Pakistan के कब्जे से Gilgit Baltistan को बचा सकता था India ? | Kashmir Accession | Tarikh Ep. 75

[@trendmaker7053]

First of All! I am From Gilgit Baltistan and secondly i thanks this guy because he tries his best to remain unbiased but that hindutva element made him to tilt towards the wrong side of history! GB was liberated by the Locals of GB and the Gilgit Scouts. No pakistani Indian or any other helped them at that time! Gilgit Got its independence from Sikh Dogras in 1 november 1947 and remained an independent state for 16 to 17 days .. Then GB annexed with Pakistan unconditionally. So in this context we were not part of any of the state at the time of annexation because we compelled the dogras to leave us by force. so There is no point to make it Harry sings decision to decide the fate of GB at that time. and secondly Pakistan attached our fate with kashmir issue at that time(it is still criticized by locals of GB to connect us again with state of kashmir). and it doesnt mean that we hate kashmir or IIOJK. we are ready to lead mujahdeens to liberate indian illegally occupied kashmir in the fronts lines..so try to stay on the right of side of history. and thirdly come out of dreams to call GB part of India ..we would rather love to die over becoming the part of Hindutva India

[@sudiphui4566]

"unconditionally joined Pakistan". So what happened now ? Tax issues, low electricity, every other day protest.

[@mujahideen3394]

​@@sudiphui4566your name sounds like phudi

[@rockyjohnson1775]

When you mentioned about mujahideen then automatically all this long comment becomes invalid…you are pak army bot

[@shahzadzaman2957]

Gilgit needs to be with 🇮🇳

[@nishantsingh9995]

Please use MAP's in the Videos for better understanding the Geographical Importance of a particular place.

[@dbarakeshkumar]

One of the best program. Jaha kam time me jyada information.

[@Zorawar2024]

Gilgit-balatistan per kabza na karna ye india ki sabse badi galti hai 1]🔷Kyu ki ye humne trade karne ke liye.....ek acha rasta ho sakta tha 2]🔷Tourism ke liye bhi ye sahi hota 3]🔷Aur china pakistan ki broader kabhi hoti hi nahi 4]🔷hume pakistan ke airspace ki jarurat nahi hoti 5]🔷 Afghanistan , Turkmenistan Uzbekistan etc ke sath bhi trade kar sakte the

[@akhileshkumarpandey7706]

India nahi nehru...aur congress.....jimmedaar hai...

[@prasenjitbiswas3629]

Agree..

[@gkhanna8415]

1947 के बाद सारे विष के बीज नेहरू और गांधी के ही बोए हुए हैं जिसकी फसल अब तैयार हो रही है।

[@nishchhatri237]

Aapki Jankari kabile tareef hai bhai,, ❤❤

[@shivamdixit5137]

1947 me USSR hua krta tha ye central Asian countries nahi thi aur USSR se dosti bandana mtlb USA 🇺🇸 se dushmani kyoki cold War kisi starting ho gayi thi. International relations contemporary conditions aur opportunity pe depend krte hai. Abhi aur pado... News channel ke gyan se chaloge to pura truth samajh nhi paoge.

[@iftikharanis5909]

May Allah grant peace to india,Pakistan and china

[@brishketuchaubey3145]

I would suggest that in this episode, there is no need to change any thing. script is master piece and voice of Nikhil sir is out of this world but In episode 72 if maps is used it will be awesome . Example are like jonney Harris KZbin channel he used maps graphs to give a view of battle or war

[@nishchhatri237]

Nice Suggestion Bro,,,

[@ankitkumarbhagat2899]

adding some map graphics would make this presentation more fascinating.

[@pankajdadhich3059]

Bahut sahi lagte h tarikh ke episodes, bas ek suggestion ki aise episodes me editing ke time map bhi add kiya jaye,jisse samjhne me aur asani ho. Shukriya.

[@Ind_deeps]

Thanks to the #lallantop team for its valuable research & broadcast . #Pakistan and its civilian may denies it, but the qurious audience will always go for findings even if they want to counter it.

[@DailyZindagi]

Munna. Tum to bahe hi heavy driver nilke. Kudos to Kamal and Deepak as well, camera did not shake a single time. And then to the video editors as well.

[@bengalkaladka3401]

bhai apka surname peshawari kyu hai, kya apki family 1947 me aaj ke peshawar wale area se aayi thi. dont feel bad , I am just curious to know

[@sukhjinderbhatyal6252]

Brig Ghansara Singh was imprisoned by the Gilgit Scouts and later handed over to India as " Prisoner of War", via Amritsar border.

[@Ali_F00]

What the f**k

[@jackripper8843]

Ek galti kar di writer ne vk menon nahi vp menon ko bheja gaya tha, dono alag vyakti hai, vp menon ne sardar patel k sath bharat ko ek karne me abhutpurv karya kia tha..vk menon defence minister the chinese war k time.

[@ashutosh_yadav]

Same experience with vertical limit 🖐🏼. I was in 6th std, I remember, watching this movie with my sister and we both were surprised to see the Pakistani army and Also some dialogue related to indian chai i.e. tea.

[@kanhyasah848]

Laggta hai appkaa gk kamjorr rahha hai 1998mayy kargil war Hui thee loggo koh pahlee baar kargil naam ki jaghah kaa patta challa ussya pahlya lay laddakv hee log janty thyy kyo kii y for yark hotta hai joh layy laddakh mayy melta hai baki vertical limit 2000hajjar mayy release Hui thee aur Sanya kargil war ki film dekee thee iss leyya mujjya toh patta thaa iss film mayy Pakistani bolty hai ki hum hindustani paan aur hindusti chai pee karr hindustanio kho galee dattya hai aur unkho uttanya kayy leyya golya fire kartya hai aur anant mayy boltya hai yah joh peechya madine parii hai whoh hum pakisvfaujio kayy leyya nahi balki ki ferangio kayyvleyya hai joh camping aur tracking kayy leyya aaya hai

[@chandrabhanyadav2610]

Kamal Ji hum bhi movie se yahi swal tha.... Aap ni bhut purni samsya yaad dila di.

[@panesar7]

Loved the idea of such episodes. Please keep it up

[@balram12446]

U r doing great job .. nice research

[@fta_freetimeacts]

कमल जी, अगर आपने इसमे map को भी जोड़ दिया होता तो, बेहतर होता।

[@AshishKumar-ex7gn]

Thank You Nikhil and Kamal ..lallantop

[@ANSHIKASARDA]

Best hai tarikh......only series I like

[@abhishekdude66]

Nikhil's narration is awesome

[@Certifiedh]

Please continue this type of episodes.

[@ayushpandey3638]

tarikh ke episode correction ke liye thanks nikhil bhai and team,ab dekhte hain kharcha paani wale kab karenge

[@ajaybhatnagar9214]

Nikhil, your research is incredible.

[@vijay9t9]

बहुत बढ़िया एपिसोड मैं हमेशा देखता हूं

[@bireshmishra2029]

When India captured what is current LOC, General Carriapa suggested to make it international border. His view was current border's geography (Ladakh, hills) was favorable to defend in future and people of this place (Buddhists, Hindus) were favorable for India. If we take entire Gilgit-Baltistan (first of all taking it was itself a mammoth task), neither geography nor people of that place will favor India.

[@saurabhshukla5552]

Yes, you are right..... original people of Gilgit and baltistan were replaced by pak army as they were Shia who is replaced by pathans of Khaibar.

[@huzaifanaveed3410]

​@@saurabhshukla5552wtf😂😂

[@shalupunjabi5896]

Awesome writer and Orator ❤️

[@brandshanisinghrajpoot5330]

कमल जी जिंदाबाद 👍🏿

[@prateekbondre4842]

I do miss Mushtaq's episode with you (nikhil) on Israel series.. Get him back , for another Middle East knowledge

[@zuhaibkhan3294]

Gilgit Scouts was introduced by Maharaja Hari Singh in 1913A.D with the help of Mir of Hunza & Mir of Nagar.

[@Sharma-o2n]

Those people also done genocide of local Hindus

[@zuhaibkhan3294]

@@Sharma-o2n Dumb person, there is no a single Hindu living in Gilgit-Baltistan..

[@digvijaysingh9555]

aap behtareen kar rahe hai.......aur karte rahe hamari yahi prarthana hai

[@markralph4739]

That area is undoubtedly Pakistan's crown jewel. Went there in 2019. Heaven on earth. Heaven

[@Ali-ld6tg]

Kaise

[@pallavisingh-vv8xd]

excellent summary

[@pradeepsingh-mq3mz]

Good work 👍 Nikhil sir ।।

[@vipinmasih9740]

निखिल pleeeeeeeeeeze मूछों में बहुत अच्छे लगते हो।

[@sksaddamhossain6306]

Kaha se information gather kiye hai uska source ka ullekh kiya kare..Taki Hume bhi pata chale.

[@abhaymahadik4607]

He mentioned book name

[@ajayshaw1835]

Bhout khub

[@praveshinanywhere7658]

Sahi kaha aj sirf bharat ki kitabon me hi h kashmir or gilgit baltistan.

[@bhavikrathodvisnagar8617]

One of the best show in Lallantop

[@Mggamer813]

V good description 👌

[@vinaykarakoti6067]

Tarikh series bhut achi h

[@ronakmistry2105]

Nice good information kabhi padhai me bhi nahi pata chala

[@surajraut68]

Sir I watch #the_lallantop_show just you series #tarikh... I made lots of notes for competitive exams and those were useful lots of times... Thanks sir...

[@arpanpeter1]

Great Job Deepak 👍

[@saurabhtalwekar4766]

Indian army was sent because of sardar patel....🔥 And not because of nehru....😠.

[@justmoment1494]

Yes sir to continue

[@RajuAnbhorkar]

निखिल भाऊ, माझी सकाळ आज दुपारी तीन ला झाली

[@ASHOKKUMAR-tb9zh]

One thing is factually incorrect and that is , it was not VK Krishna Menon , who is said to have gone to Srinagar, but it was VP Menon who Was in the Home office then and did lot of running about between Delhi and Srinagar to get the Instrument of Accession signed. After that only , India sent its troops to Kashmir.

[@jauhariakash]

Well done

[@navtejsingh5863]

Nikhil g jab maharaja Ranjit singh chal- base to aapne kaha ki "uttar-pashchim bharat par angrejo ka kabza ho gya." Ye baat galat h. Angrejo ka "punjab par kabza ho gya." Punjab ek alag desh tha.

[@rajnighera8814]

Yes of course this show, I love it.. thanks for this and especially sir your storytelling so impressive.. anchor sir I really like you. You are best in storytelling ..

[@GauravShakya.563]

Yes ye session aur bnaya jaye

[@mustakahmad8369]

Very good jankari

[@sushilsahu3626]

बहुत ही सुन्दर

[@gm002gameing]

I will request you regular broadcast in Tariq episode

[@jagjeetnishat6540]

नेहरूजी काश्मीर को भारत में चाहते थे कारण अंतृराष्ट्रीय परिस्थिति थी पर पटेल जो राष्ट्रीय परिस्थितियों के जानकार थे उन का कहना था कि हम भौगोलिक कारणों से काश्मीर व बिलोचिस्तान को संभाल नहीं पाएंगे, इसलिए उन की रुचि नहीं थी पर जब पाकिस्तान ने गुजरात के क्षेत्रों पर हक जताया तो वे काश्मीर के लिए सहमत हुए। राजा हरिसिंह की लापरवाही से, काश्मीर की भौगोलिक स्थिति और भारतीय सेना के पास गोला-बारूद न होने के कारण ( ये एक Army secret है, चाहें तो इस की पुष्टि कर सकते हैं, पाकिस्तान ने भारत से प्राप्त पैसों से हथियार ख़रीद कर काश्मीर पर हमला किया था ) युद्ध विराम स्वीकार करना हमारी मजबूरी थी। हम जब तक लड़ सकते थे लड़े पर दुश्मन को हमारी अंतृस्थिति पता लगना ख़तरनाक था। पाकिस्तान को राशि की अगली किश्त पटेल/नेहरू ने रोक दी पर गांधी जी इस नीति को न समझ कर सरकार पर भुगतान का दबाव बना रहे थे। नेहरू चुप थे पर पटेल इस से नाराज़ थे और उन्हें गोडसे ( जो मुसलमान पत्रकार बन कर उन से मिला था ) के सामने इस का ज़िक्र करना भारी पड़ गया था। काश्मीर पर नेहरू जी की अनुपस्थिति में पटेल द्वारा तमाम शर्तें मान कर रातों-रात हवाई रास्ते से फौजें भेज कर इतना काश्मीर बच सका और पाकिस्तान की आड़ में अमेरिका की चाल असफल हुई। अब शीतयुद्ध के समाप्त होने से अमेरिका की रुचि तो समाप्त हो गई है पर अब यह पाकिस्तान की प्रतिष्ठा का प्रश्न बन चुका है और उसके कुछ भाग में चीन की कूटनीतिक रुचि है।

[@mlanand6000]

Beautiful channel

[@_deepak_saini_04]

Love this show

[@sonudhaterwal4036]

Haa bilkul with animation improvw

[@brandshanisinghrajpoot5330]

चिकने निखिल भाई ❤️❤️

[@crazyprofile123a]

fantastic episode but I dont think we were taught that K2 is in India...

[@tanushree5952]

Nice explanation

[@darshanasrivastava7521]

सर जो जनमत संग्रह वाली बात आपने कही है क्या यह महाराजा हरी सिंह और भारत सरकार के बीच जिस दस्तावेज पर हस्ताक्षर हुआ था उसमें लिखा हुआ है

[@ratheeparas]

Bhai psnd krte hain tareek ko…bnd mt krna isse

[@viveksinha9246]

you have given a wrong information... not V.K menon it's V. P memon who played the important role for kashmir Accession...🤫🤭

[@MDAli-dq6ql]

Thanks

[@yafehkaleem2562]

Situation settle honay k bad bhi referendum hona tha... Waiting for refrendum

[@satpalbatra1955]

Referendum was to take place subject to withdrawal of army by Pakistan fron POK and Gilgit Baltistan. Pakistan didn't do it. So referendum couldn't take place. Thereafter Pakistan has settled a large number of non Kashmiris in that area. And many lakh Hindus from Kashmir valley have been scared away and they have settled in other parts of country. When, Pakistan didn't meet the first condition of withdrawing forces from POK, demography is stands changed in past 74 years, 3 generations have lapsed since then and the persons who were eligible to participate in referendum, where is now the point of holding referendum now. The resolution of referendum st this point of time is defunct now.

[@yafehkaleem2562]

@@satpalbatra1955 along with Pakistan India was also instructed to do the same followed by which UN will with held kashmir and will arrange referendum.. But both sides are insecure to remove their army

[@abhaysharma753]

@@yafehkaleem2562 but firt pakistan have to do ot

[@yafehkaleem2562]

@@abhaysharma753 difference is due to religion Hindus are not true hindu Bhrama sutra say.. There is only one god not another not at all, not at all... But still Hindu worship handmade statue

[@abhaysharma753]

@@yafehkaleem2562 brother this is not so true hinduism is very old and people start to question wht is god tht's why these statues work as reference for them it might can hapoen in islam after 2 or 3 thousand years too when ppl wilk start question wht is god or something like that and basically hinduism is also a way of teaching science too for example there is a statue tht have a turtle and on top of it a globe or earth is made which says tht planet can't accelerate and move in same speed tht's the way of teaching but in long run ppl forget that teaching and started just worshipping those statue it's just a way of teaching for ex when u see gita they have stories to teach but in quraan they don't make stories to teach they just spoon feded them like wht to do and not to do

[@careerpluseverything2071]

चाहे जो हो धर्म तुम्हारा चाहे जो वादी हो नहीं जी रहे अगर देश के लिए तो अपराधी हो ।

[@padmahariharan6327]

V k Krishna Menon didn't meet maharaja It is bureaucrat VP MENON WHO MET MAHARAJA

[@thisisvivek01]

until today i was thinking ki vertical limit mein Pakistani soldiers kyon hai...now i came to know....thanks for the information

[@विवेकचौहान-ज8प]

Do we have the documents?

[@anujkushwaha9817]

Dear nikhil it was vp menon who toured kashmir twice and did all the work not vk menon. You have misinterpreted between these two names

[@vikramsingh-jd8oo]

Soon both will be again part of India

[@somanthfatangade8925]

Ty

[@avyukat2314]

Bhai gilgit baltistan(POK- integral part of india ) par nahi Kashmir par kabza kiya tha jisko gilgit baltistan ka naam deta hai pakistan..

[@arjunjbhardwaj2435]

Bahut sundar

[@Mr_Advocate.X]

99 percent fact but l think that it was the local force not Brown who rebel the Sikh regime From Skardu Gilgit Baltistan

[@rahulgoodconductshowsknowl1983]

Nice one

[@RajeshKumar-cx4fs]

🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 jai Hind Jai Bharat Jai Bharat bhumiputra jai javan jai kisan vande matram jai ma bhawani Jago hind ke bhartvashiyo jago ekta bankar rhna jaruri hai aapni desh ki suraksha ke liye deshdrohiyo ko desh ke dushmano ko saphaya karna jaruri hai.

[@Navtesh]

Humne ye nhi bataya ki nehru ki wjah se deri hui kyuki vo sheikh abdula ko kashmir ka head banana chahta tha taki uska votebank pakka ho jaye, jis karan aaj tak lakho log kashmir main mar gye. Aur uski hi wjah se UNO me ye mudda gya aur ab tak solve ni hua.

[@sugandhtriapthi]

Nikhil you are looking better in clean shave.

[@jyotiprakashmohanty4716]

It is very good episode ,,it could be better with geographical map i want world history

[@Ajazkarim-b7k]

Ya hamra bat dada ke jagir ha na Pakistan ke ha na hindustan ke 💪💪

[@sobiya1264]

Also how Gilgit scouts fought with Dogra forces and kicked out Dogras and self ruled for almost 15 days then acceded to Pakistan. The day is still celebrated in GB as freedom day Where is the fake accession? Shy hasn't India presented before UN till now?😂😂😂

[@tclasses5165]

Fantastic kamal

[@eco89]

The problem with India is, India is too soft everywhere, they never want any war, that is weakness. But Peace never comes without War. Indians have to make changes on their civilization. We have to be bold and aggressive if we want to survive as a civilization.

[@gbvibeso2018]

Gilgit Baltistan Pakistan Gilgit Baltistan zindabad Pakistan zindabad 🇵🇰✌️

[@devadutts3592]

Gilgit India Gilgit Zindabad Gilgit India 🇮🇳

[@asadopgaming7419]

@@devadutts3592 Mumbai up jhunagar nagaland Assam are part of Pakistan Pakistan zindabad 🇵🇰❤️🔥

[@Baazsingh12]

@@asadopgaming7419 what about Bangladesh haha 🤣

[@lazorplayz4556]

@@devadutts3592 We are pakistanis

[@dharmendrasoni2141]

​@@lazorplayz4556 joke🤣😂 93000🖕🖕😁😁

[@Alleur]

Junagarh ko hathiyane ke liye kis maharaja ka sign liya tha India ne?

[@anubhavsingh3471]

Tere baap ka bakri chor

[@Alleur]

@@anubhavsingh3471 haha.mirchi laggi

[@UdayKumar-hg7rx]

That’s good

[@abhisheksharma-bp6sc]

राजा हरी सिंह पहले ही मिला देते तो जो आज कश्मीरी लोग झेल रहे हैं और जो कश्मीर पर अभेद कब्ज़ा पाकिस्तान ने किया वो आज नही होता न ही पाकिस्तान कश्मीर का राग गाता

[@gurmohansingh1868]

Good

[@basbashir2475]

We want freedom sir

[@ayushagarwal7811]

indian army ki ek tukri skardu bhi gayi thi arms and ammunition ke sath but vo successful nhi ho payi thi uske bare me bhi batayiye

[@abhinavsood3663]

Abdul Khan gaffar is also known as frontier gandhi was from Gilgit. The great freedom fighter.

[@user-ue5vr8hb2x]

Wrong , he was an Afghan , born in KPK .

[@vik5999]

he was from KPK, not baltistan.My dad went to see him at red fort after independence in delhi. He told me all stories of him.

[@CHAUDHARYPUSHPENDRA]

Sir aap apne face ki moment thodi kam kr do.bas Thode se serous hokr bola kro. Gajab lagoge

[@ishanmehta9087]

Grt

[@big-bang-movies]

@07:48, its LOC not LAC....right?

[@alihus5683]

Wo jona Garh main keya lekha geya tha Ap log usy kasy dehty or manty hn ( Historically) Please andhy Bahgat door rahin

[@mukesh-vb2cj]

Aap ek bat bhul gye last wali jo esane boli thi ki jiski lathi usaki bhens

[@basbashir2475]

What about our freedom fighters Muslim conference 1885 to 1948

[@lebronmjj3902]

Kamal kamal kamal kamal