What If Obi Wan and Ahsoka DIED in front of Anakin Skywalker

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Hey everyone! I REALLY enjoyed this story. Definitely felt like one of my best, so I hope you do as well!

[@MRGaines12YT]

Can we have a what if when anakin become Vader during the clone wars and become his own Sith Lord without palatine being his master

[@zelqxy3805]

I can even see him recruiting a few fallen Jedi or turning some of them to his side two of them being Ashoka and pong krell

[@eddog6666]

What if after being accused of the Jedi temple bombing Ashoka started a rival Jedi order one that uses all sides of the force. Light, dark and balanced.

[@Jmx316]

Hey I see someone suggested it, but can we please not do any stories about Palpatine or doku or someone having dementia or alzhiemers. As someone, who us losing his father to those diseases, they are terrible and not fodder for what ifs. I love your videos, they always remind me of what I love about Srar Wars, but a story making light of dementia and alzhiemers would be rough.

[@arcticfox3243]

You did a great job. Was pleasantly surprised with the ploy twist with anakin. Keep up the good work

[@tainoman7905]

Anakin losing his brother and sister is basically asking Anakin to go Super Saiyan like Broly.

[@socialaccount0000]

"Anakin look! Its such a tragedy, your family was killed by a stray lightsaber strike!"

[@Theknightofusa1]

Lol

[@Runner12981]

Lol

[@Runner12981]

Bruh if Goku went super saiyan mode and so did gohan 🤣

[@fox0yeah410]

And the most powerful human is banging a robot 😂😂😂😂😂

[@MegadeathAdams]

What If Palpatine's age caught up with him and he developed Dementia? 🤔

[@helljumper2565]

Sleepy Palpatine

[@Tyler_Persad]

Bro would use sith alchemy removing it

[@Robert_Douglass]

​@@helljumper2565Doesn't quite sound right. Sleepy Sheev, though ..

[@reidlindsey4838]

Emperor Biden

[@padmeSkywalker]

Sheev forgets he’s emperor of the galaxy

[@tonystank3091]

I thought Anakin was gonna turn Super Saiyan for a second there on Eadu.

[@phantomphan873]

Anakin and Maul teaming up really symbolizes balance. The light and dark, working together

[@EthanhopefullyjoinsFaZe123]

2 people palps manipulated team up together

[@Robert_Douglass]

No spoilers in the comments!

[@WolfTriggerMan]

Totally agree with that

[@Ancienthistoryshorts]

Eh it’s debatable but your right from a certain point of view

[@Trelitty11]

@@Ancienthistoryshortshow ? Ones light side the other is dark side

[@arcticfox3243]

Ok this was awesome. Did not see this twist but it works. Like how anakin has self realization and turns to the light.

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Glad you liked the twist!

[@Rebellion90s]

"Violence is my choice not a disease" - Grunt from Mass Effect 2 and 3. The quote describes Anakin perfectly in this story. Just like Grunt who got violent all of sudden then he got into the Rite of Passage which serve as arena for maturing Krogans to vent their rage out. In Anakin's case, he also got so violent although with a cause, but the rest is pretty much the same. Shoutout to the poor Thresher Maw named Dooku.

[@TK-ev]

The turn to the dark and the moment of self reflection after remembering the promise was both succinctly delivered and believable within the rules of the 'verse. Well done 👌

[@tjcloar1913]

obi-wan fnal wish: don't fall to the dark side Anakin: of course Obi-wan dies Anakin: what promise?

[@brothers_of_nod]

I found it surprisingly enjoyable what you did with Maul, after all Palpatine took from him, after dedicating himself to revenge, dying for vengeance for his pain, his brother's death, and what happened to the night sisters was a cause he was willing to go all in on, even if he could not deliver the final blow.

[@linda-0587]

Oh, he is ***LOOSING*** it and going absolutely ***MENTAL***

[@funbricks1]

What if when Palpatine's voice cracked when he said "Henceforth you shall be known as Darth Vader" Anakin couldn't take him seriously anymore and thought he was joking? (April fools day theory?)

[@jb-wc1hx]

You just made me picture Anakin on Mustifar telling Obi-wan “it was just a prank bro.”

[@DrSnak3]

@@jb-wc1hx what if Anakin Pranked Yoda and Obi-wan

[@josephfenech9401]

3:57 Anakin's choice to go attack Darth Tyrannus, and Darth Sidious rather than report to the Jedi Council would doom Anakin, Obi-Wan and Ahsoka to terrible fates in Erdu.

[@WilliamStamour-ey1by]

Man you are really underrated you deserve more recognition ❤

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

I appreciate that!!!♥️

[@BullVengeance]

Preach 🙏

[@wanderrbeatss]

another absolute BANGER my friend. i could feel anakin's wrath through my screen.

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Love to hear that! I really liked this one

[@jonathanbranum8976]

awwwwww, Satisfaction...TY-

[@markstark1007]

*IDEAS:* 1. What If Dagan Gera joined Cal Kestis and fought against the Empire as a Jedi? 2. What If Anakin & Padmé's children weren't Force sensitive? 3. What If Luke Skywalker traveled back in time to meet and save Padmé Amidala? 4. What If Anakin & Padmé adopted Ahsoka?(In your performance) 5. What If Satele Shan traveled into the future to the times of Galactic Empire? 6. What If Thrawn was a Jedi/Force sensitive? 7. What If Cal Kestis trained Ezra Bridger?

[@ChristianCoakley-mg3be]

What if you let the man come up with his own ideas?

[@ChristianCoakley-mg3be]

Jk

[@overhead0294]

I want alll of these done

[@markstark1007]

@@overhead0294 thanks, me too :)

[@jotheunissen9274]

Obi-Wan DID 'die' (pretend to die) in a Clone Wars episode Anakin was indeed very very mad

[@ussmc1]

This is one of the best you’ve done. Top 2. The Anakin/Dooku battle is such a satisfaction revenge. Woul love to that in real life.

[@chiefrice]

Man I love these videos! I thought it was beautifully written. Seeing this animated would be EPIC

[@brokenbridge6316]

Seeing the video title made me think the ending would be a dark one. But title's can be deceiving. And this one sure was. Great job with the video.

[@dr.veronica6155]

I would like to say that I really appreciate you correctly referring to Maul as a Dark Side user rather than a Sith Lord, because Maul hasn't been or even considered himself to be a Sith Lord since he was defeated by Obi-Wan on Naboo. I think the official story to the Senate shouldn't have labeled Maul as a Seperatist agent and instead should have said he was a Sith. That would give the modern Republic, which had never seen or heard of Sith, a reason to understand why Sith are not to be trusted. So if any others tried something later, the Republic would at least recognize a Sith when they see one.

[@ekralj4316]

I didn't still started whatching but in my head I feel Like Anakin woud destroy entire Rim in less than five seconds after this event

[@Scurvybubble242]

Anakin literally wouldve burned the planet to the ground, he would have not been stopped by anyone but padmé

[@alexandernorton693]

What if palpatine used his second saber while fighting windu after he lost his first?

[@gilsondiasfilho1858]

Up.

[@gobberz3228]

Thanks 2 What Ifs if you could: What if Yoda fought Grievous on Utapau? What if Anakin and Windu died on Ryloth?

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Thanks!! I’ll write these down

[@SevereWeatherCenter]

I’m still at the very beginning of the video, but I’m predicting that he’s going to completely lose it because not only did his mom die after he had visions, and failed to save her, but to lose Obi-Wan and Asoka, and what I am going to assume is going to be the same time will make Anakin go completely mental. He will probably go even more into the dark side then even when he fought Obi-Wan became Darth Vader.

[@Fortnite_Frost_Clips]

It’s good that you say it’s you favorite video yet because if you keep getting a new favorite you are growing as a writer

[@joshuachamberlain1485]

Was not expecting an Anakin and Maul team up

[@TheForcesWrath]

The dark side can be used for good too, the man should have balanced like Darth Revan instead of just sticking to Jedi dogma that denies the fullness of the force.

[@Decrynox]

The Anakin - Maul team up is awesome

[@Jarikraider]

Master and apprentice gone, carry on.

[@darkvortex2410]

Thank you for everything you do. These What If's are a highlight of my day. I got some interesting What if's that could be fun. • What If Luke and Leia were switch - Luke goes to Alderaan and Leia goes to Tatooine. • What If Luke stayed on Dagobah • What If Anakin Skywalker and Padme Amidala assassinated Palpatine. - Anakin could become suspicious of Palpatine and does some detective work and discovers he's a sith so he and Padme kill him in secret. • What If Rey was Kylo Ren's sister. • What If Anakin Skywalker was made Battlemaster during the clone wars. - Cyin Drelic(can't remember how to spell his name) could die and the council votes for Anakin to replace him. • What if Kylo Ren was Luke Skywalker's son instead of Han and Leia • What If Anakin Skywalker had a younger sister. - she could also be force sensitive and trained as a jedi. How would this effect Anakin's fall. • What If Count Dooku was made Grandmaster of the Jedi order - this would happen before his turn but could be interesting. • What if Anakin Skywalker was sent to Malacore during the clone wars. - Palpatine could send him their to turn him. Maybe he makes a cross-guard lightsaber. • What If Anakin Skywalker created the Knights of Ren. • What If Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi were Half Brothers. - Shmi could have been married and had Obi-Wan but they separated then Anakin was born as normal. Over the course of the story they discover the truth. Be cute to see Obi-Wan refer to Padme as his sister in law. • What If Palpatine and Sidious were two different people. - Palpatine could be a friendly politician who sees Anakin like a grandson. Sidious could be someone else trying to manipulate him. May the force be with you.

[@adapperdragon8822]

What if grievous learned that his memories were altered?

[@theseekerofancienttruth3873]

Better yet, what if this realization Occurred as he was about to Kidnap Palpatine, and so he Kills Him Instead of Capturing him as ordered?

[@adapperdragon8822]

@@theseekerofancienttruth3873 I like that!

[@demonitecallisto]

Galaxy just admit it you just love every single one of your what ifs. Ik i do i cant tell you how many times ive listen to what if order 66 was delete from the clones.

[@herrprofdralbert6844]

You make really good stories. I very enjoy them

[@karinaromero8612]

Amazing video, really entertaning. I have a what if idea What if Anakin faked the execution of order 66. I suppose he would pretend that he was going to prepare the troops but actually tell Cin Drallig to evacuate the temple. Anakin would modify the Holorecordings to make the look like the clones and Anakin were killing the jedi, Anakin would fake his death saying that Shak Ti killed him and scaped. Palpatine would go to mustafar and Anakin would follow him there. I suppose Sidious would know that all of it was fake and decide to make anakin phisically weak by making him evacuate over 8,000 persons in only a few hours and then make anakin follow him to mustafar... (I am not creative enough to figure out an end)

[@Strigon008]

Nah, keep going. You're doing good, but maybe add a little more explanation into WHY he faked Order 66.

[@irBribe]

Don't have time to listen right now but wanted to help boost with a comment! Keep up the good work!!

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Very much appreciated!!! Hope you eventually do enjoy

[@irBribe]

​@thestarwarsgalaxy got around to it today and it was a great listen I always love when anakin takes the time to find himself.

[@notapplicable1296]

I personally love your longer stories.

[@DarthTerminus-wy3gp]

Another great story, having Anakin dipping into the dark side and feels that power and yet, not truly falling to the darkness and then teaming up with maul to avenge Obi-Wan and ashoka and eliminating Palpatine and bringing peace to the galaxy and in typical jedi fashion, the council told the senate the truth from their point of view

[@EternaITruths]

Cool story, however I don't think Sidious would stand a chance against Maul and a focused Anakin together. I don't even think he'd be able to beat Anakin alone in a pure lightsaber duel.

[@Zeke313_Editz]

This is going to be a banger I can sense it through the force

[@Acuas]

To be fair, if that really happened, Anakin would be livid, and he wouldn't be able to control himself, he would either die, or kill Sidious, but he would most likely be absorbed by revenge, might regret if after, but not until he was done, and I can't blame him, Ashoka is just perfect, you can't just let that go by unpunished.

[@Tocaraca]

"The galaxy would rebuild under Chancellor Bail Organa" : never heard that line before 😂 This one was nice

[@ahmeterenekinci0741]

I have been studying english with your video , thanks a lot.

[@reeceemms1643]

Here are my ideas day 13 of asking: What if Cal and Merrin had a Daughter (Jedi Nightsister hybrid)? What if Padme was enslaved during the clone wars? What if during the rescue of Han Solo Leia failed to kill Jabba and was left behind remaining as a slave? What if Din Djarain and Bo-Katan fell in love during the events of Mando season 3? What if Luke and Leia found out they were siblings earlier (like before Empire strikes back?)? Similar to the previous one, what if Luke and Leia were not separated at brith and were both raised by Owen and Baru? What if Jyn Erso survived and went on to meet and fall in love with Luke Skywalker? What if Ahsoka found Shin Hatie before Baylon Skoll? What if the Aldani Heist went fully according to plan aka the whole payroll was stolen from under the Imperial noses?

[@StarWarsElement]

Anakin went Leroy Jenkins with the Sith Lords

[@ChillyCharizard006]

My therapist: Nightmare Fuel Photoshop Sidious and Dooku aren’t real, they cant hurt you. Nightmare Fuel Photoshop Sidious and Dooku: 2:00

[@vishalthescientist]

If Obi-Wan left the order for Satine… he stops Death Watch much earlier, but Maul strikes Mandalore sooner, Anakin is trained by someone else, Obi-Wan kills Maul again and finds out about Sidious, goes back to the order to warn the Jedi, etc etc

[@phantomphan873]

What if during his duel with Obi Wan, Anakin breaks m down in tears, throws his lightsaber to the floor, drops to knees, and confesses to his master everything, his nightmares, his crimes, etc. Please do this

[@marcusappelberg369]

That would be interesting!

[@jb-wc1hx]

Other people have made this situation if you search for it.

[@phantomphan873]

@@jb-wc1hx I know, but I want to see a more emotional charged scenario

[@codezero7981]

​@@phantomphan873I've read some fanfics with this scenario, it's really interesting

[@beyondcreativitybyisaac3172]

What if Bly and the 327th refused to execute order 66?

[@theseekerofancienttruth3873]

Better Yet, what if they Faked Aayla's Death? Nowhere does it say Stun Blasts are Always Shaped like you see in the Movies and TV Shows.

[@Xeronoia]

What if therapists existed in the star wars universe?

[@mariusconstantin6057]

They do. The Jedi just don't go to them

[@bloodstreak2001]

What if the Jedi were able to block Blaster fire just like in the old Star Wars Battlefront games

[@KingCodd]

what if sidious told the republic he was a sith when he was elected it isnt illegal to be a sith and i think it would be very interesting

[@theseekerofancienttruth3873]

Actually, I am pretty sure he got the Law Against being a Sith Changed when he was Chancellor.

[@SlipperyCastIron]

What if Anakin found a pink kyber crystal that, when channeled with the power of the chosen one, released such powerful rizz he can influence anyone?

[@salvatorediangelo453]

I just watched this fully, late to comment but this was a GREAT story. More Anakin/Maul team ups please! Another fun idea might be Dooku and a somehow motivated Anakin teaming up against Sidious as the Sith Master would pee his pants knowing he would have zero chance.

[@derekchuff1430]

Well done!

[@ArmaniGaming445]

Anakin didn't take it well when kenobi fake his defeat I could only imagine an sense Extreme darkness more than in Revenge of the Sith, but there's no plan like in the clone wars. I haven't seen this yet, but I could sense extreme darkness within skywalker.

[@Trailbreaker3966]

Well this was a great one. The emotions were very strong here. Only wish there was more R2-D2 tho. I imagine tho artoo was alongside anakin the whole time tho.

[@sonderstudios6675]

Any story where the Jedi has to lie, even for good intentions still leaves the door open for corruption, negating a "happy ending".

[@KajiConanVT]

I like tht u did a reference from the 2d sw clone wars cartoon with the fight with anakin and ventress, and change it to anakin vs dooku.

[@henri6265]

What if Maul killed Obi-Wan instead of Qui-Gon? What if Amidala was in Palpatines inner circle from her time as Queen?

[@scareditymays6yearsago477]

What if Captain Rex (specifically) was force sensitive?

[@cowsonahill]

This is how the sequels should have ended, the light and dark teaming up. A true symbol of peace.

[@itstaylor2137]

wasn't it?

[@cowsonahill]

@@itstaylor2137 kind of

[@justatankwithinternetacces8338]

When anakin first swore revenge I could only think of the kys now guy

[@lorewalkermaohao4602]

What if Palpatine was not actually a Sith Lord, just an actor paid by the real Sith Lord (you decide who)?

[@m1sterw1zard]

Iron Man did it

[@mikelightowler5220]

You son of a... how dare you write a better story altogether, lol. I edited to remove any potential spoilers. It hurt but honestly this was great.

[@zackcross7190]

What if Shmi was a Sith? What Vader was Luke’s father’s brother’s nephew’s cousin’s former roommate? What if Ben Solo chose Han’s career path?

[@theseekerofancienttruth3873]

Good Idea, Lord Helmet.

[@kvtatton]

Maul pulled off some Rengoku final sacrifice type move to win

[@titansmashproductions5001]

“Stains Of Time Intensifies.”

[@Matt_JJz]

What if Order 66 was still executed however the clones failed to kill all the jedi, causing a civil war across the galaxy as the Jedi fight for survival.

[@JazzyCurry]

Man this was emotional

[@LewsThernTelamon]

The Republic at their strongest. Vs. The Empire at their strongest. Vs. The UNSC at their strongest. (They have all Their tec, personal and knowledge from before and after the human covenant war.) Vs. The Covenant at their strongest. (They too have all their tec and personal.) Note, there can’t be any internal conflict until one faction reigns supreme, or the flood enters the conflict.

[@dianesinger9729]

I liked this one sad Obi-Wan and Ahsoka killed in front of Anakin. I liked Anakin finding himself and staying in the light

[@shawnmoun9849]

Darth vader is born

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Possibly

[@shawnmoun9849]

@@thestarwarsgalaxy can you please do what if dooku killed padme infront of anakin I already know the outcome

[@ArmaniGaming445]

@thestarwarsgalaxy Keep your eyes on the mention. I'll continue to put your channel and any other channels I've reacted in the description

[@brettweltz8135]

No not Vader a new and even more powerful Sith is born. Behold Darth Annihilus.

[@JerZy_BoiZ_Entertainment0128]

What if vader was successful in freezing luke

[@ORIGINALFBI]

What if Anakin called Chris Hansen on Palpatine?

[@Achuidian179]

This is a good storyline, but I myself didn’t enjoy it as Anakin had to see his master and Padawan die in front of his eyes. Day 53 of my list What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?

[@bestgeneralinthegalaxy]

if you can, I would like to see 2 more versions of this, like what if obi wan died/what if ahsoka died

[@ChrisTheGhostHunter]

Yoda could have been a wise Grandmaster and should have comforted Anakin after the deaths of Obi-Wan and Ahsoka. Maybe offered a hug. Sometimes a hug can be the difference, whether or not the "Hero" becomes the villain.

[@fightingfefnir1003]

They gave me gohan lying and trunks finding his body vibes

[@Robert_Douglass]

Have you thought about using another musical selection for one of your next selections? It might refresh people's interest in later entries in your Infinities playlist. Just a thought.

[@Cauin450]

What if Anakin had his own agenda. As a child of the Force, he craved all the knowledge of both the Jedi and the Sith but was not conformed or seduced by either. His goal was to become the Master Skywalker Ahsoka encounters in the World Between Worlds without dying. The Force's Avatar! Neither Light nor Dark, he stands alone at the Point of Balance.

[@DarthnightKing]

Great work I like it

[@LocksAndChains]

This is my favourite to date.

[@littlefoot5013]

As soon as you mentioned Eaudu, I wondered if it had anything to do with the Death Star, especially as the Separatists came up with the prototype for it.

[@Blue-Blazes]

Anakens mother should have went with with the moment he left for Jedi training. So that we he would been at peace hinself. Or plan a secret extraction mission at a later date not implicating the Jedi's involvement.

[@frenchtoastmafia1]

3:48 Cheeky 🤣

[@berendsmal9058]

You are the goat Star Wars galaxy🐐

[@bluntslt8023]

This was a good one am glad anakin and maul teamed up

[@vins8561]

Ahsoka dying literally breaks my heart. Anyone but ahsoka

[@shadows.82]

What if Vader found the Katana fleet? Please.

[@shadowbon11]

What if Cal Kestis was Anakin’s apprentice instead of Ahsoka

[@GothmogLives_G40]

Glad to see Anikin finally maturing

[@Tuvok1971]

What if Oib-Wan believed Dooku about SIdeous on Geonosis

[@jasonmcguire358]

What if Shmi was a exceled night sister, and a bokken Jedi!!!!!!!

[@skyj5606]

I really wonder what the background song name is. It's very good and I never find it.

[@JediMasterZim]

What if Anakin fell to the Dark Side when he wiped out the Tarkin Raiders in his rage? Would Palpatine find out before the Jedi do, and if so how would he handle Anakin falling far sooner than expected? How might the Clone Wars and beyond be impacted by such an early fall?

[@TheDogBasti]

What if windu and palps killed eachother at the same time

[@soularprimestudios5930]

The dream meeting with Anakin and Maul should have been done...