I ordered ONE OF MY CAKES from 1 vs. 5 STAR BAKERY - Ep. 2 Avocado Cake

[@TheIcingArtist]

Of alllllllllll the cakes on my channel, which one do you think I should challenge them to next???

[@annikagupta4113]

You never give any less you always impress

[@kananbhatt3373]

The crayola crayon box was the best maybe that or the one of the princesses cakes 😊

[@laurenschenck5355]

Challenge them with summer cakes ❤️❤️

[@hetalsheth3210]

Wonder woman was the best

[@ESmith7070]

What about the cinnamon roll or cookie jar cake? Also, you could do Autumn/fall cakes!

[@Spamhard]

I actually like the rough edging on the 5* one as it makes it look more like an actual avo. Plus I honestly think the spray splatters add for an extra bit of texture and shading, I honestly assumed it was on purpose until you pointed it out, and even then I'm still not sure it's accidental as you can see similar along the bottom too. I thought it was shading, as from a distance it gives it some added pop. Only downside is not having anything in the pit when the video showed it with something.

[@XOChristianaNicole]

Agreed.

[@haggardtrish]

I agree also. Same with the uneven pit color, she made it sound like that was something wrong or something they messed up, but to me it was pretty clear it was purposefully done to make it look more realistic

[@dragonarya6]

Honestly, I think the 5 star went more towards giving it a slightly realistic look. So the 'airbrush splotches' are supposed to be there since an actual avocado would have those speckles as well. And the splotchy paint on the chocolate sphere is like how an actual pit would look. The description of the cake made me want to go and get a cake asap though, haha.

[@Kelscheroni]

About the 5 star cake: yes, there were flaws with the spray coloring, the dowel was visible on top, and there was a smudge on the fondant in back. But I get the impression that the bakery was attempting to make the avocado look as realistic as possible. You pointed out that the coloring on the pit looked splotchy, but I think that was their intent, as real avocado pits are pretty splotchy. I even think they deliberately did a choppy job with the edges of the dark green fondant. Avocado peels have rough edges when you slice them open. I like that they included the stem stub on top, even if it feels like a missed opportunity to use that to cover the dowel. Having said that, however, I’m highly disappointed they didn’t fill the pit with any goodies. Especially if the video you sent them with your order specifically showed you doing that with yours. I don’t think it would’ve mattered if they put something different inside, the fact that its just a hollow shell is just downright tragic. To address some of the replies: yes, I understand that the first priority of these cakes (and ultimately the purpose of the video) is to see how closely the bakery can replicate her original creation. I was simply surprised that she looked at what appeared to be a creative flair that the 5 star added to theirs, and then treated it like technical flaws. She's been known to still commend some bakeries for doing things a little different, even if it's not what she asked for, and I felt she didn't do that this time.

[@laurenharrison7057]

I thought the exact same thing, especially in terms on the rough edges of the dark green fondant!

[@sebastien2281]

You can even see different shades of green for the flesh between the edge and the center. It is more realistic than the original design.

[@romanaa7070]

She always puts down people's work who she sees as a threat to her own. Its not shocking anymore

[@laurenharrison7057]

@@romanaa7070 oh I don’t think that! I think she was just comparing as a kawaii cake rather than just reviewing as it’s own cake. I love watching these videos- it’s important to remember it’s her opinion, we can have a different opinion of course!

[@jacquelinetheanicole]

Agreed. It was my favourite cake out of the three because of how realistic it looked; even with its fun twist.

[@EattheCheesiest]

I can’t imagine making that second cake and letting it leave the store for $300!! The fondant on the back was literally broken

[@artful1967]

I agree. I would have been sending it back.

[@lisahuber9329]

And the colors look like they just used store bought green fondant, they definitely didn't color it themselves. That is not avocado green. For 300 dollars I'd expect my avocado cake to be avocado green.

[@ix_nil]

@@artful1967 the skin’s texture too.

[@koi.in.pond3149]

It's 💩💩💩💩💩💩

[@cd2290]

I don’t know how they would even consider pricing a cake that high with that quality. I wouldn’t by a $20 cake from them after seeing that kind of work. Fingerprints and nail marks in the board fondant…eeew!

[@millybell5858]

loved the video! was it just me who was disappointed that they didn't smash the second avocado stone tho? love from london ❤️

[@MaeLanae]

I came here to find this comment😅

[@dietotaku]

i'm guessing they didn't smash it because they already pointed out that it's not even a chocolate ball, sounds like it's just more cake covered in fondant and tacked on with toothpicks.

[@eeyoreismissing]

If it was just cake I would have liked to have seen her cut into anyways. But yes I was very disappointed.

[@kidscrunchesandcooking7803]

It was the first thing I said when the video ended 😹😹😹

[@dragonlilyacres2411]

I really wanted to know what the other avocado seed was made of...

[@landt.]

The back texture of the avocado of the 5 stars store is super. Even better than her original cake. Also the wooden board is beautiful as well.

[@astridmiller8349]

"I shouldn't have to applaud a cake standing up straight, but this is where we are in this series." 😂😂

[@TheIcingArtist]

🙈

[@frankfurtonfoottours2361]

The pit in the 5* cake looked super realistic! That is what avocado pits look like. The airbrushed skin also looked realistic, rather than be all one green color.

[@shelleyl9368]

Everything that 5 star bakery does is EXCEPTIONAL. I loved their summer ice cream sundae cake, and their naughty Santa cake too. THE TALENT IS UNREAL.

[@microsoftcancelparty1915]

Do u know what Bakery that is? I AM SUPER BIASED TO THE BAKERY.

[@baseboned]

Not breaking open the 1 star pit is going to haunt me all day. I get that it wasn't chocolate or maybe even hollow, but I wanted to see what happened and what it was.

[@amyarcher8017]

I feel the same way! I have to know!

[@stephanieguzman]

SAME!!

[@nataliecidon5775]

YES!!

[@GotWrackspurts]

You can get a little hint at 7:27, how it's completely separate to the advocado. Must be very light to be attached with toothpicks to it. But def speculation isn't the same as knowing and I also want to know

[@TheIcingArtist]

Hahaha my bad!! I think it was a styrofoam ball covered in brown fondant

[@MirandaMilner]

I think the pit of the avocado was supposed to look splotchy. It was their way of making it more realistic, cause a lot of the time avocado pits look patchy, especially if you leave them out for a tiny bit.

[@almaeclu]

I get that the smooth fondant edge looks nicer, but technically a fresh cut avocado has a rough edge!

[@talismallafigueroa5023]

This is exactly what I thought, I felt it was an effort to make the texture as realistic as possible.

[@danielleking262]

That's what I was thinking! You don't want a smooth edge, it would look rough after you cut it open!!!

[@dracawyn]

I think the splotchiness of the avacado pit on the 5 star one was intentional. It looks like a real avacado pit

[@marcialitt4431]

When it cut back to both of them on the table together I was struck by just how much that thing looked like an avocado. The shading, the skin, the shape, everything

[@Pikachuwhereareyou]

The 5 star one was perfect in my opinion. The small imperfections just made it more realistic. Only disappointing nothing fell out the chocolate ball.

[@JellyJessYT]

The giant pit on the 1 star bakery cake *LOOOOOOL i'm losing it*

[@danielleking262]

She didn't even break it open!!! Or what was it made of then, was it solid??

[@amberkellie5255]

Danielle king I was wondering the same thing and she didnt even show how they were structured?

[@complainer406]

When she turned it sideways it sent me

[@ix_nil]

SKSKSKDJ IM ASCENDING

[@antoinettehomen8581]

YESSSSSS 😂😂

[@Phoenixcomplexx]

I really like the jagged edges on the edge of the fondant at the front of the 5star because it mimics how a real avocado would be

[@embraceyourwolf]

They roughly cut the fondant for the front of the 5 star cake because it looks more realistic

[@trevormanuel9869]

Hello dear how are you doing over there?

[@ojasvikumar2264]

Reasons why I love this channel 1. Pure and wholesome content 2. I love her positive attitude and her smileee 3. Creative and interesting 4. Never fails to amuse

[@Fluffnugget78]

I genuinely can't believe how much cakes cost in America/Canada. It's insane compared to here in the UK. I got an insanely decorated, intricate cake for my father's birthday, big enough for 40 people for about 60 pounds. That would be, what? $100

[@rue3816]

Yes! Here in South Africa a 5 tier top of the range wedding cake would cost about $600

[@renia1833]

As an American it always surprises me too😭 A one tier cake with minimal decorating can be 35$

[@tash4270]

It's the same in Australia, it's seriously expensive

[@itskemani2325]

She never disappoints i about to literally about to make me a cake watching all these awesome videos

[@소중한-h6g]

For those wondering, Laurie said that the belly of the 1-star bakery cake is made of some sort of styrofoam ball covered in brown fondant

[@leelandluver]

I love her hair. That color looks so flattering on her.

[@geelizz]

What about the other belly? Lol this has to be my favorite cake series. I love seeing what you get and so wish I lived by the 5 star bakery! 😋 yum!

[@Marialla.]

In another answer thread, she said she thinks it was a styrofoam ball. How weak is that!?

[@libraryoflilylol199]

@@Marialla. She THINKS? Cut open the styrofoam ball pit on camera, you coward!

[@tomato9668]

I love how she designs her own cakes then asks other people to make it It’s one of my favorite videos she does

[@createwithcait]

I got a good laugh with the "I'll do a little montage of the ones that have collapsed" 😂😂 Que the sad music!!

[@bladepanthera]

If you cut an avocado the edge is rough so I prefer the edge definition on the 5* one!

[@jorrdan.]

The fact that the 1 star bakery is even still open is amazing

[@Clarky1951]

Ha Ha Jordan….I’m a amateur/hobby cake decorator. And let me tell you, the 1 star bakery isn’t half bad compared to what I have seen go out from some home bakers. Would make you shudder. The majority of home based decorators are pretty good. But there are some, let’s just say, they need a looooooot more practice before they start selling cakes. From structure to design to execution. But they still manage to stay in business. 🤪

[@lindastrandquist2429]

So.e don't gave the same expectations of the cakes they get.

[@arcticFolder]

myb their sides are good enough to hold them up for years, not the cake but others like bread or biscuits or donuts 🤔 but so far, i think this 1star avocado is better than other 1star, like laurie said they're both standing 😂

[@KaylaKrische]

Aww you didn't open the avocado pit on the second one. The love relationship with the first cake blinded you lol

[@RJ-pk3ns]

I don't think there was anything in it, it kinda looked like a cake ball stuck on with toothpicks.

[@tabaquaberry]

@@RJ-pk3ns but who knows, that mightve been where the hazelnut espresso was hiding! lol

[@lobsterlogic]

@@tabaquaberry Haha, lol!

[@ESmith7070]

I was literally waiting for this!😂 I can’t wait to watch! Btw, love your shirt and hair!❤️

[@kikioro]

I literally laughed out loud at the second cake. Adorable but not $295 adorable hahaha

[@samsartt]

Seriously Laurie before even watching the video I can assure you that no bakery can make the exact cake that you make. I'm not sure if you need to hear it (I hope u don't because your amazing) but your an awesome cake decorator super halairious and your energy throughout the years hasent vanished

[@LotusFlowerBmb]

12:56 has me rotfl 😂 that hollow yet desperate attempt to scoop something out with the fork 🤣🤣 I felt the hope and disappointment all at the same time lol

[@TheIcingArtist]

So much disappointment... 😥

[@Marialla.]

I second what another commenter said, Please do a fall tree cake! It'd be so cool to see how you structure it. It must have multi colored leaves, a squirrel, and a swing!

[@GooseAdvocate]

It was so cute when you were jumping around with the oversized backpack.

[@dyslexiahelpforallages4176]

I thought the same thing!!

[@spitfire3984]

Why are you the cutest person ever? I truly love your energy and personality. My favorite thing on your channel is the 1 star vs 5 star.

[@lobstershorts1]

I thought they both looked really good. It would be fun if you brought them both out and critiqued them before revealing which was the one star and the five star. That way we could guess which was which.

[@trevormanuel9869]

Hello dear how are you doing over there ?

[@katierose3262]

I have to say it's very interesting watching a cake designer look at another cake designer. You can tell she loves making cakes and loves her job because of how much work she puts into it and how she can notice and see things that don't look appealing and how much fondant they put and the taste and texture.

[@candacemoore1194]

If I pay $300 for a cake I would want almost perfection you are so kind when reviewing them hands down yours was absolutely amazing and I wasn’t convinced with either cakes

[@annelibacila8657]

Replica surfaces might be her best sponsor yet! Loved it!

[@TheIcingArtist]

I honestly can't believe those photos I took. Mine usually look so amateur..... but these felt magazine worthy!! 😍

[@adaaprakash9265]

Yay I'm on time today! Love your vids, you are so amazing Laurie, pls make a video of Kevin baking and decorating a cake

[@TheIcingArtist]

Coming soon.....! What should he decorate thought??

[@adaaprakash9265]

Omg you replied to me! I cannot believe it! I think he should make a tie dye pattern cake on the inside and a buttercream rainbowish with piped flowers on it .... (another idea- a "back to school" cake). Thanks Laurie for being so amazing and inspiring, I am just 12 and I made a cake for my dad's birthday, he loved it . It's all your influence on me!

[@mayurid2110]

She is very positive. She never gives bad critiques. Love you!

[@BeDreamingTo]

I love that you guys listened to my feedback apparently and we now get to see the cake at the same time as you! Makes it a lot more fun than hearing your reaction first before we get to see it.

[@MargoMB19]

Your reaction to that chocolate strawberry cake just totally made my day, you look like you are in cake heaven!

[@bonniehowell9206]

I loved the collapsed cake montage. I could only imagine spending $300 to $500 on a cake only for it to be destroyed so quickly.

[@mimi_20009]

i love how honest and sincere she is concerning the cakes 🥰❤️.

[@trevormanuel9869]

Hello dear how are you doing over there ?

[@venuzbabi08]

The pit looking "splotchy" makes it feel more real to me

[@GlamGoreChaosQueen]

I love the little wonky arms from the one star 🥺😍 I love his little funky self he's so cute.

[@gugusikhosana478]

Loving this series so much💝

[@sampratikulkarni4016]

14:09 "Maybe I'll just leave you two alone?" XD

[@luciadiaz9426]

I love these Vids! Laurie always makes my day better! I am always so happy when she posts!

[@shriyapandita4295]

Watching your videos are like therapy 💜 helps brighten up your really crap day , thank you ❤️

[@FocusingOnChrist]

I wanted to see you break open the second pit! I’m wondering if it would just roll across the table. 😆

[@sundlaarshad9511]

i really like her becuz she always gives you honest reviews. keep it up lovely girl♥️

[@danaek3040]

Wait.. what was the pip of the 1 star bakery’s avocado made of?

[@InolaTree]

And was there anything inside it??

[@bucketobviously5499]

she says in the comments it was a Styrofoam ball lol

[@trevormanuel9869]

@@InolaTree hello dear how are you doing over there?

[@sh4577]

Her “this is delicious” face and “this tastes like a weird paper bag” face look the same lol!

[@complainer406]

Kevin knew the difference instantly though haha

[@terribowles5085]

You didn't crack open the pit of the 1 star cake. I was wondering if there was anything inside. Why don't you have the 1 star, 3 star and 5 star bakeries bake a "Fall Tree" 3D cake. Fall color leaves, squirrel on the trunk, wide branches, etc.

[@bonniehowell9206]

Turns out it was just a Styrofoam ball covered in chocolate fondant:(

[@Marialla.]

Oooo, I'd love a fall tree cake! "Will the fall tree cake fall?? Stay tuned!"

[@min_nad]

Omg that would be so cute

[@Cupofcrafts_Drishti]

I love when she uploads these kind of videos⭐🌼

[@ojasvikumar2264]

I'd love to see a Collab with sideserf cake studio! I feel like they would just click and the content would be super amazingg

[@bonniehowell9206]

Yes! I just found their channel! I was blown away by her cup of noodle and edible plastic spoon cake!

[@rescued1103]

When you said “that where we are in this series” that whole thing gave me super strong David Rose vibes. Loved the video!

[@denisemcdougal6445]

The 1 star cake is adorable but too expensive for what they did The 5 star cake looks more realistic

[@trevormanuel9869]

Hello dear how are you doing over there?

[@addisonhunger289]

I remeber watching you make the original cake in this video two years ago! Wow, time flies :)

[@stephj4295]

I love your videos, they always cheer me up. What on earth do you do with all that cake? x

[@ChickenPermission617]

You eating that 5star cake made me think of monica on friends when she’s eating that really delicious slice of cake “I think I could show this cake a good time” 😂😂😂 Love chocolate and raspberry together, that was probably so good

[@Aitherea]

When she tried the 5 star cake she literally looked SO upset i thought she hated it... and then she was like "I love it." That was the plot twist of the century.

[@garlandajoyce1980]

Neither of those cakes are worth $300! The first one maybe $80-100 but the 2nd $60 max. I use to do cakes & while I did under price them I am sure, that size of a cake doesn't require a ton of work. It doesn't take days to prep for it, it can be done all in one afternoon. The first one was super cute, just needed the pit to be slightly smaller and have candy inside.

[@baseboned]

You're time and their time is absolutely worth that. One afternoon of your time, the skill and artistry involved, the materials. SO many artists undervalue their own work. YOU'RE WORTH IT!

[@garlandajoyce1980]

@@baseboned I agree, the problem is no one wants to pay for my time just the cake. I have done cakes that took days of prep ahead of time, making fondant decorations, drying them out, baking the cakes, prep, purchasing items needed then actually spending hours on end assembling. I spent many nights up past midnight finishing a cake.

[@lorrainehicks6484]

No one can compare to your cake designs. Love the video. Thanks for sharing and as always keep on caking.

[@trevormanuel9869]

Hello dear how are you doing over there?

[@jenn1234]

I always love these or any of your videos! The 1 star bakery’s cake was definitely not worth almost $300! 😠 You sent them a video of how you did it and they both missed stuff!! WTF? It’s always fun to watch, and I’m glad that you are honest about it. I can’t wait for another one! I just love this series! Thanks Laurie and Kevin! I wished you lived closer so I could have you make me a birthday cake! 😄❤️🐬

[@ajd8558]

I'm surprised these bakeries don't know their cakes end up on your channel!

[@danielleking262]

If they do, they can't say because they would be outting themselves for any flaws she points out, hahaha But yeah, I am curious if the bakeries do catch wind of why she's ordering so.many custom cakes and found her judging videos and what they thought!!! Esp. the one-star bakeries 😁

[@cakestar1896]

Clients send it to us 😉

[@pattyfluegel7816]

the things you hate are the good things. The varigated color on the avacado pit like real vegitation, the air brushing on the front, many avacados are darker near the rind....I do wish there were sprinkles in the pit tho.

[@reeeksss_]

LOVE THIS SERIES SO MUCH. I LOVE YOU! 💕💕💕

[@laurenschenck5355]

Aww the avocado cake is so CUTE 🥰

[@amandawade7803]

This is like the perfect cake for my home town, because the biggest event of the year is the Avocado Festival which lasts three days and has the best dressed avocado contest from the middle school, the largest vat of guacamole, avocado ice cream, etc. It would be cool to make an avocado flavored cake with lime filling to mimic guacamole.

[@harmonyinmyhead91]

This sounds insanely good :o

[@AASSVIIIF-km1jn]

I just lovee her vids...They are soo entertaining and exciting 💖 😫Just a huge fannnn

[@livp2944]

Need to know the name of the 5 star bakery so I can order from them! Both Cakes looked amazing :)

[@Namealast4748]

Yes! I’ve been looking through the comments trying to figure out if anyone has a name for the 5 star bakery😭😭

[@thriftytxmom]

I can’t believe they charged you $295 for that cake! Neither were worth the price but the one star was just ridiculous.

[@trevormanuel9869]

Hello dear how are you doing over there ?

[@nannybells]

queen of not wasting time on introductions

[@lisamcgrath3132]

Neither cake, to me, looks worth $300.00!

[@danielleking262]

ikr!!! That's ridiculously expensive for such a small cake and honestly, not THAT many details!! I would think the 1-star bakery would be $100 max, smh

[@complainer406]

She's Candaian, so if you're American her $300 is your ~$235

[@ix_nil]

@@danielleking262 I’d pay 100. Sure, it’s not as much work, but I’d take it.

[@bluerabbit4010]

@@complainer406 Tbh I still don't think the 1star is worth that much XD Canadian or not lol

[@complainer406]

@@bluerabbit4010 1 star definitely not, but I think it puts the 5 star a bit more in perspective

[@nharrison3]

How funny. I actually loathe youtube, but I got cancer over a year ago and have had several surgeries. Started watching your channel and have a ball! I love decorating cakes and you have inspired me to pic it up again in between surgeries. What a hoot! Keep them coming!

[@rcherese]

Not going to lie, I'd be livid if I paid 300$ for the 2nd cake and got that. For 300$ the fondant should be immaculate without fold marks

[@triceratops_10]

I agree! it's fine that it was simple, but it should be look clean and perfect for that price point

[@pollypocket2282]

I am so excited that I’m commenting BEFORE watching! This is going to be so interesting!!!! Oh the pain…. if I showed up and someone told me that 2nd cake was $295…. I’d laugh and walk out. It looks like a home bake…. A VERY BASIC home bake…. Maybe $50. Also, you didn’t crack the 1 star pit (pit of sadness). As for the 1 star, I’d give it a B+…. Just because they were a little sloppy and had no filling in the pit… but you seemed to love the flavor! You are soooo kind to these bakeries!

[@Snowy1600]

As a fellow Canadian I really wanna know where the 5 star bakery is so I can try their cake flavors 😩😩

[@aprilebersol7195]

Yay! I always get so happy when I see you've uploaded a video ❤️❤️❤️

[@trevormanuel9869]

Hello dear how are you doing over there ?

[@judgylittleeyes7192]

Was the chocolate sphere on the second cake also empty??

[@trevormanuel9869]

Hello dear how are you doing over there ?

[@spacepawdyssey4288]

Oh my gosh you are just a joy to watch. This video was a hoot. I think I would certainly pay $300 for the 5 star bakery's cake. Not so much for the 1 star bakery.

[@ellieburton6208]

You never smashed the second pit? I know it wasn’t chocolate but what was it?

[@trevormanuel9869]

Hello dear how are you doing over there ?

[@kate4828]

Ngl I absolutely love the 5 star avocado!! I love how they made it realistic. No hate to yours (yours so absolutely beautiful!!) but I think I prefer the 5 star avocado! The detailing is amazing and the fact that they made it look like a real avocado is perfect!!

[@one_smol_duck]

Omg this one star bakery is the best at accidentally making adorably derpy cakes

[@suekelley6461]

I love the montage with the music! Thank you for the smiles today and hugs sent your way😘. 🙏🌍✌️🇺🇸

[@trevormanuel9869]

Hello dear how are you doing over there?

[@Chloesreborns123]

Was there anything in the chocolate ball of the 1 star cake?

[@kitastoi8268]

Love this, would be awesome if next time you had bakeries recreate your designs, you also recreated yours as well so we could see a physical side by side for a proper all-round comparison and how much it cost you to make/what you would sell it for verses how much theirs cost and what you would really pay for their versions. Just a thought :)

[@purplesunflower7778]

Omg I'm literally in love with the huge back pack 😂😂 I really want one😂

[@TheIcingArtist]

It's outrageous, and I love it! 🤣

[@elifdy2878]

5 star cake looks even better then others!! i love it so much it looks really realistic

[@LilBubby]

That montage was literally the saddest thing in life 😭

[@TheIcingArtist]

Seriously, how can so many cakes collapse?!

[@annagray6875]

@@TheIcingArtist because of you I was watching a cake competition tv show and they did a tall cake and the only thing I was saying was "Structure!!"

[@marcialitt4431]

Oh wow. When she shows them together the five-star cake looks exactly like an avocado!

[@bottomthor]

the one star bakery one is so stinking cute, i love the giant pit

[@BreakDanceFight]

Wait, what was the 1 star ball made out of?

[@ameliem772]

Omg! Hi Laurie I am actually wearing my avocado and toast Oodie! Perfect timing

[@chasestudio2736]

The first cake would be 300 dollars without the imperfections, and I would want it to be a little bigger considering the price point.

[@amanidaroui938]

I love this serie can't wait for the next one ❤

[@mirab5032]

i love how she starts with no intro And the sad music in the montage lmaooo

[@purplepandadollstudios4911]

That was my favorite video on your channel for so so long