And Just Like That | The Mitzvah Scene | HBO Max | S01E10 | [HD]

About this clip: Miranda - for a change - cares for Carrie's opinion on her moving to LA with Che. The eavesdropping rabbi tries to educate the arguing 50 year olds. Later, since Rock acts up and makes Charlotte feel like a loser mom (once again), the latter takes matter in her own hands and becomes "the chosen one" for the "they" mitzvah presided over by the trans-rabbi.

[@EditorEmily30]

“What are you going to do in Paris? Eat croissants?” Yeah yeah we get the reference 😉

[@jelenadimitrijevic1644]

Exactly ☺️

[@ANGIEHINA]

I think the writers are so lazy that this parallel was merely coincidental

[@allbutperfect]

@@ANGIEHINA 😭😂😂 you really believe this????

[@heathermetz3974]

Thank you for including that Miranda-Carrie SATC-NY to Paris, slap back!

[@travelchic3407]

You saved me from saying it. It’s the exact conversation 🙄

[@Serena_9]

Meanwhile, Samantha is dating a millionaire in London and travel around Europe in private jet. She lives happily ever after she dumped these selfish friends. Good for her 👍🏻

[@hidesertroamer]

How long has dating EVER lasted for Samantha?

[@Serena_9]

@@hidesertroamer As fas as I know, Sam is the one who dumped men.

[@hidesertroamer]

@@Serena_9 Yeah, no 💩

[@MaryTheresa1986]

💯

[@nemanjaras]

Samantha's PR company in London went bankrupt and she was forced to find a job as a cashier in Aldi. She's living in a room in a basement in North London and gain 20 kg of weight. She lost her front tooth but can't afford to go to a dentist.

[@Jessicag571]

Rock has to be by far the most spoil annoying child I’ve ever had to witness.

[@JayJay-nc7pr]

@Tami* but Gen Z are the darlings, yet Millennials are still hated upon

[@johniii8147]

It's not spoiled to not have a faith you don't believe in imposed on you.

[@JayJay-nc7pr]

@@johniii8147 This girl has been spoiled the entire series

[@Katie2986]

I went to prep school, I knew worse 😂

[@cupcakequeen0617]

I knew when Rose wouldn’t stop crying in the movie, she would be a pain in the ass child.

[@jrcasselman]

Having grown up lower middle class, the degree to which these children are spoiled simply appalls me.

[@jclyntoledo]

Growing up working class I feel you X2

[@jrcasselman]

@@jclyntoledo I learned this the hard way when I was in University and saw how many of my fellow students had fancy cars and TV sets in their dorms rooms What was worse was seeing how many were planning on vacationing or going off to save the world in attending protests for whatever cause was popular at the time, while I was working away at low end jobs.

[@goldilox3147]

Watching this scene these episodes is cringey. I’m sorry but this was not the sex and the city I was. Expecting I miss Samantha. Try not to compete with others just work harder but also I see in the work I am I where kids who are middle class rewarded for bad behavior daily in stores. I went shopping the other day the mother told the kid no then going out the door she baught him skittles that’s the issue right there rewarding kids with bad behavior it’s giving kids these days even if it is candy a reward for something they didn’t work hard for And I mean that with aka rock rose charlottes kid rewarded her/him for bad behavior she gets a party

[@jrcasselman]

@@goldilox3147 Well, I don't think Rock behaved badly before the party. Their parents bent over backwards to create a gender inclusive Mitzvah (I do not think any Conservative or Orthodox Jews would attend such an event), only to have Rock back out at the last second. That is just plain disrespectful. Rock could have gone with the thing and privately backed out later.

[@shiz777]

To be honest I can't connect with most people because I grew up poor with harsh discipline and traditional values. I am very successful now and very conservative on the inside so I just put on an act with most people since I view them as either spoilt, weak or weird. I only come to this show to see what an absolute train wreck society has become. Cheers!

[@jrwheeler81]

Charlotte has THE MOST annoying children I have ever seen in my entire life.

[@kristinazubic9669]

The only people who stood up to Rock? Anthony and Jen. Not the parents.

[@bryanstein9240]

I mean you don't want hit them ever or scream at them nonstop like Miranda does but teach them to not be a massive asshole

[@natevic1867]

Yeah but it’s pretty much her and Harry’s fault. They spoil their kids too much

[@GiftSparks]

Charlotte and Harry really dropped the ball on parenting. Rock is disrespectful. See if they revoke her privileges how she would just behave.

[@taroman7100]

any surprise over indulging perhaps useless people Who would care anything for these people?

[@lisal.5119]

Wait. What? Charlotte and Harry just spent $40,000-$50,000 for a Bat Mitzvah and their kid bails on them? The lack of respect is mind blowing! Talk about self-involved and selfish. I don't care if she is only thirteen.

[@queerlybeloved257]

They. Not "she." You can critique their behavior if you want, but to not use their correct pronouns is -- to use your words -- a lack of respect.

[@iluvjakee]

it’s they. get it right.

[@MaryTheresa1986]

I agree with you, Lisa. Rock is a selfish, ungrateful brat who should be sent off to military school.

[@smustipher]

Sheeeshhh...I wish my parents threw a bat mitvah for me lol...but seriously, Rock could just do it, and be grateful their family has some culture and cares about them.

[@hannahrozenberg3411]

@@smustipher it’s a beautiful ceremony. I had a combined Bar/Bat Mitzvah with other members of our congregation who had decided to go through with the ceremony later on in life. And even more meaningful, my mom and grandma were in the group. We have a three generation Bat Mitzvah. I was 20. It’s never too late.

[@ANGIEHINA]

Rock is entitled to not be labeled and to have any believe system they prefer, but it is pretty inconsiderate to wait until the day of the ceremony to bail out of it, specially after all the work Charlotte put into to make it inclusive and fit to them. If they didn't want to do it, they should have discussed it with their parents way sooner or even the day before.

[@netdsgirl7794]

Yes!! I was going to write the same response. So inconsiderate of them after all that work.

[@natevic1867]

The fact that she was able to get anyway with it without her parents being angry at her is the biggest joke. If I tried doing this shit at a ceremony that was for me I wouldn’t be asked, I’d be dragged out. And if I still didn’t do it my parents would be VERY angry at me for several weeks afterwards.

[@adikusuma3839]

And let's not forget about the money spent

[@emma2370]

If Rock were most peoples kid they would be identifying as poor and in their room after this stunt.

[@brendapayne6603]

That scene reminds me of one of my nieces. She was not going to graduate from high school, but waited until the last day to tell her parents. They spent money on grad night clothes, bought admission tickets and even hired a limo to take her around to the parties and places. Things they never had. Things they really could not afford, but somehow found a way. She went to all the places and used the limo as though she had graduated. Both my mother and I spent money to go there to watch her graduate. It was really pitiful.

[@georgiadixon3046]

The connection between friends has gone, they are just reading lines and they’ve forgotten how to be their characters. What a shame.

[@winterfire1097]

And Miranda is now just Cynthia Nixon with a grey wig.

[@michellecnebrown6792]

I feel the exact same. It was time to stop after the movies. I hope they realize it's over now, and stop messing with the legacy. This time we live in now negatively affected the script as well.

[@stella.s2macedo]

@@michellecnebrown6792 they should have stopped after the first movie. The second feature was already unnecessary!

[@michellecnebrown6792]

@@stella.s2macedoYou r right. For damn sure!

[@MN-re9oh]

Totally agree. There's no chemistry there anymore...where'd it go?!

[@adelkaizbest2038]

So we have to do everything our kids want so they can feel comfortable 100 % of the time but they don´t have to respect our work we did for them to feel included?

[@chocollatelover15]

Definitely not the way I was brought up and I'm grateful for it.

[@maylalyons677]

Agreed!

[@KD-ou2np]

Don't shower your kid with shit actually learn to communicate with them and they won't turn out like this

[@mateiadrian7668]

Of course because in life one never has to do anything they’re not 100% comfortable with. Haven’t you heard? That’s how life works! It’s all fun and chill 🫶🏻 who needs responsible people when we can have adults who don’t “identify” with their address. Very curious where Rock will receive mail if they don’t identify as a New Yorker.

[@adelkaizbest2038]

@@mateiadrian7668 Yeah. Tf that means 'I don't identify as New Yorker' 🤨

[@ellenjohnson9043]

Dear god, what have they done to SATC?? 😬😳

[@NOMADcourier85]

They got WOKE charming isn't it?

[@quirkyhill]

seems too woke. i don't think i could bear watching it :X

[@FC-hj9ub]

Lobotomised the characters and tried wayyyyy too hard

[@mayln163]

I felt bad for Charlotte. She did everything to support Rock only for them to be ungrateful and selfish.

[@MaryTheresa1986]

Right?! That brat needs to be sent to military school.

[@Alfiezeka123]

Her*

[@boynamedalexxx]

@@Alfiezeka123 it’s them. We refer to people by they and them arbitrarily all the time, usually without even realizing it. But someone asks to be referred to by that? Oh, I get it, that’s just tooo much.

[@Alfiezeka123]

@@boynamedalexxx it really is. It is absolutely crazy too.

[@KD-ou2np]

She raised a selfish kid, you can't blame the kid for growing up that way when you give them shit everytime they get upset from day one.

[@jlo803]

"That Brat-mitzvah beast...!"

[@stanbalo]

Jenny

[@taneciaevans1112]

That’s what she would say 😂

[@StargazerNorth1]

You can see the problem when Harry’s solution is to offer to bribe Rock with expensive trinkets. Maybe try parenting your kid instead, dude?

[@Plantlady70]

And let’s say a word about Harry. He wouldn’t even think about Charlotte as a wife unless she converted, yet will let his kids deny his faith? C’mon.

[@StargazerNorth1]

@@Plantlady70 If Harry really loved Charlotte, he'd have married her regardless of her faith. I always hated that she had to convert for him. No man is worth giving up who you are for.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

@@StargazerNorth1 she never called him out on his hypocrisy. Oh yeah, I have to respect your religion, but you don't have to respect mine?! There are so many mixed marriages out there (mine included). You compromise, you live, you love!

[@LittleMissHoop]

What kind of a father is Harry? Zero authority? Really?

[@annaheart7731]

With all that money, you'd think he would be better respected.

[@UsernameUnkwn21]

When did 13 year old kids who don't pay the bills get away with making the rules

[@MaryTheresa1986]

Right?! Charlotte and Harry should've dragged the brat out by their entitled little ears.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

@@MaryTheresa1986 or just let Anthony deal with her entitled butt! I say make her work for him for two months - learn some discipline and respect (and that the world does not owe you a living!)

[@MaryTheresa1986]

@@lenawagenfuehr53 That's a great idea! Charlotte and Harry have spines made of jelly, so Anthony is that kid's last hope.

[@juliancain3872]

I do wish the kid would have told Harry and Charlotte they didn't want this before they spent all this money. And the way this was handled was atrocious. But if you're not committed to this religion, I would understand not wanting to go through with it. Still, if my kid spoke to me this way in this situation? Your credit cards, frozen. Your allowence? Gone. And you'll be working at uncle Anthony's everyday after school for the next year, as in this senario Charlotte deemed the buisness appropriate for kids.

[@wendynavarro7953]

Spoiled brat is Rose/Rock

[@tabbypurrkins9129]

What an amazing Brat Mitzvah

[@jackie5046]

It was a very bad choice on the writer's part for the conversation Carrie and Miranda had about Carrie going to Paris not come up in this scene. Completely implausible. If that were real life Carrie would have reminded Miranda of it in a heartbeat. The writers dropped the ball completely

[@fbueller]

The new writers don’t seem to have watched the original ‘SATC’ series.

[@jackie5046]

@@fbueller LMFAO 🤣🤣

[@股運亨通]

exactly ! should have echoed the scene when Miranda advised Carrie not to quit her job & go to paris

[@rentme2011]

@@fbueller exactly. They also missed the opportunity to bring up Berger breaking up with Carrie via Post It note as Carries worst break up story on podcast

[@mariasingh6155]

Lazy writing, this whole train wreck of a show.

[@valkyriesardo278]

The conspicuous consumption in this show is way over the top. These women lead lives of luxury, boundless self-indulgence, and yet become traumatized at the most trivial setback. These are the last people I'd want to be stuck with if any real hardship struck.

[@blugreen123]

What is Charlotte wearing?! Prom circa 1993 needs it's dress back! 😂

[@rebelraccoon9018]

She is wearing clothes. There's no time limit to what we wear.

[@bigbowlowrong4694]

wow this is just THE WORST, am amazed the writers somehow came up with something more insufferable than the movies😆

[@Jays6926]

Rock’s storyline is very messed up. Yes you don’t have to be labeled ; but it is important to have your intersectionalities and acknowledge them. Rock and their sister seem very involved in social justice issues; it would make sense to take pride in their Jewish heritage especially since they’ve always been marginalized.

[@banannakis6723]

Yeah, that I don't get, the Jewish people have been mistreated and marginalized just like the Queer community for example. I would think both of them would want to cherish that culture of their family and people. And want their voices to be heard and respected in that culture.

[@59jlopez70]

Not a New Yorker?? Your born in New York you can’t say you wanna be you if you don’t know or accept who you really are. This a big slap in the Jewish peoples face.

[@a.g.m9078]

I mean if she doesnt believe in it, she doesnt, tho its the only thing I agree with her on, she could still do it just in the case she does change her mind later on, but shes still a child, a 12 year old and Charlotte,as Anthony says, is too indulgent

[@yanan4249]

@@59jlopez70 but by the same logic she was actually born a girl. And there is not much choice about it as well because our science haven't learned yet to turn a woman to a man. You can look like a boy and take all those hormones but still you won't have a man's reproductive system.

[@openyourmind3763]

Well, teenagers are pain in the asses, they have thier own thoughts and preferences, especially when raised in a safe, loving home where there is no trauma or authoritarian parenting restricting them. The world is changing and we have to accept it. As hard as it is, and sad at times, i would rather accept my kid then they cut me off or kill themselves. A lot of kids and LGBTQIA people suicide and we just can't have that. As disappointed as Charlotte was, what she ultimately did was the most loving thing a parent could do, which is process her feelings but then unconditionally love and accept her child, as every parent should.

[@annearaullo2917]

Miranda gave Carrie a hard time for changing her mind about heaven. Miranda can be critical of Carrie but cannot handle any questioning of her not following through on her internship. In Miranda’s world only Miranda can change.

[@Radom3mel]

This season had made me hate Miranda

[@goldenpineapple8838]

Her friends husband just died. You'd think she'd keep her stupid comments to herself. Miranda has just regressed as a person

[@Radom3mel]

@@goldenpineapple8838 exactly, she's the worst

[@jacquiew.9165]

Miranda has ALWAYS been like this. I can't believe people never saw it before.

[@terry9238]

This. Was. Not. Miranda. This was bad fan fiction-written by someone whose fantasy was Miranda leaving her family and career for someone JUST LIKE THE WRITER.

[@shirin9452]

Wait wait I’m so happy for you?? Tf is this show Charlotte ripped Carrie a new one when she cheated with Big on Aiden (rightfully so), and now she’s fine with Miranda cheating on her husband of many years!? True Charlotte would lose her mind

[@FOWLR4NOW]

Yep, Che Diaz, “the player” is totally gonna settle down w/ this out of touch, snaggle toothed old lady ... sure 👌🏼

[@justme1892]

She will because this is Cynthia Nixon’s fanfic toon

[@AnniK243]

The only thing I learnt is that Charlotte should've just had one, an adopted child, Lily. Because Rose is too spoilt and has a disgusting, entitled attitude.

[@serenity8295]

cause Char spoiled kiddos

[@luckydevil1601]

Lily is a spoilt brat too

[@tiffanyferguson829]

So is Che going to take care of Miranda when Steve takes her to the cleaner in the divorce? Not to mention she has to pay child support until Brady get out of college.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

Steve won't take her to the cleaners. But they'll have to sell the townhouse and pay for Brady's education (looks more like Vo-tech anyway) Miranda is torpedoing her life and letting the chips fall where they may... it's not going to be pretty, but fortunately Steve is a sweetheart.

[@trollinfojustice]

The reason we watched Sex and the City is because of the fun and lightheartedness. It's sooo depressing now 💆

[@christineboutin4971]

I am so annoyed at Rock in this scene. Her parents were very considerate and made alterations to the ceremony to fit her identity. The least she could have done was gone along with it. They should not have given her all that power and told her that when she moves away from home she is able to be whatever she wants(They were accepting her already as a Binary).

[@hannahrozenberg3411]

Rock should have gone along with it. You’re gonna be a Jew either way baby, your dad is a Jew and your mom Converted, which in the Reform movement means you’re a Jew! You may decide to follow traditions, observe holidays and other things, but you’re still a Jew. And do have your family nearly waste so much money for you to decide right then and there it’s not for you, ridiculous. Listen I wasn’t Bat Mitzvah at 13 because I was not ready to be. I wasn’t ready until I was 20, when I had the ceremony, alongside my mom and grandma who also weren’t Bat Mitzvahs at 13. Didn’t need to push it for 13, just wait.

[@loisen]

@@hannahrozenberg3411 Not only in the reformed. If your mother converted then you’re Jewish.

[@brunosalada7790]

their parents.

[@alexanderfischervonmollard2472]

"Their parents"

[@shaylalauren]

This isn’t realistic. The writers didn’t like the hard core fans that much. 😂😂😂😂

[@TheChunjun]

CRINGE

[@walelu777]

Sorry, not sorry… but I’d never let my child choose their own name and behave the way Rose has. Her name is rose. And if she were mine, I’d pull her out of that school who lets a 12 year old change things that in reality, have to be legally done. I’d say, “you are Rose and you’re a girl. Sorry. Be a tomboy, dress like a boy, do boy things, do girl things. But you’re a girl biologically. 1000 years from now, if your remains are found, you’ll be labeled as female. And again, your name is Rose until you’re old enough and have enough of your own money to go to social security and change it legally.” There are some decisions that parents have to make… what kind of world are we living in that parents have given control to the children? Call me a crappy person… It’s never going to change my mind.

[@Radom3mel]

I agree 100%

[@PinkyakaAyannaj]

I agree

[@anthonyL1995]

Please stay in Florida...

[@bluetomato8698]

Amen!!!!!!

[@lindac5680]

I agree! Her name is Rose!

[@winterfire1097]

Miranda perhaps the reason you're looking for Carrie's approval is because YOU have a hunch this is wrong and Carrie just confirmed it by pointing out the fact that this is a mirror of Alexander Petrovsky (except he was hot and talented). In fact I'm starting to wonder if Miranda had a stroke hence the 180 on her personality. Rabbi Jen is amazing but she needed to honestly have more time with Rose/Roc to show them just how utterly disrespectful they are to theiir family. Charlotte and Harry are loving and accepting parents to a fault and they are not just taking advantage of that but also disrespectful and ungrateful as fuk. I was so glad Anthony scolded them, someone needs to. Roc needs to be told NO more often or real world is gonna be cold wake up. I'm glad Anthony is still around to at least provide some of that.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

THIS! Preach!!

[@monicag6715]

A trans Rabbi? I don’t think so. Not kosher.

[@banannakis6723]

So Carrie isn't gonna bring up the fact that Miranda pulled this on her when she was leaving for Paris or the fact that Miranda hasn't mentioned Brady (her son) in any of this? What kind of writing is this? Also, the actress who plays the rabbi looks familiar, who is she?

[@lizze490]

Trans model/actress Hari Nef.

[@banannakis6723]

@@lizze490 Ah, that's who she is. Now I remember her.

[@bryanstein9240]

She was on will and grace she also married jack

[@jlo803]

She's the annoying star writer from YOU season 1

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

Exactly! Miranda, you were unhappy, but you have a family and a shared house. How are you going to disolve your assets, how are you going to provide for Brady's future?

[@natevic1867]

Charlotte doing the they-mitzvah instead is where the problem lies. They are way too lenient on their kid. There was no way in my family that I’d have been able to say no to anything, especially not a celebration that was thrown for me. My parents would have dragged me out and forced me to do it. They spend all that money and time preparing it and she (or they) just says no to it? And then they try using BRIBES to get her to change her mind?! lol if only we all had parents like that.

[@MaryTheresa1986]

Yeah, if Rock was my kid they would've been on that stage either going through with the ceremony, or apologizing for wasting everyone's time. They also would be paying me back with their college fund.

[@english484]

Exactly! They are not helping their kid by indulging her behavior. At 13, my parents were not afraid to tell me when I was being a dumbass and got in my face. I’ll always be grateful for that, Otherwise I’d be a pitiful woman today.

[@dorkiecookie]

Did we all not watch the same show? Didn’t Rock tell Charlotte a few time that they did not want to go through it and Charlotte did it anyway? What’s the point of forcing Rock to go through with the they mitzvah if it’s only for show. This is a commitment to one own’s faith. Charlotte very clearly back in SATC and in AJLT shows that she is committed to being Jewish. While this might have not been her bat mitvah originally, she gets to have one and strengthen her ties with God. Charlotte is a supportive mother with the best intentions even if the outcomes were not successful.

[@winterfire1097]

@@english484 Rose/Rock is never going to learn how to survive with Harry bribing them and Charlotte just wilting over the slightest little "No.. I wanna be nothing. Waaaa.." they need Super Nanny or the freakin Oompa Loompas from Willy Wonka.

[@b3_b3]

Same haha my parents wouldn’t give an f & make me go out there. I would’ve been way too scared of the consequences as a child. Lily & Rock on the other side are just spoiled brats who don’t respect their parents.

[@ladyditn1239]

I love how they recycle old storylines. Wow...didn't this exact same thing happen in reverse when Carrie was moving to France??? This show is ridiculous!!!!

[@cynthiastephie]

True and Carrie now is the one upset lol

[@lizziebkennedy7505]

Wow. So many people don't think an experience is real until it happens to them. Double standards are one of the banes of friendship.

[@davidmcmahon5809]

That was a pretty lame hand wash.

[@Camilla550]

Wow the writers really did go out of their way to make Lily and Rose/Rock the most unlikeable, annoying, spoiled and ungrateful teenagers ever! Being non-binary or whatever Rose/Rock wants to call themselves is NOT an excuse to be so disrespectful and ungrateful to their parents who have been immensely supportive of them.

[@annaheart7731]

It's a symbolic punishment for being a parent in this series. Either you're a childless or your children are a nigtmare (Miranda's son is also a dick). So the message is clear - don't have children, don't have a traditional family, you'll be fun and easy living only if you're a trans, lesbian, depraved childless.

[@telepathicmagicshop]

@@annaheart7731depraved childless😂

[@DDYLAN19]

The rabbi was the only part of this whole series that could have worked, a new character who didn't have to be introduced for anything other than being funny, wow did this show miss the mark! No need for a series 2!!!!

[@juliefizpatrick513]

The rainbow Yarmulkes were a bit much.

[@jrwheeler81]

EVERYTHING about this was a bit much, LOL. A trans rabbi???? OMG.

[@juliefizpatrick513]

@@jrwheeler81 Right!!

[@kristinazubic9669]

@@jrwheeler81 and the kid didn’t even do it!

[@cherrywilson6267]

This show is so left and woke, it’s disgusting…

[@lindac5680]

I agree, very disappointing!

[@MeMeDaVinci]

Make it a "me-mitzvah" and have a party.

[@emma2370]

I am so shocked that Carrie and Charlotte have not sat Miranda down and had a come to Jesus talk. Ruining your entire marriage and career for a shitty comedian who is just “getting to know” you?

[@dietrichjoanne]

Miranda is becoming crazy and unbalanced. She had a great family and career. Che said she doesn't want a traditional life. She is offering Miranda nothing.

[@winterfire1097]

And running off to L.A for a fuckin pilot of a show!? Does she even know how risky that is!? Most shows pilots fail and the series gets canned. Then what will Che do? Drink and smoke weed more because everything didn't work out? I would LOVE it if Che did get all Alexander Petrovsky and Steve came to Miranda's rescue like Big for Carrie but we all know the writers are 1000% behind NOTHING going wrong for either Cynthia-ahem, I mean "Miranda" or Che.. ughh..

[@KC1up]

@@winterfire1097steve deserves better anyway. He’s too good for Miranda.

[@sparxstreak02]

It would be one thing if Rock had let them know ahead of time that they didn’t want to go through with a ‘They Mitzvah’ but to drop this on them DURING the celebration is just so selfish & inconsiderate - even if they had gone through with the ‘They Mitzvah’ that doesn’t mean they had to continue practicing the faith after if they didn’t want to 🤦‍♀️ I would be ASHAMED to have such an entitled asshole of a child like Rock.

[@bryanstein9240]

What I would have said. Look kid .you got a candy bar for God's sake.part of growing up and having more freedom means holding up your end of the bargain.so get out there !

[@BloodyMary74]

This issue overblown. Miranda quit her job to be an activist anyway. She can just go to any charity organisation in LA and offer free legal advice to the poor.

[@emma2370]

Let’s be real, Miranda never cared about helping the poor. It’s all for clout.

[@hutch1197]

How about we just have Rabbi Jen and Seema move to London and hang out with Samantha, so we can have a much more interesting, enjoyable show with characters we still like?

[@dmdm528]

I miss Samantha Jones, Kim Catrall and Kristin Davis's old face...there...I said it...lol...

[@aisuxtime]

More Rabbi Jen please. She has the nonjudgemental sass that is missing from the group with Sam gone.

[@MellyMae44]

I love Rabbi Jen! All the sudden this minor character shows up and steals every scene with her no nonsense charisma and charm.

[@Ekrapf21]

I love her too

[@basedbattledroid3507]

She deserves her own spinoff show, Hari Nef is talented as heck

[@orion8835]

AND JUST LIKE CRAP. I hope this series never has another season it was God awful.

[@intorainbowzOG]

Rabbi Jen needs her own show.

[@TattoedKiss]

I can't believe we've got stucked with insufferable characters when all along we could have the Rabbi Jen? If we had a storyline with Carries useless neighbor we may as well have the Rabbi who at least was funny and charming

[@scottnorton2732]

Just coming here to say this. This actress deserved the recurring role.

[@NH-tb2sm]

I was wondering why I was the only one who adores Rabbi Jen

[@wendythe7199]

@@NH-tb2sm she needs a spin off

[@intorainbowzOG]

Rabbi Jen needs her own show. I'd watch the hell out of that.

[@zayinthesky]

@@NH-tb2sm she’s Blythe in YOU

[@musicsavage]

Che is clearly selfish, putting her/his career first and just waiting for Miranda to follow. It's a one-sided relationship but she does not want to see it.

[@banannakis6723]

She's got the rose-colored glasses on of everything is new and exciting. Reality will come at some point.

[@jrwheeler81]

Totally!!!! Miranda is in such a delusional, lustful state that she doesn't see the real picture. Che doesn't give two craps about Miranda. She doesn't want anything long-term, and she will NEVER commit to her. Che is not in love with Miranda and she never will be. She just likes the sex and she's willing to say whatever she has to in order to keep stringing Miranda along for as long as she possibly can. If Che TRULY cared about Miranda, there is no way she ever would have asked her to ditch everything she worked so hard for to follow her out to California like a little puppy. That was so selfish and ignorant of Che. Wake up, Miranda!!!!!! Go home to Steve!!!!!

[@natevic1867]

She does it because she knows she can. Miranda is beyond besotted with her, therefore it’s easy for Che to take advantage of her.

[@MaryTheresa1986]

@@jrwheeler81 I agree with everything you said except for the last part. Steve deserves better.

[@banannakis6723]

@@natevic1867 And the sad thing is, Miranda doesn't seem to care. She's so high on the "happy juice" that she gets with Che that she's ignoring all the red flags.

[@scartee13]

“I’m 13 can’t I jus be me?” I mean yes she’s only 13 years old she’s very young and still figuring shit out but that doesn’t give her the right to be selfish little brat who is so incredibly inconsiderate of all the money time and effort that was put into her “they mitzvah” specifically for her to accommodate her preferences all cuz she doesn’t wanna identify as anything. Then again Charlotte and harry didn’t do her any favors by spoiling her and enabling her bratty entitled behavior. This is what happens when you are your child’s best friend (at a young age of course) they have absolutely no respect for you and have free reign to walk all over you you reap what you sow.

What’s going on with Charlotte’s puffy sleeves in every dress? Is that supposed to be preppy now?

[@janetbeebe6578]

I loved the way Charlotte and Harry gasped when Rock said, I don't even know if I want to be a New Yorker.

[@jennifertrujillo5878]

What on Earth did the actress who plays Charlotte do to her lips? They look like she got stung by a bee!

[@remuslazar2033]

Rose, not Rock. She, not they

[@goldenpineapple8838]

Rock is the worst

[@brejinx9294]

They way Carrie uninvited Charlotte to Paris… 😂

[@GiftSparks]

Carrie is not a friend at all to Charlotte.

[@maringal44]

Yeah that was a big ouch

[@MaryTheresa1986]

@@GiftSparks Charlotte should cut ties with her and Miranda. Between Harry, Anthony, and her other friends, she doesn't need those selfish, toxic brats anyway.

[@GiftSparks]

@@MaryTheresa1986 Agree-- unlike Miranda and Carrie, people would actually WANT to be friends with Charlotte. She is a sweet, kind person. Also she needs all the help she can get given those horrid children of hers. She needs a team of Anthonys to beat them down.

[@fiestadancers]

I know! I have not seen the reboot, but from the clips, haven’t even seen her hang out with Carrie or Miranda by herself.

[@gardengirl7446]

Ridiculous stupid storyline. You WRECKED SATC!

[@deathballad]

2:02 And just like that, Charlotte wished she never got pregnant.

[@msfriendsfan4ever788]

Rock should have either done the mitza, or told Harry and Charlotte before they invited all those people

[@NJGuy1973]

Oh, you mean, act like a decent human being? LMFAO

[@natalien.9528]

The original satc was written by true creative writers, but this is a total political propaganda piece, it doesn't show real people with real behaviours and real problems

[@ChiliKatsuRamen]

The way they negotiate with their child instead of parenting her/him is the answer of all these madness.

[@TheBeanEnthusiast]

Apart from this show being terrible, I have learned that in loving relationships you let ppl feel their feelings. Miranda is trying to control and change what Carrie is thinking and feeling and thats not a loving thing to do. Love doesnt come with an improvement plan.

[@NOMADcourier85]

1:25 stupidest moment of this entire season

[@Plantlady70]

I really can’t stand either one of Charlotte’s kids.

[@CodyFairlessLee]

What’s wrong with Lily?

[@victorrodrigueesoficial]

Rabbi Jen is amazing! Love that character and actress. Talented, natural, simple, yet, dramatic... Hope to see more of her in season 2.

[@Gemmarose9012]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@tami8458]

You can see her in the new Barbie Movie!

[@heatherhoward8064]

Why the *hell* doesn't Rock immediately go up to join Charlotte at the end?? And when they do, they've got this "fine, I'll do you a big favor" grumpy look on their face. Frankly, I dislike this kid. I really, really dislike them.

[@vins1979]

Bad writing, bad acting, despicable show.

[@varinavonstefan8669]

Jesus I don’t even recognize this show. Horrifying

[@malicia12345]

I would say "mind your own business rabi"

[@GoldLeafPress]

“Every mother in this room feels like a failure at least once a day”…really selling the idea of KIDS to people who don’t have kids! 😂 NOT

[@annaheart7731]

I only think that there probably some parents that are even better than me, but I feel like I am in 10% of the best. :)))) Failure? For sure NOT ! In contrary, it happen to me (quite often) to congratulate mysekf with the fact that I'm such a good mother because I see in what high quality child my child has grown up and what a good relationship we have (yes, we argue and about small things, but over all we are very comfortable spending much time togeter).

[@luckydevil1601]

​​@@annaheart7731i don't believe that such a boastful person as you could raise a good kid.

[@annaheart7731]

@@luckydevil1601 We were talking about how we feel, and I told that I never felt a failure as a mother, that's all. If I were boastufl, I'd start to tell how great/successful/smart/beautiful my child is in detail. I could honestly say that my child is a good person but I don't go on in detail. you see? But anyway, I was telling about how I FEEL and not how things are.

[@abbyolmsted7852]

This just isn’t Miranda

[@ke4128]

This show was just too awful

[@NJGuy1973]

Oh, btw, there's a thing called a B'nai mitzvah. It can be non-gender-specific.

[@lenawagenfuehr53]

IKR... didn't they have enough Jews to check?! 🙄

[@skinnyfreakinglegend255]

Rock has to be THE WORST written nonbinary person EVER.

[@NOMADcourier85]

But according to her she's nothing now.

[@NJGuy1973]

Che Diaz. Is they a joke to you?

[@NOMADcourier85]

@@NJGuy1973 coming from Che yes it is

[@AnniK243]

Rock is just the worst person ever. So spoilt.

[@Jacksonandjulian]

@@NJGuy1973 LOL! Perfect! This should be a meme.

[@tashu6964]

Rabbi Jen: I was listening while I was PEEING, did you all understand that I was PEEING? That's an important part of this supposed friendship moment Me: Damn this show and its obsession with urine, puke, and everything else that can come out of a human being

[@susieq8424]

ROTFL! Indeed! Urine, puke, blood... 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@MG-cd9ek]

And feces...

[@sirbuffalo]

You can thank Samantha Irby for the toilet humour. She seems to be obsessed with bodily fluids and bowel movements, because she has some issues in that department herself, which is very unfortunate and understandable, but it doesn't mean that people want to hear about it.

[@playmambo9573]

#satanism

[@Jacksonandjulian]

Dont forget the other bodily fluids... Brady's used condoms and way too much time spent on Lily's tampons. I think the writers have all had lobotomies. Gross.

[@TheyMadeMePickAName]

love the audience taking bad writing as an excuse to feel vindicated in their bigotry. Really shows who the fan base is. Shows who the writers are too. Did they google "how to write queer people" for ten minutes while in the bathroom? god I'm tired

[@LeahElisheva]

🙌 this!!! Agreed! It’s pitiful

[@carriemcclure7253]

Rock is a good name for a doberman. What a spoiled silly brat.

[@julieburck9613]

Is it me, or is charlottes dress pretty ugly? I expect more from a park avenue princess…😂 I had pretty much the same exact dress for a homecoming dance in the late 80s. It was taffeta. Same color. Two piece: long-sleeved top (no puffy sleeves though) and long dress. From Macys which was a huge deal for me. My parents really were generous for that particular dance. I absolutely loved it. But still, the LATE 80s!!!! Charlotte, honey….you’re slacking big time!!!

[@FranSanTeeth90]

"Do I have to follow my own rigid rules?!" Um, anything less is hypocrisy and the absolute WORST of non physical abuse.

[@Romzylicious]

Why do so many beautiful women who have all the money in the world, get such botched plastic surgery?! :(

[@ncr4007]

The thing that bothers me is Miranda is the BIGGEST hypocrite ever. It sounds like she loves Carrie more than Steve. Charlotte shouldn’t have spent that much money on her kid without asking the kid what she wants. Char knew her kid was going through changes. She should have seen the signs. Shame on Charlotte for spending that much money.

[@Fabienna]

Well I guess at one time you should end sex and the city. The quality went way down. Totally boring.....

[@kristinetank3959]

This is what happens to spoiled children with no problems.....they create them.

[@bbeyez]

Carrie really is a horrible friend

[@joshcahanin1250]

I think I can empty the dust buster into the canal on my own.

[@jrwheeler81]

OMG, LOL

[@seaofsolace]

LOL

[@pookydootwo]

First, I would not refer to Lily as Rock. Second I'd tell her when she turns 18 she can become a turtle if she wants or whatever. And third, the family is rich, if she wants to be a little spoiled brat then withhold money for new clothes or anything else. She's 13, moods change, feelings change etc. Tomorrow she may want to be Lily again, who knows.

[@NJGuy1973]

Lily doesn't identify as Rock. Lily remains Lily. The kid orginally named Rose identifies as Rock.

[@LD71685]

Wonder if people watch this strictly for the cringe.

[@christyv4125]

Who are these people? I don't recognize any of the girls.

[@antoniasinfield1762]

Rock - drops a life changing bombshell on her parents, who bend over backwards to cater to her needs, address her as she likes, spend a fortune on tailoring her Bat Mitzvah to be completely reflective of her and basically support her completely... and yet she still manages to make herself a victim. That's what that community is revolves around. Victimhood.

[@karadizon4299]

Sometime Carrie can be too much and everything is always about her. She needs to be supportive of Miranda.

[@sharleenduplessis6632]

THIS IS SO FAR LEFT NARRATIVE ITS DISGUSTING!!!!!

[@MrCph2200]

From what this scene tells us, Charlotte is next to be pushed out of the friendship circle. The rabbi says Miranda and Carrie have a very special bond. Charlotte is not in on this, she has the thing going on with her kids But Carrie decides to push Charlotte aside because Miranda can’t go. Like everything else this looks so much like the reality between these mean girls. First Samantha (Kim) is pushed out and gets enough. From what I’ve seen it looks like it’s the Sarah Jessica / Cynthia- show now. In a season two I could imagine Charlotte would be pushed more and more aside and ridiculed more and more - I mean more than what happened in the period scene…

[@alisewalker9039]

Did MY Charlotte have a surgery to her face

[@babaklava7747]

When Sex and the City became Sad and the City

[@kristinetank3959]

This show went to hell in a handbasket. What a shame.

[@dorothyzbornak9974]

You mean to tell me that there wasn't anyone around to say let's not do this, let's end it where we ended it, and in the best show business tradition, let's hopefully leave the audience wanting more. What a shame.

[@MrsPhillips-e6j]

All the scene needs is an older Jewish lady to come in and scream