Charlottes Daughter is a 'They' AND JUST LIKE THAT HBO MAX

Links to my equipment/favorites ❤️
Planner ✏️ amzn.to/3WHdIbi
And….. amzn.to/3XIjtqw
Notebook 📔 amzn.to/3DdSU4v
Pens 🖊 amzn.to/3HafcoL
Highlighters 💡 amzn.to/3WHRhmg
Colored Pens 🌈 amzn.to/3kQOlqc
Pencil Holder amzn.to/3j8NMYx
Desktop 🖥 amzn.to/3JrmIye
Computer 💻 amzn.to/3HJpQVj
Flashdrive amzn.to/3HcT1yd
Coffee ☕️ Tumblr amzn.to/3Dje9C5
Coffee Machine☕️ amzn.to/3HxkdJE
amzn.to/3Dksq1b
Comfy clothes 💜 amzn.to/3jbV79S
Comfy Slippers ♥️ amzn.to/3Y2pNsG
Fuzzy Socks 🧦 amzn.to/3WLQAZk
Hair Clips 🥀 amzn.to/4073Ydp
KZbin Cozy Music: / @thecozyvibe
KZbin Meditations: / @meditationmarvels8829
Instagram: / the.curated. .
Pintrest: / thecuratedv. .
🤍I am an unmotitized channel, buy me a coffee🧋🧉: www.buymeacoffee.com/thecultu...
Tik Tok: tiktok.com/@theculturedqueen

[@georgecameron4754]

I can't believe I'm saying this, but Kim Cattrall dodged a bullet by not being in this awful excuse of a show, and I'm grateful for that.

[@ericaawake9503]

This show is horrible!

[@Beatrix7004]

Totally agree. This show is a muddled mess

[@katjasjoberg750]

I would have burned with anger if a teacher corrected me about my child's name. I had taken my child out of school

[@justvibin7883]

💯💯💯💯💯

[@scottlabossiere1866]

Me too

[@christina12311979]

yeah, that pissed me off too!

[@ericaawake9503]

Agree a 100% nobody will tell me how to call my child !

[@morvk2008]

My as$ she didn't know Rose changed her name. This (kind of) teacher grooms the kids that way

[@rassp3860]

As an educator…this would NEVER happen this way. This is ridiculous. And if I went into a school and this is how the conversation went down…my next move would be to withdraw my child from that school.

[@yumiko0017]

Sadly with how things are looking now, I bet some teachers have actually done this.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

@@yumiko0017 then I bet some parents with legal degrees sued the hell out of the school!

[@bluehydrangea5506]

A school is literally being sued rn because a councilor gave a child a chest binder + encouraged them to be trans without telling their parents

[@StarfireReborn]

"This Isn't How It Happens, But If It Did..." Blah Blah Blah... Nobody Ever Does Anything, Too Afraid To Be Labeled A Bigot Or A 'Phobe.

[@janeemflores]

Exactly. And the fact that nobody let the parents know what their kid is doing or has decided is a bunch of BS. Also, that teacher saying the parents are resistant to their changing identity is seriously triggering. No, they're not resisting to it. They didn't even know it was happening. Fuckng shit. Who are the writers of this series?

[@moleahy6880]

The thing I particularly like about Charlotte and Harry is that they are so believable. I've known many women who had this picture of marrying the perfect man and living the perfect life. And then the guy they fell in love with and married was the complete opposite of that. But he was a wonderful man, a terrific husband, and a great father to their children.

[@c.2538]

This is the dumbest part of the whole dumpster fire storyline.

[@Anthony-co4go]

To the writers please please never again..THE STUPIDITY!!!!!

[@evehastings9189]

Very very dumb

[@racheltwigg]

I would immediately pull my kid out if that school and tell those teachers off. The nerve of them to “correct” a father for calling his daughter by her name.

[@Amanda-zg9pz]

Wow! This scene is horrifying on so many levels. This is one time where Harry makes so much sense and these teachers sound like they have had a lobotomy.

[@kathconserv]

HBO is such such crap. They forgot that their fans have grown into their forties and fifties.

[@alemar5810]

​@@kathconserv So what?

[@justvibin7883]

Unfortunately that’s the reality of this world now

[@hidesertroamer]

@@kathconserv There are gender fluid, trans, non binary and gay people on their 40’s and 50’s. I’m in my 60’s and I support freedom of sexual identity for everyone. Not all of us become fossils.

[@kathconserv]

@@hidesertroamer be whatever you want but none of these ideals should be taught in school.

[@EM-lz9kg]

It was so patronising the way the teachers spoke to the parents, what’s happening are that we are all being told we backward bigots who can’t question change

[@Anthony-co4go]

Well its very sad whats happening..a relative of mine punched teacher out cold after a scene worse than this..After he punched him he went to jail overnight and now owes lots of money worth it? prob not BUT he would do it again.

[@ainsleystuart1234]

It’s horrible. They’re shoving it down our throats. And we’ll just shamed, attacked, or even fired for even questioning things

[@StarfireReborn]

When Really We Should Be Asking Why It's Okay To Allow Children In Adult Bodies To Tell Adults That Confused Kids Should Have Free Reign To Neuter Themselves So Humanity Dwindles Into More Corrupt Oligarchs Who Won't Be Challenged.

[@FoundSheep-AN]

Who they think they are

[@paulg6527]

"Rock," a total disregard to the parents' concerns.

[@StarfireReborn]

That's How They Ignore Addressing Actual Concerns Like "How Badly Is My Child Bullied" & "Is My Child Being Abused By An Older Faculty Member" Or "Is My Child Abusing Substances" Or "Does A Lack Of Common Values Cause This Perversion"

[@FC-hj9ub]

I love Charlotte's outfit. Some one didn't die in this series apparently.

[@ericaawake9503]

Oh shut up !

[@TititoDeBologay]

The amount of virtue signalling this show deploys, to hide the lack of actual storytelling, is just foolish at this point. Not only it's inorganic, but It also does a disservice to the issue, it's trying to depict.

[@lourdesrobles4033]

1:19 her saying “rock” like that was so rude. Rose is still his child.

[@norajeffry7368]

Exactly!!! She kinda crossed the line doing that

[@rainbowrainbow8220]

She is arrogant and self righteous! How dare she? I would never tolerate this kind of school and the teachers!

[@BlackCatFilmProductions]

Yeah, I watch this twice already and I see what you mean. This teacher is very rude to both Charlotte and Harry.

[@cristianrey1032]

This is so wrong at so many levels. The show is basically now a flagpole for parents being told by teachers how to raise their kids. As if in place of Charlotte and Harry, two intelligent, well educated, mundane middle aged adults, they were instead dealing with two illiterate dumbs from the middle ages. And the way Charlotte places her hand on him was the ultimate insult...."They know better than you, honey.." seems to be the unspoken line. Truly disgusting.

[@Anthony-co4go]

Excellent comment. I mean SATC ok so so...THIS is something else..tailor made to todays narrative. Grotesque on many levels.

[@yeetnama9094]

It's so stupid. This blatant propaganda is such garbage. The woke cult has absolutely hijacked our public education system, and now they think they own our own children

[@malcolmschnauzer1054]

You said everything that went through my mind, while watching this woke garbage.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

Why the hell didn't Harry read those women the riot act?! Why didn't he explain that Rose was his mother's name, and he does not need to be schooled by people who have no skin in the game?! He's a lawyer - he is the father, one of the the legal guardians of the child - legally, the kid doesn't have rights. The kid can't do anything without parental consent until age 18! "Rose is 12 years old - if she had her way, she 'd eat ice cream for every meal." Sure, let her play around, experiment, but until she's of age, age doesn't call the shots!

[@heatherhoward8064]

This scene infuriated me, too, but I think Charlotte was trying to get Harry to stay calm. She probably realized how angry he was getting and just wanted to keep the conversation civil. I don't think she was putting him down.

[@eboli7146]

This is beyond ridiculous. My sister for years as a kid was adamantly a tomboy, wore every day without fail short cropped hair, overalls and a baseball cap. Before that she went through a phase of pretending to be a dog and barking instead of talking. At various points she wanted to change her name. My parents didn’t pay it much attention. Now age 30 I would say she is the opposite of a tomboy and spends heavily on hair/makeup/clothes. She now insists on being called by her full birth name which apparently she didn’t like before. Kids go through phases all the time and I don’t think it’s wise to take them too seriously !!!

[@EM-lz9kg]

Well said , plus I couldn’t believe there term TOMBOY in the show is now not allowed

[@Anthony-co4go]

correct. taken wayyyyyy to seriously..One my nephews thinks that urinating in a vagina is how you make a baby. Um no that wont work, he will figure it out, lets not call the school psychiatrist , lets not hold a conferance, lets no go stupid..hes 11 years old..

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

It's so nice to see we're all on the same page on this trainwreck of a show...

[@andrej2932]

YES THIS, and the teachers acted like harry and charlotte were so insensitive to the situation, but in reality how can a child know…let alone be sure that they have a different identity, like come awnn

[@sophianachtigall3598]

I was like that! Well not the dog and barking part 😂 but definitely a tomboy. And I dressed like a boy. If that was a thing 20 years ago, who knows, maybe I would like to be gender neutral. (I never knew until recently that this could be an option) And my parents have always seen that as a phase, no one got excited about my hair a la Tokio Hotel boys (referring a German band, hope you know them). And now?! Well I am a lady with a red lipstick and a dress.

[@kramirezCordero]

Sureeee!!!! Cant drive! Cant drink alcohol!!!! Cant get a tattoo !!! But SUre!! u can decide ur identity at 12!!!!! Seriously?!!?!?! Im 33 and Im STILL figuring myself out!!! Im from Dominican Rep. WTH is going on in that country yall?

[@theprousteffect9717]

No one is "deciding their identity" for the rest of their lives. Who cares if children identify a certain way? Let them be. Maybe it's a phase, maybe it's not.

[@thehumannugakareemsupreme9484]

The devil is running wild

[@msriram9884]

To see a 12 year old is very certain about something is developmentally ridiculous. Pick a group of adults and ask them what they wanted to be at 12 or what they wanted to do at 12.

[@rainbowrainbow8220]

How do these teachers and the school explain “a supportive environment, or we are all in this together”? Allow a 12 years old to change her name without even involving the parents? Do they call this “supportive”? This is negligence! Shame for the teachers, dumb, lost souls!

[@Boobalopbop]

It’s absurd. When the kid asked them to call her Rock, they could have but then contacted the parents to see whats going on and if they need to update their files.

[@amberinezaki969]

Yet another example why this remake is a joke. The three women just sit there while all these changes are thrown at them and they are expected to just get on board without questioning or processing? Oh sorry, I forgot. Questioning is not allowed. Not PC. Just stay dumb and never ask a question or raise an objection.

[@Anthony-co4go]

There teachers and most of them SUCK !...worst offenders are college professors the indoctrinators ......Parent they are YOUR kids..they are just overpaid baby sitters that do a piss poor job anyway...empower your children.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

@J N I don't think anyone is stupid enough not to realise this is a TV show. 🙄

[@english484]

If I were the parents in that kind of situation, I would get in the teacher’s faces and tell them to not dare correct me on how I raise my child or the name of my child. They have no right making any changes like that without informing me no matter how determined the child may seem. Then of course I’d take my child out of that school and find some way to ruin the lives of those teachers.

[@TheJuiceor]

@J N this is not doing their best. So many trans people regret going through with the surgery yet society pushes every kid to do it.Let the kid grow up!They are horrible people and should not have a say in that

[@thedespense3778]

@@TheJuiceor literally not that many but bigots like you really want to pretend. and transitioning is expensive as hell and normally not covered in insurance so it like it’s that accessible anyways

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

Harry should sue the crap out of that school. They totally crossed a line!

[@breekc6783]

WHOAH WHOAH WHOAH! Harry and Charlotte are the parents of Rose/Rock and yet they were NOT informed of this situation that concerns their own child by the teachers or said child, yet they (Harry and Charlotte) are in the wrong and accused of being resistant? WTF!?!?!?!?!? They didn't know what was going on; had they have known, they would have been FULLY supportive of their child

[@melodyeisenberg2789]

Which makes you wonder why, or how they didn't know. Their not being treated as if they're wrong. Resistant isnt wrong. But that was your perception and theirs. Neither is being shocked, or confused, misinformed etc.

[@georgecameron4754]

@@melodyeisenberg2789 The teacher literally tried to correct the father about HIS CHILD'S name. That's a textbook example of "being treated as if they're wrong".

[@paulg6527]

If there is anything going on with a student, teachers should always consult/address those issues with parents and not just go along with it. It's their responsibility.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

Harry is a lawyer. He needs to remind people of the legal situation here. The school is 100% in the wrong for not keeping the parents in the loop. They need to move the kid to another school!

[@breekc6783]

Exactly. Teachers have an obligation of care to their students and if ANYTHING happens with a child they MUST inform the parents/guardians before they take any action

[@jeanandre6998]

Some don’t for fear of abuse at home after the parents find out

[@theprousteffect9717]

Outing children to their parents can put the children's safety and livelihood at risk. Not all parents take that news well and may become emotionally and physically abusive, or throw their children out of the house.

[@milmanpodcast]

Even though this scene is tough and appalling to watch, I’m glad it exists. Let people actually have a glimpse of what goes on in the schools rather than just hearing about it.

[@Faithplus1SouthPark]

Well spoken. I like your thought process.

[@melodyeisenberg2789]

What do you suggest is the alternative when a child has clearly and repeatedly expressed an expression of identity. Schools take a stance as to hear the expression as valid. This approach has been established for protection to all students due to the mass bullying that has taken place for years. This is an all exclusive approach. To teach acceptance as the norm.

[@Honeybees1005]

@@melodyeisenberg2789Ok Groomer

[@melodyeisenberg2789]

@@Honeybees1005 Clearly you have fear of exposure.

[@genxx2724]

​@@melodyeisenberg2789 I think the pendulum has swung too far. Rather than teaching the students to be respectful and kind to all, they are promoting gender and sexual orientation as choices, and that one can change one’s mind about it at will. This isn’t true, and furthermore I believe it’s ludicrous to put this kind of time and focus on an issue that affects less than one percent of the population.

[@cmendy1809]

When I was young I used to wear boys clothes and found that being a boy is just the better gender. I would tell my mother that I want to be a boy so she went to the doctors and he told her that she should consider a hormone therapy etc. my mother didn’t took it serious and now few year later I’m a growing women, love every bit of my female body, I’m so glad my mother never did that, I would feel horrible today. Don’t buy everything your child says, wait until a certain age and then let them do, if your child regrets it, he/she will need to take the consequence by them self and can’t blame their parents for it.

[@emilymay6369]

The doctor wouldn’t have given you testosterone or anything yet, you would have gotten extensive counselling and puberty blockers (completely harmless, once you stop taking them your puberty would have resumed as normal and they just mean that you would have had to have less surgeries if you had chosen to medically transition) so please don’t act like doing nothing if your child is struggling with gender identity is the right way for parents to deal with children who might be trans just because it worked out well for you (though I am happy it did) because it could damage an actual trans kids health and care - like people trying to ban puberty blockers claiming they have side effects despite them being used safely on kids who were growing too fast for years before even being suggested as a treatment for trans kids.

[@cmendy1809]

@@emilymay6369 Puberty blockers can cause irreversible change, such as breast development and deepening of the voice. I’m very feminine and it would be an issue for me today if I would know my breast are underdeveloped or my voice has deepened because of that. Let your child reach a certain age like 16 years and let them make the decision by themselves, but as a parent it is just irresponsible to let a child make such a major decision. The day your child regrets it, it will blame you for that, as he/she should, because you as a parent have failed.

[@josie5670]

@@cmendy1809 exactly puberty blockers can cause a lot of problems. Why is everyone so desprate to start pumping kids with tablets anyway? Christ alive, not your kids? Then butt your nose out

[@kabirrubaiyat]

Your mother is a wise lady. That doctor is a criminal, as are those endorsing hormone therapy!!

[@sayyestolife333]

​@@emilymay6369pubery blockers are not harmless. The makers of the drug used to block puberty have over 20 thousands lawsuits filed against them because adults who took the same drug are suffering from the side effects years later.

[@Brucehumphrey]

I’m gay and when I was a kid I loved to play with my sister’s dolls and loved wearing my mom’s heels. That didn’t make me trans or “nOn-BiNarY.” Not having 100% masculine or feminine traits/hobbies is called a personality, not “genderless.” This show is a full blown clown show🙄 Statistically speaking, almost 100% of kids who don’t like their assigned gender when they’re young change their mind and realize it’s just a phase. Encouraging a kid to be trans before 18 is child abuse. Also, how come the parents be literally the last ones to know about this clownery? Rose was simply a spoiled little brat. Nothing else.

[@carmelmulroy6459]

Thank goodness my parents weren't woke back in the day. I didn't grow out wanting to be a man until I was 25

[@evehastings9189]

Yeah ! In the show Rose is only 12 !

[@existentialcrisis8902]

your ideas are simply why we need to protect transgender youth.

[@fp5495]

@@existentialcrisis8902 stuff it

[@Brucehumphrey]

@@existentialcrisis8902 You mean from transitioning until they’re 18? Absolutely.

[@howardchu6302]

As a teacher, I felt so upset for Charlotte and Harry. While it's not a teacher's place to disclose a student's gender or sexual identity to others in any circumstances, a teacher should at least encourage the student to have this discussion with their parents. To give a specific example, report cards. If a student wishes to change their pronouns, the parents need to know ahead and not be surprised what reading their child's marks. What's more, these teachers were almost treating Charlotte and Harry as bad parents, which we all know cannot be further from the truth. And on another note, Rock's character was not very well done. Claiming they just don't want to be anything in the end after all their parents had done for them..?

[@Honeybees1005]

Nope. Kid is a minor. Not their choice. This is all radicalized BS

[@thehumannugakareemsupreme9484]

Americans 🤦🏾‍♂️. I see why shit is just sinking lower and lower

[@SmidBeach]

When that teacher corrected Harry on his own child's name...at that point I'd seriously consider removing Rose/Rock from the school. Nobody forking over lots of dough for an expensive private school should have their parental authority usurped. You can have a supportive environment for a gender fluid child, but the way they're addressing the parents is just wrongheaded.

[@maxsthoughts6204]

Well that’s probably because you’re a bad parent.

[@shiz777]

@@maxsthoughts6204 Because they don't buy into bogus theories?

[@Nirobiscloset10]

Exactly.

[@RiniDiamandis]

I'm happy they're tackling this cos this is exactly how schools treat this. And I'm happy how in another scene Charlotte asks "are you just doing this bcos Eli did this? Ncos everyone else at school is doing this?" Even Rose making a cringe tt about it, it's v much a trend for A LOT of ppl, similarly to how faking and claiming mental illnesses is now i trend. Seriously the DID epidemic is at an all time high on tt. Tons of schools now have this thing where they offer a safe space for trans or questioning kids, which is fine, but alot of teachers even head support groups and stuff and the safe part treats it kinda like therapy, so they don't talk to the parents unless the kid wants to, so it's kinda encourages kids to talk to their teachers instead of their parents, and ppl tend to blow simple things out of proportion like parents and family members GENUINELY not understanding what enby is and it scares kids like if they'll get kicked out and be homeless stuff bcos we ALWAYS hear about ppl disowning their kids cos they're lgbt. It really does serve as a way to drive a wedge between concerned parents and their kids, esp since a handful of these teachers are lgbt themselves. So it's like they're ""out"" to their friends, out at school and in social circles including social media and then get online and complain about how phobic their family members (ppl who genuinely care for them) are. Its like if school is worried about parents being GENUINELY transphobic and/or abusive then actual steps should be taken to protect that kid like cps or something. But kids are just encouraged to like keep secrets from their parents and that further the alienates them and encourages them to seek comfort from randoms who unlike their parents might NOT have their best interest at heart. Like I've seen tts where kids complain about their parents "deadnaming" them and "misgendering" them and how it makes them wanna die, but they aren't even out to their parents and then the comments are just like "omg here if you need t talk" Like???? Its just wild tbh

[@Radom3mel]

@@maxsthoughts6204 it's the teachers are being the bad one here. Who the hell are they to tell the parents how to raise their own children and not informing the parents what's going on with their children.

[@justvibin7883]

Comments passed the vibe ✅

[@deerheart87]

Harry used to be so much fun

[@BlackCatFilmProductions]

He is just sad. In the movie when Rose was born Charlotte told Carrie they got the name from Harry's grandmother. I don't know what would happen if my niece or nephew decided to change their name. But I would put it down as a nickname and leave it at that.

[@jayT0204]

Harry’s voice sounds so different

[@scinformation7229]

"This is a very supportive environment for all children, but if your daughter didn't tell you that she'd changed her name and her gender, we don't give a shit. Next?"

[@Hiddenplace414]

My 5 year old wants to be a monster truck..I mean it wants to be a truck 😂

[@sammyp9514]

My child would be OUT of that school. Michael Patrick King is a joke

[@laurajoshi6474]

As an educator myself I would never in a million years tell a parent how to call their child. This is dumb

[@norajeffry7368]

Teachers need to respect their place. Its their child in the end. If they want q safe place then they need to make one for the parents as well. Her saying rock is crossing the line. Overstepping boundries as well wtf. The parents are asking and concerened not for one if them to act like their their childs parent.

[@BlackCatFilmProductions]

Yeah, its like Rose doesn't existed anymore.

[@Anthony-co4go]

way crossing the line.....wwwayyyyy!

[@norajeffry7368]

@@BlackCatFilmProductions abs agree

[@norajeffry7368]

@@Anthony-co4go periodt ik they didnt Carry her and raise her. They need to sit down and be respectful

[@lucasgray1492]

Okay Charlotte and Harry have proven in the previous show that they are intelligent and Charlotte has proven she is capable in so many things. Yet they show them being completely ignorant of their child and the school that the child is going to. As if Charlotte wouldn’t have studied up on as much as she could’ve and as if she wouldn’t have pushed Harry to do the same.

[@stellaplunkett6456]

No offence but a small child coming out as “non-binary” or “nothing” is a huge cry for help! she’s not ignorant.

[@scinformation7229]

Parents have to be careful in front of these type of teachers. The teachers can get their kids put into "Care" and taken away.

[@doctorposting]

bro what charlotte has studied up on it, prob more than most

[@masa-pt9vs]

this is actually mortifying.....this used to be such a good show :(

[@myfriendisaac]

Nobody asked for this 🤷🏾‍♂️😂🚫 Thank God Samantha went M.I.A.

[@Nirobiscloset10]

Exactly.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

This whole series is an exercise in bullying! It's all about ordering people around, like little Red Guards in the Cultural Revolution. "This is now correct, you MUST say this!" Ask any Chinese person how well that turned out.

[@dollparts4918]

Is this rude to say, but imagine if they enrolled Rock/Rose into a public school and she really learnt identifying as something/someone else is actually a struggle & not a trend? I cannot buy R as identifying as someone else seriously with the way she does it "oh I did a tiktok"

[@lilylebowsky5908]

What a BS ....

[@wendyfrench8042]

Shows are to escape not see issues and arguments that play out on the news.

[@JGIRL0323]

what episode is this

[@Honeybees1005]

The teacher correcting a parent with the name ...😡😡😡😡😡😡😡

[@robinh9081]

I’m all about supporting and listening to children but these “teachers” have no right. Rose is just a kid. When they, as adults, finalise their identity for them, it doesn’t real help to explore. The parents should be involved. Always! What a load. Just like that is seriously a load. The only character I’m truly interested in is Steve, I want him to have his happy ending

[@juliaedlund4107]

I feel the same! Steve is the only character with any remaining dignity. This is a shame because I love the original series, but this is just....ugh, I don't even know.

[@markusnashorn1145]

Why do you agree with calling her them, but also use her real name?

[@robinh9081]

@@markusnashorn1145 Because I was talking about all children, not just Rose. If you reread you’ll notice I’m referring to children.

[@melinamollo]

This is so real. This exactly situation happened to my parents when they went to a meeting my brother's school organized to talk about him. The teachers talked to my parents like they were bad persons for not understanding. My brother was 14. We are from latin america and this is happening everywhere

[@nolagirl2458]

What the hell is a they?? Rose is a they? They is plural right? Maybe she has multiple personalities 🤔 who are these psycho teachers?

[@yumiko0017]

Sadly, this is our society now. Makes no damn sense.

[@EmmyPeggyLou]

They has been used as a singular pronoun for decades. It's not new and it's not grammatically incorrect. And even if it was, language can change and adapt. That's why we're not speaking Shakespearean English in 2022.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

@@EmmyPeggyLou 😫 I hate that half argument "language is a living/changing thing" It is, but it is primarily a tool of communication! If you change it without consensus from one day to the next, you are rendering useless! We all need to be on the same page, but now people are using it to divide us - unless you use it this way, you're not allowed to play 🤦🏻‍♀️ The changes in language do not happen overnight - it takes time to be absorbed!

[@EmmyPeggyLou]

@@lenawagenfuehr53 but those changes have to start somewhere? Besides, my point was it's not just an overnight thing, people have been using a singular they for centuries, and you learn that in primary education for those paying attention.

[@danelicker317]

When I was in school, the adults ruled the children. Not the other way around.

[@Mini-Toast_]

Yeah and they were happy to ignore the bullying. Not to mention they were just as scared of the popular kids, for some reason...

[@danelicker317]

@@Mini-Toast_ not at my old school. If you were caught bullying, you had a three day suspension plus you had to write 200 times "I will not bully other kids". You had to number each sentence and after the teacher or principal counted them, they tore the paper in half and threw it out in front of your face.

[@katharina9318]

@@danelicker317 that seems like A level pedagogy *sarcasm* (studying primary school teaching)

[@elizrebezilmadommdo1662]

I don't know what this has to do with students ruling over teachers or whatever. Kids are still doing the assignments that teachers tell them to do, following the rules, etc.

[@kinndah2519]

The kids are finally being heard. Adults used to ignore bullying a lot, now I'm glad schools are over protective. Kids need to feel supported and safe, guided and put in place, but safe.

[@offbeatblackgerl8360]

No no no... I would be so angry at those teachers.

[@MsSopla]

12 YO can be sure about a lot of things but that doesn't mean that in the future it won't change

[@kendawyatt673]

Good lord! I’m dizzy

[@SweetSeraph93]

I'm barfing. I get it, we all get 🙄

[@mooki7525]

I don't give a poop if she's trans but why does she not talk to her parents first about it instead of tiktok and teachers???

[@paulg6527]

Because it's the trend today.

[@chelseagarber]

Because they feel more comfortable with their teachers than they do with their parents.

[@zitronentee]

Unfortunately, a lot of kids like that usually have traditional parents and have difficulty of open communication. Parents expect their kids of something, and their kids respond, and sometimes the kids don't want to disappoint their parents by not telling their issues.

[@elizrebezilmadommdo1662]

Announcing it to the teachers before the parents? I could see that. If this person knows that the parents won't understand as well or will react badly, they might want to tell another trusted adult first. But TikTok? Everyone can see it, including the parents (or someone else who the parents know might see it and mention it to them), since it's online. If I wanted to go by "they/them" and I didn't feel comfortable telling my parents, if I only revealed it online, I know my parents would see it either way.

[@kinndah2519]

Bc not all parents make it easy to speak to them. If you're kid can't come to you for guidance, you're failing as a parent.

[@lilyrose7624]

This was written really well. It shows the struggle Harry and Charlotte are facing, rather than have them all happy and ok with it. I didn't find this woke

[@cherishoneal9108]

It’s perfect because they don’t warm up to it quickly

[@malicia12345]

Rose would be a good tennis player if she was raised by grandpa/grandma York.

[@home9556kefr]

Minus Samantha these two are my only left favorites from original series.

[@Supportfreespeech]

I for one am tired of this crap. When I was growing up this was not a thing. Teenagers go through a plethora of emotional changes that eventually get worked out once they are mature adults. Hollywood needs to stop.

[@koostory1776]

“That’s right, these birthing being should lay down and take it,” said the non-consensual giver.

[@mamacitakova9625]

Knew this show was going to be a shitshow *no pun intended* Too much emphasis on political correctness , not enough on the storyline . Plus this just made everyone to so out of character, Charlotte would be a very and if not the most understanding mother and they would never shit talk Samantha .

[@angelapritchard6640]

I love Harry so much...

[@rafaelortega854]

What a great future those teachers are 🤮🤮🤮

[@MissSunshine8]

Normal the state dictates what your Child is now.

[@marialee9021]

👍🏻👍🏻

[@queerlybeloved257]

The teachers emphasize they're following Rock's wishes about what they want to be called and how they want to be referred to. "The state" isn't dictating who Rock is; Rock -- the child -- is. Which is how it should be. People know their own identities and feelings best. Sure, we technically can choose to follow their wishes or not, but if we choose not to, it signals to them that we're not someone they can really trust and be at ease around.

[@SweetSeraph93]

@@queerlybeloved257 art imitates life...the teachers are now developing the children's identity and politics. It's a weird nanny state now.

[@BlancaPerdomo]

@@SweetSeraph93 🥴🥴

[@SweetSeraph93]

@@BlancaPerdomo 😘🍸?

[@sini3445]

This Robyn person insulting Charlotte and her husband 100 % saying "Rock never gave us any clue her parents were resistant to their changing identity." How inappropriate, rude and just ... I don´t know the word for it. There is absolutely no way a school can behave like this when it comes to matters of a childs name and when their discussing it with the parents. But hey, welcome to 2020. I really hope this isn´t reality or if it was, I would take my children elsewhere.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

It was completely offensive. She's accusing the parents of being bigots because they give their kid sone privacy (which the kid totally abuses)

[@breekc6783]

Charlotte and Harry were NOT resistant; they were confused and had NO idea wtf was going on because NOBODY (not even Rose/Rock themselves) informed them about the situation

[@josefinebliss2801]

Appalling. He is right. Children has no idea what they want or what is good for them. She needs a social media break and to learn that women do not have to be hyperfemme to be classified as women, something that is foreign to teenagers these days.

[@StarfireReborn]

Everyone Should Be More Concerned With Housing The Homeless, Feeding The Starving, And Not Buying Cheap Goods Made By Enslaved Children... But Instead We Have Influencers & Ladyboys... Splendid In America.

[@theprousteffect9717]

That's a very dangerous mindset to have about children. Children deserve to have some sense of autonomy, with limits, of course. One shouldn't automatically assume that it's a phase when a child identifies as a different gender, just as we shouldn't assume it's not a phase. Let it play out for a while and see how they feel. Meet them with love, compassion, and curiosity, not anger, frustration, disrespect, and patronization.

[@EllieBellie_111]

Show of hands, how many women felt like tomboys and didn't feel connected to their femininity while growing up? ✋ How many of you grew out of it and are happy you didn't go to a school that encouraged transitioning you? ✋

[@friedchicken4735]

Meeeeeee and im not a fing trans man

[@josie5670]

Literally me.

[@theprousteffect9717]

Nobody encourages anyone to transition. Bye 👋

[@genxx2724]

She loves Harry so much.

[@Nomoredrama2000]

When I was growing up, I wanted to change my name too. It ranged from adding an extra letter on my name to changing my name entirely. I also, like Rose, didn't always feel like a girl. But I grew out of it. What these teachers are doing is encouraging narcissistic behaviour and gender dysphoria - which a lot of kids do suffer now sadly. Bottom line is, teachers should not be in charge of raising children. That's the parents job.

[@MrChoirDirector87]

This is complete bullshit! That couldn’t be me, I named my child, I’m going to call them what I named them! When they’re grown, they can do whatever they want. Period!

[@theprousteffect9717]

So you're going to disrespect your child and put them through unnecessary emotional distress? Awesome, bro.

[@Donegalwildatlantic]

Boy ,girl there are two only two worlds gone nuts

[@carolynm8421]

I get freedom to explore and all that but a name change that appears on records wouldn't happen without my permission. At twelve year old isn't mature enough for such adult decisions by themselves. Trends can swing too far and ideas once reasonable can become dangerous. Moderation is usually a good idea when we're dealing with things that can effect a peron's entire life.

[@tto2t177]

These days teachers act like they own children they don’t they’re supposed to teach and listen not tell the leanest the right and wrong things to do

[@LD71685]

Propaganda to the max. (Rolls eyes)

[@jos.1839]

I loved the 90s show about actual sex and the city (NY) with original characters. not this sexes and the city show which just wants to be some grotesque manual for society....

[@apllu17]

I think Harry and Charlotte handled that well. I also understand what the teachers are doing and saying. However, there is one episode where Charlotte's friend Anthony gives her a straight talk on how to manage Rose's Gender Identity. kzbin.info/www/bejne/g16QqpaEmLJpp7M

[@sini3445]

I do not understand the teachers. You don´t change a childs name without discussing the matter with the parents.

[@clementlee2121]

Cys gender, gender fluid, non binary. Boys and girls were all we had growing up.

[@theprousteffect9717]

Right, and it didn't work.

[@BM-wh5qk]

If Charlotte were a real person, she would have moved out of NYC as soon as she had a kid.

[@shiz777]

You'd be surprised at how brainwashed people are these days

[@SweetSeraph93]

Imagine this happening in an old NYC school Catholic school? Nope😂😂

[@Boobalopbop]

Catholic school? They’d be kicked out.

[@theprousteffect9717]

Yes, because Catholism is surely at the cutting edge and an authority on child development.

[@kerrid5717]

this exact story has happened in schools before to

[@brandonbath6097]

They somehow got how absolutely ridiculous this is 100% right until the last 10 seconds

[@6-cats]

That Robyn teacher .. "Rock" as if he knows better than the parents.

[@justincase7848]

To all the people saying how awful this was- that was the point. They exaggerated the awfulness of it because this is the direction things go in nowadays.

[@djgualtiermaldeCO]

Watching only this scene makes me think probably this is a critique to this absurd child abuse agenda ...but considering the whole show is an exaltation of the genre agenda, I should say this show should be banned outside the US, were people still think more coherently

[@gilbertflores3034]

Their name is Rose. They’re a 12 year old child. If they want to legally change their name to Rock, they can do so at 18. If they want to be nicknamed Rock, that’s cool too. Don’t tell me what name to call my child by though. I wanted to slap this teacher. My child will explore, and when an adult, she will make decisions she’s capable of making with that experience.

[@markusnashorn1145]

Exactly, but why are you using they instead of she?

[@LindseyObrooke]

Who the literal fck needed to make this show such a PC dumpster fire?? I wouldn’t watch it past the first episode. Nothing political was handled this fcking dumb in the original series. The series was ahead of its time. This is like The Conners. Horrible. What an atrocious thing to do to such a remarkable show in the history of shows.

[@alma4473]

well it is New York

[@claudiam2474]

People from syria or battling real problems or from third countries never have those request...

[@buckwheatusfeatus4825]

Really, Robin corrects Harry on his child's name? What a load of BS.

[@Digmer]

They trying so hard. We woke. We rainbow. We blm!

[@mj-rg9kp]

“Author of confusion” comes to mind. Complete insanity.

[@tobermory88]

Lots of love in these comments

[@oceanzennfamxo833]

They are your children. The teaches are their to teach . For when they are out of school at least parts of life that's needing to be learnt. None of this bs

[@camaleonicas]

Bet that when Charlotte said you are a wonderful father it was impossible to Harry to say the same her. She is the worst “perfect mom” I have seen on TV. Spoiled two brats.

[@mightytaiger3000]

YIKES!!

[@blurdreamer]

Kids are exploring and learn thing, that's why they are kid, there is a reason they not allow to vote until they're adult.

[@deeavery6564]

Bullsh;:!!! Ridiculous storytime

[@marcuscarana9240]

The teachers are so punchable.

[@JessicaChastainFan]

Rock.

[@c4rmen.]

whole queer plot about kids was bullshit

[@EM-lz9kg]

Patronising teachers

[@malcolmschnauzer1054]

Two words....OY VEY!

[@Beatrix7004]

These schools have definitely overreached and overstepped their bounds.

[@lexistenceestailleurs]

What.The.Fuck

[@Trinivy]

Damn yall made about a child changing their name?