Why Do Mother Guppies Die ? Causes and Solutions

[@TheBSideDJ]

i watch a lot of fish keeping uploads, but your uploads are on another level (quality and information). I can only hope to keep enjoying your channel and can not thank you enough for all the efforts you put into this.

[@TheDave333]

Thank you. I appreciate the kind words.

[@sarahtonin256]

Aw poor mama and the babies she really tried her best. She is so beautiful. Makes me so sad and makes me cry when a guppy struggles. I love all my guppies ❤️

[@TheDave333]

Thanks for watching the video. I love guppies too, and I always try to give them the best life that I can. ❤️

[@ciber5650]

''And now lets reverse the film to see it again'' NOO that was hurtfull to watch once !! Awesome video as allways, thanks for the footage.

[@TheDave333]

My pleasure. Yeah, the replay really drives the point home! Thanks for checking out the video.

[@ajnfire]

Another great delivery! Thank you for sharing! Glad for the voice...😉

[@TheDave333]

Love the pun. Thank you. 🙂

[@yomiyoukai]

This line of yours truly is one of the best pieces of advice that some fishkeepers until this day do not take seriously "the best that we can do as responsible fish keepers are to learn as much as possible about the creatures under our care and give them the best treatment that we can." Your videos truly are wonderful and useful in learning closely.

[@lilyedgar4218]

Thank you 😊 so much for this video. I had guppies about 2 years ago & the boys were relentless in their pursuit of the females. Even when the females were pregnant they bit their tails until they killed my girls. They were all feeders for my mudskippers but I grew fond of the mothers & they gave birth inside my brackish tank. It was my first experience seeing it. I cried with joy but this close up was truly beautiful to watch & informative as usual. Thank you 😊. It was extra special to see this on Mother’s Day ❤️.

[@TheDave333]

You're very welcome. The fathers get all of the attention, but it's the mothers who do all the heavy lifting. 🙂

[@susanstaples6171]

I lost a female guppy in a similar situation. She gave birth for the first time but only to two live babies. Even with a salt treatment and as low stress environment as I could offer she died. I think I waited too long to remove her from her tank and offer salt treatment. I appreciate your advice. It breaks my heart to lose a pregnant guppy. I put them in our compost with flowers and wish them well but it is still very sad

[@TheDave333]

It's always sad to lose one of our little friends. . . It's the hardest part of the hobby for me. I wish you well.

[@SLYER_72]

samer here 🥺🥺she gave birth to 5 to 6 babies .

[@debbiefechter3477]

No, thank you.

[@sharonjack7239]

So helpful. Guppy females are so sensitive. I now put only 1 male in with a dozen or more females. Takes a bit longer for fry of course, but the females are much less stressed out. Some male guppies are just super breeders and wow, lots of females are needed. Also lots of live plants and some snails really help out. I find the fry often use large snails to hide behind if needed, lol. I really pay attention to guppies' behaviors, like you do, Dave. Thanks for addressing and sharing all this!! USA

[@TheDave333]

@sharon jack Thank you so much for watching so many of my videos, and always taking the time to leave a thoughtful comment. 🙂

[@AramsYoutube]

i keep my guppies in a natural way, where baby guppies should try their best to survive... so naturally only healthy guppies will survive other will be eaten

[@TheDave333]

That's the best way to do it.

[@madworld.]

Beautiful video as always , the quality is just perfect :):)

[@TheDave333]

Thank you very much!

[@TheRealGimynus1]

the only times guppies give birth is when ur looking away for 10 minutes and boom 20+ fry out of nowhere

[@TheDave333]

Yes, they don't like being watched. . .

[@dominiqueperrin4257]

Your videos are always interesting and perfect 👍 it’s a pleasure 🤩 thank you 🙏

[@TheDave333]

So nice of you. Thank you. 😀

[@alicialeafgreen7422]

Your talking tone is so refreshing!

[@TheDave333]

Thank you!

[@0Greenwell0]

You truly make the most amazing videos!!! I can’t wait until you are able to have members! I’d love to support you somehow! Have you ever kept a culture of daphnia? I’d love to see a video on daphnia care - I am trying to keep my colony going but I am struggling. If you have any tips or would be willing to add it to a video-to-do list that would be amazing!

[@TheDave333]

Thank you so much!! I am no expert on daphnia cultures, other than to say they can be very temperamental !

[@dianecope1469]

Hi Dave, thanks for this. I am an experienced fish keeper, and found your video really interesting. I once had a mother guppy struggling to give birth, and did a similar thing to you. However, after a while she gave birth to the 1st baby. It was very deformed and big. Luckily the rest of the babies were fine, and mum made a great recovery.

[@TheDave333]

Hello, I'm glad you liked the video. It's a labor of love. . . Pun intended. 😁

[@planettes]

I breed mystery snails now & find your channel a wealth of quality information. Favorite favorite content :’) Thank you so much!

[@TheDave333]

You're so welcome! Best of luck with the mystery snails. They're such wonderful animals. 🙂🙂🙂

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

Of all the aqaurium videos you made so far, the "I LOVE GUPPIES" one was the most unusual and the funniest. And I understand you like to keep things fresh.

[@TheDave333]

I'm glad you liked this video Chi. I do like to keep things fresh. It keeps people watching and guessing.

[@lizxu322]

Thanks so much for humanising fishes❤

[@TheDave333]

It's my pleasure. :-)

[@DebiSunset]

Feed peas to gravid guppies. Cook peas, cool and pop out of shells. Helps keep things moving. Important too cook peas and squeeze out of shell so they are soft.

[@TheDave333]

Yes, peas are great for constipation.

[@tamarrajames3590]

Really well done. I’m sorry she lost her babies, but it’s clear you knew what best to do for her.🖤🇨🇦

[@TheDave333]

I wish they could talk . . . It would be easier to know how to help. I always worry.

[@tamarrajames3590]

@@TheDave333 I understand that completely. In my younger years I was a wildlife rescue carer, and I can’t count the times I wished they could just tell me how they were feeling and what they needed. Your care for your water babies is clear and beautiful.🖤🇨🇦

[@IMaqua]

Beautiful video footage as always. I enjoyed the whole story you presented.

[@TheDave333]

Thank you very much!

[@IMaqua]

@@TheDave333 you are welcome and keep it up. You are definitely one of the channels that is different on the youtube scene. And by different I mean good.

[@jarleabelhaugeek1217]

Fantastic quality. Great video.

[@TheDave333]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@p0tato669]

These videos are cool! They feel like documentary’s

[@TheDave333]

Thank you!

[@seahyongsen5670]

Nice guppy documentation!

[@TheDave333]

Thanks!

[@andystokes8702]

Excellent video footage, exactly what we have come to expect from this channel.

[@TheDave333]

Thank you. :-)

[@ethoatom668]

There is something oddly hilarious about seeing such a serene intro with rainbows and dandelion blooms and then seeing "Why do mother guppies DIE?" appear on the screen.

[@TheDave333]

I like to be creative . . . The strange thing for me was releasing it on Mother's Day!!!

[@ethoatom668]

@@TheDave333 I didn't even realize that, was that on purpose?

[@irenicrose]

love your videos, they're so high quality and probably take a lot of time to produce :)

[@TheDave333]

Thank you . . . Yes, they do take a while to put together, but it's worth it. I love what I do, and the fish always teach me something new. :-)

[@enjuxoxo3353]

Yeaa,, this is the right information that i need. I have 1 pregnant mother guppy that exactly like this n its been over 7 week. I affraid she wont make it

[@TheDave333]

Hopefully everything works out for you and mother guppy.

[@enjuxoxo3353]

@@TheDave333 thx man,, i hope so

[@enjuxoxo3353]

she die this morning

[@bomboloniii]

i have 2 males and 1 female in a tank. i noticed the female has gotten pregnant and she's pissed by the males trying to mate with her. she started attacking the males and keep staying in a certain spot of the tank. i realized she might be stressed so i put her in a different tank. but im afraid she'll get lonely since she's gonna be in there for another 18 days.since these three are all i have, so i put the female tank in the males tank so they can still see each other and interact but not mating. am i doing this right?

[@TheDave333]

She won't get lonely, in fact you might be saving her life! Keep her in a separate tank until she has the babies, then give her a few days to rest after giving birth. It's best to have 2-3 females for each male, or they can pester her to death.

[@bomboloniii]

@@TheDave333 i see... i wanted to get one male and two females but since i bought them online, i couldn't pick, the seller gave them out randomly. tq for replying. will do

[@TheDave333]

No problem. . . Once you have babies, there will be plenty of males and females. :-)

[@blusky7122]

@@TheDave333 oh my.. maybe that’s the reason my female guppy jumped out of the tank. I thought their behaviour were normal, swimming here and there together 😔 This one male might be aggressive as I got 2 pairs at first..the other male died with torn tail. The other female died with no known reason. Another female keep jumping out of the tank..(the final jump got blood on the head not sure it caused by the fall or by the male)

[@lovenikolatesla846]

Glad to of made the decision to buy a separate tank for the pregnant fish have 3 now but it's good for them when they are breeding.

[@TheDave333]

Yes, it really is. Have you seen this guppy video? kzbin.info/www/bejne/p16Tc6CvjNV_j9U

[@lovenikolatesla846]

@@TheDave333 Much appreciated you just help me save the unborn guppies lives 👌

[@TheDave333]

Awesome! Happy to help. 😃

[@asfaqueahammed6916]

Observing skill is awesome 🔍🔬🩺

[@TheDave333]

Thank you - It's a labor of love. 💜

[@fishiemon64]

Great video awesome footage 👍🏽✌🏽

[@TheDave333]

Thanks 👍 🙂

[@nikkojoson]

coolest video i watched about guppies

[@TheDave333]

Thank you so much

[@wendysheets1916]

Thanks so much for this video.... It taught me a lot... I forgot to tell you on my comment thanking you a few min ago and telling me about this video... you have a new lifelong subscriber with the bell notification turned on so I don't miss ONE video.... I'll be binge-watching your videos this next week... thanks for teaching me... I never want to cause any of my fish to suffer... I also didn't know that I should have more females than I do now because of how many males I have.... I'll have that fixed soon... thank you!! Thanks so much again for your kindness...

[@TheDave333]

You're very welcome, and thank you so much for subscribing to my channel, and watching the videos. You're in for a real treat! Have a spectacular day. :-D

[@susanosman3643]

Very interesting- thank you! Many years ago, I had a 55 gal tank with several pairs of fancy guppies. Thank GOD something like this never happened to any of my female guppies. Yes, I did learn quite a bit!

[@TheDave333]

Thanks for watching the video. Guppies are fun, and they make lots of babies!

[@Brad.Hobbies]

Fantastic!! Thank you!

[@TheDave333]

You're very welcome!

[@wendygillard2133]

Another wonderful video!

[@TheDave333]

Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[@jeffcusack7612]

Always enjoy your videos, keep up the fantastic work 👍

[@TheDave333]

Thanks 👍

[@gohstleviathanyt9859]

Thankyou always appreciate the guppie content. :)

[@TheDave333]

My pleasure! 🙂

[@cherylmockotr]

Thank you for posting this! I have an endler who has given birth before but this time she's as huge as the fish in this video. Her nephews were beginning to pester her so I put her in a breeding box inside her tank, but that was a week ago and nothing has happened. She hasn't seemed stressed, swimming around as usual, but she got even a little bigger. I'm worried about her! Thanks to your video I just put her back in her regular tank with female platies and I put her nephews in time out inside the breeder box. I turned off the lights and put a towel over the tank... I'm hoping this will help! Today she is starting to swim awkwardly but luckily I don't see any prolapse or anything.

[@TheDave333]

I really hope that everything works out for you and mother Endler. Let me know how it goes.

[@cherylmockotr]

@@TheDave333 Thanks! As of last night she's waddling happily around the tank, no apparent signs of distress other than looking like she's going to explode at any second. The poor boys in time out aren't too happy, but they're young and healthy so they should be able to better tolerate the boredom. I'm so glad to see a picture of your female looking as big as mine... she was only half this size last time so I thought this size was extremely abnormal! She's in my office tank, so once these babies are born she'll be coming home with me to the all-girls tank.

[@shahnawazvlog6266]

should have see this video yesterday , my female guppy have same problem she end up die, extremly sad. thanks for share with us

[@TheDave333]

Sorry for your loss, it's always hard to lose one of our little friends.

[@chrispeters2645]

As usual, professional quality videography and very educational content. What's particularly impressive, is that given the subject matter, you presumably put it together on-the-fly. Am I right in thinking that female guppies can store reproductive material internally. If so, and assuming she recovers from her ordeal, will she become pregnant again even if kept in isolation?

[@TheDave333]

Thanks for checking out the video. Yes, female guppies can store reproductive material for several months. No male needed for quite some time.

[@PaulsFishroom]

Excellent photography once again 🤓👍

[@TheDave333]

Thank you so much 👍

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

Have you ever been to Maymont before? It's located in Richmond, Virginia. It's got a farm, a Japanese garden, a koi pond, and a nature center. I've been there many times before.

[@TheDave333]

I've never been there. I love Japanese gardens and koi ponds. :-)

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

​@@TheDave333You should go there someday. It's a great place.

[@melodymelody5850]

Thank u for sharing this video. i have expecting mama guppy too, what is the strain of the guppy in the video?

[@TheDave333]

I'm sorry I don't know what strain of guppy was in the video. I have so many!!! Best of luck with your expecting mama guppy. 😄

[@melodymelody5850]

@@TheDave333 sir any suggestion what kind of food should i fed my fry guppies?

[@TheDave333]

Flake food broken up into very small pieces works well. I have links to awesome guppy foods in the description section just below the video.

[@Bilisjourney]

My female gave birth to two fry yesterday, she hasn’t had anymore since then but seems calm and hiding in her separate tank w her fry(2) will she hav more when more calm or will she die 😰?

[@TheDave333]

It's really hard to say. Mother guppies will sometimes have their babies over the course of a couple days. Here are some things to consider. . . . Did she eat the other babies? Are there lots of hiding places for the newborn babies? Babies without places to hide are more likely to be eaten. Were they sucked up into the intake of a hang on back filter? She may have had them all, or she might be waiting for a quiet time to have more. . . It's hard to say for certain without more info. Keep the lights dim, and movement around her tank to a minimum. The less stress the better. Hopefully everything is okay. ❤❤❤

[@TinyvanKeulen]

Believe me, if someone has had dozens of babies at once, she won't feel well for a few days..

[@bonyylast7147]

How large was the separate tank?

[@TheDave333]

5 gallons (19 liters)

[@robertfly5991]

Excellent video, I hope to see more soon

[@TheDave333]

More to come!

[@CrowntailHalfmoon]

Thank you Sir for sharing. 👍 I myself had same issues however the females got dropsy... still born fry and slimmed down to only die about 2 weeks later...

[@TheDave333]

There's never a dull moment when keeping fish!

[@joshuaowen4290]

Could you please do a video on Carinotetraodon irrubesco the red eye (red tail) dwarf puffer. I have been unable to find good high quality videos of this or any of the other Red eye dwarf puffers. I would greatly appreciate it, if it were possible. 🥺🙏🙏

[@TheDave333]

Great suggestion! I don't have any plans at the moment to work with this species, but I'll add it to the list. . . So many fish, so little time. :-)

[@dachiken6037]

Thank you for the tip this was very useful for my guppies

[@TheDave333]

Happy to help. :-)

[@dachiken6037]

@@TheDave333 thanks

[@luci890]

Hello Dave, I have a question about your camera. Are you still using Panasonic HC-V770EP-K? These latest footages seem a little different and more colorful than at your beginning. I would love to film my fish in the same quality as you. It’s fantastic how you can see every scale😊. Thank you for your time and keep it up.

[@TheDave333]

Hello, and thanks for watching the video. Yes, I'm still using the same camera. I guess I must be getting better at capturing the little details. 🙂

[@cathyny83]

Thank you for making this video, it;s my first rodeo to learn more about fish because I do not pet any of them. I'm just wondering do fish get sick, how do you know and what can you do if you can't bring them to the VET

[@TheDave333]

Hello, and thanks for watching the video. Yes, fish do get sick, just like people. The usual reasons for sickness are. #1 - dirty water #2 - too much food (linked to #1) #3 - stress (fighting other fish, poor water quality, disease, cold water, too many fish, etc.) The best thing that you can do is to learn as much as you can about the fish that you're keeping. Learn about the nitrogen cycle and how to keep the water clean. Keep things simple, so there are less things to go wrong. This will help to keep them from getting sick. Watch the fish everyday, so you know what they look and act like when they're healthy, then if they do start to get sick, you will know right away that something is wrong.

[@cathyny83]

​@@TheDave333 It's really interesting to know! I only have some plants and I'm into horticulture recently. This video really makes me your subscriber.

[@TheDave333]

Thank you so much! I love nature, and I love to help others. Thanks for subscribing. :-D

[@tejashree2443]

Super explain 😍😍😍

[@TheDave333]

Thank you 🙂

[@TheRealGimynus1]

how do i know if my guppies are stressed or not, i have 2 breeder boxes setup in my fry tank (2 boxes with nets on the bottom) i put each guppy in one box, and they seem to be swimming in it fine but idk if they are stressed or not. bcz if they are they might not birth frys

[@TheDave333]

It seems to take forever when you're waiting and watching. . . One way to judge their stress is by their breathing, stressed fish breathe fast, and dart about the tank nervously. Watch their gill covers for signs of hyperventilation. Keeps their light dimmed, and room movements to a minimum. (No place to hide and bright light in a small box is a bad combination.) This movie might help answer some more questions. kzbin.info/www/bejne/bma4qIakmKqeipY

[@CrazyBritTho]

Are Platies the same type of labourers?

[@TheDave333]

Yes, they bear live young.

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

You deserve more views. 😁😁😁😁😁😁😁

[@TheDave333]

I agree. Tell everyone you know about my channel. :-)

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

@@TheDave333 I have done that before.

[@TheDave333]

Thanks Chi!

[@angieverescuk4311]

Great video thx Dave !

[@TheDave333]

You're very welcome !

[@TuanCaCanh]

Hello friend you have nice video

[@TheDave333]

Hello 😊 Thank you.

[@HarleysAngel2005]

Is this your real voice? Just curious....great info thank you!

[@TheDave333]

I have many voices, but yes, it's my professional voice.

[@joy3894]

@@TheDave333 it sounds so satisfying 🥰

[@YK-tl3gr]

Do you still have the betta fish who was eating mosquito larvae?

[@TheDave333]

No he passed away a while ago. He lived a long healthy life. :-)

[@YK-tl3gr]

@@TheDave333 how many years did he live?

[@Ruch82]

My female guppy is second time pregnant and I saw her big belly and box shape so i moved her to another tank but she just removed lot of black waste. I can't see her box shaped belly but black colour inside her tummy is visible so i am guessing they are babies. Any idea about such case? should I wait for her box belly formation to move her to another tank?

[@TheDave333]

Moving her too much is very stressful. If she's already in a safe place to have the babies, then I would just leave her be.

[@Ruch82]

@@TheDave333 hey thanks for reply.. there are many other fishes in tank who eat babies so i moved her to new small tank just now she gave birth to 12 babies 😊 I am very happy 🥳

[@TheDave333]

Congratulations! It's such a great experience. :-D

[@leddred2078]

Awesome

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

Dave, if you mind my asking, why did you decide to speak with a southern accent in the I LOVE GUPPIES vid?

[@TheDave333]

It's because I'm not very good at British accents!

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

@@TheDave333 I see. Well, the southern accent you were speaking with is non-rhotic just like the New York and Boston accents.

[@TheDave333]

(non-rhotic) I just learned something new! It seems like you really love accents and language. Someday, I'll have to make a video using my West Indian accent / dialect. I grew up speaking very differently than you hear me now. I guess to the untrained ear it would sound like I'm Jamaican.

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

Have you heard of a spotty/Notolabrus celidotus?

[@TheDave333]

Never heard of them until now.

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

@@TheDave333 How about a round ribbontail ray/Taeniurops meyeni?

[@TheDave333]

Never heard of that one either! I do love rays and skates though!

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

@@TheDave333 So do I! 😁

[@DNLKTV]

One time guppy girl gave a birth and while recovering was super skinny. She did not make it, dying after a couple weeks since birth. I believe it is common for females to get some body damage and have troubles after giving babies. Like bent spine and maybe even some belly collapse due to internal pressure.

[@TheDave333]

It's one of the disadvantages of bearing live young.

[@DNLKTV]

@@TheDave333 I also read that guppies are too inbred which affects their health too. What a shame!

[@indigocrayon520]

Similar to dogs, some dogs can't give birth properly, plus mills breed dogs at their 1st heat before they are fully grown which causes higher mortality rate. I just lost a female mutt guppy I got as a rehome and I've decided to start keeping the males away until the females are fully grown to help their odds!

[@TheDave333]

@DNLK Yes, the modern fancy guppy is a bit delicate. I like to hybridize them with Endler guppies, it mixes up the gene pool a little.

[@danielw3447]

Question. I have 2 female longtail adult guppies and 1 adolescent female. There is also a male crowntail betta (who is tank boss and no one even slightly challenges him) The last month or so I have noticed the 2 female adult longtails are nipping the HELL out of each others' tails. Though i will say i never have witnessed the nipping in real-time. This morning i notice they are missing some good sized chunks from their normally large beautiful fanned tails (not quite down to the quick, much more superficial) How can i curb the aggression/nipping? Someone said i should add a male but i am not prepared for the responsibility of breeding. I have a heavily planted tank full of val, bacopa, rennecki, wisteria, rotala, water lettuce, red root floaters, and other plants and plenty of sight breakers. The only thing I can think is 2 things: 1) i recently introduced that new female adolescent guppy. And 2) I may have probably been overfeeding lately. I cant even tell who is the primary aggressor the tail damage is equal between the 2.

[@TheDave333]

Sorry to hear of the trouble. Since you haven't actually seen who is causing the problem ("i will say i never have witnessed the nipping in real-time"). . . My opinion is that it's probably the male crowntail betta who is causing the trouble. I suggest sitting and watching the tank for a long time to see who is doing the damage. My guess is it's probably the tank boss!

[@flavourful_diaries_recipes]

Can you please tell me why my female guppy is die just before giving birth? I already placed her another tank but this happened

[@TheDave333]

It could be that she's being moved too close to the time when she's going to have the babies. It's probably stress related. Try setting up the main tank so that she does not have too moved. Moving is stressful.

[@dirtyoldfarmhand3]

Bravo!

[@BowHooHoo]

My mum got albino koi guppies a few months ago, 5 females and 1 male, theres this one that looked pregnant but I thought she was just full of eggs, she jumped out of the water and got hurt so I’m quarantining her until she heals. But this morning, I woke up to the quarantine tank full of babies, I never even knew guppies gave life birth, I thought fishes had external fertilization. I’m the one taking care of my mum’s fishes and now I don’t know what to do, do I leave the mum to eat her babies or do I put the mom back with the others and raise the babies in the quarantine tank? What do baby guppies eat?? Is normal guppy food too big for their little baby mouths?? I don’t even have enough room for more fish, I don’t know what the best decision is ;-;

[@TheDave333]

I would put the mom back in the main tank and keep the babies in the quarantine tank. The babies can eat crushed up flake food, as long as the pieces are small enough to fit in their mouth. This video will help. kzbin.info/www/bejne/p16Tc6CvjNV_j9U

[@BowHooHoo]

@@TheDave333 Thank you!!

[@TheDave333]

You're welcome!

[@Justmyselfiguess]

My mother guppy gave birth to 13 babies. All were healthy and so was the mother but I woke up the next morning to see that the mother ate all of the babies and was laying in the fish tank on the bottom dead. I forgot to separate them so it was my fault. I had another pregnant fish in another tank (it was also a guppy). She seemed to be suffering a lot and dying. I cleaned the water and added more plants and hiding places. 3 days passed by and she was still alive. On the 3rd day she gave birth to 7 healthy baby guppy fish. I separated them but sadly the mother died 2 days after giving birth, but all the babies were healthy and thank you so much this video helped a lot! You just earned another subscriber.

[@TheDave333]

Thank you for subscribing. Sorry to hear that you're having trouble. Are too many male guppies causing the problems by harassing the pregnant females? There should be 2-3 males for each female. 🐟🐟🐟

[@PaulsFishroom]

I’ve been keeping tropical fish since the early 1960s and sadly the domesticated strains of livebearers, and particularly guppies, are far less hardy than they used to be. The guppies today, like many farm bred species of fish in general, seem far less resilient than they used to be mainly due to excessive inbreeding IMO!

[@TheDave333]

You are 100% correct my friend. And I'll add this little bit. . . Too much coddling in perfect conditions also weakens the population as well. We create such perfect conditions that even the weak fry survive and reproduce. Fish populations improve their fitness by encountering less than ideal conditions on occasion . . . Humans and their offspring are getting a bit soft as well. . . 😊

[@PaulsFishroom]

@@TheDave333 .lol I like the ‘Humans’ bit. In the mid 1980s a group of us travelled around Germany looking at a number of fish establishments. We visited, what was at the time, Europes largest fish breeding establishment (owned by Tetra). An absolutely fascinating tour around the hatchery. All the fry rearing tanks were filtered on a central system and water was returned to the tanks via a number of UV sterilisers. Result healthy fish with little or no natural immunity.

[@TheDave333]

It's like robbing Peter to pay Paul. :-)

[@severusfoxbat2837]

My guppy just gave birth a month ago, she is very large so she had no complications. However her sister is smaller and still incubating hers. Very worried

[@TheDave333]

Keep the water clean and the stress to a minimum. fyi- those small breeder boxes can be death traps.

[@terbofish5788]

Bob Ross of guppies... Remember there are no guppy mistakes, just happy guppy accidents!

[@TheDave333]

So, true . . . Nice happy trees . . .

[@julianaello4073]

What kind of female guppy in the video?

[@TheDave333]

I don't know. Just a "mutt" guppy (mixed breed)

[@G.m.aquatic]

Ihave japan blue pairs but its almost 3monts and all guppys full loaded but not giving birth

[@TheDave333]

It might be helpful to separate the male and the females for a while.

[@batboiisme]

My Guppy Gave To All Healthy Fishes Im Searching What To Feed Them Give Me A Tip ❤️

[@TheDave333]

Flake food crushed into very small pieces.

[@batboiisme]

@@TheDave333 Thanks I've Bought New Fry Food From Fish Shop They're Eating Very Well !

[@TheDave333]

That's awesome! I love to see baby fish eating their food. It means they'll be growing!!!

[@batboiisme]

@@TheDave333 thanks ! 💖

[@sarhabernalumana4206]

i was told to not worry if my female guppies die after giving birth, because they say is normal, but I think with medicine I should be able to help them recover and live longer

[@TheDave333]

It's not normal for the females to die after giving birth.

[@StiggyAzalea]

I found my guppy in a similar state, but because of my work schedule I couldn't catch her until much later in the process. The best thing I could do was put her in a floating breeding box, but she passed overnight. I didn't know the genitals could prolapse too but after inspection it seems like that's what happened. I was so excited to see how many babies were gonna come out of this one, she's always gotten much bigger than her sisters, this last time she was bigger around than a dime. I didn't want to move her but I've got this one male who would not stop pecking at her face.

[@TheDave333]

Sorry to hear about the lady guppy. :-(

[@ivanscottw]

That last comment is something I should have known. I moved a guppy female who had gone from plump to thin from my breeder tank to the main tank - and the next she was belly up :( (well I suspect it was her because I have very few adult guppy death in my tanks). My breeder tank has still one expecting female in it, but apparently she didn't produce too many ovocytes.. she is round, but it's reasonable and looking at my tank I'm starting to see fry that wasn't there before so apparently she is expulsing the babies gradually which is less stressful - and I have plenty of waterweed (yes I know, you are not allowed these were you at) for the newborns to hide ! PS : The guppy that passed away was obviously (due to her size) a 1st time mother. I suspect that guppys that may be breeding too young may die at a higher rate.

[@TheDave333]

There are all sorts of problems that they run into in captivity such as too much food, too much competition, not enough places to hide, too much light, too hot, too cold, etc. In the wild, a pregnant female has a lot more options, and if the place she's in is unhealthy, she can just move to a new area. This is not possible in the aquarium, so they get into unhealthy situations.

[@ivanscottw]

@@TheDave333 I am fine with the situation I think. I do expect *some* of my fish to eventually die... finding 1 fish belly up every other week when you have something like 200 guppies is something that is just part of the things that happen in an aquarium. Accidents happen, one of the fish may have a genetic disease.. It's not a massive fish die off like waking up one morning and seeing 5 or 10 dead (THAT would get me worried). But when I see my fish doing their guppy "things" (like, foraging for food in the plants, the males doing the funny dance in front of the ladies, them gathering at the feeding spot every time they see me passing in front of the tank) I'm pretty certain they are happy campers !

[@TheDave333]

Yes it's true, deaths are an inevitable part of our hobby, and we do the best we can to keep our fish happy and healthy. :-D

[@ivanscottw]

@@TheDave333 Trying a new experiment.. a few baby guppies in a 5 Liter bucket with waterweed on the balcony, Paris France downtown. No heater, no feeding - but plenty of sunshine and a breeze (that should oxygenate the water) - see how they fare.. I want to see if this is possible ! The waterweed, the bugs, the junk that will eventually go in the water should give them enough food (I will monitor the situation - I'm not going to let them die if they are in distress). Thoughts ?

[@Queen_Devi]

I bought an guppy yesterday, found 1 baby yesterday evening not sure if it was hers as she was very thinn, today i found another baby but found the mother dead.. why?

[@TheDave333]

Sorry to hear about the mother guppy. Unfortunately, any number of things could have happened. She could've been bullied by the other fish, she could've been harassed by the boy guppies (2-3 females for each male works best), the stress of giving birth etc... Usually, these things are related to some sort of stress. A new environment, aggressive fish, poor water quality, etc... It's hard to tell for sure without more information. Don't give up keep trying and learning.

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

What is your favorite species of sea lion?

[@TheDave333]

I don't have a favorite species of sea lion. What's your favorite?

[@chisaquaticvibe6524]

@@TheDave333 South American, California, and steller sea lion

[@CristyB66]

I have a lot of guppies, but not one ever died after giving birth.

[@TheDave333]

Aren't you the lucky one! Nice work. :-)

[@ainalmaas6719]

My female guppies get sick after birth. Their backs become hunched and they eat less and gets emaciated and die. All other male guppies and young female guppies are fine. Do you know why that happens and anything I could do?

[@TheDave333]

Unfortunately, it happens to older females . . . The energy required to make babies takes its toll after a while. The best that we can do is to make them as comfortable as we can, and give them a break from the boys both before and after they give birth. Be sure they get bright light, and lots of healthy food. It's so sad when they die. . . .

[@boknoy4348]

what kind of guppy that

[@TheDave333]

Just a random female guppy.

[@Miss-Laine]

What snails are not reproducing like crazy are there any? 😂 I would like to have one but I am afraid to get my tank infested! I bought a plant from petco and then I had tank full of tiny snails!

[@TheDave333]

Mystery snails won't reproduce like crazy. They lay their eggs above the waterline and are very cool looking snails.

[@genergonzalez6258]

Unfortunately my female Guppy died 3 days later. I did everything to keep her alive after 28 frys but I've noticed that shes don't wanted to eat. After all that her belly was like bleeding inside. Luckily the little ones are growing and enjoying.

[@TheDave333]

It's a sad story, but a mother guppy gives everything she has to her children. Best of luck with her babies.

[@varavarte1975]

I wish i could watch this early..my pregnant guppy died in today morning..she was always in the bottom of the tank and breath heavily..i think it was just a labour..so sad!!

[@TheDave333]

It is sad, but these things happen. Sorry for your loss.

[@varavarte1975]

@@TheDave333 yeah but i lost 20 more because of poor water i think

[@TheDave333]

Clean water makes a big difference !

[@TheParallelSound]

good video thank you

[@TheDave333]

You're very welcome, my pleasure

[@NarayananV28]

How frequently should we feed Guppies?

[@TheDave333]

Small amounts at least two or three times per day

[@TinyvanKeulen]

Allow females to grow virgin for 5 months, which means separating them from their brothers and nephews within 3 weeks (or as soon as possible). When they are fully grown they will not die as quickly as when they are very young. Endlers and guppies often give birth to more than 20 young at a time, even if they are too young. As if a human teenager had to give birth to sextuplets...

[@loubock3238]

As soon as I noticed that they are pregnant I put them in a separate maternity tank since the males are just relentless and that stress the mama out even more.

[@TheDave333]

That is the best way to go. Those males don't give the females any rest.

[@creativecreative2886]

My female guppy gave birth to 17 fries yesterday. Since then she's been struggling, not eating properly, looks weak.. Today shes laying down

[@TheDave333]

Isolate her from the other fish, keep her stress to a minimum, and hope for the best.

[@creativecreative2886]

@@TheDave333 she died :(

[@frvfp-gaming5194]

@@TheDave333my male guppy is lying at the bottom of the tank. it got really fat so im not too sure if its a male anymore lmao.

[@TheDave333]

@creative creative I'm sorry . . . that stinks. Look to her children and a brighter, healthier future.

[@frvfp-gaming5194]

@@TheDave333 can you help me?

[@shatarawatkins6316]

Are the guppies supposed to swim as soon as they come out

[@TheDave333]

When they're first born they rest for a while as they get used to their new environment. They sit still and hide if they sense danger. Within half an hour, they're swimming up at the top of the tank. Guppies can swim as soon as they're born, but they like to sit and rest first unless something bothers them.

[@mikedan297]

Indeed, without your observation we don't know the problem of pregnant guppies.

[@TheDave333]

And the more closely we observe the fish, the better we will understand them.

[@yazpurple3143]

I realized half my babies had the same yolk sac when they came, only a few survived, i tried the best I could but the mother had this big red bump at her behind and i made the mistake of putting her in the breeding tank too early, she died 3 days later , RIP

[@TheDave333]

Sorry for your loss. Motherhood is difficult. Pregnant female guppies are easily stressed to the point of illness. Avoid using breeder boxes, a 5 gallon bucket or even a 2.5 gallon bucket would be better. If at all possible, try to keep the mother guppy in one place it's less stressful. Don't give up, keep trying, keep learning.

[@alanaballoon5661]

Did you use epsom salt?

[@TheDave333]

No, I don't.

[@tanteluoyi3242]

Some of the guppies nature is freshwater,no need a salt thingy for them

[@alanaballoon5661]

@@tanteluoyi3242 i asked because he said he used aquarium safe salt

[@tanteluoyi3242]

@@alanaballoon5661 I'm pretty sure it was for water purifier or something,why don't you ask him which salt Aquarium?

[@TheDave333]

There are special aquarium safe salts that can be used. Guppies can handle quite a bit of salt in their water. It can help with external parasites, and sometimes bloating.

[@htiesguitarcovers4844]

My mother guppy fish died during labor today. 🤧 I don't know why she died.

[@TheDave333]

It happens sometimes. It's always hard losing one of our little friends.

[@MarshaNPILoveCanada]

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Satisfying, calming biology video. I did watch some of your videos :)) From Bandung, Indonesia

[@TheDave333]

Awesome! Thank you!

[@rtruth550]

can a single male guppy stress out a pregnant female guppy?

[@TheDave333]

Yes, but not as much as a whole group of males. . . As long as she has a few places where she can hide, and rest for a few minutes she should be fine. The more live plants in the tank, the better. Live plants also help keep the water clean by processing the waste product produced by the fish. It's a win win situation.