Why the West Wants to Bring Down the New Syrian State - with Sami Hamdi (Part 2)

[@TheThinkingMuslim]

Please remember to subscribe - 70% of our viewers have not. This helps our channel grow organically.

[@carljohn7502]

Remember all the western world are noticing and watching your channel closely and waiting for you to expose yourself as a terrorist so we are eagerly waiting for you to show your true self and

[@tempuser109]

NEXT TIME HAMDI COMES TEACH HIM ABOUT TAIMUR, WHAT A LYING CLOWN

[@wahajhassan7307]

I would request Big Brother Sami Hamdi to open a channel and explain the Quran, Hadiths, and Islam to us. We need to establish an understanding of the Muslim Umah. We have scholars' perspectives on Islamic history. What we need to understand is HOW, AS MUSLIM UMAAH, we should think and act alike. JazakAllah.

[@antichamcha6544]

These Al Qaeda apologists have no idea what they are even discussing. It's like if we put lipstick on a pig, can it become Miss Universe? Jolani and the ilk were terrorists and will always remain so until they are no longer needed and eliminated. The best days of Syria are behind it when the secular Assad did not allow Islamists backed by Zios to take charge. Now these people are sitting over a corpse and discussing its future. The Zios are already celebrating, and even if the country continues to be called Syria, it will one of many countries/autonomous regions that will be carved from it. The sectarian brain of Hamdi and the likes is just not wired to understand these things, so they will be treated as useful idiots by Washington.

[@BasicHumansim]

I request Sami to not speak on the Palestinian issue again. Palestinians are not numbers for him to exploit. Al Julani is already meeting with Pro Zionist Western leaders. Syrian nor Egypt will free Palestine. It is the brave Palestinians and Allah that will free it.

[@Pierre_Laval]

I’m a Christian. I love Sami Hamdi’s analysis of geopolitics and his incorporation of Islamic history into the discussion. Thinking Muslim is my favourite channel for learning about geopolitics and Islam. Love to all my Muslim brothers and sisters. ❤️ Edit: FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸

[@Killa_3]

Loool stop lying 😂

[@Ruder6163]

He knowledgeable, but his wishful thinking is based in delusional. In part one, he was insinuating that PaIestine is winning. The amount of copping one must do to come to that conclusion is jaw dropping.

[@lvi25]

I invite you to Islam

[@Gulchih]

Thanks for your genuine comment. What country/culture are you from? 😊🌻

[@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386]

Of course you are a Christian. I believe you.

[@mariomaro7]

Brother Jalal, if you see this, I just want you to know you are an absolute gem for this Ummah. May Allah grant you all the barakah for making these crucial podcasts and helping me see things from a perspective I would never have discovered otherwise. Jazak Allahu Khair akhi

[@azekeaze1882]

brother Bilal, As Salamu aleykum to you and brother Sami. Please, send my warmest wishes to your team and Sami. Watching you all the way from Azerbaijan 🇦🇿.

[@J_of_islamic_psychology_Dr_RK]

True. Me too ❤

[@sgkurfi8837]

Ameen

[@TheThinkingMuslim]

Jazakallh khairm thank you for your duas! We ask Allah that he accepts from all of us

[@blususpect]

I loved Sami’s quote about people ascribing traits of Allah to America, at the end of the day Allah is in control of all things. We just have to trust in Allah’s plan, whatever the situation is.

[@teriraketty]

I feel bad for him he’s never understood Jesus he’s just heard tid bits never the whole gospel of Jesus Christ Every knee shall bow and Every tongue confess Yeshea King of Kings Lord of Lords ❤️💕❤️💕❤️💕❤️

[@teriraketty]

America has always a subscribed to the beliefs of Jesus Christ and boy have we made mistakes but just by having freedom to choose America has been blessed and punished

[@blususpect]

@@teriraketty God (Allah) never had a son, Jesus worshipped God just like Mohammed, Moses, Abraham, & Adam worshiped God without any partners. I invite you to enter the true religion of God, Islam.

[@blususpect]

God (Allah) never had a son, he is one, the eternal, he neither begets nor is he begotten, & there is nothing like Allah. I invite you the religion of Adam, Moses, Ibrahim, Jesus, & the last messenger Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him)

[@netherasaid3342]

​@teriraketty Muslims love and Respect Esa as a Prophet of Allah SWT PBUH but Muslims bow to none other than Allah SWT

[@rodzitazainal19]

Enjoyed the Part 1 and Part 2. Very eye opening and thought provoking. Looking forward to Part 3

[@aktcdc]

And part 4. And part 5. And..

[@zoro-w8x1k]

I hope not, this sectarianist is spewing toxic to My hear​@@aktcdc

[@saflam]

I've never been more proud to be a Tunisian. Sami's explanations are easy to understand and most importantly, based on Islam. As a Tunisian, I hope he does a deep dive into Tunis politically that he does for Gaza and Syria. Thank you @thethinkingmuslim for giving Sami this platform and for giving us an alternative to western media.

[@hanatouati2137]

Is he tunisian?

[@endoferagoat2393]

He’s Algerian not Tunisian

[@hanatouati2137]

@@endoferagoat2393 ow ok i see i'm proud of him am algerian too

[@saflam]

@@endoferagoat2393 He's both actually. His father is Tunisian and his mother is Algerian. My Tunisian parents are familiar with his fathers political work

[@saflam]

@@hanatouati2137 Can we share him haha😆

[@godisgreat2135]

It is not up to America to decide how Syrian people should be governed, it is up to Syrian people to decide.

[@commercialandresidentialpl7337]

But didn't America assist you in the toppling?

[@jamal22958]

No they did not. If America did help then they wouldve lifted the sanctions when they got what they wanted.

[@saraim0710]

​@@Evemeister12Al assad was way better for Israel, why do you think they only distroyed the syrian army after he ran away? Plus this family is known for their betrayal of the syrian nation, the father Hafez handed the Golan heights to Israel WITHOUT even putting up a fight😅

[@TheIntuitive-b2k]

Such idealistic views and naivety is precisely why hundreds of thousands of Arabs and Muslims cheered for the toppling of Assad, when they should have been mourning the end of Syria.

[@Mohamed_nb]

​@@TheIntuitive-b2ki think yoi should stfu and stop telling us what to do , syria is finally free

[@tanjim6848]

I have a great deal of ADHD and not prepared to watch a YT video more than 30 minutes but here I am, watching this video in one sitting. May Allah bless Sami Hamdi.

[@KhalidofEngland]

Ameen

[@uthman-lz3nk]

امين يارب العالمين

[@ibrahimmustapha8535]

Sami Hamdi - had become one of the most famous and elegant orators who mostly earned my respect and dwelled in my heart. My love goes to him and his family

[@TheMohamed950]

Sami Hamdi's analysis is incredibly insightful. It would also be great to highlight the dynamics in East Africa, especially the relationships between Somalia, Ethiopia, and the influence of Gulf states in the region. These complexities often go unnoticed but are crucial to understanding the bigger picture. Somalia, in particular, seems underrepresented in Arab media, despite its deep historical and cultural ties. It deserves more attention, as its role in the region is significant. Sami's perspective on this would definitely resonate with many!

[@crhu319]

UAE is often blamed for what happens in Sudan / South Sudan, I can't speak to how true that is, but, it's a common perception among Africans. Just as Israel is commonly blamed for what's going on in Congo, which I tend to agree with and know more about: a Zionist real estate developer in Toronto has a lot of interests in Congo, for instance.

[@Sarimoistan]

Sami's opinion on Zanzibar's forced union with Tanzania, please

[@Sabrina-v5v3t]

May Allah Almaighty unite somalis first before anything, no one can help .

[@fiqhonomics]

What's up with Kenya? Black South Africans take a dim view of Kenyans, but I'm not sure why.

[@saharla9386]

Somalia will succeed when tribal states come to an end and reconciliation starts. Somali people are kind, smart, tough and follow Islam deeply. I don’t understand why they are so divided within government. The corruption is a huge problem due to MP bribery. Somali people are great entrepreneurs and I hope a new generation comes where they run the country. Somaliland is at huge risk of being taken advantage of by UAE (and by extension, Israel) due to their separatist aspirations. Until then, Ethiopia and UAE will try to divide and eat away into Somalia. I pray a new generation of Somalis can bring the country to a new beginning

[@akyow]

Dear Muslims, stick to the sunnah and Qur’ an. No matter what you do to placate them, they won’t accept you.

[@knawaz3694]

Is making shirkmas a public holiday from the Quran and Sunnah?

[@SnowsStorm1]

When you speak about ruling us? Yeah you won't

[@klayphantom5784]

I can never get tired of listening to Sami. Jazakum Allah Khair for this eye opening episode

[@roslrefaat6924]

I swear I feel the same, I wait for a new talk from him

[@mikestanford5186]

Not enough time was alloacted to discuss matters related to Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sudan for the 2024 roundup. Please allocate time for these important topics in some future episodes. May Allah ﷻ bless you both for this endeavor.

[@sammu]

This was recorded earlier, when the Afghan-Pakistan conflict wasn’t out of control. I believe Br. Sami has spoken out about Sudan before, he was one of the first actually to do so.

[@suadfazli3079]

Yes. Especially Sudan where media coverage is almost non-existent.

[@saharla9386]

@@suadfazli3079they’ve done episodes on Sudan before. It’s where I learned about what was going on

[@TheThinkingMuslim]

Noted - inshallah we shall address these issues soon

[@FunnyBird-ho9rq]

Jzk for all the good work you and your team do May Allah reward you in this life and much more in the next ​@TheThinkingMuslim

[@FarukSerdengecti]

No Muslim state - leader - in history has ever had an independent policy without becoming stronger militarily, economically and socially. Acting without adequate preparation at a time of political change in the world will cause us to lose many gains. It should not be forgotten that victory belongs to those who are patient.

[@larabraver]

Well said 💯

[@LionKing-vd3oi]

The irony is that US and Israel will never let any Muslim country become stronger militarily. They take it as a threat to Israel. Today, out of 50 plus Muslim countries, 99 percent of leaders are US puppets and slaves. Be it UAE, Saudi, Egypt, Jordon. Israel controls US foreign policies and they wanted all the strong Muslims leader gone and they have succeeded with the exception of Iran Ayatollah. No wonder you see no leader did anything for Gaza except condemnations. This guy Jolani is a US puppet no matter what people says about him. Israel completely destroyed Syria's weapons and defence system and this Jolani guy did not utter a single word. Syria is defenceless now and this is how the west wants.

[@ibtisamhtewek8899]

You are a liar they burn the trees and the damaged the Christian cemetery we will not trust a criminal who did ate the soldiers liver and heart just stop lying

[@abdulkarim716]

I absolutely agree however if there is one lesson you can take from the life of the prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم ) that is that he never compromised Islamic principles.

[@Lab2029-l1k]

True winners never pick fights they can't win. The Muslim world has been plagued by very poor leadership for centuries now. Except for Turkey most are truly still colonized in a sense that their security depends on other countries' weapons. Invention and innovation is very very behind in the Muslim world by the standard of most advanced countries.

[@1137moiz]

It's worth noting that in immediate post-Ottoman Syria, the colonial powers made a massive song and dance about minorities, hence the foundation of Lebanon originally as a Maronite stronghold and even the call of Bashar Assad's grandfather for the French colonialists to make an Alawite version of Lebanon. At that time, a lot of intellectuals and politicians in Syria tried to placate these fears by adopting various superficial liberal measures, and that was never enough to placate the foreign powers because their concern was never truly about minorities. Generally, with very few exceptions, Syria and the rest of the Levant had been a bastion of coexistence until the modern period.

[@crhu319]

"Call of Bashar Assad's grandfather for the French colonialists to make an Alawite version of Lebanon" could now happen if the Russians will guarantee it.

[@omara3938]

Well said and on point

[@nicolebraunelias5672]

Soo true ! We are still livindcand „ fighting ( verbally)“ for it in Beirut.❤

[@themotivational5439]

This brother geopolitical analysis are the best I’ve ever heard He always came at it on different levels and one has no choice but to agree to him

[@LemonLadyRecords]

I hope this was recorded before the new year. It's extremely naive, which I am surprised to hear on this channel, which I appreciate and I've subscribed to for some time. I understand it's hard for non-Western people to understand, esp US, politics. As it's hard, without considerable study, for me to understand even other Western politics. But I do study. It's always been amazing what a Hollywood vision of the US that non-Western people have, esp when I've traveled. I grew up knowing that Syria and often Turkey, weren't US allies, because they were USSR (Russia) allies, esp Syria. The US has big plans for the world, post Cold War, which are still playing out. Esp for the ME and Russia. Who's President doesn't matter, esp now, it's a complete corporatocracy, or plutocracy, or oligarchy. Take your pick, just don't pick democracy! And Trump took $100mil from his most influential donor to annex the West Bank and his son-in-law is already designing Gaza properties. Trump also has nominated 13 billionaires for his admin, all neocons (warmongers and America should rule the world). The Republicans, who have all power now, would deport, hang or murder in war, all the Muslims in the world, if they could (Democrats just murder, just not in the US so much: votes). Have you not seen Gaza, Iraq, etc, etc? Republicans have many extremist Christians. That's why they support Zionists. If you think this is going to turn out well for Syria or Islam in Syria, think again. Any Muslim who thinks al Sharaa is not a complete puppet of the US is blind. Yet he is speaking also like the Taliban, which seems his true nature (well, ISIS) and committing violence against opposite groups. Very smart of the US, they can play both against, esp with American people, and the road of war goes through Syria to Iran and Russia. WITH American troops, full war. It's very possible and look at Iraq, want to end up like that? The prohibition on large numbers of troops is from Vietnam, then Iraq. It's highly unpopular, and we're getting others to die for us, successfully. But with the coming rhetoric, and Trump's loyal congressional cult members, plus a few "terror" acts, attributed to "ISIS", like over New Years, it can happen. The party is divided about war with Iran, but united about its hate and misconceptions of Islam. They are all bought by Israel, too. Not much will change. Trump lied when campaigning. I had small hope he would stop the military aggression, but that seems to be out the window. I mean, like any president is going to close the 850 foreign military bases? It's bigger than him. Politicias lie a LOT, though. If the US, whose CIA has used AQ and ISIS, or rather helped create them, or the Western concept of ISIS, didn't have a big plan, Assad would still be in Damascus and the prisoners would still be in prison. Why would Amerisrael allow them to be freed? Hmmmm. Because we need a big resistance to justify war. Much bigger than "Hamas", er, the Palestinian Resistance. Anyway, you will see. As Amerisrael steals ALL the Syrian oil (Trump bragged about that, thus why troops were still in NE Syria), as Syria becomes a pure Amerisrael colony, after another dirty war. Fancy becoming the West Bank? On another issue, I understand the hypocrisy of the West re Islam, but as a woman, I want the freedom NOT to die of heat stroke in a polyester hijab (it's brutally hot where I live), but I also say a woman can wear what she wants on her head, or anywhere else. When men are forced to wear total modesty, no matter how much heat or work, then maybe I'll change my mind lol. You think women don't lust after men's flesh? They just don't tell you and they aren't weak men who can't (don't have to) control themselves, as portrayed. Maybe I don't fully understand, but the complete segregation of the sexes just looks like Muslim men are weak. Ditto Orthodox Jews. And some extreme Christian sects, although there's still msny mainstrea denominations which won't allow female pastors or priests. I'm just glad to be free of religion. He yelled about the equality of minorities under Islam, but seems like only if they are male. I know from experience that Muslim men treat me with great respect, due to my age and gender, and I feel safe, but would they allow me the rights I enjoy now,, if they had control? No matter how bad the US situation is, I cannot imagine living where I have no real agency for my life. Other than that, I don't care who is the religious majority. However, I don't want to live under any religious laws or taboos, I grew up with that in the 50s and 60s, and the Christian Taliban here are always threatening to return to that and worse. You better hope the US remains secular, because that would be so bad for Muslims.

[@mohamedali2858]

Europeans exhibit a sense of superiority when discussing the form of governance, educational systems, and legal frameworks that should be established in our countries once liberated from occupation or freed from tyranny, despite the fact that no one interferes in the structure of their own education systems and laws. While Europeans beg for American protection against the Russians, they treat our nations as if we are still in the era of Lord Cromer and his ilk.

[@mohamedali2858]

French Foreign Minister: We affirm that we will stand by the representatives of civil society and Christians in Syria! The spokesperson for the German Foreign Office: “Russia has supported Bashar al-Assad for many years and has committed terrible crimes there.”And it has done nothing to prevent that. French Foreign Minister: We offer the new Syrian administration technical and legal assistance to draft a constitution for the country.

[@bubastis6306]

That’s because Muslims are incapable of governing themselves and why there are no prosperous Muslim countries unless they have a lot of oil

[@ChuckAmadi]

Please provide your source for us Europeans begging for USA protection. We've NATO and G7. Plus, the freedoms to be opinionated loudly and criticise our governments if we wish. Can you ?

[@jonoc3729]

If your form of governance violates human rights of course we will call you out.

[@mohamedali2858]

@ In 2024, the German police committed brutal assaults against supporters of Palestine who demonstrated to demand an end to the genocide in the Gaza Strip, what can be done about this situation ⁉️

[@princeamori]

This two part series was very informative, thank you to the interviewer and the guest.

[@Sheen023]

I had respect for your channel!

[@ibrahimissaiaawad2888]

Thanks Sami Hamdulillah!

[@saharla9386]

My favourite part of this episode is when Sami said people are attributing Allah’s power with America. This is so true and unfortunate. We should be praising Allah - not claiming “this is America/CIA who did this”. Syria revealed so much people having this mindset

[@elms7883]

Well, maybe America at least is real, while Allah is just one of those hundreds of sky daddies? Never existed, does not exist, never will exist.

[@Metalner]

bruh chillout cuz the CIA LITERALLY DID THIS.

[@saharla9386]

@ 😂😂 is the CIA God? They control everything in the universe?? That’s how important America is in your eyes? That you think Muslims are incompetent? The episode addressed your point but you’re still commenting. Have shame

[@callmechowdree689]

Excellent again. Get Sami on every week!

[@shelleydavis5231]

Absolutely informative and rhought provoking, love Sami, he is a beacon of truth amidst the chaos of news being reported. Well done on this and the 1st interview 🙌

[@msa3533]

Erdogan stood on the right side of history for 13 years, people will remember this. May Allah reward him for the support he gave to the Syrian Revolution.

[@digitalcamaraderie5685]

😂

[@digitalcamaraderie5685]

While trading with Israel and letting Azerbaijan oil going through turkey 😂

[@aramokurdo]

Yea you stand with ethnic cleansing innocent Muslim Kurds shame on you and your Erdog

[@majidakhtarraffi1719]

Simply amazing! Another Friday khutbah for the ummah! Thank you Thinking Muslim for keeping us informed!

[@giovatrix5184]

Masha Allah whenever Sami is on the podcast I just can’t stop Listening. Your podcast has made me literally“think” 😊about a lot. Especially when Sami is on. I love your podcast, thank you so much for your effort ❤❤❤ please keep it up masha allah and barakallahu feek.

[@loo6837]

Thinking Muslim is my favorite channel for learning about geopolitics and Islam

[@taidaff6227]

Brother sami as a Muslim and a sudanese I thank you greatly from the bottom of my heart for not alienating Sudan from the ummah when discussing the general struggle of the ummah. Many Muslim figures tend not look at us when discussing these matters , and that greatly helps the west dividing the already divided and weakening the already weakend . Thanks you for your efforts and the thinking Muslim for providing such platform in a very needed time , my Allah keep you all safe and protect our brothers and sisters in gaza 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤❤❤

[@joemccormick9109]

Some good points here. I don’t see why we could not have Eid as a holiday in Ireland. I hope this new government are left alone to give it their best go. It is truly a golden opportunity for Syrian people to experience some peace and harmony.

[@Foster-rv6ty]

You need to relocate to Pakistan where you can have all the Eid holidays. Must you live in Ireland, a non-Muslim country?

[@Hassan-zw9tb]

@@Foster-rv6ty but syria should have christmas, a muslim country?

[@ymi6945]

Hypocrisy, never will the disbelievers be our allies. We should be Muslims wholeheartedly without excuse. No if, but or maybe. We don’t want Christmas or accept it. Tell them: You have your holiday, but don’t tell me to accept any of it or to make it a national holiday. - For I don’t see it as holiday, but rather disrespect. - Celebrate privately with your disbelief. Don’t worry about the blame of the blamers, for the truth is with Islam and falsehood is with them. I agree with the statement to an extent. Muslims should work hard to go back to the Muslim countries. Their fault we are here (in the west), but our fault we stay.

[@jhonshephard921]

Muslim here. There is a good reason to not have Eid. It will just be a great opportunity for the racist far-right to attack any government who allows it. Also Muslims are still free to take the day off at work and school. I do it in the US, my boss even wishes me Eid Muburak. The rest of my co-workers who do not even know what Eid is do not need to take the day off. While I disagree a lot with these guys's points on Sharia, I agree that if a minority population is small enough(less than 5%), they can take a discretionary holiday instead of having a public holiday. And this would be for their own protection against the far-right of any religion or opportunists in right-wing media going after them.

[@Foster-rv6ty]

@@Hassan-zw9tb Syria was once a Christian country like Turkiye or Egypt. You don't know that? Do you want me to recount all the lands stolen by islam? Have you heard of OCCUPIED Constantinople and OCCUPIED Hagia Sophia Cathedral? Do you know the mosque your alqaida algolani spoke from in Damascus was a church before it was stolen?

[@lasaraungbakri7386]

Watching from Indonesia, it’s an eye opening assessment by the brilliant brother Hamdi!

[@BRICKERFORGE]

They wish to extinguish Allah’s light with their mouths, but Allah will ˹certainly˺ perfect His light, even to the dismay of the disbelievers. -Quran: 61:8

[@Foster-rv6ty]

Is Allah's light Isis or terrorism?

[@elms7883]

Allah, one of those hundreds of sky daddies, never was, never is, never will be😂😂😂

[@hazbu]

​ I wonder how you would be after death, resurrected and meet Allah?

[@Foster-rv6ty]

@@hazbu Meeting the 72 virgins I suppose.

[@justlooking4202]

​@Foster-rv6ty no that's Israelis light

[@billikash2591]

WE LOVE SAMI’S THOUGHT PROVOKING TALKS. THANKS BROTHER SAMI AND JALAL❤

[@MrPresidentoftheus]

I like Sami Hamdis coining of "People assign to America omnipotence that only belongs to God".

[@Manhalovic]

The most enlightening podcast I've ever heard.

[@faizaanazmi9086]

Dear Jalal Thank you for presenting some of the common opinions from other popular analysts for Sami to respond to. It would be great to see a live discussion between Sami and other analysts with different opinions

[@afghanman2155]

This is one the best videos I've seen regarding Syria..thank you sami

[@nadadiab7865]

Master class.

[@sabhaeljr.665]

Brothers Jalal and Sami, a deeper dive about the current situation in Sudan would be much appreciated, especially the UAE’s role in it. JazakAllahKhairan.

[@floragonseth2886]

Very usefull conversation, Sami Hamdi is a gift for our umma and brother Jalal is providing an wonderfull work by bringing this voice to the public. I wish S.H would look more deeper (or perhaps an other guest could do it) into the economical relationship between all these actors, how normalization with west capitalism is also a threat to muslim agency and what could be our liberation with our islamic principles on this specific matters. Obviously ecomical interests and institutiom play a key role, for example in Tunisia when Ghannoushi accept to maintain the FMI power on Tunisia, it also make his work of liberation from the old Ben Alinsystem more complicate. May Allah reward you!

[@AshAli-mi1cz]

Alhamdulillah,it's on finally,I was soooo looking forward to dis second part, Jazakallahu khair Sami and brother Jalal ❤

[@Ghada-ALVOICE]

Thank you for yet another fantastic analysis of Hamdi. I love listening to him because he brings facts to the table and reveals the true faces of every hypocrite and the genuine alike. Jazak Allah Khayr and may the ummah be united ya Allah and rid us of all the traitors.

[@alhajitimbo7544]

What a wise man. To whom sense is given wisdon is expected. I have learned a lots bro. I can't go back without subscribing. May Allah bless the oma

[@HeyRizvi]

Someone standing up for the Syrian people. At last! Thank you!🙂

[@Nache1]

We are blessed to have Sami in our generation

[@hasnaatiqbal3809]

Please do a roundup of the situation of the entire Ummah next time... Or do a part 3. Of course Gaza is the most important right now and Syria was probably the other biggest story of the Ummah this year but we need to keep eyes everywhere i.e Sudan, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan etc. Would love ot hear Samis thoughts on all of these countries.

[@saharla9386]

He’s done videos on Sudan before

[@hasnaatiqbal3809]

I know but the situation is constantly changing so it's good to have an update on how things currently stand, especially as is a year end roundup

[@RajuAhmed-sy7ys]

And the Uighur’s

[@saharla9386]

@@hasnaatiqbal3809 oh okay. I heard Sudan government forces have re-captured some cities which is great but I would love Sami’s perspective on what it will take for UAE will stop. No one is taking the boycott seriously so I don’t know what 2025 will look like but I’m really praying for Sudan InshaAllah

[@infinitebeast5517]

Much needed to get a better understanding about the current situation, thank you. Keep it going!

[@aFarmersLife]

I've learnt so much in this 1 podcast I can't even begin to explain. Thank you Sami Hamdi...

[@questionable1817]

KEEP UP WITH THE AMAZING WORK. LOVE YOUR PODCASTS!!❤

[@saburabdul-salaam2418]

May Allah bless, guide and protect the Muslims of Syria and the entire Muslim Ummah and all oppressed people.

[@MohamedAbdallahSaid]

Sami Hamdi is our best geopolitics analyst in our muslim countries, especially arab ones. He practically understands the conspiracy of the enemies of Islam and muslims.

[@saharla9386]

He gets so much hate and criticism because of his stance. Every truth teller looks crazy until the truth becomes common sense. It is dangerous to tell the truth in todays society

[@rkol13]

​@@saharla9386 he is banned from saudi arabia he can't do umrah truth is bitter

[@abderrahimelarabi4522]

I do believe at the end that Syrian people have enough knowledge and awareness about international politics that they will overcome all the challenges, and they will eventually make a good example of justice to all different ethnicities , Allah helps them through a good countries that wants the true freedom that Syrian will decide ,it's their right .

[@shafat6695]

"The truth has come and falsehood has vanished" v81 ch17. The Thinking Muslim and Sami Hamdi are doing their part for the Ummah, the least we can do is spread the TRUTH! If each subscriber can at least SHARE with @ least 1 other we became an Ummah that takes action. “Our Lord, pour patience upon us, make firm our steps, and help us against the disbelieving people.

[@scrappylor]

I love listening to Sami Hamdi ,you make good sense !

[@GERMANFORCE]

Always a pleasure to listen to you both💚⚪🖤

[@Swan-atl]

Wow! Sami Hamdi, eye opening conversation.InSha’Allahh! Allahh’s plan will prevail.

[@adampatel3132]

The sharia does not allow christians to drink alcahol. Rather we do not judge people for what they do hidden within their homes unknown to the public. The sahaba never allowed people to sell alcahold and drink publically even if they were kuffar.

[@knawaz3694]

He's making stuff up because he supports Jolani.

[@ABC-wi6vt]

Correct

[@brumbotrukto223]

Dhimmis in an islamic system are given the right to consume alcohol in private. This is how it was during Ottoman rule. I'm pretty sure there is also a narration of Umar RA allowing this.

[@ABC-wi6vt]

@@brumbotrukto223 evidence: trust me bro😂😂😂😂

[@Antizionist17]

Another amazing episode

[@AAA-o2v8h]

While Israel is bombing Syria, the Jolani division is preparing for war with Lebanon's Hezbollah, this is the only reason for the change of government in Syria.

[@isalutefamille]

I thought the kind of scenarios described by Sammy are just plot twists in Ertugrul series! The enemies are still using us to break us. May we always find the will to hold on to the rope of Allah.

[@حسينلعرباوي]

و يمكرون و يمكر الله و الله خير الماكرين

[@WorldPeace-AdamNeira]

Overall, this is a worthy and interesting discussion about Syria. I have just watched/listened to it in full. All 6457 seconds of it. Well done to Muhammad Jalal for hosting Sami Hamdi. They are both intelligent blokes. 👍 Take Note; Philosophy has to be the master of Politics. Not the other way around. ⚠ Thus, if the philosophical parameters of Syria are sound, the foundation of the nascent state will be strong and the future of the country will be secured. All other aspects of a Nation State, such as its Defence-Military Strategy, Foreign Policy, Economic Policy etc. are dependent upon and must fall under and be subservient to the overall Philosophical umbrella/raison d'être. All the various details/ingredients of a proper nation state can be worked out if the initial foundation is correct. The New Syrian Constitution should be based on the idea that the sovereign nation state of Syria will be based on: Moderate, Traditional, Pluralistic Monotheism. التوحيد المعتدل، التقليدي، التعددي. These four key pillars will act as the Frame of Reference/Blueprint/Template for the state that will optimally facilitate the General Welfare of the Syrian people over time. FYI, I have been auditing and analysing Syria in great depth since 21/8/2013, which was a truly pivotal day in human history. I don't think there is anyone alive who knows more about the origins and trajectory of the conflict and what the solutions are. I have put in at least 5,000 laser focused hours of work over a decade about Syria. e.g. From late 2013 to 2019 I composed in excess of 12000 tweets about Syria plus a multitude of comments and counsel to various media, agencies and leaders. (Data Mining all my past public counsel on Syria to condense my wisdom about the country is a worthy endeavour.) A very small but important part chronology of my past counsel about Syria: 28/5/2015 Replying to Petra Stienen and Bente Scheller: " He, Bashar al Assad, can be Alawite Rep. for Tartus/Latakia. If not, Putin can give him and Asma a dacha in Vladivostok. Keys ready." 29/6/2017 "Syria must not be balkanised. Existing borders to remain. 14 governates. Damascus as the capital. Moderate - Monotheist - Pluralist" 9/7/2017 SYRIA The Vision - By 2030 it becomes possible to drive in peace and security from Jerusalem to Tehran, via The Golan Heights > Damascus, Jobar, Madaya, Beirut, Tripoli, Ain Dara, Aleppo, Raqqa, Palmyra, Deir Ez Zour, Mosul and Baghdad ! Over say 8 weeks. (A/C car in summer of course. 😎) What a road trip that would be! A Grand Middle East Tour ! Visualise - Verbalise - Actualise. 16/11/2018 I counselled to the US State Dept, POTUS, Erdogan, The Elysee and Netanyahu: "If Ahmad Shah Massoud had been given the right support, and not been killed of course, Afghanistan would be completely different since 2001. The closest and most hopeful approximation to Massoud in Syria now is Jolani." 23/1/2019 Replying to Charles Lister on Twitter: As I have explained, a professional, paid 42 person "Int'ernational Transitional Oversight Committee for Syria" is required. (To work with the 50 Syrian guests at the IPC + the MDMEMP + the 24/7 Ceasefire Monitors) Charles L. gets one of the seats on ITOCS2024. 👍 12/5/2023 Replying to Wassim Nasr at France 24: "Well done Wassim and your editors at France 24 who organised this trip with help from official channels. Blessings to the good people of Idlib Governate. There is a certain set of moves of the Rubik's Cube that can and must be made now to redeem Syria. I have been following the Syrian Civil War very closely since 21/8/2013, which was a key date in human history. i.e. The Sarin Attack on East Ghouta. P.S. Jolani is a viable leader of Syria in the coming years... These recent comments by two other Syria watchers are relevant. 6/12/2024 @ Armin Rosen There is a case to be made, and I've made it here before, that the Syrian civil war is the most important event of the 21st century. Possible deadliest war, generated a host of other conflicts, produced ISIS and massive European refugee crisis... @ Nick Gorges I make this argument all the time in my personal life to explain why people need to care about Syria. Have a good day. Prayers for the peace, prosperity and security of Syria. ٱلسَّلَامُ عَلَيْكُمْ 😎 Adam Neira Founder of World Peace 2050 Founded in April 2000 Paris - Jerusalem - Melbourne

[@NazmulHasan-dj5yb]

Jazakallh Khair to Br Jalal for this fantastic eye opening post. Br Sami as always has been brilliant. This is so fundamental in our Deen that we fear on Allah and serve our own flock no matter what, Subhanallah. Muslim apologists must be feeling really shallow and exposed after this.

[@AA-ki5in]

I am sick of Western imperialist nations interfering in the Middle East.

[@Imanialia]

It's their job to destroy islam

[@hamyddiallo6864]

Good one brother, MASHA Allah, may the Almighty Allah reward your contribution...Ameen

[@andrewgoldman9019]

Great interview as always.

[@sofianzubi7211]

The Syrians have seen great examples of what NOT to do (especially what is happening to us in Libya). We hope in Allah and in people like Ahmed Al-Shara learning from others and winning in sha Allah.

[@vuvuvu6291]

I think there's a massive need to improve Islamic literacy and understanding among Muslims first before implementing Islam as political institution.

[@Yashakur-AGA]

SubhanAllah.. I’m short for words.. Jazāk Allāhu Khayran my dear brothers Jalal and Hamdi! May Allah bless and reward you both, the entire The Thinking Muslim team and your families IMMENSELY, in this and the next life inshaAllahu Ta’Ala. May Allah keep on granting you MORE Baraka in your efforts, time and eloquence, Allahumma Allāhumma Āmīn. As-Salāmu ʿAleykum wa RaḥmatulAllāhi wa Barakātuhu from my family and I here in Norway. 🙂❤️

[@MohammedAmanullahkhan-n9r]

Please can we get sami to shed light on a conflict brewing in the Indian subcontinent ie Afghanistan Pakistan India and Bangladesh

[@lakhnavi1511990]

Masha'Allah another great episode. Almost done watching the full episode. This whole Syria episode(mostly the aftermath) is drawing some parallel to what happened with Sayyidina Ali R.A.D during his Khilafa, and the first major split between the companions. I think this needs to be explored a bit more. May Allah make this change in Syria as a catalyst for the victory of Resistance in Palestine and Sudan and other places as well. Aameen JazakAllah Khair for having him again

[@SunnyHuts]

Like the western media, sami has hastened into white washing of jolani to ahmad al shara. The whole talk is based on the presumption that jolani is a genuine leader trying to strategise and balance affairs for the betterment of syria. The other option that jolani could be a cia asset is completely ignored. Strangely, jolani's extreme groveling to the western media and ignoring of israeli bombings and incursions in syria does not seem bother sami. Both options, good and bad, demand serious discussions and sami seems to be concentrating on one and ignoring the other. I advice caution as it is too early to make such judgements. Few months down the line sami may end up regretting this interview. It is good to be hopeful but at the same time, the narrative of caution cannot be ignored.

[@wadeday8706]

Syria is coming out of a 13 year civil war. 1+ million dead, 6 million refugees, 10 million displaced and most cities destroyed. Economy is also completely in ruins. Turkey will not back him in a war with Israel. What power does he have to fight Israel? The west right now is trying to buy time and strategize for its next coup or move. Syria is also still full of regime remnants and separatists movements that pose a threat to Damascus. Israel has unlimited US and western support. If Syrians attack Israelis it will give them justification to keep Syrian territory forever. Syria is in desperate need of allies and Jolani is not looking to the west he is looking towards Saudis, Qatar and Turkey.

[@Kuleto]

The U.S. doesn't even allow Imran Khan, in fact, they coup him and then the current regime carries out a genocide against its own people and yet theres nothing; no news, no condemnation, no nothing, while Imran Khan rots in a Pakistani jail on false charges. I don't need to listen to this stuff. I don't understand it. The supporting of Trump. Etc. Even after the talk with Imam Tom Faccine about the U.S. empire. Is like they totally forget everything, and havent learned a thing. Yeah Allah, I don't understand it and this channel.

[@JerusnamWien85]

And we have yet to see genuine hostility or opposition to the new leadership in Syria from the West. Sami makes it appear as if this is actually happening. I haven’t seen much condemnation from Western leaders of Ahmad Al-Share’ (Jolani)-they recently sent envoys to forge diplomatic connections with his government.

[@nfd-e2u]

Why would the jews bomb Syria if he is Cia agent 😂😂that doesn't make sense buddy they clearly aren't happy about the situation 😂😂😂

[@digitalcamaraderie5685]

He wont regret. His line is as long as salafi rules . He dont care. He criticize yeman because they are zaidi. He is munafiq hypocrite

[@CineRanter]

Excellent podcast

[@sidikikamara8381]

Thank you for your thoughts and analysis

[@renbash2137]

there's no need to overly polish Ahmad el Sharaa's regime. The burning of the Christmas tree was not fake, we Syrians literally saw live videos on Tiktok of interviews with Ahmad's men and local Christians IN FRONT OF the burned tree. the actual perpetrators were foreign fighters, who probably cant fathom the religious diversity in Syria or come to terms with the public display of other religions in their "newly liberaterd islamic lands" And we've ALWAYS had a day off at least for Christmas. EU countries are just islamophobic and dont want to give us our rights. Ahmad el Sharaa is hopefully working for the sake of all Syrians, and he's supposted to only be a de-factor ruler for 3 months now. Anything further without public support is a dictatorship in formation.

[@JerusnamWien85]

All Salafi/Muslim Brotherhood types like Sami are rejoicing over al-Share’s victory in Syria, not because Assad was toppled, but because they feel their agenda and tactics over the years have been vindicated. This is not saying that their agendas are wrong in essence-they believe that real harmony in society can be achieved through the correct implementation of the Sharee’a, with minority rights secured through that arrangement. But I highly doubt the new Syrian state will be secular like its predecessors.

[@ABC-wi6vt]

Christmas has only been a holiday in the artificial entity”Syria” imposed on us after our defeat in World War One by the coalition of atheism . Don’t misrepresent the truth . Those Muslims you call “foreigners” have more rights to decide in the eyes of Allah than secular nationalists like yourself.

[@user-xo2xx2bo7k]

Please ask Sami Hamdi in the context of Syria, that the US tried to topple the taliban, they didn’t give a damn and fought back and then eventually the US had to leave them alone

[@alanstech3724]

And today women aren't allowed to be nurses and are not allowed to speak in public. What a victory.

[@J_of_islamic_psychology_Dr_RK]

Sami hamdi is awesome and amazing ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@jimmyjajim2101]

Always good to listen to both of you.

[@SarahGrant-wk7ny]

EXCELLENT discussion. I learned so much. Thank you.

[@abdullahtariq3897]

I came searching for this video and it was just uploaded seconds ago 😂

[@Lost_Johnny]

Jolani's weakness over Israel's attacks on Syria is not very impressive.

[@aisharoberts2583]

Thank you. A very interesting & worthwhile listen. My Salams from England..

[@Malcolmxjunior]

This prodcast is crucial Ma sha Allah a very good analysis from historical perspective and reality

[@nickhobbs6514]

The US would support a State of any faith or legal system if it was in its economic interest, shariah or otherwise. Culture, morality and ideology does not matter one jot to it. Just look at the long list of its allies and enemies throughout history.

[@kingmosesix432]

Thts not true And islamic empire is antithesis to US empire by necessity

[@jhonshephard921]

100%. The same US supported so called Mujhadeen in Afghanistan when they were fighting the Soviets and they supported dictator Zia. The priority of the US government as a whole is imperialism and anti-communism. There are extremist religious elements in the government. Same is talking positively about the orange one but his ambassador for the Middle East is Mike Huckabee. That guy actually believes in "Greater Israel" for religious reasons. Medhi Hasan and Basim Yousuf did a great talk about these extremest Christian elements in the US government.

[@ABC-wi6vt]

Incorrect. They hate Islam and fought World War One against Islam and have been slaughtering Muslims in the proceeding 100 years

[@safiamumin6716]

Ya Sami habibi Syria did not fall Assad fell and Syria was liberated from a tyrant fir’awn of the ummah @muhammadJalaal may Allah bless you and give you strength to bring the situation of the ummah to light and educate people on the horrific atrocities committed against our brothers and sisters ❤

[@AneesaReyes-jv6dq]

As salaam Alaikum Brother Sami ❤.. You're so right ✅️...and blunt about Jeremy Bowen.. Jazak Allah Khair for sharing with us..

[@mehjabeeny4220]

First time i understand what was actually happened in Syria and how it was running before and much more....JazakAllah Sami

[@tehreemamitha8524]

Wasn’t Salahuddin famous for going out of his way to respect and honor minorities and he was always upheld as a model of Islamic leadership.

[@ABC-wi6vt]

No

[@omerali580]

Omar Ibn Al Khattab (RA) when he conquered Jerusalem he was being given a tour of Jerusalem and the time for Salah came, the Christian Bishop giving him a tour offered him to pray in the Church but Omar Ibn Al Khattab (RA) declined on the basis that he knew the later generations would destroy the church and build a Masjid so he prayed outside the Church. Today in that same spot right where Omar Ibn Al Khattab (RA) prayed outside the Church, there is the Masjid of Omar.

[@MuniraTufail-ob8dz]

Every word is a jewel that cannot be missed

[@RAMZANIsmail-oo6zk]

You are very right in your speech.

[@hikmayaeaql4947]

Сирия в таком положении ,а запад вместо помощи спрашивает :можно пить алкоголь...как назвать этих людей...кто они ??где их человечность вообще...

[@ismailHossain-ln9ln]

Great analysis from brother Sami

[@aminmohamed1880]

@14:50 Jalal is asking Sami, "Why care about what the West is Thinking" A ridiculous question. surely you both know why they care. its simple; Because they are the ones behind that new Government coming into power. they all Celebrated when the Syrian Government collapsed not because they care about human rights or anything. they didnt like that Government because Assad with all his weaknesses refused to bow down to them. and since they had reasons of supporting the so called revolution theyll naturally care. you must have known that when they were arming and financing you. a good muslim practice is we are taught to remember those who help us. you should both stop looking confused

[@mohammadalkhani6714]

You clearly haven’t watched the full video if you can speak so arrogantly

[@KhalidofEngland]

Jalal has to play devils advocate and ask questions that others might ask this is part of getting the best answers from people

[@mohammadalkhani6714]

@@KhalidofEngland yea Jalal is asking good questions and clearly this guy cant understand that nd cant understand Samis answer. Hes just parroting the same assadist nd Iranian propaganda tht tankie leftists are eating up.

[@KhalidofEngland]

@mohammadalkhani6714 salaam brother.ive heard this tankie term being used but I'm unsure of the meaning could you please explain it a a little bit for me?

[@KhalidofEngland]

I think it means they are just anti West for the sake of being anti West but I'm not sure

[@mar6553]

I pray that what this gentleman is saying that the new government stick to what he quite intellectually stated will happen for the ALL the people of this country where the people suffered horrible consequences of the past government. He must keep his focus on building the country with peace and security for all its people. Don’t let the west or who ever interfere with what this new leader must focus on in building back a strong government and don’t make past mistakes go for a peaceful ruling and soon other country will settle down and start to work with your leaders. Make all efforts to deal with the diversity of the people for they have suffered enough. Don’t pick conflicts that will only divide your country and your people where it will not be successful and failed. Be very diplomatic but with good leadership, great negotiation skills that comes to a win win solution for your people and your country. Don’t be quick to react but have conversation with people who are level headed and avoid being drag into a war or civil uprising. I wish you all the best and will many of Gods blessings. This man speaking could be helpful in your future achievements. Peace to the new leaders and the peace of your people and focus on healing your country for the people have suffered enough and it’s time to now move on and focus on your governing. You must succeed but with the grace and freedom of your people. Don’t let the countries around pull you off you focus and be careful the words you choose. Choose words that there is absolutely no misunderstanding, if there are go immediately and correct the misunderstanding so no one can turn or twist your words against you. Peace by with your government and the people. God bless

[@mar6553]

I hope that the new government learn from other countries mistakes in the foundering areas as it will be helpful in moving your country forward. Focus on the future.

[@iiwhite-shadowii9215]

I love the videos with Sami hamdi u could make the episode 5 hours i would listen from the beginning to the end

[@WantToKnow-b1c]

جزاكم الله خيرا Very informative MashaAllah.

[@terriej123]

Sounds about right. That’s what the west usually does, especially in the mid east.

[@RobertMangeni-m9b]

Brilliant and eloquent explanation of Syrian transition and current status.

[@IshratLubna]

As a muslim i do not want Afghanistan type of Sharia in Syria. We should have every right in new Syria.

[@homtanks7259]

As a Muslim I want Allah's law in every single Muslim country

[@knawaz3694]

Be careful your statement is close to Kufr. Shariah rejection is Kufr. I hope you mean Shariah as implemented by Taliban not Shariah overall

[@IshratLubna]

@knawaz3694 yeah Indonesia, Malaysia also have sharia but their women do not need to live in stone ages 🤷‍♀️. Muslims needs to grow very much. We need to be very serious about this. As you see if you are weak then you are no consider as a human. Living such stone age life will not be helpful.

[@HippieNinja-lv5lp]

Sami Hamdi is super smart. I like this format. Ask him direct questions, have him answer them. Ask him tougher questions.

[@mohammedgt8102]

I can't get enough of his views. He is absolutely brilliant.

[@Sana0567]

German Foreign Minister: We told the Syrian government that Europe will not give money to Islamic structures. The judiciary and the education system in Syria should not be Islamic. First, they plunge the Muslim country into chaos, war, sanctions and poverty. Then they condition that the new government must stay away from Islam.

[@nicolebraunelias5672]

The biggest shameful „ foreign minister that Germany ever had“!( as a German I know and rest assured- in 6 weeks are elections and she will be gone …Inshallah!

[@ismailHossain-ln9ln]

Until change our religion , Yahuddi Nara won't be happy .