that song I became a forever fan!

[@michaelvandino3745]

Tirans bass playing is great but also..... his stage energy and vocals really put him up there. He plays great, looks great as well.

[@bobbytubbs5469]

Saw them live in the 70's one of the best live shows ever

[@AiMR]

Tiran could most definitely bring the game, but "Takin' it to the Streets" demonstrates just how important it is to know when to just stay out of the way. That relentless left hand of Michael's dominates the verses, and Tiran did what all great musicians must do; serve the song!

[@Larrymh07]

Yes. Learning that song taught me how to 'play space.'

[@kamisener]

The Doobie Brothers locked me in when I saw them on Don Kirchner's Rock Concert! A big part of that was because of their harmonies, but a bigger part was the presence of an amazingly talented bassist, Tiran Porter. I've seen them live a few times with and without Tiran. Without was awesome, but just not the same. I love the fact that he is so down to Earth and presents himself so professionally. My favorite Tiran Porter bass line? Easy..... any track he plays on!

[@lilmelvin11]

Another underrated Bass player was Lamar Williams, who replaced Berry Oakley in the Allman Brothers Band. He came in at a sad and bad time for the band ...I have a 2-CD from the ABB label, "Live at Nassau Coliseum 51/73" and he really shines! Highly recommend. Between him, Oakley, Jamie Jamerson and Paul McCartney, I was inspired to get my first Bass as a kid. Lamar Williams....

[@jazzpunk]

Check out more of Lamar in Sea Level.

[@zentimehq5985]

So true. Agree. Lamar with ABB and later Sea Level. Love him.

[@Larrymh07]

I nicknamed all my guitars. I call my bass Lamar. He was quite a character!

[@GHopps96]

Great job, as always. My favorite Tiran Porter bassline is Long Train Runnin.' Ironically, I knew how to play three of your top 5 from him, because they are my top five. I am adding "What a Fool Believes to my learning list, as I didn't realize how great it was, as it was so in tune with Michael McDonald's left hand. I like you was so inspired as a kid seeing Trian up there with the group, as it helped solidify them as my favorite group of the 70's and very early 80's!

[@donnadee1966]

He is a legend. I also loved the era when Skylark toured with the band... such energy!

[@johnabbott3896]

My ALL TIME favorite bassist...

[@shereewilson6278]

Jeff Skunk Baxter guitarist from the Doobie Bros mentioned how great a player Tiran was and how underated as a musician he was in an interview I listened to

[@flashbazbo3932]

A Doobie fan from the beginning, I re-discovered the insane bass work Tiran created. He is in the top three bassists of all time. Thank you Tiran.

[@TheTones10]

My particular fav from Tiran is his playing on the cut "For Someone Special" off the "Takin' It To The Streets" album. Hypnotic!

[@melodyhall6886]

My favorite Tiran Porter bass guitar line is Takin it to the streets. 2022 still listening 🎶.

[@edwardmartin1253]

“It Keeps You Running”. I love that groove.

[@solodad001]

The first song I ever learned completely was Long Train Running. Later on I got to meet Pat S. and the band about 25 years ago. Very cool to meet them and even hang out with Pat for lunch. I learned a lot from Tiran's lines, but also picked up from Willie Weeks too.

[@tracibillington8025]

Now I know the “science” behind my love for these songs….and Michael McDonald’s vocal & piano lead. I also recognized Tiran from appearances on TV with the Doobies. 👍🏽

[@MikeHunt-gy6lc]

Thank you for sharing those very personal thoughts at the end of the video. It’s really cool that he touched and inspire you in such a big way. That’s actually how I felt about about Tom Johnston when I was coming of age. Looking forward to more of your analysis’

[@billswinford1026]

Tiran is so inspiring! I totally agree re: the cuts off of the Minute by Minute LP, that whole album kicks ass His vocals were also a huge part of the Doobie Brothers sound.

[@Scottie_S]

Tiran was somebody that made me concentrate more on loving the bass and pushing myself harder instead of me just being cranky when I'd fuck up. I'd sit on the floor and listen to his bass lines and fall in love with the music I was playing along with him and the Doobies. He was like a hidden gem that we brushed the dust off and fell in love with. He made me a better player and a better man.

[@danielpalmersofficial]

Tiran, you’ll always have a place in our bass playing hearts. ✌️☺️

[@michaelanthony9068]

Great call… I never noticed Tyran’s part because they all are so much a seamless but necessary part of every song. Got to relisten to all these favorites. Thank you ! Great analysis !

[@keithroberts4952]

Thank you so much for this latest episode. It brought tears to my eyes when you mentioned about tiran at the end. He almost never gets a mention. I always encounter vicious debates about which doobie period was the better which tends to get personal! I liked both periods but I tend to lean heavily towards the Michael period simply because it satisfied me more musically speaking. Minute by minute is my fav!

[@Larrymh07]

Right on! Regardless of which period of The Doobies one favors, Tiran was there to establish the groove in his ingenious manner.

[@jonnuanez7183]

My favorite song of theirs, It Keeps You Runnin', has an awesome bassline. He is their unsung hero. Thanks for this.

[@johnhornak9916]

Neal's Fandango. My band, The county Line Band 1977-1982 covered many of the Doobies Bros songs playing the North East College/Club Circuit. Tiran's Driving Bass in Neal's Fandango would lift the energy of the crowd to a frenzy every time we played it.

[@attichatchsound-bobkowal5328]

Great to see Tiran getting some props! Such a musical player. I grew up learning 'pre McDonald" Doobies songs. Generally EVERY song has a memorable bass-line. Maybe my favorite playing by him is on "Wheels of Fortune". Has it all: syncopation - a walking section- then that "Anthony Jackson-ish" phase shifted groove.- so strong they gave us eight bars of just that bass line and drums!

[@danpalmer4820]

First song that came to mind.

[@fuzzytimes187]

Tiran does a nice note on the second verse of the Doobies "Listen To The Music" on The Midnight Special. Thanks for highlighting Tiran Porter.

[@markmiwurdz202]

My favourite Tiran Porter bass lines are from "For Someone Special" ( did he write that song for Tom Johnston when Tommy's health was not good and he had to take some time out from the band?), "Neal's Fandango" and "Wheel Of Fortune" ( first track, side one on "Takin' It To The Streets". The album credits drummer Richie Hayward (RIP) of Little Feat playing alongside Tiran on that track). Peace.

[@dicksaunders7543]

As an African American, Tiran Porter's work with the Doobie Brothers was all I needed to enjoy their sound and rock and roll in general! Back in 1973 racially mixed groups fit into more than one category and record labels disliked it. IMO, the Doobies were the funkiest rock band at that time thanks to Mr. Tiran Porter.

[@fntsmk]

Listen to the Music and Long Train Running are my favorite Tiran Porter bass masterpieces.

[@mlinderict]

As noted elsewhere, "For Someone Special" always gets me. Bass, vocals, and meaning.

[@kevbob]

In 1981 I was just out of high school and working as a gofer sweeping floors, wiping things at an antique store in Los Gatos California. One day Tiran came into the shop. As a gigging guitar player at the time and Doobies fan (local heroes) you bet I knew who it was. He and his lady were buying something and I was sweeping the floor around them and sheepishly said “Um, are you Tiran Porter?” and he was very nice and said yes, that’s me. I was pretty star struck and didn’t say a whole lot but man, that made my day. I still remember it vividly. (Tho one of the shop ladies said “Oh Kevin do we have a celebrity here?” and I felt awful for that. She goes “Ooo I met Elvis’ drummer once!” and I just melted away at that comment. 😂

[@kyleetie5608]

Thanks for featuring one of the most underrated bass players of all time… He always struck me as playing very “guitar-like”, but never mind that… The stone-cold bass groove was always there!

[@rillloudmother]

"That's what a fool believes, Kenny. That's what a fool believes..!"

[@OutnBacker]

Excellent synopsis on Tiran Porter. Also, the point about having the bass up front like vocals is spot on. I have always believed the bass should be right out there - not in the background. Tiran remains in my Top 5 bassists of all time for his nimble stylings and tone.

[@thomwest1724]

👍Thanks for posting the outstanding bass work of Tiran, the recognition is long overdue🎼🎸

[@russelljones8303]

One of my favorite Tiran Porter baselines that I was hoping you'd share in this video is from There's a light, which is also off the the Living On The Fault Line album. This is a ballad+like tune that we didn't here from the Doobies much, but I feel it shows diversity and also how Porter and Michael McDonald could still create a great groove in a whole other setting. And Tiran Porter was able to give it a little funk in some places too.

[@keepgrindingup7661]

Some real great tracks like " Eyes of Silver ", "Another Park Another Sunday"... and WHAT can you say about the brilliant "Jesus Is Just Alright"? Tiran's driving groove just pushes thag great song fully into the Stratosphere. SO GOOD

[@razorcatshark3223]

So grateful to happen upon this fitting tribute to an amazing player who deserves all the props!

[@lockedin60]

For all that they accomplished Tiran Porter was NOT an afterthought. He was upfront and badass. I always loved his bass lines. I can appreciate that even though my instrument is guitar. I have been a Doobie Brother's fan since Captain and Me was released. Now throughout the years I have picked up their earlier albums. I know a lot of people may have disliked the Michael McDonald era but he allowed Tom Johnston to heal and keep the Doobie Brothers relevant. I think it was good that they brought in Jazz elements. If we are honest most of the more popular acts of the 1970s incorporated Jazz elements along with their Rock roots. IMHO you can't love the the 19970s and early 1980s Doobie Brothers without that steady beat and tasteful licks of Tiran Porter!

[@Hawk-ODA212]

Mr. Porter had an incredible talent for creating complex bass lines in his mind and interjecting them seamlessly into any music. I cannot imagine hearing any one of the songs you listed with a different bass line. There are a lot of bass players during that era that I admire but I honestly don't think any of these songs would have enjoyed as much success as they did without him laying down the foundation. Thanks for an awesome post, sir.

[@treed873]

Huge influence on me becoming a bass player! His groove is awesome!

[@cliff2011]

Tiran is so totally under rated. He is really one of the greats on the instrument in my mind, and a big influence. He's a real bass player, who obviously loves the color, function and timber of bass. Strong rhythms and a very melodic player as well.

[@Law-hi8un]

I share in that sentiment. As an African American youth growing up in the 70’s Mr Porter gave me encouragement to like and embrace all kinds of music. As I listened to groups like the Doobies and Steely Dan, I was able to better understand the adage, “Music is the universal language.”

[@EightTrackBass]

Thank you for putting this together. One of my favorite Bassists and more people need to know about his greatness.

[@harleyhexxe9806]

I Loved all the Doobie's music, and in my humble opinion, he was the best bass player they ever had.

[@HighTechCinnamon]

Man, I struggled to learn Long Train Running for a while, it is deceptive, but it is such a great groove.

[@soyounoat]

As a bass player of 30+ years, I have aspired to sound as funky, soulful, tasteful and in the pocket as possible in hopes of being as good as Tiran Porter. Still working on it.

[@stanleydunbar6753]

Totally agree, when it wasn't popular to to not go with the majority, I didn't care what anyone said I love good music played by great musicians. Music has no color. My favorite Tyrant bass is in it keeps you running

[@chrisschrecker5497]

Chinatown from the Livin’ on the Fault Line album is another good one where Tiran takes the band through a few tempo changes. Gotta love Tiran!!

[@jamesboddington9565]

An absolute monster of the bass. What A Fool Believes is almost the perfect bassline. The space and unplayed notes are as good as the notes he plays. Someone who can service the song and be brilliantly creative and articulate within that role

[@Al69BfR]

Long train running is still a classic I played with many bands over the last 40 years. And the chorus of Listen to the music is one of my favorite Doobie Brothers bass lines.

[@no_guarantees]

Was unaware of this cat, thanks for bringing him much needed shine.

[@bennythedog93]

Thank you for this! Love the Doobies, love Tiran. I’d have to say that while all these are good, the Tiran line(s) that get me up and going are the ones in Wheels of Fortune, the opening track from the TITTS LLP. There’s more too. You’ve challenged me to jam even more Doobies this weekend than I normally do and pay particular attention to Tiran’s bass lines. I will report back! :-)

[@philipmanitta333]

Tiran is one of the most underrated bass players ever. He had a huge vocabulary and consummate tastefulness and I’ve learned as much from him as I got from Geddy, or John Paul or anyone else. Thank you for calling him out!

[@randygivens8421]

Minute by Minute and What fools believe are my favorites. Now after your dissertation, I will listen to the other songs more closely . Thank you for this video.

[@mikebassy]

This bass player with the doobies is a total legend on his instrument, love that whole taking it to the streets vibe . Great bassist no doubt about it at all

[@mdturnerinoz]

Great choices, although I had forgotten some; I have most of the Doobs from the CD era as my vinyl wore out long ago. Thanks, heaps for this! And Tiran is still kickin' too! BTW I still like Takin' It To The Streets as the most-fun Doobs bass line I got to play.

[@johndurant8687]

Thanks for sharing! I just want you to know that I've always loved the Doobie Bros. and Tiran Porter also! Great music unites humanity as one Family! We're so Blessed to be part of this Human Song!

[@stephenmead5488]

Wheels of Fortune, Eighth Avenue Shuffle, Rio, Taking It to the Street, Another Park Another Sunday, Listen to the Music, China Grove, Long Train Running, Ukiah, The Captain and Me….The list just goes on and on. Tiran is the man!

[@billjohnson6300]

FINALLY! Tiran Porter gets credit for the Doobie's sound! I've always been a big fan of his and really miss him in the Doobie's line up. Great video and really nice concept for a channel. I loved the fact that he was the black man in a white rock band. It created a very special anchor for the group and emphasized how we can all live together and make something great! Your description of yourself as a youngster seeing him in that band really resonated with me. I played bass in a Temptations-type group in Minneapolis in the early 1970's, the only white boy in the band. I learned so much and had so much fun.

[@Larrymh07]

I learned bass pretty much by listening to Tiran. Of course, that got me into trouble when rock bass playing started closing up in the late 70's. I cannot begin to express how good this video is and how grateful I am to you for giving this man his due! My favorite? All of them!

[@edjefferson9175]

BIG Tiran fan here. Listen to the Music. His bass groove is like another song in a song. The feel just makes you happy. Thanks for this! PS put some flats on that P Bass! 70’s style picked flatwound bass is cool. Peter Cetera is another favorite of that era.

[@caryd67]

Finally!! Some love for Tiran!! 🙏🏻👍🏻👍🏻 The outro on Without You is some fantastic playing from him.

[@seanmcmillan472]

It keeps you running is my favorite Tiran Porter baseline

[@sidsimo]

It's absolutely essential to acknowledge guys like Tiran Porter. He is a foundational player in a wonderful era of music. I was a young kid at that time figuring out the Doobs music in our garage bands. We were young Caucasian kids who looked them as amazing musicians. I never remember anyone commenting on any of their differences. Only how we marveled at the music they produced.

[@CharlieBass5]

Seeing Tiran playing bass with the Doobies was like seeing the black drummer for Three Dog Night, MIND BLOWING!!! I was in the first grade fall of 1960 in North Carolina. For me music was split by race. When The Righteous Brothers were singing and then The Young Rascals, I started looking at musician differently.

[@15tmun]

Paul, you really did your homework with this list, thank you. Another honorable mention song, for me, would be Another Park Another Sunday.

[@bb_lz9790]

As budding young bassists in the mid '70s, my friend and I really loved the bass line to "Long Train Runnin'"! When our high school band gets together every three years or so, it's usually on the song list and we flip a coin as to who gets to play it. Another favorite is "China Grove". But in general, I love Tiran's bass lines!

[@100157rs]

So good... love Tiran Porter. When I was a kid in high school, I was asked to be a driver of the Doobie Brothers from the airport in Memphis to the performance venue. I felt very cool. I was an amateur pianist, with a "garage band" dreaming in those days. (..never made anything of it, but always loved great musicianship). Tiran Porter was not the first melodic bass player, but he came on the scene playing unlike any bass player in a rock n roll band music...so refreshing, jazzy...was not there to only play whole notes on the bottom .. but he made thing interesting melodically and rhythmically, he took the song to another level. I hope he is doing well.