The Tungsten Boat Riddle - Theory vs. Reality

  Рет қаралды 137,118

JaDropping Science

JaDropping Science

8 ай бұрын

Become a JaDropping Supporter using this link:
/ @jadroppingscience
What happens when you drop a heavy object off of a boat? Does the water level rise, lower or stay the same?
Here's an affiliate link to the Tungsten block I got on Amazon if anyone is interested: amzn.to/44uT4PI

Пікірлер: 253
@pixelpuppy
@pixelpuppy 8 ай бұрын
I didn't get it at first, but I understand now. the key is dropping it from a boat rather than from the air. because the boat is displacing both the weight of the tungsten and itself, and once you drop the tungsten, the boat becomes more buoyant, and displaces less water.
@marshy25
@marshy25 8 ай бұрын
thank you this helped me understand it better.
@Zinericks
@Zinericks 8 ай бұрын
​@@marshy25me too
@dataexpunged6969
@dataexpunged6969 8 ай бұрын
This comment clarified the whole video. Thank you so much!
@thesillygoose2
@thesillygoose2 8 ай бұрын
And to put it in more simplier terms in case you still don't understand well this is how my brain seen it and it made since to me before he explained it. So for me instead of seeing it as displacement of water I saw it as well a boat sinking or having alot of weight if you throw out the heavy cargo in the boat the lighter the boat becomes therefore making it float more but the proper term for it is buoyancy. And I guess all that is basically displacement of water so idk thats just how my toddler brain understood it 😂
@OmegaINDcreates
@OmegaINDcreates 8 ай бұрын
So, it has nothing to do with the block of tungsten, it's just the object making the boat float higher than it was with the block, lowering the water level because there's less object volume in the water
@jamiejam9976
@jamiejam9976 8 ай бұрын
Mad respect for designing such a complex and sophisticated timed release mechanism for this
@AlrenClan
@AlrenClan 8 ай бұрын
The way I just visualise it is when you drop the cube the boat would float higher and your relative water level would fall and therefore you would displace less meaning the total water level would fall. ( in case anyone needs a different explanation.)
@SwiftShadow887
@SwiftShadow887 8 ай бұрын
He should have just hired you to explain it in this video 🤦‍♂️
@k_brie7890
@k_brie7890 22 күн бұрын
That is a great explanation, however, I still do not understand. I’m going to have to come back to this video and your comment at a later time with the hope that after my mind has had some rest, I’ll be able to comprehend the experiment. Me quedé echa papas 🥔😅😂
@manuelferran4483
@manuelferran4483 8 ай бұрын
I completely ignored the fact that we were dropping this thing from a boat
@paulosullivan3472
@paulosullivan3472 26 күн бұрын
Yeah it literally wasnt until the very end of the video when I realised that his original premise was dropping it from a boat and not just dropping a cube of tungsten into water. I was sitting there the whole time saying no... it definately will raise the water... and then that little oversight of mine dawned on me!
@Tvngsten
@Tvngsten 8 ай бұрын
I would like to not be dropped off a boat, please.
@JaDroppingScience
@JaDroppingScience 8 ай бұрын
If there's any concepts that confuse you and you'd like to see me do a real-life demo on, let me know here in the comments!
@Sooliyakkottai_PUMS
@Sooliyakkottai_PUMS 8 ай бұрын
Can you explain about the magnetic filed by a circular conductor while passing electricity because it has poles circular so all the points of circle are poles?
@the888gamemaster
@the888gamemaster 8 ай бұрын
You should have also included the explanation about how it's due to the boat that causes the water to lower, it's not actually based around the tungsten cube
@Reeeexce
@Reeeexce 8 ай бұрын
Yes please, my brain wants to say "well actually, less Styrofoam is in the container, causing it to look like less"
@OhhCrapGuy
@OhhCrapGuy 8 ай бұрын
I just have to say that I LOVE approach to teaching people to be less credulous, and that the educational value of what you're creating simply cannot be overstated. I think that one very valuable thing you could add is instead of viewers merely finishing the video and simply knowing 𝘵𝘩𝘢𝘵 something is true or fake, providing them the facts, clues, and logical connections that could have used to 𝙪𝙣𝙙𝙚𝙧𝙨𝙩𝙖𝙣𝙙 why it's true or fake. For instance, for the recent "Sunscreen blocking IR light", I didn't 𝘬𝘯𝘰𝘸 it was fake, I 𝙪𝙣𝙙𝙚𝙧𝙨𝙩𝙤𝙤𝙙 that it was. 1. Infra means "under", so "infrared" is under red, meaning it's lower wavelength 2. Ultra means "over" or "more", so "ultraviolet" has a higher wavelength. 3. X Rays and Gamma Rays are very short wavelength, while radio is long. 4. Ultraviolet must be the dangerous one, not IR, sunscreen doesn't block IR. Or with more specific knowledge: 1. IR is generally between a millimeter and a micrometer and is less powerful than visible light 2. UV is between 100-400 nanometers and is more powerful than visible light. 3. If IR was harmful, then visible light would be as well 4. More powerful individual photons do more damage 5. Because IR is closer to the scale of cells and larger, it can't affect DNA. Its effect must be on entire cells. 6. UV is closer to the scale of proteins and molecules, so it can affect parts of a cell, and when parts of a cell break, you can get cancer. 7. Sunscreen prevents cancer. Or with even more different knowledge: 1. 50% of solar radiation at sea level is IR, 3% is UV, and sunscreen doesn't make the sun feel half as hot. And the same thing goes for the truths, what were the facts we might know that would let us 𝙪𝙣𝙙𝙚𝙧𝙨𝙩𝙖𝙣𝙙 what is happening, rather than just knowing that it's true. For the Ice + Salt + water + water bottles, that fact could be knowing that sodium chloride salt lowers the freezing point of water, allowing the salt water mixed with the ice to become colder than 0C without freezing even in the presence of nucleation sites, and allowing the pure water in the bottles to become super cooled until it encounters existing ice which acts as a nucleation site to allow the creation of the slush. But again, thank you so much for what you're doing to encourage more incredulity.
@footyxeditimsubbingtoevery5457
@footyxeditimsubbingtoevery5457 6 ай бұрын
How mirrors work😂
@richieshambharkar3938
@richieshambharkar3938 5 ай бұрын
This was a mock exam MCQ question in my IGCSE papers. My teacher deliberately gave it, and everyone got it wrong in the exam. Its been 5 years since that, I am almost done with my degree in Physics. But stuff like this always kept me wondering. Thanks for the explanation, please keep uploading more videos.
@Countzz
@Countzz 8 ай бұрын
This question gets much harder if the block of tungsten is connected to the boat by a chain
@anonymoususer8517
@anonymoususer8517 8 ай бұрын
not really it would just momentarily be the same as the video and then it would displace about the same amount as when on the boat then its just a matter of how much more or less then before is displaced depending on what kind of chain
@mcmonkey26
@mcmonkey26 8 ай бұрын
@@anonymoususer8517wouldnt it displace more watee than in the boat, because it displaces some water by its volume but also pulls the boat down and makes that displace wayer
@Aure457
@Aure457 8 ай бұрын
@@mcmonkey26It wouldn’t, because the volume that the cube displaces is also counted towards the total volume displaced by the boat and the cube combined, a way of seeing it is: if you weigh the cube and the boat in grams, it will be the milliliters of water that it displaces, no matter the configuration (in real life it’ll displace a little bit more not because te configuration, but because the weight of the chain)
@ddrmadness
@ddrmadness 13 күн бұрын
@Countzz I think it would depend on the type and the length. Regardless of either though, the same principle will apply when you drop the cube off the boat at first (the water level will lower). This is because it is then in free fall and objects that are in free fall are weightless (this is why things seem weightless on the ISS, it's actually in constant freefall). The water level should rise back up as more of the chain enters the water, so this is where it will depend on the type. The length of the chain then matters once the freefall of the cube ends. If the chain is long enough reach the bottom of the water, then the water level will not rise any more than it did from the volume of chain entering the water since relative to the water the cube is not part of the weight of the boat. If the chain is not long enough to reach the bottom, the cube then becomes part of the weight of the boat again relative to the water and will cause the water level to rise since the boat will now need to displace more water to float.
@senounatsuru6453
@senounatsuru6453 7 ай бұрын
Thinking about it for a moment, yes it makes perfect sense. The boat is now displacing less water because it now has less mass to displace, making the water level lower slightly.
@mywhiteboardisgood
@mywhiteboardisgood 8 ай бұрын
If you don't get it, the density of tungsten first pulls the Styrofoam down causing it and the Styrofoam to displace a lot of water. When the tungsten is dropped it sinks down and the Styrofoam goes up. Since the volume of Styrofoam is larger it will "undisplace"(no longer displace so much water) When he put it inside water with a rope, the rope displaces less water than the tungsten so it won't work
@k_brie7890
@k_brie7890 22 күн бұрын
Thank you, I didn’t understand until I read your comment ❤
@nathanbernard2004
@nathanbernard2004 8 ай бұрын
0:18 let's not talk abt the stickman that was violently murdered and disolved in acid
@chillpumkin
@chillpumkin 3 ай бұрын
Another good way I've learnt/heard is to take the extreme. Imagine a boat about the size of a canoe, and imagine a very spectacularly dense material which say has the volume of a pea and the mass of about 35kgs. (this is impossible but still) When the pea is in the boat, the boat goes down, and water rises (bouyancy), so the level is higher. But, if i drop the little pea into the water, suddenly the boat is no longer "heavy" and displaces much little water, and the pea barely takes up any volume This is of course highly _not_ rigorous, but is good to "predict" outcomes. This method's esp useful for me when it comes to code. Imagine the worst thing that can be thrown at the thing you are making. What is the worst possible outcome, and a) can the effects be reduced or b) is it worth fixing in the first place.If b), exaggerate less :v
@venerable_nelson
@venerable_nelson 4 ай бұрын
Water level lowers. 3 things to look up to verify. The density of tungsten, water, and the formula for buoyancy. Tungsten: 19.3g/cm3 Water: 1g/cm3 Buoyancy = Density of fluid * volume of displaced liquid * gravitational acceleration (Also, know that the buoyant force upwards is equal to the "weight" of the displaced fluid) The main thing to consider is bouncy. Since the block of tungsten starts on the boat there is a buoyant force acting on the block of tungsten. The entire boat is floating, and the mass of the tungsten is included with the mass of the boat. We can ignore gravitational acceleration in the formula for buoyancy and the "weight" of the boat. So, the mass of the boat including tungsten equals a certain volume of displaced water. When the tungsten is taken out of the boat, the mass of the boat is decreased, which causes the volume of displaced water to decrease as well. Let's consider how much that volume would decrease by. Say we have a cube 1cm3, the mass would be 19.3g. When this mass is removed, that will allow for 19.3g of water to no longer be displaced. Since water is 1g/cm3 that would mean 19.3 cm3 of water is no longer displaced. Once the block enters the water it will sink, since tungsten is denser than water. Before we were working with a 1cm3 cube of tungsten, so that will displace 1cm3 of water when it sinks. We started with displacing 19.3cm3 of water for this 1cm3 cube of tungsten to displacing 1cm3 of water for the tungsten. A higher volume of displaced fluid in a fixed container would indicate a higher water level. Having less volume displaced would indicate that the water level is lowering. The exact size of our tungsten cube really doesn't matter. A cube of twice the size will displace twice the water, half the size half the water. The important part is that tungsten is denser than water, and quite a lot so.
@Wise_That
@Wise_That 8 ай бұрын
Put another way, when it floats, it needs to be lifted ONLY by water. When it's on the bottom, its being held up by the ground, and so much less water needs to be displaced to hold it up.
@Eric-st2tj
@Eric-st2tj 7 ай бұрын
good point, but careful you don’t confuse the displacement of the boat and the displacement of the cube. in this example it can easily be mistaken that the cube is somehow lessening it’s displacement.
@landizzle08
@landizzle08 8 ай бұрын
Lot of respect for people who study math and sciences. I don't even know what half of this stuff means lol 😂
@camerontupper1138
@camerontupper1138 8 ай бұрын
The most complicated word he said was displacement if you can’t understand that then you need better education
@Username-pb4xz
@Username-pb4xz 8 ай бұрын
You can learn; it gets really fun when nuclear fusion and fission get involved, for obvious reasons; the information can be found over the internet
@tomnyskull
@tomnyskull Ай бұрын
Thanks for the explanation, you visualized it really well
@JustAFriendlyFrenchDude
@JustAFriendlyFrenchDude 8 ай бұрын
That was an awesome demonstration, thanks a lot !
@ProWeltfrieden
@ProWeltfrieden 8 ай бұрын
I think it would have helped to mention that the reason it lowers the see level is because it displaces the water while on the boat. That is actually what I missed the first time.
@JaDroppingScience
@JaDroppingScience 8 ай бұрын
Yeah the phrasing definitely could have been improved, but this is the standard way it gets asked as an interview question. I also should have shown the boat rising in the first clip.
@jffrysith4365
@jffrysith4365 8 ай бұрын
I was so prepared for this to be a "nothing changes" in the 2 truths and trash video. (because when we talk about floating ice cubes melting into water, the water level won't change). However, I spent a second to check if I was right because I thought of the extreme case (consider a very heavy and very small object in a massive boat, when the object is in the boat, it really lowers the boat, displacing a lot of water, but when you put it in the water, the object only displaces it's own volume. (so if it's very dense, it won't displace very much water relatively to the amount if pushes the boat down)) In this thought experiment I stumbled exactly into this result.
@carultch
@carultch 5 ай бұрын
If the boat were supporting a plastic block that were equal in density to water, then the water level would remain the same when you release the block.
@jffrysith4365
@jffrysith4365 5 ай бұрын
@@carultchnot quite, and to explain why, consider what the boat has in it after the plastic block is removed, in this case, it'll just have air on it, which is lighter than water (the plastic). This means it will necessarily be lighter after losing the plastic block, and thus will rise afterwards. A way to explain this, is consider if we had the boat sitting on the water - empty. Then we slowly added water until it was full. As it fills with water you will see it start to sink, and with most boats, it'll completely submerge and then keep going. (This is why boats always have tools to remove water, and many sailors really don't like a lot of water inside the boat.)
@carultch
@carultch 5 ай бұрын
@@jffrysith4365 Ok, I'll rephrase my point. If the boat were supporting a plastic block, hung from below its hull (the way the tungsten block was in this video), that equaled the density of water, then releasing the plastic block would yield no net change in the water level. The plastic block would also just hover in place and neither sink nor float.
@jffrysith4365
@jffrysith4365 5 ай бұрын
@@carultch yes, that would be true, because the boat won't be supporting the cube (as it will 'float' mixed in the water, so the rope will be slack (assuming the ropes mass is negligible lol) Sorry, I can't remember exactly how the experiment went on this video as I saw it a while ago.
@jffrysith4365
@jffrysith4365 5 ай бұрын
@@carultchOh, I see where this point was coming from from my original comment. And no this is not an analogue if the cube is hanging from the boat. To explain why, first we must consider where the mass of an ice-cube is being stored. In this case, the entire mass is stored in the boat. Consider now, this experiment. In this experiment, the mass is stored in two separate chunks. One part is stored in the boat, and the other in the plastic cube. Now consider the plastic cube, for it to pull down on the boat, it must be the case that the net force on the cube must be negative (down) This means the force of gravity is greater than the force of buoyancy. This happens when the weight of the item is greater than the mass of that around it. (in this case, the mass of the water.) Now since the plastic is in the water, the plastic will experience no net force from gravity / buoyancy as they will be equal. Consider now if the plastic was out of the water, say on a stick above the boat. In this case, it will be heavier than the air around it, so it will apply a force down on the boat (this makes sense because it will try to fall on the boat if we used string instead of a stick.) This means these both are different because the object is surrounded by a different medium. In the ice-cubes case, since the ice is all attached to the 'boat', this is similar to the latter case. To explain why, the reason the plastic doesn't pull on the boat is because the plastic is able to float on it's own seperately from the boat, but the ice cube can't do that, if one part floats the other part floats too.
@claytonharting9899
@claytonharting9899 8 ай бұрын
Oh that makes so much sense now! The water level lowers because once the cube is released, it’s no longer pulling the whole styrofoam volume down with it
@Ratapoopie
@Ratapoopie 8 ай бұрын
This guy teaches me more than my science teacher
@jasonzervos
@jasonzervos 8 ай бұрын
I thought it would stay the same at first but yeah. It makes perfect sense when you think about the difference of volume and weight and how those affect buoyancy. That's why massive ships can float. They can displace more water than they weigh
@walnut7137
@walnut7137 8 ай бұрын
Excellent video! I now understand: on the boat, with the tungsten, the average density of the boat is still less than that of water, which causes all of its weight to equal extra upthrust from the water on the boat, which is equal to the weight of the water displaced (which is larger as a result). Throwing the tungsten cube off the boat causes it to sink since its average density is higher than that of the water, so a smaller volume of water is displaced since upthrust is now less than weight and the density:volume ratio of the cube is much higher than the density:volume ratio of the cube + boat. I really love your vids and enjoy physics as a hobby myself!
@ShoCallananAnim
@ShoCallananAnim 7 ай бұрын
this is so awesome! I never even considered that!!!
@charteon9092
@charteon9092 3 ай бұрын
Once he said that it actually got lower I understood immediately. Really cool concept that’s very intuitive.
@GunSpyEnthusiast
@GunSpyEnthusiast 5 ай бұрын
the way i see it is the tungsten weighs the boat down, allowing it to displace more water then it would otherwise, thus raising the water more when its on the boat.
@justarandomdood
@justarandomdood 8 ай бұрын
Ayyy I JUST saw this on the Science Asylum channel! Love seeing even more physical demonstrations of science theory :)
@berzerkvideos655
@berzerkvideos655 Ай бұрын
I had the wrong answer for the right reason! I assumed it would be EQUAL because the weight of the cube was already moving the boat down, but neglected how you transfer it's displacement from Weight to Volume by simply _chucking_ it off the boat! That is Fascinating!
@migueljoserivera9030
@migueljoserivera9030 8 ай бұрын
I was thinking I didn't understand the statement, I was like "anything that you drop in water will displace its submerged volume", then you repeated "from a boat" and then I remembered that this is how ballast works. Nice video 😄
@athomesuperhero
@athomesuperhero 21 күн бұрын
So essentially the weight of the cube is pulling the larger volume deeper, thus displacing more water. So when you drop the heavy material, even though that small material displaces water, it replaces the water as the boat now rises out more from the water
@connerebeyer1005
@connerebeyer1005 7 ай бұрын
The styrofoam felt like April fools
@FPT_FINEST
@FPT_FINEST 8 ай бұрын
Bros better than my science teacher💀
@deldarel
@deldarel 8 ай бұрын
Every word the details are so important in that first one.
@Username-pb4xz
@Username-pb4xz 8 ай бұрын
A very clear and informative demonstration
@someasiandude4797
@someasiandude4797 19 күн бұрын
This is incredibly simple and complex at the same time
@luca._.gaming
@luca._.gaming 8 ай бұрын
0:17 bro really showed us some breaking bad footage💀
@soletluna4897
@soletluna4897 7 ай бұрын
It makes so much sense now🤯
@jamesvernon6358
@jamesvernon6358 5 ай бұрын
My brain exploded for a minute. This man just open the new gateway for me of knowledge😅
@randylayhe4554
@randylayhe4554 8 ай бұрын
This only works if the objects dropped are denser than the material of the boat
@shohamsen8986
@shohamsen8986 5 ай бұрын
yeah the key thing is that lower of water is relative to the person on the boat. From an intertial frame the boat rises (needs to displace less volume of water as total weight is less) and the water level doesnt change much (due to tungsten sinking to the bottom and displacing its volume of water)
@randommewtwo
@randommewtwo 8 ай бұрын
Thank you my good sir for being the first time I used that feature on the KZbin short
@eggsandredstone
@eggsandredstone 8 ай бұрын
yo jadropping science is the best tbh
@JaDroppingScience
@JaDroppingScience 8 ай бұрын
appreciate you!
@eggsandredstone
@eggsandredstone 8 ай бұрын
@@JaDroppingScience same for you
@UltimateDillon
@UltimateDillon 7 ай бұрын
I almost thought this was a joke video. You need to include the detail about the boat directly
@samuelking4723
@samuelking4723 5 ай бұрын
While in the boat, the weight of the tungsten displaces water based on the volume of the boat. When dropped in the water, the weight of the tungsten displaces water based on the volume of the block. Imagine you had a hyper-dense material the same size as that tungsten block. Because it’s so heavy, it would push the boat pretty deep into the water. That change in depth between when you’re holding the block and when you drop it is pretty large, and that means a lot of volume had been pushed under water by the block’s weight (“air” in the boat that is below water level now, but not after you drop the block because the boat rises up). But when you drop the block in the water, now the only displacement is based on the volume of the block itself, which is comparably very small next to the volume it caused the boat to displace. So more water is displaced while you’re holding the block in the boat, meaning the water level is higher before you drop the block.
@barneylaurance1865
@barneylaurance1865 5 ай бұрын
While in the boat, the weight of tungsten displaces water based on the weight of the tungsten. If the tungsten weighs one pound then it will displace one pound of water.
@samuelking4723
@samuelking4723 5 ай бұрын
@@barneylaurance1865 That’s not how that works.
@borischan5252
@borischan5252 7 ай бұрын
the key is that the cube is MUCH more dense than water. and as the density of the material goes up, it still displace the same volume. So by having a flower, you distribute the density across larger volume until it reaches equilibrium. When you detach the weight, all that density is again concentrated to that small object.
@braedenchambers6835
@braedenchambers6835 3 ай бұрын
So what you’re saying is that we have to drop a whole bunch of tungsten off boats to stop the rising sea level
@richardadkin5340
@richardadkin5340 Ай бұрын
no because we would probably create specialised boats to do this so taking resources of land into the water will actually speed up the rising sea level if you want me to explain more just ask fuck i sound like a nerd
@user-dn5vr4lr2t
@user-dn5vr4lr2t 5 ай бұрын
Excellent Video, I now have a even worse understanding then I did before!
@scientificapple69
@scientificapple69 5 ай бұрын
Where did you get that cube of tungsten? I love elemental metals 😊
@bighairyballoon4818
@bighairyballoon4818 6 ай бұрын
Damn, never thought to think of it as if the boat wasn’t negligible.
@mydude9904
@mydude9904 6 ай бұрын
Damn logically the boat was heavy with the object and therefore if the object is in water or not even in water,the boat's overall weight is reduce,making it float a little bit higher
@GamerX-2000
@GamerX-2000 8 ай бұрын
This makes logical sense, but aren't there other factors to take into account for that we would see in a real boat. Understandable you are trying to simplify this to exaggerate the effect, but if we have a wide enough boat would this just cancel out? like the tinfoil penny boat. Make more of a canoe shape and itll hold like nothing, make more of a barge and you can hold a lot more. It should stand to reason, although I may be wrong, that the pennies are displacing the barge less than the canoe (Im not sure why this is, but my guess would be that it may be due to surface tension of the water or something of the sort?), which would mean that the change in displacement of the water will be far less. Could we reach a point in which the boat is displacing less water than the cube can, therefore making it so that the water level will rise when the cube drops? Or maybe just reach a point in which the displacement doesnt change?
@dabs4270
@dabs4270 8 ай бұрын
it doesnt matter how wide the boat is, it will still take 19 cubes of water to hold up the tungsten, so when you throw it off the boat the water level will always drop by 18 cubes
@logosking2848
@logosking2848 8 ай бұрын
This is exactly what I initially thought, that the removed weight on the boat more than counteracts the displacement of the cube but I still don't get it honestly
@nikoskontraros9161
@nikoskontraros9161 7 ай бұрын
That is very interesting
@shinobi6497
@shinobi6497 8 ай бұрын
Oh, I see, the key word in the statement is “boat” because if it was dropped from land, in would only rise, but when it’s dropped from a boat, it causes the boat to weigh less, thus, displacing less water
@richardfinch2296
@richardfinch2296 8 ай бұрын
After a lot of mental gymnastics, it makes sense, but my brain still hates it
@grocerygopher
@grocerygopher Ай бұрын
The water level still lowers, the boat just gets lighter.
@higuys9789
@higuys9789 8 ай бұрын
So basically the tungsten cube weighs down the styrofoam to disperse the water and when released, the styrofoam floats up, un-dispersing the water
@amyx231
@amyx231 5 ай бұрын
Oh! Density. Forgot that 😂
@UsedNameTag13
@UsedNameTag13 12 күн бұрын
I feel like I just figured out the scooby doo villain before the reveal
@HeidiRoberts-dl8wz
@HeidiRoberts-dl8wz 5 ай бұрын
The part when the body was put in the acid or something caught me off guard
@TinyFord1
@TinyFord1 5 ай бұрын
Yeah the only problem with the video and the question being different is the fact that the question asked “if you drop it INTO water” and not “if you release it while already in the water”
@Chapo-ni1sm
@Chapo-ni1sm 7 ай бұрын
This is how we stop water levels rising
@JohnSmith_1123
@JohnSmith_1123 8 ай бұрын
This is fascinating
@JacksonBockus
@JacksonBockus Ай бұрын
Got asked this question in a job interview once.
@munjee2
@munjee2 8 ай бұрын
I didnt consider that he said its from a boat, so basically the tungsten is holding the boat down, with it gone the boat can float up and decrease water level, i feel like this is still conditional, you could probably see the water level rise is the mass was slightly denser than water and the boat was slightly less dense
@helen6994
@helen6994 7 ай бұрын
The first one seemed ao simple and correct that i went for it
@narutoneoji9611
@narutoneoji9611 5 ай бұрын
Is that true also for boats, that are like v shaped at the bottom? I feel like this is only true for a floating ground. But I can be wrong here.
@coleeolee
@coleeolee 8 ай бұрын
I was close. I thought it would stay the same because of these same reasons, except I thought the boat rising would only equalize it out
@sunharper-zahn8788
@sunharper-zahn8788 8 ай бұрын
I wasnt even thinking about the boast part in the beginning the entire time😅
@marcoantoniobarretovera756
@marcoantoniobarretovera756 5 ай бұрын
"If you drop large dense objects in a pool of water, the level will rise slighty" This is TRUE. No matter boats and sht. You are putting extra volumen on a closed system, the system will increase in volumen. Period
@NotGoodContent_
@NotGoodContent_ 7 ай бұрын
the water lowers because the boat has less mass, see how when the cube fell the boat rises? its the weight of the boat that lowers and therefore less water is displaced
@zacharytaylor190
@zacharytaylor190 5 ай бұрын
we've found the solution to rising sea levels. Just drop a few big tungsten cubes off boats! genius!
@dhwanitbhatt3170
@dhwanitbhatt3170 7 ай бұрын
I still don't understand.. if you maintain the level of styrofoam before and after dropping tungsten then it should stay the same right? So is it ok if I just assume that you just decreased the weight of the boat?
@DianeSteele
@DianeSteele 5 ай бұрын
it's impossible to maintain the level of the boat because the weight of the cube causes it to displace more, thats the whole point
@Banana_Fusion
@Banana_Fusion 8 ай бұрын
This video cured my mortality.
@here_be_dragons9184
@here_be_dragons9184 5 ай бұрын
That's a very long video just to say "pay attention, it's dropped *from a boat* " which I guess is what the majority of people including myself just glossed over like "you're putting stuff into water, off course the level is rising, duh". Now stay with me, many people would assume the "level of water" is the level of the lake in general, not the level right after the boat dropped its stuff. That could have been an interesting question but really most people just missed the point.
@2drad279
@2drad279 7 ай бұрын
"Off of a boat" is doing alot of the lifting in that sentence isnt it?
@lightuk8958
@lightuk8958 6 ай бұрын
Ah so “from a boat” is the key here… if it was from dry land that would be another matter entirely.
@ayakashiamori8068
@ayakashiamori8068 5 ай бұрын
Fun fact, surface of the ocean (water level) is similar to the ground level of said ocen, so if you drop dense object (that will be big enough to make visible for human eyes change) it will change the level of the surface. What you explained in the video is how floting objects interact with water when they have different weight put on them (I don't know the name of the science term in English). To summarize the amount of the water stays the same, so when you put objects in it, the level of the water will rise. Similar to how you rise the level of the water when you go in the bathtub (even if your body would float in the bigger pool of water). Please don't spread misinformation 🙏🙏🙏
@samlewis6487
@samlewis6487 8 ай бұрын
Depends how big the boat is, and on how buoyant the boat already is. It only works if the boat is at the minimum possible bouyancy and thus minimum possible size. It's thouroughly ridiculous.
@matthewjrw6218
@matthewjrw6218 8 ай бұрын
it lowers displacment because the syrafoam was also not doing any displacing anymore
@greatdane145
@greatdane145 24 күн бұрын
Just compare it’s weight/density ratio to the air inside the boat that pushes the water away
@randomyoutuber4829
@randomyoutuber4829 8 ай бұрын
Thanks, man, now I'll definitely become a star student in science EDIT: they're calling me a nerd now
@seanmckenzie3877
@seanmckenzie3877 Ай бұрын
The point that this video makes is only hard to understand because you don't make it clear that you were factoring the boat into the question. Like, yes it will temporarily lower to what it was when the tungsten was still inside the boat. But once you're back ashore, the water level will still be higher than what it was before you went out and dropped a block of tungsten in it.
@KrazyCouch2
@KrazyCouch2 7 ай бұрын
My large dense object was actually like absolutely massive and my boat was really wacky and super tall so checkmate. Or something.
@ZonaLol0000
@ZonaLol0000 7 ай бұрын
so if you drop tungsten into water the water goes up but if you drop tungstun from a boat then water will go down
@subyouwont
@subyouwont 8 ай бұрын
The explanation with the blocks is a lot more confusing than it needs to be, but the demos are great
@LatvianVideo
@LatvianVideo 6 ай бұрын
Nice, i thought about it for a minute and decided it Lowers, good i was right
@Bread.799
@Bread.799 6 ай бұрын
0:19 WHAT was that illustration
@sunky-
@sunky- 6 ай бұрын
😂
@OWMANez
@OWMANez 8 ай бұрын
Man thats insane o_O
@peterhu7039
@peterhu7039 8 ай бұрын
thats super cool
@BadakMahashay
@BadakMahashay 3 ай бұрын
Why isn't my brain braining today 🤔
@yorgos37
@yorgos37 8 ай бұрын
The key is that it's thrown from a boat if it were from the coast it would obviously rise
@lillily1678
@lillily1678 8 ай бұрын
This is interesting, but it's just a trick question that could've been explained in seconds rather that needing it's own video
@eliramirez2332
@eliramirez2332 3 ай бұрын
Im using this as a science fair project gehehe
@enavoid6285
@enavoid6285 Ай бұрын
So basically I got the answer wrong because i didn't know the boat was part of the experiment
@musclechicken9036
@musclechicken9036 7 ай бұрын
OHHH, it’s because the boat is displacing less water!
@No_one_is_here_jk
@No_one_is_here_jk Ай бұрын
Its because of the Styrofoam and its a lot of volume so of course it will sink because the Styrofoam isn't completely in the wanter
@Marshwoah
@Marshwoah 8 ай бұрын
same
@justanerdguy3054
@justanerdguy3054 6 ай бұрын
Wow!
@Zander10102
@Zander10102 5 ай бұрын
Right the seafloor
Fact-Checking The Most Viral Videos of 2021
8:07
JaDropping Science
Рет қаралды 754 М.
Cursed Units
18:29
Joseph Newton
Рет қаралды 2 МЛН
Glow Stick Secret (part 2) 😱 #shorts
00:33
Mr DegrEE
Рет қаралды 52 МЛН
Watch gravity pull two metal balls together
12:47
Steve Mould
Рет қаралды 4,9 МЛН
Animation vs. Physics
16:08
Alan Becker
Рет қаралды 22 МЛН
24 Cool Gifts & Gadgets for Science Lovers!
9:22
JaDropping Science
Рет қаралды 1 МЛН
Tungsten (new) - Periodic Table of Videos
22:43
Periodic Videos
Рет қаралды 337 М.
Tungsten vs. Hydraulic Press: Who Will Win?
9:27
Hydraulic Press Channel
Рет қаралды 267 М.
Flying Phone Scam Exposed (so I built a REAL one)
10:57
Mark Rober
Рет қаралды 64 МЛН
Is It Possible To Completely Fill a Klein Bottle?
7:01
The Action Lab
Рет қаралды 21 МЛН
Can soap propel a leaf boat? (2 Truths & Trash)
3:59
JaDropping Science
Рет қаралды 165 М.
The Language Counting Paradox
3:43
MinuteEarth
Рет қаралды 144 М.
Samsung or iPhone
0:19
rishton vines😇
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
Xiaomi Note 13 Pro по безумной цене в России
0:43
Простые Технологии
Рет қаралды 1,8 МЛН
Airpods’un Gizli Özelliği mi var?
0:14
Safak Novruz
Рет қаралды 6 МЛН
Переходник для IPhone • 181649538                         Делюсь обзорами в профиле @lykofandrei
0:15
Vortex Cannon vs Drone
20:44
Mark Rober
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН
Распаковка айфона в воде😱 #shorts
0:25
Mevaza
Рет қаралды 1,6 МЛН