The Warning - Disciple REACTION by professional singer

That's My Guy merch: wrigheousj.mys...
Presave:
Spotify: open.spotify.c...

[@wrighteousj]

Presave Among the Phoenix: distrokid.com/hyperfollow/cityofsound/among-the-phoenix-2?Email+&SendGrid That's My Guy merch: wrigheousj.myshopify.com/ Spotify: open.spotify.com/artist/19ErqV3IIZFacXLQF0mqgs?si=E_r3tnXWRSCbc2nkZZjJqw

[@wolfgangwalk337]

This song becomes a whole different beast live. They opened their Pepsi Center concert with it. They hit the ground at 200 mph - and accelerated from there.

[@gregoryvlchek269]

A fun fact about the core bassline of this song - Paulina, the drummer who also plays piano (all three began as classically-trained pianists) sits at the home piano working out initial, basic ideas, concepts and melodies for the majority of the band's songs. However, one day while out grocery shopping, this bassline popped into her head while walking down an aisle. So she wouldn't forget it, she took out her phone and recorded it on the Garage Band app. When she got home, she immediately played it for her sister, the bassist, Alejandra. Long story short, that shopping trip ultimately gave us a killer, catchy and infectious bassline to one of their best and most-loved songs. In a recent interview, Paulina cited the song as one of her top-five favorites songwriting-wise.

[@CraigCholar]

Similar to how Paul McCartney "wrote" the melody to Yesterday while dreaming, and when he woke up he immediately scrambled around to get the melody down before he forgot it. He had a hard time believing the melody arrived in a dream fully-formed so while working on the lyrics he kept playing the melody to just about everyone he knew, asking them if they had heard the tune elsewhere. Paul thought he had heard the melody sometime in the past, and simply dreamed the tune of an already existing song... Nope, he hadn't, and it became the most covered song in history, with over 3000 versions recorded.

[@Ruisu-San]

For you, being an independent band is very important, also for them, even though they are signed with Lava Records, they remain independent creatively. They negotiated a 5 albums contract with Lava Records, this negotiation took 7 months, keep in mind that they were a lot younger at that time. They wanted to stay true to themselves and they wanted total freedom to create their music. Also they maintain control to their patreon account. These ladies are pretty, smart and talented. Full package.

[@biglew1161]

I'm sure their preexisting popularity and social media presence gave them a lot of negotiating power to get a lot of what they wanted. I believe I read that they also have copyright control over their preexisting catalogue.

[@gill2105]

I love that ya’ll are independent The Warning are very inspiring in that regard, even though they’re with a big label now they fought hard for 7 months on the signing to get creative control and to keep their patreon and fan base in tact. Hoping all the best for you guys hope to get to see you live one day. 🤘⚡️🤘

[@Chip-dm5uw]

Make no excuses for your continued reactions to The Warning. It is an addiction and in my opinion, you do not do enough😊. Maybe in future reactions you could the mv followed by the live performance to see how good The Warning are live. Choke, Martirio, Automatic Sun are good examples. Dust to Dust/ Dull Knives is a great live performance at the Pepsi centre. Great reactions. Congrats with the tour. 🤟

[@xXxJSHxXx]

Listen to this song Live it's incredibly good! The Warning - DISCIPLE Live at Teatro Metropolitan CDMX 08/29/2022 this concert has the best sound.

[@the_hetman]

You should really watch one of the live versions where Pau sings over that tricky beat in the second verse and over the monster fill.

[@shelbyxyz]

I DARE you to watch the live version of this song from their Pepsi Center concert - even if you don't record your reaction to it.

[@tomcanfield705]

Actually I prefer the 2022 Teatro Metropolitan CDMX version, it just gobsmacked me. TWB songs are loaded with moments, none more than Disciple. I mean 2, 3, GO!

[@ramonacevedo356]

@@tomcanfield705 both?

[@anderseriksson3603]

yes its so much better live

[@tomcanfield705]

@anderseriksson3603 like prett pretty all TWB songs

[@anderseriksson3603]

@tomcanfield705 true

[@danburnes722]

This band checks all the boxes from talent, to songwriting, to presentation and the visuals are always stunning.

[@wilarluis9363]

Great reaction from someone taking the path in the industry. That fact they stayed true to themselves and said no to big labels in the past is a testament to their musical creativity and pride. Their structure in writing is complex with every song not to flex but for its precise purpose.

[@AlfonsoAyala-l7m]

Great reaction. Great driving song with some awesome drops. TWA is here for the journey and support your channel. Keep Rockin' my friend 🤘⚡🤘

[@philwrichtube]

Shared vocals and great riffs. Love this song ! 🤟🏼🎸🥁🎸🤟🏼

[@rdombek]

The foos were my favorite band for 29 years, then I got Warned 🤘⚡️

[@bl4ckfl4g]

The live version of this is insane, especially cdmx. You can watch her do that drum fill live while singing

[@g.garcia7151]

💯

[@nichep1]

Pepsi Center version will melt your face!

[@tunes77]

I still always get amazed Pau sings so well through that drum fill she is laying down

[@marktaylor1799]

I love this song and they sound just like this live, if you enjoyed this you should watch the the Dust to Dust / Dull Knives performance from the Pepsi Arena CDMX.

[@alejandrovillela2400]

Man, do yourself a favor and react or watch on your own the live version at Pepsi Center so you can see how they connect with the fans. Fans chanting the riff is crazy, the freaking riff and answering the calls from Pau it's awesome. What I like the most from your reactions it's the knowledge of the composition and music itself you add to the reaction, I really enjoy it. Thank you.

[@paulrowe006]

The way they connect to an audience is amazing.

[@spaceknave]

Trivia: when they were recording it, Pau sings "non-believers start running". Someone first noted that it sounded like Numberly Garfs and soon nobody could unhear it. I think Pau even tried rerecording it but it sounded the same. So numberly garfs became a big inside joke and tag for the song.

[@wrighteousj]

@@spaceknave LMAOOOO

[@CraigCholar]

Cool, I didn't know that! To me, Numberly Garfs sounds like a character from a Dickens novel.

[@ThomasHooper-bt1xf]

This is even much better LIVE!!!!

[@paulbrinkmann1469]

Anything Live!! It's their super power ❤⚡⚡⚡🎶🤟🏻🤘🤟🏻

[@paulrowe006]

They have two lead singers/front women in one family/band and Ale has a great voice too. It's crazy.

[@tonyforte3271]

Ale has perfect pitch, and has a wider vocal range than Dani and Pau. Ale is amazing and so talented it is a shame she prefers not to sing lead but does step up when Dani's voice is not up to it if she is tired or ill.

[@paulrowe006]

@@tonyforte3271 Saw the last show of this tour and was kind of hoping Dany would be tired so we could see Ale sing lead on a couple. We did see them debut Apologize though.

[@rdombek]

You just found your new favorite band 🤘⚡️

[@sweetmandolynsurbanfarm7188]

NEED to see this live from Pepsi Center concert. ❤🤘⚡️

[@davejohnston2197]

As an independent band, understand they turned down some major offers. Even Disney wanted to sign them. They said nope. We aren't changing for money, and lived off crowd sourcing and Patreon until they found a label who didn't want to change them. Stay true to the music. You won't have to change the name of the band to a symbol 😂 ) ❤️⚡🤘

[@AuntDandy]

This was awesome, but you have to watch the Pepsi center concert! That made me a true fan!💜💜💜

[@dennismitchell9500]

They used the Warning Army as stand-ins in this video. i.e. their fans.

[@wrighteousj]

@@dennismitchell9500 LOVE that and sounds familiar 😂

[@CraigCholar]

I like how you use your musical background to point the nuances of The Warning's songwriting that I would otherwise miss. I helps me appreciate their talent even more, so thanks!

[@johanhartjes]

Love this song and it’s a great OMV. 🤘 When hearing and experiencing this song live takes it to an other level.. 🔥⚡️🤘

[@randymarple9830]

You are sounding much healthier than the last reaction. Good for you!! Life on the road is brutal.

[@carlosmed2872]

Their videos and recordings are great, but live is the superpower! Pepsi Center 2023 concert is the way.

[@reactionsaccount3955]

FYI Live she plays that drum fill while singing lead. 🤯 The live video from Pepsi Centre takes this song to a whole new level.

[@Purplegma]

Love the drummer !

[@FelipeSilva-nm9hx]

Love your reactions! Best of luck with your project 🎉

[@mrh3578]

Always been one of favorites.

[@michaelsmith2017]

A few more suggestions.... They have been releasing their Pepsi Center CDMX concert song by song with the full concert as the last release. Watch every single one, there are no filler songs. Specifically check out Dust to Dust/Dull Knives and if you really want to see something different from them, check out Black Holes, Breathe and When I'm Alone from the same show. You really can't go wrong. Ale, the bassist and the youngest is 19, Pau, the drummer is 22 and Dany the guitarist is 24. The show was their 10th anniversary show in October of 2023. Do the math on how old they were when they started... I believe Ale was 9 when the covered Enter Sandman on KZbin and Kirk Hammett made them go viral.

[@northof4912]

Their talent in the video made them go viral. Kirk Hammett simply commented on it, after the fact.

[@michaelsmith2017]

@@northof4912 very true, but Kirk's 10M followers seeing his post sure didn't hurt.

[@northof4912]

@ It was a great boost, but it was they who created the sensation that he noticed! It all came together to allow us to be where we are today as fans!

[@wchaza67]

No such thing as The Warning overkill bro. Loving tracking your journey. Loving that you are watching how The Warning worked through theirs. You should check out their 6-part series (5 minutes per episode) about their signing with Lava records, going from independent to partnering with Lava (United/Warner). They got an unprecedented level of control over their music after 7 months of negotiation. These girls don't concede anything - not to mention the first south-of-the-border rock band to sign with a major US label. They are nasty, in the best possible way as far as negotiating the industry and maintaining control, and that's also a tribute to their manager Rudy. You should reach out... why not?

[@chasingbirds3073]

I've listened to their whole catalog and this might be my favorite. It's especially good as the live version because they extend the bridge and interact with the crowd. Also, the lyrics of this song hit home a little harder today in light of the election results in the US yesterday.

[@TWA-4LIFE]

THE WARNING... LIVE, LIVE, LIVE, LIVE, LIVE, THE WARNING IS EXCEPTIONAL LIVE. AT THE PEPSI CENTER CDMX OR TEATRO METROPOLITAN CDMX 2022 .. Keep doing The Warning. "LIVE" 🤘🎶

[@CarlD70]

Ditto this comment....Live is where it is at. Great OMV's and all but nothing compares to LIVE!!! Thanks J. And YES, have your music on my Spotify playlist...love the band.

[@marianogonzalez1977]

Keep digging TW 24x7, I don't mind. LOL! Cheers from Buenos Aires!!!

[@Robertsmith-dy3sh]

No need to apologize for The Warning content! Like you I am in an independent band and I find The Warning to be very inspiring!

[@thontor]

"Disciple" is all about social media and how people get manipulated by disinformation without even realizing it. [Dany, the guitarist, sings from the perspective of those spreading hate and ignorance for power and money.] She talks about how people avoid facing their own flaws and welcome the chaos that’s created. Then [Pau, the drummer, plays the "disciple"], representing those falling for it, blindly following what they’re told. The chorus is cool because Dany sings about fighting the system, trying to wake people up, but Pau's part reinforces staying trapped in ignorance-like a tug-of-war between rebellion and control. By the end, the "disciple" is totally brainwashed, swimming in hate, and still following the system. It’s a warning that if people don’t wake up, they’ll stay stuck in this loop of ignorance.

[@wilddekardde]

very relevant song considering the recent election results . Dany sings trumps message and Pau sings maga reactions .

[@olemadsen2113]

Cool, thanks! If you watch the Pepsi Center CDMX live version of this - highly recommended - catch Ale's double bass slide at 3m38s (in that video, not this one in case YT makes this a link) and Ale (and Pau?) doing angelic harmonies to Dany's lead just after 3m49s or so 🔥💙

[@wilddekardde]

very relevant song considering the recent election results .

[@phillipchunjr7042]

You have been Warned! That's the Warning nothing but bad ass!🤘🏽🤙🏽😁

[@arctic_haze]

This is the song which made me a fan. I love this video but live versions are even better. Try the Teatro Metropolitan or Pepdi Cener ones (both from Mexico City).

[@Dale-m9t]

If I remember right this was the 1st song I ever heard from them and it was the video...instantly captured me!

[@VebastionSettel]

You will never get accused of too much Warning! You calling this a favourite is not out of place at all, the band themselves had this in 4th when asked for their 'top 5 Warning songs'. It's also a major fan favourite so much so that when Ale steps to the stage center early in the set people will know immediately it's Disciple and she's going to rip that bass off. This is also an excellent song for reactors to check out live (Pepsi or Teatro, or really any fan cam) because it has so much Warning in it: Awesome heavy bassline, Pau killing it on the drums (her fill in the middle is soooo satisfying in person), and Dany and Pau trading off the lead several times in the song. The bridge is also well written as it works perfectly for them to extend and allow Dany to do some crowdwork depending on the show. And somehow Dany notes in this song are better in person than the album. Love hearing your take on the structure of the song, I don't have much in the way of musical knowledge so having someone that can pick out specific reasons why something is cool and then explain them in an understandable way is very cool.

[@alvasquez2931]

Ditto. We watch The Warning, all reactors,

[@americanswan]

"Her voice is so good." - 6:09 Whose? Dany and Pau tag team this song.

[@northof4912]

Yes!

[@oregonlt3]

Don’t worry, they have 60 “best” & “favorite” & “my #1” songs. The whole Q:”what’s your favorite The Warning song?” A:“YES!” Is 💯true.

[@lohresouza9406]

Nice !! 🤟🤟🎸🥁

[@samsonjpedroza]

THE WARNING HAS NO BAD SONGS !!! WELCOME TO THE WARNING ARMY .... YOU EARNED A NEW SUB. TILL THE NEXT THE WARNING VIDEO ...PEACE ! INDEPENDENCE RULES !!!!!

[@ronaldmorgan7632]

I'll echo the others who said that their live stuff is just so much better than their studio.

[@robloschiavo246]

I concur...their studio versions are really good, but they'll blow your mind (and steal your heart) on the live stage.

[@Dale-m9t]

A fun OMV to do is Que Mas Quieres. The song is up for a Latin Grammy and the video was Pau's directorial debut. (She co-directed with Ivan.) Also the ladies acted in it. And it's a really fun song!!

[@franciscotavares4600]

THEY ARE BETTER IN THE LIVE VERSIONS

[@fourortwelvestrings]

And I gotta say, seeing Pau sing through that drum fill, live, was a complete jaw dropping experience for me. I mean they do lots of things that stun me, but that bit there, just made me agog. I've seen her do it half a dozen times now, so it wasn't a one-off, it's just Pau doing the impossible, routinely.

[@Bekka_Noyb]

Great song & video! Seen them play this live a few times! Of course they killed it! ♥

[@SO.CAL-D.Edwards]

Better watch the Live version. Live at the Pepsi Center cdmx.The Warning is built for "LIVE" shows. 🌎✌️

[@billyowell0113]

Even better live at Pepsi Center CDMX(Mexico City).

[@g.garcia7151]

Thank you for continuing with TW. And I look forward to hearing your new song. By the way, is Future Islands an influence on you all, or at least a band you see a connection to?

[@romeoromo-kt5vn]

Excellent my friend... excellent!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@bobpaulin6913]

The warning are great and really making a name for their selves past 2 years. But you need to watch them live to really appreciate how good they are. They are incredible live check out the Live from pepsi Center CDMX over 8000 people. Look for this song Disciple, Dust to Dust, Black holes and Hell you call a dream plus many others.

[@joelpinckney9782]

Good stuff, man. I have no technical feel for music, but you present in a way that's not too much. Can really tell how much you appreciate and respect what's going on in the composition. Keep it up.

[@TimberWolf762]

Subbing since you are doing more of *The Warning!*

[@v6jim2]

Please, please, please just soin around and pop out the live version from Pepsi. It's a riot!

[@figuerio1]

!!!GOODISM¡¡¡ The Warning is 100% ‍🔥 !!!🎵Ole Ole Ole Oleeee Warning Warning🎵¡¡¡. Greetings from Argentina.

[@vincentstephenson2397]

Spec Ops Command, The Warning Army, Northern England checking in. I salute your Warning reviews. Enjoying the insight from your musician perspective. Keep going recruit and TWA will show up. Brace for Impact. I have subbed soldier and will be monitoring comms. That is all.

[@laurahicklin7436]

i saw these at Rock City in Nottingham one of the best i’ve been to. the feeling there was so immersive and just felt like you could touch the music ❤🤘🎸

[@gustavoorozco4211]

I respect your opinión and your way of work, i'm just disapointed You didn't go for the live versión@pepsi Center, the warning is alwas better love, but this is My opinión, You are doing great SO far!!!!

[@t0o0o0o0o0oty]

wow, i just listened to your latest song because of your Outro, it's great. You should feel free to shill your band more on your channel, i've watched several of your reactions and you've never mentioned the name of your band once. No one's going to complain about you advertising it more.

[@wrighteousj]

@@t0o0o0o0o0oty I appreciate that so much! Got an announcement for our final song of the year tomorrow! Thank you for supporting independent rock!

[@bl4ckfl4g]

Same it’s pretty dope

[@wrighteousj]

@@bl4ckfl4g aye thank you and welcome to the Madness (our fanbase) LOVE HEARING THAT!

[@CraigCholar]

@@wrighteousjI'm a new member of The Madness, and I'm hyped for the new song!

[@jluisg622]

Las composiciones de The Warning son sin duda un rock nítido y puro ,pura energía y poder,en vivo nadie las iguala

[@russellherrmann6748]

Live at Teatro Metropolitan CDMX

[@100_Chris]

Excellent reaction again! Love your insight and don´t worry - there is no such thing as too much of TW😊. Highly recommend you check out “ANIMOSITY” Live at Teatro Metropolitan show, pro quality audio, you will love it.

[@RosAsol2028]

This song live from Pepsi Center!!! 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@outwest1014]

The video of them working with Band Maid in Japan is a great video. You get a sense of their off-stage everyday personalities. Plus the Dani/Kanami PRS interview. Now for my standard Nag - Please react to Unlucky Morpheus, "Black Pentagram" live with your violinist reacting with you.

[@ivanmolina3563]

A singer powerful Daniela.

[@monicatapia6147]

Hello, have you listened to their song "Queen of the murder scene?

[@ramonacevedo356]

I actually like there stuff.

[@brianslifeafterstroke5990]

once your done with older stuyff start watchong them now, and see how they have grown...best place to start is with newest Pepsi Center concert...

[@jarrydsavage7547]

Bro I don’t know if you can stop with The Warning reactions, they seriously have just too many good songs and they kill playing live better than the studio. Their songwriting is wild aswell, often dark and meaningful, it’s unbelievable some of the songs Pau was writing at 13.Really loving your channel and reactions brother 🤘🏻

[@jaimeerlandchavezbustillo3961]

Me encanta odyssey!!❤ Felicidades Todos los dias la escucho.

[@dlblakey62]

🤘⚡️🔥

[@americanswan]

​​The Warning is a Mexican rock band formed in 2013 by the Villarreal Vélez sisters:​​ ​​- Daniela "Dany" Villarreal Vélez: Born January 30, 2000.​​ ​​- Paulina "Pau" Villarreal Vélez: Born February 5, 2002.​​ ​​- Alejandra "Ale" Villarreal Vélez: Born December 13, 2004.​​ Indy ​​**Escape the Mind EP (2015)**​​ ​​ Dany: 15 years old​​ ​​- Pau: 13 years old​​ ​​- Ale: 10 years old​​ Indy ​​**XXI Century Blood (2017)**​​ ​​- Dany: 17 years old​​ ​​- Pau: 15 years old​​ ​​- Ale: 12 years old​​ Indy ​​**Queen of the Murder Scene (2018)**​​ ​​- Dany: 18 years old​​ ​​- Pau: 16 years old​​ ​​- Ale: 13 years old​​ Signed with Lava / Republic (I suspect the band funded a lot of this album's creation due to online fundraising and Lava not having a lot of money during COVID) ​​**Error (2022)**​​ ​​- Dany: 22 years old​​ ​​- Pau: 20 years old​​ ​​- Ale: 17 years old​​ ​​**Keep Me Fed (2024)**​​ ​​- Dany: 24 years old​​ ​​- Pau: 22 years old​​ ​​- Ale: 19 years old​​​​ The Warning are managed independently by a friend and their parents in association with Lava.

[@maxfitch4864]

⚠️ ⚡ 🔥 ⚡ ⚠️

[@gregjetnikoff7124]

You don't have to react to it, but do yourself a favour and watch the live CDMX version of this at full throttle!!!!!!!! Pau sings properly and perfectly WHILE doing that drum fill!!!

[@sandgroper1970]

Look who cares if you are reviewing or watching a lot of The Warning. The Warning are great, maybe not to everyone taste. I may have only discovered them recently but I have 3 albums in heavy rotation on my stereo system.

[@seleniromero-iw2ef]

Genial 🤘

[@IkkjeDus]

First and foremost: I like your reactions and your band is interesting as well. I won't say `you should` as the OMV and full produced songs have their own strengths, but including a/the live performance illustrates their real power on stage (I know you already listened to some). You can combine both, if you want 🤘One minor gripe, though: the music sound is in mono which takes away from the dynamic. I hope you can improve that.

[@Jessicasalsera]

⚠️❣️⚡️❤️‍🔥⚡️❣️⚠️

[@darrinashby9019]

Punk/metal.....yeah, throw in some classic hard rock and a little grunge, Thats The Warning. "Z" at Teatro Metropolitan show. Punk right in your face to open the concert. This song like all of their songs are made to be played live. This song at the Metropolitan show makes you peel yourself off the back wall. For your convenience.....all the songs are broken up to easily find. Metro show. kzbin.info/www/bejne/bZnFc5RnYpajba8

[@mikeantos6930]

You’re catching that Dani and Pau are taking turns at lead, yeah?

[@mikeantos6930]

I vote Choke at Teatro Metropolitan should be next.

[@celinel9750]

I don't think he did ;-) lol

[@tpandos8451]

The live version will kill you!

[@RockMusic1959]

Great Reaction again. Ok he did react to "More & Sick Live @ the Pepsi center. Try a two-fer the OMV then the LIVE. I would recommend reacting to "AutoMatic Sun" from Tecate Pa'l Norte OMV and Then "Automatic Sun" Live at MTV Push or Live At Vevo studios Live is absolutely Their SuperPower...

[@CraigCholar]

Counterpoint: I wish the MTV Push and Live at Vevo videos weren't so dark ! I know it was to set a mood, but I think both lighting directors went overboard. Another thing is that neither of those two videos has a live audience to feed off of. The Jimmy Kimmel version of Automatic Sun is lit better and has an audience they interact with during the break that has the "thump thump thump" beat. Some have said the audio is off, but I didn't pick that up.

[@roywall8169]

🤘🏻🤘🏻

[@tay13666]

You think the studio version is good 😀 You should do the live version from the Pepsi Center. The crowd work during the guitar section. That drop you were waiting for hits so much harder live (especially with that bass rev from Ale)

[@HDW-dz1lj]

Try reaching out to The Warning management/Freeze the Fall for some sort of collab

[@rogerreed905]

👍👋🇳🇿🍻twa

[@troysublett8493]

🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘😎

[@fredymendez855]

DUDE are you the lost child of John Rzeznik (Goo Goo Dolls lead vocalist).....I was just watching the IRIS music video again and you came to mind. Get a DNA test brother

[@MULEHEAD73]

Great reaction but as good as this is as you need to do the live versions of every song they have so much better rock on the warning

[@tomcanfield705]

Actually I prefer the 2022 Teatro Metropolitan CDMX live version, it just gobsmacked me. TWB songs are loaded with moments, none more than Disciple. I mean 2, 3, GO! And having the lyrics up no doubt helps. Pau, the Spanish speaking firecracker, writes better English lyrics than 95% of pretty much anyone.

[@CraigCholar]

Yes! Pau's flair for lyrics is very palpable!