Resident Evil - The BEST Jill Valentine Design?

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

So that's another weekly episode out the bag! Wonder how long I can keep this up for? Let me know what you thought in the comments section below! Next episode will be on Final Fantasy 7's Tifa Lockhart! PS. I left Tom Nooks name in the credits as he still hasn't given my girlfriend back. PLEASE GIVE HER BACK!

[@noobthro5630]

*PP MUSIC STARTS*

[@timmytommynook9296]

The ransom has changed yes yes, we require 2.5 million bells for your woman (woman) or another great character design video. Do not slander our grand CEO or her knee caps are next (next)

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

@@timmytommynook9296 ffs

[@actually-will1606]

Great video man! keep up the good work

[@TheBlueGhoul]

Could you do a Pac man character design video

[@alejandromolinac]

Might be an age thing..... I don’t get the “sexualized” angle.... those tube tops and cardigans were such a everyday staple of late 90’s girl attire.... and if the outbreak was “sudden”..... it would make sense she was dressed as a civilian......

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

There seems to be a pretty big diff between her in RE1 and 3, the outfit itself definitely isn't anything that crazy. But it felt like (to me at least) that the actual look all round was designed to make Jill more 'attractive'. Hence what I mean by sexualized, don't think it's too much of a stretch given the way Lara Croft was smashing through games during the same period lol.

[@alejandromolinac]

Like I said before.... must be an age thing.... I was in my early 20’s when this came out.... and she’s wearing clothes of the time.... you can KZbin Old Navy or Gap Commercials or any Teen Dramas .... she’s not even showing cleavage.....

[@alfriesmacdonalds5879]

@@alejandromolinac she was hot in the original RE3 though... I dont like the new Jill's face and she has doesn't have as big assets as her original. HAted RE5 version of her.

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

@@alejandromolinac Like I said before dude, it's about the way she's presented vs the exact specifics of what she's wearing. Don't think it's an age thing, but I'm not specifically speaking about the outfit. I'm speaking about the difference in design in general, her RE1 design did not feel like it was meant to be 'attractive' and RE3 felt like they were trying to! But fair play I was 9 when RE3 came out so. 😂

[@PlaystationSimmer]

While I didn't grow up in the 90's, looking at late 90's and early 2000's movies and other media, she fits right in

[@MugenLord]

Everyone keep talking about how impracticable her out was in RE3, but tend to forget that she was on her day off when the outbreak happened. She wasn't on duty at all, the outbreak happened suddenly so it makes sense why she would be in that outfit.

[@MugenLord]

@Oscar Coello How does Jill hold a laser cannon twice her size with that skinny frame of hers, at the end of the RE3 Remake to defeat nemesis? So now we have to leave realism for a jacket wrapped around her waist in a video game?

[@MugenLord]

@Oscar Coello she uses a big laser cannon at the end of RE3 Remake. Theres nothing buff about Jill's frame lol.

[@EvoSwatch]

@@MugenLord your statement is a little contradicting... its unrealistic for her to carry the railgun... but then you said its realistic for her to wear that old outfit because she is off duty? So should we think realistically or not?

[@MugenLord]

@@EvoSwatch No, I was arguing 2 points, why her classic outfit would work regardless what stance you take. If you want to say realistic then the reason for her outfit would be realistic because its an unexpected event that happen while she was in civilian clothing off duty. But if you want to argue that its unrealistic for her to wear it then you can argue that the entire game is unrealistic for the fact she can carry a last gun twice her size. So its stupid reason to drop her classic costume to begin with. But we now know the reason now. The designer recently admitted in an interview that they wanted to remove her sex appeal so she can be taken seriously. So wait, you mean the fan base behind Jill never took her seriously? So a woman isn't taken seriously if she have an ounce of sex appeal to her? Thats an insult and there are female gamers who feel insulted by that statement. Jill has been kicking since RE1 that's why people love her.

[@ryutavox]

Mugen Lord she got time to prepare her equipments during the intro of Re3 (original) but she didn’t change her clothes? That’s unrealistic tho and btw she wasn’t on day off she was suspended huge difference

[@buffysummers5828]

My favorite design will always be the RE1 remake! She looked exactly how I imagined the original Jill in RE1 and 3 looked if they were “real” if that makes sense. She didn’t look different to me, just her with more realistic looking high quality graphics.

[@solaris4019]

Yes...total agree , Julia Voth face is so beautiful.

[@purefoldnz3070]

sure it wasnt for the japanese jiggle physics?

[@RumitheBartender]

Julia! ❤

[@Despoina_Nyx]

My problem with the new design is that it feels derivative to a lot of modern female character design. She is a bit to similar to Lara Croft of the remakes. Like even if Claire's outfit in the past remakes still seemed too unispired (I feel that giving color to her Jacket logo would had help her pop out a bit) She feels at least separate from that design trend up until she takes out the jacket and is left with tank top and jeans going back to the same look like the rest.

[@decadentgamer3108]

That's a nice perspective. That's kinda how I feel with Claire's redesign in RE2. I personally loved her tacky outfit with the jean shorts worn over black spandex whereas her new outfit just made me think she looks like a grown up Ellie from The Last Of Us lol.

[@Despoina_Nyx]

@@decadentgamer3108 thinking about it I would perhaps use Jill's sweater in the new design with a blue t-shirt or something else. The bottoms are anither thing I don't have much problems with the jeans per se tho something with more of a military style would make more sense. At this point I just want some variety in charecter design, it's the whole white military guy with short/shaved hair version for female characters, it's ok to use it every once in a while but overuse it and characters start to feel the same as a whole. At the very least they need to understand that there are more types of tops than tanktops

[@decadentgamer3108]

@@Despoina_Nyx Yeah that is true and that's why Jill's first design worked as well as it did because the concept artist didn't like generic military looks and took the liberty to make Jill fit the profile without looking generic and ended up creating one of the most iconic looks in gaming history.

[@GideonFrost]

Remake Claire was basically Chloe from Left for Dead

[@Sofiaode18]

Yeah I feel like they kinda did the girls dirty with how generic they look.

[@homer_thompson5090]

The best version of Jill is the one between two slices of wheat bread.

[@steventan2754]

this is the only correct answer.

[@onyx7ven10en5]

2:49

[@duhsasjekirom555]

Is it a burger or is it a hot dog? No! It's S...

[@slaypa]

@@duhsasjekirom555 andwich:")

[@duhsasjekirom555]

@@slaypa indeed! 😁

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

PS. I did not mention Julia Voth in this video. I somehow missed that. I await the comments pointing this out and brace myself for the massacre.

[@cattusfattus6369]

Pin this

[@gabrielaaraujo4124]

Yeah bro, she's still the best Jill. Since zero.

[@arkhamfivehundred]

My favorite Jill design is her BSAA uniform in RE5's Lost In Nightmares mode. She looks older and more experienced, like she knows exactly what she's doing thanks to her experience in Raccoon City. Also, I love how it borrows some things from the STARS uniform from RE1, while still feeling unique.

[@riatorex8722]

She's also way hotter in RE5. Not sure if you dig it but well, you know

[@arkhamfivehundred]

@@riatorex8722 Oh, I totally agree! Nothing beats Jill with her classic Julia Voth face!

[@bombomos]

Agreed. It's hella good

[@Coffemore63]

Everyone: RE3 original Jill's costume is impractical and weird Me: my *favourite* of them all

[@Coffemore63]

@Thunder Life hell......yeah

[@silent_stalker3687]

Also them: Her carrying a 5-ton tail gun is completely practical and realistic

[@cay7809]

Ya can bring the costume with mods (there is dlc with the remake but there’s a fucking skort which is a skirt and short pants ya can fix it and put a actual skirt with mods)

[@cay7809]

She hot tho

[@Platinumshadow_153]

Agree and since Jill should not suppose to prepare for the outbreak and still rest in her apartment so she should wear comfortable design not full operating outfit.

[@naniorossi3067]

I might sound like a broken record when I say this, but, Julia Voth's face really suited Jill's personality. She's still beautiful now, so no shade on the new model. However, I always hated reboots of any kind of nature.

[@gabrielcaro]

I talked with her about if she was ever approached by Capcom to do the remake again. She said “Capcom never approached me about doing RE3 remake”, but she would have “loved to do it!” Would’ve been a dream come true for her.

[@riatorex8722]

I agree. I grew up playing the game with Julia's face on Jill's model. It's the one that I will always remember. Inezh was very good too

[@riatorex8722]

@@gabrielcaro Oof that sucks. I heard that it's because she's too old for the character (Julia is 37 while in the remake, Jill is around 24), which I can understand, but it's still pretty dumb honestly, because she's still stunning at her age

[@theHeartlessNooB]

She's no longer beautiful. She's acceptable at best, but ends up look disgusting because of the butch hairstyle.

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

Incorrect

[@AlexLeMonroeee]

I don't like how thay changed her face so drastically in RE3 Remake :(

[@JillValentine8908]

I agree with you 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@Dzzy123]

Her design in the RE3 remake reminds me too much of Lara Croft reboot.

[@GamerDude.23]

They changed her because they want her to be less attractive. It's a common thing nowadays. Female characters in video games and movies are made ugly and usually with terrible personalities.

[@GoodmansGhost]

Short answer to the video title: NO! Long answer: While it is far from her worst design, the tanktop and jeans combo is really, REALLY generic looking. In my opinion her best look is the one in Resident Evil 1, specifically the version from the remake.

[@Charles-jj2su]

I like how she looks in REV and 5 most, but I’m a sucker for tight bodysuits. Not a huge fan of her new design, but eh, mods can easily fix it.

[@stephenthedude4383]

Revelation Jills face looks like she got bad plastic surgery

[@freddyfazbear2056]

​@@stephenthedude4383 yes omg, the model itself it's fine But when it comes to the game....idk it just looks odd

[@sarcap878]

I love her in RE3, the first RE game I played and I did not really mind the changes that came with her design, she is still and will be my favorite RE character followed by Ada and Leon

[@PacoTheeTacoo]

I personally love the MVC2 design the most. It was my first introduction to Jill and it’s been the one I think of when I think Jill for years. I just love how expressive she is, she’s afraid when she summons the zombies, she’s relaxed when she’s won, she’s holding on for dear life when she used the bazooka! It’s all there and so fun, and personally I adore the cheesy voice lines in the game that don’t really fit lol. Second favorite would actually be the RE5 DLC look. I think it’s an updated take on what her job and seeing as she’s become less of a military cop and works in the shadows chasing after Wesker it makes sense that she would look more sleek.

[@cloud9afn971]

THIS is the comment I was gonna post too lol, I thought I was the only one who would mention Jill from MVC2. The cartoony version of her was my top favorite from all and the voice too lol. I was really hoping they would have at least brought her out in MVC3 too when It released but they never did unfortunately.

[@Razor-Blade]

I’m mixed on Jill’s new current model, her face is what is making me mixed but I like her outfit a lot. my favourite design of Jill is her RE1 remake. It may be just be the same as the original core design, the way they modelled her is what makes me love that version of her. Great video Mark! EDIT: I’ve watched my friend playthrough some of the game and I changed my mind on her face it suits her, well at least that version of her. I still prefer RE1 remake.

[@realamericannegro977]

Her face actually does match the original cgi design but they made her look angular. Due to how she is dressed. When she wears her offical police suit she looks perfect and has a round face.

[@Jose-se9pu]

The difference is the hair, in RE3 she had looooooooooong hair under the hat, in the remake they gave her her RE3 haircut.

[@CmdrShepard4Ever]

@@Jose-se9pu She had short hair in RE3 and wasn't wearing a hat

[@jondoe7036]

It's the eyes and nose that most bug me about the new design. Original Jill has this cute nacho nose, whereas in REmake3 she has this sharp fox nose, same as Claire and I just can't buy character as Jill without those striking clear blue orbs of hers; without them she is like Leon without a dorky hairdo.

[@Kordalicious]

I think RE remake and Re5 had the best face for Jill I really dislike this Jill

[@Mr.JayJayGaming24]

REmake 1 has the best design hands down.

[@riatorex8722]

RE1 remake Jill is still my personal favourite. The outfit is so iconic, and the actual character itself is perfection. Cute, smart and sleek, the perfect counterpart to the Shonen manga hero that is Chris Redfield. For the face design, I do feel like Julia Voth really has that quintessential late 90s to early 2000s pin-up look to her, which is exactly how Jill Valentine should be. And as a side note, they also share the same initials

[@ailmen]

I don't like her new outfit in RE3 remake. It's way too much like one of the new Lara croft's outfits it's a costume that doesn't feels like a "Jill valentine exclusive look". Example: If a cosplayer wears this outfit in a convention you only can tell if it is a Lara or Jill cosplay just by looking the cosplayer hairstyle, thats how bland the new costume is.

[@ailmen]

@Oscar Coello Yes, I remember perfectly Lara´s classic outfit from tomb raider 1,2 & 3 (1996). If you put side by side lara from 1,2 & 3 and Jill from RE (1999), people can tell which character is who, even witout seeing both of their faces, here is no longer the case. In reality the new outfit is so unimaginative that just by adding a ponytail hairstyle to jill (like the one she uses in revelations) turns her 90% in lara croft. Just watch the ouffit from tomb raider 2013 and watch RE3 remake Jill outfit, swaping the characters heads barely do any change.

[@maiseree1511]

@@ailmen Jill has a white undershirt and more belts and holsters, and hers is a more vibrant shade of blue. I think it differentiates well enough

[@thevenom2731]

@@maiseree1511 Exactly, RE3 Remake Jill looks different enough from Lara Croft. It feels like people are bored from quarantine and are just looking for things to nitpick and bitch about.

[@diligentone-six2688]

I kinda like the tank-top since that it resembles actual survival.

[@lovenala1987]

@@thevenom2731 You do realise that people can criticise the design and dislike it just as how others appreciate it right? It's bold of you to assume that this is just petty nitpicking due to quarantine. The new Jill costume is pretty bland in my opinion as well because its just not "Jill" for me. I am not against new inventions or designs but the tank top is the most basic of the basic designs and it isn't anything interesting. Maybe the only different thing about it would be the white shirt underneath but imo, it serves little purpose to present this design as something new or innovative. If they were going for something more 'relatable' well, a tank top is not the only option. I will not say that if we swap Lara Croft with Jill, it would be the same. I disagree in that. But I will say that the tank top reminded me of Lara Croft as well because playing both games, the tank top has sort of become Lara Croft's identity now. She is among the most famous characters in the gaming world that wears it and it's like her signature look. That does not mean other game characters cannot wear a tank top but that does not mean it will not remind others of Lara Croft. Comparisons will be made and from a creative perspective, it can look bland to others. If some gamers want Jill to have her own new innovative costume (or the classic one) and if some gamers think this tank top is just not for her, what's so wrong about that? If I made up my mind to play this remake, I don't expect it to be just a copy-paste from the classic but I also don't expect it to be 'different' with the most basic stuff. For a remake like this, I will not only consider the gameplay/graphics/etc but also the visual designs of each character. So, give me something more broader than a tank top or just give me the old outfit. And thankfully, Capcom did give us the old outfit through DLC so I was glad about it. You like the new design? That's fantastic. You do you! However, I don't think there is anything wrong for not liking it at all. In the end, we can agree to disagree.

[@noizusagi6901]

Her face model for 5 is the same face model as the original. To say that her face looks drastically different is obviously a big stretch. Her hair is blonde and she got paler skin but she still looks like Jill. As compared to the 360 makeover they did in RE3 remake. Let's not even. I'm a year late buuh 🥺 Edit: and in revelations her face looks botched as fuuc...

[@hotnessgaming1396]

I like her original design way more. New one’s kinda growing on me but the original RE3 was too perfect

[@12ealDealOfficial]

Same here. Loved her proportions and her face. Had a sophisticated look about her.

[@tardistime6857]

I quit like her design in revelations . Nothing can beat the original design though.

[@duhsasjekirom555]

Revelations was one of my fav.

[@விஷ்ணு_கார்த்திக்]

Jill = Shoulder Pads Leon = The Jacket Chris = Green Tactical Vest Barry = Red Tactical Vest They did a good of keeping Chris,Leon&Barry's appearances consistent but they got rid of the shoulder pads for Jill. Also, i would be suing Capcom if i was jill's face model lmao, they made her look ugly

[@PrinzeDemagio]

விஷ்ணு கார்த்திக் Clair red jacket

[@Uragaking]

Wesker's Black Glasses

[@matthewlugo2417]

For people who forget jill was off duty and dressed to either go clubing or shopping with friends which is the damn point, would u be wearing ur uniform if an actual zombie apocalypse broke out? No no u wouldnt, its why re3 outfit is iconic

[@12ealDealOfficial]

I prefer her original RE3 design in those promotional renders. Same with Code Veronica Chris and RE2 Claire. They looked like real people without looking "gritty" or extra thicc. Chris wasn't on roids, Claire looked her age, Jill looked sophisticated.

[@negan6735]

Short answer: Yes Long answer: Mostly yes, but I think my favorite look isn’t just RE3make, but...(slight spoiler) • • • • • • • • 3remake Jill with the Stars outfit. It looks amazing

[@erickchristian1970]

@Solomon Guile jill is perfect in this game bro...

[@monojuice]

Solomon Guile ugly face? Nah you capping

[@AdoringFan....]

@Solomon Guile pfttt weabo like 2d Jill

[@zackfair6791]

It's okay but not the best. Something is off about the new design. I think it's the hair.

[@thevenom2731]

@Solomon Guile Ugly face? Have you seen the RE5 design?!

[@chainmail5886]

RE1, Remake and RE3 Origoinal Jill: Sleek, Smart, Warm, Talented woman. Compensates her lack of physical strength with intellgence. Cute and Sexy. Respected by men and women. RE3 Remake Jill: Generic Female Action Hero Cold Hearted Mary Sue that Picks up a heavy rail cannon which makes Chris's boulder look stupidily light. Mocked by most.

[@riatorex8722]

Yeah, I'm with you on this one. RE3 remake Jill feels too badass for her own good. I mean, yes she's a professional, but she's not meant to be this self-sufficient supercop with inhuman strength capable of lifting a goddamn rail gun. Not yet. This is still 1998 Jill, not the bullet-dodging, mind-controlled quasi-BOW in 2009 with thighs so thicc she can snap people's necks with them

[@hdb1975]

mary sue? arent all the resident evil characters overpowered at some point?

[@UnifiedEntity]

Jills original Re3 outfit with the "impractical" comment. I feel it adds to situation coming out of nowhere and blind siding EVERYONE and that no one was prepared. New Design is kinda bland.

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

Think they are both good for different reasons to be honest! Like I say I like the RE3 original design, but can get behind the new look as well as the alternate costume.

[@Aalijah_Matyevna]

Exactly bro. Like why would you stay at home with tank top, jeans and combat boots. Like it's obvious no one expected it. Jill wearing an off duty outfit makes more sense.

[@Platinumshadow_153]

Why people try to say "RE3 original Jill's costume is impractical and weird", from the original and remake of RE3, you can see that everything is happened by surprise. Jill should not suppose to prepare for the outbreak and still rest in her apartment. It should be in comfortable outfit and she need to remove her outer vest to move comfortable. I hate the "make sense" outfit since no one will sleep when wear the jeans. so tank top with outer clot, short/skirt are making sense more than wear 2 shirt with jeans when rest in the apartment Also, the original blue RE1 cloth is great since she is a police not soldier so keep the blue colour design is great.

[@1stNumberOne]

I would LOVE to see what they can do with a fixed camera style RE like the GameCube remake. The graphics were FAR ahead of its time. I think it’s because of the fixed camera angle, they were able to detail the environment so much better..

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

100% the fixed angles really helped make that game look incredible

[@Kev_Stars]

How unfortunate that Jill has become part of the Generic Tank top & Jeans Combo Bad Girls Club.

[@picolete]

"Does Resident Evil 3 Remake have the BEST Jill Valentine Design?" Short answer: no Long answer: nope

[@jaypond4368]

I like her design from 2009 on (re5, Revelations etc) . Shes thick, yet not too over the top sex appeal, and still cool looking. Now with re3 remake, will have to have this generic instagram model Jill forever.

[@NoMoreHeroes75]

Remake 1 will always be the best

[@Renegade77784]

Best answer: HELL FUCKING NO LOL. They really overdo it with CGI and facial recognition. I like when they have more of that emo anime look to the characters. Square enix gets it.

[@jaypond4368]

@Caio Coelho RE 5 Untold Story DLC Jill is the same. But regardless, From 09 onward Jill's overall body shape / face / bust are the same. The clothing changed, and once her hair turned blond, but its the same consistent design.

[@goxy287]

@@NoMoreHeroes75 Agreed. Re3 remake #notmyjill xdd

[@weightycarlos]

Her S.T.A.R.S. outfit is the best for me. It's sooo iconic.

[@JuneieBack]

I think Jill just always looks best in a uniform.

[@fadetoblack40k]

I think her original costume fits better for Jill. She's a feminine woman who shows it through her appearance and has always had a motherly sense of attitude and personality. While her remake appearance also fits well and was still caught off guard when she was off duty from work, and had no issues with looking pretty and beautiful. Now in the remake it just looks like they gave her the Lara Croft remake treatment.

[@ladylaracroft9647]

Jill’s re3 outfit was completely practical. She wasn’t expecting the zombie outbreak to happen as fast as it did, she was in more casual clothing because of this. Once Jill noticed zombies had started taking over it was too late. She had to leave her apartment RIGHT AWAY. She didn’t have time “oh what’s practical for me to wear right now” zombies took over her apartment and like I said she had to GO. So storyline wise the outfit completely makes sense regardless of your personal feelings towards the outfit. And in remake the outfit also would’ve made complete sense as well because close to the original it happens literally in the blink of an eye with a twist this time nemesis showing up to her apartment. That design is iconic.

[@ladylaracroft9647]

Btw putting on a pair of pants doesn’t help how insanely re3 remake is unreleastic. Like she doesn’t become a bad ass because she put on pants. She isn’t able to survive a rocket launcher just because she has on pants now.

[@ladylaracroft9647]

And on top of that those are more skinny jeans. Those are not really ideal to have on if you need to go go go.

[@Therealopgaming]

Unpopular opinion: BSAA Jill Valentine is one of the bad ass costume, totally reflects on her since she's a bad ass because of all the things she been through.

[@aidenphire9794]

My fav outfit

[@JohnSmith-tt1nh]

They didn't even try with her redesign. They just made her look like modern Lara Croft to be as inoffensive as possible. That's not how good character designs are made. The very least they could have done is give her a white belt or something to keep the original color scheme in tact.

[@slaypa]

oof i think i'm the only one who like Jill's in the new remake's :')

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

I like her too! Think both the original and remake have their own charms tbh.

[@slaypa]

@@ArtistMarkFlynn true true ♡

[@mariapazgonzalezlesme]

The toilet paper joke omg. Those are my thoughts about few of Jill Valentine's characters designs. First, her S.T.A.R uniform from RE. It's simple yet practical. While it not realistically militar as you mentioned, I think the color gaves flavor to her design, since blue is a color usually connected with the police. And the remaster, just made it better. Second, her outfit from RE3. It's impractical. However, it adds charm to her design and highlights to her feminity. Her RE: Revelations outfit looks like an entire suit. However, it reminds more of a spy aesthetic than an actual soldier. And finally the RE3 Remake design. Her outfit still retains the famous blue, however, it's practical, simple and suits better for the situation. On few occasions, I noticed that Jill's short hairstyle tends to change from left to right. It doesn't add more significance, it's only a little detail that I wanted to point out. Otherwise, either short or long hair suits her anyways.

[@watwat3682]

I honestly think that the arguments about practicality are a bit silly. Especially in a game where people survive impossible to survive things in cutscenes ( which makes it canon ) and it's not like it's a medieval setting where people fight with swords in armor xD. I can understand that it doesn't fit her character in the remake, but I mean Ada is wearing a dress and heels in RE2R. The fact that Ada wears heels alone ( and her dress is quite tight too ) is actually genuinely impractical and unrealistic. But it didn't make it any worse or Ada a weaker character, if anything I think that it just added to her character and the fact that it was impractical doesn't really matter. And it does make arguments about what is and isn't practical or impractical come across as a bit silly to me, because it clearly doesn't matter in this series. The only way in which Jill's original outfit in RE3 is really impractical tho is that there would be a lot of upskirts going on with the different camera angles and it doesn't fit the tone of the character ( it still works with Ada tho ). I dunno tho, it kinda just annoys me when people talk about practicality in a way. Because I think that this excessive obsession with '' practicality '' leads to very boring and samey character designs in games with realistic graphics. Ada's design would be way less interesting if she had to be wearing '' practical '' clothes. Sometimes style over function is just more interesting, and ultimately it's a video game meant for entertainment and not a simulator or real life. I get what a lot of people are saying about the tone and Jill as a character specifically, but every time I hear the word '' impractical '' I can't help but to think that people don't actually care about it for real. Because if they did they'd be going on about it with Ada but everyone seems to have totally forgotten about her and never talked about her wearing heels at all. But suddenly now it's a subject people are talking about? It just seems insanely selective to me, and I don't think that an outfit being '' practical '' or not makes it inherently better or worse in a game. It has no impact on aesthetics imo.

[@realamericannegro977]

Yet her remake suit makes zero sense because how would she have know an outbreak would happen. Her original part 3 costume made way more sense and sold the scenario way better.

[@realamericannegro977]

@@watwat3682 at the end of the day the old games sold the outbreak narrative better because ever character looked like they were caught up in a situation they never saw coming.

[@aagh8714]

@@realamericannegro977 shes wearing normal clothes in remake

[@lostandtravellingwhentimes9260]

Easily my favourite design of hers is the re5 dlc version.

[@lethalButters]

I think all her designs look great. Favorite clothes are RE1 Remake and RE3 Remake. Best face and personality is RE1 Remake. My problem with RE3 Remake is they changed her personality and I really don't like how she's depicted in that game.

[@flygonkerel781]

the RE1 remake appearance is objectively the best.

[@Shishizurui]

1999 RE3 design for sure~ personality wise they really do a good job with progressing her being a very heartfelt character that sees umbrella as monsters for doing this to the ppl of raccoon city. ok so back when the game was new I was 12, I questioned her outfit choice too. but it makes sense back then a friend told me look at what the zombies are wearing its probably very hot. and it makes more sense as i've gotten older shes a 23,24 year old woman, just because shes a badass stars operative doesn't mean that it has to overwrite her wanting to be sheek, she was probably getting dirt on Umbrella as the city went to shit so it would make sense that she would try to blend in, operation racoon city jill looks pretty too. New 2020 jill looks like a Rip off of new Tombraider with an alpha bitch atttiude RE5 jill is a joke

[@ShoryukenThatHadoken]

New. Vothfans were going to be loyal no matter what. Jill has to strike a delicate balance between "eyecandy" and "believably recruited into an elite tactical rescue team". RE3make is the only one to strike that balance.

[@DanielGonzalez-qq7gh]

I first encountered Jill in RE5 so that’s the design I associate her with

[@GenerationWest]

I'm in love her design with those Jill renders, they're just top notch, and for RE3 remake, as much as i like it too, my first initial response was "Hey, that's a fusion of Mila Jovovich and Kate Bosworth" and no one can tell me otherwise lol

[@kaeuiir1024]

Re1 remastered jill was the best looking I loved that one. About this one I am gonna say it is near the bottom of the list

[@Kleigen]

"Which Jill design is better?........" *Insert BOTH IS GOOD Meme* Period.

[@Mandalore.The.Hero7]

Julia Voth is the best Jill face model of all time period 💯

[@louismessina9163]

What Jill wears in Resident Evil 3 is supposed to be impractical though...she's not on duty and has to suddenly escape. Given her design in re1, I think it's fair to say she generally cares about looking good. Her stars uniform isn't out of place, but stands out as being a bit more fashion-y than the others and reflects her personality. Her wearing normal clothes in resident evil 3 gives this extra sense of dread and reminds you the entire time that the player/Jill is not really prepared or equipped for this. It's reminds you that the events are messing with her life. The outfit isn't out of the ordinary either. Like I said she clearly cares a bit more about fashion, and what she wears is just generally slightly fashion-y and trendy for the time

[@flygonkerel781]

RE5 jills appearance MAKES SENSE and her face is similar to her RE1 remake model

[@merritt2014]

Her Revelations 1 design is pretty underrated.

[@lssjgaming1599]

I like her original Re3 outfit because it’s the one I wanna cosplay most and it also shows her as a bit more human in a way by wearing more normal clothing

[@WebstersYouTube]

There was a big change to her facial features for the Gamecube remake that I really didn't like. Her face went from narrow, petite, and almost cat-like, to this broader, more square-jawed, and in my view less attractive model. I actually really like her model in Operation Raccoon City and I'm not thrilled with the remake version's hair. I always saw Jill as being quite straight laced, confident, and refined, but her latest portrayal is more rebellious, punk rock, and rough 'n' ready.

[@martinlayne5612]

The uniform given as a pre order bonus is not the same. She wares a pants skirt and not the original skirt

[@Cruxis_Angel]

REmake Jill is just the best. Some games just perfected the design of these characters. Similar with RE4 Leon. When you think of these characters you imagine those interpretations

[@KonEl17]

She had real model faces before the remake of 3 buddy, Julia Voth and Amra Silajdzic

[@TheHalloweenSpirit]

Best Designs: 1. RE 1 Remake 2. RE 3 Nemesis 3. RE 3 Remake 4. Revelations Worst Design: RE 5 Blonde Look

[@goddamnarshia]

Everything from Re:remake imo. I don't dislike her re3 remake design...but i can't unsee that she looks like the karens of the world from certain angles

[@joeblack3623]

The new Jill in the RE3 remake is gorgeous. That is my pick.

[@KyudoKun]

I don't know about you, but I still love the OG RE3 Jill.

[@nachofernandezcomics5238]

The face modelling based on Julia Voth had a lot of charisma. This new one looks so generic, so boring....

[@comicking428]

While we're on Capcom characters, I think Ryu may be a character worth analyzing. The changes aren't drastic, but hes been in so many games and crossovers that he's worth having a look.

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

I definitely want to go more into capcom in general. There are so many great characters from street fighter and megaman alone!

[@RtistiqSkubie]

@@ArtistMarkFlynn the mere fact Capcom can't decide what Ryu hair color is is enough to talk about him. His only other noticable changes are hair style & what gloves he wears.

[@chocov1233]

I like RE1 and it's remakes' design the most, it's the most unique. RE3 is pretty cool/cute too, but I wish that you had the option to put on the white jacket, it would make the outfit come together.

[@josephf5393]

I think Jill was perfectly done in RE3 Remake. She’s traumatized from the previous events at the Spencer Mansion and is on a mission to destroy umbrella. She doesn’t seem overpowered but she’s smart and capable of defeating Nemesis.

[@chainmail5886]

Nah. Chris was equally as traumtized and didn't change character till like RE6.

[@MEDDlNO]

Makes me sad that you’re not very fond of Jill’s RE5 Design, because I think it’s her best one. I like how they kept the blue and added a baseball cap in exchange of her beret and a ponytail

[@lucianobruzzone537]

Resident Evil 1 remake Jill = Ultimate waifu

[@nemesis3587]

Best version Remake Jill (Julia Voth face). My second favorite is Revelations ( that wet suit is so good). I didn't like that new desing. I really didn't understand how it looks worse than that actual face model. And costume is generic as hell. I didn't understand these practical or realistic arguments. It is a video game about zombies and creatures, who really cares about realistic look. Just desing something creative. Was Ada's RE4 costume practical or realistic? No way. Was original RE3 Jill outfit practical or realistic? No way. But they were creative, good looking and turned iconic now.

[@souseiseki90]

Sad thing is, with few modification, the original re 3 costume can be modified to look more practical without changing its original look. Keep the blue crop top, change skirt into skort or shorts, keep the boots, add a little bit of armor and gear like in re1 alternate costume, Julia Voth face, done. They should do that instead of changing entirely.

[@dillankempter5780]

I always hated the Revelations design of Jill because instead of the Lara Croft style outfit in RE3make, she has the Lara Croft style haircut which has been and always will be the most basic video game female haircut ever

[@BellowDGaming]

I got two words "Julia Voth"

[@noizusagi6901]

🙌🏻🙌🏻

[@merdicmagic6171]

nutted

[@BellowDGaming]

lol

[@noizusagi6901]

@Cyberdemon Mike not at all

[@ShizzThe69kinG]

BellowD Gaming ayeeee Katsuragi, you get a thumbs up from me just for that avatar alone

[@daffaagung]

For me, the first RE Remake has the best Design. I don't know, her being gullible despite looking so pretty is kinda cute

[@VluMandamientoXIII]

I just wish we had the RE1 or RE revelations Jill . She’s my favorite female character

[@Al_Pantalone]

Her face from RE1 remake is what I miss the most

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

Yep definitely my fave face of hers!

[@elektra8535]

I like most of her designs Even the kinda hated re3 remake design while the look is generic it's like the 2546 time we see a brave/badass woman in a tank top and jeans but it works, Lara croft, Sarah Connor, claire in the remake, Ellie Even sheva already had that design but it works the only problem is that it is generic after the abuse of it

[@2l84me8]

Both versions of Jill are beautiful. Though I may be a bit more bias toward Julia Voth’s design.

[@riatorex8722]

I'm all for Julia's model. Sasha is fine, not great for me personally

[@AvaCassandraYT]

i am OBSESSED with character design like this, and resident evil, so this video is an absolute Treat for me Curious on your opinion of the updated STARS outfit in the re3 remake now that its been out a week

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

Think it looks pretty cool! Bit jarring seeing the new face model with it though! Lol

[@darksiders2002]

STARS, B.S.A.A. and Battlesuit are the best for me. RE3 original is pretty nice too, but remake is absolute miss (nicer way to say I hate it).

[@genjibenkei]

I like Original and RE3 Jill. This new one looks good also. Didn’t care much for her RE5 version

[@xeox4280]

The resident evil 1 design is the best one. The original.

[@daltonweakly]

I hope we get more RE characters soon

[@christianordonez9231]

I grew up playing all of resident evil games, my first introduction to the series was the original Resident Evil Nemesis and back in the days I did have this crush with Jill haha. Every time I think of Resident Evil, Jill is the first protagonist that comes to my mind. If I have to say I totally agree with you, the best version of Jill was from REmake. The face of Julia Voth makes her soo beautiful, but still they gave us this badass protagonist which fits perfectly in the S.T.A.R.S team. As well they did gave us the custom from resident evil 3, by far my favourite Jill design.

[@sygyzy0933]

You do know her face was modeled after Julia voth from the 1 remake up until this new remake right?

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

Yeah someone else has pointed that out. I can't believe it is! Looks so different to me lol guess the blonde hair was too distracting for me to cope with

[@riatorex8722]

Not quite. They changed her face model for Revelations

[@genesis2697]

Julia voth is Jill valentine

[@UbeMDC]

I liked every version so I don’t mind which one they’ll stick with in the next RE games

[@baynemarrowe2003]

I like her new outfit because it's practical but I'm a bit unsettled with her face. Capcom really was trying to feature its face capturing technology here but atleast they could have kept a few features of jill from past games. One thing i kinda hoped from her face design is an emphasis on her Jap/French features. Most of her designs are all Caucasian but no Asian whatsoever.

[@Hero_Of_Old]

I was worried you were going to slate the new design, I'm glad you didnt. I'm new to the series, the RE3 remake design is my favourite, the REmake being my second favourite.

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

I can definitely understand if people don't like it but nah it's not worth slating. The game looks gorgeous and I'm surprised to see people so up in arms about it. Lol

[@ultimate_savage190]

Julia Voth is Jill Valentine, and Jill Valentine is Julia Voth.... PERIOD ! there can be no other replacement. this new model is not Jill, and never will be ! that is why i have it on PC so i can have the real deal. thank you modding community !

[@MrMarioschannel]

Could you could critique Solid Snake's or Big Boss's design evolution over the years for one of your vids? Keep up the great work love the series and contact man!

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

Super keen to do a snake episode down the road! Just not sure when yet!

[@Shelf0808]

She looks best in the original REmake, and also in re3 1999

[@allisonfields3108]

I really love Julia Voth, but I'm so confused about all the complaints I've seen about the new Jill model from long time series purists. I think she's super hot, but maybe it's just me lmao

[@Coreisus]

Allison Fields its not about being hot its about looking like herself. We have 2 decades of media content showing her face with specific dimensions... now she's got a completely different jaw

[@shorewall]

@@Coreisus Exactly.

[@riatorex8722]

Julia Voth is way hotter for me. But the nostalgia of growing up with that face as Jill is really what seals the deal for me. Sasha is alright

[@Onmysheet]

RE3 original had the best design of Jill, in looks, voice and attire. In following games they just kept changing her appearance.

[@leroidethunes3913]

remember when Julia Voth was Jill's face model and not a random russian? good times... i agree Re:Remake Jill's model is the best one, like Re4's Leon, don't really know what the hell Capcom's doing to it's characters :(

[@Chris_M_Romero]

The RE 5 dlc outfit it's by far the best one. I can't help but think of Julianne Moore's character in _Next_ . That outfit really sells the explosives expert turned anti-BOWs activist persona. And just in case you didn't know, none of her outfits "sexualises" her, and even it did, there's nothing wrong with sexualizing her. Nothing a man likes is wrong. Feminism bad, men good 👍

[@MetalheadSean666]

Resident evil 3’s original design has always been my favourite

[@analothor]

RE3R Jills face is just too different than the consistency we've been shown before hand

[@samjuniordimok]

At 7:33 that is the costume at the end of the RE3 remake game, where she takes the broken vaccine bile shot by Nickolai. Its either Jill or Rebecca.. What do you guys think...

[@Belbecat]

Yasss I just cannot for the life of me understand why RE:Make is so underrated by the masses yet anyone who has played it will always rank it as the best game in the whole series. Need Silent Hill to get onboard and man, if they can hit the same spots as RE:Make the world will once again remember what true horror is, and that is much scarier than bloody jump scares and monsters with goopey long tongues, clowns or half naked dudes with big swords...

[@sleepycowboy18]

"less like pouting victoria beckham" im 💀

[@ArtistMarkFlynn]

🤣

[@tillcest]

They should really make a “Jill Sandwich” Costume for Jill

[@re2fan123]

While I like all the Jill costumes I still have to go with her lost in nightmares outfit I do like that one more than her original stars uniform or her tube top outfit I think it's the hat