Asics Gel-Nimbus 25 vs New Balance More v4: Which is the best max-cushioned shoe?

The New Balance More v4 and Asics Gel-Nimbus 25 are big shoes built to provide the last word in comfort on your easy and long runs, and both are very good at that job. However, there are plenty of differences between them, starting with the price, since the Gel-Nimbus is considerably more expensive than the More v4.
In this video Run Testers Mike, Tom and Nick talk through the pros and cons of each shoe and say which they’d opt for if you’re in the market for a max-cushioned shoe.
Check out our full reviews of both shoes:
Asics Gel-Nimbus 25 Multi-Tester Review: • Asics Gel-Nimbus 25 Re...
New Balance Fresh Foam X More v4 Review: • New Balance Fresh Foam...
JUMP STRAIGHT IN:
00:00​​​​ - Intro
00:17 - Design & Key Stats
02:29 - How’s The Fit?
03:41 - The Run Test
15:18 - Verdict & Alternatives
Subscribe to The Run Testers for more running gear reviews:
kzbin.info...
Asics Gel-Nimbus 25 vs Novablast 3: • Asics Gel-Nimbus 25 vs...
Brooks Glycerin 20 Multi-Tester Review: • Brooks Glycerin 20 Mul...
The Run Testers Awards 2022: • The Best Running Shoes...
New Balance Fresh Foam X More V4 Vs Nike Invincible Run 2: • New Balance Fresh Foam...
Brooks Glycerin 20 vs Nike Infinity Run 3: • Brooks Glycerin 20 vs ...
Saucony Tempus Multi-tester Review: • Saucony Tempus Multi-t...
Nike React Infinity Run Flyknit 3 Multi-Tester Review: • Nike React Infinity Ru...
Best Running Shoes 2022: • The Best Running Shoes...

[@cwalker1569]

Thank you both for two different views on the two shoes. I feel like both are good shoes but have to agree that at the price difference I would try the More first. Also we are getting closer to the More v5 discussions....

[@rachaelmonnelfit]

Did not think I’d like the new balance more v4 but I’m obsessed with it for my long/easy day runs. Soo comfortable!!.

[@MiracleWarriors]

Yah, the Gel-Nimbus keeps changing a lot with every interaction. I had the Nimbus 21 to 24 so far and the 21 was stiff and heavy but super stable, the #22 was still firm and stable but was a lot less heavy and more breathable . Then the #23 was extremely comfortable for walking, probably the most comfortable shoe for walking that I ever had but for running was just ok. Was like running in the beach where my feet sinks in the sand. Then the most versatile, quick and lightweight came : Gel-Nimbus 24. What a shoe ! It beat every lightweight daily trainer I had. Last year and years before. Can't wait to try the Gel-Nimbus 25, a new experience is about to initiate for me in 2023.

[@rotcod1771]

With the rocker in the v4, I can keep a good pace. Ran a 10k and tried to keep an easy 10 minute pace, but it was responsive and did a 9:30 pace, it was nice and snappy up hills

[@roostermiller]

It would be interesting to see how they would stack up if the drops where both 4mm or both 8mm. Because that changes the ride. I have found that in max stack shoes 0mm to 5mm you don't notice it as much because of the the stack height, but when you go to 8mm you can really feel the forward angle. Ran in Altra Olympus (3, 3.5 & 4) 0mm, Hoka (Clifton, Rincon, Mach) 5 to 6mm, NB more V4 4mm. Saucony (speed 2) 8mm, really notice the difference in the Saucony.

[@dawncyclist]

got the nimbus 25 today. ran 6km and it is a comfy shoe! i had zoom fly5 which is crap and this as my shoe for slow easy run. I wouldnt use it as a tempo. i got the black metallic and i will def use it for work lol

[@Thomasrice07]

Nimbus is the clear winner for me. I am a heavy runner and for all the cushioning in the More v4, it still leaves my legs sore. Not so with the Nimbus. It is the most comfortable ride that I have experienced. Asics built a quality shoe in this version.

[@sptnk87]

Have you tried the Nike invincible shoes? I’m kinda heavy and I’m liking the Nike so far.

[@saiken811]

Great! That's all I need to hear!

[@rygi23]

Agree. I tried both and chose Nimbus. The upper felt better and the cushioning felt much plusher.

[@AngryPatriotss]

I have both invincible and nimbus and I feel like nimbus is more robust foam , not as bouncy and playful as invincible but lot more durable. Nimbus is still not broken in but I like them both a lot. I just wish the invincible was more durable. Less than a month and the traction pads are starting to separate on the invincible.

[@mouahmong]

Define heavy? I’m a heavier runner at 225 lbs and I prefer the more v4 due to the lower drop. It’s my recovery day shoe.

[@ericguqin]

cant wait for nimbus 25 on sale to pick up a pair!

[@rygi23]

I tried on both at the store and chose the Nimbus. Felt a little better in every way. The cushioning had a much plusher feel to it.

[@esalinas916]

I just received both today. I have a left ankle issue so my needs are different. The gel nimbus is nice and bouncy but the NB More v4 is more stable and more comfortable and easier for me to slip in more like a Hoka. Going to use the NB for everyday and Asics for running.

[@mickyward3716]

The heel sink from the split design midsole on the v4 did not work for me at all. It also was to roomy and felt like a brick on foot. The nimbus has the best upper in the game and in my opinion is my choice as an athlete nearing 190 lbs also makes an amazing walking shoe.

[@Strongforthem365]

Had the nimbus for about 4 weeks. Loved the midsole bounce/energy return and really enjoyed them. For some reason as they broke in, i was unable to keep my midfootfoot locked down. Foot slid around and started to blister my forefoot and pinky toes on any run over 6 or so miles. Just exchanged for the More. Hoping to have better experience!

[@faiznakarema3030]

how does it feel now? more v4 better than nimbus or not?

[@Strongforthem365]

@@faiznakarema3030 very glad with my decision! Actually just broke 100 miles in the More v4 this week. Not as much bounce, but really enjoy the smooth rolling sensation in the new balance. Fits my foot shape great and no hotspots. Worn them up to half marathon distance with no issues at all. Both great shoes and you can't go wrong either way.

[@gauravbathija6783]

Yeah I agree with you about the 1080 v12. Even walking in the shoe has this dead feeling where there is no energy return and it doesn't feel particularly soft. I came from the Ultraboost 22 and much prefer that after having tried the 1080 v12 over the last week or so. Ordered the nimbus 25. Excited to get it in my hands and on my feet.

[@stonerc27]

How was the Nimbus 25 compared to the 1080V12?

[@gauravbathija6783]

@@stonerc27 Nimbus 25 is way more plush than the 1080v12 when it comes to cushioning. Probably one of my favorites so far. The energy return is pretty good as well.

[@stonerc27]

@@gauravbathija6783 great to hear, and much thanks for the reply.

[@mattw785]

More v4 is great but I found it narrower on 1 foot, very odd. The rocker is great. The Nimbus felt like you said similar, would prefer the Nimbus. Both are great.

[@DV1979]

New Balance 1080 v12 is wider and better than More V14. I would compare between Nimbus 25 and 1080 v12

[@shirrinvisetpukdi3869]

I got both shoes and I prefer the Nimbus 25. The rocker geometry in the V4 is definitely better than the Nimbus25 but because the upper of the V4 is a bit voluminous for my thin (but a bit wide) feet, the Nimbus25 feels less clunky for a max cushion shoes. The outsole of the V4 maybe a bit better but the I prefer the upper material of the Nimbus25 (I had the wide US8 size for the Nimbus and a regular US8 for the V4).

[@bev9708]

Very interesting and useful, thanks guys, and I couldn't agree more with Tom's point about the cost... it's gotten ridiculous quite frankly so videos like this for me are strictly for future reference when they go on sale!! I would REALLY appreciate a comparison with the Triumph 20 if that's possible, which seems a bit more versatile than these 2 perhaps?? I'm a fan of the Nimbus Lite myself, though again, only worth it on sale imho, and I do LOVE my NB More Trail V2.

[@peter7371]

Yeah ever since I tried the Triumph man I do not take that shoe off. It feels comfortable, bouncy and soft enough, w/o being as exaggerated as the Invincible.

[@bev9708]

@@peter7371 Ohhhhh you’re making me salivate Pedro!!! 😂😂

[@i.p2088]

I have the Triumph 20. Extremely comfortable and good energy return.

[@mr.h.9103]

@@i.p2088 How does the Triumph handle the long run? I need a good long run shoe. I tired the More v4, drop was too low for my right Achilles. I need at least 8 mill drop right now.

[@peter7371]

@@mr.h.9103 great one for long runs. The new pwrrun + foam is so light and soft that also helps if you need to pick up the pace during that long run imo. But also just a cruiser during easy days

[@user-so8kx7uj2x]

NB More V4 for life!!! It's the most well rounded classic max cushioned shoe. Also, very reliable! The midsole almost never dies

[@hongqichin]

right now if there is just one max cushion shoe and one daily trainer that you guys would recommend, which shoes will they be

[@yavuzbolluk3363]

I'm very happy asics nimbus 25

[@PremsaiT]

Hi , which one do you suggest for working long shifts like 8 hrs please?

[@dumitrupreda6161]

Shame to Asics in UK 🇬🇧 the price difference is huge , that’s not to mention New Balance doing frequently 30 or 40% discounts and this is like half price of Nimbus 25

[@danieltay1052]

Nick, as the unofficial spokesperson for Puma Velocity Nitro 2(and thanks for your consistency in recommending the shoes, I went ahead and grabbed one) how is the cushion and bounce/responsiveness of Nimbus 25 and More V4 against your all time favourite, Puma Velocity Nitro 2? They maybe in the different categories, but I am curious on how much more cushion or bounce is the max cushion shoes offering against supercritical foam like the Nitro. Again, thanks for your great recommendation, loving my Puma Velocity Nitro 2

[@peter7371]

You know I just picked mine up and used them for an ez double session and they didn’t wow me. Idk if eventually that cushion comes to live but I can see why they are a solid daily trainer. The best thing I would compare it to or similar would be a Pegasus with better grip. To me they felt a bit firm! But maybe they break in eventually? Still very solid daily trainer

[@danieltay1052]

@@peter7371are you talking about nimbus 25?

[@peter7371]

@@danieltay1052 no hahaha this was velocity nitro 2!

[@jansing327]

It's a matter of taste...there both very good!

[@user-uh1nm3dj4l]

As a beginner runner looking for comfortable and fun shoes, what do you recommend more Nimbus 25 / Sacconi Triumph 20 / Nike Invincible 3 / New Balance more v4?

[@lindameggers1999]

I am wanting to know which one of the shoes you mentioned is Great for walking in as a nurse

[@SonyBravia65]

​@tried crocs. Durability is pretty bad. Slightly wet floor, and you're smelling the water. I'd say Hoka recovery slides are much much better and I'm loving those atm.

[@SonyBravia65]

Nike and NB, haven't tried. Asics Gel Nimbus 25 is such if you put in your feet, you aren't going to let go of them. Triumph 20 is another comfortable shoe and is a bit on a firmer side than the Nimbus. Can't go wrong with either. Both are different shoes. Depends upon what you feel when you put them on. I personally love Nimbus 25. That walk on the clouds feel is terrific.

[@SonyBravia65]

@ Valid point.

[@yavuzbolluk3363]

I bought it asics nimbus 25 today I have Nike zoomx invincible 1.and 2

[@ammarkriss2]

Which is more comfortable out of 3 you mentioned ?

[@yavuzbolluk3363]

@@ammarkriss2 nike zoomx invincible 2.👍

[@Cam101077]

That’s what I’m seeing here, invincible is still the comfiest shoe, but the nimbus is good too and probably more stable

[@suryopras]

Why does the Nimbus 41.5mm stack look thinner than the 34mm More v4?

[@bev9708]

They explained that in the video actually … the midsole on the More is not as high as it looks as it actually wraps up the side of the foot a little, so your foot sits down inside it somewhat, so the underfoot thickness is less than it looks from the outside. NB has done that with a few models actually , as has Hoka too!

[@suryopras]

@@bev9708 oh like a bucket seat right. Thx to explain

[@DAjugRnaut]

Anyone have any preference between more v4 and hoka bondi? I’m 260 5’9 so pretty heavy for my height

[@gustavoquemasdarodriguez7332]

Yo tengo la bondi y no me convencieron quizás la placa de carbono las hace más duras a pesar del precio. Prefiero las enteriores las hocka one . La nimbus 25 o la hocka one van mejor para corredores cde 90 kilo

[@rotcod1771]

Nimbus 24 is an amazing shoe to wear day to day, not quite my shoe for runs. Both are better than the Glycerin 20, so excited for it and it was just... plain

[@OhWanya]

The Glycerin was not a good shoe and no space for the toes imo

[@kungfukenny9300]

The thing with Asics, Thier shoes never seem to go on sale. So get the shoe with the better price as both are quality.

[@formulaic78]

Here in Shanghai it's the opposite. ASICS always give about 15% off automatically whereas New Balance,ON, Hoka give nothing. Was looking at UK prices too and no sign of discounts at present.

[@user-so8kx7uj2x]

If you know how to wear the laces properly, than you know More V4 has perfect lacing system!!

[@i.p2088]

I think the question is Nimbus 25 or Superblast ❓Same price and both good for long slow runs... I am horrified by any shoe over 260gr for a long run.. I have the Nimbus 24 and its very stable and comfortable but BORING. Novablast 3 foot slaps and heel unstable.. So Superblast ❓❓❓

[@Fozzee.1970]

Nimbus and Superblast aren't the same price?

[@i.p2088]

@@Fozzee.1970 They are in the shop.

[@Thomasrice07]

The Superblast and Nimbus are companions but they do different things. The Nimbus is easy on your legs. The Superblast is not, but it is much faster. If I am getting just one shoe to run everyday, it would be the Nimbus. But if I want to run tempo and mix it up, then Superblast. But Superblast is not really a daily trainer. You need an easy day shoe. Superblast is not it.

[@robusttj]

@ 16:30 bad choice for 25 £ difference for because Gel Nimbus is clearly the winner. I switched to ASICS Gel Nimbus because of its superior value proposition.

[@shinguts4838]

Bonjour je coureur de 100 kg ayant eu la Nimbus 25 et la More v4 je préfère de loin la New Balance

[@shawngee1]

Thanks for the review, but your audios are all over the place.

[@blackcatsarenopussies]

Nothing beats the Invincible 2. Especially now at below 100 USD offers

[@jimmybutcheehinful]

I can't buy one in hong kong now😢

[@maulikdave2164]

Gel nimbus top notch.

[@hugoantunesmusic]

This More V4 running shoe lasted only 6 months until the upper tissue teared close to the front sole. Don't advise it

[@owenlewis9258]

V4 has failed to deliver for me. Tongue is very narrow. Midsole does nothing for me. Outsole showing wear on both sides after only 57 miles. Generally feels cheap. A disappointment!

[@lindameggers1999]

I am on my feet ALL day as a nurse. I have plantar fascistitis ...i know i spelled it wrong. Looking for a sneaker that has the max cushion for my feet. And have bad knees

[@Cam101077]

Nike Invincible zoom x is softest shoe. Haven’t tried gel nimbus yet tho, just bought ut

[@SonyBravia65]

Also, I'm waiting for a huge sale on Gel Nimbus 25 and I'd jump on it. Was considering NB More V4 but it has less stack height so probably won't be good for the knees as per some experts' reviews.

[@Cam101077]

Ok so I am wearing the nimbus right now. It’s not as unbelievably soft as the invincibles, but it is still one of the most comfortable shoes. Im happy with my purchase, but will probably also buy some new invincibles when I get the chance.

[@Revelation1316]

Nimbus 25 was not built for running. It was built for 95% of who buy expensive sneakers. Regular citizens.

[@nonyabusiness1126]

What's the point of all that foam without more give? Seems like unneeded bulk and weight when a standard shoe can offer equal cushioned feeling and protection. Nike got it right. Others are posers atm

[@i.p2088]

Exactly.

[@mratran]

The extra foam is desired during long and recovery runs, which these shoes are designed for. Running Shoes are becoming specialized now. Different foam and tech for various types of workouts.

[@Thomasrice07]

It gives much more than this video presents. It just doesn't squish all the way to the road like the More v 4 does. For a heavy runner, I thin the Nimbus is much better.

[@nonyabusiness1126]

@@Thomasrice07 I wore Keyano lite 2's the first time today. I only used an elliptical today, but I already like them better than the Invincible run 3 I just returned.

[@phatmhat9174]

the arch hump in the v4 is bigger than in the nimbus, and it hurt my foot. so i liked the nimbus, and i actually think the nimbus is more plush than the v4.

[@LionelBaronArtiste]

This new running Gel25 is a real failure! asics did not know how to respond to the impact of the ground! she is beautiful ! it has a carbon effect! it offers cushioning and that's it! unfortunately for it and unfortunately for those who are going to buy it (me personally, phew!!!!! I was able to resell it after 3 disastrous tests, and it's without regret, the GEL24 is 10 times better, finally?? for those who really want to run and not sink into the ground with instability) ... too much flexibility makes this running bathe only in comfort, but too much !!? it's too much. Not having a response to the impact of the ground, it's terrible for a running! it is already the end of its existence!

[@danielpaiguen]

More v4 is the clear winner for me. By far

[@user-uh1nm3dj4l]

As a beginner runner looking for comfortable and fun shoes, what do you recommend more Nimbus 25 / Sacconi Triumph 20 / Nike Invincible 3 / New Balance more v4?

[@nathanielrivas729]

I’m a big fan of the nimbus 25! I’ve used all expect for the triumph 20s. Best shoe if you’re also just getting started!

[@user-uh1nm3dj4l]

@@nathanielrivas729 Thanks bro, keep making many more videos on the fun to watch channel...

[@vVn19]

Hi! Try the shoe in the store if possible, even 5-10 meters run in the store can be very informative, never fully rely on reviews. Most of the reviewers are low weight athletes , they can run "our 10km" in any shoe. I personally didn't like Nimbus 25, comparing to 23/24 sent it back