Shared Culture and History of India and Pakistan - Sanjay Rajoura and Aamir Mughal -

[@sayhitoabhijit]

Majority Pakistanis (mostly punjabis) claim to be of Arab , Iran and now Turkic ancestory because they can’t admit they were Hindus at once because of which they will not accept their shared history with India.

[@naveedafzal4584]

in pakistan Punjab there are many descendant of Arabs, turk, Irani origin. and in Punjab Pakistan significant number of Kashmiris and jammu people also reside.

[@ravindramorey5433]

​@@naveedafzal4584yes like hasan nisar who claims to be from South of Central Asia, which is really confusing because he never really pin pointed from where he is but what he definitely implied was that he is not Pakistani ( who basically are hindustani). I think the best way is genetic testing, which is routinely available in India for very reasonable amount affordable to most of Pakistani ( by the way hasan nisar did his dna mapping in USA or somewhere in West so no one can challenge it)

[@Kolking5588]

I agree. However, many Jatts and Rajputs in Pakistan retained their original surnames and are definitely proud of their ancestry. Ironically Gen Bajwa is such an example.

[@mpqw]

​@@naveedafzal4584$50 main DNA test hota hai karalo. Sab malum pad jayega lol.

[@BilalHussain-dx8fx]

Yes, we share history with India, and there's no point in denying it because that won't change the fact. As far as accepting Hindu ancestry is concerned, my ancestors were Kashmiri Pandits, and I have no shame in accepting that, because it's a fact. However, the question is, why are some Indians so adamant about forcing Pakistanis to accept it? I mean, if some Pakistani Muslims don't take pride in their Hindu ancestry, then what's the big deal here?

[@Robinbeniwal33]

Actually in India, 14th August is marked as national partition horror remembrance day ( started in 2021) and memorial is in jalliyawalan bagh

[@jasha9sandhu]

Talking about partition violence should start with Jinnah 's call for ", direct action day" - state condoned massacre of Hindus in Calcutta, followed by massacre of Sikhs in and around Rawalpindi, then poonch and muzaffarabaad. Reconciliation requires Truth. ( Source: Professor Ishtiaq Ahmed )

[@jasha9sandhu]

@@DevRajKhadka-hj4xu I was commenting specifically about partition violence in 1947

[@bizdevapurva933]

Started in 2021 is the key before that we never gave it a thought shows the intention behind it.

[@rajsinghji-84]

Beniwal bhai, achcha likha aapne. Jat samaaj bhi ab samajh raha ki ham Hindu hain pehle, Jat baad mein.

[@vikata5499]

​@@jasha9sandhunot only jinnah also bangladeshi leaders.

[@saraa271]

As a South Indian never really got to understand the mayhem of partition and trauma because it never came to our experience and only read in a chapter of the school history book.. To know through such podcasts is educational 👏👍

[@sadenb]

As a bengali, my family faced the true hit of the partition. My grand parents had to come from bangladesh before partition.

[@QuaideAzamPakistan]

اِشاعتِ اسلام فرنگستان میں ضمیر اس مَدنِیّت کا دِیں سے ہے خالی فرنگیوں میں اخوّت کا ہے نسَب پہ قیام بلند تر نہیں انگریز کی نگاہوں میں قبولِ دینِ مسیحی سے برہَمن کا مقام اگر قبول کرے، دینِ مصطفیؐ، انگریز سیاہ روز مسلماں رہے گا پھر بھی غلام

[@lol8q]

​@@QuaideAzamPakistanwhat is this maggi language

[@kumarrj1956]

As a South Indian myself, I am asking you that on 09-11-1921 Mopalah massacre happened in kerala....

[@Salmankkk638]

I'f Sardar Patel was Not There In South also We should Have been Second Pakistan .. Didn't know About Rajakars Massacre by Nizam ???? buddy??

[@Takecare55]

14th August India : Partition Horrors Remembrance Day Pakistan : Independence Day ( although it should be Foundation Day )

[@Takecare55]

@@harlowida No your country is made for it.

[@amitjgd52]

Fact check: 'Ao bachon tumhen dikahen Jhanki Hindustan Ki' and 'Hum Layen Hain Toofan Se Kashti Nikal Ke' were written by Kavi Pradeep (born Ramchandra Narayanji Dwivedi) for the 1954 film Jagriti. He was born in the present day Madhya Pradesh and died in Mumbai. He never migrated to Pakistan.

[@nishanghosh3948]

Neither did Hemant Mukherjee who composed the songs. The pakistani version is a rip off

[@lanoklom9697]

Please also get your facts right, "Aon Bachon Sair karaein, tumko Pakistan ki" was written and played on TV in 1951. It is available on youtube as well, in fact when you watch it you will notice Balochistan was not shown in that song, because at the time it had not integrated with Pakistan. So your Indian version is the rip-off, which is the case most of time. Dunno how many Bollywood songs you guys have ripped off of us.

[@amish2394]

​@@lanoklom9697lol Pakistan literally copied Bollywood movies in 60s and 70s, and nobody in the world cares about cheap Pakistani versions, India has become a brand

[@ruparao2971]

Bedari was released in 1956 I thought?

[@misramalvi]

Alama Iqbal wrote : mazhab nahin sikhata aapas mein bair rakhna, hindi hain hum watan hai hindustan humara. Then goes on to be a central voice in the creation of pakistan and two nation theory. We till date learn this poem in school.

[@mangopeople1941]

Yehi to masla hai, parha hi to nahi gya

[@Purplerose0301]

Indoctrination kiya gaya muslims ka us samay

[@sachin37]

Bhai pahle pad le alama Iqbal ko ,vo partition k tarane likhta tha , Islamist tha vo kattar

[@affaqmalik5876]

@@sachin37 onho nay reality dekh li thi na samaj unhay aa gaye thi naa yumharay dimag tab baad mai kiya jo ky acha howa

[@pathikkandhari]

There is a difference between India and Pak,we don’t celebrate partition we call it bloody but it is celebrated in Pakistan as victory and people who got killed were called shaheed

[@ThePakistanExperience]

India celebrates on 15th August. Pakistan celebrates on 14th August. Neither country is celebrating the deaths.

[@mpqw]

​@ThePakistanExperience India celebrates independence, but pakistan celebrates the formation. There's a difference

[@d10saikia]

​@@ThePakistanExperienceyou guys became Arab/Turk/Central asian and we remained who we are.

[@IamRajanKhanna]

​ I agree with you

[@nawoxare5194]

There is difference between Britain and India. Indians celebrate the day British left and gave India it's Independence and call shaheed to those people who fought against "civilizing" Britishers while in Britain it is mourned that London was not ruling India anymore.

[@DoomSlayerTheGamer12.]

My maternal and paternal grandparents migrated from Chiniot Pakistan…though thy shared beautiful childhood memories with us but thy also told us the horrors of partition… thy fondly remembered tht city but nvr wanted to revisit it..

[@ahsan2926]

My maternal or paternal grandparents migrated from Hoshiarpur my mom said me the stories of hoshiarpur what my nana,dadi,nani has said them my few relatives are lives in india but we are not in contacts we dont know where are they

[@DrVJ-med]

18:43 I remember in my childhood, in Delhi in early 60's we used to wear woolens by Diwali (mid to late October) and razai by November. Now when I go to India, I use fan in November and it starts to get hot by late Feb. Mosquitoes and flies used to die out in winter, now they dont.

[@Prof_UpitSultan]

Whilst loss of lives during partition is heart wrenching, you don’t realise that India/ Bharat Mata is a living entity for all of us. Places of reverence and worship are spread across the length and breadth of this ancient land. Not many will understand the pain of their motherland being split for ever. That said, if you ask whether I support a re-unification. My answer would be NO. We have worked hard to get $600 billion in our reserves. Maybe when you manage to have a $100 billion of your own, we can talk.

[@ayushmankar4100]

Wo 100 billion ki vik mang lenge

[@vellaanjan1103]

the cleanest river in India is Umngot river in meghalaya , chambal is the second cleanest. the reason being absence of industries like leather and thermal power plants near it. the religious rituals in india has been going on since indus valley but never caused pollution. the supreme court in MC MEHTA VS UNION OF INDIA cited leather industries of kanpur city for pollution of Ganga river. please get your facts rights.

[@duhduh666]

Sanjay R cannot be relied upon for fact checking. He says something as stupid as capitalism pollutes rivers.

[@SYLFan2008]

Never caused pollution? No, mate, you don't have data to support that. Even if the negative effects back in Indus Valley days were minimal, the population growth and frequency of activities do not justify holding such rites and polluting the river (even if the major contribution is from tanneries). Surely we can adapt to the times, can we not?

[@foodie_gulps]

Now that Pakistan economy is at the bottom, they are concerned about Indian Culture, History, friendship n trade between India Pakistan.... Had the situation been reversed n India was on its bottom, half of our territory including Kashmir n Punjab would have been captured by Pakistan by now n these Pakistanis would have been justifying it .

[@DoomSlayerTheGamer12.]

100% true

[@BilalHussain-dx8fx]

Musibat me gadhay ko bhi baap banana parhta hai 😅

[@mylord3003]

Never trust sumlims

[@Ex_Peace]

100% true 😂 Nowadays these Pakistanis are trying to become Hindustani because no money, Once money starts coming these Pakistanis will become Gohri Gazi & start sending te®®0®ists inside india, Best possible thing is break pakistan into 4 pieces or keep pakistan in Beggers level

[@zulfizulfiqar9377]

Nobody here concerned about same culture or friendship with India. Its only in podcasts😂

[@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386]

Identity of Pakjistan is set correctly. It is not Bharat. It is Religion. Religion is not dharma. Hindus put intuition above all. Muslims put their book above all. It all fits.

[@mrgyani]

Hindus put institution above all, in 2023? Today's Hs might be one of the most fanatical, tribal, unjust religious groups. In Pakistan after the attack on Christians - - cases filed against 1000s, 100s arrested - from the majority side - celebs, religious figures, public - everyone spoke out against it - even their chief justice visited the place - they are rebuilding the houses - in many blasphemy murders in the past - people have been given death sentence This is an example of institutions working. Unimaginable in today's India. Even though we may have weekly cases of such attacks. Same thing in bangaldesh after the durga Pooja attacks : - cases against 1000s, 100s arrested, stringent sections against main perpetrators - fake news on social media was shut down - celebrities condemned it - public came out in support of minorities Show me a single instance of comparable action in India, where: - 100s of accused from majority community arrested - celebs condemned any communal violence - public condemned any communal violence Show me an example of institutions working (in India).

[@vinsin328]

Nope, hmm...majority of Hindus do not eat beef that is against Dharma. Majority of Hindus put Brahmavad over intutiton and books.

[@farrukhsohail1]

Is it though my friend? Then how come your "muslim" state has always had corrupt leadership, 1965 ki betuki war, East Pakistan ky sath itny zulm ky the fucking majority of your country left you and the eradication of minorities and violation of civil rights? You think this is Pakistan? Bro Pakistan was created because we had the majority of muslim population in Bengal, this isnt Pakistan... Pakistan left us in 1971 and became Bangladesh.

[@vikas__patel24]

India name given by greeks.. Megasthenes wrote account of mauryan Empire.. his book name was indika...

[@yashashsgowda6662]

I don't understand why Pakistanis talk about shared culture and heritage, we were literally the same people, you got your country based on your religion that was the only difference back then. Why is it a big surprise that we have shared culture launguage?! Correct me on this, i think its the propaganda that's been taught that Pakistan is different from rest. Also I dont understand the glorification of invaders like Ghazni, Qasim etc. in Pakistan ,hey literally r*ped k*lled your ancestors. You may like it or not thats the fact !!

[@chandaniberry9369]

The talk has only now begin because they r failing and India is successful.

[@SYLFan2008]

//we were literally the same people// "Were" being the operative word. We are definitely not the same anymore. Time to move on. There is nothing to be gained from reminiscing about days past.

[@vinsin328]

In India also there is glorification of Brahmavad who killed and raped Hindus.

[@jasha9sandhu]

Talking about partition violence should start with Jinnah 's call for ", direct action day" - state condoned massacre of Hindus in Calcutta, followed by massacre of Sikhs in and around Rawalpindi, then poonch and muzaffarabaad. Reconciliation requires Truth. ( Source: Professor Ishtiaq Ahmed )

[@SirKasim666]

6:01 1. Unknowingly Shezad is correct, the music of Bedari is a lift / inspiration from Jagriti the composer surprise surprise is by Fateh Ali Khan the father of Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. 2. Jagriti was from 1954 & Bedari is from 1956. Both are identical stories, scene for scene practically Few actors are the same: The lead boy Ratan Kumar or Syed Nazir are same. The teacher in both Sanotsh Kumar or Syed Musa are same. Another fact both these lead actors kept their Hindu screen names even in the credits of Pakistani film Bedari. 3. There are three identical songs in both films with slight changes to suit the location of Pakistan. 4. Syed Nazir later left for studies to Germany, then after his daughter's tragic death, moved to California to never ever return to Pakistan he expired 6 years ago. 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Wah

[@promodmathur9739]

SANJAY'sknowledge of HINDI films is somewhat warped.The two songs that he mentioned were from a 1955 film called JAGRITI. This was a blockbuster,and,the songs that he mentioned were penned by the legendary Hindi poet KAVI PRADEEP.For Sanjay's knowledge,it was PRADEEP who penned AI MERE WATAN KE LOGON. PRADEEP lived and died happily in India.Yes,the child hero of JAGRITI,RATAN KUMAR,who was a Muslim from Ajmer,did migrate to PAKISTAN,and,lived unhappily thereafter. He migrated to the US eventually. The songs that SANJAY mentioned were plagiarised for a Pakistani film,with the altered words and same tune.

[@duhduh666]

Sanjay’s knowledge of a lot of things is warped. And his above it all attitude is cringe if not stupid

[@loveislove9211]

Well said . And Irony is that when Aye mere watan ke logo was launched in delhi after 1962 war defeat . When Nehru cried that time kavi Pradeep was not even invited to the program.

[@rakesh8041]

I would like to take a moment to appreciate the very humble demeanour of Amir Mughal, I watched due to Sanjay Rajoura of whom I'm huge fan but Amir Mughal felt like someone very own....please don't change

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@azizkhan938]

Thank you so much Shehzad for the amazing podcast. Loved each and every second of it. My respect to Amir bhai and Sanjay!.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤❤❤

[@asifmemon3607]

the next guest should be Amar jaleel. amar jaleel is a well know sindhi writer amd intellect. he had spoke in many conterversial topics about sindhi and pakistani identity. his tv show name " The classroom show" is masterpiece for Sindhi Televesion. He is an intellectual person, It would be a treat to listen him speak on sindh, sindhi history and culture.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

I've tried getting his contact but have failed

[@ThePakistanExperience]

If you can help please email us at [e-mail]

[@nomadbanda9562]

Amir Mughal saab is back! Thanks Shehzad bhai much love from Delhi ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@arjunkumarsharma3973]

Pakistani supporter 😂

[@sanjeevsharma3465]

Intriguing podcast. Mr. Mughal is indeed an ocean of knowledge. Loved your podcast to the brim.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@ravindramorey5433]

Very true. The biggest challenge is global warming. In Mumbai since last 10 yrs the monsoon rain do not arrive with monsoon winds ( the way it should) at the outset but simply it pours. It is not monsoon, but it is a cloud burst. Only good part is that cloud burst are happening during monsoon period but for how long is anybody's guess.

[@asangha182]

The name India dates back to Megasthenes(Greek) and Herodotus. The Mauryan Empire was at its peak then.The British didn't name India..

[@harshpatel-ws4yw]

It’s still a name given by outsiders. What did people say about themselves. If Hindus/Vedas have been in the subcontinent for 8000 years and they say Bharat is this land than it is what we called ourselves

[@BagishAstro]

India 400 BC se hoga, Bharat 400 BC se nhi hai

[@vikata5499]

​@@harshpatel-ws4ywno it's not Sapta Sindhu civilization became hapta Hindu which forms Hindu nation. I.e. Indian nation.

[@lanoklom9697]

@@harshpatel-ws4yw Bharat does not include Deccan (Dakshin), also would not include NE India

[@QuantumClasses-h5s]

​@@lanoklom9697Vishnu Puran has clear depiction to Bharat . please read it . Don't speak with ill knowledge.

[@GavIsHti]

The indian guy supposed to be ... is not indian in sense that he didnt do research while saying something of value ..he said ganges is most polluted river becoz of religious activities is it so .. than before 1970s why was it not considered polluted there were no religious activities happening than?? ... its polluted becoz of industrial and human waste going into it ..on its banks large cities have emarged...... most polluted lication is kanpur(industrial location) and least polluted area is haridwar (religious location)... i didnt expect from an indian he would say things without doing research...

[@yourhomebuddy140]

But religion also contributing to pollute it can’t denied

[@sumithas9193]

​@@yourhomebuddy140burial of bodies polluted the earth too. When the population was less it was perhaps okay. But now the case is different. The ground water gets polluted because of the rotting bodies.

[@PatSen]

Incorrect title. Example of a correct title would be: *Is Pakistan interested in reclaiming it’s civilisational roots?* Why is the title incorrect? Because ‘sharing of culture’ is a phrase more apt for distinct civilisations that have some common areas. Example of that would be Indian and Persian. No matter how far back one goes in history, this would be true for India and Persia. On the other hand, at any date before August 14, 1947, there was no Pakistani civilisation. There still isn’t any Pakistani civilisation. What one has is a nation state called Pakistan. If Pakistanis still get confused between civilisation and nation-state, it is because they have rejected their civilisational roots. This discussion is therefore, meaningless, as it’s starting assumption is faulty.

[@ishantgaming]

"My maternal family migrated from Jhang, and my great-grandfather was 24 years old at the time of partition. Until his death, he used to talk about the good old times and his childhood. It was so sad to see him reminiscing about his childhood friends, etc. However, with his passing, the true connection that my family had to its original homeland has also ended. Now, nobody remembers it, and it will be completely forgotten in the next 2-3 generations." but what can we say or do it is what it is but i was fortunate enough to be present when my great-grandfather was alive

[@TechForgeEmmad]

Jhang is my hometown, since many generations, sad sad stories.

[@shantanushekharsjunerft9783]

Our memories lie to us all the time and exaggerate things. I grew up in small town of India, have been living overseas for 25 years now. My parents are still in that city and go visit once a year. The place doesn’t hold any value for me anymore, just my parents do and I don’t miss anything. Your grandfather wouldn’t have found the place so exciting even if he went back.

[@tractorandfarmingvlogs8931]

As a fourth generation of partition effected family, we don’t celebrate partition. Our elders migrated from Pakistan Punjab to Indian Punjab and half of the family was killed.

[@aadie3763]

Our's to

[@amoghdhodapkar1338]

Just for clarification- The word INDIA has been mentioned as a fairly recent context. And when I say recent it is only a few hundred years old. Whereas the word BHARAT is quiet ancient. It's orgin lies is Rig Veda, the ancient Vedic scripture estimate to have written about 3000 years old by some Indian/western historians. The scripture says the word BHARATVARSHA which means the land that is South of the Himalayas. Bharatvarsha was hence also the land of Saptasindhu or 7 rivers that includes now extinct Sarasvati. Calling INDIA, BHARAT was done with 2 purposes- 1. Political 2. Cultural. It resonates with the BJP's stated intention to reclaim the civilizational heritage.

[@durgacdks]

No one's talking about the elephant in the room.... The hatred and intolerance for non-Muslims is the reason why there wont be any long lasting peace bw the two countries.

[@vinsin328]

non-Brahmins also hated by Brahmavads, so what is the difference. Brahmavadi are mostly food terrorists.

[@NiazHJafri]

Bravo all of you !!! 👏👏👏 & ❤❤❤ I am sending my love to Sanjay, Amir Mughal, & Shahzad. Sincere prayers for the everlasting peace between India, Pakistan, & Bangladesh. 🤲🤲🤲 Aameen, Elaahi Aameen

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤❤

[@AnilSharma-hc6tf]

Enjoyed the discussion.Sanjay is absolutely right,l have seen a photograph which appeared in a newspaper,the SUV he had purchased was bigger than his jhopari.His land was acquired because Chandigarh airport was to be expanded.

[@AnilSharma-hc6tf]

Sorry Sheikh you were wrong when you mentioned Bengal famine the wheat was shifted to somewhere in Europe where Australian troops were fighting by Churchil instead of feeding the dying Bengalis.

[@mohitkumarrai5536]

We Indians never forget 26/11 attack

[@vnayzsingh2761]

When Alexander was marching to the east...he was marching towards India....the name is older than the time of Alexander....no one knows how the name came to be

[@digitalSurge0n]

Hindu word was coined by Persians. India is just English version of it.

[@thedpkk]

Sanjay's always typical Leftist mind and always criticised BJP 😂

[@Vladimir_Putin0]

Bhai sb bakwas kar rhe h ye 😂..

[@sachin37]

​@@Vladimir_Putin0Islamist and leftist collation hai, propoganda kar rahe hai ,both muslim are convert karwao nam na badlo ka gana ga rahe ,aur ek hindu leftist anti riligion ho raha hai

[@Shrimpspiration]

1:05:08 I had been looking to find this part of history for so long, and explained in a minute. Would love an expanded view of this timeline.

[@ajaysaranchoudhary9338]

I agree on this point that we have shared culture and there should be peace between both countries 😊but uska ek process h.agar aapko India Pak ke beech tensions and procedure of peace establishment ke bare m correct analysis Chahiye to plz Smita Prakash Ka ek ani podcast dekhiye ...last month m hi Aaya h😊😊....I think it'll be very helpful to understand complete scenario

[@Indianpoliticsexplainer]

Except two main culture kashmiri and punjabi what we share ?

[@pa1ful]

woah....thank you so much for this. I think its safe to say that we'll see more of these discussions and more like-minded people coming together to converse with civility and open-mindedness.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@BaagiBunty]

Good thing is that people now discuss these things publicly 😊

[@shahrozdanish9213]

So happy after watching this podcast, but saddened at the same time over how hatred and conflict for a long period of time can only lead to massacres and bloodshed

[@Samadabro12]

Many people especially hindus are saying that our ansestor were hindus first of all hindhu is not a religion sanatan or vedic dharama is a religion hindhu is just a corruption of word Sindhu and we are proud Sindhu but we cant do anything about people in pakistan calling themselves arab turks and supporting invaders and the hindhu in sindh who is SINDHU Basically has nothing to do with the hindhu in other part of india because they and us are the native people of this land Hindhu is just a geographical representation of people living across the indus/sindhu river

[@TarunSachdeva-f8n]

They made contributions, although they did not provide us with the Metro train or expressways. Despite this, we now have both, along with many other developments. However, it's important to note that they did extract resources from our region.

[@shakunimama3419]

1) There are more similarities among us than differences. 2) You can fool some people all the time. You can fool all the people sometimes but you can’t fool all the people all the time. 3) Jo Tarikh ko masskh karte hai, Tarikh unnkhe masskh karti hai !! 4) Bill aakhir (at the end eventually) truth will always prevail 👍🏼

[@nishanghosh3948]

Sanjay Rajoura 'Ao Bachon tumhe dikhaye jhanki hindustan ki' was written by Kavi Pradeep and composed by Hemant Mukherjee and none of them migrated to Pakistan.

[@jmudikun]

I love watching your interviews 😊 Thank you so much. An Indian living in Spain

[@d10saikia]

Dawki is the cleanest river in Asia so obviously in India too. Not chambal

[@nitovatorsnitj]

One of the most interesting thing I observed is that what Mr. Amir Mughal is saying (like Dharam shalas, gau shalas, shared heritage of Pakistan with India), that is opposed tooth and nail in India by likes of Sanjay Rajoura and Mani Shankar Aiyer. This shared heritage of India and Pakistan in Pakistan is basically what RSS say in principle!

[@debashishchakraborty2897]

Well done three of you. Kudos.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@rajsinghji-84]

I am an Indian and I have never heard of Sanjay Rajoura. And I follow stand up comedy like hell. Who is this guy?

[@rajsinghji-84]

@@system7962 And he is popular in Pakistan? On this podcast where there are hardly 800 likes? Make it make sense.

[@sash0047]

Probably a washed up loser

[@vikas__patel24]

Aamir mughal is right .. if some outsiders have done exceptionally great work than nothing wrong to accepting their name. I mean Mumbai was made from seven islands.. they were not connected by land.. it is engineering Marvel of British that join all these islands into single landmass.

[@rahulvishnu4426]

I would love to share a peg with Aamir Mughal if he ever came to India (I am in Bangalore). This is the kind of person I like listening to while having a conversation over a drink. (I apologise in advance if this idea seems offensive, I mean no offense)

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Nobody is offended. Everyone listening wants to have a peg with Aamir Bhai 😅

[@stallionspirit1576]

@@ThePakistanExperience will aamir ..pay for the peg??...lol

[@indmusiclover]

If we are crediting (negative credit) to the British for hindu-muslim divide, though a tough and uneasy question to the Pakistanis: should the same credit be given to Jinnah for his slogan to get a separate land for muslims was exactly that. Ok, if we decide to move on , how. Recently the PCB chairman said something silly, prior to that the caretaker PM. the list of "loose talk" is endless.

[@Shrimpspiration]

29:21 this is exactly the same thing that happened in Lahore. I have seen farmers with ‘boris’ of cash after selling their land in the 2000s. That place used to be all farm land, now itself DHA

[@geetaprabhakar4261]

Very informative and balanced podcast ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@juliens1948]

The mindset that doesn't go beyong Alhamdulillah, Mashaallah, Inshallah is prevelent in Pakistan which is quite absent in India.

[@rogermilla2358]

Aamir Mughal looks like an older version of Indian actor Sushant Singh (not the one who died, the other one).

[@Eskimo251]

Loved the podcast, thanks to Sanjay for his candid views and for visiting our Sindh. Such podcasts can bridge the gap between both countries as compared to listening to warmongers on TV shows whose sole agenda is to gain TRP ratings.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤❤❤

[@michaelscott5916]

Loved this ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@ASHWANIHANDA]

I really wish India & Pakistan were one country we would be very successful

[@prathamlotia9986]

40:49 I am fascinated with Sindh. My best friend is sindhi and I am a Gujarati. I want to cross the gujarat Sindh border with him

[@Abbas.5]

1:02:40 they didn’t give us the railway, communication and so forth, it was for their own good to make the robbed goods flow freely I suppose

[@rakeshkumar-wo5mr]

absolutely true

[@niranjanganjawala254]

38:24 talking about LK Advani: "India jaake itna kyun badal gaye" Same logic, Mohammad Ali Jinnah's family was from Rajkot, Gujarat, India. his grand father's name was Jinabhai thats where Jinnah comes from, so same thing: "Pakistan jaake itna kyun badal gaye".

[@SanjayChauhanMumbai]

Greetings from Mumbai...Good effort Shehzad bhai . We both ( India and Pakistan) are immature, kiddish , jingoistic , loud, emotional .... we carry old , bloodiest baggage ...destroying our present.... missing golden opportunity . Unless we dont leave behind our past , forget religious extremist ideas .... we both will continue squabble like immature , uncivilised kids Amidst al despondency , hatred existing in this region... such podcast brings whiff of fresh air , hope...lets pray sanity comes to South Asia . regards

[@anynomous-iv5lo]

India repents partition though I have no personal connection to partition I feel a great loss for my country, though I am a complete West Bengali I deeply feels loss for the loss of East Bengal and Punjab,sindh Balochistan and nwfp, it lefts such mark in me that I keep searching for podcasts related to partition though I have no connection with history as academy as I am a post graduate student of chemistry in IIT Hyderabad

[@yara-cp3lj]

no we dont!!

[@SubhashishBagchi]

I am Bengali from Siliguri and I don't feel any regret leaving Bangladesh behind.

[@anynomous-iv5lo]

@@SubhashishBagchi don't you repent losing everything you had?

[@lighttread]

Much power to Rajoura. Great show!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@lighttread]

@@DevRajKhadka-hj4xu 😂😂

[@lighttread]

@@DevRajKhadka-hj4xu 😂😂

[@dsam6149]

@@DevRajKhadka-hj4xu are jane de...harami hai ye lok...inke khoon me inki kaum Sani hai...harami sale..

[@umangdesai4136]

India was a name given by the Greeks.. The word "Indonesia" in Greek means - Indian Islands..

[@swapanghosh9867]

Do you recommend departmental examination for everyone in five years?

[@Shrvp]

Greatest True secular institution in entire subcontinent or for that reason in the world is Bollywood film industry. In bollywood your box office success is the only criterion. Maximum interfaith marraiges are in Bollywood without any social disturbances. That's greatest gift of Bollywood to the world.

[@gautamchandran]

The reason quoted for pollution of river ganga in the podcast is disposal of "Hawan n Pooja" materials😅😅..how scientific n logical..

[@dharmeshparikh7837]

14th August is surprisingly declared by current government of India as dark day of partition only last year or few years back. 😅😅 So Shezad its not that noone is remembering horrors of partition in India. I never expected BJP government to declare partition as dark day of mourning. You should conduct podcast with Dr. Ishtiaq who recently visited India and he can give you detailed discussions on partition which he did during his India visit. He even appeared on one of the biggest digital media platform called "Lallantop".

[@AnilBaruah-yl8kt]

Amir Mughal Sab is avery well read Pakistani and also a very modern mind. So is the host of this podcast,as always. Enjoyed watching.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@TheAmmu21]

Greeks named it India. Indika by Megasthenes was an account of the Mauryan empire.

[@swapanghosh9867]

Water has to travel by train and cargo and air on priority. Options?

[@SudhirPatil]

Indian film industry was setup by Marathi peoples first Indian film made by Dadasaheb Falke in 1913 and grown intailly by Prabhat film studio at that they made many great films art direction and real effects of movie 'Sant Tukaram' was acclaimed worldwide. Yes then Hindi film industry grown by All those people which you guy's mentioned and parallely Telugu, Tamil industry was also grown by people like Ramaji Rao and many more, There are many people behind Indian film industry results of Bahubali and Dangal made by almost 2 corner of India.

[@qbs6261]

Loved the insightful discussion,, it was a treat,, thanks 😊 Although still trying to figure out what were you guys using 😅

[@asitgandhi76]

Cross border terrorism started by the Pakistan after losing the war against the Bangladesh. India did not win the Bangladesh but Pakistan lost the Bangladesh due to their policies. Dono desh bhaley hi garib hongey lekin India ka intention Live and Let others live tha jab ki Pakistan ka intention "ghaas kha lenge leking atam bam banakar rahenge" tha.... India ne intervention 2014 ke baad chaalu kiya... Kab tak sahenge?

[@areebahmedali8555]

Brilliant, these topics should be discussed

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@patmclaughlin107]

@33:38 Till Pakistan Army’s slogan is “Jihad fi sabilallah”, things will remain “mushkil”.

[@tjay8433]

As a rajasthani i respect aamir saheb. ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@hardtimeschaney]

Gentlemen, even the ancient Greeks knew India and have called it so... just read the works.

[@swapanghosh9867]

I've had a symposiu with traditional and integrity. Change is always for the messenger for personal reasons so that message does not fall into wrong hands.

[@bhupendersingh5207]

I want that day in my life where I could roam in the streets of Lahore, Karachi, peshawar, queta, without any visa and without any fear. Love from Delhi ❤❤❤

[@shresthaswagatika]

India and Bharat discussion was just for a while. A distracting stunt. Public is alright by now.😄

[@ajaysaranchoudhary9338]

Yess... it's true 😂

[@akshat_khare]

Should jinnah and gang also be villains for Indians , vaise they perpetuated the Britisher's view ...... If Britishers are being portrayed as villains z why shouldn't they ?

[@marspalk7611]

This is not a true feeling but an alegator tears when Pakistan has reached rock bottom. Now they good relation with india.

[@ishtiaq968]

I thought this whole Pakistan movement started from East and Northern India but they end up becoming the respected Bangladesh without the hatred but we end up suffering with all sorts of issues and being hated. The name itself Pak suggests others are NaPaak but really we are the ones who are NaKaam. Is there anyway we can undo the past? There was no need for a separation. Yes we have different beliefs and perspectives on life, but that was the case for hundreds of years...

[@RanaRajput-o4r]

When fakir aziz u deen when went to negotiate with. Afghan in Belhalf of MahaRaja Ranjit singh They told how can you came to talk us of kaffir the fakir Aziz u din replied pleas take your words back maharaja and when your mahamood Gaznavi came to attack. India had 3500 Hindu soldiers and 5 generals and those Hindus never better their so i will also never betray my maharaja

[@anuchugh31]

Extremely Thought provoking. A question to Shehzad - can Mughal sahab encourage the Army to retreat one step from terrorism, some of the Indians will pressurise the government to open talks? Tired of religious bigotry on both sides 🙏🏾 and No 26/11 likes. The other day we lost 3 of our bravest

[@RevsAndWheels]

Mujhe India-Pakistan ki shared history me sabse kharab event (war to be specific) 1947 ki war lagti hai. Kyuki wo jo war thi usme jo log aapasme ladh rahe hai jo ek dusre ki jaan ke piche pade hue hai, wo kuch mahino pehle saath me ghul-milkar reh rahe the aur shayad unme se kuch soldiers toh saathme world wars me bhi ladhe hoge, apni jaan khatre me daalkar dusre ki jaan jo bacha rahe the, wo us waqt ek-dusre ki jaan lene par tule hue the... Bohot ajeeb aur mentally challenging war rahi hogi wo dono mulqo ke liye...

[@thedpkk]

Pakistan always compare Pakistan situations with India 🇮🇳 and they said... Hame inn Hindu Muslims se bahar nikalna chahiye but they forgot ki 2 nation theory Ko sabse jyada provoked Pakistani & Specially Punjabis karte hain 🤣🗿

[@pascalwager4544]

Just changing the name of a company or a product during a branding exercise is a nightmare. I don't understand people willing to change names of cities and countries. The ripple effect of such a change in India's official name will be unlike anything anyone has imagined.

[@amitbeliever4218]

Love ur podcast, u r truly representing ur country..

[@amitbeliever4218]

Love from Pune, india

[@Scientist1351]

Chale ja udhar😂

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@Nitish.Singhal]

28:55 Sanjay toh pkka line snort ke beitha hai...kya bk rha hai bhai😂😂.... Kisan se zameen leli usse kheti krni thi..😂😂 Perfect liberandu.... Aur agricultural zameen aise he acquire nhi hoti... residential purpose ke jaise pakistan mein hoti...new expansion is banned in Delhi NCR...other then lands which got sold before 2013

[@septemfluous3]

Thank you for sharing a great discussion - agree with changing city/area names back to the original. Why honour name changes that were imposed during 200 years of British rule - especially when the history of the region dates back over 5000 years!

[@SnipeMaster77]

@sadianaseem1437 where is your lecture on India I would like to attend 😂😂😂😂

[@septemfluous3]

@@SnipeMaster77 🤣🤣🤣

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@swapanghosh9867]

Do you learn some thing..I've had so many friends who are religions sense Whoregret the time for no reason for others who haven't any reason what do ever. Don't know what happened One person was pure in the best sense of the word talked about at least two generations before he passed away he was 68 While I was 70

[@atinhazra2552]

This is the BEST podcast i have seen in recent years! Dear Host, Kudos to you! It's a pity that we're watching it for free

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤❤❤❤

[@arpittitoria]

Respected Sir, Gurgaon is a barren land and not a part of sugarcane belt.

[@shinsukinakahamu1125]

300th podcast wow shehzad, happy to have seen each and every one.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@effendi77]

It wasn't Anglo or Persian, but Greek, that first started calling it Indoi.

[@AsBi1]

very nice podcast, i like them both, good to see them again.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤❤❤