LIVE JURY TRIAL | MA v. Karen Read Day 20 | MORNING | Ashley Vaillier Cross

[@samperryman3386]

Why did her brain melt when he asked who delivered the evidence?

[@sherrycostonde]

Because she was told to avoid saying trooper proctor if she could

[@nict6549]

I didn’t know where defense was going with the tail light, but now I see they didn’t find that one area because that’s where she backed her car into his car in the driveway. It’s on ring, so all that other red clear black possibly plastic crap, is because trooper proctor took something to break it all up after the car was in custody and then went on to pin on Karen!

[@valc6908]

Every time this guy says Trooper Proctor my wife hears Chupacabra. 😂

[@SydneyBooksMusic]

All I hear is a bunch of stuttering and Proctor Trooper.

[@GgTothemaxx]

Me 2!!😂 I thought it was just me..

[@AdrianaHernandez-zr9gd]

😂😂😂😂

[@elsiefernandez3354]

😂

[@CountessKitten]

🤣😭🤣😭

[@phonetics8272]

That taillight must´ve gotten a big impact to break it in so many pieces... . She would´ve felt that collision without a doubt.

[@debraward1813]

Like a hammer maybe??

[@donnaallen3815]

JM testified she heard no crash, sounds , or fighting when she was at the door 5 xs. - sad case of injustice for Officer O’Keefe. Witnesses lying like this is disgusting. Hope karma comes to the ones that lied.

[@roseharvey2664]

Yet no damage to the car except the light.

[@moralfortitude...2217]

he messed up & finally said it... *LACERATIONS* and then he said oh uh, abrasions... hahaha...gotta ya, hoping they noticed... *Freudian moment* @ its best... ~he accidentally blurted out something he had been trying to avoid, what the right arm wounds truly are, lacerations. *cuts, punctures, rips, tearing of the skin layers deep* (abrasions are on surface skin wounds) *KARMA*

[@nict6549]

I find it actually funny that was allowed to elaborate on medical issues. He’s a trooper not a medical professional.

[@moralfortitude...2217]

@@nict6549 well technically he can say what he observed by experience aspect *only* that defense objected on that ground, not be a dr the judge overruled w/ instructions to only answer observation but not any further, like what or how he thinks caused those particular wounds happened. that why all the pro' medical witnesses & this trooper have been using the the term (abrasions) mildest form of skin wound to minimize & deflect for what they really are lacerations (tears, punctures & ripping of the skin) that's why the trooper (f)up & said lacerations. God don't like ugly & lies. I am flabbergasted that Read would actually say cover~up, although it is, it's just you don't ever let the right hand know what the left is doing & vice-versa. I think that really tainted the narrative EVERRRRRYONE is in cahoots... (and no one thinks even 1 person keep a secret, so they surely ain't going to believe more than 1 can. and calling it a conspiracy blown way out of orbit. This is not that they didn't cover stuff up cuz they did it's just the way people take it and run with it and when you use nowadays words like conspiracy all people going haywire of all the different scenarios in the making it much deeper than it really is with those narratives. uhhh, yeah but "who is everyone"

[@FloridaTim]

As much as I would like a Directed Verdict, I really want to see Lally try to cross the Defense witnesses

[@LightningStorm73]

Thank you for another great video.

[@cynthiahotchkiss1597]

The brother will be so upset when he finds out Karen did not do this.

[@missybrewer423]

Even if Karen Read spent her whole life savings! These attorneys are worth it! How the F did case even become able to be prosecuted? 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@wendl15]

Massachusetts

[@moralfortitude...2217]

Why do they keep calling his right arm wounds abrasions they are clearly not abrasion but most definitely very defensive wound as his arm was bent trying to protect himself from the disappearing dog as he was being attacked by it. The wounds on the forearm are clearly bite marks because you can see pooling of the blood in the bite puncture wounds. there are puncture holes in the right sleeve of the sweatshirt... blood was running from the right eye... *BOOM* the guy just messed up & said it *lacerations* ! and then tried to clean it up... oh uh, abrasions... LIAR !!! 🤦‍♀️🤨🤦‍♂️

[@nonakabyrd5759]

Hmmm, she seems much secure and confident than on prosecution, odd. She doesn't want to lie, good girl!

[@AnthonyThomas-zv3jb]

Really simple: glass is silica (sand) and plastic is carbon (oil).

[@normcaissie5598]

They said the sweater was shredded from being dragged. No way that would happen in the snow.

[@missybrewer423]

I'm sure AJ was 10x the attorney this Judge ever was. I watch a lot of cases. I am by no means an attorney, but she is so biased and it is so apparent to me so I'm assuming it is to the Jury as well

[@briancorbier3549]

Is the water ok in Mass....so many people "dont recall" real often.

[@JS-pe7uc]

Cop defense. Real common in depositions.

[@triciaiannarone7657]

I can’t To get that tune out of my head now. Thx Larry!!!!

[@shastascorner3430]

So, Karen supposedly hit John, drove home, drove 30 miles, the car towed another 30 miles in a blizzard, and they were able to put the whole taillight back together? Nothing suspicious about that! Ummmmm.

[@samperryman3386]

Here go the conspiracy theorist, now youre gonna tell me hair would have blown off traveling nearly 100 miles in a blizzard. This trial is a joke

[@realhousewifeoftransylvania1.0]

Your summary is bs that's why you can't believe it

[@realanarchobill]

you are hilarious wish i could a seen the live but watching just the cross was nice. loving your channel so much ha.

[@AshleyMarieMommy]

I’m a Mandoo supporter I’m so glad you and him worked together to keep his channel up. I’ve watched him everyday since I got home from the hospital after my stroke.

[@grandykim]

Poor stenographer. She has to write all those ums. Lawyer is doing it too....

[@Insideyourbones]

That’s what I wanted to ask. Are they noted down? The umms? Crazy

[@SydneyBooksMusic]

Trying to listen to this last testimony is painful. I don’t think these people are used to interacting with people. Ever.

[@pamterry1277]

I really dont think the witness thinks anything is funny. I believe its just a nervous laugh. I do the same thing when I get nervous.

[@Remmysage]

Right, like why attack a witness, clearly they don’t want to be there and are just doing their job (testing evidence that was sent to them!) like why hate on them for literally just doing their job? Classless!

[@wendysturrock8759]

They have to get all of Lally's pictures in !!!!!!!!!!

[@cynthiahotchkiss1597]

I think her nervous speech And small giggles are due to nerves. She was not a trained speaker and probably never expected she would be sitting in a court room like this where a persons life depends on her evidence she provides.

[@sherrycostonde]

She should have know she would have to testify in courts of law. It’s part of the job

[@racheldeschamps5979]

@@sherrycostondeit still doesn’t make her any less nervous to be there

[@Remmysage]

@@sherrycostondecould be her first time. Who cares. She’s there to talk about what she tested not be a public speaker. Who cares?? She got what she studied out.

[@rogerbastien2354]

Larry the car light could have some out of a junk yard please make that clear

[@Vivian-hz3hz]

Will The Glarer is so adorable DUI GUY it’s my first time on your channel I subscribed 🎉

[@summercavenaugh4057]

OMG I caught a Live!! Nice

[@allabouttheshade]

That shoe looks like a whole different Nike. I could be wrong but I thought in pictures it looked like a low top black and white dunks.

[@shastascorner3430]

Looks brand new too. no dirt or wear and tear on it. Way too clean.

[@christineanderson2237]

Attorney reminds me of the members of the Lollipop Guild form original Wizard of Oz; hair and red face

[@rock0228maggie]

The video at the bar with J.O. and K.R. clearly shows that J.O. right arm has no injuries, scratches, wounds because K.R. touched that arm in an endearing manner and J.O. did not reacted like he was in pain. The video shows that J.O. was NOT injured. So where and when did J.O. sustained the right arm injuries. Both of them looks happy to see each other too. I'm just wondering how com Commonwealth called 50+ witnesses already and has not called the lead investigator and the coroner which are more relevant. I guess, commonwealth tries to sell their narrative and hopefully without proof would make jurors believe commonwealth.

[@jenniferruth812]

3:19:19 “At some point did you learn the name of the body or the person that was found on the lawn at Fairview?” -Lally To me the represents the entire prosecution side- John is just a BODY to them.

[@DanielleDague]

Larry, your hair looks great.

[@summercavenaugh4057]

And no internal injuries or broken bones?! Hmm

[@Bloodborn420]

I sure would like to hear those ear buds😁

[@Fluffylover261]

She’s protecting the whole gang

[@briangalligan53]

Did she ever take fingerprints from the items

[@carolavanmeenen9917]

I knew it was Trooper Procter before she said it. She knew the anser but did not want to say what i think

[@patriciakelleher9529]

We know that’s not how a canton finest stored the evidence

[@CrystalLaRosa-z1w]

Yea! DUI 😺 ❤❤❤

[@mrsanchez27]

lol under the bridge and he’s wearing a Red Hot Chili Peppers shirt I love it great coincidence

[@gloriagillham9844]

How did glass come from a shirt in an evidence bag that has never been opened?

[@springer585]

Why did they go to the mccabe residence and not the Alberts house, I wonder

[@markf350s]

I thought all the evidence had to be brought in before the trial started. Did that change?

[@Remmysage]

Ummm no. Lol. That’s not how trial works

[@Loch1234]

Check out John’s shoe admitted into evidence. It looks new and it’s white underneath. The one found in the snow and up against the curb is black underneath.

[@missylynns8966]

That Nike looks brand new!!!

[@lukeholler4364]

FACT: These 2 women working in the crime lab are partners

[@specialkl4792]

?

[@Goomba21]

Gay

[@JulieRushworth]

​@anthonymonaco7984 Oh, you know these 2 people?

[@6laireau]

Assume that’s true. What’s the probative value of that fact?

[@Insideyourbones]

So much speaking in ummms lol

[@thevinecrime]

How did you just noticed that Beverly is rushing Jackson she has rushed them she has said objection against them and said because the lawyer didn't get a chance to stand up and Larry agreed with it she tells them to hurry up and get over it but Larry has her filling out paperwork and she has the court reporter doing it all instead of the other two that are sitting there and then after she's done doing 1620 pages of evidence numbers she tells Jackson that he's wasting time Alan that he's not fast enough but it's okay for Lally to lollygag and for her to control every single thing how does a judge I've never heard of it a judge should not know every single thing the prosecution is doing when where and how so she can stand up and judge for them she says we will let him have it she never says I overrule she has made this her case through the prosecution

[@MSwain-yz4gl]

Is it normal for a judge to ask the prosecutor if he has an objection to the defenses submission? If he has an objection, he'd do so without her seeming to almost request an objection.

[@Remmysage]

Yes it’s normal

[@wendysturrock8759]

You are VERY LOUD !!

[@otisbuttress8576]

She knows she is innocent.

[@jeffwilliams3452]

The evidence is overwhelming now!

[@martinmccartney8874]

Sarcasm ??

[@tombulger]

You mean for acquittal, right???

[@michellefrew9764]

How do u get gifted a membership?

[@cynthiahotchkiss1597]

Also this is the first time we heard the word vomit Oder.

[@beastshawnee]

So far the prosecutor has proven by evidence that John was wearing clothes when he was murdered. Like…I just am waiting for the part connecting Karen to it except for Jen putting that in her head…Jen who googled “ Hos long to die in the snow?” Jen who barks like a rabid dog when confronted with her cover up.

[@sherrycostonde]

Your Johnny Depp mg has crossbone skully on it

[@jcs137]

That opening with the Boston accent.

[@cynthiahotchkiss1597]

When a person is needing medical attention they cut the clothes off of the victims. My sister in law was picked up from an accident and was unconscious and right there I the ambulance they cut her clothes off. The EMT-she found out was a friend from school. But I believe there is damage from a dog too, believe the dog was involved .

[@wendysturrock8759]

Can't they give Lally his personal Microphone that he HAS to speak into at all times !!!! He seems yo be the ONLY ONE we can't hear !!!!!

[@carolavanmeenen9917]

Go on whit the ums i have to laugh everytime you say it❤

[@stefanmagyar4042]

Proceeded to observe a particular individual…

[@RichardDonaldson-xx9ec]

Its such ashame that the forensic employees are dealling with planted bits of glass and hair, hair that managed to stick to a car that went through a blizzard!!!

[@bethany2495]

You can Clearly see when Karen left the driveway her light wasn't broken as it glowed Red from both tail lights as if it were broken & the red area all busted out Even if the light still worked it wouldn't glow red, as the light itself is white and only looks red due to The plastic cover

[@HeWhoHath]

Your sound is totally fucked up, dude I was trying to listen this while driving, and every time you cut in just about broke my eardrums. You need to match it to the testimony

[@Still17InMyMind]

Grrrrr! I hate that I cannot watch live chat replay, when I watch your lives, late. Sometimes KZbin puts it on there, and sometimes they don't. It's very annoying. Oh, well.

[@TheWizardOfEgo]

Why did you talk over major pieces of testimony. You totally missed Jackson making it clear there was not match between the glass on the bumper and the glass at the scene and the only match for the glass on the bumper was the glass that Proctor provided at a later date

[@ThndrRdQueen]

Why didn't Bukake show all sides of the orange shirt and jeans as he did the hoody.???

[@springer585]

I wondered that as well

[@missylynns8966]

Wasn’t John buried in the snow for hours how is his shoe so clean????

[@springer585]

Exactly my observations! It looked brand new to me

[@Remmysage]

Snow usually is clean

[@markf350s]

WOW

[@terrymathews2397]

This lady has been doing this time in her life so much she doesn't even realize she does it it's an automatic thing she does she cannot help it it's just like muscle memory it's going to do it

[@thevinecrime]

The reason why your volume is solo on the court case is because the channel you are watching everybody has gone through them and True Crime is the only one playing the True Value all these other sites their volume is turned down too low I'm in the middle of watching you and truth and transparency because yes it's a court case you're watching on that channel you're viewing it on compare to True Crime channel that is loud and clear

[@specialkl4792]

Who is the Glarer?

[@michelletaylor4211]

No court on Friday!

[@B555-o4f]

He definitely has a touch of the tism. -Theo Von

[@Remmysage]

Cute and classy comment

[@jencaligal6345]

Hey DUI guy- @2:56 it's an important question that he's asking heard… and it's difficult to hear when you are speaking- perhaps you can pause the video when you want to interject / speak on the video. No criticism here- just a suggestion. I went to another KZbin page to hear it. It's an important part. With this portion and what came out from her is "…The item could of come from another source with the same characteristics …" meaning it could of been planted there with a part from another SUV with the exact same year, model, color, etc… Another source: SUV Same characteristics: SUV same year, model, style, color… etc… wow wow wow

[@Remmysage]

At 2:56 the court want even in session yet?

[@Volsman5150]

He doesn’t live in Mass……..he’s in Florida

[@matt_orangecrushfan]

Some of those laughs seem to be from nervousness.

[@Remmysage]

They are clearly nervous and feel awkward. Seems really low to try and attack them for it.

[@teleworkmom6595]

No court friday

[@DebbieFaria-u2c]

He lives in Tennessee

[@patriciakelleher9529]

Paul😊

[@coyotebait3689]

Why is he so fixated on the plastic from taillight?

[@michellefrew9764]

How much in gbp per month

[@shastascorner3430]

Does anyone know who the guy in the red and white shirt to the left of the defense is? Keeps staring at Karen.

[@dreadede]

I believe that is John OKeefe’s brother

[@shastascorner3430]

@@dreadede Thank you.

[@sir_squonks_alot_castro4438]

Larry reminds me of a gay guy that loves broadway lol

[@slapadabass13]

Just curious who is working on your case load while you’re doing so much streaming for superchats?

[@nancyobrien7741]

Stoooopppp!!! The only thing more annoying than this woman doing this is you doing this!!!😂😂

[@JulieRushworth]

Your rude.

[@Remmysage]

@@JulieRushworthyou’re* and you’re the rude one. You had to start your comment off with “not to be rude” which means, YOU’RE rude! lol

[@AshleyMarieMommy]

Most annoying person I ever heard talk she said Umm over and over then add Lally then he started saying umm

[@The_Brew_Dog]

I didn’t hear a thing she said, the only thing I heard was the word “um”.

[@patriciakelleher9529]

DID YOU SEE THE SMIlE smeark 🤥🤥🤥

[@rufusbrownstone6190]

Is this going to be on 48 hrs or Forensic. With this trial are they also going to find out who killed him or just prove she didn't do it? This is my first rodeo 🤷‍♀️

[@grandykim]

"Um" is a very rude word. It means: "Don't talk. I'm still talking. I need time to think."

[@Vivian-hz3hz]

So true 😂or Um I Um I Um don’t want to Um date you anymore

[@The_Brew_Dog]

I don’t know if I’d label it as “rude” but I definitely consider it offensive to my mental health. 😂

[@JulieRushworth]

The witness is nervous and anxious

[@robertstanley9405]

Were is the ball cap?

[@Insideyourbones]

True! Where is his cap??

[@angelamurray8392]

Maybe the judge noes it's corrupt and making sure it all looks fare

[@lauraostman5120]

Never changed gloves during this display!

[@Insideyourbones]

GOOd point!!! !!! This could very easily demonstrate the kind of cross contact which has gone on during evidence collection.., because highly doubt these police has one ounce of a fkin clue… Imagine a doctor is doing surgery and is working on a patient, then with the same gloves just starts operating on another.. WHAT! Ok so the same goes to evidence collecting! Even with tweezers, every single item touched should be done so with a new set of gloves, new or disinfected clean tweezers unless it is collected without touching the sample at all - like being scooped directly into an evidence bag- a plastic one. It’s like when you see people in hospitality wearing gloves to make a sandwich, but then handling money at the register and then making sandwiches again… no no no! Lol Seriously I wouldn’t trust a scrap of evidence from the police based purely on the fact that they can’t be trusted to follow correct procedure, and they seem to decide according to their beliefs rather than relentlessly documenting evidence, with photos at every single pint of contact, and not having body cams to back up anything they do… at no pint have they takien a photo when they first saw Karen’s car, didn’t photograph if when they were at the Reads, to timestamp and show - this is how it looked when we picked it up! Instead we are shown videos from the defendants ring camera, … so they are relying on others indirect angles to argue that they are correct in their behaviour and judgment… what the hell.:: if I were Karen I too would have taken photos initially (not at Fairview because she was attending to John of course) but I have learnt to always document so you can back yourself or at least have the truth. That’s also why dash cameras can be so helpful too… she was in shock and then had zero time to really do this before they immediately point the finger at her, yet failed to get any evidence at the time to back up their theories… which just screams to me that Karen is not at fault here!

[@normcaissie5598]

Mocking her with the Umms is more annoying then her doing it.

[@Insideyourbones]

I hate to be judgyyyy but there were so many ummmmms.. every time a question is asked, it is said prior to anything (pretty much!) even in different tones and emotion! I felt like lawlly lolly started to even say ummm more as her was being influenced by the amount of ummms…

[@Remmysage]

It’s judgey, you should hate it. It’s always and the questions are very vague. They feel awkward if you can’t tell.

[@sherrycostonde]

She is so immature

[@jcs137]

Ok….the commentary..lol

[@gloriagillham9844]

The bags don't even look like they have even been to a lab or forensics

[@carinapersson8476]

Socks

[@perthyren601]

What do you breathing with? Rectum?