Another Analysis of Scraptrap's Design (and a new redesign) [Part 2]

After my video "A Deep Dive Into Scraptrap's Design (and how i'd redesign him)" blew up way beyond my expectations, I've felt very negatively toward the quality of said video, and the Scraptrap redesign contained within it. Today I fix that, and present something I'm far happier with.
If you're new and want some context on the first video (this somewhat serves as a part 2) then here's a link. I don't recommend it, but you do you: • A Deep Dive into Scrap...
Hi-Res Image of the new Scraptrap Redesign: drive.google.com/file/d/1MMST...
Artist Credits:
Thudner: www.deviantart.com/thudner
EndyArts: www.deviantart.com/endyarts
Martin Walls’ Scraptrap Proportions Edit: t.co/7ibNoblUr6
Enderziom2004: www.deviantart.com/enderziom2004
Gustavo785690: / gustavo785690
Akatsuki Arashi: / __yhl0214_fnaf
DragonessAnimations: / dragonessanim
Playcenter: / playcentermd
CoolioArt: / coolio_art
CharltonN2: / charltonn2
Dasabucket (Anawizachu585): / dasabucket
SoaresSkeleton93 (accidentally credited as In the Glitch): / soaresskl93
Promythical2021: / promythical2021
Masterful: / frostbitekye
springboi-snek: / springboi-snek
Exotic_Tangerine0: / exotic_tangerine0
manue1234556: www.deviantart.com/manue1234556
NerdMaedel: / nerdmaedel
SuperMarioJustin4: www.deviantart.com/supermario...
BAYG: / therbayg

[@theooftroop]

Thoughts on Burntrap (SB Spoilers): kzbin.info/www/bejne/d17bqJRqoN2Fg8k Extra Notes: -The point about the Withered animatronics is confusing people. The newspaper at the end of FNaF 2 states the Withered animatronics will be repurposed for a new location, which becomes becomes FNaF 1 restaurant. They are canonically the same animatronics as the classics while having nothing in common. Suit design and endoskeletons are completely different but they're still the same. -Links to all the artists whose fanart is used in the video is in the description, as well as a link to a Google drive that has a hi-res png of the new Scraptrap redesign. -I am not taking redesign requests.

[@69replieslol]

Thank you for existing you need way more subscribers

[@SoftwareNeos]

Nice

[@joechristo2]

it’s too tall

[@matthewmatthew981]

How did this video just pop into existence out of nowhere?

[@matthewmatthew981]

Your original design wasn't that bad it's just that you neglected to give us an idea of what it looks like in 3D space, and it seemed to lack enough of the animatronic springlock internals that would be required to allow him to stand up.

[@fnaf2isthegoat75]

The redesigned series "always comes back"

[@insertenombreramdom1150]

Lol

[@sentientsausage684]

I agree with your comment, name, and profile picture.

[@baconytofficial6069]

haha i see what you did there

[@fnaf2isthegoat75]

@@sentientsausage684 thank you

[@fnaf2isthegoat75]

@@baconytofficial6069 yeah

[@flumpee4059]

“I don’t think someone calling a bunny rabbit stupid is what he would lose sleep over, and with that said, he looks stupid.” That had me dying. (In a laughing way)

[@dream_walker9726]

*bro same*

[@mokra1602]

Not me (in a cool way)

[@ttracs]

“I don’t think someone calling a bunny rabbit stupid is what he would lose sleep over, and with that said, he looks stupid.” That has me dying. (Scott cawthon snuck into my house and snapped my neck)

[@jordanwarner1352]

@@mokra1602 based

[@schnoig_]

@@mokra1602 so cool...

[@papaparsley7695]

Personally i really love the bulky design of springtrap as it makes him have a much more imposing silhouette, it gives off a very dangerous vibe while scraptrap feels more eerie and creepy

[@Duckbusinessman]

Scrap trap feels like you could have a one on one fight. But old spring trap feels like he could tower over you without breaking a sweat as he glares expressionless at your soon to be corpse

[@cursed3546]

@@Duckbusinessman Springtrap's bulky body gives off a vibe of a strong, but relatively slow moving opponent. Scraptrap's thinner, eerie body type gives a more agile and quick feel to it, having sacrificed Springtraps strength for being able to move quicker than expected

[@connorstamps1298]

SpringTraps built like a truck, compared to ScrapTraps motorcycle esc build

[@ElectriKMadnezz]

@@Duckbusinessman Springtrap: Monster Scraptrap: Jimmy Neutron

[@anxietyprimev6983]

Personally, my ideal Scraptrap design would just go 100% into the "plausible demonstration of what it would look like if an adult human male was crushed and mangled inside of an anthropomorphic rabbit animatronic" direction. The FNAF3 security tapes say that the springlock suits work by compressing the internal mechanisms of the animatronics against the insides of the suit, and when the springs fail then the internals just shoot back to their original places super hard, so I'm thinking the entire character would look so much more freaky if Afton actually looked like an extremely gory workplace accident come to life. I'm talking blood _everywhere,_ pallid, half-decomposed flesh pierced with copious amounts of metal, metal rods where bones are supposed to be, angry human eyes peering through the mask's eye sockets, all that jazz. Granted, FNAF is more or less a kid's game, so Scott would obviously never go this hard on the gore, but if he did? Aside from the obvious shock value, I bet there'd be a very strong element of raw psychological terror in that you're looking at a man who has suffered a _terrible_ fate and should by all accounts be stone cold dead, except he just keeps walking, fueled by nothing but _sheer, burning hatred._ _That's_ horror. I really like your redesign, it already looks pretty damn scary if you ask me, but in my opinion absolutely nothing can beat what I've dreamed up.

[@ultmateragnarok8376]

I've always had this sort of design mentality, either I go hyperrealistic and all logic thought out or it makes me disappointed when I look back at it. FNaF 3 had that element of psychological horror you mention (one of my favorite types to try in games), since it was just this strange thing to see - not only was he, in those badly lit and grainy images, seemingly a quite accurate shattered corpse intertwined with a robotic mechanism twisted out of shape, but also he seemed to have been partly flayed and a sort of amalgamation of parts. However, you couldn't tell who was in control - was the animatronic doing what it might've been built to do, approaching you for reasons perhaps sinister and perhaps only unintentionally dangerous? Or was the man inside still somehow piloting it, trying to reach you for some reason, whether to plead for help or to do to you what was done to him? While it's not my favorite of the games, Springtrap was really unique and an extremely effective design and horror element at the time.

[@anxietyprimev6983]

@@ultmateragnarok8376 Oh hell yeah, exactly. I mean, I might've only been about 10 when FNAF3 came out, but Springtrap's design was still complete nightmare fuel, especially since I hadn't really seen that much gore before then. Even now, an entire 7 years later, I can still look back on those loading screens and know exactly what was so damn scary about them. Granted, I have to get past the surface level narm first now that I'm significantly older and I've seen all the low effort jumpscare horror I could ever want, but if you really think about it and put yourself in your size 5 elementary schooler shoes then you can let your mind fill in all the gaps like it did back when you first saw the pictures, and then it's just terrifying in general. I can't imagine a skull full of giant lightbulbs would be all that pleasant no matter how old you are.

[@RPGTKingpin]

I'm glad someone else agrees with that perspective. The way I picture it, Springtrap should have been a hellish amalgam of flesh, metal and fabric. Picture it like this: The tattered suit is wrapped around a mesh-like endoskeleton that looks like the shutter doors on old fashioned elevators, serving as reinforcement for the slimmer-than-average endoskeleton that would be needed to accommodate a human being in the suit at the same time. Tattered muscle and skin hang off the collapsible edges of the endoskeleton, demonstrating that he was literally shredded and perforated all the way down to the bone when the springlocks went off, demonstrating just how terrible a fate it was. The ribcage is shattered and splintered, punching out of the chest cavity as a result of the endoskeleton being launched forward from the suit's spine when the springlocks went off. The result is a jagged maw of splintered bone that looks like the mouth of a viperfish, with the withered remains of what may have been vital organs hanging off of some of them. It basically serves as the ultimate juxtaposition of the whole "you'll get stuffed into a suit" threat of FNaF 1. The limbs have all been badly shattered and splintered, with shards that used t o be his legs sticking out at impossible angles, jamming the normal range of motion for the animatronic and forcing an awkward, rocking gait. The eyes would be bloodshot but glowing as they did in FNaF 3's version; a side effect of possession rather than any kind of animatronic. The rods that shot up through his lower and upper jaws went up into his braincase. Could even add in an extra tidbit and say that somewhere along the way the rods hit whatever controls human empathy, so now even if there was once some form of empathy or remorse in Afton in life, it's long gone now. For Scraptrap, weather the suit further, char it in places, remove a leg and arm. The leg has been fully replaced from the knee down with a normal animatronic leg, tied in place with steel cables and the suit that once covered it on its previous owner. The arm couldn't be replaced with something functional, so instead, Afton tied a shard of sheet metal off an A/C unit to his upper arm with steel cable.

[@Puddor]

This is precisely why Springtrap is my favourite character. In FNAF 2 there’s an element of plausible deniability- faulty programming- but FNAF3? There’s a literal, walking corpse coming after you, burning with hate, and perhaps the desire to continue his child-killing spree (following BB’s voice).

[@doomcat4465]

@@Puddor William isn't consciously following the noise. The SpringBonnie programming is still intact, which "for ease of function turn and walk toward sound they hear." When Springtrap hears it, the friendly mascot wants to entertain the child, but William knows it's a trick. That's why sometimes he ignores it (he can do that!) William manages to control the suit and continue making his way to you.

[@TheKingMgee]

Even the original Afton model looks so good in the Salvage section. Imagine if he had no eyes, like it appears in Salvage, and he has to navigate by audio with his bone ears. Just the tapping of the bone/knife/arm/thing as he comes towards you sounds really eerie.

[@Mike14264]

Oh that's actually a cool idea.

[@Mike14264]

Say, could you help me with a little thing? Working up some concepts I came up with.

[@TheKingMgee]

@@Mike14264 Uh i guess yeah

[@Mike14264]

@@TheKingMgee ok so, I had this idea for one a these Fnaf fan games. I probably won't use it, but it was something that popped into my mind. Similar to Popgoes, the animatronics are all critters from my country. As for the office, it has a big front window with electric blinds (a-la Candy's 1), a vent on the left with internal shutters and a door with a broken lock on the right. The idea is that, if a robot is on the hallways outside your door, you can shine them away. Problem is, they're kinda quick, and you have to shine your light at the doorway before peeking to make sure they ain't too close. If they are, well, you can't lock the doo, so just close it, hold it shut, and pray that they stop banging on it and go away. Which they do, but the door can only take so much of a pounding before giving way. I'm thinking that you can also shine away the ones that get too close into the office by the vent, but maybe that'll just push them back enough to give you time to shut the vent grate right on their face.

[@Mike14264]

@@TheKingMgee as for the bots, we have the ones that tackle the left and right, the main one might get already active on night 2 and be more of a mixed bag of mechanics, a jack of most trades, to make it feel like he learns from the others and make him feel more dangerous... One, in retrospective, might be a little too similar to Blank from Candy's 1, but the thing is, it'd play more like Death Horse from Animator's Hell. Once it exits the closet right in front of your hallway window, it has its eyes set on you, and it will keep on pounding the window, even if you shut the blinds, which are only inside. So you have to flash the light and then close the blinds to make it work. And the blinds take power, so you can't just keep them shut forever. The two robots from the side stage would come from the same side, though they can take a detour through the Lounge Room to cover more ground. Since they're on the same stage, they're connected to each other, and that would play on their mechanic: one would be sensitive to sound only (which you can distract it with by turning on the TV in the Lounge Room from the control remote), and the other would be sensitive to light only. Problem is, that's random each night.

[@alexanderparker2219]

you mentioning the fourth closet and how William surgically removed himself from the spring locks reminded me of something I always found weird which was how in the twisted ones William gave this big speech about how spring trap was who he was now and then just decided "nah I'll just go back to being human again" almost like a teenager going through a phase

[@PyreOManiac]

"This is who I am now." *"Hmm this kinda sucks now that I think about it."*

[@Mike14264]

Yeah, I too thought that.

[@Skibbutz]

In the fourth closet william basically admits his "springtrap phase" was basically him going on a power trip

[@Griftyfox]

Anyone also notice how they kept having Charlie mention how she'd been doing squats for no reason just so she could make a dumb joke while fighting Springtrap?? Like it just felt so out of place lol

[@cappedminer369]

@@Griftyfox i think you mean sit ups

[@assembledremnant]

With Scraptrap’s bottom teeth, I always imagined them being sharp because maybe in fact they arent teeth, maybe nails or screws holding what would be teeth onto the bottom jaw itself. Just a small idea ive had for years lol

[@captainkhalprojects1528]

It could maybe a springlock parts

[@elibecton3558]

I always thought that he never really changed suits because come on, where the helll would he find another spring Bonnie suit just “lying around”. I honestly think Scott went for beat up design and didn’t really have enough time to fine-tune it. Also another theory of mine is it his top teeth are actually the same from the old suit except he just pulled all the other ones out just to have two buck teeth

[@Vicioussnakeboy]

​@@elibecton3558For a while I though that he'd only replaced the Springbonnie's head, not the whole body, until I googled springtrap without the suit and realised Springbonnie's endo is much thiccer than Jimmy Neutrontrap's whole body is

[@ericgolightly8450]

​@@elibecton3558The animatronic parts were shipped to Fazbear Frights. In cutscenes, we can see several different Spring Bonnie costumes. It's possible he found a burnt/torn Spring Bonnie suit at the FNaF 3 location that he used to replace the old one.

[@Silv3rPhantom]

While I still enjoy Springtrap's design over Scraptrap's (a dont fix it if it ain't broke mentality), I seriously appreciate your take on it! It makes me not hate the character and you have truly fixed the worst parts, while still preserving the essence of the design.

[@theooftroop]

thank you!

[@sarcasticstudios7798]

As someone who models in blender I (think) I know why his rips are so blocky. Scott probably made the holes in the mesh by deleting faces, then to try and smooth out the holes, just hit the subdivision surface modifier. If this is done incorrectly, however, all the holes will remain blocky (dunno how he didn’t notice tho, or perhaps he thought no one would notice). Anyways, Ty for coming to my TedTalk.

[@themaskedtalker2171]

3d animation student here... this ain't just a blender problem. I work with Autodesk Maya, and results like this can also be achieved there too; extruding by FACE rather than VERTECES, and using the smoothing will still result in this. I reckon it could be due to the design being completely rushed. Then again, we known damn well how voracious the appetites of the fandom are. I personally am better with robotics and animals more than humans, but even I'm aware of proportions. Then again, humans isn't Scott's strong point as a modeler, and that's perfectly fine. Hell; even with the original Springtrap, he found an excellent way to get the design to work... is it odd that in the original one the head looks more anatomically correct???

[@bmprimer7809]

you people are speaking a completely different language

[@sarcasticstudios7798]

@@themaskedtalker2171 yeah, I’m just more used to blender, lol and I think that’s what Scott used. It is odd how the original was more correct, but I can’t blame him. I suck at human modeling too.

[@adventurekitty1016]

@@bmprimer7809 I would translate but I overcomplicate things when explaining.

[@theoriginalstarwalker4357]

"No one will notice" "Everyone noticed" - random Undertale animation

[@toxicscope511]

Of all the redesigns I think the "skeleton ribs still intact" is my favorite "trend", it makes so much sense having the bones (aka the last thing that withers in your body) still inside of the animatronic possibly even holding his spirit. If someone is reading this and is thinking on doing a redesign yourself, keep the bone structure please.

[@christosdoesthings]

I defineatly agree, I think it looks awesome, that's why I also kept them when redesigning him.

[@Breakaway-ic5gj]

I am replying so that more people see this

[@toxicscope511]

@@Breakaway-ic5gj is that how this works?

[@flamepelt3092]

@@toxicscope511 likes and comments boost comments, sadly not just likes as it should honestly be although I have no clue if I'm right or wrong with what I just said

[@camel662]

@@toxicscope511 Spot on, scot also stated in the past the another main reason for the redesign was for pretty much Lore puposes, he wanted to make it look more like an ACTUAL human being stuck inside it, actual bones more flesh that actaully looks like muscles, not just strings. for me they both look scary but the redesign without the suit is terrifying lol, it even has ORGANs lol

[@Horneroid]

My biggest problem with Scraptrap is that it feels like Scott was trying why too hard to make him creepy and twisted. The original design was already creepy, he didn’t need a redesign.

[@EuclidEndless5]

Personally I think my favorite theory of how he changed suits was a video that came out recently where as springtrap, he basically just forced out his flesh and endoskeleton as some kind of amorphous blob and reintegrated into the suit shapeshifter style- doesn't quite make as much sense but as far as fantastical, cool looking things that are paranormal as hell, it's definitely more interesting; either that or what he did in the fourth closet where he just surgically removed himself and instead of staying out of it he put something else on (most likely due to a lack of places to return to)

[@theooftroop]

I saw that video, it was so freakin cool. Definitely not how I imagine it happening but it's such a unique and unsettling take on it that I love it

[@EuclidEndless5]

@@theooftroop definitely!

[@voltronimusprime3833]

Which video was that?

[@DisasterEnby]

Never seen that video, but I've been using a pretty similar idea - Afton somehow got out of the old Springtrap suit because it'd rotted too heavily to pass to begin with, and then there'd be the signs of the aftermath of the Fazbear Frights fire. Admittedly the suit he's then changing into is rottes to hell as well, but it's at least _passable._ Also taking the ridiculous scraptrap skull as the old Springtrap head essentially being flattened against Afton's head by the new one. This also exains the tiny ears - they're the old Springtrap ears, awkwardly merged with the new suit.

[@thedarkdevil1661]

In terms of scraptrap's missing arm... Instead of it just being a bone sticking out, I thought that he lost his arm, found a metal rod and just placed it in to use as a weapon. Horror villains have done this before I.E Chucky in the final battle of child's play 2.

[@savvythedivineyethuggable7493]

And Spirit in DBD.

[@yese2769]

I think the point sticking out is just his arm is the bone snapped

[@enderlord69]

He sharpened the bone to use as a knife so he does kinda do what ur talking about

[@sev1120]

@@savvythedivineyethuggable7493 the spirit doesn't really fit this, and she's an Onryo (a vengeful spirit in japanese mythology) She is assuming a relatively human form, with her body held together by nothing more than rage and stubbornness. Plus, her weapon's an actual katana, as opposed to the hammers used by Leatherface or the Hillbilly, where they're tools that they use as weapons

[@savvythedivineyethuggable7493]

@@sev1120 I don't really know why you brought Letherface and Hillbilly into this. But, my point is that Spirit's katana is located in her arm when not in use.

[@moxienerd4714]

Ooftroop really said “this murder bunny is getting a glow up and theres nothing he can do about it”

[@75JUNAKI]

I mean it’s Oof Trap are you surprised?

[@PyroNick01]

@@75JUNAKI ooftroop*

[@mcsash6965]

To the person reading this comment You are awesome & hope you are having a great day My dream is to hit 1k I hope you can help me accomplish my dreams..

[@altkingofdogs2373]

@@mcsash6965 bot

[@ok-ji2zn]

@@mcsash6965 ratio

[@bunsenn5064]

I think Scraptrap should’ve just been a burnt/charred version of Springtrap, with the same obscurity of the corpse inside. Part of the mystique about the original Springtrap is that you could see bits of flesh, but you couldn’t see who was actually in there. I like the idea of a design that obscures his corpse, with his creepy, human gaze being the only thing you see through the suit.

[@teclinsoro4523]

he just looks goofy. it’s honestly impressive that scott somehow managed to make a withering rabbit animatronic that literally has a dead man’s bloodied skull sticking out, comical.

[@Tabth3778]

My biggest issues with Scraptrap's design: - his eyes - his weird blocky patches that make him look like he was designed in minecraft - his jimmy neutron forehead - his extremely weird corpse -his weird lower teeth - his tiny ears But other than that I love Scraptrap lol, and I think the reason his suit looks so much different, other than Scott just having a different approach with the design, is because he's probably able to replace some parts of the suit, but he's not able to just completely take himself out of the old one (Also why did Dark Springtrap get more merch than Scraptrap?)

[@BonnieTheBunny20]

His forehead is realistic

[@angrybirdsfan9826]

@@BonnieTheBunny20 this is FNaF there is no realism

[@somethingwithbungalows]

@@BonnieTheBunny20 there’s time traveling ballpits dude

[@KennyLastname]

The forehead is actually normal sized

[@somethingwithbungalows]

@@KennyLastname oh hello!

[@themagicalaxolotl2258]

I like how the redesign makes the suit more like a mascot costume with wiring and metal support and less of another animatronic because I always found it odd that Afton went from one animatronic suit to another. I don't think a guy who was stuck rotting in a old rusty machine for several years would willingly decide to put himself in another, slightly different one

[@elijahsmall5873]

What if his old one was ruined by oh, I don't know, A FIRE?

[@themagicalaxolotl2258]

@@elijahsmall5873 I mean, if that's the reason, then like.. sure I guess? Its still entirely unnecessary

[@elijahsmall5873]

@@themagicalaxolotl2258 ok

[@Mr_Heron]

@@themagicalaxolotl2258i mean, would you rather have your organs and guts exposed in a burnt, wrecked suit, or find a new one?

[@themagicalaxolotl2258]

@@Mr_Heron I'd rather him just be dead after 3 actually idk why they brought him back at all

[@werewolfpoison]

I think the problem I have with Scraptrap is that he's too cartoony and kinda.. clay/doughy looking to me? He doesn't look withered and broken but more molded by playdough xD I was excited for him coming back as he is my fave character then I looked at Scraptrap and my inner designer started screaming loudly. I love your redesign!!! I think if yours was the design we got I would've loved him a lot more

[@geraldgreg5370]

Honestly SpringTrap is probably my favorite character and design from the series, it's very scary and makes what would be the worst jump scare in the series actually scary and pretty cool due to how great the design was. And when I first played Pizzeria Simulator, I thought that ScrapTrap looked great because the only times I saw him was the art of him out in the street and how intimidating and spooky he looked when cloaked in shadow when you were adopting him into your pizzeria; But after watching your video and seeing in indepth look at his design, I was so disappointed that they took one of my favorite designs and characters in the whole series and turned him into a Muppet, or a human you'd find in an old early 2000s animated short. I already liked your design in the original video, and this new one improved on an already great design.

[@arxidiax2arxidiax276]

There’s a fan game called FNAF 6: Freakshow that has a REALLY awesome re-design of Scrappy, I think you’ll like it!

[@theooftroop]

said this in another comment, I haven't seen too much of that fangame but I wasn't too captivated by the scraptrap design in it. I haven't looked too much into it though so I could very well change my mind seeing it more

[@christosdoesthings]

@@theooftroop it looks kinda goofy, he has some gigantic teeth.

[@Fvdp00]

Ok, but can we just appreciate how good he is at drawing.

[@theooftroop]

thank you!

[@StephenDurnan]

@@theooftroop also that thumbnail is just a masterpiece. Good job to whoever made it. It's so good. We need a full image of it

[@theooftroop]

@@StephenDurnan I made it, thank you!

[@StephenDurnan]

@@theooftroop no problem, it's a cool thumbnail and a spectacular scraptrap

[@elijahsmall5873]

Ikr

[@dexterity494]

One thing I really like about the redesign is the curling of the metal around his legs. This makes it seem like vines, which almost always has meaning relating to corruption or extreme age... Both of which William afton has.

[@tuc-kaankaraayan]

My man... This version feels like if I were to see it the first time in Pizzaria Simulator I would actually go "Let's gOOOOOOO!!!!!" because it fixes the issues, logic and inconsistencies very well. Well done.

[@christosdoesthings]

1:26 I agree, I feel like Scott designed the character with that lighting and room in mind and based it around it.

[@drawingdragon]

"I don't think Scott will lose sleep over me saying 'this rabbit man looks stupid.'" "That being said," *"This rabbit man looks stupid."* Also, "My man's got ankle guts." Lol

[@Blue-fj6js]

“His skull looks like the blender monkey”

[@Xiborg1]

As someone who has ankle guts, I confirm this is truly one of the design elements of all time.

[@xmsjd]

I feel like there was a sort of style shift between FNAF 4 and Sister Location. The first 4 games seemed to go for a more grittier (whether that’s intentional can be argued) look with more rough looking textures for things like the fur of the suits or the bumpy look you can kinda see on them, as opposed to the more, sleeker(?) look of the following games with characters more commonly being made with a plastic, metallic polymer look in mind. Now that’s not to say that it’s not just a redesign, could very well just be a redesign, no one in actuality knows except Scott himself. But I feel like just putting that base Springtrap model we see in Fnaf 3, tweaking it a bit to add more damage, discolouration, etc, etc, it just wouldn’t fit amongst the other characters. It’s like putting two different art styles next to one another and trying to pass them both off as the same. Obviously, having to completely (again, it’s arguable as to whether it’s COMPLETELY but that’s neither here nor there) redesign a model of a character you’ve already created in one general tonal theme into a new one you’re working with, there will quite clearly be things that you will struggle with in keeping continuity. Scott very well could of tweaked the original model, built off of it, but I think that with this new tonal theme, he wanted to start from scratch to make it fit pretty solidly amongst the others he designed that way, and he didn’t exactly hit the spot.

[@ic0nic707]

What I’m about to do is extremely cringe .. _UNDERRATED COMMENT_

[@catmario-_3170]

I still think it would have been best if he did reuse Springtrap's FNAF 3 model but tweak. I don't think anyone would have complained

[@SPACEVZN]

Can we talk about how your art has improved? Major props coming back and making use of your audience's feedback so directly, and for dedicating time to this!

[@original2598]

Let's all just hope that Williams return in Security Breach is better than Scraptrap. From the purple hand its looking good!

[@original2598]

@Mr.SuperSpringtrapFriends idk I personally like Springbonnie and Fredbear

[@deletedbyuser103]

I have bad news :( Soo there is a new trailer for security breach and apparently Afton is now a spider Music Man :(

[@deletedbyuser103]

@Mr.SuperSpringtrapFriends DUDE DO YOU NOT KNOW WHAT “APPARENTLY” MEANS?! ITS NOT CONFIRMED!? GEEZ!

[@original2598]

@@deletedbyuser103 BRO YOU GOT ME DEAD 😂🤣

[@deletedbyuser103]

@Mr.SuperSpringtrapFriends Oh ok

[@furvurt]

Lets be honest its not scotts reason scraptraps design "sucks" Its just william and his huge forehead (no i do not hate him hes my favorite animatronic)

[@deviljinxe198]

lmao

[@backerson5576]

he is just big braining guys

[@KennyLastname]

Fr thought we were done with the forehead jokes 💀

[@shabillalma4907]

The forehead is normal sized The mask is seemingly the issue

[@furvurt]

@@KennyLastname he still has a peanut forhead

[@davidkonevky7372]

I love how your redesign looks more like a human in a torn suit rather than an animatronic with a body inside. It emphasizes that this was not the same suit as from fnaf 3 and that he is freed from the programming of the original suit

[@KindredKeepsake]

I love this re-re design! It looks even better than the first one! I never thought about William escaping the original Springtrap suit before, but it makes a TON of sense--given how different both the Springtrap and Scraptrap suits are. Despite these differences, both have corpse parts in them, and are voiced by the same voice actor. Because of this, I am even more spooked. On top of being cursed with immortality and durability, now he's even more like a zombie--one that can apparently take himself apart and migrate to different animatronic suits as much as he wants. This guy won't die now matter HOW many fires it takes!

[@rabi6562]

honestly, for an artist with a love for character design who does a LOT of them, seeing a fellow artist redesigning their original design because they didnt like it over time is so relatable LGHFJDFHGJD thank you for this!! we need more indecided artists representation edit: forgot to add: it looks absolutely amazing! your take looks so original and cool

[@starcross-studios]

Still waiting for the Morshu redesign

[@minecraftboy2465]

As Ooftroop always says: “you can’t fix perfection”

[@DimentiosLoyalest]

1:12 I had to pause for a minute to laugh at this bit. Some brilliant commentary and delivery there.

[@monkeofwisdom9990]

Your redesign looks really cool! I especially like that the sharpening of the arm bone makes him look more intimidating and he could possibly use it as a weapon

[@minecraftboy2465]

He’s at it again. Brace yourselves for perfection

[@MrHam-od4dd]

I personally think that the reason Scraptrap canonically looks this way is just because Scott tried something different and it failed, it makes more sense to me that it's the same suit than that William got out of one and then purposely got springlocked in another.

[@undertalemodtool]

1:00 I Like how it Drops as soon as the whole pitchforks part happens

[@BlockieStudios]

My personal explanation for the whole inconsistency between FNAF 2 Withered and FNAF 1 animatronics is that the "repurposed for a new location thing" just means that they were scrapped for parts and rebuilt with new endos and shells that used parts from the old ones. That way the spirits hang onto the parts but the design change isn't totally mindboggling

[@insmashbaby4347]

Your redesign of your redesign is super well done. I love the mummified corpse idea, and the elongated bone-spear-arm. Also, don't feel pressured to continue the redesign series if you don't want to, I am sure there is still many ways for people to enjoy you as a creator than just redesigns. Like Springtrap goes to Wisconsin

[@NightBread]

“This funny rabbit man looks stupid” A phrase that will never leave my mind

[@hagenspringtrap9431]

There is something I want to try to set straight (atleast this is the way I understand it), Springtrap's insides the human endoskeleton, isn't just the little flesh tendrils and the head, more then likely canonically there is a full body there, it was just easier and frankly smart to only model the suit and the flesh that was visible

[@addzmad2729]

I absolutely love this redesign. It makes him look less stubby.

[@y0353]

I have a theory about Aftons design which is based on illusion discs. I think that's how Mike sees him. His memory twisted how he percieves his father, since when the disc is used, it creates the illusion that depends on how you remember and imagine the character. That's why Afton has the same little details but is somehow out of shape... If you know what I mean. Our memory and imagination does strange things...

[@ic0nic707]

If this was canon I think a lot of people would be more accepting of the design

[@twinzzlers]

@@ic0nic707 Not me, the books are stupid.

[@ic0nic707]

@@twinzzlers it’s only been 6 months and I’m so confused how I thought this lol

[@twinzzlers]

@@ic0nic707 Maybe you made it really late during the night? I don't know a single Fnaf fan that want the books to be in the main canon.

[@ic0nic707]

@@twinzzlers Honestly FNaF lore is kinda dead to me. *DSaF is superior*

[@fordearle6031]

i really loved the design you gave it both times, but this one is personally my favorite.

[@jasonian2339]

6:30, the reason the withered animatronics look different in the second from the first main 4 is because the second game is a prequel and their designs were changed after the second game to the first, because Fazbear Entertainment wanted them to look less ugly for the first game’s location

[@nadie887]

thank you for including the endoskeleton, Scraptrap somehow has almost none and that defies everything we know about how possession works, after all he IS his endoskeleton

[@raptorguy6464]

Dude, your Scraptrap redesigns look so good! Do you perhaps make any characters of your own? If not, I think you really should!

[@theooftroop]

I do! I don't talk about them on KZbin but I make a lot of my own characters for a personal project.

[@raptorguy6464]

@@theooftroop is it a project you planning on sharing in the future? I'm sorry if I don't know, I only seen your scraptrap videos so far

[@theooftroop]

@@raptorguy6464 I've shown some of the characters on my Twitter account but in general I don't plan on showing much of it since I want to flesh it out more and get something more official ready in the future

[@raptorguy6464]

@@theooftroop I see, well good luck on your project man! Excited to see where you'll take it!

[@ShinyCapArt]

Wow dude! I watched your other video and I liked the design already, but this one I love even more! It’s such an awesome improvement. You did an amazing job with both designs honestly! I love how it turned out- great job. I wish that I could see Scraptrap’s model/design in games look this good some day!

[@rokoisokay]

genuinely my favorite part of this video is seeing your art improve. better design choices, color palates and shading, anatomy, all of it. so cool to see your growth

[@ckc9913studios]

The only thing about Scraptrap that bothers me us the corpse. The proportion and blocky-ness are fine by me. He's "scrap" after all. (The blocks get to me a bit) That's just my opinion. I really like your Scraptrap idea tho.

[@Andy_TEL]

Oh my goodness I'm so excited for you to bless us with yet another round of facts and logic

[@gjota1371]

I hate the theory that "William escaped his suit". Not because it is bad, or without any proof, but because it shits on the thing that made springtrap himself scary. He was scary at First simply because he was a broken down and withered animatronic, but when you find out there is a rotten body inside him, he becomes a lot more creepy. And the whole thing about springtrap was the irony of it. William, trapped forever inside of the thing that he used to kill children, and the same thing that killed HIM. He has to "live" with the fact that he is well, "trapped" inside this suit. He can't simply move on, or get better. He is now just another monster, full with weird feelings, maybe regret, anger, or even, a feeling of fascination.

[@cremoso4247]

8:00 Man, with that arm he might as well compete in basketball instead of opening a pizzeria.

[@dragonheart3484]

He’s a part I found funny Just as an example nobody is ever been up in arms about springtraps corpse been atomically incorrect cos the design is Overall just works anyways. (my man has ankle guts) and nobody cares just as it should be. My man his ankle guts 😹😸😂🤣😆😁😄🤣😂🤣😂😆🤣😂😆🤣😂🤣😂😁😆😹😸😹😸😹😸🤔 And it’s so true he does have ankle guts and then makes it so much funnier

[@10.ikadekanandadwipayadnya83]

11:14 "Bet you weren't expecting another video on this guy again, huh?" "Well you know what they say, he always comes back"

[@MisterMoodyHere]

5:43 smart transition with the light flickering!! You really put a lot of effort into these videos, most of which goes under the radar. Yet, you still do it. Keep up the good work!

[@noahsepicgamingandstuff]

Ok personally I never liked the "suit swap" idea i personally like the "malformed suit" idea that the suit deforms after the fnaf 3 fire but this redesign and a few others I've seen do it very well Tl;dr I like this even though I don't like the "swapped suit" idea.

[@elibecton3558]

Finally someone who I can agree with, I also have the idea that he was still alive in Fnaf three as he never talked, but as in fnaf six he can finally talk because he is “possessing” the suit/ “given life”

[@noahsepicgamingandstuff]

@@elibecton3558 YES!!! How do we have the same ideas. (P.S the scraptrap possession thing is a idea that grew on me)

[@elibecton3558]

@@noahsepicgamingandstuff and People say “oh yeah he Didn’t look like that when Fasbear frights burned down” when they don’t realize he did live out in the streets for about three or so years.

[@noahsepicgamingandstuff]

@@elibecton3558 YES.

[@xx_london_xx7807]

I love this redesign! It sticks to it still being Scraptrap but also still retains some of Springtraps…look? Idk how to explain it. But overall you did a good job!

[@Sugardrop50]

The og video single handedly made me love scraptrap, so I'm super happy seeing another video on him

[@OnlyLinkCanDefeatGanon]

Just came from the other redesign videos! I know I'm a year late, but again, great job on the redesign! I didn't think your art could get any better, and then I saw this lovely corpse rabbit! Hope you're doing well Ooftroop!

[@Teethmafia]

It’s nice seeing this kind of thoughtful content.

[@MajoradeMayhem]

For me, it's strictly Even More Withered Springtrap or gtfo with those bone ears. However, I do like the concept of a Scraptrap with properly salvaged parts, like if his jaw was blue coloured and very obviously stolen from Bonnie, or he took a hook from Foxy. Maybe a Chica leg.

[@MajoradeMayhem]

Actually seeing the poster and colouring book images makes all the difference. Scraptrap looks WAY better in those drawings and it's more obvious what the artist was going for. They're much more believable as a repaired/damaged Springtrap - and no bone ear in sight!

[@Sharauni]

Much much more awesome design for Scraptrap, love it!

[@woodshunter1003]

all right that art is amazing and the detail is amazing

[@springharry1256]

You re-explaining things was a lot more improved than the original video and the new re-design was exactly what I wanted, and love. The old re-design had some problems that I didn’t like a lot but your new and improved version looks so good, I’m stuck wether I would want that to be the new official design or not, it’s so good! Great video

[@christosdoesthings]

I saw the redesign on reddit, it's great, although get ready for the "Redesign more characters1!1!1!!!1!! Redesign this character" comments.

[@theooftroop]

it'll never end I must accept it

[@christosdoesthings]

@@theooftroop oh yeah, now that you replied, *REDeSIgn Sp-Rknboinnhgie!!1!!!!11!!*

[@KnapfordProductions]

I love both of your redesigns I don't have a favourite one but you did an amazing job

[@firstcanonkill1767]

YES! I love your other scraptrap video I’m so happy to see you rehashing it again

[@theooftroop]

give the people what they want

[@auddragon2247]

Hey, love the new design! Man you have grown so much since the last video you made on scrap!! Also these edits are amazing!! Great job!! PS: Scrap trap really needed the love. He's defiantly is a character that is neglected.

[@mrsuit8210]

Always love your vids! Especially the redesigns!!

[@theoneandonly3646]

Honestly of trip you’re literally the best drawer I know for for now

[@swirlybugs7701]

LOVING THE IMPROVEMENT

[@austinkaos3682]

I really like the redesign! I've always thought scraptrap was an interesting look for the character with the potential to look even better than springtrap's design. I honesty think your redesign fixes most of the problems I had with the original scrooptroop. So good job!!! =3

[@someguywhodoesstuff7877]

For me, I don’t really mind the suit itself minus smoothening it a bit, I personally would just replace the majority of the bone with metal except the skull. I fell it doesn’t make sense for his suit to be held with rotting muscle and bone is ridiculous logically, springtrap’s anatomical inaccuracies being easily glossed over as its a mangled and warped corpse. I would make the head more of a skull as I’ve always thought that the red layer was his skinless muscle after the springlocks essentially flayed him, so making it closer to a skull makes more sense to me as the red parts on his head seem like the remnants of his burnt and rotted muscle, a broken skull likely being used as well since the endoskeleton likely had mechanical pieces to its head. I like your direction but the head is the only thing I’d change for the reasons I said above, you seem really good at this and hope you continue on with these skills

[@ultmateragnarok8376]

The concept of the springlock failure being violent enough to physically peel his skin from his head, most likely from the sections around the neck tearing the skin off and downwards, is an absolutely terrifying one. That would be unfathomably painful even compared to being full-body skewered with mechanical parts.

[@ic0nic707]

@@ultmateragnarok8376 *my god..*

[@blazeofficial3885]

Aw that's sad, I quite liked the redesign you did in part 1.

[@mistress.lilith5793]

This one’s really great! I love this one much mroe

[@LockytheLimeHare]

I realized since I started making models in Blender and such, that the blotchy stuff on Scraptrap looks like a WIP on the model. Like it was supposed to be smoothed out but the model didn't save it or something.. In fact, there's an exact tool I remember that works and looks like that when sculpting a model. Really weird how I realize stuff like that years later. I donno. But I really enjoyed both videos on your personal redesigns. The first really seemed(to me at least) like fanart of the existing design more than a redesign. The new one here looks great and definitely has more in common with the other scrapped characters. One thing that seemed off was how stringy the fur seemed, but that could've just been your sort of art style. Overall, I love your videos and watching them while I'm drawing or writing really helps me with working on character design!

[@feralhawg867]

I like the redesign, it looks great, awesome job! However, I'm of the opinion that he really needs more bulky, mechanical elements and more gory innards. The gory insides would make him look both scarier ("scarier" is subjective though of course) and reflect how gruesome his "death" was, and making him more mechanical and bulky gives him a (imo) more intimidating presence, and it's important to exemplify the fusion between blood and metal by making it look less like a costume. Though obviously that isn't faithful to Scraptrap at all, and is basically asking for the OG Springtrap again. You made a faithful remake of Scraptrap that fixes all of his problems, and it looks sick! His more lanky body would make him a great stealth-based enemy, almost like Freddy in FNaF 1 or FNaF 3 Springtrap. Come to think of it, he would be TERRYIFYING in the setting of FNaF 4. Again, good stuff.

[@Labeti]

alr the redesign is just- *muah* cheff kiss ❤

[@mosiden4656]

The blocky patches are supposed to be bacteria or a type of mold growing in the suit, but they aren’t this square

[@AndrewGarfield_]

Do you think that in the future you can get someone or fans to make a super hd redesign of your redesign in 3D render? That would be super neat to see! What if you made a series were you ask fans to redesign past characters and top comment would be the redesign reviewed that would be sweet!

[@dothvoir9909]

wayy far better than the first one( also a banger) but now, its HUGE AMAZING

[@oldmancorecentral]

a part 2? wow, this series always comes back

[@Andrew-li6ie]

Since there’s a body inside of springtrap you’d think there would be a cloud of flies Around him giving off his position every time he moves causing all the flies to buzz around

[@bravecylinder93]

The only thing that I think would make this version *perfect*, is for the body to have many more smaller, withered-away holes and openings in it, like Springtrap has in FNaF 3. That aspect would be kinda neat. Or atleast have it like that for an arm or leg, to show that Afton couldn’t exactly squeeze himself out of the original Spring-Bonnie suit. FNaF 3 Springtrap has much more withered/broken pieces to the suit than Pizzeria Simulator, but that’s to show that Afton could (mostly) replace his damaged parts. 9.7/10 for me, chief

[@cryptidx6088]

YES. now THIS is much better. the old one isnt bad, but this revision is awesome. the proportions are so much better

[@wheezlin]

suuuuper sick video. love how you improved on your original redesign (which i was already crazy for)-this one definitely takes the cake. massive ups for taking the time to think about the intricacies of his anatomy and exoskeleton support! it’s hard to put into words how solid this design is, and i wish this approach was taken to the character instead. i’ll totally be thinking about this extensively for the coming days, so great work!! (didn’t realize i hadn’t been subbed before so hoohoo new sub from me)

[@theooftroop]

thank you!

[@ok-ji2zn]

5:59 i think i have an explanation for this During that cutscene it’s Michael talking just after Ennard left his body. Springtrap is still in the spare room in the FNAF 1 location just before being found by the owners of Fazbear Fright :3

[@ic0nic707]

Well, I’m pretty sure we see a burnt and broken Fazbear’s fright sign in the cutscene..

[@GippyHappy]

If I were gonna redesign Scraptrap I think I'd take a really unpopular direction, but I'd want him to have almost no "suit" covering him, just bones and flesh and metal. Maybe his head could have a new mask mostly covering it, though. It'd give the same idea that Afton managed to get out of the Spring Bonnie suit (as best he could anyway), but just didn't want to or couldn't get a replacement. Tbh I don't really know what the benefit of putting on a new suit that's equally or more damaged as the last one is. I guess you could say it's a disguise but creepy bunny robot might actually stand out more than if he just put on some sunglasses and a trench coat. It's not like he's walking into a Wendy's or anything, probably just prowling around dumpsters and alleyways. Wait I think I just made the stitchwraith oops- Anyway, I know this would probably be over the top but if they avoided showing his full body and kept him obscured by shadow I think it'd look really cool and make him stand more from the actual animatronics. Though I may just be partial to gross/gory skeletons. I would draw a proof of concept but I'm lazy and I think if I put links in my comment KZbin will blast me into the sun. Oh good vid by the way and I love love love the new artwork/design, sorry I talk too much.

[@smiff862]

IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS

[@living5662]

I love this remodel of Scraptrap. I like how you kept some of the features from Springtrap in the suit.

[@mintychips22]

Your new redesign is amazing! But riddle me this: how did the endoskeleton get inside his bones? At this point the suit is wearing HIM, and that's terrifying.

[@k1ng_n0th1ng9]

I’m giving it a few days until someone makes a model of the new redesign

[@theooftroop]

there were already two being made before the video was done cus I posted the redesign on twitter early

[@elijahsmall5873]

I really this your updated redesign of him is really good. I love the details like the heart shaped rip in his chest and more accurate bone anatomy. I honestly love Scraptrap as a whole. Sure they may be a few problems with it, but I just kinda find some sort of appeal towards him. 🙂

[@pandorasangel2747]

Didnt realise you made an update, I just commented on the originally. I definitely think this is way better then your original redesign although I love both :)

[@ghosttrae]

Good redesign! Nothing to say, just good. Keep on doing these or else I’ll CRY.

[@theooftroop]

weep.