Projection Matrices in OpenGL

[@ryanmeyers3863]

The minute I changed my projection matrix to no longer be centered at 0 my triangles were getting drawn in totally bizarre ways... took me half an hour to remember that matrix multiplication order matters and I was multiplying backwards in my vertex shader!

[@_slep]

I made the same mistake (heh..) Was getting some really odd shapes being drawn with objects looking like they were smeared across the window

[@thatKurtis]

Almost did the same, but my brain froze for 2 minutes thinking about exactly this

[@jinxblaze]

opengl is column major so that fucks things up for me :( im so used to row major

[@kiljeaden767]

Thanks brave man, you just saved me half an hour.

[@Pdrum2]

ha, it messed up the numbers

[@jrp2k9]

The conversion of orthographic projection matrix values from relative to pixel really help explained this concept for me. The quick math demonstration at the end was perfect. Wish I could like the video twice.

[@cykablyat2746]

A few years late but for anyone still watching this, javidx9 has an amazing series where he tackles the graphics pipeline in depth through the use of a console and the power of the CPU.It provides a far more intuitive view over what is actually going on under the hood.

[@rajasbondale6512]

I like how he is also explaining how things far away look smaller. I mean he's just not excluding anyone with different skill levels. Love you

[@Micha-mj7vg]

If your vertex positions got messed up but everything seems to be alright, it could be bacause of your shader program. instead of gl_Position = position * u_MVP; write gl_Position = u_MVP * position ; as the matrix multiplication is NOT communicative ( mat_1 * mat_2 != mat_2 * mat_1 )

[@gr3yknigh1]

thanks!

[@SwarnimArun]

math! Math! MATH! I want some MATH.

[@beProsto]

javidx9 is the guy to go

[@JaredThirsk]

It sounds like what you really want are maths.

[@sids3194]

math....not even once.

[@skrolikowski]

More theory please. You can find thousands of videos already of people just coding without explanation.

[@alanmejia1330]

Im not sure if youre still interested in this kind of topics but you can read about this in a linear algrebra book (I like linear algebra by grossman) and this other book Mathematics for 3D game programming and computer graphics

[@ASCENDANTGAMERSAGE]

I've heard that Graphics Programming:Practices and Principles is good. It's available online for free.

[@regbot4432]

watch 3blue1brown series about linear algebra

[@rauldragu9447]

@@regbot4432 and then maybe follow along with javidx9's graphics engine from scratch to see then concepts in action. That how I learned it and I still don't think that there's a better resource out there to truly learn this stuff. The maths and theory is still my favorite thing about 3D graphics.

[@bebekngayang]

You can watch code it yourself 3d engine videos on javidx9 youtube channel

[@finnbuhse4775]

Just so everyone knows, he didn't mention that matrix multiplication is NOT commutative, and has to be matrix * vec4

[@salihkavaf2864]

My square wasn't rendering until I realized that I've flipped it in reverse to what it is in the video.

[@Dodo17sky]

Thanks a lot. My square wasn't rendering ok until I read your comment

[@nerijusvilcinskas7851]

This is exactly what I needed in order to understand how to convert SDL2 renderer stuff to OpenGL in my game, thank you so much! Projection Matrices FTW

[@nikoszervo]

Well before these series it was extremely difficult to learn graphics API'S from the Internet. For some reason there are no good tutorials out there about that stuff even that programming is actually one of the easiest topics to learn through the internet. Very good job! Keep going! (We also can't wait for the Game Engine Series)!!!!!!!!!!

[@no5x937]

Another GREAT Technical Video Cherno! Much appreciated. More theory with practical application is the BEST teaching style. Theory BEFORE application is necessary for real understand, memory recall, and better applications development.

[@BlackJar72]

Implementing your own projection matrix is very useful; it makes it easy to get the inverse. Getting the inverse very handy for shooting a ray though an arbitrary point on the screen (e.g., to find what's under a mouse pointer).

[@Jack-4242]

why not just use the GL Matrix Utility functions for inverting matrices?

[@BlackJar72]

I don't know how it actually works under the hood -- there is a very slow and complex way of computationally inverting any matrix. But, there is a *much* faster way to get an inverse projection matrix. This is a much simpler and faster formula that can be worked out with pencil and paper and turned into its own function. More efficient than a generic matrix inversion function, which is probably what a utility would use. Besides, where's the fun in letting someone else write everything for you?

[@BichoPragmatico]

you also have to use orthographic projection when implementing shadow mapping from a sun-like light source (outdoor scene), As "sun rays are parallel "

[@violenceisfun991]

6:25 reminds me of that episode of Father Ted where he's trying to explain the difference between a small sheep and a far away sheep

[@vertigo6982]

I know some people below dont like the mostly talking and few coding, but I find that style to be the best. It was how my programming teachers in college taught. Basically in the 1 hour 15 minutes of course time it would be on just one topic. 45 minutes of the class to talk about logic and syntax.. do's and don'ts. History of the topic, current status, why its good, etc.. then we would have 30 minutes on the computers to play with the code. You know what you're doing. You know the code and theory.. so you know how complex it is.. If you feel you should do it this way to make sure everyone gets it then thats probably the best way. After all you know more about this stuff then we do.

[@emanuelkokovics]

It is so weird, because what you say makes sense and it is the same, unless I try to project an image! Practically my image will show if I move the viewing area (12:32) from being centered to being more to the top right part! Anyone else with this problem?At 15:46 with the white square I get same result as Cherno, with the image I get black screen. Anyone with this problem? Maybe the "coordinate system" works differently on my pc (because of my GC), because it seems to handle images differently (not as simple squares), not as in the video!

[@jairoacosta8940]

damn man, you saved me from pulling my hair out (edit: once again). thanks.

[@not_halls]

the emotionally motivating music at the start damn

[@dmaster20ify]

Love the theory Mr. Cherno. You ave done a great explanation of OpenGL. Like I didn't know that GLU was the one that loaded all those function pointers. I was always confused as to how I could just call these OpenGL functions without loading them from the DLL first. Note GLU has extra functions such as GluPerspective(...). I learnt what the hell are shaders in modern graphics libraries. I learnt about vertex shaders and fragment shaders. I learnt that by using gl buffers you could store memory directly into the GPU. And shaders allow you to write callback functions that run on the GPU.

[@timothyvandyke9511]

I'm very thankful for all this explanation of how things work. I finally have a grasp of what's happening when I type code!

[@AxElKo440]

I've been looking for this, good video. Thank you

[@myaramon]

Hey Yan. You are doing great job. Would you be interestend in making cmake tutorial for us not blessed with Visual Studio on linux? :)

[@ianharvey9136]

Fantastic explanation! Thank you.

[@Destroyer19941995]

How do I set up custom screen coordinates in perspective matrix since on the internet I only see width, height, fov and aspect ratio. There is no left and right.

[@Neran280]

glm::perspectivefov();

[@vrysk7685]

Would like to see an application of the concepts you've gone over, maybe in rendering a basic first person scene, but it's certainly useful to get the theory in a well-packed video too! Maybe another series?

[@quaylynrimer11]

13:39 your example here is not working the same on my machine it still keeps 0 , 0 as the center of the screen

[@_slep]

Your multiplying the matricies incorrectly, had the same issue. Need to change _position*u_MVP;_ to _u_MVP*position;_ in your basic.shader file (As matricies have a specific order of multiplication in this case)

[@goldenlava1019]

@@_slep Thank you so much, would have never found the problem and probably would have rewritten the entire thing to try to fix it. Because normally it doesn't matter what order you do multiplication.

[@_slep]

@@goldenlava1019Yeah matricies are odd in the way that they arent commutative (a * b != b * a). Would reccomend looking into a little linear algebra since it shows up a fair bit in graphics programming (3b1b is pretty good)

[@goldenlava1019]

@@_slep thanks

[@simonvyhnis5813]

So many things now make sence..., thanks.

[@kaushalchari5686]

I am trying to use perspective projection instead of orthographic, but it does not seem to work the same way and I am getting weird results. Where can I get an example with perspective projection/

[@puyadaravi3109]

Thank you for the great series! Could you also make a video about how projection works for 3D displays?

[@xtiooplus]

Nice explaination: 8/10

[@tapanotbind]

Hi. Why did you say that after projection we have got the coordinates in NDC and in range of [-1,1] while they are in the range of [-w, w] and this space is called 'clip space'. And OpenGL do division by 'w' for us and after that we are in the NDC and in the range [-1,1]. No?

[@praveshgaire3437]

glm::mat4 proj = glm::ortho(0.0f, 960.0f, 0.0f, 540.0f, -1.0f, 1.0f); Are the last two parameters to tell what our normalized ranges are ???? The docs says they are near value and far value, not sure what that means.

[@Byynx]

How do you select and write down in two different places at the same time?

[@infinitecmdz]

in most cases, you wouldnt be using projection matrix directly with vertices in model/local/world space. Generally, you would have a camera/view space. I think you would then base your projection matrix as a function of your view space, correct?

[@bankoftrustnwobot3218]

Siddharth P Yes but I would suggest to use quaternions instead of matrices for projection/rotation.

[@emanuelkokovics]

For me using your positions , column 1 and 2 coordinates, makes a rectangles -> that seems to be divided into 4 , and my image gets projected in the right top corner (or on the full rectangle just the left bottom corner of my images is projected). It is weird. Could this be because how my graphics card drivers are handling stuff (implementations)?

[@SketchpunkLabs]

Just to add an extra example of how Orthographic Projection can be 3D, I've used that sort of projection when I was playing around with isometric camera. For anyone who does not know what an Isometric view is, think Diablo, World Craft 3, sim city. Making games like that, ortho will be your friend :)

[@dmitrykolesnikovich]

What kind of shader language are you using ?

[@MaxwellsWitch]

Can you do a stencil buffer video?

[@user-lk2vo8fo2q]

3:32 you were using a projection matrix, right? it's just an identity projection.

[@TheCherno]

Not really. An identity matrix is just diagonal 1's, meaning any other matrix multiplied with the identity matrix will result in no change. We never did any matrix multiplication, we just set each vertex position of our geometry to the value stored in the vertex buffer.

[@soupman2177]

What is your favorite soup? your tutorials are amazing.

[@10monthspregnant]

BeautifulSoup4

[@praveen18p1]

Great job !!! very well explained :)

[@VoidAshen]

keep it at glm::mat4 proj = glm::ortho(-480.0f, 480.0f, -270.0f, 270.0f, -1.0f, 1.0f); its convenient cuz the origin is still at the center.

[@simonbechara2814]

I enjoyed your clear explanation in the Video, I would like to know how to convert from 3D space coordinates to Screen Coordinates in both Cases, Ortho2D and Perspective, Thx

[@logancheatum8397]

Some people might find this interest but I feel like this is the moment I feel like I actually understand out 3d graphics work on a fundamental level.

[@jakubkawczynski8854]

only 8,5k views and nearly 50 comments? well.. only a few have come this far by seeking better understanding :p

[@ryanbinter2447]

yea im in no hurry to use open GL for a project so i would prefer to understand the underlying things.

[@mikamulperi]

How to transform so that we have 0,0 on top left?

[@mikamulperi]

Figured it out myself, just put height to bottom argument : glm::ortho(0.0f, (float)WIDTH, (float)HEIGHT, 0.0f, -1.0f, 1.0f);

[@webgpu]

After multiplying a vertex position by the projection matrix, is the resulting vertex in clip space or NDC space? (and does this distinction matter in any way?)

[@pronobroy8389]

Result will be in clip space then those vertex will divide by W component (vertex.x/vertex.w, vertex.y/vertex.w, vertex.z/vertex.w) and now it is NDC

[@k1ngsavage15]

I'm so confused on how your rendering a cube with only 4 rows of x, y, z vertices. My cube has 36 rows. I must be missing something important A mat4 matrix is used for 3d shapes, but can only have 4x4 rows and columns, but that's not enough information to render a cube is it?

[@bankoftrustnwobot3218]

I doesn‘t matter how many „rows“ your cube has. Projection is intended for three/two-dimensional shapes (with W for special rotation calculations). For a better understanding I recommend looking at „2blue1brown“ channel videos. He has awesome visualization of projections and rotations. Look for „quaternions“ on his channel.

[@dwarfda]

​@@bankoftrustnwobot3218 although i agree 3b1b videos would help him understand more, quaternions have nothing to do with his question. I believe his problem is, he didn't watch the video about index buffers, hence if hes trying to draw a cube with 6 sides made of 12 triangles, he has to repeat each vertex 3 times for the 3 sides they're connecting. Also he doesn't quite understand matrix multiplication and how matrices actually work.

[@Byynx]

This isn't a cube it's a square. And because he uses a index buffer ti select which vetlrtex will compose the flat square the vertex count is smaller.

[@mario7501]

If you guys are really interested in how the maths behind graphics processing works, javidx9 has a really good series on graphics programming where he dives into the maths :D

[@karlsteinmeister7245]

so in the end it will all have to be floats from -1 to 1... do they _have to_ be like that or is there a way for me to use ints instead? honestly i expect the answer to be no there is no way, but if there is, please let me know... i don't like floats at all. they are too impercise and unpredictable for my likeing (and i would think are more performance hungry since they are formated weridly, unlike ints (or shorts or longs or chars/bytes)). btw cherno, i love the in depth videos, i always hate it when i write code and have no good understanding of what is going on in the background. it also makes it a lot harder to optimize code.

[@wva6809]

You can of course, cast to an int. Try to fiddle around with that, but you won't have ANY control. As, You only have 3 positions to render in. In the left, middle or right

[@szymonwojtala9334]

When are you going to start "Game Engine" series?

[@Xxp0r]

When do you think you will do a video about exception handling? I saw your vid about smart pointers and you mentioned you didn't like exceptions/would do a video about it :)

[@oamost]

That's a bit offtopic here.

[@jumbledfox2098]

10x less views than the first video - dont give up, guys!

[@wojtekpilwinski]

Hello Cherno, I love your tutorials but the music in the background isn't little bit too exaggerated? :)

[@lyte69]

thanks for the explanation it was good :).

[@sphereman3572]

My orthographic matrix rotates it for some reason

[@d.a.t.6784]

Is it just me or is there some creepy breathing sounds in the background right before ~19:00?

[@ty_teynium]

This involves the world object and view coordinates right?

[@BlackJar72]

Coordinates would be used to transform the projection matrix to see a different areas / look different directions. A world object is something you might build later, though I've built couple beginner graphics engines that didn't use any such concept -- this just has a view port (window), that all it need up to this point.

[@ty_teynium]

Jared Blackburn I'm sorry I meant object view and world views. I'm hoping that clears it up and thank you for the reply!

[@noneofyourdamnbuisness3484]

10:02 personal

[@IllIlIIllIlIl]

Please start linking to in-depth resources in the description rather than saying "might do a video on it in the future". Your videos are great but are not as in-depth as they sometimes need to be to understand how something works.

[@navaneeth6157]

who disliked?

[@mohammednihad6755]

💙

[@dattatreyapujar4068]

Cool..

[@platin2148]

Don't forget to tell them that gl wants the stupid format for matrices and we need to transpose them wich takes time.

[@user-lk2vo8fo2q]

column major? for whatever reason a lot of scientific libraries do it that way.

[@platin2148]

Agenda

[@5Gazto]

Nice job. However I think that you shouldn't confuse your audience with mingling 2D movement with 3D graphics. You dedicated way too much time on It.

[@SketchpunkLabs]

You have to spend a little time in the beginning with 2D, because OpenGL is really just 2D by nature. You... the developer, create the 3D content and data, then with the use of the projection matrix flatten it out to be displayed on a 2D canvas. So in the end of the day, all the fancy 3D stuff you make has to be brought back into 2D space. Besides, knowing ortho and the aspect of 2D, this is where you will create many of your UI elements that will live on top of your 3D content. So its all connected.

[@giancedrick507]

I suppose this is one of the cases where you should make a PowerPoint, because I just replayed the whole video three times just to get it :(

[@incredibletech5081]

This video was very helpfull for my project. i want to donate through brave rewards can you please become a brave reward certified channel. lots of wishes

[@h.hristov]

Ayy

[@mandre96]

I WANT 3D 3D 3D 3D GO GO GO HURRY UP! lol

[@L2PTQ]

Stop this arm thing at the beginning. What the fuck.