Cadillac XT4 / Mazda CX-5 / Subaru Forester - Blurring The Luxury Line?

[@theredline]

Ready for the ultimate door slamming comparison? Skip to 14:00 in the video where we compare the door closing sound of these 3 vehicles and let us know below which one you think sounds the best! ;)

[@peruprofundodance]

Redline Reviews I like the Subaru

[@naveenthemachine]

I like the sound of the CX5.

[@coffhaulic4564]

Actually, all Foresters have standard LED headlights on all trims looking from the website. Only the Sport and Touring get LED fog lights while the other trims are halogen.

[@JDMHaze]

As long as it doesn't sound ridiculously cheap I'm fine I'm not that picky about that

[@normt5463]

The XT4 is not shared with the Equinox, but with GMC Acadia.

[@michaelstephenson1585]

This type of review is a HUGE improvement over single reviews. I find this very informative with the direct comparison, side by side. Please keep doing this type of review! Very helpful!

[@huskydinosaur2860]

Ditto, but we really need a way to factor in the fact that certain brands never ever sell for close to MSRP. Some brands prefer the "omg check out 25% off" which is everyday pricing. Buy a Subaru, and expect to pay over invoice. I've never seen a Subaru with the $10K+ off advertisements that you see for GM vehicles for example.

[@blackwhirlwind1245]

Husky Dinosaur although Subaru probably doesn’t do much discount, but I am sure they are willing discount a thousand or 2 thousand off the MSRP, which is still cheaper than any of its competitors, I keep hearing from owners that they got the fully loaded sport trim forester for 2 or 3 thousands cheaper.

[@naveenthemachine]

CX5 hands down. Gorgeous looks outside and inside, great HUD, lots of torque.

[@gregholman2930]

I thought the beautiful caramel seats & infotainment unit looked better in the Caddy!

[@stephanlevesque7632]

The Mazda falls short on cargo capacity and mpg. It’s gorgeous looking and the interior is great but for me, the poor mpg and bottom dwelling cargo room rule it out for me. The forrester is too boring looks wise

[@sdhami9641]

I just wish it had a panoramic roof, then it would be perfect

[@knutnskar6796]

Mazda all the way

[@asdfghjqwertyu1858]

I know I may get hate for this, but I honestly think the Mazda has the nicest exterior out of all the three SUV"s in this video.

[@bobbowie9350]

Caddy is the worst

[@kelllessley4017]

JN DSTY I would agree, the subaru while decent looking looks like a minivan or just any other car, and the caddy is just plain ugly

[@Redfeather80]

Bob Bowie caddy interior is horrid

[@emptysaint]

It's def the most feminine of the trio. Best soccer mom ride by far.

[@Finestizpro]

Nope your right im caddy fan but now im a huge mazda fan as long as they keep there fun to drive mentality

[@truckercowboyed2638]

*Chevrolet Equinox has left the chat*

[@normt5463]

Not on the Equinox platform with Terrain and Envision.

[@truckercowboyed2638]

@@normt5463 so the terrain is the same platform as the Cadillac

[@normt5463]

@@truckercowboyed2638 Cadillac is assembled with Acadia on a version of the Epsilon platform. The three I mentioned above are in the D2XX(Delta)platform.

[@truckercowboyed2638]

@@normt5463 what about the old equinox. It's even smaller than the new one

[@normt5463]

@@truckercowboyed2638 that was on the Theta platform and not used anymore.

[@97I30T]

The Forester is boring, but it’s easily the most well rounded vehicle here. It probably makes the most sense for most buyers. Personally I’d choose the CX-5 though.

[@forza388]

Forester does better offroad and in snow then the other 2 😁

[@truckercowboyed2638]

Who came just for the triple door closures???

[@JDMHaze]

Edward Enterline I didn't but it was a nice little bonus

[@carstartups623]

Edward Enterline me!

[@BruceLeedar]

When I go to a dealership, I don't ask for a test drive: I open and close the front door and check to see if the glovebox is damped and lined with felt.

[@barrygoldwasser5449]

@@BruceLeedar LMAO! Good one!

[@JDMHaze]

BruceLeedar 😂😂😂😂

[@robertschneider3391]

I’ll take the Mazda CX-5. Mainly because of how it drives, premium looks, and price. Definitely get your moneys worth.

[@tommy13965]

Your big smile on the cx5 run says it all lol.

[@jordancatcher6663]

I'd take the CX-5 , a decently equipped pakage with adequate power for speed and space for needs. The Forester is ok if you're looking for a comfortable and nicely equipped everyday car for seniors and need longevity (Not sure about that cvt though). As for the xt4 , 55k ?! That's a no for me when there's the much nicer mid level xt5 that's equipped with almost everything the xt4 has with a v6 , although I do like the xt4.

[@normt5463]

Same reason some would choose a $32K BMW or Mercedes, XT4 and CX-5 2.5T can match it on price in the low $30's with AWD, which do you want to pull up to the valet in? I have yet to see a valet park a Mazda out front and Subaru owners are provided a free pair of Birkenstocks to walk from the re.ote parking lot.

[@andersonrodriguez8258]

Well he Mazda transmission too is made by jatco/Nissan just like subaru so we not sure about both

[@tonychau1983]

@@andersonrodriguez8258 Subaru makes their own cvt

[@casualsuede]

Subaru for seniors? Try again. With mazda, Subaru has one of the youngest ownership demo (fourth with mazda as #1).

[@jordancatcher6663]

@@casualsuede yup , that's why the average age of a Forester buyer is 61 , the more you know. 🤷♂ Didn't mean subie as a brand is a seniors car , but the Forester in particular is.

[@michaelcolarusso7545]

I own a '19 Signature trim CX-5. There is just no way to get 18 mpg in typical driving. For the first 500 miles I've averaged 24.5 mpg in a mix of city and highway driving. IMHO, you'd have to be doing a 0-60 test from every stop light to average 18 mpg. Unless there was something terribly wrong with the tested vehicle in this video, to present a 9 mpg differential between the Forester and CX-5 is misleading to potential buyers.

[@Newzchspy]

Michael Colarusso when you do a half-baked comparison with no real objective numbers, then there's going to be inaccuracies. Thanks for your input as an owner and not as just a reviewer.

[@drbatteries]

It might need a few more miles on it, my first couple tanks I was getting 17-18 as well (with a heavy foot). Now I have about 1900 miles on my Signature and the life time average has crept up to 20.3. Wish it was a touch higher, but the turbo engine is so much fun I can live with it.

[@thethespian5757]

Of the three Mazda would get my money.

[@JDMHaze]

Floyd Dellon EASILY!!!

[@fcg243]

Mazda would also be my choice 👌🏻

[@wbwayne8887]

A shame for Mazdathat the general public doesn't share in your belief. They build such competitive and solid vehicles in all of their segments. It should be reflected in sales, but unfortunately for Mazda, it is isn't.

[@eleanormassaro5195]

God, I just love the CX5! And in that red paint it is just gorgeous! And what’s great about the CX-5 is if you want to get better gas mileage, you can get a grand touring NA engine, plus it will cost less. Just like Sofyan, the Mazda puts a big old smile on my face! I actually like the Cadillac too, but it would have to be about 10 grand less with a lot of those features coming standard and not nickel and diming you to death with the options😁👍🏻

[@jeffr.3464]

Eleanor Massaro, oddly CR only reports averaging 24mpg with the NA engine. Not sure what the fuelly.com average is.

[@copa8]

I bought the Forester a few months ago. Loving it, especially during the past winter.

[@joecovey2235]

I agree with you. Out of those three choices, the winner and the one I'd buy would be the CX5.

[@boa4533]

I think the only thing conventional vehicles need to do is to upgrade their design like Mazda has been doing. I don't see why I would spend 20k more for a badge.

[@FromQnz2King]

RIP Cadillac. Got a CX5 couldn’t be more happier driving it around. It feels more like a sedan than an SUV when driving.

[@normt5463]

The XT4 is al ost a full second faster than CX-5 2.5t around Motor Trend's figure-8 handling test.

[@FromQnz2King]

Norm T 50k to be one second faster? Cadillac loves customers like you 😉.

[@mbukukanyau]

FromQnz2King , man, the Cadillac ownership experience is worth the price difference

[@ryanlittleton5615]

@@FromQnz2King Norm is a GM salesman actually.

[@copa8]

@@mbukukanyau LMAO!

[@butterfly2847]

*Mazda all day everyday. Can't wait to buy Mazda 3!* 🚘

[@shashankshekhar2611]

I bought one a year ago, it is a great car :)

[@fahada783]

Wish u all success to buy it and enjoy it.

[@armandocortez9995]

Trash Subaru

[@zackeryjones2314]

I would pick the Mazda CX-5 one cause it's nice looking two the interior it has luxury like premium materials and three it has more power than both than the Subaru Forester and the Cadillac XT4

[@JaredRosenholtz]

Great job Sofyan! Comparing three vehicles and keeping all of those facts straight takes a crazy amount of work.

[@yeaboy172007]

mazda have been moving up this pass few years man, they stepping up

[@normt5463]

Mazda Skyactiv is not winning the fuel economy race with this car.

[@Redfeather80]

They’re also way more expensive nowadays

[@remyd8767]

@@Redfeather80 exactly. They moved up because they got more expensive

[@penvon]

Have they fixed their rust issues?

[@justinfontaine5539]

Mazda is on a roll now making some excellent vehicles. I'm still amazed how many people do not shop this brand. I guess that shows how many people car about driving a fun car or even driving at all.

[@TheYellowSchoolBusDude]

LED Headlights are a standard feature on the Forester.

[@Maheenstar1]

LED headlights are actually standard on the 2019 Forester.

[@coltseavers6298]

Same with the Apple Car Play and Android Auto, too. He needs to research the Forester better.

[@jasonkresock2196]

And the same enjine, and eyesight. Best deal from the base up.

[@deet4895]

it's a easy choice, the Mazda CX-5.

[@itsuyoko]

Thanks for this really helpful review! Love the style. We are convinced to getting a Mazda CX-5 2019 Signature trim.

[@rashaudl.1605]

That XT4 is really growing on me...the others are nice to.

[@yellowglass2260]

The fact that you can spin the tires in the Mazda means it’s not full time AWD like the Subaru. You can probably spin the tires on the non turbo cx5 with traction control off as well.

[@ALEX-sh3tx]

What's the point of including the Cadillac if you were just going to move it out the way anyway ?

[@johnnytampocao7671]

CX-5 all the way, I'm not concerned about the space, I love the looks and driving pleasure you can get from it. I am very optimistic and excited about the next Gen of this car that Mazda will address all the concern of the viewers like the space, paddle shifter, camera resolution and new infotainment system and it certainly be better than the current model in every detail like the new Mazda 3 which is superb.🏎🏎🏎

[@eleanormassaro5195]

Johnny Tampocao I agree. I wish I was in need of a new car because I would definitely seriously consider the CX-5 right now. But I’m almost finished paying off my 2010 RX 350 and it still rides like new, and absolutely no issues with it😌

[@inodesnet]

The interesting thing here is that although Mazda is a mainstream brand, and therefore the dash stitching would be assume to be faux stitching.... it actually is real stitching. A little known fact is that the dash assemblies, for decades have been put together by a women only team. They recently decided to up their materials on the dash, which meant adding real stitched leather components. Even the metal additions to the dash and doors is now real machined metal instead of coloured plastic. Very nice touch Mazda! They have highlighted this in their new video: "Tailored to you". Although I was hearing about this last year on my trip to their main factory in Hiroshima, Japan.

[@ms3173]

Mazda said they are a premium brand.

[@JTL-uv6cm]

I really like the Mazda. It's interior is really nice for what you pay for. The Forester is definitely the better family vehicle. I like the Caddy but its price is too high for what you get.

[@ConnecticutDashcam]

Everyone saying “$55k for an equinox no thanks!!” As if every aspect of the XT4 was equal to the equinox.. even if they’re not direct competition, put them both side by side and compare fit and finish, material quality, features, you’ll see why it costs a good deal more

[@coltseavers6298]

Subaru also has Apple Car Play and Android Auto standard on ALL models.

[@jasonkresock2196]

100 percent best from Base up!

[@jasonkresock2196]

And standard LED from base up

[@xlprincess123567]

The subaru Forester has better space and not cramped like the Mazda and cadillac. I would rather buy the subaru.

[@KraziVokalz]

First and per most car enthusiast usual, Subaru’s customer wouldn’t cross shop anything here except for the Mazda 5 and that’s a big if. People who follow the Subaru brand looks for practicality, functionality, dependability, longevity and resale value. How many of those could the other 2 check off???. I’LL Wait. If you want to do a comparison, compare cars with their competitors. Not something that they’ll never see. The only time these cars would meet is at Whole Foods. *Cadillac would’ve just came for whole wheat bread and fresh cut turkey breast *Mazda would’ve came for Lactose Free milk, farm raised eggs, and tonight’s dinner *And Subaru would have enough room for a months worth of groceries, plus space for a new flat screen tv and movies to watch after tonight’s great meal. And for those of you buying for looks, please study : Reliability Cost to own Crash test ratings Consumers Report ratings Brand report Cards And Resale value In a year that $55,000 caddy will be the same price as a base 2020 Subaru Impreza. And the Mazda might get you $18,000 if you’re lucky... Research people.....

[@adam1abe]

I have to say that i'm just in love with the visibility of the forrester, you feel like you're in a cookpit! having said that i'd pick the mazda, but i'll wait for the new skyactiv-x engines with the better milage per liter! difinetely a gorgeous car!

[@chekvb]

Forester is the most practical and the best family car in the group.

[@v60polestar88]

You mean boring and uninspiring!!

[@worrywart1311]

You must be thinking of Toyota, @@v60polestar88

[@v60polestar88]

Worrywart Nope!! WRX is the only inspirational car in Subaru line up..BRZ nope to slow don’t care how well it handles plus Toyota has a version too. You buy a Subaru for point A to B transportation. CVT transmissions and underpowered engines make for a dreadful driving experience aka boring. Notice how the Legacy sedan isn’t even mentioned in the same Camry, Accord, or 6. BORING

[@worrywart1311]

@@v60polestar88 Guess what, a car is transportation, as you will discover when you've grown up.

[@v60polestar88]

Worrywart You proved my point. You’ve Subaru target customer. Boring, lifeless, soulless, and probably a beta male. Leave car talk to enthusiast and worry about your stamp collection

[@jordynhixson655]

Love these side by side reviews. I think this has been the best video I've seen in a while. Can't wait for you to do this with affordable performance cars and crossovers. Thank you Sofyan!

[@jrthetravelingsalesman6357]

I sell Cadillacs and this XT4 is incredible, they have a lot of “GO” to them with the Turbo and the car itself it’s flawless. They are beautiful in person, especially the sport versions. This video does the XT4 NO justice.

[@SlickJeff2020]

With Subaru you feel your time traveling back to 1980s.

[@canmtb4676]

Another failure from GM. CX-5 is always a winner. And love my 2017 cx5 GT and 2019 cx9 Sig. the torque of 2.5T makes you smile all the times.

[@worrywart1311]

Sitting in bumper to bumper traffic the turbo is of no benefit so I'll take the extra space, view and airiness of the Subaru, thanks.

[@justinfontaine5539]

Mazda all day long. Forester while "all new" it is still the choice if you want no driving dynamics. Only good thing about the Subaru is their AWD system. Cadillac doesn't even compare at 20k more and you'll probably be using the warranty often. No brainer here.

[@Stressless2023]

That Cadillac looks the best (to me). The Mazda seems like the best overall value. And the Subaru looks the worst.

[@CalebRulez2]

I'm pretty sure LED headlights are standard for the 19 Forester. Upper trims might get adaptive ones but LEDs are standard I do believe.

[@blackwhirlwind1245]

Caleb Koeshall limited and touring also gets steering responsive headlights

[@dragSD666]

Subaru looks a little ugly.. that front:/

[@sergeihanush2262]

I would say Subaru is not luxury just because of how it looks like

[@Newzchspy]

As a rule, Subarus are ugly. Only decent looking Subie is Legacy and WRX......

[@La-yt1wr]

The grill looks so similar to the 2010 or 2011 Forester

[@aayonce4]

And can we give the Camera man some love omg !! Awesome work!

[@casualsuede]

If I were an outdoorsy person I would get the subaru. If I lived a suburban lifestyle, I'd get a mazda. If I had a lot of money.....I'd get a lexus.

[@worrywart1311]

But which Lexus? I'd be happiest in an Outback, and I'm not at all outdoorsy.

[@subazealand9158]

I like the CX-5, and recently drove the 2.5 Turbo. Amazing how nice looks and feels, everyone talks so good about the premium feeling it has, but I personally like the SUV to feel more like I'm driving something less urban, and more rugged/off road (otherwise I'd go for a wagon), so I go for the Forester in this test.

[@cloudjc22]

Really enjoy this type of comparison. Do more of these please!!

[@ericb.9907]

The CX5 win hands down for those that don't need extra room. Gorgeous inside and out - I wish it had the brown leather of the Caddi to add some color inside though -

[@travelerfourever1347]

As always, I love your reviews. You are the best. We bought a 2021 Mazda CX-5 Signature in red. I really like how it drives and its quite cabin. Please keep making vehicle reviews.

[@ZuMi_rcf]

Forester owner here - definitely has the visibility and practicality for a family. But Mazda stepped up their game. It would be nice to see the CX5 with the new Mazda 3 interior.

[@carbrickscity]

IMO the interior of the CX5 Signature is on par with the new Mazda3 Premium. I own the new Mazda3.

[@johnnytampocao7671]

That is coming definitely next year or in the up coming next generation of this magnificent compact SUV. I love the CX-5, this is definitely I'm looking to trade my Montero.🏎🏎🏎

[@97I30T]

GC Angeles I’d say to expect most Mazdas to get a similar interior to the new Mazda3 in the coming years as the other models are redesigned.

[@EM.1.]

I thought I was the only one thinking all 3 are compatible, thank you for proving me right. I have the 2017 CX-5 and actually did look at the XT-4 but the price just kills it.

[@caglioso]

I have to assume you can get a good dealer discount on the xt4? Otherwise that’s an absurd price for what it is.

[@gregholman2930]

Yeah, I like the new Chevy Blazer but it too is way over priced! It seems that all of General Motors's products are way over priced!

[@caglioso]

Greg Holman yea that’s why I’m inclined to think you can get a good chunk off the msrp, can’t imagine anyone paying near the sticker for those.

[@jaylee8703]

55K ?? Go look on autotrader.. they have the XT4's for 31k without high level package and only FWD which in most areas is totally adequate.

[@GraysonCarr]

XT4 without high level packages has less features than even a middle trim Forester though. They are really stripped down. Cadillac doesn't even allow you to option in basic features like adaptive cruise control unless you get one of the top two trims.

[@project_calais4977]

I may be biased, but the CX5 is the best in my opinion. I love the brand though funny enough I don't own a Mazda. Purely for the sake of looks, features and brand recognition, the Mazda sits in first place. That being said we don't have Cadillac as a brand in Australia, not anymore at least. So it makes it harder to personally judge it against both the Subaru and Mazda given those two are sold here. Interesting comparison though! Great video as always!

[@tigerfan8244]

I like the upscale look and feel of the Mazda and they are great vehicles, but it falls in versatility and useable space which is one reason you buy an SUV, so I would go with the Forester. You couldn’t give me the Cadillac with it’s subpar reliability, low resale value, radio screen that will stop working, and ridiculous asking price.

[@wasiuuu1]

Finally Mazda gets fair review . just got two mazdas CX5 GT turbo , very happy with them, thx U for the review :-)

[@Smallvillefreak]

I’d most likely go with the Subaru despite my love for Cadillac. But the Mazda definitely has my attention.

[@gregholman2930]

The Sub. needs better paint & wheels to give it a more premium appearance! It looks like plain Jane as presently presented!

[@cristianjimenez3657]

Looking at the three, I’d honestly still take the RDX over the three.

[@user-nu1ci6ps2j]

Yeah i just got me sh awd rxd for $40k..nice ride!!!

[@MrAzzaaa]

LED headlights are standard on all trims of the forester, but only the limited and touring get the steering responsive headlights

[@swanblake]

Just a grear honest take here by him. Great review. The CVT is never luxury. Subaru is instantly out. Just no. I'd take the Mazda CX5 or Acura RDX over pretty much any SUV in its class size. Cadillac on the Other hand is so overpriced its insulting. Volvo XC40 in its class would be my choice. X2 is you want something sporty

[@ryanlittleton5615]

110% agree.

[@erictorres4923]

The Cadillac does have fog lights they are integrated on the bottom of the LED strip.

[@trelane88]

Just ordered me a 50k 2016 Grand Touring CX5 today. Can't wait to pick it up Sunday!

[@joshua38410]

I wouldn’t pay 35k for the Cadillac much less 55k, it’s unreliable and the Mazda is better in a lot of ways.

[@ALEX-sh3tx]

No one vehicle is alike so how can you say something is unreliable? Any vehicle can have issues...your statement is so ignorant

[@joshua38410]

Trenton_ A ignorant?? Son you must know nothing about cars. GM is one of the worst manufacturers as far as reliability that there exists. On top of the 55k price tag, you would be either rich or poor and stupid to buy it. Buy a Cadillac, you’ll soon see what I’m saying.

[@rashaudl.1605]

You've never own a Cadillac I'm sure so how would you know?

[@cheeweiloy1156]

Rashaud L. Don’t have to own one. There r reliability reports out there.

[@joshua38410]

Rashaud L. Yeah I’ve never owned one because I’ve already seen what happens when you buy one....have you no eyes to read a article?

[@joeniederhofer2566]

I have a Forester, my sister has a new CX5 (non turbo). The CX5 is a bit more premium feeling, but the Subaru seems MUCH roomier, enhanced by big, wide seats and a huge greenhouse. For a tallish guy like myself (6'3"), that is luxury! Both are great, though - can't go wrong with either.

[@Sirgromulus]

We own both in our family and I concur.

[@VB-3]

Pound for pound the Forester is the best option. Best MPG, most capacity, most passenger space, best safety tech system (eyesight), best AWD, best ground clearance, best visibility, best resale, lowest insurance, lowest depreciation.

[@bobbowie9350]

Caddy lower intake belongs in the rear. So cheap and misplaced

[@protochris]

18 mpg is inexcusable for the Mazda, especially since it has the least amount of room. That's a deal breaker if you have a family and live in California (high gas prices).

[@scottlynch5804]

Who would buy that Cadillac at $55K? That's a $40K car at best.

[@blackwhirlwind1245]

Scott Lynch at $40, I can buy the fully loaded new outback and still get sporty feel with XT turbo engine and luxurious interior.

[@Jeffjones12234]

No matter how many reviews I see on KZbin for vehicles, anything with a CVT is an automatic out for me at this point. Always love your reviews!

[@AFLive]

Gosh Great 👍🏾 Review But You Feel sooooo RUSHED! My heart-rate definitely kept speeding up listening to you lol 😆

[@harryli6138]

first of all, love the comparison video btw, even tho im not buying any of these rn. my suggestion is next time you get a base Cadillac, for around 35-40k, and than compare it to fully loaded subarus or mazads etc... that way they have a same price tag, and we will see which one is worth the money, respectively. tho for me im gonna pick the mazda cx5 as well, the difference on every aspect feels like more than just $4k. the Cadillac, 55k, I would rather get a bmw x3 stuff like that, even tho I know im not getting as many features in the bmw as I am in the Cadillac, but still.

[@eleanormassaro5195]

That soul red color on the CX-5 is 🔥! I like the looks of the Cadillac too, but it’s just too overpriced for what you get!

[@jmay5583]

2020 to 2022 xt4 has had big improvements. I recommend doing a new video with an updated comparison. Supercruise, brakes, handling, the active sport suspension, etc. And comparative to other luxury brands has great performance. I test drove a gtr Mazda cx5 and xt4, and much prevered the xt4. Wierd to listen to you say it didn't feel that way for you. Mazda also drinks fuel, and is less reliable. Cx5 has an bad feeling ride and I drive a civic as my daily to compare lol.

[@MrNemo721]

The CX5 turbo is Mazda's equivalent to the now discontinued foresterXT and frankly it is better inside and out so I'd take it hands down.

[@blackwhirlwind1245]

DangerousDan when Subaru refresh forester, I hope they put 2.4L turbo in forester, the same one in new outback and ascent, that means if more and more people buying the XT outback, I am sure Subaru will bring back the XT Forester once again.

[@nosah8415]

I'd take the Subaru just because I've always loved the Forester. But that Mazda is so nice. I'd take either over the Cadillac. $55k for subpar reliability and terrible resale? No thanks.

[@NileshR12]

That interior color is the exact color interior I'd consider for the XT4. I'd be torn between the brown & light gray interior colors

[@tntmyth]

I really like the Mazda but the rear seats won't fold down flat without scooting the front seat forward or taking out the headrests. There is also a learning curve on the Mazda infotainment. The cargo capacity is limited.

[@mbukukanyau]

Anyone who has been paying attention knows that XT4 is more closely related to the Buick Regal or Lacrosse or Chevy Malibu as it sits on all new variation of the Epsilon II platform. And that platform is widely acclaimed for its premium feel. Contrastingly, the Equinox is on the Delta platform which it is a variation with the Chevy Cruze Opel Astra. In fact, when introduced both GM and Cadillac said that it is on its own unnamed platform. The idea that this is related to the Equinox is an anti-Cadillac disinformation campaign. It’s origins are not a state secret for crying out loud.

[@oliverroo59]

LED headlights are standard on every new Forester (including the base base base trim) for 2019.

[@worrywart1311]

And once the new Legacy/ Outback get the new turbo next year, expect it to turn up in the Forester as well by the year after.

[@wingmanhoy3999]

I like the Subaru Forester out of them all, style, practicality, Symetrical AWD unbeaten for New England weather and off road ability, comfort, convenience, safety, and amenities, for my money #1 hands down the very best as good as it gets, and I also think its the best looking, also best gas mileage, and range, this vehicle is not just for families.

[@joecanis484]

I purchased a 2018 Subaru Forester Touring XT with the 2.0 turbo. It beats these three in every category that I value. It is faster, better volume, better greenhouse, more comfortable, and cost me much less than the Mazda or Cadillac. The other features you cover are not worth the money unless people think the moniker is worth thousands of dollars for some imagined bragging rights.

[@alkoma4586]

Not faster at all unless you're comparing with the non turbo

[@oans84]

Great review Sofyan!! As always. Love the CX-5 definitely, for single guys, like us lol, it's the better choice, although, if I had the money...... I'll buy a Volvo XC-40 R Design 🤪 with all the "toys"

[@UhhhhhnooOOo00oO]

Oh...what production value and editing in this one. CR gave the Forester the top score in it's class. It proves as always, more money equals better car, (all cars here) unless you go American. (really United States of America brands)

[@paulm6481]

I don’t think the Caddy is worth 50k, may take it in low 30s. Otherwise I take the Subaru of the three.

[@ericb.4358]

DISCLAIMER: I own a 2019 MAZDA CX-5 Grand TouringReserve (2.5 L. turbo, AWD) and given its 5 star crash test rating, great steering feel and very good handling plus its MANY safety and convenience features I'll STILL take it over the Caddy. And then there is the US $15,000. lower price than the Cadillac. BTW I removed my "low rent" prop rod and installed dual gas hood struts. MUCH nicer. NOTE: If you run 100 octane gas in a turbo CX-5 you will feel POWER! Glad the ECU is programmed to handle 100 octane gas.

[@Dr.Speller]

I must’ve missed the point in time where things shifted to where sportiness in SUVs was something people were really looking for. Maybe I’m just old school in associating luxury with smooth rides and SUVs with body-on-frame. 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@tonychau1983]

Everything lifted is a SUV now.

[@AshwinF1Bloke]

The CX5 all the way! Love what Mazda is doing with their products. That Subaru, while being functional, looks, feels and has the appeal of an upmarket hearse van. Why does it sell in buckets astonishes me!

[@copa8]

Better AWD system dawg. In the snow/ice, you're more likely to end up in a hearse driving the Mazda than the Subaru.

[@rog351]

Excellent review and great to see the comparison. Also, I would really really like for you to do the same with the Cadillac XT5 currently .... or better yet with the upgraded XT5 when it is available at end of this year. Thanks.

[@brybrysofly4093]

First off, snaps for the triple door closing lol. I don’t think the Caddy stood a chance. For $55k, that is just not worth it. Like you said; if it was ten grand less and had a bit more space in the rear and the truck, it would be an good choice (minus the gauges). I would’ve chosen the Subie for practicality (in another color and with the more powerful engine). The Mazda though, it stirs and emotion and jars a reaction. It would be my choice as well just because the Subie isn’t as powerful in this test and because of that horrid color lol

[@zangaraj2]

LED headlights are standard on the Forester. The only thing that is optional is the steering-responsive feature.

[@theaeronauticalchannel446]

the forester with the seats up has 35.4 cu ft. of space. w/ the seats down it is 76.8 cu ft. of space.

[@justinstewart950]

I see soooo many CX-5s on the road here in the GTA, Ontario

[@bradleyhankin]

If the new Outback has the same interior as the new Legacy, it will definitely close the gap between the Mazda, especially with the new turbo engine.

[@normt5463]

The Regal TourX best them all with 295 lb-ft of torque(316 lb-ft of torque on overboost), torque vectoring awd and low $20' entry price.

[@bradleyhankin]

@@normt5463 Yes the TourX is a very nice wagon.

[@dennisdrogo2473]

Except the Premium lux XT4 does not sticker for $55k, the Sport Trim is an "eye watering" $56k if you get everything. The trim doesn't determine the price, it determines the features. A feature less Sport XT4 MSRP is $44k or a completely built Prem Lux at $51. This is a weird comparison, is there a yacht vs fishing boat somewhere on this channel? Do you have the luxury to purchase a new vehicle or can you just barely afford a new one?

[@bobbowie9350]

10:15. sorry but the center stack looks just odd. its a hardpoint nightmare with the heat/AC controls being way too low. it looks better than the one they replaced but it will look completely dated and weird in a few years.

[@yuryb2802]

Mazda cx-5, hands down

[@geigerzoola6642]

Gosh just get the Mazda....Fin

[@hxcmusiclife]

I'd take the Mazda any day, even the Subaru

[@jasonkresock2196]

Between the 2 , I'm going Subaru. Better for use in the north. Stomps the shit out of the Mazda off road. He's acting like a soccer mom. Since when does being S.U.V. not count in an SUV? No mention of 4 wheel, down hill decent control, or the 3 tire control settings. Very Disappointing comparisons. He clearly favors the Mazda, though as an S.U.V., the Forester is FAR superior.

[@peteg4328]

I have a 18 CX9 but damn when did CX5 cost up to 39k? My CX9 only cost me 38k out the door, and much larger and spacious...lol. Well given it only the 2nd trim from base but it got almost everything this 39k CX5 got except for HUD, ventilated seat and steering wheel heater, and AWD. Even does better in mpg than this CX5, and hold up to 7 passengers, better rear seat vent control, have rear seat sunshade built in on 2nd row. Now this really got my head scratching, now to have everything this CX5 has in CX9, it only cost 5k more in GT trim, almost seems like CX9 is a better value compare to CX5.