Theory of Jazz: Coltrane changes/Three Tonic System

[@Androslop]

Constructive criticism: The explanation would be better if we could hear the sound of the chords and melodies that are being displayed on the screen. Those who do not have any piano around, cannot imagine what all of this sounds like. You could also write the name of the chords and notes below the stave. Greetings from Catalonia.

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

Thanks for that. Noted

[@burtshort9900]

Androux Guitar that makes too much sense.

[@AEFic]

Yeah that was pretty frustrating

[@lennartjakobs1213]

Best analysis I've seen so far! Clear and concise information in a re-watchable format. Thanks a lot!

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

You're welcome Lennart Jakobs. Thanks for watching

[@thormusique]

This is so concisely and brilliantly laid out, cheers!

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

You're welcome

[@innocentoctave]

Excellent content. Presentation a little dry and monotonous. A few musical illustrations would have been welcome. Subscribed.

[@PeopleR2sensitive]

flight of the coltranes over here

[@jeffcrusan2102]

Very clearly explained -- not only for people who want to analyze music but for people who want to write it as well.

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

Thanks Jeff!

[@fingerstyleguitarjournal9593]

I'm very impressed by this and look forward to watching and studying more. Thanks so much for doing this.

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

You're welcome. Glad you found it useful. Thanks for the comment

[@7thson341]

AH I GET IT!! you want me to get off my ass and grab mah darn instrument so my music-ILITERATE ASS can figure out how those scales sounds!! no easy way outta this one. what principality! i like it!

[@robbes7rh]

Useful? Definitely. Powerfully illuminating and epiphanous? Big time! Key concepts in physics are explained by invariance and symmetries. Considering that the field of physics began with the investigation of pitch and harmony, it seems fitting that underlying structures in music can be understood and explained by these same very principles.

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

Yes, there has always been a relationship between music and other fields. Fascinating how it all ties in. Thanks for the comment

[@urzathehappy72]

Wow alot of great info packed into this video. Plz add the music next time tho since my sight reading is very basic

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

Thanks Roger [kirkbydudelol] Waters, yes my later videos have the music. Thanks for the comment

[@royercrafter]

This was a great explanation, not only do you explain what the theoretical framework of what the changes do, but you also give some useful examples to get your gears going! Thanks

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

You're welcome. Thanks for the comment

[@halasimov1362]

Thanks for the Big Step by Step!

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

You're welcome

[@unsatura]

can't wait to try it out ... thanks

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

You're welcome

[@rockingbuddah]

Great video!!

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

Thanks Ivan. Appreciate the comment

[@robertaguirre8632]

great stuff!

[@Kosmo999]

Comic sans!

[@robertaguirre8632]

but it is not an equal division of the Octave. It is composed of 2 Major 3rds and a Spetimal Major 3rd. But when the Augmented Triad completes the Octave it is actually using 2 Major 3rds and a Spetimal Major 3rd. A Major 3rd is 386c. 386+386+386 = 1158 And so 3 stacked Major 3rds is 42 cents short of the Octave. 42 cents is the Septimal Diesis. 386+386= 772 1200-772= 428 and 428 cents is the space of the Spetimal Major 3rd with a harmonic ratio of 9:7 *The Septimal Major 3rd is actually closer to 435cents. the reason that there is space between 435 and 428 is due to yet another diesis.

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

Thanks for this

[@wyc7tjmf794]

Robert Aguirre Well, I guess it is quite clear from the video that he talks about equal division of the octave in the context of 12-ET. An interesting point anyway though.

[@EllieMcEla]

well the simple ratios are irrelevant when discussing jazz theory where everything is based in 12ET. would be fun to hear this piece in just intonation though

[@gottliebfischer5720]

Coltrane was thinking more about Slonimski, search the thesaurus by Nicolas Slonimski is really good

[@andres-quezada]

thank you, very well explained :)

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

You're welcome

[@Rheologist]

Lmao comic sans

[@markusschultz4637]

Is the uploader British?

[@decipheringguitarmusictheory]

No, from New Zealand

[@HADJEE]

I think that he is from New Zealand.

[@williamwinslow6582]

I could tell because a fan of Flight of the Conchords.

[@robertaguirre8632]

great stuff!