Robin Gibb (Live 2004) with The Neue Philarmonie Frankfurt Orchestra

[@anna-rexia]

A voice like Robin's didn't need all of this pomp. Personally for me his voice alone, unplugged, is only what all of us Robin Gibb fans ever needed to hear.

[@kenhartman6237]

Hi Anna 👋 How are you doing?

[@chayafuerst9246]

They are drowning Robin out! "Hello everyone, thank you for coming." Nice!

[@kenhartman6237]

@@chayafuerst9246 Oh ok Chaya. Where are you from?

[@estrellaasikainen4679]

202I April love team Watching Europé OFW Tanxs Beegess Brother Steel Number One in Our Heart 💖 💞 ☝ ☝ ☝ 👍 👍 👍 👍 💖 ❤ 🙇 🙏 👼 Always AMEN. ..

[@mariauller9562]

Q⁰ Gratulation

[@wendydubois3872]

Robin looked so happy to be singing, that was when he seems to be at his happiest especially singing solo.🐦🎶

[@ilariaenrico4742]

❤

[@estelacobas4416]

Es verdad, se ve feliz cantando solo, lo anulaba Barry!

[@erikareid9528]

Robin was a one off, I’ve watched this video so many times,he looked so happy going solo. Love and miss him ❤❤❤

[@bessmulholland5805]

Either that,or a false front❤😊

[@IsabelMonardes]

PORQUE FALSA ?? ES NUESTRO GRANDIOSO ROBIN HACIENDO LO QUE MÁS AMABA !!! LA MÚSICA ERA LA PASIÓN DE LOS TRES HERMANOS MARAVILLOS !!! GRANDE ROBIN !!!💋💔🌹🎵💔❤🎵🎵🌹

[@theresabrown1272]

I love when Robin smiles. He’s usually serious . Barry and Mo smile a lot , especially Barry. Robin absolutely lights up when he smiles. Miss him and Maurice so much

[@Gizella2010]

@theresabrown1272 Too much laughing and smiling can also be interpreted as nervousness, which Robin never suffered from. He was a natural at whatever he did. Robin's smile could melt mountains of ice. Robin was a wonderful person. R.I.P Robin

[@Flosy29Vera]

I don't get it when you separate the three brothers & pull them apart from one another even when they've died assuming this & that, God Almighty planned it that way, as brothers so that they are near they're near another so that they can pool their minds hearts & souls together to compose the what now have been the musical masterpieces, God - given for the listening pleasure of humanity for infinity. They couldn't have done that much if they were separated entitiés. This you've got to realize. I love them three + Andy and their music. Why not just enjoy their music? Me? I play their songs to background my activities, yes, even when I go to sleep.

[@Gizella2010]

@@Flosy29Vera That's you! But you can't decide that the rest of us should be too. Yes, they played well together, but they still had their own sides, their own skills, they were not cast in the same mold, neither you nor YOUR GOD can take that away from them. And whether you understand or not, a lot of the rest of us will differ, but of course you can do what you want, with or without YOUR GOD!!

[@debmcpartland9528]

I have read some terrible things about Robin and it is none of peoples Bisness Robin wasnt weird he was Dedicated and a Musical Genius and had the most Beautiful and Diverse Voices Noone will come close to him. And he was a kind and honourable man. I know from experience. It was 1989 in Melbourne Australia for the One concert. After the concert my parents and I lined up to meet the Bee Gees. We had different preferences My Dad lined up for Barry My mum loved Maurice and me I was a fan of Robins. Someone behind pushed forward and I fell. I started to cry I was 13 at the time and I didnt want Robin to see. Anyway I felt someone pull me to my feet and it was Robin. He was so concerned if I was ok. He told me to stand to 1 side and I thought I wasnt going to get his Autograph. I heard him say to security to go and Get something and It was a special one LP. He personally signed it with my name. I have never forgotten a big star like Robin was so kind to a child like he was to me. And I still have that LP to this day. And I cried when I heard of his death. He was 1 of a kind and I will miss you.

[@tiffanywagner8027]

❤️

[@raewynturei5382]

What a gift, you will always treasure. Robin being the caring Gentleman👍

[@carminabarrios5676]

You are lucky man years ago lucky child

[@Renata.06]

Que lindo isso, eu fui descobrir o grande cantor que ele foi só ano passado. Só escutava as músicas mais dançantes e cantadas pelo Barry Gibb.

[@estelacobas4416]

Que cosas horribles escuchaste de Robin! Tendrías que decir el nombre de esa persona que habla mal de el,! Te felicito por conocerlo, fue muy bueno contigo,ningún artista hace eso, que recuerdo hermoso,!

[@katabaticblast6121]

No matter how alone or how lonely, a true artist must perform, needs to perforrm. One brother passed on, the other brother drowning his sorrows in front of his television, and here is brave Robin singing his heart out, doing what he loves most in the world to satisfy his soul. Heartbreaking and beautiful at the same time. One man carrying the load of three.

[@susannewade6915]

This is incredible how I enjoyed it Robin you're an angel in heaven I bet your parents are thankful to be so blessed

[@foreverealm]

Grief is a very private, individual thing. If you are a person that gets your energy replenished by being around others (regardless of how quiet, shy, or gregarious you are), then you are more comfortable on a stage with a crowd. You can also be congenial and fun, but if you are a person that needs “alone” time to replenish energy, then you will definitely need to retreat when you are grieving. Being surrounded by strangers that want you to perform for them might be the last thing you need to heal. There is nothing wrong with either M.O.; we don’t “choose” how we naturally get drained or replenished; it’s an innate temperament thing. I don’t think when an immediate family member dies (and with them, 1/3 of your band), that anything is owed the public. A true extrovert must surround themselves with people to heal; a true introvert desperately needs to cave to heal. And true artistry exists across the temperaments. With respect.

[@patriciatolliver4057]

​@@susannewade6915He's carrying it well. I think he puts a different light on the songs without his brothers.

[@HeatherMyfanwyTylerGreey]

Robin once said that Maurice's legacy was their music. He must have seen honouring Maurice was to bring his work to the world. Robin rarely smiled when he sang with the Bee Gees Maurice was the clown - here he rarely stopped smiling.Perhaps he was feeling Mo very close indeed.

[@verarobertson4395]

The instruments over powering the singing.

[@heleng3973]

Robin‘s voice does not need background singers or a loud orchestra. Just his smile is worth to see it.

[@L.M.O.]

@ HELEN G I agree about the back-up singers. His voice is just enough. However, Robin produced this entire cut of this album. That decision would of went through Robin. I also agree the orchestra was too loud, drowning out Robin' s voice. These are matters we can not understand. For some reason Robin seemed to want others to carry his voice. Perhaps it has something to do with the timing!! I believe this performance was cut into an album. This would have been the following months after he lost his best friend, his twin brother Maurice. He may have feared he could not hold it together, and was covering himself in case he couldn't. Let' s cut Robin a little slack. Thank you for understanding. 🤔

[@paulinehorne4150]

The talent shows through every time🎵🎶👍🏻👍🏻💗

[@elainekhouri278]

I agree with Helen G., just to see Robin so happy is worth the. concert, plus his beautiful voice. He finally had a chance to shine in his own light. How much we miss you, beloved Robin!! RIP!

[@leahelam6073]

He really is precious.

[@paolameoni4693]

Memorabile gruppo bravissimo anche da solista

[@paulinehorne4150]

I watched Robin with the Frankfurt Orchestra over & over again he put his heart & soul into every song being on the stage that long with no break could not be easy the audience was with him all the way he deserves every standing ovation he got Miss you Robin

[@PaulaSmith-dj9bq]

He could not let is first wife go

[@PaulaSmith-dj9bq]

And she was with him on is right hand

[@maryloubuoymaster889]

@@PaulaSmith-dj9bq.what$”😮?????!

[@terriholliday8038]

Yes, miss you Robin!

[@mariliapereira9282]

O melhor de todos ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@ednamiranda5930]

It is now 2020 in a covid 19 pandemic. I am a physician and to take away my stress I always listen to the Bee Gees before I sleep. I love Robin and his brothers. They are not only good singers but good people as well.

[@spiderreed350]

Ain't going nowhere, somebody help me...

[@elainekhouri278]

It is so great to see Robin so happy, performing his own concert!! About time he could shine by himself! It warms my heart!!

[@ednalandingin1728]

Its alteady 2022. Pandemic is almost done.election is here in our country and war is starting in ussr to Ukraine. Still listening to the bee gees! What a fantastic group.

[@L.M.O.]

@ EDNA MIRANDA It is now 2022 in the Covid 19 pandemic. THANK YOU for your service being a physician. Your position always carries much drama, chaos, and stress. Especially in these last 2 yrs. with Covid. My hat goes off to you. THANK YOU AGAIN. Thank you also for your comment post. Your words, "They are good singers and good people as well". They certainly are. I couldn' t agree with you more.It's"phenomenal" that their music is comforting and relaxing, helping you to sleep. Your probably not listening to "Saturday Night Fever" tracks before retiring for the night! 😂 😎🤣 That' s great music, but not relaxing and retiring music to 💤with! Keep enjoying The Bee Gees, they are one talented group.

[@ednamiranda5930]

Thank you for taking time to read my reply. I am a big fan of Mr. Robin Gibb and his three brothers. Before I sleep I always listen to his songs on you tube though I heared them alot of times before. I feel relax and entertain everytime I listen to him. God bless him and all of you guys who are keeping his music alive.

[@christineh13]

Robin's voice is a millennial voice that will not be found again soon. His brothers are also fantastic singers. I love the Bee Gees to the end of my days🌹🌹

[@vilmagapic-pc8ey]

Nobody can come next to the Bee gees

[@Ivoorlandodefaria]

Verdade 😂😂❤

[@bessmulholland5805]

I know the feeling of this 🎶,it’s true,love does hurt❤❤❤when you can’t have what you finally,found out what you want,but can’t have.LIFE. SUCKS…😂😂😢❤

[@bessmulholland5805]

Robin’s not doing to bad on his own,but still not the same some how,and now,it 👎 never will❤😢😊

[@bessmulholland5805]

❤Robin has a 👍 voice on his own ❤😊😊😊

[@leticiapelayo8243]

Robin Gibb wil sing again in the new world. When he is resurrected in the paradise on earth. We love you Jehovah!

[@tobiasikas5078]

The Bee Gees were loved in Germany like no other band in the world. Robin's voice was fantastic.

[@ellieaquitaine6396]

Is the band too loud, Robin not projecting enough or the backup singers drown him out? I'm glad I didn't pay to see this.

[@PietaDeOl-ob8gq]

Wanker

[@PietaDeOl-ob8gq]

Not Robin of course,his beautiful

[@maggiehoward1854]

Robin is more than a legend.no-one has got such a unique voice as he has.

[@accountswilliams5712]

Robin, Roy Orbison, the Everly Bros. all unique voices. All gone RIP. Robins Ellan Vannin with the church choir is magic. As he was born on the Isle of Man

[@theresabrown1272]

I remember hearing an interview with Barry after Robin passed and he said he misses Robins voice so much as it was so special!

[@lindareavis5971]

Robin had such a beautiful give your bones a chill, Barry touches ever fiber of your soul, Maurice is a beautiful singer .. put it all together & we get to hear The Bee Gees best and e er to grace the stage with their own composed songs.. such a party going on!!!

[@lindareavis5971]

@@theresabrown1272 I watched that one or one similar he dated Robin to sing much higher than he could..

[@L.M.O.]

@@lindareavis5971 I watched a video as well like that. But this was late in his Cancer. He looked like he wasn' t feeling well @ all that day. I also have seen a video interview where Barry states he knew Robin didn' t feel well for quite some time. Barry said Robin never wanted to talk about why. Barry says he didn' t know of his Cancer until Robin' s last 6 months. I never will know why Barry didn' t make his amends with Robin in those 6 months??

[@jean7213-x4t]

Helen and anna you are speaking the truth!!! Absolutely!!!! I love his songs and his voice. His smile is precious. .

[@StrawberrySoul77]

What an amazing and beautiful treat to hear Robin Gibb harmonizing with the Neue Philharmonie Frankfurt Orchestra! RIP RG 🐝G💜

[@telmacervetto7911]

Robin, the greatest of all the singers!!!

[@robinnoseff1690]

God he sounds so good with any band behind him or just him w/ out any band. Robin has a one of a kind voice. Rest in peace Robin, but we sure miss you and Mo

[@kthor]

He sounds good?!😬

[@hernanpena542]

Thank you Robin for giving us tremendous interpretations in which you transmit many emotions, feelings of tenderness, of love. Your voice is great, unique, it's a delight and enjoy every song of yours. You have lived for an end, to marvel and make our life more pleasant. We'll love you for all that, wherever you are.

[@CarolNovella]

We love your singing solo, and singing along with your brothers, may you R.I.P.

[@mavilgapic7188]

I love you always Robin , Jesus our Lord love you more,enjoy singing with the angels to the Lord now.

[@IsabelMonardes-c8z]

es emocionante escuchar todos estos aplausos para nuestro amado y dulce Robin !!! siempre lo tendremos en nuestro corazón !!!💔 💋 !!! soy adicta a mi gran amor de mi vida !!!!

[@isabellabourchier3498]

It makes my heart glad just to see the smile on his face at the end of each song. I honestly thought he would never never recover from Mo’s passing and although the sadness is still evident in his eyes and was for the rest of his life , he is taking a lot of energy and love from that crowd . So good to see him relaxed and thoroughly enjoying himself.

[@claireblack1551]

Still wish all the brothers were living😭😭😭😭

[@loisheckman8380]

Love Him

[@quiteriabezerra9840]

Sim concordo contigo.os BeeGees foram os melhores de todos os tempos.Robin meu patinho tímido.sofreu muito com essa terrível doença.chamada Colite..quanta paixão existia na sua maravilhosa voz.

[@quiteriabezerra9840]

@@claireblack1551 eu também amada.mas assim é á vida na terra 🌎um dia todos nós teremos que partir.mas o melhor de todas as coisas é quando deixamos SAUDADES.é o que eles realizaram á terra os marcou para toda Eternidade..um grande abraço...

[@isabellabourchier3498]

@@quiteriabezerra9840 not sure about the colitis comment. This is 2004. He was bereaved and not eating properly.

[@elainerighi1989]

Robin and his unique voice! He sings like an angel!!! Robin... always and forever in our hearts ! Who still listening in 2020?❤♥️❤

[@marlenesullivan3113]

GOD ONLY TAKES THE BEST SINGERS FOR HIS BAND 🕺

[@linorossi2648]

Great....great.. great !!!

[@marthamgomezabreu1183]

I do... Gone but never ever forgotten!

[@luizantoniomaia1020]

Me in Brazil. From Tres Coracoes, MG.

[@marthamgomezabreu1183]

I do. He's always been my fav BG, he had a very characteristic voice... miss him fully!!

[@marisegrove1274]

So glad he made an album with the orchestra. Great combination of a super voice and instrumenthal. Music at its best! Thank you for a great performance.

[@Johnfoley6876]

Hello Marise where are you from?

[@mariondoyle9549]

Robin is the best singer ther is he is Incredible incredible ther will never be another Robin gibb his music will live on and Robin will live on forever so strong he sang till the very end

[@johnnyangel7936]

The Bee Gees really are an incredible band, with countless hits. Nice to see Robin holding his own without Barry and Maurice! Robin is humble and an inspiration to us all!

[@joaoalvescampos4195]

Os Beatles. eram considerados mas gostava mais do bee gees e Robin a voz destacou entre seus pares só agora percebi que o grupo sem ele não funcionava .

[@L.M.O.]

@ JOHNNY ANGEL Your words, "Nice to see Robin holding his own without Barry or Maurice".....Robin is a Humble man." TOTALLY AGREE.

[@gailwebb9481]

We love. Robin. Gibb. Beautiful. Unique. Voice rip. Robin. Gibb.

[@brendamorris3385]

They are great

[@felysaavedra2384]

I love The Bee Gees. Wonderful Robin, wonderful Barry, wonderful Maurice and wonderful the jung brother, Andy.

[@truthbetold3550]

SO HUMBLE! Sweet! Kind! So many good things! His voice was AMAZING!!

[@valerieslater-t1v]

Robin has the most distinctive, superb vocals and all the extras were superfluous to me, just give me the wonderful Robin all on his own...

[@terrygotwhatheheaskedforfo7789]

He stands out with his voice never be another person like him

[@terrygotwhatheheaskedforfo7789]

Thank you for your reply I just looked his voice he has a great voice and thanks for your reply 🙂☺️

[@ajoruram]

That smile that I love!, This concert of Robin gives me great joy, to see him so happy, with his unparalleled voice singing complete songs, giving himself happy to his audience, as it should have always been. Robin wonderful.

[@puriejensen3215]

Robin has a beautiful voice and I like it when he is singing R,I P Robin

[@carmenbindiu5546]

The incredible, amazing, brilliant, beautiful Robin Gibb! Always in our hearts!

[@regineescavi5245]

🥰🥰 ROBIN the king 👑 !! 🥰❤🥰

[@LynnKozelka]

Robin had the best voice!

[@paulinehorne4150]

Robin with the Frankfurt Orchestra was fantastic he put his heart & soul in his performance the audience showed their appreciation many many times. Robins Morris and Andy

[@paulinehorne4150]

The brothers are making beautiful music in heaven may they rest in peace

[@brunogregoire9624]

superbe robin, 1 des meilleur bee gees avec son frère jumeau Maurice malheureusement parti trop tôt tout les deux

[@lin_mrachek]

Watch an amazing impromptu event from about TC 56:56 to 58:40 ...... The crowd sings back to Robin. And it as if they do not want the magic moment to end. Highlight of concert for me.

[@GM4mp035]

Robin deserves much praise and gratitude for the unique voice he gifted us with... there is no better melody than the Bee Gee's with their unique vocal abilities! BEE GEES FOREVER❤❤❤ ❤

[@urgdaddy]

Robin is the 'Voice of the BGees'. Always has been.

[@ИгорьЛевин-о5у]

Я русский из России , но мне очень нравиться эта музыка ! Это великие музыканты !

[@anaprado5282]

I just wanna say: Thank you very much mr. Robin Gibb.🙇‍♀️

[@mindareyes7565]

Yes dear Robin nailed another concert. Look at the audience, young old and middle age all enjoying this wonderful guy. Plus the orchestra is simply fantastic.!!

[@diegopratesi]

NO ONE CAN SING EVER LIKE HIM!

[@BEEGEESMIAMOR]

Diego Pratesi I completely agree with you. Thanks for posting your beautiful feelings for Robin. ................................................................ Estoy completamente de acuerdo contigo. Gracias por publicar tus bellos sentimientos por ROBIN.

[@МираббосАкбаров-ш8л]

Я помню эти голоса с детства, когда я еще не знала эту группу, но запомнила эти голоса, когда слушали взрослые. Потом поняла кто это был. Какое же счастливое время было у нас. Мы познали прекрасное. Сейчас мне 60. И наслаждаемся и сейчас. Они бессмертны.

[@mindareyes7565]

Robin did a very good job on this. He place himself and concentrated on music after Maurice’s death. The band was great too.

[@badsvil7671]

Not too late to become fan of bee gees especially Sir Robin Gibb, sweet voice as always. Thanks yt, for this wonderful videos that we new generation can watch and witness true and real music that comes from the heart. I miss sir Robin Gibb.

[@ralonzo1101]

Robin, your voice is one off a kind😊

[@magdalenacunanan8874]

robins' voice keeps resounding in my head n his smile leaves an impression in my mind.... too very sad that he left this world so early 😇

[@davidbonillaruiz8833]

Espectacular

[@valplaz]

robin must be the greatest voice of all times... seriously nobody can compare him at all

[@sizeman007]

Sure when he doesn't try to sing big brother Barry's led songs. I mean he has a gorgeous voice but why try to sing the fever songs????? It sounds ridiculous

[@theresabrown1272]

@@sizeman007 well that’s a bit harsh .. ridiculous? Maybe he likes being on his own once in a while . And I adore Barry ..

[@L.M.O.]

@@sizeman007 You say, "Sure when he doesn' t try to sing big brother Barry' s leads songs.......why try to sing the fever songs.... ridiculous" ????? I' m not sure what you meant by that statement. But regardless,---it really comes across to sound quite NEGITIVE of Robin. Both these brothers are extremely TALENTED, DRIVEN & have STRONG CHARACTERS. Perhaps because he is the oldest brother, Barry can @ times be a 'bit controlling', with Robin, and yes, as a result Barry leads a lot of songs, because he wants to. However, that doesn' t mean Robin doesn' t want to sing lead. What is the point you are trying to make? PLEASE explain.

[@christinestornable1816]

I just came across this today. What a wonderful pleasure? This answers why Robin had the better voice of the Bee Gees. His voice is strong even above an orchestra he can sing above the instruments and background singers and still sound like our earth angel Robin. Miss him so much. Along with that voice that smile can't ever be replaced.

[@MrLamasl]

Agosto 2022........Quienes están disfrutando de este bello concierto de Robin Gibb.......súper estrella brillando desde el Cielo ???!!!

[@veraluciabarbosa1334]

O Robin sempre cantou sozinho desde que começou. Muita gente nesta orquestra. Ele sozinho sempre deu conta de todas as suas músicas. Achei um exagero.

[@angelesgomez1688]

Yo en ahosto del 23

[@estelacobas4416]

@@veraluciabarbosa1334 yo en enero de 2024!

[@JavierFedericoAquino]

De que murió???

[@jackiescaletta7958]

I'm truly enjoying this concert. I miss Robin and Mo so much. Thank you for your gifts of incredible music❤❤❤

[@williampalacio1270]

You are absolutely right,,no other ever, like him for thousands of years,,,

[@mindareyes7565]

This concert was simply one of the best! The band was super.

[@elainekhouri278]

Just to see his handsome , smiling face and his angelic voice would put a smile on anyone's face! Love & miss you Robin!!!

[@elainekhouri278]

I wish Robin would have gone solo. His voice and smile is infectous!

[@rainbowruby8394]

3:58 I've Gotta Get A Message To You 8:10 How Deep Is Your Love 12:55 Nights On Broadway 18:33 Love Hurts 22:55 Massasuchetts 26:16 My Lover's Prayer 30:51 New York Mining Disaster 1941 37:53 Saved By The Bell 41:40 To Love Somebody 45:41 Words 49:13 You Win Again 53:44 Juliet 59:04 Tragedy 1:04:31 Jive Talkin' 1:08:11 Stayin' Alive

[@rettersp]

0:00 Night Fever... 👍👍👍

[@lindagarcia8826]

Hi Rainbow Rudy You're so kind to take the time and provide this well appreciated timeline for all. Have a Merry Christmas and Happy New Year

[@massimatrix18xd62]

@@lindagarcia8826 yes, marvelous concert!

[@lindagarcia8826]

@@massimatrix18xd62 Hi Msdimatrix18XD, I guess you were at the concert, how exciting!!! One of my biggest regret in life is not seeing The Bee Gees in concert. All the videos of their concerts are amazing. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year. Stay safe and healthy, God bless

[@MrGaz652]

Thanks

[@Deleila]

Bravo Robin Gibbs

[@radjimontenejo4032]

I like your thump up.and smile.. I missed your beautiful voice.

[@evaanikoszabo159]

LOVE, LOVE LOVE,,,,,,,,,,,FANTASTIC ROBIN

[@marlenesullivan3113]

Simply A LEGEND

[@Lulu4Him]

Even though the back ground singers over whelm Robin's voice sometimes, his voice is still as sweet as ever. Taken from us all way too soon. Love you Robin.

[@lilise3965]

The worst is the orchestra behind. His mike should've been powered up theirs lowered. This is the review of knowledgeable musical critics who have reviewed the CD from this concert.

[@simonamercuryjackson1874]

@@lilise3965 I totally 👍 agree

[@SuperWoolfolk]

Drums are too loud!

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

Robin should have done a through sound check before hand. The orchestra is over powering his vocals!! The sound engineer should have been monitoring that!?

[@L.M.O.]

@ Lulu4Him, You wouldn' t happen to be, by any chance the "artist" LULU who was married to Robin' s twin, MAURICE???

[@Annie-49]

I just finished watching this again. He's just the greatest; so sexy, so adorable. No musician makes me happier than Robin. It's so easy to drift away with his perfect voice serenading you... Although I like this show, I wish it was just Robin, acappella; or maybe just one instrument, nothing else. That exquisite voice didn't need any accompaniment. I want you back Robin. x

[@beverleycox1254]

BeeGeees Music will remain in our hearts forever. I am saddened that Barry is the only surviving Brother of this gifted family, but inevitably, they will all unite in Heaven. Robin, Maurice, Andy...SIP...🙏🙏🙏

[@gailwebb9481]

Robin. Gibb. Had. A. Beautiful. Unique. Voice. Rip. Robin. Gibb

[@Johnfoley6876]

Hello Gail where are you from?

[@fleursnow12]

Robin so marvelous artist so marvelous man, and the most wonderful voice !!!!!!!! I miss him sooooo much ! I miss Maurice too !

[@kenhartman6237]

Hello Fleur 👋 How are you doing?

[@isabelodonnell9103]

He was absolutely beautiful with an incredible voice and smile X

[@patriciatolliver4057]

Maurice and that charming smile and dreamy eyes. However, Robin has and always be my favorite.

[@suzanneduma3435]

I just love this concert! Some of the best musicians in the world with Robin Gibb and that Great Voice!!! The world is certainly missing Robin! RIP

[@kenhartman6237]

Hi Suzanne 👋 How are you doing?

[@lindaknight5018]

Also you can tell this entire orchestra were enjoying themselves for the entire show

[@brendaconner2005]

Linda Knight I was thinking the same thing it was crazy if you had a bad day and you went in that building you would come out a different person even the building had smile on it

[@janetmilne4196]

Love this song

[@pinascavo5590]

I'll love you for ever wonderful Robin. Rest in peace❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@Stevewm869]

It’s a shame they never did something like this when they were altogether would have sounded a lot better with all three of them and would have put the orchestra more in the background none the less this showcases Robins voice at the age he was my favourite Bee Gees song is Wedding Day when Robins voice comes in on the chorus, sends shivers down my spine and chokes me up absolutely beautiful sadly missed but still greatly enjoyed by millions .

[@maryanderson2602]

The best part of this whole concert was to see Robin smiling so much. I wasn’t sure he was going to make it all the way back after Maurice’s death.

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

Robin never really made it back. Robin was running for his life. And he kept on running until his own death in 2012. His work schedule was non-stop. But it kept his mind occupied. That was his way of dealing with the death of his twin. Robin was just lost without Mo.I hate that he had to experience that sad and devastating loss.💔

[@L.M.O.]

@@gloriamaryhaywood2217 Thanks for your sentiment. I would say for the most part,---that is how men often deal with mourning a loss, WORK, WORK, WORK! Not in all cases of course.ROBIN was a man of strong character and enormous talent, I admire him for that. When I view the video' s of his CHILDHOOD, he was HAPPY, FUNNY, JOYFUL, ENERGETIC, the CLOWN of the FAMILY. Gloria,--- Unfortunately his ADULT life included far too MUCH TRAGEDY. Far beyond the death of his best of the best friend, his twin Maurice. In addition to brother Andy' s death & his father, there was the divorce of his first love Molly. The seperation with his son & daughter 'cause of the divorce. Even before all this, there was more. Two close brushes with death in his very young adulthood. During Molly and Robin's engagement, they both went through a disastrous, horrible, tragic train derailment. They had injuries and were trapped. Once found, leaving for hospital they needed to cross paths, (in some cases 'stepover')numerous injured, dying, and dead bodies. In one of the video interviews posted on KZbin Robin compared it to "walking through a 'WAR ZONE' ". Can you imagine the YEARS Robin and Molly suffered NIGHTMARES of their experience. You hear of 'veterans of war' having nightmares with their PTSD. It would be the SAME THING FOR ROBIN & MOLLY! Add to this,--- when on their honeymoon, they were trapped in an Avalanche in their cabin. NOT FOUND FOR 4 DAYS!! This is how his ADULT life differed w/his childhood. In spite of the tragedy,---he prodded along w/his songwriting. Hands down, by far most of the fruits of his labor were serious, sad, tragic, melancholy tracks. It could have been both empathy for others who suffered with tragedies & therapeutic for himself. It was a way to release some sorrow. Now, don' t forget his cause of death. He suffered for many, many years of treatment of this insidious disease of CANCER. THE BOTTOM LINE, my point I make for you in this comment of mine is meant for a purpose. The emotional PAIN in both EYES and VOICE comes from more than his loss of twin brother Maurice. It is an accumulation of MANY TRAGEDIES in his ADULT LIFE, compared to his CHILDHOOD that was HAPPY, FUNNY, JOYFUL, ENERGETIC, CLOWN OF FAMILY. He DEALT with it, the BEST he could,---IN his SONGWRITING.... He wrote about other' s TRAGEDIES in many of his songs, (Ellan Vannan/ A Requiem for Titanic/ I' ve Gotta Get A Message To You/New York Mining Disaster). It had to be therapeutic for him. It' s the reason the LYRICS and HIS VOICE CUTS through TO the HEART & the EARS of his listening FANS. I ADMIRE THIS MAN'S CHARACTER. 💔💓💕❤💗 AND I KNOW YOU DO AS WELL.

[@L.M.O.]

@ MARY ANDERSON, Not only the loss of his BEST FRIEND and TWIN BROTHER MAURICE, but an entire ADULT LIFETIME OF TRAGEDIES. The horrible, tragic train derailment during Robin & Molly engagement & were injured in. They were trapped, once found making their way out to get to ambulance was a harrowing experience. Robin compared that in an interview as "walking through a 'WAR ZONE' ". They had to walk around & step-over injured, dying, and dead bodies. Think of PTSD NIGHTMARES!! This interview was on one of video's posted @ KZbin. On Robin and Molly' s honeymoon, yet another brush of death & fear of dying. Their cabin suffered an avalanche, trapped for 4 days. Add to this, he suffered a divorce from Molly, seperation with his son and daughter because of divorce, the death of brother Andy, his father, then Maurice. And many, many years fighting the insidious disease of Cancer, and I' m sure the side-effects of treatment. Far more tragedy than the loss of twin brother Maurice,---if that wasn' t enough. I believe a good part of him surviving all the tragedies of his adult life was his talent of SONGWRITING. That had to be therapeutic for him. He often wrote of trag- edies, not just his own losses, but others, (A Requiem for Titanic/ I Gotta Get a Message To You/New York Mining Disaster/Ellan Vannan). Then singing those songs more emotional release. I admire this man's 💗CHARACTER as well as his TALENT.💕💓

[@Rondyeletronica]

Robin forever

[@Ivoorlandodefaria]

Sem dúvida 😂😂😂❤

[@mariondoyle9549]

Robin is fantastic even though he looks happy u can still see the sadness in is eyes I never got to see Robin live I so much regret it ther will never be another Robin gibb his personality is incredible incredible may be we will be together one day but what a great loss his singing is incredible incredible he leaves everyone standing no one to come close to Robin we all won't let u be forgotten never I love u Robin gibb I 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔

[@angelasuey1000]

Yes Robin truly had a unique voice, and no one will ever fill his shoes loved hearing him sing,R.I.P Robin ❤ loved you too❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@luciamaria7787]

Realmente era único, 😢 ouço suas canções e não me canço 😢😢

[@cristologaelcira771]

Robin aquí ya estaba con cáncer y así estuvo entregando su hermosa voz y todas sus energías, fue un guerrero hasta el final gracias Robin

[@angelesgomez1688]

.no se lo detectaron en 2010

[@dagmarmuller1305]

Schön das Robin Geeb so schöne Lieder alleine singt❤

[@hadoenough]

Robin was a humble and beautiful soul. He and his brothers will never be equaled. The Bee Gees ...superb musicians and magnificent songwriters.

[@岡田啓子-m3p]

ロビンの最初の奥さ ん見たい

[@simonamercuryjackson1874]

@@岡田啓子-m3p????

[@andreasolana3607]

I love you!❤❤❤

[@glenphillips9068]

Dirty man

[@LuanaSilva526]

@@glenphillips9068 Porque tá falando assim? Why are you talking like that?

[@algs229635]

Magnificent, only those who lived at that time know what it means to go back in time and remember wonderful moments when souls leave the body and travel on the sound waves of this unparalleled voice of Robin

[@diegopratesi]

All the world will miss Robin forever! A legend!

[@MichaelBrown-um3mv]

Robin + this great orchestra made the perfect combination together + performance was excellent. Im sure they sold tons of these albums + videos for us to watch over + over again. Great . The Bee Gees are the very best + # 1 group on stage along with my 2nd . Favorite group on stage tjat their music lives on today + fir future generations. ABBA . So many songs their the best along with the BEE GEES .

[@MichaelBrown-um3mv]

❤?

[@MichaelBrown-um3mv]

This is my most favorite BEE GEES song . I play it every single day . I'm 72 now + followed them from the beginning. When the 3 brthers sing it with their own original band it sounds good but not even close to when Robin's magnificent voice matched up with these fantastic back up singers especially Harold's voice + the greatest orchestra I believe in the world playing their instruments so remarkable that when it all comes together there's no other group or band that comes anywhere close to perfection like these musicians + Singers . Their all in a wonderful world of their own . You can see their all happy + smiling + loving it together. Their the greatest combination out there. 10 on 10 for sure . I live them all .

[@jindriskastepnickova8135]

Tak to s vami nesouhlasim.Nejlepsi byli jako celek tri hlasu Bee gees😮

[@patriciaeddy7629]

What a guy! So much full of life when singing his heart out. What a great he is still. Love ya, Robin H.Gibb! 💖

[@silvina8432]

I love Robin's voice. The Beegees forever in my life!💜🌞🌟🌜

[@jeannowo2294]

La légende des Bee Gees c’est vous,cher Robin. La plupart des musiciens n’étaient pas nés quand vous avez interprété vos merveilleuses mélodies avec Maurice et Barry . Quel honneur pour eux d’accompagner le génie que vous êtes Vous êtes toujours parmi nous dans la mémoire et dans le cœur de tout vos administrateurs Bernadette,madame Jean

[@mariondoyle9549]

Robin is as good as anyone no one can sing like Robin no one is a incredible and magnificent incredible man who's voice was the best ther is Robin will go down in history ❤️

[@marfernandez2722]

Claro que jamas sera mejor que Barry el SI que tenía una voz incomparable!

[@marfernandez2722]

No me gusto Jamás su voz tan temblorosa y poco versátil. Lo siento pero nadie mejor que Barry y Morice.❤❤

[@tommasocataldo4077]

Robin.. Hai lasciato ricordi indelebile... Sei stato una delle migliori voce della canzone mondiale... Grandi BEE GEES.

[@donnasilver940]

He kept his voice even as he got older.Some don't.

[@felysaavedra2384]

Wonderful, my dear ROBIN!!!! For always in my heart!!!!!!!

[@marlenesullivan3113]

MINE TOO

[@Wintergreen31]

The music is good just has a better harmony when he's with his brothers

[@kathymartinets771]

I love this man and all his hard work to bring this music to us. It breaks my heart to read about all the issues he and his brothers went thru. I am thankful for all the music he and his brothers brought to the world so I can enjoy such great songs to my last year's on this earth. Love and kisses to the entire Gibb family. 💕

[@kikiu2619]

Cool we have these concerts with Robin, who is such an incredible singer and songwriter.

[@JenniferHoots-o4j]

What surprises me is alot of celebrities don't Thank God for there talents and accomplishments because God gives us all a talent.

[@mellissahodge8531]

Love that beautiful smile.....

[@ginamarie007]

That was an amazing concert to watch. I can’t imagine how much better it was in person. I grew up in the 70’s & 80’s. Saturday Night Fever was huge. I loved them then and I love them even more now. Robin is spectacular here ❤️

[@elainekhouri278]

If only all the brothers could imagine how much joy they bring to my life, every single day. Without their beautiful music, I honestly don't think I could endure all my physcial pain, every day of my life. Thank God for Barry, Robin and Maurice. How could these three handsome, humble icons all bring us so much happiness. God bless them all. Barry, please keep up the music, you are truly an incredible human being. We all love you so very much!

[@lightdweller1]

What a special man... so talented yet so humble, with a beautiful soul. I love seeing his smile at the end of each song as the audience applauds him...he looks so chuffed, there’s a childlike innocence in him. I’m so glad he got to see how loved and respected he is just solo. It’s so good to see Barry now doing the same solo tours... he’s great too, another great man with a beautiful soul. The Bee Gees are legend... there will never be anything like them again!

[@sassonaticarello368]

Yes is true, is a original man, no need's word.!!

[@eldestin2344]

Une vraie leçon d'amour pour tous ❣

[@lightdweller1]

@@eldestin2344 définitivement une leçon d'amour et de vie ♥️

[@nhoelyntugade8471]

We love you Robin, we missed you. Your golden voice remains in our hearths forever

[@jurgenf5771]

Robin war ein wundervoller Sänger. Seine tollen Songs bleiben immer da. Man was für eine tolle Stimme. Kann mich noch erinnern als ich in der Musikbox Songs von ua. von Robin gewählt habe. R. I. P Robin

[@lindarush3165]

Woonderful Robin great voice such as always....we love you

[@harrychristopher7702]

Robin’s performances are just perfect and his backing group are in time Such a loss lucky we have all these wonderful videos to hold on to

[@LauroRM]

There will never be another band like the Bee Gees.

[@yvonnesosa1040]

LauroRM you are so right. Robin died wanting another number 1 hit that never was to be. According to Barry, Robin couldn't accept it. He kept chasing & chasing different music but he got very sick. The last musical project was Recoded with his son. Requiems of the Titanic? Something like that. I'm sorry but I haven't given it the justice it deserves. Sometimes a band comes along at just the right time and then fades away. The Bee gees will never be one of those. Their hits will always be hits no matter when they're heard! This concert is a perfect example of it. Robin sings their hits and he sounds terrific! There are 3brothers singing in heaven now. Barry still has many years ahead of him so the brothers will have to wait. God bless them all. They are solely missed!

[@soniasilvestrini7524]

@ Lauro RM I agree with you!!!

[@carmenbindiu5546]

Indeed!

[@ambiebabelonia2621]

The brothers' team up could never be matched by any other band. They have that uniqueness only the Beegees had. A legend indeed...

[@mariesmith599]

There is a group of young men called the REO Brothers. Check them out they really have tried to honor the Bee Gees. They are indeed sincere in their music.

[@lin_mrachek]

I hope performing helped Robin cope with the terrible grief he must be dealing with because of the loss of Mo his twin. It is so nice to Robin smile ! He seemed very happy singing their songs. I miss both Robin and Mo. Very sad to know the three brothers will never ever get to perform together again. But the Bee Gees music will last forever.

[@bweeks-marshall3826]

Robin Gibb has the sweetest smile I've ever seen. I miss the Brothers Gibb as well as Andy Gibb. May their music and those incredible voices and harmonies live forever. Barry, you are loved.

[@patriciaelg1464]

Robin has the most beautiful voice. Honestly, all these instruments and voices get in the way of hearing Robin.

[@johnevans2059]

Never tire of watching this concert fantastic five star

[@marilynfulo9053]

Robin was at his happiest times.Love this concert and I miss him so much.

[@nazfan43]

Love Robin!!! Love his smile and how tickled he is when he gets the audience's approval... almost childlike !!! Beautiful robin..........

[@ewawedholm6814]

Han är den bästa av alla

[@MA-oy3sx]

@@ewawedholm6814 Visst e han

[@louisebeichner8379]

❤ what a great concert, Robin loved to perform and he was awesome.. I know it had to be hard without Maurice and Barry...

[@nasbyszbrown1656]

Thank you DarlingMan. I love your voice

[@katiabellucio1390]

Robin Gibb com sua voz perfeita! Isso sim que é um espetáculo. Muitas saudades...Robin...

[@isabelcunha1942]

Sem dúvida🥰

[@Gerrione]

Kate: Two fingers up for your comment, I feel the same way!

[@audranorwood3113]

Such a fabulous event! So sad he’s gone!

[@erikakovacs5257]

Robin my favorite.He was the Best world.The was Angels voice.I love Robin.

[@Quistosweetie]

I bet he’s singing in the angels choir! God bless him! RIP sweet man!

[@roleensumner7604]

Robin's personality and voice are amazing. He and MO were enjoying it as much as we were. Thank God for all of the great video's.

[@orlandocuevatamburini3649]

❤❤❤❤❤ hermosisimas canciones van directo al corazon