The Truth Behind Jim 'Boy' Calloway - Red Dead Redemption 2

COMMUNITY DISCORD: / discord
Support me on Patreon: / fishyyarpster
If you feel like tipping, go here: streamlabs.com...
Channel merch:
- teespring.com/...
- shop.spreadshir...
Four Pillars:
LazerzZ: / g4m3rv1dz
Tynamite: / ac3follower
LongEaredFox: / longearedfoxgaming
Join (Curse) Union for Gamers: www.unionforga...
My second channel: • Video
Snapchat: cabbagefishd3
Follow me on Twitter: / ejwoodgates
Woof: / doggoofhappines
Like my Facebook page: / fishyyarpster
Thanks for watching!
Please:
Like
Subscribe
Share
Comment
TELL YOUR FRIENDS ABOUT ME (please?)
NO SELF ADVERTISING WHETHER IT BE OF PRODUCTS OR CHANNELS (if you want me to notice your videos/products then be sure to privately message me)
I hope you enjoy the video!
Music from Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsou...
#RDR2 #RedDeadRedemption #RockstarGames

[@sjurnilsen6342]

If you shoot Billy Midnight's gun out of his hand, he will pull out another and shoot himself. Fun for the whole family!

[@AxeGaijin]

I my last playthrough, I shot the gun out of his hand, then shot him between the eyes when he drew the second gun before he could shoot himself :)

[@sjurnilsen6342]

Unfortunately, you can't shoot the second pistol away, he's going down one way or another.

[@herbertmoon9989]

AutoCody14 can you laso him when he has his first gun out

[@folari2390]

Mr shit showers gabin has harmonica you miss that.. All the gunslingers got nice new guns... So you miss alot If you don't take those free and rare guns.. sorry My english im from Finland

[@vanukas8783]

Folari torilla tavataan

[@splayairplane3418]

The greatest evil you can do in this game is starting as Arthur and coming back as John meaning Levin had to stay with Calloway for 8 years before you helped

[@rainbow4567]

Jim boy calloways story for Red Redemption 3

[@jayeezus]

@@rainbow4567 he's a coward bitch anyway. Something about Jack hall gang? Idk

[@meowmeow3778]

That's canon though, I mean, in my view, John tracks down "Plato" becuase Arthur didn't visit them after the incidents.

[@meowmeow3778]

@ZebraToxin ??? When he talks to Levin, he asks if it's him, Levin also doesn't remember him.

[@Laesis]

@@meowmeow3778 Arthur never mentioned his name to Levin either, so you get pretty much the same encounter.

[@joaovitorjuliatti287]

The funny is that when John says "send it to Jim Milton, and no it ain't my real name" if you play it with Arthur he will say almost that but instead of "Jim Milton" he says "Tacitus Kilgore"

[@antthomas7916]

Arthur's fake name is infinitely better than John's. I'm thinking about using it myself haha

[@alfiemckenna9576]

Ant Thomas it’s the entire Gangs fake name for mail

[@jpeezy6273]

@@alfiemckenna9576 yeah, Arthurs fake name is Arthur Callaghan

[@EdwinZ2000]

And John's is Rip Van Winkle

[@soofjandepr0]

FENTON!

[@victorysaber1608]

Jim boy calloway killed 14 men once. Arthur: hold my beer. Responsible for all the lemoyne raiders, o'Driscoll gang, and 100s of others deaths singluarly.

[@LiquidSnipess]

Wouldn't Arthur be considered a legendary gunslinger

[@MikeTheD]

Arthur was the most legendary gunslinger in history but he never wanted the high profile, he found it silly and vain and would affect his crew. He just wanted the muneh.

[@AlexKS1992]

And he did it when he was sick. He makes Doc Holliday and Jim Bowie look like pansies.

[@user-jd9kf8ow2q]

and he massacred 2 diffirent army brigades making it possible that he killed 3,000 or 4,000 in total

[@antthomas7916]

@@LiquidSnipess I'd say Arthur and John are the legendary gunslingers.

[@miguellucero]

I only just realized that the voice actor for Marston had to voice act hours and hours of Arthur’s lines! Crazy!

[@thenicemare]

Whats crazier is that this game is 95% performance capture, not voice acting. Which means the actor who played John had to actually act out all of the motions that Arthur did, as well as delivering the lines.

[@goobiusthetrafficcone1438]

Also I'm pretty sure theres some variations in movements and dialogue written with the two

[@tappavapahvi6184]

@@thenicemare How can I play as John

[@redshirt49]

@@tappavapahvi6184 Finish the main story up to a certain point. The last two chapters you will play as John. Though I highly recommend making a seperate hard save before the Dutch mission "Our Best Selves" in Chapter 6 because that's a point of no return in the story that the game does not warn you about, if you don't make a save here you'll be stuck with John for your entire save. Well, barring the use of cheats and mods of course.

[@tappavapahvi6184]

@@redshirt49 oh. I hope I can hang out with Arthur

[@thejadedeagle6729]

"There'll always be people who'll shoot you in the back and rewrite history." Such a great line.

[@MegaMCCow]

Pretty ironic when you think about it

[@aaronrachiele5521]

Thomas mother flippin Edison

[@reddeaddude2187]

The United States Government

[@elisarosales-solis5999]

@@reddeaddude2187 pretty much

[@ivanthehighman177]

@@MegaMCCow Based?

[@carter2.005]

In Emmett Granger’s house there is a harmonica for Sadie that she requests in chapter 3

[@andreioprea5396]

Yo thanks

[@sirskalitz2356]

Thanks I’d been needing that and forgot to look for it 😂

[@imanobody5898]

Carter 2.0 that what I forgot to get last time I was there

[@theyeetman1817]

Carter 2.0 do you know how to get Pearson’s compass

[@imanobody5898]

NoobMaster69 the navy compass Ya I think it somewhere around the brightwites (the people who took jack) don’t know how to right there name

[@Sean-zf7il]

I'd argue this string of missions is better if you play it all the way through as Arthur

[@mattprince3324]

Sean St. Aubin id argue nearly everything is better played as arthur if you can

[@briandettlinger]

I KNEW I would miss Arthur once he was gone. I did as much of the game as I could with him.

[@noamias4897]

Arthur reacts to thing so much more in his voice than John. John sounds like he’s watching it on TV and not actually doing it or really caring

[@burningsexuality1540]

Nah, I see john as the legendary gunslinger type.

[@burningsexuality1540]

John seems to idolize gunslingers like Landon Ricketts anyway

[@greedgod5827]

Even if he is a coward, he certainly is the quickest of the bunch when you fight him

[@soundwavesuperior28]

Ya, but Billy Midnight is by far the most serious. It’s not easy to manage to actually shoot the lad before he ducks, usually you’ll end up missing and getting shot yourself.

[@niggaman5069]

cole lappan Micah?

[@bruh-jr3qi]

flaco got me a couple times cuz i just couldnt get the placement of the reticle for when he dives. Billy got me once cuz i watched someone fight him and he pulled the suicide gun first but for me he squatted and faked me out :(

[@Lunaish03]

Billy killed me four times before I literally jammed my right trigger in anger and didn't give him much of a chance get me first.

[@bigben9492]

When I did it the first time, I expected sum underhanded shit and I got distracted by his gold belt buckle he was shining at my eyes and got shot in the chest 😤

[@fuzzydunlop7928]

"I even killed rocks!" Forgot about this absolute contender for best quote in the game. If you notice, Calloway is more educated then he lets on - correcting himself when he says "that which" and changing it to "thems which" during the riverboat scene, after casually name-dropping Caesar, Achilles, and Plato.

[@ZACHANDJACKSZACHSMAFIA]

True

[@raloniusmaximus]

And Gawain, one of King Arthur's knights, who is a very unknown character

[@142doddy]

Muhammad Ali: "I hurt a rock, I hospitalised a stone, I killed a brick, I'm so mean I make medicine sick" I don't think he was talking nonsense, I think he was trying to boast.

[@Leon-ub8pe]

How is thems which better that that which

[@nunyabisness7055]

And Gawain. Who the fuck has heard of Gawain?

[@riastradh]

I’m pretty sure Arthur has canonically killed more than 14 men at once by himself

[@AB-qc3qe]

What?! I knew Arthur was one of the best gunslingers but 14! Damn...

[@weebalo_]

Non Canonically the most I've done as Arthur is 15. Dead Eye points go a long way.

[@grapefruitjuice9473]

My revolver stats say the gun has killed 1028 people

[@weebalo_]

@@grapefruitjuice9473 we're talking at once

[@grapefruitjuice9473]

@@weebalo_ well mine killed 23 with the evans repeater in one go

[@Skinned_fried_n_cut_up_potato]

I like how if you finish the book as Arthur you can read it in johns house.

[@toucansam3645]

I didn't know that, how do you get it to activate as Arthur? Just wait?

[@quinnobrien4639]

you can go to the river boat in chapter 4 not sure if you have to do any of the chapter 4 missions

[@abiatfinns]

In the start of the epilog when John, abigale and Jack are moving to strawberry they are talking about the book in the carriage. Abigale liked the book but Jack liked stories about English knights more.

[@Nono-gj6sp]

@@toucansam3645 the mission will eventually spawn in valentine and you can do the river boat mission in chapter 4

[@xrafter]

​ the mission continues in chapter 4. I think You need to finish trewlany's mission first in that same boat, that's how I activated.

[@ivikaputova3177]

Theodore is a nice dude... he had waited for you whole 8 years😂

[@RaytheGrayt]

I'm done 😂

[@BreakingWhite]

Every stranger does

[@bluecayser1498]

I got the money as John when I started the epoiloge. It helped actually.

[@Caupolicanus]

I killed Emmet Granger and Flaco Hernandez in Chapter 6 :v and i continued with john

[@badreedinedjellali1328]

he's face looks very fimler he looks like a an actor that I saw him in other movies

[@comradenapoleon4908]

When looking back at the duel with Calloway, I noticed that he's kind of wiggling a bit. I also noticed how uncharacteristically shiny his belt buckle is. So I've come to the conclusion that he's using his belt buckle to reflect sunlight into your eyes to increase your chances of missing. A coward and a cheater till the end it seems.

[@John-doe955]

Frankly that just sounds clever to me.

[@Richard-Nixon-Gaming]

¹0

[@lunix3259]

Did not noticed that the first time. Now I realized I spent few seconds on his shiny belt instead of his gun

[@Shitposting_IHMN]

I never did this mission, didnt realise that inspecting photos gives you the location, and couldnt be bothered about finding them, do I forgot about this

[@DrYnroh]

It worked on me honestly - I still won the duel but I definitely looked at his stupid belt for a fraction of a second lol

[@frogg5368]

I love how they give John slight changes to his dialog. Like telling him to send the money to Jim Milton, instead of tacitus Kilgore

[@king10k15]

Well why tf would he say send it to tacitus kilgore if hes not in the gang anymore

[@user-en7rr2jt1n]

king 10k shut up, he’s admiring the game for slight changes and the amount of detail

[@bradcook7694]

It still wouldn't make sense if he said to send it to the gang. Slight details or common sense.

[@frogg5368]

@@bradcook7694 that's the point, they realized it wouldn't make sense so they changed the line. But that detail is not something you see in every game

[@OFAH55]

Just one interesting thing for Flaco, I don't remember how I triggered it but you can talk to his men then they will walk away.

[@esoscorridasos105]

You have to antagonize the men when they talk to you.

[@OFAH55]

I couldn't remember how to do it on my second playthrough. But that seems right thinking about it.

[@carter2.005]

OFAH88 I didn’t know that

[@CrungleFunk]

Yeah, trying to be nice gets you in a fight if you go that route

[@c0nn0r0hagan]

i threw dinamite at him

[@jackd00711]

Fun fact, Jim “boy” Calloway was a reference to bully, Jim as the main character Jimmy Hopkins, everyone called him “boy” and the name Calloway is similar to the English teacher Galloway

[@Pughausen]

And his gun shared its inscription with the European name of Bully, Canis Canem Edit (Dog Eat Dog in latin)

[@SammyJoee]

wow that’s sick

[@mrowley7300]

Didn't know that, that's kinda cool

[@allan-ls9zo]

also both calloway and galloway are alcoholics

[@carter2.005]

Jackdeannn 7 his revolver also says Canis Canem Edit which was what the code name given to Bully in Australia because apparently Bully is too inappropriate for a video game according to the Australian government

[@souptime7058]

I like this quest a lot. Black Belle was such a nice lady.

[@nandinhocunha440]

She's a bad ass and honest person

[@2_572]

More like violent.

[@lunix3259]

@@2_572 Huh.

[@2_572]

@@lunix3259 she was a pleasant violent lady.

[@Mister_RandomGuychannel]

In read dead online she threatens to suicide bomb us with dynamite bruh

[@God_Is_An_Atheist]

I always laugh when Arthur says "I'm unarmed", even though it's clearly visible that he's armed to the teeth.

[@kayn2222]

I think he says that cuz originally I had my gun drawn at the door, and the gunslinger makes you put ur gun away before he comes out.

[@Whiskers4169]

@@kayn2222if you threaten the gang members they just escort you to the door and escape when you kill flaco

[@bekleedee]

It's crazy that Billy Midnight was plastered but STILL managed to draw so quickly. Also, Black Belle is amazing.

[@dext1971]

Unfortunately, we couldn't kill her and get her gun to

[@dext1971]

@scarletgoat173 no it isn't.

[@chokomaru5465]

yeah he also uses a double action pistol tho so he gets to shoot faster

[@bekleedee]

@@dext1971 blasphemy! I wouldn't kill her! I'd want her to team up with Arthur

[@RhysWerner]

Ai wanna play as her in rdr3​@@bekleedee

[@tenebrae6049]

The reason you get the gunslingers locations is because the photos have the last known location of them on the back

[@DyzioThingsGang]

Conveniently they’re exactly there at the exact time you’re thee

[@IAmKentori]

Tenebrae ke

[@noamias4897]

Catalysts imagine one of them being out shopping food or whatever

[@Guccipoooch]

@@noamias4897 and somebody at the same aisle as him yells “DRAW”

[@antthomas7916]

That station clerk is the shit, I love that guy haha

[@redspider3513]

Rab'Anderson2013 It’s Alden.

[@kadz2.088]

But he set the gang up

[@kingofthedaddys8012]

Kadz 2.0 did he?

[@kadz2.088]

King of the Daddy's Yeah, Dutch, Lenny or Charles (don’t remember) and Arthur were going to rob a station in Saint Denis, Because Alden said it was full of money. But when they robbed it all the cops in Saint denis showed up in a few seconds after. Plus all they got was $15 so Alden lied and set them up.

[@TheAddictiveVideos]

@@kadz2.088 No, that was Bronte that set them up. Alden didn't do anything. Source: I replayed that mission yesterday.

[@Skywalker_-qq2mb]

"Don't confused what's famous for what's true" - Black Belle

[@No._.Boundariesz]

Ok

[@whatzpoppin6181]

Good quote

[@Jobe-13]

True. Funny thing is, the truth tends to be crazier than fiction

[@mrcaesar3123]

@@Jobe-13 or more disappointing than it is made out to be.

[@metaknight115]

@Yubio The battle of Samar is a good example, where a few small US Navy destroyers managed to fight off a giant Japanese fleet, led by the largest and most powerful battleship ever built

[@thomasj.8081]

Honest to god, I felt horrible killing Jim. I used his revolver in every mission from then on, in honor of him.

[@NotPixer]

Goosche You did him a good service. I mostly used midnights pistol

[@cobussy]

Not Pixer i didn’t really care to use midnights, as it had pretty low stats.

[@bigsmoke9369]

I dual wielded granger and flacos revolvers

[@inshan3st3r]

I didn't feel guilty. But I used his custom engraved revolver.

[@braydennivon4663]

Could of used volcanic pistols

[@toucansam3645]

I wish Flacco Hernandez was in the game alot more, I liked his character and his style. Almost like Danny Trejo.

[@BlackWolf-vs6uo]

Inspired by him

[@UttaButta89568]

I think he’s in online mode as a stranger mission

[@liaq8768]

yes! i liked flaco so much! its cool that in rd online you can meet him and do dirty jobs for him, but i really wish he participated more in the game

[@JesusChrist-bq6lu]

Devthebest374 online is set a few years before story mode Micah isn’t even part of the gang yet

[@shadysam7161]

I wish Black Belle was more involved in the game, IMO she'd make a better badass gunslinger than Sadie Adler.

[@MasterGaming234]

Best to do this with Arthur you get more dialogue

[@RaytheGrayt]

They tried to make Sadie the ultimate badass, but Black Belle is my choice.

[@cxx23]

Agreed! Black Belle is amazing. Though I do love Sadie too.

[@-scrim]

Sadie is the most overrated character. They tried _way_ too hard to make her a badass, imo.

[@cxx23]

@@-scrim They probably did try hard but it worked fine in my opinion. The idea that they tried too hard in my opinion is silly, when you consider that almost every main protagonist you've ever played as has been the result of dev's trying insanely hard to make a character come across as a badass. Did they write "strong female character on a whiteboard and pool ideas from there? Probably. But I'm not against it. She's a fine character with a classic revenge story.

[@NinjapowerMS]

@@cxx23 Thing is Arthur or John has years of experience as a gunslinger with the gang. Sadie just becomes yeah I'm a badass woman now because lol revenge. Maybe if they slowly develop her throughout the story to justify her skills with the gun maybe she wouldn't come off as a try hard written character even then jesus lower her achievements will ya. She's as volatile as Micah in gunfights and apparantly she's just fine getting away with that crap because cool wahmen

[@cxx23]

@@NinjapowerMS I can agree that the jump from victim to badass was too fast and we never see her hone her skills. I think comparing her to Micah is unrealistic though. They are both unpredictable sure, but with Micah you have to worry he'll kill innocents. Sadie only goes off on those trying to take advantage of her, and of course the O'Driscolls. My reason for coming to her defense is that we are willing to suspend our belief for sudden male badasses all the time. Normal guy turns instant killing machine when his daughter/wife/dog/etc is killed. I agree at least that Sadies classic "sudden badassery trope" is a bit out of place in RDR2s otherwise realistic world. Especially scenes like the one where you have to run to "help" her during the O'Driscoll raid of Shady Bell and she's completely destroying these guys who had her outnumbered with guns, with a knife.

[@breezyhillproductions349]

What would be really cool is if the third Red Dead Redemption goes even further back and we get cameos from all these gun slingers in their heyday.

[@ab14967]

It feels like that's what they're doing. We might see the time when Hosea and Dutch were getting their gang in full force.

[@DR-54]

@S U N N Y Damn you're 10?

[@swoluigi3828]

@@DR-54 bruh he 2

[@thoughtpolice2191]

Swoluigi man he’s still swimming in my nuts.

[@ice_sea5527]

RDR3 except you play as uncle

[@lakotacable9623]

I think Jim Boy Calloway was trying to blind you by reflecting the sun off his belt buckle in the dual.

[@CapnCrunc3]

Inside Granger’s house is the harmonica Sadie asks for in one of the first missions of chapter 3

[@Fizhy]

Yup.

[@CrungleFunk]

Gabriel Muniz Shit! Really?! I totally ended up breaking into some dude’s cabin and I had to squeeze the life out of him.

[@HeyBoss695]

Awesome! Thanks for the tip.

[@larrymays4244]

Can you still give to her after chapter 6?

[@laurak2999]

@@larrymays4244 no, I don't think so

[@dr.bright6272]

From what Belle tells Arthur, the only thing Calloway did in gunfights is run and hide. Same thing is mentioned by the Marshall when you bring him to Calloway. Calloway never showed up for their duel.

[@erosaguirre2133]

Jimmy Calloway's Cousin is ALIVE. If wondering who is he is, It's the Doctor from Valentine. If you buy something in his shop, He'll mention his cousin saying "My cousin Jimmy......(forgot the rest of the Dialog)" which means Slim Grand Didn't/never shot Calloway's cousin because Jim Boy was probably drunk while away from a fight like Black Belle mention

[@chokomaru5465]

yeah but hes still the fastest out of the 4 you duel

[@Whiskers4169]

@@chokomaru5465being swift does not amount to anything if the man is a coward and a cheater

[@MCEnderbornGaming]

10:55 if you antagonize the del lobos they’ll let you talk to Flaco without a fight. The cutscene still plays out the same and the gang turns hostile when Flaco does, but all the gang members will flee after Flaco dies.

[@awittyusernamepleaselaugh7481]

Honestly I wish you could recruit Black Belle for the gang. She'd have been incredibly useful to have around and there's no way she'd have fallen for Micah's BS.

[@laprincesadelacocina]

She is a badass

[@michaellorah9051]

Problem is, I doubt she'd have fallen for Dutch's BS either. She'd have called the whole gang a bunch of moronic sheep and laughed as she walked away.

[@awittyusernamepleaselaugh7481]

@@michaellorah9051 I could see her liking Dutch before he goes nuts, and seeing as you tend to meet her relatively early on Dutch would still be mostly sane?

[@degew9367]

@@awittyusernamepleaselaugh7481 dutch probably never changed, just showed who he really was, as John put it

[@anonymousangel1831]

@@degew9367 nah I feel like he hit his head and got crazy and crazier has he lost hose

[@parth3074]

If you finish all the missions as arthur. Levins book actually gets published and is mentioned by jack. I love this detail

[@conormartin3476]

What does he say about it?

[@rushellealexandra5243]

it says that regardless as i didnt get to looking at pictures till after i was john was just too busy then forget and came back to it jack says that about the book no matter what .. so i think its a seprate book then the one jack refers to ..as jack was refering to one that was only about jim and his one friend but didnt include his other friends and was seperate side story .... vs a complete history ....

[@rushellealexandra5243]

that book jack refers about is found at the cabin with the two dead kids in it and made many yrs prior to the new one they wanted to make

[@Mister_RandomGuychannel]

Yeah i was impressed by detail when i first heard it

[@enthusiasticallydry]

different book

[@e-scope]

I did the Slim Grant part in Chapter 6 so when they said he was going to Beaver Hollow to look for some outlaws, I got super worried

[@Alexpoatanereira]

I think you have to do it in chapter 6

[@jarnoveldman9256]

@@Alexpoatanereira You can do it anytime after chapter 4

[@yaboytroy357]

@@jarnoveldman9256 you can access the mission as soon as you do the riverboat poker heist

[@mapleflag6518]

@@AlexpoatanereiraUh…… did you even watch the video?

[@オクタン-g7u]

I noticed out of all the gunslingers, billy was significantly younger, with him probably being fairly early 40's he probably still has his speed which made him so famous.

[@waffler-yz3gw]

mid 30s sounds more right

[@tomvanvilsteren1694]

Nothing is better than watching a 25 min video of the mysteries of Red Dead 2 with crisps

[@noamias4897]

I’m always eating sausage and meatballs when I watch videos about Jim Boy Calloway and the other gunslingers, but now I’m eating cornflakes, so this sucks! Good video as always.

[@toucansam3645]

Shrimp scampi for me 🍤. (Edit:I never like my own comments, but this one I legit like.)

[@drewhendrickson2467]

Toucan Sam hol up you rich?

[@toucansam3645]

Drew Hendrickson Na, it's from a pre frozen bag.

[@uselesstomato8191]

I agree

[@wrongcourier6894]

Jim boy may be a coward but he also felt really bad when he shot him in the back, meaning he wanted an honorable duel and to get his revenge fair and square. P.S shooting someone in the back is the most Dishonorable thing you could do in the old west.

[@Meese12]

Wrong Courier 6 well, it was the most dishonorable thing to do in the romanticized Wild West we’ve created that Jim Calloway abides by. In the real Wild West, happened all the time.

[@wrongcourier6894]

@@Meese12 thats true lol, ever since this comment ive since done more wild west history and know about it now.

[@user-en7rr2jt1n]

Also shooting someone unarmed

[@elmothecrackaddict646]

I think it was more of the most cowardly things to do

[@loganrcooke]

Emmet is definitely a coward he didn’t even draw he threw a knife and went to attack you

[@supergenius6256]

Black Belle was an interesting character to me tbh, would like to see her expanded upon at a later time.

[@WowDoodWuuut]

I mean she's based off Belle Starr.. just read a book.

[@supergenius6256]

@@WowDoodWuuut Ah, I never considered to see who she was based off of.

[@KevinCCucumber]

You don't have to kill those Del Lobos on the mountain. I chose the second option and they let me speak to him. They run away after the duel

[@rickperry3165]

Why? Kill em and loot em. Free money and jewelry lol

[@KevinCCucumber]

@@rickperry3165 if you're on a replay and are speedrunning antagonizing them will certainly speed it up

[@rickperry3165]

@@KevinCCucumber yes I understand that bro. But I love the looting lol. I love stockpiling everything I need and that I can sell. Plus I never speed play. I'm more of a complete precision gamer. I've already beat this game 100% quite a few times and I can't get enough of it. Always something to do.

[@nandinhocunha440]

They shot at me so I shot back at them

[@Sorrelhas]

"What were they like, then? Those days they all talk about" "Same as now, I guess. Only longer ago" That's a really good line that frankly applies to every age, not just to the Wild West.

[@Skinned_fried_n_cut_up_potato]

13:04 me hunting player bounties 13:19 how it always ends

[@roboalexjohn5353]

Yeah that's about right

[@javierescuella731]

Haha I play on Xbox do everyone is bad alongside me

[@Felandil]

*Theodore: Do you think anyone noticed it was you?* *John: Noticed? The People **_I shot noticed._* *But he didnt shot those Gunslingers Arthur did!* *I mean in this Video.*

[@skrunklyOwO]

@@king10k15 go back to school and learn basic grammar lmao.

[@boxcutter4]

@@king10k15 arthur is a legend in this game, dont get so butthurt about it

[@samperrin7965]

@@king10k15 Arthur is a better character though

[@jacrispy3275]

Both are awesome characters. Now move the fuck on.

[@lagilagoson8392]

Mathew C. I could not have said it better myself

[@Mangler559]

"I even killed rocks. And I killed 'em good." -Emmet Granger

[@rk800prototype5]

What an absolute chad

[@kevybeslersunlandpark4130]

In the old west there actually was a couple of duels that were legit. Only like 2 famous duels were real though the rest of the gunslinger stories were just crazy drunkin shootouts and robberies gone bad.

[@ZACHANDJACKSZACHSMAFIA]

Clay allison?

[@ZACHANDJACKSZACHSMAFIA]

I'm sorry but I love calloway oddly after I saw his odd speed and skill I just couldn't say he isnt legendary.... his character sadly resonates with mine

[@gamercore5216]

And theres Frank M. Canton who is practically a red dead protag himself

[@cameronsteidel3610]

"Caved into Arthurs threats" I mean wouldn't you, the man's terrifying when he needs to be.

[@andrelunaisatuna]

If you antagonize Flaco's fellow Del Lobos instead of greeting them, they don't initiate a battle, they just let you talk to Flaco, and after you kill him they all just scatter.

[@jorgebersabe293]

If you read the biography on the Del Lobo Gang, it specifically says that loyalty isn't something that they consider important and it's seen in this scene.

[@thomasyoung5323]

Fun fact if you complete the entire stranger mission as Arthur during the epilogue beginning cut scene Jack Marston mentions reading Boy Callaway's biography

[@payteyboy3809]

"i took a carriage to save time" *CUTS TO 8 YEARS LATER*

[@TheFinnflash]

I'd rather read a book about Black Belle then little boy Calloway really.

[@alexkhaid]

Jericho Jim but black belle ain’t interested in books

[@HereIsWisdom1318]

Weird. When I went to Flacco Hernandez, I didn’t “discover” the Del Lobo gang (that I remember).

[@ivikaputova3177]

HereIsWisdom 1318 me neither on 1st play through, neither 2nd... but on 3rd yes 😂

[@noamias4897]

It’s because you didn’t kill any of them when you did it. That’s why I always antagonize them, then shoot one after they run away

[@HereIsWisdom1318]

Noamias I had to kill them; there was a bunch outside the cabin.

[@noamias4897]

HereIsWisdom 1318 if you threat them they let you walk there peacefully

[@mistervanwyk7405]

He was still the fastest compared to the other gunslingers. Flaco Hernandez was also pretty fast and his little trick of jumping sideway and drawing up a sawed off shotgun if you doesn't kill him right on the first bullet during the duel is pretty badass. Emmett Granger have balls to do a revolver duel armed with a throwing knife and he was also pretty fast especially considering the fact that he used a damn throwing knife....

[@eduparada970]

Yeah, if Im not wrong Jim Boy Calloway has the fastest drawing speed in the game for an npc meaning that the only way of winning is cheating or at the very best it will end as a draw (both you and him death)

[@chokomaru5465]

@@eduparada970 i just beat him fair and square about 10 mins ago bro.

[@greg_hammelson]

​@@eduparada970 Not sure how I did it but I managed to kill him first try by quickdrawing to his head

[@SoSoDEVIL]

If you are new to this game I'd definitely recommend doing the three male gunslingers immediately. They give you some very good and one of a kind guns. Flaco also has a treasure map in his shack.

[@Herandro_just_Herandro]

There's also a harmonica inside Granger's house that will be useful in the future.

[@TheWonkster]

It's insane that 3 of these dudes were absolutely blasted when you duel them and they STILL draw like they do. Even Calloway, who I expected to be a joke fake-out only to get Arthur's skull perforated five times in a row, makes it seem like he WAS a great gunslinger and maybe he's drinking to forget some things instead

[@GodProdutions]

I think it's crazy that so many of these missions could be finished as Morgan or Marston, lotta work for all those voice lines

[@welon17]

I'm a writer aficionado myself, I write stories for kids, I'm still learning. But one of the first things I learned is that "lying" or making up unbelievable stuff is more efficient than being realistic, the ending Levin came up with is genius, he is an excellent writer.

[@Ricardo_Rick]

I have a challenge for you: a video explaining how the van der linde gang could have succeeded in the game after every chapter, let me explain: You need to say what the gang could have done to have success in their plans after each chapter, for example: chapter 1, how could the gang succeeded after the blackwater fail? chapter 2: how could they have succeeded after the events of chapter one, etc. Winning condition: the gang gets enough money and vanish (either to the west or to TAHITI, your choice) Losing Condition: The gang gets destroyed, arrested or gets any members killed (i won't let you got the easy way out and sacrifice Micah, even if he deserves it) You can be honorable or not, you choice. What do you think? could the gang have succeeded in every chapter? or it was doomed to fail since the beggining?

[@superrknight1858]

Ricardo Magalhães I agree although I don't see how they could've succeeded after chapter 4

[@Ricardo_Rick]

@@superrknight1858 if after they rescued jack they have gone straight for the bank instead of the failed trolley station and the revenge against bronte they would have a lot of money and no pinkertons in the city already

[@superrknight1858]

Ricardo Magalhães That's possible but I mean after chapter 4 ( 5 and 6). I don't really see how they could've successfully escape unless I'm missing something

[@number1semetaryfan]

Can't kill Micah? Who the hell do you take me or him for! KILL THE RAT

[@Ricardo_Rick]

@@number1semetaryfan i would love to see him dead, but hey, that would be too easy

[@lukeschofield574]

8:10 I miss the healthy Arthur man.....

[@PanzerMan332]

This why I kinda believe the "Red is Uncle" theory people throw around. It makes a lot more sense if you consider that Red was a folk hero gunslinger who likely did none of the things people said he did, disappeared, and had a legacy attached to him after the fact by a dime store novel about his life that was written by someone else, just like Jim Calloway. Red is the larger-than-life figure, Uncle is the shadow of that person.

[@bluesnake1713]

I feel as if killing Granger on the spot, made me felt like he deserved it.

[@TheTaterTotP80]

I believe honour and dishonour did and does exist, both back then and now. Although I'm sure many a story is romanticisation of the survivors by them and their peers.

[@AwesomeGuy123]

Something I just realized, was replaying the game again and went to the doctor to rob the secret business for quick money and shot him during it in an accidental Dead Eye lock to the head. He of course was bandaged and put back in his shop. And then after he was fully healed and I went back to his shop he said. “You watch yourself, the name Calloway means something round here.” The Valentine doctor is related to Jim Boy Calloway!

[@DoctorBright]

If you antagonize the del lobos you don’t have to fight them

[@ethanStieg]

For flaco hernandez if you holster weapons and defuse the before the gunfight you can go talk with him but you have to do the gunfight afterwards

[@Scoat]

Not true. If you play fair duel him fairly then they note this and move on. Also don't defuse, antagonise, show the gang you have balls. Most reasonable gang I've met. Kill their leader and they see it as the way of life.

[@ethanStieg]

@@Scoat oh I didn't know that

[@abhaykaushik9824]

Levin should have called John to help him make a book about Arthur

[@goinawol9447]

With Flaco, if you antagonize the del Lobos, they dont kill you but if you defuse they do.

[@midnight-x-rayne9003]

You failed to mention that each of the outlaws that you kill has their own special gun you can pick up.

[@the_ceeman]

Fun fact you can leave emmet granger and flaco alive if you shoot them in the leg then knock them out

[@ciarandolan7695]

you know you can do this whole questline as Arthur right also you can find a newspaper as Arthur after completing this quest that corroborates a lot of what they tell you like the whole backstory behind midnight and the very real atrocities granger committed or was apart of plus the rest of them

[@walkrslayer1305]

I think it’s cool that Arthur saying he has no name is a reference to Clint Eastwood the man with no name.

[@Gallifreyanqueen]

I found out in my current playthrough of the game that if you threaten the gang member who demands to know what you're doing there, they'll say "ok, if it's just questions, he's in that cabin." and let you just walk up. Then after, when you will the duel against him, they all run away yelling about how they aren't gonna die for him

[@SomerandomShmuck]

What i like about the little gunslinger stories and cards is that they have interesting stories and such. Me being a huge western nerd, i am fascinated by the stories and gunslinger missions like i am with real life gunslingers in the past. And they make them seem like real life gunslingers with interesting events and such. Also, some of them are probably hugely based off of real stores. Like Billy Midnight, it's said that after his slinger days he would perform plays and such like buffallo bill, and Black Belle probably based on Calamity Jane. The aformentioned, and famous, Otis Miller, maybe based on Jesse James. It's so fucking cool that Rockstar did this.

[@an0rangutan]

That's weird, I didn't have to fight the Gang members at Flaco's place, I just asked them where he was and talked to him, after I killed him they either ran off or just sat there, I forget which.

[@oscar_jjuarez5266]

Been well over a year I’ve done like 5 play throughs (currently on 6 1st 100% trying my best) and I never bat a eye on these scenes BRILLIANT! Oh and great Video BOAH

[@jlash259]

Oscar_J Juarez nice. Working on my second 100%. Damn gambler and herbalist challenges suck!!!

[@oscar_jjuarez5266]

JLash gambler is a damn joke 🤦‍♂️

[@michaellorah9051]

Of the 5 gunslingers you meet, when they were in their prime the two deadliest in a straight up duel would arguably have been Midnight and Calloway. Their speed and accuracy are insane and they're both old, drunk, and rusty. Hell, midnight is damn near insane. Granger is nothing more than a loudmouth with a temper. Flaco is simply tricky with his unpredictability. Black Belle is practically chaos incarnate and would rather blow shit up than duel straight.

[@eduparada970]

Calloway so fast bro 💀 Cant even imagine him in his prime since he was old and drunk and yet the only way to win as a prime arthur morgan or prime john is by cheating

[@marcusmclean3842]

Granger kills you with a throw knife if you don't draw quick enough so lol

[@chokomaru5465]

@@eduparada970 you can win without cheating.

[@1000herecomesthepain]

Who knew throwing dynamite at manure would cause such a shitstorm?

[@rtbmb]

1000herecomesthepain literally

[@AderpHi]

I’ve redone this mission recently and for flaco Hernandez you can threaten his men or something like that and you don’t have to fight them

[@KaladinVegapunk]

Aw, it feels so weird doing it as John and not Arthur hahah, his reaction to Slim's death is just so much funnier haha, he's stoked

[@Indarow]

If you threaten Flaco’s men instead of try to defuse the situation, they’ll let you speak to Flaco. After killing Flaco, his men will hit the dust about half the time.

[@noamias4897]

I’m always eating sausage and meatballs when I watch videos about Jim Boy Calloway and the other gunslingers, but now I’m eating cornflakes, so this sucks! Good video as always.

[@TheChaoticToaster]

How tough are you? *”I killed rocks.”*

[@rickperry3165]

Actually in Grangers house, that is where you get the harmonica for Sadie Adler. And a can of baked beans lol.

[@deathslingermain7467]

After the first Black Belle cutscene finished, I forgot I was on KZbin and started to position my hands as I would when playing RDR2 before I realized I was watching a video.

[@pugachevskobra5636]

For new or returning players who suffer from long term amnesia this mission is the earliest and best way to get a camera that your player can use. I didn’t know about this during my first play through so it was a pleasant surprise.

[@ブルンバーグ]

In Grangers Hoggery there’s the harmonica for Sadie. Just wanted to let anyone who was looking for that know :)

[@notsae66]

I wish Arthur had given the writer his name, then he could have had a little portion of his (more than mildly romanticized) history immortalized. He was by far the best gunslinger around, and he deserved to go down in history for it. Just adds to the tragedy, I suppose.

[@koczisek]

"In a world where only survival of the fittest is important, honor is irrelevant" - great quote! I feel like I'm going to cite it periodically.

[@finnbarmccready3383]

this is probably my favourite side mission because of all the unique revolvers you get from the gunslingers

[@GoddesseyCreations]

"You just took yourself a regular shit shower, Mr. Granger" 😂😂😂 Love that damn line.

[@robertorellana103]

22:43 gets me every time

[@bigsauce7099]

I love how no one talks about John wearing the same clothes for 4 years😂😂

[@trainknut]

"Hey I'm already damned" is probably the best line in this whole quest.

[@bradenr867]

“He once killed 14 men” Arthur: rookie numbers

[@glados8653]

Levin: last of the gunslingers Me: black belle is still alive lol

[@alexzaze1407]

It's so weird seeing Marston acting like Arthur...

[@king10k15]

Hes not those missions aren't even cannon asshole

[@antthomas7916]

@@king10k15 How are they not cannon?

[@MrLiverpoolfan92]

@@king10k15 They are

[@blackskullz7934]

U like how you added the bandolier like from rdr1 Edit: I wish they gave us landon ricketts instead of all these gunslingers.

[@martyrobbins5241]

Maybe any plans with him were scrapped after the actor died

[@ogloc8212]

The only one I liked out of the gun slingers was flaco

[@bigskullnobrain3974]

Might not of worked cause he was the one who might of shot John in the Blackwater massacre and with most missions you can carry them on with John in the epilogue so him meeting landed rickets wouldn't make sense since you meet him for the first time in rdr1

[@tonyleblanc7302]

I think this character was based on English Bob from Unforgiven. It’s pretty parallel with the writer following around, not knowing he’s a coward.

[@Tsudkyk]

I think most the gun slingers were also suffering from PTSD, the likely acted out of fear and live with a lot of guilt. They are probably terrified making the same mistake twice or becoming the victim of something like them.

[@thegamegamer69]

When your so early your back in 2017 when everyone said “fIrSt”

[@bruh_3139]

That still happens though regardless of year

[@theelderworm9134]

You're I'm so sorry.

[@dimez3702]

The Game Gamer25 people never stopped saying first

[@thegamegamer69]

The Elderworm no I’m sorry I should have double checked my spelling before posting something in your grammar cop territory /s

[@bruh_3139]

The Game Gamer25 “Game Gamer” Ironic

[@-Thunder-Warrior-]

Oh cool you finished the Mission with John? I did it with Arthur, but it's awesome you can do either!