Muslim Questioned About The Prophet's Marriage! Muhammed Ali

Support Me and The Channel:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
/ themuslimlantern
cash.app/%C2%A3TheMuslimLantern
Follow me on Social Media:
/ chainless_slave
/ chainless_slave
/ themuslimlantern

[@TheMuslimLantern]

Brothers and Sisters don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah! Support Me and The Channel: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern cash.app/%C2%A3TheMuslimLantern

[@yahiiiaplays1252]

You forgot to mention that Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) gave his daughter in marriage at 10 too.

[@yahiiiaplays1252]

You also forgot to mention that the reason we kept increasing the laws was because of prostitution and sexual liberation which put young women in danger of being kidnapped and used for pleasure and nothing else, like described in the article "The Maiden Tribute of Babylon.".

[@shahidhussain9176]

Marry at age 12 married Joseph who was 90 and Issac married rebbeca age 3 And Aisha age is disputed from 9-14/17 to 27 Marry De Robigne Mortimer Bennett says that the book ‘History of Joseph the Carpenter,’ was believed and genuine by Early Evangelical Church. Not just that, he also mentions when Joseph married Mary, she was 12 years old and he was 90 years old. At the end of his statement on ‘History of Joseph the Carpenter,’ he states, “These statements should undoubtedly be taken with many grains of allowance.” Here, he himself agrees that the statements where it mentions that Joseph was 90-year-old when he married 12 Mary is true, and should be accepted. Bernard L. Fontana also mentions that Mary was 12 years old and Joseph 90 years old when married: “Thanks to the apocrypha writings, which inspired many artists over the ages, the popular belief became widespread that Joseph had first married when he was forty years old and fathered six children by his wife before she died when he was eighty-nine years old. The youngest of his child was said to be James the Less, ‘Christ’s brother.’ This tradition holds that Joseph was ninety years old when he went to Jerusalem to join other candidates seeking the hand of the twelve- to fourteen year old Mary in Marriage.” [9] 4. Early Church Fathers Believed Joseph was 80 to 90 years old when he married 12-year-old Mary The very advanced age of Joseph, marrying Mary, was true and accepted by most early Church Fathers. Reverend Jeremiah Jones writes about 2 to 3 pages long that Infancy Protevangelion of James was accepted by Early Church Fathers as truthful account of Mary and Joseph’s marriage. If one reads the Infancy Gospel of James (Protevangelion of James), in Chapter 8 it says that Mary was married to Joseph when she was 12 years old. “…His eldest son was James, surnamed Oblias-that he begat him when he was about forty years old: after him he had another son named Jose, then Simeon and Judas, and then his two daughters Mary and Salome: after his wife’s death he continued many years a widower, and about fourscore years old married Mary. Besides Epiphanius, several other of the Greek fathers have given into this same opinion, viz. Hilary, Chrysostome, Cyrill, Euthyymius, Theophylact, Cecumenius, and generally, as bishop Peaterson says: ‘all Latin fathers till Ambrose, and the Greeks afterward; from which it is very evident that the account of Joseph’s age and family, which is in the Gospel of the Birth Mary, and the Protevangelion of James, met with very general credit among ancient Christians.” [10] Jeremiah Jones continues: “I might, add here, that the learned annalist cardinal Baronius, in his surprising apologies for the Virgin Mary, (…) cites many of the fathers as giving credit to its accounts, and particularly as to that of her being brought at three years of age to the temple, and devoted to its service, (Evang. Mar. c. 4. 6. Protevang. Jacob. C. 7.) and that she continued there eleven years. He says it is testified by Euodius, Gregory Nyssene, Damascene, Germanus bishop of Constantinople, Andreas Cretensis, George Bishop of Nicomedia, and others. See Apparat. Ad Annal. No. 48. And Casaubon’s reflections upon this Exercit. 1. Contr. Baron. Ad eund. Numer.” [10] Charles Burlingame Waite, was a United States lawyer and a jurist, he also cites Epiphanies that Joseph was 80 years old when he married Mary, “Joseph was very old when he married Mary, and had been many years a widower; that he was the brother of Clophas, the son of James, surnamed Panther; that he had his first wife of the tribe of Judah, and by her six children, to wit, four sons and two daughters. His eldest son was James, surnamed Oblias, (this probably taken from Eusebius, Ecc, Hist. 2. 23), that he begat him when he was about forty years old; after him he had another son named Jose, then Simeon and Judas, and then his two daughters Mary and Salome: after his wife’s death, he continued many years a widower, and about fourscore years old, married Mary.”- Epiph. Haeres. 78, see. 8. [11] As we have read, most early church fathers believed Mary was married off when she was 12 years old and Joseph the carpenter was a very old man. Here is the list of fathers who believed that Joseph was fourscore years old when he married 12-year-old Mary: 1. Epiphanius (310 - 403AD) 2. Hilary (Hilarius) of Poitiers (300 - 368AD) 3. John Chrysostom (Born between 344 and 349 - Died 407 AD) 4. Cyril of Alexandria (376 - 444 AD) 5. Saint Euthymius the Great (377 - 473 AD) 6. Theophylact of Ohrid (also known as Theophylact of Bulgaria) (1055 - 1107 AD) 7. Cecumenius 8. Eusebius (263 - 339 AD) 1. Sarah gave birth to Isaac at the age of ninety (Genesis 17). 2. Isaac was in his thirties when the incident of Mount Moriah occurred with his father, Abraham (Genesis 22). 3. Immediately after Isaac and Abraham’s incident on Mount Moriah, Rebecca is born (Genesis 22). 4. As soon as Rebecca’s birth is mentioned in Genesis 22, few verses down (next chapter), we read that Sarah died at the age of 127 years old (Genesis 23:1-3). 5. At the time of Sarah’s death, Isaac would be have been 37-years-old. 6. Isaac married Rebecca at the age of 40 (Genesis 25:20), this would show from the Bible that Rebecca was only three years old, given that she was only born three years prior, just after the Mount Moriah incident and the death of Sarah.

[@muhammedalimi]

Amin Ya Allah

[@miscgar9663]

Muhammad copied books of Bible and made Quran. He married many to help them. He killed many as they were bad. So he added polygamy and jihad and made Quran. You will get many women on earth and in heaven. Beware in the last days many logical men will make many to fall. Pray nonstop till you know God Jesus is the only way truth and life.

[@Sal_A]

You can’t compare the Xbox/Tik Tok kids of today to the kids of yesterday. Muhammad Akbar was 14 years old when he led an army to India, which 14 year old can do that today?

[@sunset2.00]

Kids can't even push up

[@khairiaris]

Let's use their history.. Alexander was 18 and started kicking asses.. Joan of Arc was even younger, a girl at that.. How many teens today are shaking global politics?

[@crafterianinks7219]

Not only that... A scientific research Gluckmann and Hanson (2006) shows how in agricultural era 10 year olds had already reached physical and mental maturity. And how it has changed over the years. Even the lancet published it.

[@AbdAllah_54564]

Muhammad bin Qasim led armies at the age of 17, Fatih Mehmed Sultan conquered Constantinople (Istanbul, now) when 21, many Islamic scholars and scientists already started off their career in teenage. These people were mature beyond years for today's world. I sometimes wish to go back in time to live with these great men, may Allah reward them and grant them Mercy Ameen.

[@sluggishhollow2030]

Babur not Akbar

[@yassir2824]

Think about this: if it was taboo in the prophets pbuh time, then how come his biggest enemies never said anything negative towards his marriage to Aisha ra? Parents have to approve their daughter to be married, so why did Abu Bakr not disagree if it was so bad? How come no critic of Islam before the modern era ever brought this issue up? These people have no other criticism to attack the character of Rasulullah pbuh except the marriage age and the verses about killing, and both of those things have been explained a million times. He spent 39 years of his life being the most honest man, the most trustworthy and all of a sudden because he received revelation he will become a degenerate? Come on, be for real.

[@sonyequator6852]

jahiil people always ask useless things. Even we explain well. So agree with Bro Ali. we had nothing to prove or justified kind of question.

[@rusmaibrahim4881]

Aishah grew up to be an intellectual lady… a reference point after the death of Nabi…. not a girl who had been abused by her elderly husband. So what is the problem?

[@sandrathompson1277]

Perhaps people then didn’t go around preaching what they believed in..like Muslims do now..each to their own..an old saying would save the world so much hate…killings..and wars…

[@IRABAH]

It's just ther hatred fr Islam.

[@avoidedmonster4117]

he was a degenerate from the beginning to even entertain the idearaping a 9 year old at 53. why can’t you change the quran to remove the parts allowing muslims to marry children and have sex with them. the time is modern. no need to allow your whole religion be ruined by having dogshit in your passages.

[@richthessolonian1842]

If an 18-year-old man comes to you and says he’s getting married, you’d question his decision-making skills. You’d think he’s getting married too early. Similarly, if an 18-year-old woman tells you that she’s getting married, you’d ask her to do a “reality check” and may be even discourage her by telling her she’s too young, and she should go to college or build a career. Even though 18 is the legal age most countries, no one really believes that an 18-year-old is ready for marriage! Should it be same for girls and boys? Or, should girls have a different minimum age than boys? Should the fact that girls mature earlier than boys be takin into account? Does "one size fits all" really work for determining a minimum age? In pre-modern cultures, girls would look forward to getting married and start a family. They did not see it as we see it today. They saw marriage as a benefit, not a burden like we do. That was the norm for them. And this was true in all religions, cultures, and regions of the world. The minimum age for marriage has been increasing worldwide. In all pre-modern traditional cultures, it wasn’t unusual for girls to consummate marriages between the ages of 10 and 12 and that was considered normal back then, but not today. In most modern societies, girls are highly discouraged from getting married, even at 18. Early marriage is considered bad. They’re told that education and careers are far more important and beneficial for a young woman than marriage and having children. Today, we’ve been indoctrinated into believing that it's always better for a woman to have a career and work than to have children and raise them. Women are taught to delay marriage for career. How has this impacted women, men, children and the society at large? The result is that most Western nations are in decline-population is imploding. Marriage is ruined. People are having fewer and fewer children than the previous generations. Corporations and business do not like early marriage because it’s bad for the economy. Women entering the workforce helps increase the supply of labor which in turns lowers wages. Business and corporations benefit when there are more women in the workforce. Women who work consume more and spend more. So, it’s good for business to have working women. We’re even told that it’s possible and perfectly normal for a woman to have both a career and raise children at the same time. While this may work for some, it doesn’t work for all women. Many women get burnt out trying to juggle jobs and raising kids. It's such a huge responsibility. We expect women to work like they have no kids. We expect women to have kids like they don't have a job. All this has put unrealistic demands on women. Stress, depression, and disintegration of the family. That statistics are there. It is unfair to women. Women have been tricked into believing that having a career and family are the norm. Modernity and liberalism have changed everything. Today we find early marriage shocking, but the pre-modern people lived in a very different time period. They didn’t go to schools or colleges. Liberalism has brainwashed us into rejecting early marriage. Girls are denied the freedom to marry early. Yet, girls are told they can sleep with anyone they want, have sex with anyone, “discover”, and even change their gender any time without parental consent! Liberalism is stupid, dangerous, and destructive. It’s ruining lives, families, communities, and societies. Use this link to share: tinyurl.com/EarlyMarriageTruth

[@EB-gt1pq]

Beautiful comment! And yes, as a mother of two little kids, I developed severe anxiety and had to be medicated because I had to juggle work and my kids. Mind you I did not want to work, I had to because my husband doesn’t make enough money.

[@ryojs4286]

Liberalism and the other isms and schisms *are cults*

[@azeemr8961]

Man this deserves to be published!

[@Asiyah2000]

You nailed it bravo mashaAllah 👍💪🏼

[@Sal_A]

Well said. I would add that the advancement of technology has also impacted the role of the home & family

[@acefula6585]

This guy is polite calm and pleasant .. may Allah guide him

[@Assyaroni]

Aameen Allaahumma aameen

[@bryarslemani]

Amen ya rablalamin

[@xxCrimsonSpiritxx]

Ameen

[@Shap0o.PlayZz]

Ameen 😊🎉

[@PNess-bv7jb]

Guide him to what exactly? This is a guy justifying peadophilia and the peadophilia involving Prophet Mohammad.

[@motod1866]

I am blown away by the answer and calm posture of M.Ali. May ALLAH protect you and reward you AAMEEN

[@zakirnaikahmaddeedat3651]

One of the best online du"aat today masya Allah.

[@PNess-bv7jb]

Are you sick in the head? You praising a guy who is justifying peadophilia and the peadophilia involving Prophet Mohammad

[@kyrptonite1825]

For one, the Hadiths say Muhammad married Aisha at Six, she got sick, and once she was better, cons-mmated the Marriage at n-ne. Narrated 'Aisha: that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old, and then she remained with him for nine years (i.e., till his death). (Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 62, Number 64; see also Numbers 65 and 88) Narrated Hisham's father: Khadija died three years before the Prophet departed to Medina. He stayed there for two years or so and then he married 'Aisha when she was a girl of six years of age, and he consumed that marriage when she was nine years old. (Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 5, Book 58, Number 236) Aisha said: The Apostle of Allah (may peace be upon him) married me when I was seven years old. The narrator Sulaiman said: Or six years. He had intercourse with me when I was nine years old. (Sunan Abu Dawud, Number 2116) Next Ashia, had not reached puberty by the age of nine. She was also still a little girl playing with toys: 'A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported that Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) married her when she was seven years old, and he was taken to his house as a bride when she was nine, and her dolls were with her; and when he (the Holy Prophet) died she was eighteen years old. (Sahih Muslim, Book 008, Number 3311) Sahih al-Bukhari 6130 Narrated `Aisha: I used to play with the dolls in the presence of the Prophet, and my girl friends also used to play with me. When Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) used to enter (my dwelling place) they used to hide themselves, but the Prophet would call them to join and play with me. (The playing with the dolls and similar images is forbidden, but it was allowed for `Aisha at that time, as she was a little girl, not yet reached the age of puberty.) (Fath-ul-Bari page 143, Vol.13) Narrated Aisha: The Prophet engaged me when I was a girl of six (years). We went to Medina and stayed at the home of Bani-al-Harith bin Khazraj. Then I got ill and my hair fell down. Later on my hair grew (again) and my mother, Um Ruman, came to me while I was playing in a swing with some of my girl friends. She called me, and I went to her, not knowing what she wanted to do to me. She caught me by the hand and made me stand at the door of the house. I was breathless then, and when my breathing became all right, she took some water and rubbed my face and head with it. Then she took me into the house. There in the house I saw some Ansari women who said, "Best wishes and Allah's Blessing and a good luck." Then she entrusted me to them and they prepared me (for the marriage). Unexpectedly Allah's Apostle came to me in the forenoon and my mother handed me over to him, and at that time I was a girl of nine years of age. (Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 5, Book 58, Number 234) The swing was also not allowed until p-berty. Plus, there is no historical evidence Arab women back then matured faster. Actually, they matured slower due to malnutrition. Aisha didn’t reach p-berry until like 15. And she didn’t have any children, probably due to having s- too young. Precocious puberty also doesn’t mean a g-rl is ready. It is harmful in the younger years. Furthermore, here is what the Quran says: Quran 33:49 O You who have believed, when you marry believing women and then divorce them before you have touched them, then there is not for you any waiting period to count concerning them. Quran 65:4 As for your women past the age of menstruation, in case you do not know, their waiting period is three months, and those who have not menstruated as well. As for those who are pregnant, their waiting period ends with delivery.1 And whoever is mindful of Allah, He will make their matters easy for them So no s3- = no Iddah. There is an Iddah in the second Surah for: 1. Women too old to menstr-te 2. Girls to yo-ng to menst-te (those who have not menstr-ted) 3. Pregnant women Therefore, a Muslim man, according to Quran, can Marry, have s with and divorce, so others then Marry, a pre-pubesc-nt girl. As for why his enemies did not say anything, this might have been a common practice in Arabia, that doesn’t make it right. Think about what they did to female infants, for example. True Religion must rise above the morals of the time. Also, for those saying this is because Aisha became a great scholar, then why command this through an evil means; why not wait? Also, you can’t appeal to culture or relative morality, since Islam is supposed to be final revelation, for all cultures and times, and Muslims believe in Objective Morality. One cannot say this isn’t wrong, as God’s Law is Written on the heart of every man. And let me tell you, we know deep down that this is wr-ng and logically know it is. Now, I can understand different cultures. I can understand in a different time and place, teens might Marry, or something. But having s with a child is unheard of and clearly immoral compared to this. You can argue morally, because if something is immoral, from God, and we can know morality, and God is supposed to be Perfectly Good, then God shouldn’t Teach evil. Muhammad is also supposed to be the example in conduct for all Muslims and mankind, according to the Quran. Also, the Rebbekah is three argument doesn’t work. It assumes that when Abraham found out about Rebekah’s birth, this is when she was born. This doesn’t work, because without modern phones, information traveled slowly. This is also the time Abraham learned about her father’s birth, meaning they would have had to been born at the same time, according to the logic of that argument! Doesn’t work. It could have been many years since then, we don’t know. Rebbekah was called a “young woman” in Hebrew, and carried enough jugs of water to feed a man and all of his camels. As for Mary, no verses in the Bible mention Mary’s age. Jewish women normally got Married around the late teens, I think (unsure). The Tradition is also quiet on this, except for later apocryphal works, which aren’t trustworthy. The Tradition also holds Mary to be a Perpetual Virgin, and Jesus’s Birth as without Pangs and like Light Through Glass. Now, the Canonical Age of Marriage in Meideval Europe was 7, mainly for political alliances (once could probably get an annulment, in this case), but the age for cons-mmation was 13, if there were clear signs of maturity. Way better than 9, the te-n years. And even then, this was a matter of discipline, it seems, not doctrine. And with later science, it becomes different. But we see with Islam, a matter of revelation, says that it’s okay to have rel-ti-ns with a little g-, which is dam-ging. Does anyone have a response???

[@Aliya-gh2ec]

Yes I just want to put my fists up, ready

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I have made a video on this topic from a different perspective, please have a look, you might find it useful. Thanks.

[@rayasellam8847]

I am a Moroccan woman living in the West. I remember when going on Holiday as a young girl I was playing with dolls and baking fake cookies with sand while a Moroccan young girl my age was taking care of her brothers and sisters and baking real bread and doing house choices. So yes look at the culture, country and traditions. Western can't compair themselves with Africans or Middle Easters for example.

[@showtime1235]

so because a young girl plays w dolls and cooking then it’s justified for her to have s*x w a 60yr old man…. very bulletproof logic you got there

[@7625e]

Not just that. It was 1500 years ago as well. A doll would probably be the only thing to entertain their imagination. This is an illiterate society as well. I mean in 70’s and presocial media teen agers had action figures etc. They throw out all this context smh

[@showtime1235]

@@7625e still justifying sleeping w a 9yr old

[@Bella-bd5st]

@@showtime1235someone who didn’t watch the video 🤦‍♀️

[@showtime1235]

@@Bella-bd5st it’s funny how you say i didn’t watch the video while addressing exact points that were in the video…

[@truearabhustla]

Salam brother. As a Muslim who is always learning, I had a coworker ask me this before and it was a good question. He was asking out of pure curiosity. I mentioned the times were different back then compared to now, however you helped give me a better and deeper understanding. JazakAllah Khayrun! May Allah reward you, Inshallah!

[@phoazal-m728]

This is also a very good and educational video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pHuafYmwebqCd68 It goes into the matter very good

[@Honesttalk767]

i love the pure respect between them in the dialogue

[@kareemnj6248]

Yes such a great questioner, nothing but genuine conversation here.

[@doneknee3125]

Agreed.. rare lol

[@purpleprinc3]

Indeed, he is genuinely sincere, which is noice 👌 😅

[@xdaydreamerx]

Its more important that they are respecting children and not promoting using them for marriages like they are doing.

[@unmouscat]

​@@xdaydreamerxu mean like how westerners encourage their kids to date and then annoyed when they have boyfriends? Lol

[@abdullahfaridi2397]

I Attended this session live But will watch again , in sha allah It's always worth it to watch your videos, Masha allah

[@Dontbeasheep345]

When was this live because I’m been trying to catch his lives.

[@tarjamalism]

me 2

[@aha..]

#Still the question remains, as to why Mohammad,a SELF-PROCLAIMED ROLE MODEL wanted to marry a young girl of 6 when he was 53 and her grandpa's age! #Why did he want to have a 6 year old bride after having many other wives? #All those who are trying to justify him must understand that even then it was not regular practise of men to marry children of age 6 or age 8. That is why all the other wives' of Mohammad's and his contemporaries were of respectable age, and not children. So this is in no way becoming of a person who claims to be a ROLE-MODEL & PROPHET. #What did Allah have to do with this marriage, or the many marriages, and sex life of Mohhammad outside of his marriage; in the Salvation plan of humanity?

[@Dontbeasheep345]

@@aha.. WHY DID JOSEPH 99 YEAR OLD MARRED 12 YEAR OLD MARRY (THE MOTHER OF YOUR GOD? WHY DID YOUR COUNTRY LOWERED THE AGE OF MARRIAGE FROM 10 YEAR OLD TO 7 YEAR OLD. Good thing you asked the right questions for your right answer. Wait a minute, why they didn’t teach you in the history class. That your great grandmother were possibly at 7 years old when they got married. Amigo it’s was the law. Here you go. AGE OF MARRIAGE IN 🇺🇸 USA 19th and 20th centuries In Delaware, the age of consent was 10 years old until 1871 when it was lowered to 7 years old. Under the 1871 law, a man was given the death penalty for sex with a girl below the age of consent.[22] In 1880, 37 states had an age of consent of 10 years, 10 stat es had an age of consent at 12 years, and Delaware had an age of consent of 7 years. [23][24]

[@Dontbeasheep345]

@@aha.. at what age do you teach young girls on how to make a DILDO? HOW TO MAKE A DILDO IN THE BIBLE. Ezekiel 16:17 You also took the fine jewelry of gold and silver I had given you, and you made male idols with which to prostitute yourself.

[@animatedislamichistory]

It's really the best answer I have heard. There is nothing to justify, our morals and values come from the Quran. While there is some truth to societal norms across time & space, and you would most likely not marry a 6yo today, saying that it was wrong in the past is completely out of touch with the norms of the times. Tabarakallah, great talks as usual!

[@-Ahmed8592]

Morality is a created thing, and Allah is the Creator so what is moral or not is purely decided by Him. And He tells us what to do and what not to do!

[@RenderingUser]

I guess this is also one thing that makes the societal system in islam perfect Parents having a say in their daughter's marriage can allow for age of marriage to adapt to different cultures and different times Since the parents will be following the societal norms

[@Nero-F121]

@@MrSmith-vc8xd What a wall!

[@harryd8010]

Your morals come from Muhammad the pedo 😂

[@Fire-pt2xu]

@@-Ahmed8592 so your also a pedo?

[@rubana7487]

Right now in the US Middle school, 11 to 14-year-old children are being given BIRTH CONTROL yet no one has a problem with it, but AYASHA who has been DEAD for 1400 years is a BIG ISSUE for them.

[@chickennuggets6122]

​​@uncertaintyeclipses5936oday's issue is because now kids are spoiled and not mature. Very different compared to people who used to live to survive and their biggest concern was living and being able to eat and drink. Nowadays the biggest concern of 11 year olds is getting the new iPhone, you see the difference?

[@rubana7487]

@uncertaintyeclipses5936 If you believe giving Middle School birth control is wrong I am sure you are working to change it? Or are fighting to stop child marriage, according to the UN last decade there were more than 200,000 child marriages in the US. Tell me all about your activism to fight it or are you just one who needs to criticize Muhammed, and can not find anything else so you bring up Ayesha. Do you even know she was one of the greatest scholars in Islam? Or that she was a warrior who led an army to battle? Do you know anything about her life? There is a whole industry built up around criticizing the Prophet, yet so many of those are at the forefront of this industry are becoming Muslim every day, Google Shermon Burgess, the latest a notorious anti-Muslim is now a Muslim, one of the 2 billion followers of Muhammed (SAW). When someone spits at the moon, it doesn't touch the moon but falls back on the face of the one who spits.

[@doomdesire3460]

@Uncertainty Eclipses fair enough Personally you can't accept child marriage past present future But you have no moral compass except your personal feelings

[@doomdesire3460]

@Uncertainty Eclipses a load of bullshit Did God think twice before placing a child in the womb of 12 year old Mary pbuh ???? NO, she was at the age of puberty People then didn't put numbers over our heads, saying I'm 9 12, 90 100 If you are growing out little hairs on your face, you are going to be called a man, If you hit your menses You are going to be called a woman Forget about age Age is only an issue today We have 18 year olds acting like 2 year olds

[@rubana7487]

@uncertaintyeclipses5936 Never happened, keep making up stuff that is all you and your kind are good. People 100x more vicious liars than you, men who have made careers, and political careers criticized Islam have accepted Islam, so not wasting any more time one a 1 subject pony.

[@MO9ALA7]

Everyone talks about her age, may Allah be pleased with her, but doesn't know anything about what she has contributed to the religion, like memorized 2000 hadith and one of the most hadith narrators! WHAT A SHAME!!

[@yesihavereadit]

several of the 200 hadith she narated tell us that she was 6 when married and 9 when Mohammed diddled her.

[@yesihavereadit]

She is supposedly the source of 2000 hadiths, but what she "remembered" compared to what *_actually_* happened might be two different things. An awful lot of them are quite mundane, what people had for breakfast, who had a nicer camel, sitting watching black soldiers practice sword fighting, taking dolls to play with at her husbands house.....

[@brucewayne7875]

Because it's irrelevant

[@soloxslick]

​@@yesihavereaditRebecca was 3

[@nazifarahman5330]

​@@yesihavereaditKeep talking you are sooo sad that this misconception got cleared. Go and cry to mommy😂😂

[@nigo123]

{ why do I need justify something happened that is Not wrong } that answer is enough .. 🌹 Jazak اللە khairan akhi .

[@Fire-pt2xu]

Pedo

[@mubarakisonline]

​@@omarrenteria2542 Marrying an adult is correct

[@barel8741]

@@omarrenteria2542 do u even watched the videos?

[@roarkoo4648]

​@@omarrenteria2542 correct. Aisha was an adult

[@alifiamd9963]

​@@mubarakisonline emphasize on the Marrying, these liberals don't even do that nowadays.

[@samiman5606]

It was narrated that 'Aa'ishah (may Allah be pleased with her) said that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) never struck a servant or a woman, nor did he ever strike anything with his hand except to strive for the sake of Allah

[@mohamedsalsal3792]

Because it’s the truth

[@aha..]

#Still the question remains, as to why Mohammad,a SELF-PROCLAIMED ROLE MODEL wanted to marry a young girl of 6 when he was 53 and her grandpa's age! #Why did he want to have a 6 year old bride after having many other wives? #All those who are trying to justify him must understand that even then it was not regular practise of men to marry children of age 6 or age 8. That is why all the other wives' of Mohammad's and his contemporaries were of respectable age, and not children. So this is in no way becoming of a person who claims to be a ROLE-MODEL & PROPHET. #What did Allah have to do with this marriage, or the many marriages, and sex life of Mohhammad outside of his marriage; in the Salvation plan of humanity?

[@SalemAhmed-pb4tf]

@@aha.. God is wise and ordered Aisha to marry so that he became a senior women's scholars

[@SalemAhmed-pb4tf]

@@aha.. Prophet Muhammad's marriage was a political affair of the likes of the Jewish tribe leader's daughter even allies

[@SalemAhmed-pb4tf]

@@aha.. You will not know the biography of the Messenger, and you will not ask, and if he was the leader and the state, then they must be the reason.

[@TheRockeyAllen]

Presentism: In the premodern era, there was - High child morality rates - Low life expectancy - Your societies ability to resist invasion and annihilation depends directly on your the quantitative size of your armed forces You and I, we are here because of that practice. The human civilization survives because of that practice.

[@ummerfarooq5383]

Present: marriages banned, rapes 99% #metoo left right and center

[@JP-pq9xi]

If you have a 9 year old daughter, I hope you can find her a handsome Muslim man!

[@rahmanibrothers1017]

@@JP-pq9xi no need since islam has law of marriage also which states both boy and girl should have hit puberty and give consent

[@bryg3577]

Do you think it’s ok to sleep with children in today’s day? If no (hopefully), you are better than Muhammad

[@mia3033]

​@@JP-pq9xiit doesnt work that way in present time, it was only normal in the past

[@AfricanSoil]

Unapologetic, We shouldn't feel shy or afraid for our laws and rules came from the creator.

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I have made a video on this topic from a different perspective, please have a look, you might find it useful. Thanks.

[@yington]

So would you ever sleep with a 9 year old child if you were in your 50’s?

[@AfricanSoil]

@@yington You are one of those.

[@yington]

@@AfricanSoil Would you do what Mohammed did with a 9 year old?

[@Just_logic]

This Chanel is under rated. Mashallah.

[@Just_logic]

@Ruzaini BinYusof and why do you think that is not under rated?

[@zakirnaikahmaddeedat3651]

Let's share this channel more and more. M. Ali deserves billions subs insya Allah.

[@sandrathompson1277]

Maybe most normal people think it’s a load of rubbish…a backwards look at life..time moves forwards …not back..you all should be sent back to a Muslim country..maybe five hundred years ago..that would probably suit you all…

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I have made a video on this topic from a different perspective, please have a look, you might find it useful. Thanks.

[@Just_logic]

@@TheologyWithLogic What is the name of your channel? Theology with logic?

[@ebrahimi44]

The Christians forget Mary( RA) was 12 years old when she was pregnant with Jesus( AS) and she married to Joseph when he was 90. Their hypocrisy is astronomical. Thank God for guiding me to Islam!

[@abdi2.094]

From where do you have this. Which verse?

[@ebrahimi44]

@@abdi2.094 Its in the apocrypha gospels which are probably close to the truth than the four gospels that were written by unknown scribes. Also it was the Jewish tradition to let their children marry young( both male and female) at that age or younger than that.

[@RichardEdwards40]

​​​@@ebrahimi44 jews usually married their girls at ages 15-16 and boys at ages 17-19 so joseph was likely 20 and mary 16 when jesus was born.

[@fatalslice2168]

Their is a difference muslims don't see. Muhammad is according to them a timeless example (unlike all others)...yet he isn't, since most muslims today wouldn't touch a 9 year old.

[@FreeP321]

@@RichardEdwards40That’s a blatant lie, you’re giving false information

[@saudpanchi1500]

This was the answer that I was searching for everywhere. Mic Drop. Ma Sha Allah

[@showtime1235]

this was not a mic drop hahahah he just discredited your prophet and you didn’t even know because you’re so blind for your bias

[@Buzzmanthegreat]

@@showtime1235 stop replying to every comment with garbage and rewatch the video maybe with a notepad this time

[@showtime1235]

@@Buzzmanthegreat if you don’t have an answer just say that

[@justanaquarius320]

Are you deaf? You can turn on the subtitles right? ​@@showtime1235

[@extrazikgaming2694]

"Indeed, it's not the eyes that are blind but the hearts" May allah guide you .

[@zackf6696]

Allah Hu Akbar! I had to Takbir multiple times in this video. It was so satisfying to see the critics dismantled in such a casual fashion. Even brother Grizz was sharing a chuckle lol. Jazak'Allah Khair brother for all these beneficial conversations, may Allah keep you steadfast and prosperous, Ameen.

[@Soldier-of-Messiah-Yeshua]

Ewwwwwwwwww

[@PNess-bv7jb]

zachf.... Don't you feel ashamed at glorifying a guy who is justifying peadophilia and the peadophilia involving Prophet Mohammad. Sick and disturbing

[@MuhammadIdris-jb6jv]

@@Soldier-of-Messiah-Yeshuamarriage isn’t about schmex dum dum

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I have made a video on this topic from a different perspective, please have a look, you might find it useful. Thanks.

[@hadithoftheday3858]

The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "The world compared to the Hereafter is but like what one of you gets when placing his finger into the sea, so look at what you draw from it." Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2323

[@aha..]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/aWm6m6mIipp0g9E Boy dies in a car wreck - Goes to Heaven ...and then... Sid Roth's It's Supernatural

[@aha..]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/l2GZdYR8mNSDpas Every night, demons came to William Wood's home for a visit, UNTIL one night... Sid Roth

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I have made a video on this topic from a different perspective, please have a look, you might find it useful. Thanks.

[@talibhamdain2099]

The best explaination of the marriage of A'isha RA. May Almighty ALLAH grant success on Brother Muhammad Ali Da'wah & Islamic activities, and bestow him the highest level of Paradise, Jannatul Firdaus. from Mindanao, Southern Philippines

[@sidiksamion3]

Amiin ya Rabbal'alamiin

[@zenoist2101]

The best explanation is that MO was a pedo.

[@aha..]

#Still the question remains, as to why Mohammad,a SELF-PROCLAIMED ROLE MODEL wanted to marry a young girl of 6 when he was 53 and her grandpa's age! #Why did he want to have a 6 year old bride after having many other wives? #All those who are trying to justify him must understand that even then it was not regular practise of men to marry children of age 6 or age 8. That is why all the other wives' of Mohammad's and his contemporaries were of respectable age, and not children. So this is in no way becoming of a person who claims to be a ROLE-MODEL & PROPHET. #What did Allah have to do with this marriage, or the many marriages, and sex life of Mohhammad outside of his marriage; in the Salvation plan of humanity?

[@Adnan_Khan__111]

​@@aha.. last question's answer: Because He was a prophet to guide humanity, he must be upright.

[@aha..]

@Adnan Khan What? Is that your answer? Does that mean a prophet can get away with any wrongs he committed and not be punished or corrected by his god? Is that the reason why Allah encouraged his sexual life with who all he wanted?

[@jamalbabu5357]

As far as ummul mumineen Ayesha's marriage to our Prophet is concerned, it is by the command of Almighty Allah.They were the happiest couple ever lived.Moreover it was our mother Ayesha who gave more 2000 authentic hadees.She was so intelligent with super memory power by the grace of almighty Allah.And each hadees is precious than a mountain of gold.

[@jitedurmu5564]

Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2016 Abu Abdullah Al-Jadali narrated: "I asked 'Aishah about the character of the Messenger of Allah. She said: 'He was not obscene, nor uttering obscenities, nor screaming in the markets, he would not return an evil with an evil, but rather he was pardoning and forgiving."

[@env0x]

what about Quran 5:45

[@Chainless_Slave7]

@@env0x what about it?

[@env0x]

@@Chainless_Slave7 "he would not return an evil with an evil" but the Qur'an commands to return eye for eye, hand for hand, nose for nose, ear for ear, tooth for tooth.

[@mbillal_2342]

@@env0xfinish the verse

[@amerabdulkarim5544]

Another thing to keep in mind is back in those days people didn’t have birth certificates or any type of photo identification like we do now to determine the age of someone. Like brother Muhammad Ali said you were an adult once you hit puberty physically/mentally.

[@Assyaroni]

Yup..i agree that we are an adult once we hit puberty..even my father still using that

[@Halal_Dan]

​@@omarrenteria2542 She hit puberty at 9, and was tall enough to rest her chin on the Prophet's shoulder.

[@Halal_Dan]

@@omarrenteria2542 I'm shaking down your idea that Aisha was some small child who didn't know what was going on.

[@joshuaramjee7251]

its funny how muslims try to jusitfy this act of pedophilia

[@Nusahhh]

Can I have the source brother. This is new to me al hamdullillah.@@Halal_Dan

[@IhabFahmy]

Thank you for your polite and logical approach. Thank you for gently educating the questioner (who also practices respectful.discourse with no ulterior motive, so I applaud his character). And most of all, thankyou for educating me.

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I have made a video on this topic from a different perspective, please have a look, you might find it useful. Thanks.

[@ads9057]

It was an eye opener to understand how the things were 1400 years ago. Great response to the question. The guy on the call was amazing and did a great job researching.

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I have made a video on this topic from a different perspective, please have a look, you might find it useful. Thanks.

[@rainnaturesleep1382]

This Brother Muhammad Ali is absolutely lovely, Masha'Allah, Alhamdulillah, May Allah preserve you, strengthen you, protect you and bless you, Brother. Amīn Thumma Amīn.

[@PNess-bv7jb]

I think you need investigating by the authorities because you clearly so happy that someone who you listened to is justifying peadophilia and the peadophilia involving Prophet Mohammad.

[@vanessac0382]

It's lovely to believe pedophilia is ok?

[@Finaldo_number_1]

@@PNess-bv7jb there is an europien prince who married 7 years old girl Western culture has thats also

[@leemajor5003]

This is hands down the best explanation of Muhammad and Ayisha marriage on the interent.

[@desertnomadbilal4512]

don't bother explain to them , they just can't accept that thier "wild card" don't work anymore i have explained to them that not long ago about 50 years ago marriag age was 12 years old and today in 2023 girls in the US are losing their virginity at the age of 11-12 but that doesn't matter to someone who just want to smear

[@AlMahdirehan]

ﷺ|سلام الله عليها رضي الله عنها

[@PercyRaymond]

😂😂😂😂😂 crap

[@Velaldo-nw7ve]

How? Would you allow ur 6 year old daughter with a 53 year old grown man?

[@leemajor5003]

@Velaldo-nw7ve After 15 minutes of coherent, contextual, intellectual explanation, you go back to asking the same question. As the quran states, it is not the eyes that are blind, its the hearts. Also, if the messenger of Allah wants to marry my daughter at that age, i would consent because the messenger is infallible. Now are u christion or athiest?

[@aishax01]

He doesn't miss ❤ may Allah be pleased with her Aisha (radiAllahu anha) I hope to meet her, inshaAllah, in Jannah

[@bann9437]

Loved the discussion ! Best video on explanation of this “controversial” topic.

[@Hok0ri]

This was an amazing response and I learned a lot from this video. I converted and I had a lot of questions about this topic but as I spoke with Muslim I felt I had my judgement of the Quran twisted and coming to find out Islam is a beautiful religion. There’s a lot of things that kept me away from it and a lot of things I was told that was false or misunderstood without studying. I was at first surprised in the beginning but now I feel at ease during studies

[@pearlsof5534]

Brother Mohammed Ali is an eloquent speaker he speaks beautifully and explains things with reason and clearly Alhamdullilah

[@jnpkzwjx]

Yeah

[@TheologyWithLogic]

@@jnpkzwjx I have made a video on this topic from a different perspective, please have a look, you might find it useful. Thanks.

[@RANasution]

One of the best explanations about the topics. Barakallahufiikum bro Ali.

[@maimoonasayeed5112]

Assalamualaikum. I was searching for this video(and many more on various topics). Jazakallah

[@m4nm0n]

this is by far the best explanation on this topic. thank you brother.

[@imamhosen6101]

❤ from Bangladesh 🇧🇩.

[@Top.Ramin.Noodles]

It’s so funny to me because this was NEVER an issue up until now.

[@yesihavereadit]

yep thats how poor a moral guide the Quran and Hadith are

[@ambrosiamlinga8402]

Quran is being translate now that why we are seing all this evil things mohamed did

[@MI-vc9lp]

​@@yesihavereadit No, it just means that people are gullible and credulous

[@WaleedHassan-bu1ff]

@@yesihavereadit Nope this shows that societies morals change for example 200 years ago lgbt were considered bad

[@Top.Ramin.Noodles]

@@yesihavereaditNo, marriage at young ages like that were normal up until recently. Like a hundred years ago men would marry girls younger than 16 and you’re trying to judge a man who lived 1500 years ago. Society changes.

[@kavitaaknath8607]

Best answer I’ve heard on this topic. The ease of communication SubhanAllah 👌

[@showtime1235]

it’s an absolutely horrible answer by saying that something was done then and can’t be used in modern context would also apply to the teachings from mohammed so unless your saying gods not eternal then your logic is extremely flawed esp because we can look at things done in the past in modern context and still say they were bad

[@Buzzmanthegreat]

@@showtime1235 i think you watched a different video entirely

[@showtime1235]

@@Buzzmanthegreat i replied directly to what he said little guy

[@dahirismail5931]

@@showtime1235no. We have rules set for marriage in islam. You must be physically and mentally mature. Aisha was both. It is a good answer because no one is asking this from an academic perspective but an emotional one. Everyone is coming with a “oh it weird and taboo but I cant prove the marriage to be wrong” Aisha was mature and enjoyed her relationship with Muhammad.

[@astonnoor]

​@@dahirismail5931Even though he has eyes still can't see.

[@IpahayagNyo]

jazakallahu khairan brother, I've learn lot of vital topics from you. May Allah keep you safe and continue your journey in Dawa'h

[@showtime1235]

by saying that something was done then and can’t be used in modern context would also apply to the teachings from mohammed so unless your saying gods not eternal then your logic is extremely flawed esp because we can look at things done in the past in modern context and still say they were bad

[@nazrighazali]

Thank you brother. I just subscribed after watching some of your videos. You are doing excellent work to provide knowledge and education to people. I am learning a lot from your videos. May Allah swt bless you brother.

[@coolshariq]

No don't be sheep stop watching videos about nonsense and read a Quran .

[@hoosainsayedabdurrahaman6653]

Beautifully spoken jazakalla for sharing. Really appreciate. ‬السَّلَامُ عَلَيْكُم وَرَحْمَةُ اللَّهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ Jazakalla for sharing knowledge.

[@stanloona5498]

بارك الله فيك أخي، إجابة شافية كافية

[@muhammadamjad2537]

Such a brilliant explanation.. May Allah bless you brother Ali..

[@PNess-bv7jb]

You need investigating by the authorities. You arecso happy to hear someone justifying peadophilia and the peadophilia involving Prophet Mohammad.

[@AneeS24SaleeM]

@@PNess-bv7jblmaoo I love how mad you are, the only thing you islamaphobes thought you had on our beloved prophet was this topic and to have it completely dismantled leaves you afraid and grasping at straws 😂😂😂😂😂 keep crying as Islam stands as the most perfect religion, which is no wonder why it’s the fastest growing religion in the world, most converts being WOMEN . Allahu Akbar

[@unmouscat]

​@@PNess-bv7jbur entire western culture has to be investigated😂 putting dating kissing sx in the minds of young children and then act surprised when they get pregnant as teens. And then there is a whole nonsense of celebrating teen pregnancy I'm ur culture. Smh

[@ntluck1592]

ngl, that was a much better answer than I could come up with. Good job on the rational reasoning

[@Ria1D13]

The best explanation hands down. As a Muslim, I also feel no need for justification on this matter as I know it just how it was back then. But I still need an approach of how to handle this question when somebody ask so they can be educated. Thank you so much brother Muhammed Ali, I learned so much from you. May Allah SWT bless you..

[@itsmichaelakin5421]

If you had the power to, would you make it illegal to marry a child in 600AD? The answer to that question determines whether Muhammad is someone worth following or not.

[@myinstgiscarbenuim1693]

​@@itsmichaelakin5421 a child? yes and it was already illegal to marry a child at that time anyways, Aisha was not considered a child nor was girls who reached physical maturity and mental maturity to understand the concept of marriage like she did .

[@itsmichaelakin5421]

@@myinstgiscarbenuim1693 The definition of child has nothing to do with mental maturity. 6 years old is nowhere near enough time. Just admit your prophet isn’t an example to be followed.

[@FHASHI]

​@@itsmichaelakin5421 based on what? And that was the marriage contract at age 6.She did not move in or consumate the marriage until 9 y/o. She was also a great person. The daughter of his favourite companion abu bakr. And I belief she was also the only wife born into the religion, as the prophet was already given the prophethood a few years earlier.

[@itsmichaelakin5421]

@@FHASHI Based on Jesus Christ, the Son of God. He who knew no sin, but became sin so that to those that believe in him they may receive the righteousness of God. He is the one to be followed, because he was completely innocent of any sin and did not deserve death, yet laid down his life to save this world from its sins. Even Muhammad needs Jesus to save him, because God will hold him to account for every sin he has committed in defiance against him. None shall be hidden. But I suppose it’s too late for him since he’s dead, but you still have time. Repent and believe in Jesus so you don’t perish like your prophet.

[@Muhammad-AbduRahman]

Thank you so very much for the explanation and the information.

[@hyzum7998]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fWKcq5aooLqHe6s&ab_channel=MiddleNation

[@knowledgeseeker2]

Jazakallah Akhi, this is the best explanation I ever got . Alhamdulillah with lots of challenging questions makes me eager to learn more about the deen otherwise I would be lazy.

[@PNess-bv7jb]

The peadophilia involving Prophet Mohammad is justva fraction of the sickening disturbing and dangerous stuff in the Quran and Islamic authentic Hadiths.

[@AbdulFatahShieryar]

جزاک الله خیرا As a Muslim I had the same question. Now it is crystal clear.

[@shafiuddin5118]

The best explanation i have ever got for this question. May allah bless you with success in the life after.

[@FunMotivatation]

SUBHANALLAH You cleared my mind love from PAKISTAN 🥰🥰

[@PNess-bv7jb]

funmotivation...You obviously taking great joy in someone you are listening to who is justifying peadophilia and the peadophilia involving Prophet Mohammad.

[@AbdullaTashrib]

@@PNess-bv7jb cry

[@MikkaMeows]

@@PNess-bv7jbjust stop yapping buddy Aisha herself claimed that her marriage to Mohammad was the best 😂

[@abdelrazzaqabuhejleh6625]

Wallah your answers should be written and made as a book

[@togr824get]

This was the Best Explanation I've heard..Thank you.. Now when someone throws that up in my face(Aisha's age) I have a very good rebuttal ..Thank you very very much Sir..

[@hyzum7998]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fWKcq5aooLqHe6s&ab_channel=MiddleNation

[@yasco9684]

She wasn’t a child when she got married she was an adult 21 years old.

[@hibathullahsaudha8824]

Jazkallahu khair brother.... you really helped to turn my perspective in a right way 🌸

[@rayndaba3166]

Asma the elder sister of Aisha, was ten years older than Aisha. It is reported in Taqreeb al-Tehzeeb as well as in Ibn Kathir s Al-Bidayah wa al-Nihayah that Asma died in the 73rd year after migration of Muhammad when she was 100 years old. Now, obviously if Asma was 100 years old in the 73rd year after Migration to Medina, she should have been 27 or 28 years old at the time of migration. If Asma was 27 or 28 years old at the time of hijrah, Aisha should have been 17 or 18 years old at that time. Thus, if Aisha got married in year 1 AH or 2 AH (after Migration to Medina), she must have been between 18 to 20 years old at the time of her marriage.

[@Itzyasir2]

weak narration

[@rayndaba3166]

@@Itzyasir2 it isn't because the evidence supports it. Check the time-line of events.

[@Itzyasir2]

@@rayndaba3166 the narration is weak and not reliable.

[@rayndaba3166]

@@Itzyasir2 yet all the evidence supports it. But the way the narration of prophet marrying Aisha at 9 is weak and not supported bu any evidence.

[@Itzyasir2]

@@rayndaba3166 the hadith of prophet marrying aisha at 9 is sahih

[@salman_alanas]

As-salamu_alaykum. to my all Muslim brothers and sisters.

[@shahid8545]

Walaikum salaam rahmatuallahi wa barakatu

[@mdazlanawati7434]

Walekumassalam wa rehmatullahi wa barakatu

[@IbrahimKhan-ri6qx]

وعليكم السلام و رحمة الله و بركاته

[@UD-qs8dz]

Wa alaikumus salaam wa rahmatulLaah

[@Iuluuu]

walekumassalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh

[@Shaheeda-fn2pr]

JazakAllah Khairan, this is by far the best discourse with regard to the subject matter. This explanation gives so much dignity and truth to the subject matter and neutralizes the uneducated attack on the person of our beloved Rasul(sws)..It puts into perspective for everyone the question about our beloved nana Aisha and her life and marriage to our beloved Rasul(sws)

[@SultanRahman1]

Jazakallah for sharing this with the public

[@shahidhussain9176]

1. Sarah gave birth to Isaac at the age of ninety (Genesis 17). 2. Isaac was in his thirties when the incident of Mount Moriah occurred with his father, Abraham (Genesis 22). 3. Immediately after Isaac and Abraham’s incident on Mount Moriah, Rebecca is born (Genesis 22). 4. As soon as Rebecca’s birth is mentioned in Genesis 22, few verses down (next chapter), we read that Sarah died at the age of 127 years old (Genesis 23:1-3). 5. At the time of Sarah’s death, Isaac would be have been 37-years-old. 6. Isaac married Rebecca at the age of 40 (Genesis 25:20), this would show from the Bible that Rebecca was only three years old, given that she was only born three years prior, just after the Mount Moriah incident and the death of Sarah.

[@evenly.2529]

Lol

[@rayyaanpinky2284]

3 yrs old at that time is more mature manageable than 40 yrs in 2023 🤷‍♀️

[@alifiamd9963]

Permission to copy this akhi🙏

[@shahidhussain9176]

@@alifiamd9963 Of course you can brother that’s why I put it up there and any thing you need help with just message me

[@aha..]

#Still the question remains, as to why Mohammad,a SELF-PROCLAIMED ROLE MODEL wanted to marry a young girl of 6 when he was 53 and her grandpa's age! #Why did he want to have a 6 year old bride after having many other wives? #All those who are trying to justify him must understand that even then it was not regular practise of men to marry children of age 6 or age 8. That is why all the other wives' of Mohammad's and his contemporaries were of respectable age, and not children. So this is in no way becoming of a person who claims to be a ROLE-MODEL & PROPHET. #What did Allah have to do with this marriage, or the many marriages, and sex life of Mohhammad outside of his marriage; in the Salvation plan of humanity?

[@nazari2]

Great explanation ❤

[@karimaly9670]

Great work Akhi may Allah bless you for all your efforts and grant you janat Al firdous

[@sufyandanjumaibrahim3524]

Very insightful 👏. Alhamdulillah

[@bakhtiyorsulaymonov]

Thanks for the video and explanation

[@ServantofTheMostGreat]

SUB HAN ALLAH BROTHER MUHAMMAD ALI YOU CLARIFIED THE SITUATION SO GOOD THE GUY WAS LISTENING CONTINUOUSLY!!

[@Sarahsh03]

Thank you for explaining this so clearly. As a Muslim I always hear about people speaking down on prophet Mohammad pbuh so much becuase of this and saying very hurtful things and literally boils my blood. People’s literally such closed minded and ignorant people so I stay quiet. But thank you. Alhamduillah

[@ramlangoddos4425]

Masha Allah. This is the most comprehensive answer from dae Muhammad Ali to constant barrages of attacks on Prophet Muhammad on his marriage to Aisha. People just need to be educated and historically more objective without looking at it from the lenses of "presentism" the term used by Muhammad Ali. This is a great, educational video. Jazakallah khairan.

[@showtime1235]

you’re argument is essentially saying that god is not eternal very poor argument if you are pro islam

[@Buzzmanthegreat]

@@showtime1235stop being braindead may Allah guide you

[@dahirismail5931]

@@showtime1235no our morals didn’t change. You must be physically and mentally mature 1400 years ago and present time. Tell me how a physically and mentally mature woman who got married at the same time as everyone else until 1900 is wrong.

[@RynneFdin]

Best response I've seen so far about Aisha ra marriage. Mostly we thought we are the one who has to explain to them not otherwise. They made the claim, the burden of proof should be on them. Jazakallah khairan Brother M.Ali 🙏

[@lanavandutch5591]

You should watch Shahid Bolsen’s response about the west’s obsession with Aisha and the Prophet, I was blown away he is very smart and intelligent.

[@showtime1235]

by saying that something was done then and can’t be used in modern context would also apply to the teachings from mohammed so unless your saying gods not eternal then your logic is extremely flawed esp because we can look at things done in the past in modern context and still say they were bad

[@lilkurva180]

@@showtime1235 No its not lol. Because its a different scale. People do not simply live until 35 today. They live until they are 80, 90, some 100. If we use todays standard for the past especially with life expectancy then by that standard every human in history should have hoped they were born into the modern world I guess. Because they would have died out. What the Quran and by Muhammad standard is to marry someone who is a woman. If at that point by the average Aisha almost lived a third of the naturally expected life, what exactly is wrong with her getting married at that time? Today however they would have lived 10-15 percent of their life. Completely different standard.

[@dahirismail5931]

@@showtime1235your obsession is funny. No where did we say the criteria has changed. What changed was the public’s view on what age of marriage is acceptable and what isn’t. There is multiple perspectives you can answer this question and he used one of many and your bent on saying the same thing

[@showtime1235]

@@dahirismail5931 100% the criteria changed unless you believe there isn’t anything wrong w sleeping w a 9yr old if god is meant to be forever then his prophets teachings and practices will be viewed as perfect throughout all time and obviously that’s not true w thsi (unless ofc again you believe it’s okay to sleep w a 9yr old) if mohammed was gods prophet and a perfect person who muslims can model their life after this is a bit of an issue and that’s not even taking into account the fact he got permission to break rules such as having more than 4 wives but lets stick to aisha

[@enamullah4796]

thank you brother. u explained tha very nice and gently. it was confusing me also but now i got clarity thanks to you. salam.

[@Just_A_Stranger]

Good answer Jazakum Allahu Khairan wa barak feekom

[@WeWillAllReturnToAllahSoon]

well said brother Muhammad Ali, baaraka Allahu feek wa zadaka min fadlih 🤝✨

[@TheMessenger1981]

Thanks brother. Bless you

[@Smabverse]

your point about "the person who makes the claim that something is weird is the person who should explain" and asking that person where he/she got his/her moral compass from is so strong too 😎

[@abdelhaksaouli8802]

ثبت الله أجرك The best video yoou did in your life

[@TheCanamera]

Jazakaallahu Khair. Very good answer.

[@sadiaabdullahi3235]

How stupid could a person be to ask this same question. If this marriage was an issue back then, the same people who called him “crazy, magician” would have made it big deal and call him names. Anyone who uses logic can see it was not an issue, it was the norm. But they can’t find any faults so they have to come up with one.

[@showtime1235]

by saying that something was done then and can’t be used in modern context would also apply to the teachings from mohammed so unless your saying gods not eternal then your logic is extremely flawed esp because we can look at things done in the past in modern context and still say they were bad your logic is so flawed that it’s kinda convincing me that you’re just a troll

[@sadiaabdullahi3235]

God is eternal, social/cultural norms change over time. The point am trying to make is, when prophet SCW told the people at the time to worship one god, you will be resurrected after you die, they mocked him and called him names”a magician, a poet, crazy man”, Why didn’t they call him rap**t or ped**hile if his marriage to our mother Aisha was wrong or something out of cultural norm. It wasn’t this only became an issue when the feminist movement began or around that time.

[@dahirismail5931]

@@showtime1235everyone is answering this question to tend to the social contruct that your holding against Islam. Our religious view on it hasn’t changed but we must tend to those that don’t believe in Islam. You get it

[@Brien831]

⁠@@dahirismail5931So if I understand you correctly, the prophet did nothing wrong and Allah approved. So if I want to follow the words of Allah and establish them as law, it should be done so that I would be able to marry a girl as young as Aisha? So Allah allows people to marry children and have sexual intercourse with them?

[@PariJha-vz9ep]

​@@Brien831In Islam,one can only marry if there is no physical mental and psychological harm in it. So in today's world marrying a 9 year old is wrong as per islam. Also,societal norms are also taken into consideration before marriage so your point doesn't add up

[@budidayaberuk6144]

Thank you. Out of all the explanations, presentations, and sermons regarding this matter, somehow i found your response the most concise and enlightening. Alhamdulillah, thank you again.

[@rahma_h2y]

حَسْبُنَا اللَّهُ سَيُؤْتِينَا اللَّهُ مِن فَضْلِهِ وَرَسُولُهُ إِنَّا إِلَى اللَّهِ رَاغِبُونَ

[@samiman5606]

This lady 'Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her) is asked by people: What are the morals of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) with his wives? How did the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) deal with his household? And what was he doing in his house with you? She replied, may Allah be pleased with her, with a brief and eloquent description: ((The Messenger of Allah, may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him, was the softest of people and the most generous of people, he was one of your men, but he was a poisonous laugher[2], he was a human being who undressed his robe, milked his sheep, and served himself[3], he used to sew his dress, and blow his soles, and he used to do what men do in their homes[4], he used to be in the profession of his family - meaning: Serving his family - if he attends the prayer, he goes out to pray))[5]

[@jamesjumah1171]

Alhamdulillah, !!!

[@ebrahimi44]

What does poisonous laugher mean?

[@zakirnaikahmaddeedat3651]

Allaahumma Baarik

[@PNess-bv7jb]

Samiman... you obviously take great joy in the peadophilia involving Prophet Mohammad and this presenter of this video justifying peadophilia. You obviously have not read carefully the Quran and Islamic authentic Hadiths to see other sickening disturbing and dangerous stuff in Islam. If you are justifying peadophilia then you need investigating by the authorities.

[@xdaydreamerx]

Mohammed groomed her and made her believe what he wanted. She was 6 years old when she lived with him what do you expect she would say about him hes like her father at that point. Its abusive.

[@sistersembellishments949]

Asalam Alakum Waramotullahi Wabaraktu Thanks so much for sharing knowledge and insights with us.People who critise and condemn the practices of our beloved Prophet Muhammed SAW are hypocrites and engage in double standard! The more they Cherry pick from Quran and Sunnah the more Islam is becoming the fastest growing religion globally most especially in the West. May SWT increase our Eeman and make Islam easy for reverts , people born into Islam and humanity to seek for knowledge in our beautiful Deen Ameen Ya Rabb. May Allah SWT bless you and others propagating our beautiful Deen Islam positively in this world and Hereafter Ameen Ya Rabb. Jazakallahu Khairan.

[@PNess-bv7jb]

Are you mentally sick? Are you implying that you justifying peadophilia and the r*pe of the little child by the 'Best of mankind'.

[@zamboe]

they always repeating the same question. 😬😬 Why they really like comparing ppl who lived 1400 years ago with ppl now.

[@EB-gt1pq]

At least he was respectful about it

[@kusali11]

Then Islam is not timeless. It was a perfect desert religion where tribes constantly were at war.

[@md.shahadathossain8880]

​@@kusali11islam is adaptable in the right way

[@kusali11]

@@md.shahadathossain8880 how so?

[@editname7931]

@@kusali11watch the video. He’s clearly mentioned criteria not numbers. Starting to show that you clicked on the video and went straight to the comments

[@figdetwithme7577]

Mashallah keep it up brother amaizing

[@caseycasey6961]

This is the best and honest questions and answers I ever learned regarding this issue, Thank you brother Muhammad Ali, for clarifying with great intellectual

[@afsinbey1161]

this was the best answer i have ever received, have heard a lot of sheikhs but tbh this is the best, we dont have to justify anything.

[@muhammadamirhamzah6477]

I like the manner of this discussion. Both sides are such gentlemen

[@A.P.A.F321]

The explanation is very smooth

[@adamfitbellaadam4790]

Al Hamdullilah for Islam

[@realnightowl908]

For me, this is the most understandable, informative explanation on this question non-Muslims usually try to ask. May Almighty Allah bless you my brother.❤

[@MuatasimMimi]

Everyone should share this episode

[@simasoumi5551]

In the 17th. Century girls in Britain were married at the age of 11 :)...but it only becomes a problem when it concerns muslims. Even worse in fact the youngest parents nowadays are from the UK, and the girl I think is only 9 ....so hold ur horses On another note, Allah ordered His prophet pbuh to marry Aisha rahia Allah aanha

[@lawunmibalogun2971]

All I’m hearing is a fight for the right to engage in sexual acts with minors because others have

[@walisaib443]

May allah soubhanahou wa ta'ala reward you brother

[@Assyaroni]

Aameen Allaahumma aameen

[@Lipurshan]

The man who asked is polite so we appreciated that. It's so rare to behave like that.

[@diahnurhayati7306]

Wellsaid.. May Allah open heart of many who watch this video 🤲🏻 and give hidayah to accept Islam

[@mim.luqman]

OMG🤯 the best answer I have ever gone through. Thank you brother.

[@Ivan.A.Churlyuski]

He just said Muslims don’t think having sex with a nine-year-old girl is wrong….

[@user78554]

YEP THIS DUDE IS CRAZY HE SHOULD BE PUT ON A WATCH LIST

[@amooshukroh8297]

Am sure you are deaf

[@hasibkhan2299]

Did u hear the term "Presentism "

[@nicebleachgamer1214]

bro did not watch the video

[@TheGoatOfMMA]

it's like dehumanising our ancestors because of western liberal laws and morals that don't make sense. You guy's are willing to do this for going against islam it's hilarious 🤧 In old times people were short lived and have responsibilities from short age, marrying and living their life, but now we study and so on society changed, we have no household responsibility and a society where you take responsibility of your life early on and create your house. Marriage is not one of our early priorities now it's study and job which in old time was almost non existent. Our ancestors lives hard life they mature according to their society structure.

[@rachidaboukarrou5783]

13 years old that time is like 25 years old They were more mature and responsible they fellowed the Quran 100%

[@KhalidJj]

ماشاءالله تبارك الله.. إن من البيان لسحرا.. الله يفتح عليك

[@Ramez_0]

Salam alaykum brother, will you be streaming today? ❤

[@sunset2.00]

Turn the Chanel notification on

[@alih1214]

I am always amazed at the question of Aisha, may Allah be pleased with her and make her contented !!!! Firstly, she did not complain to them or others, and she was not harmed. Secondly, if the opponent is a christian, I challenge him to bring any clear verse from his scriptures that forbid this, they have Isaac, who is forty years old, married Rebecca, who is three years old. Thirdly, if the opponent is an atheist, then this is a great contradiction. Atheism considers man an animal, and animals mate as soon as they reach puberty. So the matter is not related to the age of marriage or logic, but rather to the hatred of these people against Islam and Muslims.

[@Ibrahim-de1gj]

Jazak'Allah kher