2024 BMW S1000XR Review - Sports bike thrills without the chiropractor bills

[@CAJLAMB]

Interestingly I’ve gone the other way - having owned an S1000XR since they first came out, I’ve moved to a 1300GS. Loved my XR, but the engine loved to rev and much of the enjoyment came at speeds beyond the legal limit. While the GS can be very quick, it doesn’t need to revved hard to be enjoyed.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Fair enough!

[@Flienlow]

I found that to be the case with my super duke GT chasing a M1000 RR. I was just as quick in the twisties and all the power out of the hole. When we swapped I couldnt wait to get back on the KTM.

[@simond5208]

"if you're not going to go off road why would you buy a GS?" It's a similar question that those who hate SUVs ask. In reality the GS is a terrible off road bike for all but the most capable riders. Both the GS and XR have always been road bikes - the GS prioritises comfort and two up ability and the XR prioritises performance. They're both great bikes, I look forward to buying a second hand one in 10 years!!

[@Oliverlikesbikes]

Yes good point and you could go a step further and say why have that instead of an s1000r? (apart from i suspect pillion comfort). I am not a good enough rider to exploit the difference in handling but personally i hate the beak thing. You could buy a decenf 2nd hand s1000 for 6-7k?

[@steveinskip4897]

You can easily take the GS off-road in Europe and US as there’s many flattish dual-track and un-made roads to have a go at. Probably include Cumbria in that. For the average UK green lane I’d think there are more suitable bikes available.

[@Gary-UBIQUE144]

On the subject of the GS never going off road & consequently the ridicule the GS rider sometimes gets? what about the the sports bike rider with race leathers & the hump backed jacket who never go on the track? The bottom line is you pay for what you like & like what you’ve got, everyone to their own. But I do like the new s1000XR. I test rode one a couple of years ago & the seat was a killer, looks like that’s been sorted out. Great review as always. Thanks.

[@hgv1883]

If you're not going on a race track why buy a sports bike?

[@Gary-UBIQUE144]

@@hgv1883 I think if you were going on a race track then a sports bike would be what you would want.

[@pistolpete6321]

I’m going on 3 years of ownership and still love my XR. I sort of feel like this bike flies under the radar and is overlooked a bit because of the GS. More people should test ride the XR when considering a sport touring bike, it’s an amazing machine.

[@billreynolds2221]

Rode one of these back to back with the gs in 2022. Overall ergonomics were vaguely similar but don't let the basic physical appearance fool you. The gs has a more relaxed riding position and feels less busy while riding. The additional horse power doesn't mean much to an old gent like me.

[@georgeturkington5591]

Nice review Andy. I think your reviews esp when you discuss specs would benefit from info on service intervals and costs including valve checks. So many reviewers neglect this and I think it’s of interest to potential buyers. That said keep doing a brilliant job. Thanks

[@dougrandall2370]

I have a 23S 1000 XR never really noticed excessive vibrations. You know you’re right the motorcycle it’s in line for that does rev pretty nicely, but nothing uncomfortable or bothersome on long rides. That in-line for is just amazing. Nothing beats an in-line for for sound and pure enjoyment of the ride is an amazing bike and all the bikes are owned. It’s my favorite.

[@Lctrvl]

I completely agree with your observation about in line 4s, and is the reason I bought one, and also have a Z900RS… Now, the original exhaust sound on this S1000XR does not do justice to the engine (thanks Euro 5!!!) so that’s an adjustment needed right away (check pro-race). For long trips, I also recommend changing the visor (check MRA). These small adjustments go a long way in making it an almost perfect bike (there will never be such a thing as a perfect bike 😂)

[@nsweeney3970]

You should try Yamahas CP4 flat plane crank engine (R1 or MT10), the sound of that is something else when it’s been decatted.

[@LambChopRides]

Got the M1000XR ATM and cannot wait to ride it! Enjoyed that review Andy 👍 Because the M has the shiftcam engine it 'should' have the same bottom end power...

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Tbh I’m a bit frightened to try the M!! Amazing bikes these….

[@marcos.1771]

In 2023 I was sure to pre-order the MXR, but then the final version was announced by BMW and it turned out that there are 5 things missing, which are definitely a deal breaker to me. As soon as it stops raining here, I'll consider getting the 2024 (or the 2025) SXR (M Package) with those nifty new rims and the 200mm rear tyres on them.

[@rosco950ss7]

I went from a Ducati supersport950 to the R1250GS trying to find a bike thats ticks all my boxes. You summed it up so well at the end and I relate to your comments - I'm a Ducati fan so test-road the Multistrada V4 twice as I really wanted to love it. I then rode the s1000xr straight after and it just felt right and I was at home on it. Seriously considering the XR now...

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

It is a lovely machine....my favourite of the current BMWs maybe.....

[@rickdelmonte1682]

As someone who considered both bikes I can tell you why I ended up with the 1300GS: -seat height. I have a 31” inseam and with the adaptive ride height and low seat get the GS down to an 800mm seat height. Considerably lower than the XR -weight distribution. The weight on the XR is higher than on the GS, and pulling it off the side stand makes it feel heavier than the GS. -vibrations. It’s still a vibey engine, certainly compared to the smoothness of the GS. -power. I just don’t need more power than the 1300GS, and the extra 25hp are up high in a place where I seldom tend to go. I’ll take the torque. -looks. Sorry, the GS is better looking to my eyes. The small front wheel with the tall bike looks awkward to me. -having said all this is, if I was a sport rider looking for comfort, then the XR would be very appealing. Good review, thank you.

[@chrishart8548]

It is surprisingly heavy getting thens1000xr off the side stand I was shocked.

[@tomtraynor5384]

@@chrishart8548 Same--compared to my heavier Pikes Peak V4. I was surprised.

[@nandyth]

I also debated a lot between the 2 and got the 1300GS despite my wife almost forcing me to get the XR coz it looked better hahaha

[@salishwanderer7869]

My 16 was the best bike I've ever owned and this 24 has a great color scheme. Will be my next bike, again, most likely. Has everything I need, and all I love.

[@spikodemiko5514]

Nice initial review Andy. I’ve got a 2022 XR and must be one of the few who doesn’t have a complaint about either the vibes or the seat. Came from an r1250r and it really put some excitement back in my biking. Not really much choice in this sector other than the Multistrada and the Suzuki GX so think I’ll be ordering another XR.

[@dannykhoury85]

Just picked up this exact bike! I rode a ‘23 and then a ‘24 back to back. Went with the ‘24 the seat and vibes on the ‘24 are much improved. Love the bike. So much fun and comfortable. Nice review!

[@gianni3774]

Nice bro! How about a 2020 model?

[@dannykhoury85]

@@gianni3774 I haven’t ridden a 2020. But my guess it’s almost the same as the new. Maybe a bit more vibes and the seat is different.

[@Mark-dd2nh]

I had a 2017 s1000XR and truly loved riding it. The only down side was not really getting the full potential of that motor. Almost impossible to be in the +7k rev range without breaking every speed limit in 3rd gear. I moved to a GS. More suited to my cruising style now and opens up a few gravel roads to venture down. Perfect world would be to have both.

[@specialandroid1603]

Got the 22 BMW S1000 XR and what an amazing bike. Riding it keeps me smiling.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Fabulous machine isn't it....

[@michaelmclarney1994]

Great review as usual Andy and a decent bike. The side view reminds me of the old Fazer 1000, another great bike 👍

[@kevin9sc]

Nice bike and excellent review, as ever. I have to say though, I'm very happy with my 'GS for the road' - my '22 R1250RS. The fabulous shift-cam engine is plenty quick enough for me. She is relatively economical, as well as being all day comfortable two-up, and fully loaded. I don't see me going back to an inline 4, and definitely wouldn't swap the shaft drive for a chain.

[@simonporter6209]

Those bits around the radiator I believe are heat deflectors. Thanks Andy for another great review on a bike worth trying out.👍

[@garyhope0103]

That certainly looks a great bike, and if I was in the market at the moment, even having never owned a BMW, I think this would be one sports tourer I'd have a look at. Great 1st ride video as usual, thank you.

[@SuperSnallygaster]

Great ride, Andy. I love these bikes. They're very versatile - daily it, take it on tour, or to the odd track day. The acceleration is addictive. Thanks for taking us along!

[@SC-vz9ie]

Great review, thanks! I rode the RS1250SE last week (absolute fantastic) then the GS1300 (smooth-as-silk ride but clunky quickshifter and engine braking). I tried the S1000XR 3 days ago and I’m still exhilarated by it. Incidentally, the quickshifter is sublime even 1st-2nd gear. My plans for long-distance European holidays have been put back by a couple of years, so I’m going for the thrill of the S1000XR for the next year or two. All three bikes are fantastic - horses for courses, as they say.

[@andychapman9687]

I love the styling of the machine, perfect for me being 6 foot 3 I just feel in proportion with the bike and also very comfortable. I ride a MT09 SP and love the immediate pull when you twist the throttle. Something this bike lacks when I test rode it. You need to properly wind it up before you feel the full power and the theatre of noise which is superb. The GS has the benefit of the torque and having immediate usable power when you need it and also it’s shaft driven which is better for touring.

[@460Dave]

I’ve got the old XR I’ve put heavier bar end weights on that sorts most of the vibration issues, having ridden the newer model I think it’s a bit too well refined I cracking bike but just lacking something, when I jumped back on mine I felt the lack of refinement makes it more fun to ride especially when up the pace a bit. Having said that I make you right it looks nice in the blue. 😎👍

[@olivierdefaux8651]

I test rode the 2023 S1000XR and the 1300GS. Both superb bikes. But I bought the XR. I loved the Jekyll and Hyde character of the bike - calm and civilised low in the RPM and a beast higher up. The GS feels too good. Too polished. It does everything and in a way I felt it was taking away from the riding experience. My dealer called it a bit soulless. With the XR I have to work more. Plan more. And have the Jekyll/Hyde option. I also feel the road much better because of the lack of a telelever suspension. Much more fun for my purposes.

[@ManicMarvin]

I do miss my 2016 XR at times and this new model does look great but now running an Africa Twin which i love even more. I much prefer the twin engine on the roads. Nice review.

[@paulvarnsverry11]

The only bike I have ever ridden that required me to seek the services of a chiropractor afterwards was a Harley-Davidson FXRT Sport Glide (one day’s test ride, followed by four weeks of treatment) - so, yes; it appears if “Sport” appears in the bike’s name then your hypothesis may be correct, Mr. Flyer. 😉😄

[@Domitianvs]

This is going to be a serious contender for me when it's time to look at upgrading from my current R1150GS, for sure. Although, I do love that old boxer, it has something special that an inline four just can't compete with...

[@grahamwalsh7237]

Another great video Andy. Bike looks great but can someone tell me why it needs to be so tall for us older people ? Surely if you don't go off road on a GS you need an RT.

[@onaroad4505]

Ordered ❤ one arriving in 3 weeks can’t wait.. I like the honest review as usual love the channel ❤😮 traded my Multistrada in it’s been a fantastic bike for two years covered nearly 7000 miles on it no complaints (bit top heavy at standstill 2 up ) this XR seems lighter fingers crossed , Ash

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Hope you enjoy it!

[@nickrider5220]

Glowing review TMF ! The lack of intrusive vibes is a big improvement for this type of bike 👍🏻

[@richardsalsman1069]

I think I need to get one of these out for a ride. Agree it is a good on road alternative to a GS

[@onaroad4505]

Loved your short first impression on it , I agree after two hour ride out on one it was good enough to order one , Ash

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Congratulations!

[@stephenpotts8170]

Hi Andy, yes I do like the latest iteration of the XR, I have to say my reasons for opting for the my GS ADV are the shaft drive and it's standard very good crash protection for my occasional clumsy drops of my bike. Thank you

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Yes good point!

[@javier6d2]

The shaft drive is one big reason to get a GS over one of these as a road bike. Chain maintenance is a pain in the ass.

[@BibTheBoulderTheOriginalOne]

I think modern chains are in a different world these days.. I have a ZZR1400 and the chain has not had to be adjusted for over 5,000 miles.

[@DucatiDale]

Yeah that one adjustment every 500+ miles and the odd clean and lube is a right pain there’s a reason there’s only like 3 bikes on the market that have the heavy power draining shaft drive

[@javier6d2]

@@DucatiDale Count again, but this time paying more attention.

[@snowballed4]

Chain adjustment isn't a hard or lengthy process. But then again, I am old-skool I suppose.

[@Teatimeted]

It's not just chain maintenance. Shaft drive removes the bother of rear wheel alignment, which I have found to be a pain in the chopper, on both belt and chain drive motorcycles. Shaft drive deletes all that misery, for a small loss of power through the drivetrain on a vehicle that already is blessed with an excess of power to weight.

[@leeblackburn15]

It looks better now than when it was first introduced. As for being a sportsbike for those of us that find sports machines too uncomfortable - I'm with you. My GSX-S1000GT serves that purpose for me 😉

[@rlw85]

Glad you like the bike I’ve got a 21 plate one and love it

[@two4wheels]

Great review Andy, I'm just waiting to pick mine up this weekend - same spec as the one you have tested.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Ooh congratulations - exciting times!

[@iainamurray]

My father in law swapped his GS for an XR after spending a lot of time (and money!) with Rapid Training who had moved over because of the performance. I prefer the GS!

[@paulv22]

Nice review. I ride an R1250RS and I've been wanting more legroom. I should probably test ride one of these.

[@static369]

Can’t wait to test ride before getting it. Love this bike.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Hope you enjoy it!

[@jamesread9014]

et another interesting road test. I will have to have a serious look at it to replace my R1200R in due course. All down to how it would be for a youthful 69yr old 176cm/5' 9" fella. Could consider it for my 70th! in March. Enjoy your Spring and Summer. From the cooler late autumn South Island of New Zealand

[@firstnamed1501]

Great video as always! 👌🏻 Wow, look at the spraying of the skies (1.00 in). 😢

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

"Spraying of the skies"? What are you on buddy....

[@firstnamed1501]

Surely the lines that fade out to a permagrey ceiling and then incessant rain have been correlated? It’s been ubiquitous and relentless this year… Very different to the normal vapour trails that disappear almost immediately.

[@iainf6]

Stunning bike Andy, my new favourite 👍😎

[@EVILSPAWN1003]

Wohoo, picking mine up tomorrow🥳 This exact spec. Killing time by watching videos of it⏳⌛️

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Congratulations!

[@EVILSPAWN1003]

@@TheMissendenFlyer First 200 miles done, first proper ride. And all i have to say is: OMfuc!ngG🤩 It’s perfect! The quickshifter, that engine, the handling in the twisties, the performance combined with such comfort🥳 I am VERY happy with my choice this time.

[@reinmansmith]

I agree that this bike has always been the sweet spot in the BMW range, with more performance than anyone could realistically use along with the comfort not usually associated with such a sporty bike.

[@kyotosal]

Great sounding engine. Thank you Sir! I love it!

[@borkarms]

Very Well Reviewed , enjoyed watching.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Glad to hear that - thank you!

[@robertfay7750]

Great video as always, however we could do with mrs flyers verdict on pillion comfort as i seem to remember she was less than impressed but the new revised pillion seat looks more comfortable etc

[@arabianjules]

Love my 2020, they are a beast, and good for touring.

[@thepictontwowheels7195]

I'd love to hear you do review of the Ducati Grand Tour. Yet another great vid cheers Andy

[@matthewbodish6133]

I am looking at the S1000XR and the R1250RS. This would be a great comparison to see

[@koshtie]

HI Andy I must say that bike is very tempting in every way, what a machine for the real world ? You left us on video with you heading towards that other airfield Wycombe air park ? he he, ATB Wayne 😀👍

[@TheSpainy]

Came from an 1200rs to an XR and Im very happy to have done so. The inline 4 engine with super elastic gearing and a smooth quick shifter is a total grin compared to the tractor like, short geared, awful quick shifter of the boxer engine. I hated the sound so much I could only ride with ear plugs.

[@opinionsmatter-xx4go]

I just hope that they put all the touring features of the GS/RT into this and I’ll surely buy it.

[@u187146]

Flipping epic. I'm 54 and I grew up on sports bikes, including bikes that would now be considered sports tourers. I can't stand ADV style bikes, and whilst I've had bikes with V twin, parallel twin and triple, there is something about an angry 4 cylinder that is addictive, although you do have to be going quite rapidly. That said, noone ever bought a motorcycle to go slowly.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

True!

[@dankorolyk5917]

Great review,was always curious about this bike.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Glad you liked it!

[@markscrivener979]

Great review as always, but as this is a sports tourer, it may have been helpful to include some commentary around practicality issues. Centrestand, luggage, pillion, under seat storage, tank range etc. can’t ever see myself spending upwards of £18k on a bike though.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Noted!

[@steveinskip4897]

Great looking bike and thanks for that Andy. I remembered on the previous version there was a bit of a vibration and the BMW RS was deemed a lot better sports-touring bike for long distances (you’re going to be going more than 73mph on a French or German motorway). So there’s a place for it for BMW fans that want a 4 cylinder sports-tourer but it’s in a crowded market. Cheers bud!

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

No worries - and good to hear from you again!

[@steveinskip4897]

@@TheMissendenFlyer thanks Andy. I’ve been following your stuff (as for the last 12 odd years), but had a very bad bout of Malaria and it’s taken me about a year to get strong enough to ride my bikes again. 6 months of fuzziness and 6 months recuperating. Anyway all good for this year hopefully. Keep at it mate, you’re doing a great job!

[@wombal177jim]

That's a nice bike, thanks enjoyed that.

[@harryksouthafrica3203]

This is an incredible machine. Sad that it has to be ridden at 40mph and hardly sees 5k rpm. On the highway I don’t see much more excitement. Come to South Africa and get a chance to really fall in love with this bike… Thanks for a great channel!

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

My pleasure!

[@Bikerbug2020]

That very same bike is at my local dealership (and it has a twin on the floor), not very often two of the same. Have owned the 1200RT, 1200GS, and now the 1250R, truly thinking about a 1000XR or 1250GSA yes very different, but you made some serious good points. Thinking that since the beginning I have looked at getting an XR and always opted for something different thinking it is time to get the XR and see if that was what I was supposed to have purchased the entire time. Hmmmm

[@booshallmighty]

I had this a loaner bike while my R1200 was in the shop. This is no doubt a great bike, I could easily get both feet flat on the ground, I'm also 5'8. I ft this bike was much more nimble than the GS, I found myself going into bends at faster speeds. The roads felt bigger on this bike which felt odd in a good way, I could carve up the bends like a sports bike. What I didn't like was the bike made me feel really hot, the heat seems to flow right up you. It was a a fairly hot day 23C. I did find it a bit vibey maybe that would be more tiresome at longer rides. I found the seat holds your bum different, like on a chair which made it feel more comfortable than it should be as it's so thin. Not sure how this would feel after 2 hours in the saddle. I have to say I felt much better getting back on tractor. While this is more fun in many ways I would no way swap it for my GS

[@MrCapetonians]

Thanks for the great video. I just completed 15.000 km, mostly on a 1250GS, Northern Thailand on a 600 Vstrom in Jan, did NZ in Feb, California in March, parts of Western Cape in April and then the wettest week in the Yorkshire Dales and Moor in July (!!!). The UK ride was on a 1260 Multistrada which blew me away totally. My question here, how does the XR handle at low speeds through your tiny villages and Hamlets? I struggled initially on that Ducati as it required lots of clutch work with low speeds, something a GS handles perfectly. But I loved to Ducati handling, steering, power, sound, everything. Any comments? Thanks again for your great videos.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Don't recall the XR being especially difficult at slow speeds - great bike....

[@deco5159]

Great review as always Andy, I’ve been waiting for you to upload this one. I’ve been contemplating S1000XR for a while now. After riding my F750GS as a daily commuter for the last 5 years, I now and feel I would like a bit more from a bike. This looks like the one for me, think I’ll booking a test ride asap. 👍🏻

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Good plan!

[@ChrisBrownFazer1]

Like your review. Own a gen2 MY20 grey tour XR. There's hardly any difference compared to the '24 model I'm glad to say. I commute a lot, it certainly isn't built for it! Runs quite roughly at low revs. The quick shifter doesn't like lower revs either. Plus gets very hot when the fan kicks in at the lights, especially on warm and hot days.

[@flatcapcaferacer]

Plenty of warp 10 bikes out there today but darn few warp 10 riders out there. Honestly for street use only dialing the horsepower down to 100 to 110, with more midrange punch and fewer vibes and lowering the cost about 25% would be what I would call and improvement.

[@AdyRider]

A good review Andy as always. I do think if you’re a Boxer or twin fan then it would perhaps be a no. If you’re not fussed with the twins then I would imagine it would be a cracking bike to own.

[@d33b33]

I've heard someone call the bits of shroud around the radiator the 'valances'. I remember because I had to look that up (English = second language for me).

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Let's go with shrouds - a valance sounds like part of a 1970's bed clothes.

[@MichaelDisney]

"Shroud" sounds biblical! Why not fairings, or panels?

[@d33b33]

@@MichaelDisney Oh yeah, like the Shroud of Turin, I didn't think of that. Fairings are all the panels, not just the ones around the radiator. Perhaps cowling could cover both ends of the Pacific. Radiator cowling?

[@splodge57]

Big horrible lumps of cheap plastic.

[@robbo3106]

70mph my cruising speed- 😂😂😂 yeah we believe you - was on my list but got a Multistrada V4S to replace my Tuono. Very happy with it

[@busterrabbit]

Chain drive, so not for me. I've had a few 4 cyl BMW as loan bikes whilst my own bike has been in for servicing and I just don't like the engine characteristics; they are too "busy" for me 5,000 RPM at 70 MPH? The continuous drone from the exhaust at similar speeds was quite tiring, the previous models were quite vibey too. Yes the power comes in with a whoosh at higher revs, probably great on track, but too frantic for me on the road.

[@Hooner77]

Another great review. There is a lot to like about this bike. For me the GS would be the one I would pick. At 64 the lower center of gravity is a +. The other thing I look for in a touring bike is the range. Most of the riders I know on 1 liter sport touring bikes start looking for a gas station at 150 miles. Having a 200+ range gives more choices when planning my trips. I live in the Western US, and I have done trips where you need at least 200 miles of range. That being said I would love to see how the XR compares to the new Suzuki GSX-1000GX+. They both have a similar style with a more upright sitting position.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Having recently ridden the GSX-S1000GX+ I can assure you the two are VERY different (the BMW would leave it for dust!)

[@Hooner77]

@@TheMissendenFlyer Thanks for the reply. So is that enough reason to pay 2k USD. more for the BMW. There may be more to the BMW to justify the extra money. I hope to see the Suzuki in an upcoming video so we can learn more about it from a source that gives fair and honest reviews.

[@LonelyTreeSunset]

Waiting for the R1300 RS. The boxer in the real world is far superior to an inline 4. Agree with you though, the XR is a better looking machine compared to the GS. Hope the RS takes more design cues from the S series.

[@louislopez55]

I wouldn’t want to give up shaft drive, lower center of gravity, lower rpm’s at any given speed and boxer twin sound and charm. I also wouldn’t want more vibration and probable lower resale value compared to a GS. Of course, not everyone wants a boxer…

[@JRobinson-xu5kt]

i rode the old model my arse after 20 miles was numb, i ride a 1250 gsa i was so glad to get back on it. not to mention the lack of grunt at low rpms the xr felt gutless at low rpm you need to ring its neck to go fast. ill stick with the 1250 .

[@stuartjohnston1086]

Looks like a great bike, but for myself, given the state of the "roads" here in southwest Scotland, the GS makes sense.

[@WeAreTheTrueMedia]

8:30 I must admit Andy, I did find it funny when 'Chopsy' had a dig about your height on his last video 😂

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

He’s mostly jealous of my hair…

[@NBMBC40]

I had the previous version top spec with ESA and it is a very under rated bike, I thought it was better than the Ducati and a fair bit cheeper. I got rid of it as I found it to quick and thought I'm going to loose my licence before long.

[@marcos.1771]

Nice review, but I was surprised by the sluggish acceleration of this bike. I ride my S1000XR model 2022 (M Package) exclusively in DYNAMIC PRO mode. Probably your bike doesn't have that mode. I had the 2020 model before my current one, and indeed, there were more vibrations around 4,000 RPM. These vibrations have vanished from my current bike. In 2023 I was 100% sure to get the M1000XR, but now that the complete specs are out, there are 5 things missing, where each one is a deal breaker to me. If it stops raining (here in Belgium since October 2023), I am going to consider getting the latest S1000XR (M Package) with those nifty new rims and the 200mm tyres.

[@n22pdf]

Great review dude.. must say this is a handsome looking bike.. still a GS for me though if I was in the market an ADV style bike 😊 Pete 👍👍

[@adventurebeforedementia2090]

Give me a GSA with excellent fuel economy and range, shaft drive convenience, torquey power delivery and unobtrusive noise at motorway speeds any day of the week! I’m sure the XR is a great Sunday bike but I’m not convinced it would out trump a GSA on a tour of Europe?? 🤔

[@colindeans5972]

It's definitely a better looking bike than the new GS. For touring, wouldn't a twin be better? I'd have a 1200 or 1250GS over this I reckon. Thanks again.

[@davidbarber5707]

I test ride the last one after owning a s1000r. Expected similiar experience but more comfort. After 5 mins of riding it I took it back. The vibes and the seat were terrible. Sounds like they have sorted it now so not surprised it will get good reviews now

[@TucsonDude]

I own an S1000R and wondered if the XR is enough of an improvement to upgrade.

[@johnDukemaster]

Looks alot like the old Triumph Tiger Sport 1050. Now that was a lovely machine! I'm sure this is too. But an inline4? No thank you. 5000rpm at 70m/h? Makes me stressed! Cheers!

[@sarge2665]

Whilst I like the idea of extra "oomph" would I swap the para/tele lever suspension and shaft drive of my GS? I don't think so.....

[@barney3417]

Great review as always! I had one of the first ones and sold it fairly quickly after my hand went numb after 50 miles and getting 38mpg !! not good for touring ,glad they seemed to have fixed the vibe thing ., A better choice than the 1300GS which I do NOT like the looks of . Like all BMW's now getting pricey so I've recently ,after 20 years of loyalty, gone away from the brand and gone Yamaha Tracer 9GT+. which I love ,I don't need 170 bhp . I know you love a triple! so could you try to get one to review please Andy, i would be interested in your view as it's changed quite a bit.

[@kugangles9860]

I love my current XR. I did think about trading it in for the M1000XR. Then I realized most of the extra power of that shiftcam motor is above 10k which for street use is pretty unusable.....If you plan on keeping your license and staying out of jail that is.

[@syfi323]

I have a 2020 XR. So for long rides the stock seat sucks, it dug into the back of my legs at the three hour point it was painful. If the seat design is the same that would be a no go.

[@pgVeritas]

If you’re an all year round biker, the GS is better because of the shaft drive and telelever. However, if when I come to swap out my RT in a year’s time, the 1300GSA isn’t around, I’m likely to buy a 1250GSA.

[@robinblowfield]

Wasn't happy with the clutch on my original S1000XR, cable and none adjustable I believe; hopefully that’s improved on this model. Stuck in huge queue at Silverstone ended up with arm pump😂

[@davewilton3101]

Signal lights and brake lights......Look pretty tiny. How are they for being visible in daylight? Got rear ended once. Rather not repeat it. Did you take notice of the fuel consumption. Thinking of range on a tank at reasonable speeds.

[@kenny4k]

Another option to the GS is the RS, people seem to hate on that bike

[@CCooke-nm2be]

Excellent review Andy . I don’t think the GS and the XR are in the same catchment area. The XR doesn’t offer the technology the GS has . The range is a lot less on the XR, being a much thirstier beast . A bit of an odd ball bike and residuals reflect this when compared to the GS .

[@stallebrass]

I do quite like the BMW S1000XR... I miss in the line 4 smoothness. I also much prefer the symmetrical front end on this. I'll probably never get one though as I love my GSA telelever and the GSA ride position is relaxed and comfy, even more so with my rises with pullback and the SW Motech lowered pegs. My GSA also has the shaft drive as opposed to the S1000XR chain drive.

[@MV-XD2]

What is it with GS owners and shaft drive? It’s heavy (and more unsprung weight), has more driveline lash, sucks up more power than a chain, if it has an issue or fails on a trip you’re screwed and the maintenance on modern chains is next to nothing. There’s a good reason there are so few shaft drive bikes nowadays.

[@wokeupandsmellthecoffee214]

Morning Andy, as much as I love bikes like yourself I also love aviation after spending 43 years in the industry so I'm craving another aviation vid from you. Any chance of doing one or three soon ? 👍🛩

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

They mess up the algorithm for me - never say never but they will be very few and far between....

[@everythinggaming7938]

Looks more like a sport adventure than a sports tourer. I love it

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Yes I tend to agree...

[@kwak1k]

Adventure sport or as I describe my Versys1000, a tallrounder 😉

[@FenTour]

That bike is a beauty, however you should also try the M1000XR which pulls even harder low down! Having said that this bike the SXR is a superb all round bike for the road and touring too.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

I am very tempted to try the M1000XR - probably wasted on me mind you!

[@FenTour]

@@TheMissendenFlyer it’s wasted on me but I ended up getting one!! I as yet date not go past 8k RpM it’s loony fast, but looks good!

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Lucky you - lovely looking thing now I think....

[@FenTour]

@@TheMissendenFlyer maybe but I am now skint! 😂

[@stuarthilton2819]

Hi, loved the video, but can I ask? my 2019 S1000 XR has 4 settings rain,road, dynamic and super dynamic what does the 2024 have. 👍

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

Can't remember off the top of my head - sorry....

[@glockparaastra]

Smoothest riding bike I’ve been on. Definitely for the GS guys who never get their bikes dusty 😂

[@jjnewman65]

Very nice indeed flyer. Certainly sporty. But a tourer? I would like to see its luggage capability options. It’s lovely thing.

[@furnacemountainrides]

I’d love to try one of those 🏍️

[@JezNashMusic]

Cracking review, as ever. Tempting, but I fear it would constantly be encouraging me to ride a little beyond my capabilities and, perhaps even the speed limit.

[@TheMissendenFlyer]

You and me both!