The Untold Story of Min Hee Jin

[@shonwendy9850]

Min Hee Jin and SM in their Golden Era

[@virginiabaguio3526]

Agree. greedy

[@urhypeboy]

​@@virginiabaguio3526greedy how? Grow the hell up.

[@tralala3997]

Daaaayum, i never knew how iconic she was until know, her ideas were literally the backbone of every SM artists' success, the front runner of kpop before.🤯

[@SamEricLlort]

She is just lying. She did the bare minimum. Also everything MHJ did was copied from something western.

[@urhypeboy]

​@@SamEricLlortthe one who is lying and does the bare minimum in life is you. Grow up.

[@urhypeboy]

​@@SamEricLlortthe one who is lying and does the bare minimum is you. Grow up.

[@B.A.R.B.I.E]

​@@SamEricLlort Don't interfere in other countries affairs. You are not citizen of south korea.

[@SamEricLlort]

@@B.A.R.B.I.E Then kpop artists should not die to perform in the west either. If we can’t interfere, then they should also not perform in the west either.

[@flyingkangaroo814]

I don't buy HYBE's story just yet. I think it is best if we wait for this whole controversy to end before we can judge Min Hee Jin. After all, both sides are saying contrasting statements to each other. I do think it is such a low blow to HYBE for spreading the information of what happened to the public. That is literally the worst form of public shaming, criminal or not. I can't imagine working at that company. It is probably scary to be an employee at HYBE.

[@narkogrunt7863]

Min Heejin is a groomer and gaslighter. She also has said weird remarks on underages. She said to a Nct member ”the youngest is like clear weather».

[@urhypeboy]

Couldn't care less about HYBE. HYBE is probably the most evil company in the whole kpop industry.

[@narkogrunt7863]

Min Heejin is a criminal herself. She also has a huge ftsh for underages.

[@jasminirauch4322]

I was leaning towards being on her side until I saw her playing poor woman in sweats and with horrible hair at her own press conference. If you are in the right you would not seek pity from people.

[@delia8162]

​@@jasminirauch4322she was not seeking pity, that would have been the reaction of anyone in her situation, she was fed up the whole time and kept calling them a bunch of bastards, if she had come out well dressed and spoke calmly people would have called her cold and calculated, no matter what she did, she was gonna get judged for it, it's a lose lose situation

[@winterleaves_autumnsnow]

Hope she starts her own label without any ties to other companies, she'd probably take them all out with her concepts etc.

[@ladykitty16]

Edit: Sooo I haven't had time to check on this scandal since this video came out, but yes for what is has come out after the press conference I can tell there's sooooo much more to the story and the way this person carried herself- Just want to say my comment was based on the info provided on this video only, I did not research this person and her previous wrong doings or anything but I appreciate your comments and feedback, now I will basically not comment unless I have the full story, thank you! I don't understand the hate towards this woman, she is basically the creator of all major concepts that we fell in love with back in the 2nd generation. She is a genius and I wish her nothing but the best!

[@alphaumarrbah410]

Honestly

[@rufinongogui8514]

agree! whether you like her or not, you cant deny that she's a genius

[@saintkira]

She sexualises kids…???? Tf you mean “I don’t understand hate towards her”

[@XxMABY_LauxX]

Same

[@sugalin9330]

It's because she has an attitude problem despite of being smart 😅

[@MC_MONSTIEZ]

Min Hee-Jin is an artistic genius.

[@safz15]

Most of nj aesthetics are copied from old japanese & american girl groups

[@Daisy-ue9vk]

@@safz15 bingo

[@K-Blink_K.K143]

@@safz15we aren’t talkign only about new jeans

[@mayumikawagoe4169]

Yeh.. and manipulative and greedy

[@beahlunchung-nn8lt]

☠️💀☠️what tf how are they supposed to do y2k without y2k like how stupid can u be​@@safz15

[@vel9095]

Bang Shi Hyuk hated New Jeans and Min Hee Jin so much that he intentionally created a girl group called ILLIT to emulate them. He brought Min Hee Jin, a renowned director, to HYBE because she had been famous for a long time, but Bang Shi Hyuk got angry because he couldn't control her as he wished. Originally, Bang Shi Hyuk didn't like the current members of New Jeans either, so he tried to form New Jeans with members he handpicked, but Min Hee Jin fiercely opposed it and managed to protect the current members. If you're a New Jeans fan, you can't morally insult Min Hee Jin... The New Jeans members knew that too, so they cried while trying to protect Min Hee Jin. Min Hee Jin fought fiercely to protect New Jeans, even battling HYBE, while Bang Shi Hyuk tried to drive Min Hee Jin out, resorting to media manipulation even involving BTS. If you mess with BTS, their fans won't stay silent. Currently, part-time workers at HYBE are being called in to instigate and slander Min Hee Jin and New Jeans in the comments. All the news articles in Korea are in favor of HYBE, and the comments are all insulting Min Hee Jin. Additionally, Korean choreographers have admitted that ILLIT copied many of New Jeans' choreographies. HYBE is trying to ruin New Jeans. There isn't a single photo of New Jeans with Bang Shi Hyuk. In contrast, Le Serafim and ILLIT have photos with Bang Shi Hyuk. Also, during award ceremonies, Le Serafim and ILLIT thanked Bang Shi Hyuk, but New Jeans thanked Min Hee Jin. If it weren't for Min Hee Jin, New Jeans would have changed their concept to something weird like Girlfriend and suddenly disbanded. Currently, New Jeans' fashion style and music have become a trend for many people. Moreover, securing luxury brand ambassadorships was also a result of Min Hee Jin's direct contacts, and this time, there was also collaboration with a famous Japanese artist. Bang Shi Hyuk is just garbage.

[@geri911]

Thank you so much for this! So many people are clueless at who she is. The amount of disrespect like she can be replaced just like that. As an F(x) fan she was the reason why I now like Newjeans. Such a genius.

[@nicatine]

I stand with MHJ

[@nehalilisays]

Many fans say that she "shouldn't drag any idols into her mess" but what if the NewJeans members are genuinely on her side? I think they are probably emotionally very attached to her, especially because they are so young and she has focussed on their success for the last few years. Do you think the girls can just go on with their career without her? (Personally, I have no clue)

[@mauryroblovich]

exactly. the people saying MHJ are "dragging the idols into it" have never had a mentor, and it shows.

[@delia8162]

Also the idols she talked about were not "dragged" they were litteraly part of the story, like ? You "drag" someone when they have nothing to do with a situation, but everyone she mentioned were part of the chain of events, it would have been super confusing otherwise

[@flor07]

​@@delia8162 They are confused because media released an article (by hyɓe btw) saying "someone listened her "saying" this, that, those, these idols copied me".. But that was a Hyɓe strategy, to put those fandoms against her.., and because people (most armys) blindly believed what hyɓe said.. Thats why you are going to find that fandom (the most) against her.. And also she ""said"": "I want ɓts out of my way, it's better" armys got mad, but when MHJ revealed Bang PD chat saying "crush aespa/end aespa" they were saying it's just business.. 😂😂 🤡

[@randomuaena2859]

This aged perfectly with the recent new jeans emergency live the did against hybe

[@CARL_093]

Min hee jin deserves more

[@seraphemme]

idk who's telling the truth when it comes to the hybe/MHJ beef but the glazing for MHJ is crazy when she's literally creepy asf towards children or the concept of being a child. I'm not gonna say she's a full on pdfile but she's definitely a creep.

[@ike7484]

Because HYBE would never debut groups with sexualized concepts catered towards the male gaze when some of the idols are minors... surely not....

[@Blackcat_myjk]

after reading all the comments, i'm glad that i was not the only one who noticed how bias this channel is getting. for the past few days, this channel has been putting so much effort in putting this woman on a certain light (as how one of the comments put it).

[@JkLina13]

She was contacted by MHJ side 100%

[@siddhisalvi1628]

Saddest thing is bunnies are supporting this women yeah I don't care about hype they are way too suspicious but I don't want those innocent girls to be with her

[@Agustdswifey]

RIGHT DUDE!?!?? LIKE DAMN TALK ABOUT BEING SO BIASED 😭😭

[@sarangsarang3174]

Exactly i noticed too

[@micah459]

Yeah I definitely agree. No one is denying her contributions to K-pop but this channel is acting like she isn't sus. Like the video didn't mention how she made Taemin feel uncomfortable and sexual. Or how some of NewJeans dances are inappropriate for teenagers

[@dns0095]

Like it or not, she's basically the one who makes your fav become your fav

[@narkogrunt7863]

She has nothing to do with Apink, The Boyz and Victon. I am glad my favs are away from that creep who takes advantage of minors.

[@dns0095]

@@narkogrunt7863 unfortunately she has... The concept she created for example school uniform with natural makeup look, the one that becomes the trend, that will later be followed by your fav

[@LovelyKissess]

Not mine, but I wouldn't have minded her working with them. I can only imagine how much more iconic they'll be

[@Salacia15]

​@@narkogrunt7863as if she's the only creep in the industry

[@seoyeons_wavs]

no she's not

[@lesley1346]

you didnt mention any of the controversies that she has had in the past

[@Nasania]

I had a feeling something weird was going on here like did y’all see those texts?!? 😅

[@Luna-wp3nj]

Ok, so how much is Min Heejin paying this channel exactly? The bias towards her is crazy. MHJ is a total CREEP, but whenever this channel talks about her, they make her seem like an angel who's always the victim and never report a single bad thing she did. They even said the NJ girls are safe with her during the peak of the cookie scandal She's talented, yes, but she's not a good person. Hybe and Min Heejin both are in the wrong and have always been the bad guys.

[@lawtraf8008]

Nothing. You just don't like the truth and worship hybe.

[@Luna-wp3nj]

@lawtraf8008 No, it's just that my brain is actually used and doesn't just sit there like it's for decoration. I specifically said BOTH parties are bad MJH's creepy behaviours have been a topic of discussion since her early SM days. She publicly accused SEVERAL groups of copying her and even said Bang PD copied BTS from her. She said Hybe violated her privacy by sharing details of her suspicious activities WHILE she was showing a crowd of reporters Bang PDs private texts MJH is delusional and narcissistic while Hybe is evil and money hungry

[@Luna-wp3nj]

@soysauceboy2023 Buddy, don't you have basic reading comprehension? How many times do I have to say Hybe is bad MHJ literally sh-ot herself in the head in that press conference by spewing delusional bs. Her lawyer looked like he wanted the ground to swallow him whole, lol I'm focusing on her because this channel is working overtime to make her look like a Saint when she's a total creep

[@Luna-wp3nj]

@soysauceboy2023 Buddy, don't you have basic reading comprehension? How many times do I have to say Hybe is bad MHJ literally sh-ot herself in the head in that press conference by spewing delusional bs. Her lawyer looked like he wanted the ground to swallow him whole, lol I'm focusing on her because this channel is working overtime to make her look like a saint when she's a total creep

[@LuraMarry-be7kt]

Both are doin media play and are wrong . People are worshipping this chick, as if she's don't have pedophile claims.

[@EmmaJalandoni-x6b]

Thank you MHJ EXO’s growl will forever be iconic!!! EXO brought the school boy uniform into the spotlight!!!!!

[@samanthahan1432]

She was the one who also accused BTS of copying for literally wearing school uniforms by EXO 💀

[@EmmaJalandoni-x6b]

@@samanthahan1432 they did didn’t they lol

[@undonido9193]

@@samanthahan1432its because THEY DID 😏

[@hannipham7777]

FINALLY ISTG FINALLY SOMEONE ACKNOWLEDGES HER SHES SO CREATIVEEE GAHH

[@_DreamzGaming]

It's Minji's birthday and this is what's happening 😭

[@minilee3552]

외국인들이 민희진 싫어하는 이유는 단순하지.. BTS 팬들이 대다수니까. 한국에서도 BTS팬들은 민희진 욕함. 근데 모든 한국인들이 민희진편임 BTS 팬들 제외하고ㅋㅋ 방시혁은 민희진한테 줄 1000억이 없었고 돈줄 날짜가 다가오니까 민희진이 배임이라고 언론에 광고해서 내쫓으려던것 뿐임. 방시혁이 배임의 증거라고 제시한 카톡에서 민희진은 단 한마디 했음. "대박" 정작 구체적으로 방법을 제시한 직원은 짤리지도 않았고 고소당하지도 않았음ㅋㅋ 이게 무슨 뜻이냐면 실제로 배임 따위는 없었다는거지. 기자회견에서 울었다고 공격하는게 제일 멍청함. 민희진이 울어서 여론이 움직인게 아니라 모든 뒷 이야기를 숨김 없이 공개했고 그게 논리적으로 맞는 말이기 때문임. 불만 있으면 두시간 동안 니가 살아온 모든 것들을 거짓말로 설득해봐 모든 증거에 알맞게 대본도 없이.

[@bclp005]

I'm a BTS stan, and I don't support HYBE nor Min Hee-Jin.

[@dianaosazenaye1313]

She many have a lot of enemies But she done a lot!!

[@devikakrishna7372]

The way this channel is trying their hardest to portray this lady as the next mother teresa while ignoring the mess she just made some days ago so they can blame all the things on that company is showing..

[@safz15]

Her PR is working extra hard to clean her image

[@hakkenn]

she’s the right one tho?

[@gojosatoru72869]

I said the exact same thing yesterday if you search on KZbin you would see other KZbin channel critizing her style and way of content

[@Daisy-ue9vk]

Trying so hard

[@gojosatoru72869]

@@Daisy-ue9vk yep trying so hard since last week she has tried portraying that woman as the good person and hybe as the bad. I honestly just feel bad for the girls

[@alexndinh]

Her aesthetic on next level. Her works are backbone for most KPOP concept (gen 2 KPOP to be precise). Men don't like women become success

[@whereisjustice5112]

So MHJ really contribute a lot to K-Pop. Without her, K-Pop won't flourish.

[@SamEricLlort]

Nah MHJ just made kpop worse with her discount american sound.

[@jazzyg.1374]

Geniuses can also be evil. My intuition at first knowledge that she transfered from SM was really on point. Together with her direction on NJ songs & concepts that were inappropriate & borderline sexualization of teens, I DID NOT like her at all. Hope this case against her gets a satisfying conclusion of her being booted out of the kpop industry & the public will know with hard evidence what a traitor she is to the company that hired her.

[@shristimagar5727]

One or two video us understandable but so many videos on the same topice its like you are trying to clear her name and put her on positive spotlight too much suspicious

[@sonexcarat99]

Just like the media has been doing since the beginning, literally bombarding k-netizens with articles putting out statements claiming MHJ had said this and done that… If you suspect this channel because of the repetitive intent, then shouldn’t what Hybe has done become suspicious to you, too?

[@LLA-lr8kw]

f(x) was her muse. She created their every album.

[@neueone]

all I can think of lately is how much I admire her

[@micah459]

A lot of these comments tell me that they either are ignorant to her nasty behaviors or just don't care about teen idols being sexualized for adults. Also, I'm disappointed in this channel for not mentioning how this woman sexualized Taemin and Newjeans. I thought this channel supported idols?

[@Agustdswifey]

Exactly dude. Like this channel is so fucking arrogant and ignorant. They completely overlook all the questions and very fucking weird shit MHJ has done. Especially for her Lolita references and questionable lyrics in Cookie and Ice Cream Cake.

[@sonexcarat99]

Sexualized?? Evidence please as I don’t know what you are referring to! Kasper, who is best friend with Taemin and other idols like Baekhyun and Kai, showed his support to Min Hye Jin amidst all of this.

[@micah459]

@sonexcarat99 Okay? Taemin has expressed that he felt uncomfortable with the Sherlock photos, which Min Hee Jin created the concept for. It's also weird she photoshop Jonghyun's abs off his body to make him look younger and called the photos "a gift for the noonas" which is creepy since Taemin was like 18

[@nishweeb2356]

@@micah459 you mentioned newjeans as well , so explain that as well plaese .

[@micah459]

@nishantweeb2356 The youngest member was like 13 when she debuted but some of NewJeans outfits/dances are too sexual for her to be doing. An example is Attention. Keep in mind, they were all teenagers when this song came out

[@srisumarni2147]

If she REALLY CAPABLE, why don't she just started her OWN Company like BSH do to BIG HIT, From zero to hero? ? ? Instead broke so many GRIEND Fans, she destroy source music. She bring their TRAINEE, Staff etc also using their money and foundation. Why don't she use her ability to UPGRADE GFRIEND, fromis 9 and Le Sserafim 1st and then SLOWLY create New GG when company already stabLe. Just being honest, she also BEING GREEDY for BTS Popularity. She has PROBLEM when ILLIT uses NJ media play, but she's FINE when NJ USING BTS all the time. What the hell. . . Nj already ENJOY the popularity with BTS Name. Trust me, so many grup or idol more talent than them but get less chance. Say THANK TO BTS. Stop saying so poor For MJH. BSH dan she just the same person. OBSESS and GREEDY PERSON . I Stand BIG HIT dan HYBE. I Love SEVENTEEN even before join to HYBE 🤕🙄 From now, please STOP DRAG SM ENT or other artist, their life already hard.

[@Okay79775]

tis channel is not on mhj side she just said that mhj have given the proves while hybe doesn,t . and this video is about mhj contribution to kpop every iconic eras

[@Department_of_Justice]

BS. Name the proof. Hybe is filing official court docs, min is whining to the public.

[@Salacia15]

​@@Department_of_Justicehybe is using media play, unfortunately ur a victim of their media play. Proof? Go watch the 3 hour conference, hybe is doing bs

[@Salacia15]

​@@Department_of_Justicego watch the conference instead of blindly supporting fatman PD

[@Okay79775]

@@Department_of_Justice first of all i only defend this channel as the comments you have seen . and talking about official court docs where are they if hybe now know how mhj wants to take ador why are they not showing to the public

[@Agustdswifey]

Ok so. Min Heejin's talent so what? That doesnt mean shes an innocent angel either. She has a history of being very QUESTIONABLE to literally MINORS. The naked photos of brooke shields on her wall, SHINee's Taemin during their Sherlock era and Newjean's cookie lyrics. Do not tell me that "oh your just making the lyrics sound perverted" this the same woman who was involved with Red Velvet's Ice Cream Cake dont even 💀 You know what tho, her talents are amazing that i can say. But theirs also a thing call separating the art from the artist. (Aka Min Heejin's work.) Dont go saying that i support Hybe either because BOTH Hybe and Min Heejin are in the wrong. In reality its the Idols who are the victims here, not Min Heejin, Hybe or whoever the fuck else. Its the people who Hybe & MHJ dragged into the crossfire. There was absolutely no need to mention any of the idols who were mentioned. For now im only just watching from the side til all of this drama clears off.

[@Agustdswifey]

And for those who don't know Yuri was 16 during the Ice Cream Cake era. And take a read to the lyrics for Ice Cream Cake & Cookie and you'll know what I mean. :)

[@Xenobee_]

She was manipulative and problematic since the beginning of her career and these people are extremely dumb to understand that. I literally saw a comment "why men can't see a successful woman in front of them" like be for real! What she did was wrong- What hybe did was also wrong

[@MonicaDianNoveliaJatmiko]

I’m crying 😭 tbh, I’m her fan. After reading some articles about mhj, about her works, about newjeans, I cant help but feeling mesmerized and adore her. Mhj is super genius, her creative visions is just superb. Daepyo nim, saranghaeyo ❤ thank you for taking care the girls and wish you healthy ❤

[@scanspeak00]

Imagine having your tireless creative work stolen by others. I would be so furious and want to leave too!

[@neoneunnamanespecial]

Imagine crying about another group plagiarising the group you managed when you yourself plagiarised another group to make this group word for word bar for bar. Such a hypocrite she is =))

[@mata-jh9hi]

Hybe trolls are blinded by their one sided mentality. They use BTS as a shield for the real culprit Bangman. I don't know why 2023 isn't being investigated? There were definitely a lot of anomalies during the members solo debut and "Hybe is Corrupt" trended many times. Bangman is not a Visionary he relied on everyone's creativity around him, from Creative Directors like MJH, BTS members, Video makers Lumpen and GDW, Choreographers and yes YG concepts for behind the scenes. If Bangman is guilty of misdeeds then BTS also has every right to know. MJH should be applauded for her strong stance and contribution to the KPop Industry instead her integrity is being attacked by ignorant trolls. If it's true Mr A was paid by BHE before he was jailed then there is definitely reason to investigate. What makes me cringe is fans don't care that Scooter and Ithaca Artists recvd enormous sums during the merge and then later he is appointed CEO of Hybe USA there was no mention of his Salary but apparently MJH is the highest paid employee?? I wish her and NJ's all the best for the future. This is all about Control. Plot twist Scooter makes a bid to take over Hybe in 5 yrs, he could be buying up stock this very minute, wouldn't that be a doozie.

[@kiwiwooq]

We support you Min Hee Jin 🫶

[@a.198]

I really don't understand people who are siding with mhj...

[@stevenmaster]

Maybe you should go check the court verdict and MHJ won the case, and HYBE now using the shareholders meeting to change out her 2 capable staffs then replace 3 from HYBE to "monitor" on her + Ador ...

[@ike7484]

Probably because you are blinded by your love for some of HYBE's idols (and I think I know who), but you have to see that HYBE is a huge corporation with internal power struggles. Some things they (HMB mostly) did against MHJ are just super shady (such as rushing the debut of Le Sserafim to deceive the public and capitalize on the hype for MHJ's first "own girlgroup").

[@joeE-kt8of]

she is a GENIUS. thank you for putting out solid material, subscribed !

[@PZ0613]

It looks like these days most kpop youtubes are more bias then what they use to be. In the last few days I've seen so many videos of painting her in a certain light. I'm really surprise. Everyone and anyone can say what they want but until proven there's no innocence. Also, the only victims are the idols.

[@evilwelshman]

Wait..... are you actually trying to make an argument that people should be deemed guilty until proven innocent?! What the heck??

[@sonexcarat99]

@@evilwelshmanlol I know, right???!!! Like this person’s mind is so warped. In the justice system, it has always been “innocent until proven guilty”

[@joeE-kt8of]

it is " innocent until proven guilty "sweetie, omg hybe brain dead zombies, stay in school kids.

[@PZ0613]

@evilwelshman I think you guys misunderstood me. Basically, they both shouldn't be claiming to be the innocent ones until all evidence is proven otherwise, that's all I was saying.

[@sonexcarat99]

@@PZ0613 👍🏻👍🏻 & I apologize for what I said 😃

[@winkythepooh]

a proof that most of global fans are easy to manipulate by huge influential companies like hybe to the point that they even tries to discredit a legend. MHJ already proven her talent and dedication to kpop and it even transcends most concepts that. it just so unfortunate that these idols under their company are the ones who's getting all the fatal blows from all this disputes.

[@eslnter]

They are truly dumb enough to stan the company instead of the idols hahaha life is truly amusing.

[@ike7484]

It's the mindless fans that only got into kpop because of BTS and will shill for everything and everyone related to them.

[@R_ixxLp]

this video is like showing only the good side of politicians.😂😂😂

[@kanpekiken2481]

If she was really that good, SM wouldn’t let her go

[@michaelt1154]

I'm so glad you made this. I'm still fresh to the scene. 2 years now and New Jeans is my favorite group. I researched her a bit before watching this, and this really magnified what I found out. I'm so sad things are the way they are.

[@ike7484]

Look! An international fan that was not too brainwashed by the BTS craze to simp for a megacorporation that is ruining the industry! More of this please!

[@Alice-gr6ps]

Even SM ppl came out to say she is trouble. Her true colors shown after gaining some success as CEO of Ador and demanded more. She is not innocent. This channel seem one sided with her and doesn’t talk about all the fact.

[@zevil89]

You guys realize that an artistic person can also be a shrewd businesswoman at the same time right? No one is questioning her creativity, but her shrewdness is not acceptable in any business environment. Imagine having a business and your number one sales agent taking away your clients by starting her own business. Not everything legal is ethical.

[@princesscherry5217]

HYBE is lying

[@Tia9736]

Genius to copies speed mv concept 🎭🤣

[@Thighlicious]

@@princesscherry5217how do you know? Because honestly even without hybe making evidence public the blame is still shifted onto her with how she’s responded to this situation, like I’ve never seen anyone look more guilty. And she hasn’t even addressed what they said that’s the funny part. It’s not really want people say but what they don’t say and that was the whole point of this conference, but now she’s making herself look like a crybaby.

[@vybzalways5293]

​@@princesscherry5217MHJ didnt deny that the plan didnt exist,she said it was just a joke between colleagues.like wtf

[@eslnter]

@@vybzalways5293 I mean don't you always work and said similiar jokes to your friend when there are unfair treatment during work? I see no issue in that honestly. Unless you're still not working then probably that's why you don't understand.

[@siddhisalvi1628]

How sweet of you telling her untold story ☺️☺️ but does that reduce all that sins she did? No matter how talented person is bad than that person is bad. I am not even talk about the drama right now that court will decide right now both the parties are just blaming but that women does not deserve any respect "she is too old to dedut" yeah if she wants she can make 5 year old debut in this industry very talented

[@BG0178]

For who she said that ?

[@PlatyMadness]

What Sins?

[@samobalkanmp.3]

​@@PlatyMadness She sexualised many kpop idols. Back in early 2009, SM boy group SHINEE returned with their 2nd mini-album “ROMEO”, where Min Hee-jin was in charge of creative directing. In the photo shoot for this comeback, SHINee members can be seen using child-like accessories like toys and milk bottles, at the same time wearing youthful clothes. Certain photos also show member Key shooting a water gun into his own face, while Minho appears drowsy in a lying pose, raising speculations about fantasies related to young children. Additionally, in the concept photo for SHINee’s 4th album “Sherlock”, which was released in 2012, a photo of Minho bare in his upper half while sucking on a glass bottle roused controversies. In 2016, Red Velvet released one of their signature songs - “Russian Roulette”. However, the MV for this song, which Min Hee-jin was in charge of, include several scenes and contents related to “Lolita” - a controversial work that include themes of child sexualization. Additionally, the clothes worn by Red Velvet members in the MV were short and bear strong resemblances to children’s outfits. When NewJeans first debuted, a huge controversy broke over the girl group’s clothes in their “Attention” MV and the lyrics of their song “Cookie”. In particular, “Cookie” is a sexual slang in English, leading to the lyrics of NewJeans’ song, which includes lines like: “Cookies I made. It’s so soft (what?) I keep thinking of you (ayy)”; “If you want it, you can get it”; “(Keep) looking at my cookie. The scent is different (taste it), one bite is not enough (uh)”; “Take it, don’t break it, I wanna see you taste it.”, to be suspected of being sexual innuendos. Back in 2022, it was pointed out that in the photos published on Min Hee-jin’s SNS, which shows the CEO’s studio, there were photos of a blonde girl with her top off and a girl exposing her underwear by lifting her dress. One of the girls is a character from the 1974 film “le farò da padre,” in which a middle-aged male lawyer tries to get money by kidnapping a mentally retarded minor girl, who is the daughter of a wealthy aristocrat. After that, the lawyer falls in love with the girl (and even had a sexual relationship with her), and eventually gives up the money. The nature of the film has thus, lead to netizens suspecting Min Hee-jin of having a “pedophilia” tendency.

[@PlatyMadness]

@K-Blubberop Yep they are waging a war against singing

[@lawtraf8008]

Which sins? She came with receipts backing her claims and innocence while Hybe is only giving empty statements with nothing to back their accusations.

[@mahabubajannathashi1199]

Min Hee Jin is a Creative Genius, Newjeans is her Masterpiece. Hybe is trying to seperate the Artist from her own Art! The international fans are so clueless...

[@vybzalways5293]

The likes of you are the ones who are clueless.she is just an employee at Hybe,she gets oaid for her every services provided at Hybe.its like when you pay someone to build a swimming pool in your backyard,after they finish it ,they claim its theirs😅

[@vybzalways5293]

@@Kookietaetan a CEO who is paid by HYBE😅my facts a correct kid.she should have started her own company and be a CEO who pays herself,there you can talk.its looke like the likes of you think that Ador is her company😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@dwp_orange8416]

@@vybzalways5293 loll see how the other kpoppie wants to argue with you when you're agreeing with them? lets all calm down. supporting Hybe will only get you to purchase multiple albums to maybe get the photocard u want & make you watch your idols get overworked to near death. we can't deny that Min Heejin's management has been superb for newjeans. If you want that for your idol, you should be at least listening to what she has to say.

[@carojo7064]

How many videos are you gna make about this one topic

[@urhypeboy]

Ppl who hate on her are so miserable. Imagine being that bitter and jealous... I feel sorry for them.

[@Salacia15]

Fr

[@ike7484]

HYBE is a disaster for the industry and people who defend them are mostly foreign BTS fans who only know them as the company behind their favourite idols and know nothing of the shady sht they do.

[@Eepbul]

You guys should know that newjeans debut was delayed because hybe really wanted to let le sserafim debut first. Hybe also didnt let min hee jin advertise newjeans to make people think that le sserafim is MHJ's group. Even with interuptions, MHJ went to a korean Tv show called "You Quiz" to tell that newjeans is debuting. MHJ did all what she could to make newjeans success. Also you could see that newjeans members never referenced bang si hyuk and only mentioned MHJ when they get awards. Newjeans was the cinderella in hybe and MHJ was the only one to help newjeans success. (These info were all from MHJ's press conference.)

[@aliceramirez8079]

Doesn't make her right!!!

[@hakkenn]

she is

[@Daisy-ue9vk]

​@@hakkennshe's a professional at lying

[@hakkenn]

@@Daisy-ue9vk she’s not lying tho she is the right one in this case

[@Daisy-ue9vk]

@@hakkenn you must be following the news for kookielit because they ain't legit

[@neoneunnamanespecial]

⁠@@hakkennRight for being a hypocrite?

[@superkawaiyenne]

I didn't know she was that iconic thank you

[@seoyeons_wavs]

She is most of the reason a rookie girl group is getting hated on & threats against them, what's so iconic about that???😂 she deserves nothing

[@Vinadet]

Nah, thats on everyone else for being so immature - including you

[@ike7484]

Imagine simping for a megacorporation that is trying to monopolize the music industry in South Korea. People like MHJ at least bring some creative vision and introduces new things to the genre instead of pumping out an endless mass of songs that sound the same by more and more rookies that didn't get the proper training, all so they can buy up more companies, not for the love of the music but to consolidate power over the industry and make more money. Kpop was better before HYBE and would be better if it split up. Just because you like BTS does not mean you have to like the corp.

[@Yveszine]

I don't like her, but will never deny that she is super talented. I wonder why Sm didnt let her do what she wanted later [like giving her own sub label]

[@melo3427]

They afraid she over throw them... its about power and position

[@ChiYuki44]

I don't hate her but I don't like what she is doing right now. You can list all the great things about her but if she is getting greedy and planning to separate herself from the company that gave her the financial support to not have to start ADOR from Zero. Then in my opinion she should act a little less greedy. Hyolin from Sistar doesn't have such financial help from anyone she started from Zero and the company does not have much earnings. Min Hee Jin is talented yes that is warranted, but does that make it an excuse for people not to see how she is acting? I have seen the press conference, and this woman is guilty of trying to separate ADOR from Hybe. I get it she is talented, she is behind everything that went on ADOR and New Jeans. BUT LET US REMIND OURSELVES THERE WILL BE NO ADOR NOR NEW JEANS WITHOUT HYBE GIVING HER ALL THE RESOURCES AS WELL. It takes a lot of money and a long hard process for her to get ADOR as her own independent company. But this woman cannot wait to keep all those bills to herself and independence she is saying nonsense and people are eating it. She may be behind all SM artist but not HYBE and she didn't have the money to start her own independent company and wanted HYBE to just serve it to her in a plate? please

[@petitegrandpa]

That’s great that she made a lot of concepts for kpop but that isn’t the topic at hand when it comes to MHJ and Hybe. I agree that BSH shouldn’t have attempted to replicate NJ due to their success but a channel should stay neutral when delivering news. Leave it up to the viewers to determine if they like or dislike MHJ. Do not put this woman on a pedestal.

[@maidatariq4934]

She is really an amazing creative designer she did so well with new jeans I really love new jeans concept their song everything about them makes me fall I love with them I hope the situation get solved and girls stay in peace

[@karinabluu.x]

I hate her,feel so bad for ILLIT and NewJeans

[@karinabluu.x]

@@soysauceboy2023 she was always problematic,though I agree HYBE is a very bad company

[@gojo6418]

​@@karinabluu.xi hate hybe too

[@raemontargaryen3005]

i can see her saying Illit copying new jeans. but BTS sounds like a far fetch on Hybe part. i dont see anything resemblances between bts and new jeans concept whatsoever. and im pretty sure shes smart enough to be able to not say such things. the problem is the mindless "army" that Hybe used as their literal "army" on this conflict LMFAO. tsk tsk tsk, i would love to see BTS members supporting MHJ and NewJeans, just to see how these mindless army will react, they will probably jumping on MHJ boat as soon as their idol do it. its pretty pathetic to be honest. theyve been played and they dont even realizes it.

[@Newjeans.newtee]

She denied that, she hadn't said anything about BTS

[@AbdullahKhan-fd5hl]

I never knew she did all that

[@robertthomas2312]

There's no doubt she creative and talented. But she is also conniving and power hungry, a perfect match with HYBE. But there can only be one!

[@Melissa-sy9lk]

Her splitting from Hybe is without doubt Hybe's loss. Creativity is innate and all the money the world can't buy that kind of talent.

[@universe986]

you forgot to mention how she sexualized innocence and feminized idols when they were very uncomfortable with it and how even their parents were against it. I'm talking about SHINee Sherlock. Taemin wasn't even legal by korean norms at that time, he was already facing weird comments by weird adults on TV shows since he was 15, and in Sherlock he was partially naked in very suggestive poses eating grapes. he openly talked about on shows how this image of himself made him uncomfortable and he struggled with it for years. in his recent comeback Guilty about abuse of young people and sexualization of innocence, he also used direct references to Sherlock concept

[@TammyAustin-p6u]

I have a question for people out there. Who put together the plan to bombard the audit with complaints today? Even the government is starting to question whats going on. It seems at a certain time today they received quite a lot of emails complaining about HYBE, but what was suspicious was everyone of them were the same thing according to officials,word for word coming from NJ fan club.

[@IkigaiKK0]

Min he Jin ❤

[@Usery5439]

she is a genius. if she didn't do this, she could've gone so much higher

[@tiffanyt9329]

Exactly, if she had just waited 5 more years after newjeans contract was up. Hybe probably would giving her more of Adore share. She thought NewJeans was at Blackpink level of term of sucess but it took them 7 years to get there. Should have wait a few more years to demand whatever she wanted. Hybe probably would have given to her.

[@maria_maria3568]

​​@@tiffanyt9329the plan she had was exactly this.wait for 5 to 6 years and take make ador independent. What hybe found was just some doodles of this future plan. She didn’t want to part ways with hybe now but Later. She has been in this industry for a long time, so she should not be that dumb to make such a mistake when she has just 18℅ of ador not even hybe. The thing is she and band pd had some issues from before when she didn’t go with le serafim project and made ador to debut nj.and now when she questioned them about i'll it, they planed to remove her for once and all (of course mhj is not also innocent herself). But they maybe didn’t expect her to creat such a mess

[@Xuepreme69]

@@tiffanyt9329 she was going to wait. the reason why she didn't is due to the audit and then Hybe started spoting out rumors to news tabloid accusing of so many things. she really was going to sit quiet and not say anything to the public.

[@liliankill]

Not denying her talent, but did she, or didn't she try to take over Hybe? I think that's the real debate here. Nobody ever doubted her amazing skills, but did she act maliciously or not?

[@hakkenn]

she didn’t

[@Phd366]

I don’t think she wanted to “take over” hype. She wanted to have more creative freedom and direction in her career. Hence, having her own agency. I just feel she was getting to big for Hybe’s ceo to take. He wanted her there but not THAT much.

[@Daisy-ue9vk]

​@@hakkenn😂

[@brianhansen1374]

if you own 80 percent of something,,,how can anyone take over that thing? explain pls

[@princesscherry5217]

@@Daisy-ue9vki’ve seen you on other videos where the creator has a MHJ bias. when you comment, you boost these videos into the algorithm. more people will see it & get this side of the story, so thank you! ☺️

[@lathavaratharajan5071]

Oh its MHJ channel 😂

[@nougat75]

I certainly acknowledge the fact that she is a genius, but I also think she is a problematic person. After all, many geniuses are problematic persons. I never boycotted her work and I still don't think she should be cancelled, but it seems like it is going to be difficult for any company to work with her now. Maybe she will set up her own agency in the future. Will I support her then? I still don't know if I should, it's complicated.

[@underwhelmingboy6315]

Love MHJ! K-Pop without her would be nothing💖

[@seoyeons_wavs]

Kpop will honestly be better w/o her

[@promtherizzler]

@@seoyeons_wavsI disagree

[@promtherizzler]

@airflowswest okay??

[@arinco6944]

She maybe very talented but she needs to be independent. She is too psychopathic to work with others.

[@EnanTk]

Only the international fans hate MHJ and they dont know the whole story or just indenial

[@ike7484]

This is so true. It's all just international fans that are too in love with BTS to bother looking at all the shady things HYBE are doing. In Korea the only people that hate her are incels that hate her just for being a woman.

[@wwxnho9894]

MHJ has some weird facts on her side. But I'd rather believe her instead of Hybe. Right minus wrong, Hybe gets more minus points. Plus no one can deny how MHJ put her 100000% on NJ so it's just fair to feel hurt the way she does for NJ towards all the mistreatment the group gets.

[@aoichan4353]

i don't get why men don't like successful women

[@riizeified]

I don’t get why you’d assume shit like this.

[@aoichan4353]

@@riizeified i don't really mean to say just about MHJ but also a lot of other women, kpop idols and many more females.. and MHJ can be seen to be taken down as she is soo artistically blessed ngl

[@mansininixo1441]

It's called insecurity.

[@ming5090]

Drinking and golf...she doesn't.

[@ike7484]

FR the only people that shill for HYBE in this case are delusional BTS fans from the west and Korean incels that can't stand her as a sign of women gaining power in the corporate world.

[@ssummerdew]

she is an amazing creator no doubt. but looking at how she created trends and changed the industry since the beginning, why the plagiarism claims now for 1 particular group? if this is plagiarism then she might as well claim the whole industry copied her (which is tbh very bold since you can't own a concept, but you can create trends that others will follow. that's what a trendsetter is!)

[@yumyummy3478]

many are just scared that all this controversy might harm the group and want her just move on in silence but they forget that behind all those groups there are someones hard work. Big corporations using their power to steal and suppress not something new. All those discussion and terms can be unfair to those creative minds which needs to change. I think in that regard Korean fans might understand more since they know better the how entertainment work conditions are

[@linsteven309]

Tons of people who support her is shocking to me, people just don’t care about morals. What about her lies, greed and intentions to hurt innocent people?

[@RajendraPrasad-cr8kz]

How can people still belive her after she fat shamed NJ's youngest member and call them useless without her

[@JRiley813]

She is definitely talented, but in your piece you basically state that other groups have been pulling inspiration from her work since 2nd gen so this whole Illit situation seems like smoke screen to cover up what's really been going on. Personally I feel Illit has a dreamcore vibe not y2k, yes there is familiarity but you can find familiarity all throughout kpop. She didn't invent y2k she just repopularized a look from the late 90s/early 2000s. To think other groups won't incorporate that in their concepts seems odd since she has seen it happen her entire career. Again just my opinion based on everything we've seen so far with this situation. There is definitely more to this that we don't know.

[@remuspierre7573]

Amazing Topics

[@scanspeak00]

Big, money-hungry corporation Hybe is trying to control the narrative and make her some sort of super villain. I'm glad you are showing the amazing iconic human being that is Min Hee-Jin 😃🥰

[@imapotatochip5481]

Well this didn’t age well after what she said about the members on kakaotalk At this point I really don’t know whom to support and not 😭😭😭 and in all of this not only nj but many other groups are suffering

[@ani4xL]

This channel only posts one side of the story. MHJ biased. 😂

[@ike7484]

She played her cards right and now Mr Bang is scared to lose sole power over his monopoly project, because that is what HYBE is trying to be now.

[@wandalewis5097]

She may be all those things But she’s a devil in sheep clothing. She’s done this to herself She needs to keep BTS out of her Mouth 💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@hakkenn]

she’s not a devil she’s the right one in this case

[@PlatyMadness]

When did she put BTS in her mouth?

[@wandalewis5097]

@@hakkenn explain please

[@Daisy-ue9vk]

​@@hakkennsheep and your min heejin is your shepherd 😂😂

[@wandalewis5097]

@lilirine1446 and you Believe her. She admitted to asking about BTS military claims she was just curious Bull. You really believe that.

[@hellodarknessmyoldfriends9729]

When HyBe want to reveal MHJ drug/illegal kids/s3x video/bully case??? They already accuse her of stealing money 😂🤔

[@ike7484]

Ironic considering how they do everything to cover the same things when it's the idols Mr. Bang push for that do it.

[@S.N_21]

She's a creative genius

[@amoswang1473]

Meanwhile YT seoulite always throw negative propaganda about MHJ. 😢😢😢

[@Circle46]

Hybe pays well🤑🤑🤑

[@susurrodelagua]

No matter how talent your are ,you need to know your place. Employees are employees and owners are owners. If you want to do all things on your way you have to start your own company with your own money not others people money.

[@obriendenis3965]

Bang pd wanted her in the first place? Tf you on? If anything you should look at that guy instead

[@skyraywastaken]

the press conference is basically her way of saying "oh you want to get rid of me? Let all of us fall" by exposing all the shady stuff at hybe

[@JkLina13]

​@obriendenis3965 but she accepted to join ? Right ? So whyshes yapping now? This channel won't speak about this but leme tell u that she herself selfsecured if NJ would fail and she wouldn't lose anything , she herself didn't belive in her own product how could she start her own label and take all risks with no huge budget covering her ass ? Only brainless ppl can defende that witch .

[@MyCaelieCakes]

@@obriendenis3965 To be fair, he was not the only one who made her an offer of employment, a lot of entertainment companies wanted her from what has been reported. She supposedly had her pick, and she was the one who chose to go with Hybe probably because she liked their offer the most at the time. No one forced her to sign their contract, it's on her to do her due diligence and go through everything to make sure she was happy with what she was getting out of the deal. At first it seemed like she was satisfied, but as time went on she made requests that Hybe was not willing to fulfil. And to be clear, I'm on no one's side except the ones who are innocent victims in this whole ridiculous company feud, and that's the artists.

[@eslnter]

Is funny how you categorize her as employee. She is not just an employee, she is a CEO creative director and owns some share. Merely an employee don't own shares. Bang was the one that agrees to provide her a label while she help him to develop the first successful girl group but then Bang PD didn't trust her concept and went with LSF instead. Like he contradicted himself there. And Newjeans success probably hurt that little man ego. The sub-label is still within the Hybe building so idk what you're talking. All Hybe did was label an office for ADOR and provide financial support to debut the girls which they should.

[@avchryfilms]

I won’t lie the fact that this channel has become a whole min hee jin channel is annoying

[@AJNAL777]

Leave

[@avchryfilms]

@tokkimaku I literally could care less about either hybe or min hee jin and their drama. it’s funny how the only come back you can come up with is just saying in other words that I’m defending hybe, a literal company that could literally care less for their workers, idols, or the fans of those idols, be so fr

[@avchryfilms]

@tokkimaku how exactly am I being biter though? like serious genuine question when you responded to my comment with “Ok HYBE stan” like…

[@avchryfilms]

@tokkimaku why does it bother you that I decided to comment though? just ignore my comment and that’s it. if this channel became a channel dedicated to hybe it would be annoying as well so your point doesn’t make sense. either way I won’t keep humoring this useless back and forth, have a nice day.

[@Shts-n7h]

Min Heejin is very intelligent 🤓🧠

[@remuspierre7573]

Cool reading glasses min hee jin

[@shazaza1]

Undoubtedly she is extremely talented. She should have started her own firm with her own money and investors instead of joining a large, established company to use their resources - money, network, connections etc. It's unrealistic to use other peoples' money yet have the control to call the shots and unilaterally end talents' contracts. You need to have skin in the game, which she didn't, allegedly she bought shares in Ador with money borrowed from Bang. Hybe is a listed company, the public owns shares, she cannot expect to use other peoples' money as she wished without having reporting and getting approval from investors.

[@rubiirae]

finally a comment made by someone with a brain! totally agreed! you can't sit here and demand full equity when you're barely an employee, doesn't matter what kind of benefit package that the company offers you, at the end of the day, you're still just an employee. If you want your own company, you've gotta deal with the grinding that come along with it, not using others' resources to mitigate risks and promote your product.

[@eslnter]

@@rubiirae That's no brainer there hahaha. She is not just an employee but a CEO creative director. She is also a boss which got undermined by her business partner Bang Si Hyuk. It amaze me how you guys perceive the situation like you all still don't understand a single thing.

[@rubiirae]

@@eslntera ceo job titleis still just an employee. You’re probably mistaking ceo as founder who built a company from the ground up with full equity. A ceo can be a founder but they’re not mutually exclusive. If you’ve ever worked at a corporate job you would understand the concepts better, but I guess education and common sense is severely lacking in your world. You should read business for dummy before you comment

[@shazaza1]

@@eslnter Terminating the sole asset (NJ's contract) of the company constitutes a major transaction. This requires the approval of the company's board of directors, and its majority shareholder Hybe who own 80% of Ador. Otherwise, she could take away the sole asset of Hybe (whose shareholders include the public) and the company would be left with nothing. If she wanted to be able to do whatever without reporting to anyone, she wanted she should have used her own money to start her own company and buy Source and started NJ.

[@eslnter]

@@shazaza1 she can request to terminate the contract if Hybe breached the trust through courts settlement if I’m not wrong. But we’ll see. I just hope Newjeans get treated right and the only person that truly care for their wellbeing is MHJ. You can watch Yoo Quiz Newjeans interview done by Yoo Jae Suk. I believe that interview answers some doubt from the press conference.

[@hooryazar1038]

Wtf there are some bots in this comment section lmao

[@crazysodan7934]

Her downfall wouldn't have happened if she wasn't greedy, she made an offensive move when an audit was done to her label. If she didn't make any corruption or anything then she would've been fine. She made a bold move which in turn made into a big scandal and dragged other labels group down the mud. Now newjeans is following her footstep and is making a wrong move following her into the mud.

[@scanspeak00]

A pioneer, a creative genius, a trail-blazer in a male-dominated industry. I respect and admire her immensely.

[@michellepehlynlyn8744]

I told someone before. New Jeans popularity is short spend. Hope it's not true.

[@pcavanagh62ify]

Nobody appreciates her cool hunter skills. Everybody thinks they could have done the same thing.

[@newbeans-45]

Most people see Min Hee Jin as a monster because she was giving child m*lester vibes, but I see her as a hero because without her K-Pop would be total crap and NewJeans would never have existed! WE SUPPORT YOU MHJ

[@harujung6]

The saddest part is she signed a contract where she is unable to work on other projects as long as she has adore shares, which she cannot sell completely without hybe’s approval. So if she tries to get out of the company she would have to terminate the contract by going to court. But that will take a while because of the court process.

[@favi54]

A good arist doesn't mean a good business person. And vice versa.

[@ike7484]

But she is a good business person. Mr. Bang realized it too late and now he is trying to backtrack and get rid of her.

[@favi54]

@@ike7484 she's tied too much of her own brand to new jeans. It's something you learn not to do in business school because of situations like this.

[@ike7484]

@@favi54 Did you watch the video? She has a huge resume that is way more than New Jeans.

[@quarterarcade8825]

She is a legend.