Rumours about Shias, Moharram and Karbala - Syed Muhammad Kumail -

[@ThePakistanExperience]

The famed 007 episode with Kumail: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nomuYYqki72hg9U

[@shazy319]

Being a shia kid raised in Karachi, I was bullied at school with these rumours. Refreshing to see that now its addressed.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@kapilmohansharma6135]

do u really spit in food u share with other people ?

[@harimali5397]

No not at all ​@@kapilmohansharma6135

[@syednaqvi2288]

@@kapilmohansharma6135 no not at all

[@shazy319]

@@kapilmohansharma6135 who with the sane mind would ever do that??

[@hamzasyed5774]

Maula Abbas (AS) zikr brought tears to my eyes. Very eloquently put Kumail

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@haiderimran8415]

❤

[@ruhmafatima5142]

❤

[@aemanshahid4733]

Yes 😢

[@nandkumaryewale4643]

I am from Pune Maharashtra India and in my city almost all Shias are financially strong community They well educated and more patriotic than Sunni muslims. They never get involved in anti social activities.Mostly are businessmen.

[@jayanthisrinivasan9055]

Very true.Peaceful and prosperous

[@tatheerfatima4751]

Shia Muslim from Hyderabad India ....❤❤.... You got my respect

[@mohitjain2157]

I'm from Mumbai and can confirm the same, have seen first hand they conduct themselves very well, other sects of Islamic faith should learn from them

[@abhinabbora6779]

in India Shia business community are a blessing for the society. Also dey follow der religion very sincerely. They do not engage in any religious controversy.they acknowledge d fact they are son of the soil. They don't call themselves Arabs or turks.

[@apurvabhide2860]

Don't fool yourselves we Indians know where their actual loyalty lies

[@MunnaMobile000]

Honestly, the light-hearted way this episode went was the EXACT way to respond to centuries of bogus, outrageous rumours directed at the Shia Muslim community (or any religious minority found in a majoritarian state). These misconceptions need to be talked about, sure, but more importantly they need to be made fun of openly just to show how stupid they are, and how stupid some people can be when they blindly believe them growing up.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@key9849]

@@ThePakistanExperienceiiiii NBC V n n n V n

[@SpontaneousSana]

My idea of Shia community changed after coming to USA when I joined Shia mosque some years ago just because it was closest to my house and it was convenient for me. And I am glad I did, cause I now know how wrong all of those rumors were.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ShiaNoorAhlBayt]

Thanks for the true clarification❤

[@samikha-du4me]

Shia bhi bun jao, i am also in US wahan toh imam two piece mein namaz parhata hai

[@adnanhaider3277]

❤❤

[@vk6722]

❤❤❤

[@bhagiganti]

I enjoyed this podcast simply because making a joke of the rumours is the best way to diffuse them.... 😂😂😂 I am literally rolling on the floor!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌🤣

[@Vans374]

Who told you that?

[@ahsanhaider7624]

Kumail speaks very bravely about Muavia , Allah protects you from evil. Plz care yourself now 🙏🙏🙏😭

[@UrduMom]

My favourite part of this podcast has to be when Kumail goes all majlis-mode (being Shia myself, Kumail I get it!) and Shehzad listens patiently (even with the sunglasses on! And yes, I agree capatalism is the biggest religion. An important read on this topic and more details on the various incidents that Kumail mentions from Muslim history is “after the prophet: the epic story of Shia-Sunni split” by Lesley Hazelton. Shehzad you should read the book as part of your book reviews and if you ever want someone to discuss the book with you on the podcast, I would love to!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@abuzarrizvi2294]

Ulti charpai is a tradition in rural UP which symbolises utter pain and it’s a tradition to do if someone one dies . We remember this during our village Muharram in childhood. The phrase “ khat khada hona” comes form that which means it’s happens when some one dies .

[@nayan7721]

I came to like only, will listen to this podcast tomorrow morning while going office in Delhi Metro 😊

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Life in a Metro

[@nayan7721]

@@ThePakistanExperience 😄life is good Monsieur

[@asimhaneef2276]

Cult following ki misaal

[@mukulparashar8067]

Bhai konse metro station se jaate ho ? Mein toh Pitampura se jaata hun red line, yellow line use karta hun.

[@aitzazali7398]

On this 10th muharram I have been in a majlis of hazara community Here in Norway because most of them were my Costumers and I found them very organized Open minded very Kind and well educated and I Gave them my Parking spots For those who were coming for majlis and I went there on Sham-e-ghareeba I did’t understand anything because they were speaking in Parisian and believe me I never experienced that kind of atmosphere Of sadness Dedication And Respect I found them one of best religious community When it comes to Discipline And Harmony Although I’m not religious altogether but I know all these are rumors about Shia community

[@fatimabatool5340]

Thank you for taking care of my shia hazara brothers and sisters there

[@aitzazali7398]

@@fatimabatool5340 🫶🏻

[@yasinali7616]

May Allah almighty for the love of Hussain a.s bless you with everything you desire for❤ ameen

[@syedjafferimam5789]

Being a Shia, I have no intention to debate Sunni people about these rumours. We seriously don’t need you to come to our events. What we have achieved through this Azadari is much more Sunnis can ever dream of. I’m talking about the dare to speak up against evil that too in the middle of the road. Tum apni Well me baithe raho.. Shias need to concentrate on education, development and philanthropy.

[@deepalashplani]

"I may not know everything about Shia and Sunni, but I definitely enjoyed the episode."

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@azeemA147]

Thank you so much for this podcast. Legendary

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@waqasahmed569]

I was a pure cutter sunni .... Kbi na prha na research ki Muhallay me ek bnda tha wo jo kehta tha hum maan lete thay kch kch swaal atay thay but hum research ni krtay thay k is ne keh dia to theek e hoga .... Phr Last muharram i thought k dekha jaye, prha jaye , research kia jaye K koi judge b dono side ko sunay bina fesla ni sunata .... So jese jese tehqeeq krta gya .... Ankhen khulti gyin Now Alhamdulillah i am Hussaini

[@ahsanhaider7624]

Mashallah that's great

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@MansourAlameri-p8e]

You were gumrah before and still choose to be gumrah

[@waqasahmed569]

@@MansourAlameri-p8e if being Hussaini is gumrahi ..... M happy with it

[@MansourAlameri-p8e]

@@waqasahmed569 Be a Muslim. Period

[@adilzain076]

Sham e Ghareeban ki shururat Lucknow ke Imambada Gufranmaab se shuru hui thi 😊 sham-e-ghareeban jisme shia or kuch sunni bhi hote hai sab ek jagh farsh par bina tent ke raat me karbala ka waky yad kar ke giriya karte hai or khoob ziyada rote hai ❤️‍🩹🇮🇳

[@haiderimran8415]

سید کمیل آپکا بہت بہت شکریہ اس جدید دور میں جدید زبان میں سب بیان کیا ❤ الصلوۃ والسلام علیک یا حسین ع و اولاد حسین ع

[@Cutekumbhu]

I am Hindu from India and my best friend is Shia 😊

[@azizrizvi2234]

Asa a shia I love Hindu from Pakistan

[@tatheerfatima4751]

Am a Shia from Hyderabad India and my best friend for 15 yrs is an Iyengar brahman from south and I can vouch for her. It's common in india to have such friendships and perhaps that is why India is a safe heaven for all religions.

[@janmuhammad2109]

I'm a Sunni but guys this guy spits facts with humor i wish ye aik serious talk hoti I'm definitely searching this dude Muhammad Kumail

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@haiderimran8415]

مولا کریم ع سلامت رکھیں.. ہر شر سے محفوظ رکھیں. آمین محترم سید کمیل

[@donbrad6011]

Shias in India are a very prosperous successful community

[@azizee6972]

ALLAHA ka shukurya 🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲

[@abdullahtahir9622]

😂😂😂😂😂😂 prosperity

[@FahadZahr]

So are the ones in Pakistan. That was lame mate

[@kapilmohansharma6135]

I know a sunni guy... he always say that Shia spit in everything food etc

[@RajKumar-bq9hb]

​@@azizee6972Jahil hinduo kz shukriya kar Allha ka kya matlab Hindustan main

[@zainraza3302]

Thanks shehzad for bringing this topic, i really admire your work!! ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@namansrivastav2008]

I personally find Shia Muslims as good and liberal as I live in Lucknow and they are in majority here and they are good people .

[@TheIndianxperience]

Aur funny baat ye hai ki kuch log yaha in dono ke liye thook wala rumour felaya karte hain😂 irony

[@namansrivastav2008]

@@TheIndianxperience kaha ?

[@shuja591]

I’m only commenting because of the way he described the role and shahadat e Hazrat Abbas as. Super likeeeee !

[@ruhmafatima5142]

What if you are shia, knows everything and still watching it😅

[@saroashali2409]

OHMYGOD, the last podcast you did with kumail, the Shia experience one was sooooo close to my heart that I listened to it so many times. This is such a great surprise. Can't wait for more of these conversations. ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

[@shivsharma883]

Brilliant discussion. You guys just killed it. Way to go. Loved it.😊

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@doctorstrange-s1m]

I am a sunni but i am staunch believer of these lines انسان کو بیدار تو ہو لینے دو ہر قوم پکارے گی ہمارے ہیں حسین

[@AfzalQazi786]

Me too

[@NiazHJafri]

Bahut Aala Podcast !!! Bravo Shehzad & Kumail !!! 👏👏👏👏👏 You guys have demonstrated the power of messaging through 'Comedy/Satire' & in the process, you have been able to have the most difficult of conversations rather seamlessly & with ease. More & More Power To Both of YOU !!! 👍🤘🤟✌️✊️👊🤛🤜 Sincere prayers for both of you 🤲🤲🤲

[@yashsrivastava5486]

I am a hindu from Lucknow,the heart of Shias in India and used to live in old part of the city where the mohallas of muslims are split in shias and Sunnis .In lucknow ,many hindus take part in procession and touch the main tazia for blessings .Since ,Shia and Sunni in lko are numerically almost same in number ,there is always tensions and we often see riots ,stone pelting among them both and both run in hindu mohallas for safety .Sunnis abuse shias matam by saying ,ki katmal(termite) ,machar maar rhe h .Lucknow is probably the only city where we see shia sunni conflict not hindu muslim.

[@krishnaswami346]

@@yashsrivastava5486 muslims need conflict. Look around the world. Muslims are the cause of every war in the world. Either against them or for them. Within the Muslim world Iran Vs Saudi is the biggest conflict of the world. No education, no science just fight and blood shed is the history of Islam.

[@MunnaMobile000]

@@krishnaswami346 can we say the same about Hindu rajas fighting each other and destroying each other's temples in the past?

[@SyedaSamanGulzar]

So Hindus in Lucknow are lucky 😊 I myself am a Shia Muslim BTW.

[@abhijitmaisuria5703]

@@MunnaMobile000Hindu Rajas fighting over territory & Shia Sunni rioting over belief is different thing. Hindu raja would defeat their opponent & then sometime destroy the temple to disrespect opponent. Fun Fact: Idol of that temple was always relocated & sometimes in grander temple. Bhai whatsapp pe history mat padha kar.

[@syedwaseemakram7006]

​@@abhijitmaisuria5703Have you ever read about the shaivites and vaishnavite wars in south india.

[@sheikhsaud4845]

Abay bhai😂😂😂😂 had me in first 2 minutes of 2 hour prodcast. Brilliant shehzad.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🤣

[@ilmoadab7426]

We love our Shia Brothers. ❤ Shia + Suni = Bhai Bhai ❤

[@sanahasnain]

🤣🤣 I am Shia and I approve this 🙌🏽

[@sanahasnain]

The first 5 minutes of it at least lol which is what I have watched so far and was compelled to leave a comment 😅✌🏽

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Praveen_834]

I wonder do 20th century shias approve adding spit to food they serve.

[@MurtazaDot]

Moula Abbas a.s ka zikar sun k aankho se aanso aa gaye

[@Vans374]

Hum oun ko hazrat Abbas kehtain shia mola boltain hain, aaj say 20,30 yrs pehlay such termonolgy was very rare among ordinary shia, both sunnis and shias were a bit fluid back in the days when relgion stayed home or in mosques not like now when its always in your face

[@azizrizvi2234]

😢😢

[@kkbhai254]

Don't forget Hussaini Brahmins who fought in karbala.

[@MunnaMobile000]

that's a myth. very detailed historical accounts of Karbala exist from different sources, including the names of every single martyr of Karbala. No Hussaini Brahmins were in that event. Yes, there was an African Christian freed slave called Jawn (John) who was part of Imam Hussain's contingent and was martyred at Karbala, but that was it really. The Hussaini Brahmin story was likely made many centuries later in the subcontinent when some Brahmin communities would take part in Muharram rituals where Shias had a strong cultural presence to commemorate Karbala as a way of showing intercommunal solidarity.

[@masoombari]

It's not historically supported. maybe it started as a cultural thing to get through the month in brotherhood but certainly there is this saying that they were on the way to karbala. And before reaching there they heard the devastating news

[@hassancheema2268]

@@MunnaMobile000 john a.s was not the only non-muslim in Karbala army. check list again, please.

[@Anomyno09484]

@@hassancheema2268 Wahab e Kalbi was also christian

[@abhishek_083]

Ghanta, it's a myth

[@aakashsrivastava2418]

Fun fact in India Shia community is actually supressed by opposition specially in UP when Samajwadi party to woo Sunni vote banned a form of morning prayer and when bjp came to power overturned this and since then Shia clerics have close relation with bjp top functionaries

[@luckytyagi8582]

😂😂😂😂​@@AMPA33

[@deception6666]

So you love BJP bcoz they suppress Sunnis ..😂

[@parjanyashukla176]

What Samajwadi party did was aberration. In Lucknow and (almost) all parts of Eastern UP, Shia Muslims were always dominating culturally. Lucknow Shia-Sunni riots were started by British.

[@rexalbalushi999]

Im a baloch sunni but i respect shias.. plus all religions too❤❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@azizrizvi2234]

Thanks

[@tarabshadab9272]

Wel done Syed Muhammad kumail Dil Khush kir dia❤

[@tahaj7916]

Kumail did a great job , i think your selection of the guest was perfect

[@zainabbas422]

Kumail elaborated it better than many maulanas from mimber, in a lighter way!

[@abhinabbora6779]

in India Shia business community are a blessing for the society. Also dey follow der religion very sincerely. They do not engage in any religious controversy.they acknowledge d fact they are son of the soil. They don't call themselves Arabs or turks.

[@apurvabhide2860]

@@abhinabbora6779 do fool yourself we Indians know where their loyalty lies

[@afshanali7054]

I am sunni syed but I stand with Ahle Bait

[@AL1zZzOP]

A much needed topic

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@naqashhaider1164]

A rumour from KPK Jo k pehle bohot howa karta tha FATA k ilaqo mai ab aisa mana jata hai, K Shia logo k kaan(ears) raat ko bare ho jate hai aur wo aik kaan k upar soote hai aur dosre se jism dhamp lete hai.

[@Mesum_haider]

Hahahaha

[@azizrizvi2234]

😂😂😂

[@farwabatool6138]

Lol!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@tahaj7916]

That's new 😂😂😂

[@Jaiceplays16]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 aj tak meray kan nhi baray huay

[@sanna9672]

As an Ahmadi Muslim viewer I really appreciate the efforts you guys are doing but i also feel sad that could never bring an Ahamdi speaker to discuss the same things 😢

[@SheheryarRaza-h8v]

"Ay Yabnattulaqa" "Oh those who were freed" - Shahzadi Zainab SA. This one phrase is the summary of Banu Umaiiyah and is enough to get Umawis lose their shit.

[@escapebeat]

Listening to the episode in the car while driving to work. Will take a few runs but worth it !

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@rameezmehdi1]

Love your podcasts, bro. I have never commented before but would like to do so today just to clarify one fact. It's an old UP tradition that the cots or carpiyis are turned upside down from 7th mohorram to 10th mohorram as it is a sign of mourning from the olden days and no one sleeps on the bed during those 4 nights. Thanks and keep on doing the good work.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Interesting

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Vans374]

Even the old times jews used to do it, 3 days of mourning, in pak punjab up untill early 70s some ppl did it for three days.

[@hassanzaidi1593]

Alhamdolillah 5 of my friends joined us this moharram and went on all the majalis with us and the 9 and 10th jaloos. They witnessed everything themselves from 11 am in the morning till 12pm at night. They themselves started doing matam and crying and said this has a special attraction when you come close and observe it yourself and that they were told lies by molvis deliberately and they did not think to investigate it. Now being from ahl e hadees they all say they are Hussaini and listen to majalis to expand their knowledge. Khud ao or dekho, college k dosto ki baato pe dusro ko na samjho

[@murlimenon2291]

Shehzad... i watched half the show; will chk the rest tomorrow. In a nation that is so fixated to ultra religiosity; humor is indeed the best way to shed light about misconceptions and bigotry. Salute bro.. you guys have shown guts to hold a show on Shia -Suni divide.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@shatnermohanty6678]

It would sound strange but in my home state Odisha which has 2% Muslim population , Shia and Sunnis come together to celebrate Moharram . I have asked many Muslims about this and many aren't aware of the difference . And those who are aware , say this is our festival , and won't comment further . I wish some KZbinr or news channel would cover this topic in Odisha . It seems , when people are in a minority , they forget their differences more readily . I also wonder , do Hindus of pakistan , forget their caste differences , considering they are also less than 2% of the population ?

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Interestingly Hindus and Christians in Pakistan often participate in Moharram processions

[@shatnermohanty6678]

@@ThePakistanExperiencean Australian comedian had once appeared on an Indian news channel and he presented this joke : A Tamilian and a Kannadiga meet and there is an unspoken hostility ( Kaveri river waters etc ) Then they see a Bihari and the Two come together : now they are South Indians facing a North Indian Then they see a pakistani and the Three come together: now they are Indians facing a pakistani . Then they see a South African and the Four come together: Subcontinental Solidarity Then they see a Britisher and the Five come together : Commonwealth countries facing their ex colonial ruler I don't remember how it ends but it does tell something about human psychology 😂😂😂

[@krishnaswami346]

For the muslims the enemy are the non believers. Sunni believe Shia is is non Muslim and they hate the Shia and vice versa. In india both Shia and sunni hate the hindu and other non believers of islam. Also the Muslims have practise to spit in food before they serve.

[@navneetparmar3632]

​@@ThePakistanExperiencelike they have option😂

[@mohammadraza8611]

​@@navneetparmar3632for your kind information shia is minority sect and most of the Muslim majority considers it haram to participate in moharram rituals toh kia Christan and Hindu ko minority se ziada khatra hoga ya majority se jo moharram rituals ko boycott karti hai there should be a petition filed in the international court to stop uneducated Indians of using social media platforms

[@Silencio0996]

Sectarian mind to kabhi tha hi ni jo misconceptions thi wo b gai.. Thank you sooo much.. my mind got more clarity after watching this.. excellent effort..

[@DarkEdgeMedia007]

Karachi Shia and Isb Shia and Indian Shia are on top in education open minded and progressive even hazara Shia are good

[@ninbuwolf]

as a Shia I approve this lol we do all of the above mentioned

[@AhmedKhan-sm7ww]

Saw him in junaid akram podcast now here, he is a gem 💎

[@naheedkhattak4305]

Am sending this to my younger brother so that he can learn about this controversial topic

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@nazzimnaqvi5510]

on 1:21 min charpai ulti kr k sona, it's meen k zameen pr chatai bicha kr sona, Punjab main and interior Sindh main mostly log Charpai pr sona pasan krty hain un ko Mattress pr ya farsh pr neend nahin aati to aisy Shia log charpai ko ulta kr us pr so jaty hain meen k Ayam Moharam gham k Izhar k ley zameen pr so jaty hain

[@medroaster]

That's the concept ❤

[@KaramKhan-tu8td]

Agree

[@Vans374]

Sindh ka toh pata nei, but punjab main 3 din takk zameen par bhaitay hain teesray din officialy mourning period ends jub chitai, phuri ota li jaati hay.

[@kishwer-w9k]

MY MOM IS FROM SYED FAMILY, 1/2 ARE SUNNIES AND 1/2 ARE SHIAS. MY TOLD ME WHEN HIS BROTHER USED TO GO AND JOIN "MATUM", MY GRAND FATHER USED TO WORRIED AS HE HAD ONLY ONE EMPTY HEAD SON. MY MOM USED TO GO JALSAS OF MAHARAM "TO ONE OF THEIR CLOSE FRIENDS SHIA URDU SPEAKING", SHE USED TO TAKE ME, ONCE I LOST, MY FRIENDS(WHO WERE ALSO URDU SPEAKERS) USED TO TELL ME DO NOT GO TO THEIR JALSAS AS THEY "EAT" SUNNIES CHILDREN AND ALSO VERY ROMANTIC STORIES ABOUT "SHAM E GARIBAN".), I SLAPPED MY CHEST HARDER THEN SHIAS SO THEY DO NOT CATCH ME AND EAT ME, FINALLY MY MOM FOUND ME,.

[@o.p.revolutionary7829]

Beautiful podcast….most entertaining ❤ & message for jaahils

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@kabirsk4266]

Its true that some shia have kind of hate for sunny

[@Seekhoaajse]

I never seen a shia brother so friendly and kool about to telling his believes.god bless you

[@rbhimjee]

What a frivolous conversation!

[@surabhi11]

Hahahhahahaa oh my god with sunglasses! Pure entertainment! ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@mehreenabbas1]

Really enjoyed the podcast, it was fun as well as educational😊

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@chiraghinduja7466]

22:59: Same happens in our culture also where we distribute food to our close relatives on death anniversary of our grand-father/mother/father/mother...so its quiet common

[@medroaster]

Shehzad, u did podcast with Engineer mirza and also with M hasan ilyas and when it comes about discussing anything about shiasm u call ur childhood friend not any shia scholar Is it right and justice to the topic?

[@ThePakistanExperience]

How do you know I don’t call Shia scholars People have to agree to come on too

[@medroaster]

​​@@ThePakistanExperience So shehzad, u are also saying right. But apart from Rumors and misnomer, other topics like Hazrat Abbas as story, Zuljinah story, and bibi Zainab sa story these questions should only be asked from proper shia scholar who give u proper historical answer and concept bcz half knowledge can create more fuss than ignorance. Btw still discussing these rumors is really appreciateable. Keep doing and breaking stereotypes brother. ❤❤❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

I am trying to get one. Dua karo woh maan jayen

[@medroaster]

@@ThePakistanExperience Duain to Hamesha AP ky sath hoti hain Mola salamat rakhe Apko Shehzad bhai. Ameen. ❣️❣️ Try to bring a neutral shia scholar. Just an advice

[@s.mabbasali8790]

@@ThePakistanExperience I CAN ARRANGE ONE FOR YOU.

[@iffatabbas5391]

Lesley hazleton has written nicely on shia sunni conflict. If you like to think critically, you can raise many questions. You can even raised questions related to Islamic teaching.

[@alevelbio6529]

Enjoyed this podcast so much Absolutely loved it

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@somiishaw2572]

U spoke my heart when u said Hazrat Abbas was the most oppressed💔 (despite being the strongest) the brave lion of banu hashim.. He was ordered by Imam to stand down, despite knowing he could make enemy's blood run cold. N that was the biggest test of hazrat abbas to not fight to protect Imam where he could fight n win the war n he obeyed although it was v. difficult for him .. That war was imposed on Imam by yazid.. O Abbas nobody can imagine what u went thru. U are the sea of obedience to Allah n his appointed Imam on earth.. I've heard Mola wasn given permission to fight bcoz he could win the war n intention of Imam was not to win physically but to spread the word of truth against tyranny n if Imam would win the war, the word of truth would be blurred by ppl saying Imam fought against the Muslims n won ... So Imam chose to lose the war physically but he won actually bcoz the word of truth prevailed to all humanity n still word of Imam is prevailing. Imam a.s succeeded in his mission , n for wt he n his family n friends fought for

[@hassanzaidi1593]

Regarding why Karbala happened: Syria was conquered during the time of the third caliph and Banu Ummaya were made the governors. The people of Syria did not know the Prophet AS neither the Ahl ul Bayt. Banu Ummaiya famously knowm for their hatred of the AhleBayt instill hatred in the Syrians regarding them. Mola Ali was cursed throughout Muavias era from the mimbers of masajid. One of the point of Imam Hassan’s truce with Muavia was that this should be stopped and that he will not install a Khalifa himself after him. Both he accepted but did not adhere to and made Yazid the khalifa in his lifetime. Hence, when Karbala happened, the people of Syria having a large army was against the Ahle Bayt because they were on the side of the ruler

[@Skywimz]

Please Make a Video on the Pakistan Woman Who Celebrated Her Divorce in USA with a Party We Should Encourage Such Women, So that In this Misogynistic Society More Women Open Up

[@sarahyousif7518]

Thank GOD it took more than 7 months for someone to mention Iran and Palestinian resistance on this podcast 👏🏻

[@BeasitfyShorts]

👏 for Kumail, despite not being a scholar, he has properly advocated fiqh e Jafariya. Plus, the comedy in this podcast was amazing.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@pigeon-fd5zq]

In India no shia rumours In Pakistan many shia rumors Shows how ununited muslim live in Pakistan

[@abbasjaffery1]

Karbala has became a powerful symbol of the struggle against oppression and the importance of upholding one's beliefs even in the face of certain death. commemoration of Ashura, the day of the battle, with mourning rituals and reflections on the themes of justice, sacrifice, and resilience in the face of tyranny. It is continuous reminder of injustice and the call for struggle against injustice.

[@Vans374]

Saari umar hum betrayal ka suntay ayen hain and aaj oppression ho gai. It was about power, tribal rivalry and betrayal.baaki over the yrs jaisay jaisay log attay rahay, kahanian jhortay gaye. Aab agay ja kay pata challay ga how the real events unfolded which led to shadat of hazrat IH and his family member at karbela.

[@abbasjaffery1]

What I wrote is what has been a common knowledge, there books after books which describe these events. It was a battle of rights and wrongs.

[@muhammadmehran1812]

Ye bahut serious topic hai....being a sunni I have heard all these rumors throughout my life about shias and still are popular among sunnis....inn sab rumors ko bahut categorically deny karna chahiye tha and counter karna chahiye tha...har bath py baghair kisi waja ke hahaha hahah karna is very annoying and irritating.

[@azizrizvi2234]

سخت موضوع کو اس انداز میں لوگ تک پہنچایا جایا تو ہی بھتر ہے

[@muhammadmehran1812]

@@azizrizvi2234 میں اتفاق نہیں کرتا...ان سب باتوں کی سختی اور صفائی سے تردید ہونی چاہیے تاکہ کچھ مبہم نہ رہے

[@naveedullah7232]

​@@muhammadmehran1812 aqal mand k liyee ishara kafi hai, or enho ne tou ishare se bhar kar deny kiya hai

[@Vr90009]

Great episode . My reaction in this episode 😂😮😅😂😂😢😂😂. Too many emotions in one video . Invite him back soon .

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🤣

[@meharbanshkhan9]

That's why it is called shahzad shaikh....❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@asmer.q]

Honesty couldn't recognize kumil until he mentioned he is a physics teacher

[@stoic851]

This was so entertaining

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@arsalanshahid679]

This episode reminds me of RJ Fasi Zaka and Yasir 2006-2008 radio shows

[@blightente]

This was brilliant. Keh bhi diya jo kehna tha aur nahi bhi kaha jo kehna tha

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@syedahmadarshad3711]

This was so much needed Shahzad. While growing up, all I heard was these myths spread about the Shias. However, when someone told me about the whole Sham e Ghariban myth, I knew it couldn't be more ridiculous and started questioning everything I was told. Thank you for addressing this in a light-hearted way!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@mahnoorawan6554]

Omg .. I'm the earliest of the fans of TPE. Since i'd listened to that podcast as well when Kumayl was first invited ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@ThePakistanExperience]

OG!

[@Kulyar_g]

Shahzad Bhai bouht Maza aaya ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@Ramrasaili26]

I'm hindu but i respect Shia muslim 🙏 Shia Muslims are educated and respect everyone

[@xayyyd1532]

EPIC CONVERSATION!!! LOVE FROM NEW DELHI.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@tatheerfatima4751]

Hands down one of best episodes (refering to few others with uzair younis and syed muzamil etc). You had a list of rumours handy that is some homework..😂

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@tatheerfatima4751]

@@ThePakistanExperience I am indian Shia Muslim from Hyderabad.... appreciate your thoughts behind doing the podcast...I absolutely love your content....pls consider getting genuine Shia scholar to negate these rumours.

[@AhsanShah-xm6vp]

I have shia relatives, all of other rumors are lies, except the charpai thing(it doesn't happen now) our old shia relatives in village some time place charpai ulti, but they don't sleep on that It doesn't happen now a days.

[@muhammadabdullah7581]

I have also seen this.

[@rameezmehdi1]

It still happens and it is a UP, India tradition where we turn the charpai uprise down as it is sign of mourning and no one sleeps on the ( it's done fro 7th mohorram to 10th mohorram)

[@jabbi1234]

Mashallah great podcast

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ScientistofPolitics]

Well done Brother, But my suggestion is to invite a Shia Scholar as well on your podcast.!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

I am trying 🙌

[@smansoor1472]

I can help you if needed. Thanks​@@ThePakistanExperience

[@anasasghar5831]

great episode

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@AsBi1]

please have Akbar chaudhry on this podcast

[@AhmedHassan-uq6qu]

Refreshing to see such conversations taking place. It's about time that people should cut down on generational bull sh*t and start acting as knowledgeable people.

[@Farwaaliart]

Kumail Bhai apny tu Moula Ghaziع k masaib hi parhdiye😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@mariamtee]

The most widely held rumour I heard as a teen was that most actresses and prostitutes are Shia. The reason, supposedly, for that being that they practice temporary nikah or ‘muttah’ with their clients thus going about their dhanda guilt free. Of course this makes me laugh out loud now 😅

[@Dzine-with-tabz]

My father was sunni my mother shia. We all Siblings follow sunni fiqah. We all r married in family. Now we r searching rishta for my little brother but na hi suuni mante or na hi shiya.... hum toh beech main plans gaye hain.

[@mariamtee]

1:29:50 hahaha really funny. I listened to that ‘roast’ multiple times

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🤣

[@afshanali7054]

I would suggest everyone to read a book “ the epic shia sunni divide”