Great team, I would have had the following: 2. Codie Taylor 10. Fin Russel 11. Kurt-Lee Arense (he had a crazy year) 15. Thomas Ramos
@wouterroos23592 сағат бұрын
The Southern Lions will never lose a test ever.
@petelivinlarge52 минут бұрын
Damien McKenzie was the biggest benefactor of the Boks using 4 Flyhalves this season... He was average at best....
@arthurharrison2972Сағат бұрын
South africa only managed 1 player in the year they won the RWC 23 Eben. Have got the accolades in 2024. Guess world rugby can get it right when they have very little choice. Had a great 12 months of rugby from Hamish. Thank you for keeping us covered
@JohnWhitney-x7y2 сағат бұрын
2 of the Irish are New Zealanders
@nielvanderwalt196527 минут бұрын
Nr 10 i wouldve gone for marcus smith or ramos
@corcaigh5 сағат бұрын
Menoncello was best player of 6 nations. No French player is surprising. Taylor should have got the nod over Marx.
@rodeo4-p6u2 сағат бұрын
have a soft-spot for Ardie Savea simply warrior class but totally agree with Pablo Matera good on you Mckenzie with a dream team behind you 🔥 Lowe doesn't do it for me in with the French Flier Bierrey .done.
@Karma-qt4jiСағат бұрын
Cody Taylor in place of Malcolm Marx. DMac definitely not the form 10 this year so I would say Marcus Smith perhaps. Bielle-Biarry (excuse spelling) or Arendse in place of Lowe. Mallia at 15. Hard to put Jordon there given how little time he played there this year.
@nielvanderwalt196521 минут бұрын
Mauvaka
@Antoinette-iv6evСағат бұрын
And who is the coach for world 15
@luke531646 минут бұрын
Who would be on the bench for this team?
@NickHiltermann5 сағат бұрын
It feels like World Rugby compensated for snubbing so many World Cup winning Springboks last year. I'm a South African and very happy for Marx but I have to admit that Mauvaka or Codie Taylor were probably the best Hookers in 2024.
@JacquesGeldenhuis3 сағат бұрын
And then they give PSDT player of the year , but ignore rassie for coach. and give dupont 7s POTY even though he played only 2 tourneys 😂😂
@pauljansen6650Сағат бұрын
Agree Marx shouldn't be in the team
@danielstone803 сағат бұрын
1. Nshe 2. mauvaka 3. lomax 4. Estebeth 5. Byrne 6. Du Toit 7. Sititi 8. Doris 9. Gibson-Park 10. Smith 11. correras 12. de Allende 13. Kriel 14. Kolbe 15. mallia From a Bok fan
@jameswyatt4443Сағат бұрын
Marcus Smith didn’t starting in the Six Nations though, I’d go Ramos. Mallia was robbed.
@dominicjohnson53525 сағат бұрын
three all blacks isn't great but not a single french player?
@jameswyatt4443Сағат бұрын
They drew to Italy, lost the Six Nations, and they don’t ever send good players to the SH on tour. They deserve nothing.
@Tuatara5875 сағат бұрын
Only 2 all blacks deserve to be in the dream team - DeGroot and Lomax.
@wouterroos23592 сағат бұрын
I really disagree with de Groot. It seems like he really ruins your scrums.
@rileyfreeman9726Сағат бұрын
De Groot has barely made any tests
@Karma-qt4jiСағат бұрын
Only one. Taylor.
@dombear5 минут бұрын
nobody's surprised to see 7 AFs players, no French, no English, no Scot????
@greggalant754342 минут бұрын
James louw is a quality player, I think Kurt Lee is better.
@trevor88924 сағат бұрын
What about Fin Russel,😮
@deanadams58124 сағат бұрын
So true
@rory75905 сағат бұрын
France fans will be annoyed! For NZ, that isn't bad, considering that they aren't the best team in the world currently.
@lewiswilliams227Сағат бұрын
Sititi should be there definitely all blacks best player is a rookie ..dont think will jordan was the best full back in the comp
@guesswho692531 минут бұрын
James Lowe and Pablo matera selections make absolutely no sense at all!
@wouterroos23592 сағат бұрын
PSDT should be blind side.
@ivanmynhardt2 сағат бұрын
he is blindside they just have the numbers the otherside only SA do we have our blindside as 7
@rileyfreeman9726Сағат бұрын
@@ivanmynhardtFrance and Argentina do the same
@jameswyatt4443Сағат бұрын
@@rileyfreeman9726France technically don’t, I believe they have a left side and right side.
@stefannieuwoudt47822 сағат бұрын
So Rassie has only won 1 coach of the year since 2019? That’s a joke!
@rileyfreeman9726Сағат бұрын
Maybe because he hasn't been the head coach since 2019 🤦🤦
@stefannieuwoudt4782Сағат бұрын
@ ah, that’s a good point. He has been this year though.
@rileyfreeman9726Сағат бұрын
@@stefannieuwoudt4782Yea kind of crazy how he didn't win it this year Tbf
@nielvanderwalt196519 минут бұрын
@@rileyfreeman9726 he didnt win it this year because what did he do? Look at his squad. My grandmother could coach that squad
@petrusvanderMerwe-o9k5 сағат бұрын
cant fault team
@Morkiemoose-zrt5 сағат бұрын
My team 1.Tamati Williams 2.Asafua aumua 3.Pasilio tose 4.Pieter Steph du toit 5.patrick tuipolotu 6.Wallace sititi 7.Josh van de flair 8.Arlie savea 9.Jamison Gibson Park 10.Damian McKenzie 11.Caleb Clark 12.Jordie Barrett 13.Gary ring rose 14 Kurt lee Arense 15.Thomas Ramos Sorry if I got some spelling wrong
@vanessamay36893 сағат бұрын
Nice ❤
@rodeo4-p6uСағат бұрын
Razor should tap into that frontrow as a point of difference. ball handling - carrying alongside setpiece and when Taukeiaho comes online. bingo ?
@brandendejongh732345 минут бұрын
Cody Taylor not getting the nr 2 is criminal
@AndrewAW-w2l3 сағат бұрын
No DuPont heresy 😂😂
@zabowookie3 сағат бұрын
it's only for English colony, so British
@andremaube50694 сағат бұрын
As a french fan, my disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined
@Edgycoo3 сағат бұрын
I have no idea how there are so few french and I think have so many boks is a bit odd.
@soidog6593 сағат бұрын
Because the Springboks are better.
@Edgycoo3 сағат бұрын
@@soidog659 barely. Theyve lost 3 out of 4 games to ireland and are 50% win loss ratio to france over the last couple of years.
@thurmanmerman27203 сағат бұрын
@@Edgycoo If you have read any comments by SA fans on line then you should realize that they only lose matches they have planned to lose
@Edgycoo3 сағат бұрын
@@thurmanmerman2720 oh that is an obvious delusion that all bok fans have for sure. They were trying new guys etc etc 11 changes etc etc. Win or lose they always have an excuse its quite entertaining.
@ColinAnderson-hy2oj4 сағат бұрын
..and not an Englishman in sight!
@nepiahemopo17022 сағат бұрын
As an ABs fan, I was both surprised and delighted DMac was selected ahead of Smith from England.
@wouterroos23592 сағат бұрын
1. Ox 2. Codie (he was better than Marx this season) 3. Williams 4. Eben 5. George Martin (he had a pretty good season, didn't he?) 6. PSDT (because SA switch the flankers) 7. Ardie 8. Sititi (just think how lethal this loose trio will be) 9. JGP 10. Marcus 11. Kolbe 12. DDA 13. Jesse 14. Jordan 15. Ramos
@jameswyatt4443Сағат бұрын
Terrible team. Williams is a loosehead, he can’t play 3. George Martin wasn’t England’s best lock, and the perennial losers don’t get players in the Word 15. Ardie played 8, Sititi played blindside, and they were not at good as other players in those positions. Marcus Smith didn’t start in the Six Nations, and he lost 5 games in a row when he did start.
@Balance-v8xСағат бұрын
Dmac at 10 is an absolute farcical call, so typical of world rugby, they have lost touch with reality.
@derekmirk59825 сағат бұрын
Damian Mckenzie wtf he's not reliable,really dumb pick
@MaryanneA95 сағат бұрын
Obviously you know nothing about rugby and talent.
@derekmirk59824 сағат бұрын
Wake up mary,
@nepiahemopo17022 сағат бұрын
Who was your choice?
@Balance-v8xСағат бұрын
And you don't obviously@@MaryanneA9
@derekmirk5982Сағат бұрын
On form it's definitely a problem,hope ritcie goes straight back in as number 1 in the 10 jersey when he returns.Hes on another level to who we have atm.
@blankmedia0142 минут бұрын
Macolm Marx and Damien Mckenzie should not be in this team.
@aurelienbertrand32772 сағат бұрын
Dupont ?!? 😅
@wouterroos23592 сағат бұрын
Didn't play much rugby.
@pauljansen6650Сағат бұрын
What??? Shows you the delusion of some fans
@AndrewAW-w2l3 сағат бұрын
Doesn’t make sense PTSD is blindside flank. SA no 6 jersey is designated open side. MORE WR cluelessness on display
@bradnaude233424 минут бұрын
he plays 7 for SA
@shaneclifford73987 минут бұрын
James Lowe and Jordan makes no sence!
@brentwithey42413 сағат бұрын
Bauden Barrett was our best against the French and you say a mistake not playing dmac your dreaming
@rodeo4-p6uСағат бұрын
I think it was a tactical mistake by Razor he played a very astute game against the Irish and showed maturity guiding the Abs and we know what he can do when the conditions are right. all in hindsight of course
@brentwithey42413 сағат бұрын
Dmac what joke
@nepiahemopo17022 сағат бұрын
DMac rules.
@AndrewAW-w2l2 сағат бұрын
James Lowe over Kurt Lee Arendse - what coach would realistically make that choice- Lowe is an open try line finisher, KLA scores through heavy traffic time and again and then there’s the French kid…
@wouterroos23592 сағат бұрын
I fully agree. I would not have JL in the top 10 wingers.
@rodeo4-p6u2 сағат бұрын
Lowe the show pony.
@jameswyatt4443Сағат бұрын
KLA is a better player. But James Lowe had a great year, the second wing could have been any of 4-5 wingers, Lowe is not a problematic pick for me.
@Karma-qt4jiСағат бұрын
@@jameswyatt4443 We love James Lowe because he gave us the win in the first Ireland test lol.
@michaelkissling8432Сағат бұрын
Will Jordan should've always been 15, Beauden Barrett should be far away from the 15 jersey as possible, shouldn't even be on the team!
@Janpan694 сағат бұрын
James lowe sucks
@nepiahemopo17022 сағат бұрын
Because he's a babe magnet?
@wouterroos23592 сағат бұрын
Agreed. He isn't in the top 10 wingers.
@wouterroos23592 сағат бұрын
But to be fair. He is really goos. Just nowhere near as good as I is made out to be.
@rodeo4-p6uСағат бұрын
Because he does. Funny how he doesn't feature in other comments 😳
@wlk240834 минут бұрын
Marcus Smith and Fin Russel were way better than DM.