The Wheatfield: A Gettysburg Battle Walk - Ranger John Hoptak

Few battles were more confusing and bloody than the July 2nd, 1863 fighting in farmer John Rose's wheatfield. Join National Park Ranger John Hoptak for an indepth tour through some of the bloodiest and misunderstood ground in Gettysburg National Military Park.

[@trajancanada]

When someone loves history, and reads on it, and has a talent for public speaking and explaining --- this happens. This man found his calling. Cheers.

[@Kunfucious577]

Absolutely. I got lucky in high school when i got a passionate history teacher. He got me to love history my whole life.

[@boondocksaint621]

This guy is great, just an excellent grasp on the situation.

[@mfs2778]

Absolutely. Wish I had that the sense and foresight early on, to go after such a challenging and HONEST vision of American history.. I hope Howard Zinn and his ilk ROT in HELL

[@IamNiggler]

@@Kunfucious577don't be gay

[@y00h0011]

That was most outstanding, Ranger Hoptak. Presentation delivered with conviction. I will watch this again!

[@Steve-wb1rp]

This man is a great communicator and storyteller. He puts his emotions into every phrase so you feel what they felt on that horrific day.

[@battmann678]

Probably the finest presentation I've seen in this series. This place breaks my heart, and yet I cannot look away.

[@tyronebailey52]

One of the finest presentations I've witnessed in years...this guy is a true professional and really loves his job...Thank you for bringing history to life again.

[@scotttyson7970]

Excellent storytelling man .And he ha remembered every bit of the Battle

[@counciousstream]

I've been to Gettysburg 4 times and have done multiple tours on my own and with guides. I highly recommend paying for a guide as having someone with greater knowledge explain the battle as it happened just as Ranger John does. One great thing about this park is that you can walk through the woods from Devils Den to the Wheatfield just as Anderson's Brigade did. Climb Little Round Top and find the rifle positions along the base of Big Round Top. If you are up for it you can climb the same route that the Confederates did as they attacked Culp's Hill and you can walk from the Virginia Memorial on Seminary Ridge to the Pennsylvania Memorial on Cemetery Ridge just as Pickett's troops did. It can be rigorous and in some places dangerous if you are not physically up for it and dressed appropriately. Just keep in mind that this national treasure is for everyone to enjoy for the next 150 years. Don't carve your name in a tree or hammer it into a rock, leave everything as it is. Take nothing but pictures and leave nothing but footprints.

[@df5295]

What amazed me was it seemed like people still lived on the farms on the battlefield. It seemed like it was private property. Do you know if that's true?

[@indy_go_blue6048]

@@df5295 GNBP consists of about 20 sq miles. Not all of the complete battle is a part of the park. Many parts are still privately owned but the park owns the most meaningful parts.

[@npdcpa]

Another fantastic Ranger presentation. The Rangers are the best ambassadors of our National Parks.

[@jonfouracre1254]

This guy is a pleasure to watch - very informative - I'm from the UK but hope to get over and visit the battlefield very soon. Love the way he gets all the folks involved.

[@eastofthemississippi968]

That's awesome.

[@insertnamehere5146]

on i am also in the UK. did you ever get to this battlefield? if so is it a expensive experience? Thanks

[@jonfouracre1254]

@@insertnamehere5146 Hi - not made it yet - and its obviously very problematic at the moment - but its still on my to do/bucket list. Can you recomend a good tour, I'd love to do a tour re day 2 of the fighting - the Wheatfield and Peach Orchard!

[@870Rem12gauge]

These tour guides know their stuff. A pleasure to hear them.

[@alejandrojimenez4169]

Gavin are you born in the 1600s because of your profile

[@JimJonesKoolaid]

@@alejandrojimenez4169 i didnt know Clint Eastwood was from the 1600s...

[@ryanmcswain1143]

Their job is to know that stuff

[@natedog1619]

@@ryanmcswain1143 - Presenting this amount of Gettysburg specific information and being able to talk about it endlessly for hours on end to a group of people from an ADHD ridden society who likely have no outside knowledge of the topic is an extremely difficult skill set to master. Most don’t make the cut

[@benjaminpendleton7797]

I spent a lot of time with the Rangers at Antietam. They are amazing.

[@carolhindley7942]

An absolutely superb presentation! I have a much clearer understanding of what transpired that late afternoon and early evening of July 2. Thank you Ranger John Hoptak!

[@karenvecchio2229]

My ancestor Samuel Shaw died in this wheatfield. my 3 great Grandfather was wounded in the leg at the Battle of Wilderness, recovered & fought in the little round top. His name was Edward Shaw. He survived the war.

[@benjaminpendleton7797]

This Ranger not only knows Gettysburg, I saw him as a Ranger at Antietam as well. He wrote a book on the Battle of South Mountain. An extremely knowledgeable, impressive, engaging historian.

[@_Acameraandthesomme]

Absolutely captivating, in amongst all the chaos of the Wheatfield, Mr Hoptak gives us a fantastic understanding of what went on back in 1863. You Rangers do a fantastic job John truly appreciated by people like me who will probably never get the chance to visit ourselves, thank you.

[@decimated550]

do you notice...he does not even refer to notes. all in his head. wow

[@westvapaul]

Excellent presentation! An expert on what he is saying and his passion arises from his thorough understanding while he paints a picture for your mind’s eye! A great way to get children involved too, Kudos to an excellent, passionate Ranger!

[@SnapSuplexSeanVA]

These are AWESOME videos guys. Keep em coming! Thanks for posting.

[@yannschonfeld5847]

N.P.S. guide, John Hoptak gives a very Professional and captivating description of those events. Thank you.

[@susiepittman601]

this man is really good at his job. I felt like I was there. Thanks so much.

[@CrazySC833]

One day I hope in retirement to become a battlefield guide. John Hoptak is EXCEPTIONAL!

[@indy_go_blue6048]

Mr. Hoptak is my second favorite presenter in these NPS videos. Matt is #1 for his humor, but John is knowledgeable and very enthusiastic. I like that.

[@davidbowman4259]

Matt jokes too much.

[@gettysburgerrn]

Well done!! Excellent presentation my Mr. Hoptak....A great description of some of the most confusing fighting at Gettysburg...Thank you for posting

[@shannonhamrick6668]

hi Ken!!

[@tsf5-productions]

As stated before from me (I think) - There were MANY different men to lead their men to various places and engage in battles. Yes...the whole Civil War, literally, had rough grounds that made the years really hard on these soldiers. Clothing - from head to toes and all the belongings they were allowed to carry was something! Like the modern day soldiers of militaries throughout the world, the men, young and old that qualified to fight, had real stress on them. Imagen the conflicts! Decisions, that to live...or die...were paramount on their spirits. Most men knew the Lord...knew that their time was at hand. What a "feeling"! Nice, as said before, to involve the visitors on the tours. Means something to them...especially the young ones that, we, as older citizens of the U.S., have an impact on these kids. Very well explained, Ranger John! You, and the fellow NPR employees love and keep yourselves educated.

[@steed3902]

after watching Ranger Matt's video about little round top...i can appreciate this video so much more! Great presentation Ranger John! :-)

[@Westcoastjazzer]

Wonderful story teller! None of this made sense to me in the beginning but he ties everything together and it makes sense at the end. I will be there in April and hope to do one of this mans tours.

[@meljen8592]

Pleasure to watch, mr hoptak knows his stuff👍

[@donkeylong7707]

My great great grandfather was in Brooke’s unit in the 53rd Pennsylvania … Cpl. George Washington Carpenter Jr , .. papa I don’t know how you survived the wheat field and rose woods but thank the good lord you did because if you hadn’t I wouldn’t be here. Thank you for your galant service papa… love you ☺️

[@jpeez12345]

I just attended a battlefield walk with John Hoptak on Seminary Ridge and McPeherson's Farm. He was excellent. If going to Gettysburg, try to get on one of his ranger talks.

[@ctham5316]

Well done Ranger Hoptak! Next best thing to being there are these battle walk videos! Please keep them coming!

[@Colm2243]

Great presentation! John makes sense of the sometimes chaotic maneuvering and fighting that occurred that day.

[@Rogijimbex]

John Hoptak is one of the best battlefield presenters I've listened to. Not only does he have superb command of the material - he also presents it in a really understandable way. Just great!

[@needmorecowbell6460]

5 of my relatives … a father and four sons fought in that wheat 🌾 field in the 53rd Penn. Vol. Inf. Co.I

[@tomr1630]

My great great grandfather fought with the 8th New Jersey in the wheatfield. Where would I find an after action report or something along those lines? Good job on the battlefield walk video. I'd love to take that walk if I ever get back there.

[@kimberleyannedemong5621]

Amazing battlewalk. Heartfelt & convincing. John Hoptak is an excellent guide & teacher

[@wanderdworld]

That was very good. I enjoyed that. And well done to you also Mr Camera Man:)

[@bcask61]

I really like Rgr. Hoptak’s walks. He has a great way of explaining things and has a firm grasp on the material. I enjoy all of his programs.

[@normamassey1000]

What a fantastic battle walk. John Hoptak really draws you into the action and puts it all together so well.

[@mrdddeeezzzweldor5039]

A very powerful and poignant presentation by this Ranger. The battle came into my living room!

[@ekim0513]

This is fantastic. Thanks for videoing this for those of us who want to go to Gettysburg, but not sure if they will ever make it. And kudos to the Park Ranger who is exceptional at his job.

[@jurgent5755]

Awesome videos. More plz. Should go to sleep, but I have to play some Scourge of War: Gettysburg after seeing these.

[@jurgent5755]

u serious? I played a lot of empire: total war, including the excellent civil war mod. However much I like the TW series, the battles always feel generic and like small scale skirmishes, as a battle system just supporting the turn-based campaign game. I love the feel of the Take Command games, where a battle builds up slowly, roads and other terrain are much more important than in TW, there are no overpowered heroic units and battles are long enough that it actually makes sense to regroup, rest and keep a sizable reserve. In all of those ways TC battles are way more realistic and deep. Visuals and user interface design could be a lot better in the TC games though.

[@sdingeswho]

Best discussion of The Wheatfield I have seen! One always hears about The Wheatfield, but even Ken Burns sort of went around it (was mainly focusing on the nearby Peach Orchard), but this engagement (which admittedly was set-up by Sickles’ precipitous move into the orchard) absolutely defines the phrase “fog of war”! What a cluster ___ 😮! Second Day of Gettysburg is IT! The south end of the battlefield, the attempts to flank the Army of the Potomac on its left, and the ensuing chaos … THAT’S what I would want to tramp-over, if I ever made it to G-Burg! Major respect to our Ranger, for keeping all those details in his head of one of the most complex and confused actions of the war that I’ve yet heard of 🥇!

[@mikehaye5527]

Catching up on our history - that was amazing - thank you for your energy and expertise!

[@paulelliott3220]

Very interesting indeed I went to Gettysburg and it was fascinating, and the Wheatfield an absolutely chilling place The Rangers have a superb knowledge and these tours are truly excellent

[@BennyDawkins]

Thank you so much for posting this! Very, very well done!

[@jeff2178]

I wish all the National Battlefields would record their battle walks...

[@bcask61]

I doubt there is a battlefield anywhere in the world that has been preserved as well as Gettysburg. You can immerse yourself in the history and it is very moving. I live about three hrs drive and visit often.

[@nicksivds]

Gettysburg is wonderful. It is not preserved very well though. I have been there 3 times and loved it! Shiloh is a well preserved battlefield. Antietam is very nice as well

[@jackpine62]

I'm currently reading Stephen Sears' "Gettysburg" and just finished this section of the book. Wished I'd seen it earlier since to help visualize the location as I read (and it's a great book, by the way). These rangers and guides are so knowledgeable and skilled at telling the story. I'm always impressed!

[@TheWarStoreMan]

This is a place you have to see and feel to understand. I remember reading the history of the Wheatfield as a youngster and not understanding how men could keep charging, keep fighting back and forth so savagely for this little piece of ground. I could not understand it, and the Wheatfield became my least favorite part of history to read about. Until I went there. When you go you experience how this little field surrounded by woods and higher ground feels so isolated from the rest of the Battlefield. I got the fleeting sense of how this piece of earth, for the space of an afternoon, could become the most important place on earth. Indeed the only place, and holding it a matter of the deepest honor, worthy of a death struggle. Amazing. There are places on that battlefield that have to be seen to be understood.

[@owenmccullagh3462]

At the end the emotions for the injured and dead were getting him. Thanks for caring

[@natedog1619]

Presenting this amount of Gettysburg specific information and being able to talk about it endlessly for hours on end to a group of people from an ADHD ridden society who likely have no outside knowledge of the topic is an extremely difficult skill set to master. Most don’t make the cut

[@indy_go_blue6048]

You underestimate the intelligence and interest of a large portion of the American and even world public. Many of the visitors have even read numerous books 🤓 on the subject.

[@alysonbiscamp4702]

WOW… awesome story telling …great job !

[@billhowes5871]

Very few people know that "Elongated Drive" was General LongStreet's name before having it legally changed. -Bill Howes, Civil War Historian.

[@vivians9392]

Who has a strange name as elongated drive? ( two words?). Longstreet sounds proper, and I think is the original name.

[@indy_go_blue6048]

@@vivians9392 Truly some people have no sense of humor or appreciation of the absurd. Bill even capped two letters in the name as a clue for the clueless.

[@rebelsoul5980]

@@indy_go_blue6048 haha internet humor can be tough sometimes, I'm headed to Gettysburg this 4th of July weekend(2021) can't wait!!❌

[@davidbowman4259]

@@indy_go_blue6048 It was a bad joke to start with.

[@OdinNjord]

What a very visual park ranger! One of the best I've seen. Job well done!

[@crazycarlsju]

Fantastic tour!! Thanks for sharing these.

[@danielwyvern5]

Interesting to hear about this battle. My Great Great Grandfather: Connell, William E., Private Company I, 50th Georgia Infantry Regiment. 8/22/62 Appointed Sargeant; Wounded at Gettysburg, PA. 7/2/63; Discharged 4/10/64 upon being elected Judge of Ordinary Court, Berrien County, Ga.; Widow filed for Confederate Soldiers Pension, Berrien County 1910.

[@midnight-2021]

I am a descendant of several Union soldiers with one fighting at this battle and getting wounded at this battle in the 102nd Pennsylvania infantry, a private named Peter Zellers. Today I am at Gettysburg and very often visit this battlefield, especially since I live only 25 miles north of Gettysburg. I am pissed off today because these BLM protesters are at the town center with several of them holding signs saying to take Confederate monuments and Lee and Longstreet's statue down. These Confederate monuments and Lee's statue especially are very important to this battlefield and any civil war battlefield. They are trying to erase history and this is total bullshit. They are stepping way out of line targeting Confederate monuments and statues at civil war battlefields. These BLM, Antifa and white liberal elitist along with these far left mainstream media outlets like CNN and MSNBC are trying to change history as they seem fit and they are going to eventually go too far, especially if these people go into Gettysburg or other civil war battlefields and physically remove Confederate monuments and statues. Hell if we would get another Civil war it will not be the south vs the north but rural and conservative Christian Americans and working class Americans which will not just be white people but some black, Latino and Asian people vs urbanites, BLM, antifa, and liberal so called educated elites who happen to be mostly white people that are these liberal educated elitists. They want a war they will get a war if they continue to go too far. Gun sales and ammonium sales are rapidly increasing in the last few weeks and I can see why, especially since our politicians seem to be backing these people and agreeing to defund and possibly eliminate our police departments.

[@danielwyvern5]

punk 2008 - very sad. For they first time in my life, I’m ashamed of America. Most people are falling for the “Big Lie”.

[@midnight-2021]

@@danielwyvern5 so far they seem to be only protesting at the town center. After I drove by the town center I went to w Confederate Avenue and all the Confederate monuments and statues are in good shape. But if these people wanted to they easily could get in this area and cause damage to these monuments and statues because I don't see many people around and I haven't seen any park rangers or police presence in the area. I am driving home now and I hope that I don't read that something happened to these monuments and statues in the next few days or anytime in the future.

[@danielwyvern5]

punk 2008 - thanks for the update. I visited Gettysburg’s many years ago. It’s a magical place. I hope it stays that way.

[@timothyvanscoy6953]

Mine was in Co C, 51st Georgia, so they were side by side for most of the day

[@eastofthemississippi968]

Just imagine how much lead is in the ground right there ladies and gentlemen.

[@johnmonroe7378]

GREAT job sir. One of my grandfathers fought there, in the 7th South Carolina, under the gallant Kershaw.

[@BilgePump]

Very good presentation. Historical and very well researched.

[@davidbowman4259]

This fellow is my favorite Gettysburg guide.

[@williamzambrano7635]

Did anyone else notice the white myst or white apparition at time stamp 31:44 between the park ranger and the tree directly to the left of him. I rewind it so many times and I don’t see anyone smoking. Please somebody, anybody look at time stamp 31:40-31:45 between the park ranger and the tree directly to the left of him, can’t miss it, it will blow your mind. Please reply if anyone else sees what I saw, thank you. Park ranger tour did you guys see it? Wow just wow

[@gregbychich4376]

I definitely saw it to thanks for pointing it out it looks almost like a person trying to form

[@6thmichcav262]

The man directly behind the ranger is smoking.

[@michaelborek378]

Wow what a presentation!! Thank you

[@counciousstream]

Ranger Hoptak brings history to life, American history that over 150 years later still influences the sense of who we as Americans are. Even today the descendants of the men who fought and died here still carry a sense of pride and honor that stems from that sacrifice.

[@deborahchapman9777]

I loved this virtual trip. Thank you.

[@thomaswhitmore2571]

EXCELLANT presentation

[@RobbyHouseIV]

Great battle walk! However, given the many moving parts of this particular area on the 2nd day of fighting a couple of visual aids in the form of a map would definitely come in handy to allow people to get their bearings as to what's happening where in relation to everything else.

[@bcask61]

Robby House If you are interested, there is a book titled “The Battle Maps of Gettysburg” which is a great book and really helps you understand the movements and terrain.

[@kevinbooth6293]

John is one of the best! Passionate about what he does! And a very good friend

[@MsAngie4545]

I'm going there on a field trip from school on this up coming Thursday I think ! I can't wait!

[@voodoochef100]

Gigiix Dixon Hope they didnt make you watch the long boring movie @ cyclorama/museum center. Touring the battlefield is alot more educational & interesting.

[@MsAngie4545]

voodoochef100 Noo we got a tour around the area and stuff

[@walterforsyth1414]

awesome...brought this battle to life and cleared up many questions..should be a book.

[@ARichardP]

Excellent presentation. Makes me want to go back for a third visit.

[@Saewelo-returns]

Thank you for this, as a foreigner who will never get to see the battlefield in person this is truly the next best thing. No one honours the dead like the Americans, and the attention to detail and energy of Mr.Hoptak is just wonderful. That said, I must confess that at times I was sick to the pit of my stomach at the recounting of the carnage brought about by Mr.Lincoln. In England Charles Stuart was referred to as that man of blood by Oliver Cromwell, surely Lincoln should share that terrible accolade. In the final analysis, what system of governance is so moral or just that it must be enforced through warfare, invasion, plunder and destruction. Lincoln unleashed the bloodbath but was at least called to account: So ye shall not pollute the land wherein ye are: for blood it defileth the land: and the land cannot be cleansed of the blood that is shed therein, but by the blood of him that shed it. -King James Bible Numbers 35:33.

[@degel1963]

The Confederates fired first on Fort Sumter on Union troops. Fail to see how Lincoln started it.

[@degel1963]

***** Lincoln the lawyer was always pro union though and thought to break it was unconstitutional and would fracture democracy. "My paramount object in this struggle is to save the Union, and is not either to save or to destroy slavery. If I could save the Union without freeing any slave I would do it, and if I could save it by freeing all the slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that."

[@wendeln92]

Sæwelō it is obvious you know nothing about Lincoln or the true causes of our Civil War, I think you better just stick to your bible reading and forget about commenting on American history until you understand it a little better.

[@jeffsmith8197]

I hope that all you Britishers come to America, to Pennsylvania, to see our Gettysburg Battlefield. I was very much entertained and awed by my visit to the UK in 1987 where I visited the many sites and castles of your glorious history.

[@mrsegundas3988]

Excellent presentation. The US Park Rangers and the preservation of battlefields show how it should be done.

[@stealthownz1676]

Was in Gettysburg last weekend. Such beautiful land. I didnt get too see as much as I wanted but I will be going back to cover everything.

[@po2313]

A very impressive historian and guide. He has numerous books to his credit on the Civil War.

[@34scot]

That guy needs a raise

[@greenshades1234]

This guy is excellent. No disrespect to the other Rangers but this is the only guy who I would be interested in doing a walk with.

[@scotttyson7970]

Those kids are sitting on a very historical Rock.They are part of history now . Good to see kids learning of their history.

[@gcjbhar]

Great description to elude to the fact that war is an absolutely futile attempt to control everything around oneself.

[@adirondackbushcraft5496]

Excellent lecture and tour.

[@scott2582]

Very good, John's delivery of the story reminds me of Troy Harmon.

[@brunoch95]

Amazing job Ranger!

[@lonniemayessr.9722]

Great presentation 👏

[@nareniyer9366]

Simply Awesome!

[@scottk3034]

When I was with 2-8 Infantry at Ft Carson we sounded off with "Regulars, Sir." as we saluted officers.

[@robertschultz9802]

See I don't here when the 2nd regiment regular was put into action

[@scottk3034]

@@robertschultz9802 That is 2nd Battalion of the 4th Infantry Regiment. Most regiments these days don't serve on the same post. 1985ish 1st and 2nd battalions were at Fort Carson and the 3rd and 4th battalions were in Germany.

[@benjaminpendleton7797]

The reason that Semmes' Brigade doesn't get a lot of discussion in relation to The Wheatfield is because General Semmes was mortally wounded leading his men into battle, and did not file a report on his brigade's actions. My great, great uncle was with the 50th Georgia Regiment of Semmes' Brigade. Lt. Colonel Kearse, commander of the 50th, was killed by grape shot. The 50th broke apart somewhere in or around The Wheatfield, Major McGlashen, my uncle and some others of the 50th ended up with Kershaw's Brigade. According to Major McGlashen of the 50th, it was hand to hand fighting in The Wheatfield. If I remember correctly, he wrote that it was "clubbed muskets and bayonets."

[@10ecjohn64]

First class all the way! Thank you!

[@01SOMWS6]

At the 30 minute mark, Ranger John references the 5th Corps troops stopping to make coffee, and he wasn't buying that. I had an uncle under Col Brooks (53rd PVI) in the 2nd Corps say in a letter home that "We moved a little to the left before noon and lay where we could see all that was going on and had the opportunity to make all the coffee we wanted. Between 2 and 3 oc P.M. the firing began to be pretty brisk and more to the left of us about or a little before 4 oc the engagement commenced with great fury on the left and extreme right." So, a coffee delay is possible! hah

[@TaterChip91]

Straight up bucket list shit right here 👍👍👍👍

[@seabasscardsandcomics4264]

Great presentation

[@charleebrosh7331]

I love this stuff

[@darrenpeach7182]

Excellent!!!

[@noctaviassky672]

150 years ago(Give or take), that doesnt feel that long ago... history is such a fascinating thing.

[@joslynscott466]

Ranger John knows how to tell a story.

[@thedukeofswellington1827]

Is the NPS hiring? I currently work for the SSA and would consider this a DREAM JOB. I got my B.A. in history and took a Civil War seminar. Was my favorite time. Would love to make this my profession

[@CrazySC833]

There is a VERY clear apparition directly behind John at 31:36, its like a fog develops behind him! Watch for yourself!

[@frankierodriguez4132]

Guy smoking

[@thesidelinebeekeeper-craig6924]

I saw it too! The soldier is walking and it appeared to be two.

[@theringer2283]

Very well done. It was nice to see the respect given for both the blue and the grey.

[@gribwitch]

No, it is disgusting to see respect given to such a racist regime as the Confederacy and the "men" who shamefully fought for the prejudice it enshrined in its constitution.

[@gribwitch]

@@user-oi8cj9gc4o The parallels with the nazis ARE valid. "...the ideologies in-congruent and separated by decades, not to mention an ocean as well, the Nazis were not Americans The Nazis also weren't in a Civil War either, ....". Time and geographical locations do not matter. Think about it. It is IDEOLOGY we are talking about. Ideology is not affected by time or distance. The nazis didn't need to have a civil war. Their racist programme was enforced by the State and had popular support, their intent was to create a pure white ( Aryan ) race. Which they viewed as superior to what they saw as physically and mentally weaker types. The Confederacy didn't have that situation, so they had earlier attempted to set one up of their own. In fact the Confederates didn't need to breed their version of Aryan dominance into existence, they ALREADY DEEMED the blacks to be inferior. and themselves to be their masters. That is white supremacy from both regimes, plain and simple. The nazis, with their contempt for human rights and dignity, targeted mainly Jews, the Confederacy targeted blacks There is no difference. About respecting and honouring the enemy - most wars are fought over political or hegemonic issues. The civil war was principally fought by the South over preserving and expanding slavery - that is a HUMANITARIAN issue. Oppressing and ill treating others is not a cause to be admired and memorialised. Those who do - like yourself evidently, are despicable. I notice you hardly say a word of sympathy and compassion for those blacks that were institutionally brutalised and degraded for many many decades. That is a common thread among Southern war apologists. It appears to indicate where their true sympathies lie. I'm aware the war was not all black and white. But it was undeniably fought over slaves and the South's "state's rights" to own them. There is ample evidence to show this. There were racists on both sides yes, but the difference is that the North realised their position was wrong and reformed their attitude accordingly, as did the rest of the world eventually. The abolitionist movement originated in the North. Why was there no growing clamour for abolition in the South ? The South started the war over their "right" to maintain and protect their "peculiar institution" as they called it. It was they that committed treason by seceding as well. A double insult. "...this war framed America and was a step forward to making our nation great. It was required,...". It was required because the South refused to change and become civilised. Even Britain had eliminated their slave trade before the civil war. It was indeed a "terrible affair". The lives of 600,000 Americans were lost unnecessarily. Good triumphed over evil in the end, and that was because of the efforts of the... North ! Why aren't you celebrating THAT fact, rather than paying sychophantic homage to those who unapologetically aimed to perpetuate that evil which consequently ripped the nation apart ?

[@MrIluvbutts]

Confederates were traitors and slavers. Despicable all, and their deaths to be celebrated.

[@Heystraw]

Nice job John. I had a battle map of the wheatfield and google maps to piece all of the information together.

[@Wyvern137]

My third Great Grandfather, Sgt William Evander Connell, Company I, Berrien County, 50th Georgia Infantry Regiment, was wounded during the Battle of the Wheat Field. I have found four Great Grandfathers who fought in the Civil War. William Evander was the only one to survive. I should probably visit the graves of the ones who died, before they are destroyed, for the sin of being on the wrong side of history.

[@eTraxx]

I need to put together a definitive list of where my ancestors fought. I know my2nd Great Grandfather fell at Kennesaw Mountain in GA but for others I only know they served.

[@counciousstream]

There isn't a wrong side of history. As long as the National Park Service exists (is funded) the history of Gettysburg will be preserved.

[@aruproy8793]

fantastic video.

[@lamichiganr326]

*Sickles was infuriating! He really screwed the pooch on that section of the battle.*

[@alzaidi7739]

Nice talk. Dramatic and still accurate.

[@JimJonesKoolaid]

These are amazing! Dream job!