What a trip! Vocal Coach reacts to Led Zeppelin performing Since I've Been Loving You LIVE in 1973

This isn't a first-time reaction because I know I've heard Led Zeppelin's "Stairway to Heaven", but I haven't explored much else from the band's catalog. Today we're watching them perform "Since I've Been Loving You" live at Madison Square Garden in 1973.
Watch the original video uninterrupted: • Since I've Been Loving...
🎶 Website: www.thevocalys...
💙 Patreon: / thevocalyst
#ledzeppelin #reaction #vocalcoach

[@PeterTea]

Don’t worry, Led Zeppelin has been blowing peoples minds for over 50 years. 🤯

[@jamesbosenberg4060]

55 years 👍👍👍

[@gistechrep3816]

And it sounds absolutely fresh and emotional each and every time! Led Zeppelin was such an influential group in the early days of rock, blues rock, hard rock music that by the time I saw them live in 1979 my image was shattered - they were human after all!

[@leelyda4308]

Listen to,Going to California,it is a great chill song.

[@PeterTea]

@@leelyda4308 I think I’ve listened to every Zeppelin song at least a 1001 times.

[@kevinharalson4538]

44 years for me!

[@mikeballentine1984]

There’s 2 kinds of people. Those who love Led Zeppelin, and those who haven’t heard them yet.

[@johnr.8275]

You forgot all the ones who piss and moan about what thieves they think Led Zeppelin were. I pity those people.

[@KendraAndTheLaw]

Amen 🙂

[@guysolis5843]

You're wrong. There's 3 types of people, the third ones are the ones who know better..

[@МаксимЗадворнов-ы3д]

you forgot to insert the word 'only' between the "therer's" & '2'

[@ДмитрийВеселов-у2д]

Only The Beatles exist for 2 people.

[@dust4magnet]

The studio version is well worth hearing. Plant himself considers it his best performance. It's sublime.

[@jons3808]

100% agree 👍🏻

[@youreatoilet]

Exactly, the studio version is easily the best imo

[@HeavyBrocks]

Definitely well worth listening to, my personal fave. But… perhaps you’re confused? I’ve heard Plant in an interview say that The Rain Song is his proudest Zep moment.

[@snodgrassgerald2352]

no it's not/ not even close to this. yeah i know you got a led t-shirt last year. it's all good. i saw them this '73 tour. sit down

[@wiggles877]

There's also a version from the Zeppelin DVD that's from a different night at MSG, it's a little tighter. I think it's the better version, though they are quite similar.

[@robarnold6998]

Zeppelin was notorious for improvisation during live performances. That’s what really made them special to see live. Their performance was never canned. Maybe not always clean and pristine but never, ever boring. Four of the most accomplished musicians in the history of Rock music. Really enjoyed your reaction, young lady.

[@ionicast]

Attention English hopeful...NOTORIOUS has a negative connotation: infamous, disreputable...I think you have meant: Zeppelin was WELL-KNOWN for....that's something quite different...

[@Mr.Ekshin]

@@ionicast - Notorious has two meanings... one simply meaning "of note", "famous" or "worth noting". But yeah... it is also often used in a negative sense to describe criminal notoriety or an underhanded sort of fame. PS - The word that people always seem to misuse in this context is "infamous" which is always a negative.

[@oscardopantes]

Amen

[@mizzconstrued9994]

You said it exactly what I was going to say plus the best band ever!!

[@Topsrite]

💯 correct

[@robincruson9040]

Robert and Jimmy often hit/play the same notes at the same time. It is just ONE of the reasons that nobody has ever come along that compares to Zeppelin. Pure greatness.

[@capstan50g]

Led Zeppelin were famous for not playing songs the same way twice. They're just great musicians. It was fun to watch your appreciation of their blues chops on this one. Speaking as a guitar player, that high note near the end that you were curious about is most certainly Robert Plant's voice. I can't get enough of this particular version of the song. Great reaction, Bethany!

[@vadimmalinovskiy8970]

This is indeed Plant's voice. If anyone is in doubt, just look at Jimmy Page's left hand. If he played this high note, then his hand should have slid to the base of the guitar neck: this is where the strings are clamped on high notes. But he didn't. I did not immediately understand, and then I began to closely follow the guitarist, and not the singer. This is Plant's note.🙂

[@michaelmaltzer5426]

Another band to look at on that note (not playing the song the same way twice), listen to the Grateful Dead. Any song, it doesn’t matter, they were a jam band more than anything else. Their lives shows were an experience… even if you weren’t on anything (but I’d say only 1% of people at dead shows were not on one drug or another🤣… at least that’s what a friend told me😜🤣

[@j_freed]

He goes for the high note but his voice breaks, as does happen on tour playing many shows a month.

[@salsonny]

@@j_freed Plus all the cigy's , cocaine and booze you want, dont help the vocal chords

[@tilnilken1406]

I agree his voice breaks - I have heard other recordings where it doesn’t in this song. But it is definitely his voice and not the guitar.

[@TheRscorp]

He was 24/25 here. Which just blows my mind how much confidence and stage presence he had. Actually even their first recordings when he was 20. Just an unreal performer. Best of the best.

[@johnp5351]

Yep going to see him in Nov with his UK band of the moment Saving Grace , lovely folk blues psych fusion . He is not the Robert Plant of Zep but he is at 75 still a great vocalist , v musical and v playful with a few nods to his past and if youre lucky the odd Planty scream

[@Grimalken1969]

He had a lot of experience, having started performing on stage while only around 17 years old. He was only 20 when Page found him.

[@psycomole]

Yes all of them

[@jcc3999]

​@@Grimalken1969he was 16 in his first band band of joy 1964 bonham got his first set of drums at 14 years old he played in his first band the king snakes when he was 16 years old 1964

[@jcc3999]

Also Remember no voice lessons either Just all natural crazy that also goes for Bonham I believe he went to one drum lesson and the teacher told him to save his money and don't come back there was nothing he could teach him he was 14 then first year that he got a drum kit two years later his playing in the king snakes

[@Drjoyitas]

This was 50 years ago. Still is the best rock performance in history

[@T.D.I.Y.M.F.M]

You can say that again! Ever since my step dad showed me this when I was a kid back when we had VHS it did something inside me that I can't explain. My life was never the same and ever since that night long ago I have not stopped watching it from VHS, DVD to Blu-ray they even came out with an album of the show and now waiting for it to come out on 4k. Can't even remember how many times I've seen/listened to this. As a matter of fact I'm watching it on KZbin, forgot what I was searching for but the whole movie/concert was free to watch with ads. How can I not click on it.

[@Topsrite]

All the dates were in 75&77

[@Siblysm]

@@T.D.I.Y.M.F.MSame here!

[@alcelaya1365]

Half a century

[@craigking8758]

She blushed the whole song.nothing to do with Robert plants tight pants 😂❤😊😊

[@stevemmmm1341]

Led Zeppelin are still the most important band in Rock n Roll history

[@francishughes542]

Surely you mean "History".

[@tubecoatue]

Yep.

[@markweaver3352]

They were recognized and given a Kennedy Center award for the best rock group...they are musical geniuses.

[@mariomunozgrasso6327]

Led Zeppelin recibió el premio nobel de la música en 2005 . El premio "Polar" En Suecia.

[@coyotecreekband236]

The fact that you couldn't figure out where the guitar playing left off and the vocals began truly showcases why this band was one of the all time greats. The incredible talent of Jimmy Page's fingers and Robert Plant's voice is nothing short of amazing. They showed it time and time again on most of their signature songs, and I haven't even given props to the multi-instrumentalist John Paul Jones and the powerhouse percussion of John Bonham. I was fortunate to see them on more than one occasion and they brought their A game to every show.

[@Onlyanaccount]

You saw Zeppelin? Which shows

[@williambissell5943]

WHY ARE THERE NO BANDS LIKE THEM OR THE WHO TODAY??

[@FredAmnit]

Don't know, but it seems like back then money was a side-effect of the music. Now music is the side-effect. @@williambissell5943

[@smith9808]

The studio version is absolutely biblical. Gives me chills the last 3 minutes of the song. Plants voice pre-1972 is the greatest male vocal I’ve ever heard and I’ve heard it all. The power he had in Zeps early days is 2nd to none including Mercurys.

[@finlybenyunes8385]

Freddie Mercury acknowledged that!

[@douglaschristine8387]

I agree that the studio album version blows this away plus theirs no effects either.

[@chrisbanks6659]

Totally agree. Not so much a Plant as a Burning Bush. Well - that's biblical, at least. LOL

[@cthree87]

The original recording is brilliant.

[@scottgray8892]

​@patrice384 an old gf of mine would get moist EVERY time she heard him sing! If she wasn't in the mood, I'd put some Zeppelin on and it time to let it all out...😅😅😅😅😅

[@ballsyrocker]

I saw them live in 1975 and true, he doesn't seem to use his diaphram at all. I like your reactions. i think that Zeppelin's partial success was the fact all four members stand out in each and every song on their own contributions, whether it is vocal, guitar ,bass ,or drums. They are all excellent. Peace and Love. (I am 74 and when I saw them live, tickets were only $10.50 for a non stop 3 1/2 hour gig. no frills, no auto tune, or dancers, just talent from four excellent musicians.).

[@nigel274]

I saw then in uk in 1975....yep.. 3.5 hours...Best gig I ever went to.😊

[@kathiekinsler]

I’m so jealous. They would have been amazing to see then

[@gtxjhcrbq]

@@nigel274 в 75ом мне было 5 лет))

[@cliffjenkins6419]

Watching the young ladys face during this vid was magic. Heres hoping she does all of Zepplins work. I've been a huge fan for sixty odd years. Young lady has years to enjoy their majesty! Enjoy and Rock and Roll

[@j.a.armour2427]

Bluesy is right. Conversational is right. Improvisational is right. Soulful is right. This song actually beats out Stairway to Heaven for me. It's like a religious experience each time I listen to it. A stillness overtakes me as I listen in awe to the raw emotion being portrayed so masterfully by all the musicians in the band with each of them complimenting one another. I enjoyed your cool insights to my favorite Led Zeppelin song! As an aside, I saw them live 4 times! The first two times were at the Kinetic Playground in Chicago. Oh, were they HOT!

[@jpsf37miller48]

I saw them at the Kinetic Playground in spring ‘69 as well-with a little purple haze, they were spellbinding. Bonzo’s Moby Dick was epic.

[@pchuk3622]

Loved them but never saw them live.....Dam!

[@joefeld3697]

Saw them 3rd row right in the middle at Madison Square 1977 tour. Unreal!

[@oneox958]

Very few bands could get into a pocket like Led Zeppelin. Those four made magic together; their grooves feel almost telepathic.

[@BBaldwin]

They were, are and WILL ALWAYS BE the ultimate rock band.

[@jessewolf7649]

Add “Roll” to your comment and it’s The Stones, hands down.

[@grandpar468]

Yes , Stones were great . Have been lung on past laurels for the last 30 years

[@grandpar468]

Living

[@aandpman]

Arguably, one of the finest performances ever captured on film. Improvisation and working together, playing off one anothers' riffs was part of the magic of Zep.

[@ivanjulian2532]

Agreed. This and Comfortably Numb at the Pulse concert is the probably the Mt Everest of live performances - nothiwthstanding apparently LZ did many better performances than the TSRTS film.

[@roxannekabotsky2997]

The older I get, the more I appreciate the music of my youth. 50 plus years and better now than ever. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@Busywave]

Same. I still remember in 1972 in 8th grade hearing Led Zeppelin 4 for the very first time.

[@michaeldewitt5229]

This 1973 live performance at MSG is a timeless classic. I never get tired of listening to the whole show. Truly, one of rock and roll's greatest bands.

[@matthewdawson129]

Zeppelin was basically a blues band that added rock to their sound, but huge chunks of their discography is straight blues.

[@lyndoncmp5751]

And folk.

[@michaelmaltzer5426]

And rock n roll was born out of blues, or at the very least… inspired by blues

[@johnirvine1491]

And a bit of Country, Californian, English Tolkien, Middle Eastern. Country and Eastern? 9

[@mrled8555]

​@michaelmaltzer5426 as Muddy Waters said "The blues had a baby,and they named it rock&roll"

[@klodm.2064]

That's kind of what rock is in the first place. Blues with some more stuff added to it. They are a real proper rock band.

[@scottarnest8980]

The aura of this band live is unexplainable. They have double doses of the "it" factor.

[@finlybenyunes8385]

Quadruple doses! Zep were peerless!

[@d.brooks2035]

Deal with the Devil, baby.

[@williamgullett5911]

I don’t always listen to Led Zeppelin but when I do so do my neighbors

[@roxannekabotsky2997]

Yep. ❤

[@capecyn]

🤣 🤘

[@thaliaaeder1495]

😂😂😂

[@isadona59]

😂😂😂😂

[@ledbus36]

lol...🤣😂🤣😁

[@hughmanatee7657]

Gods. The POWER of Led Zeppelin is unmatched.

[@kathleenkishkabibbles2759]

Lez Zeppelin and Robert Plant have been my favorite since I was a young teenager. I'm now 60. Robert still puts me on another level of consiousness, not to mention I was in love with him just for HIM but his vocals just put me on another level. Still makes my heart beat fast and sweating. There will never be another Led Zeppelin.

[@roxannekabotsky2997]

So amazingly talented and sexy. Mwuahhhh. ❤

[@thedata831]

To answer your question: this is the music I want to listen to. All of Zeppelin. All of it.

[@carolynejubber]

Each member of Led Zeppelin is a master of their craft. My favourite band of all time since 1972 when I was 12 years old. As I got older I came to appreciate their back-catalogue (which I was too young to appreciate at first) as well, and my love affair with them has continued and grown ever since.

[@satortenet]

Led Zeppelin is just that band that you can find a 60 year old granddad that has been listen to it since a teenager, and never gets over it.

[@slave2tyranny]

I'm 55 so I've been a Led Zeppelin fan all my life.

[@davidwethington9320]

Guilty

[@lunarmodule7802]

Agree!

[@juliemanarin4127]

I'm 63 and listen to then every day!

[@stanleythomas8457]

i was 18 when i first heard it and I’m now 71

[@deborahwarren6710]

I’ve been loosing my worried mind listening to Led Zeppelin for 50 years now, for me it soothes the soul like no other band

[@JakeandtheMan]

The best thing is you kids are discovering what real music from the 50's, 60's and 70's was, and is all about, turning 70 tomorrow and still listen to it everyday.

[@gjamieson1956]

Yeo mate ,from Australia

[@AzaleaLala]

I was a teenager in the 70s and Led Zeppelin is what we listened to. They are who I think of when I think of rock music.

[@roxannekabotsky2997]

❤

[@melanieredfield9736]

Plant and Page had great instincts for blues and mastered call & response between Robert's voice and Jimmy's guitar. In "Dazed and Confused" there is an entire section that showcases such an interlude between the two. They were just a fantastic band, all 4 members locked in together so they could riff and improvise without ever losing their groove. Robert also plays harmonica but in the style of vocals; he's amazing on "When the Levee Breaks".

[@yoellcall]

As a kiwi woman...im so grateful ive had these musician's in my life as a constant backgroud sound to my life. Discovered them when i was 16. Loved them ever since...deeply soulful connection. Love them always.

[@gil82b]

Led Zeppelin 1 is number 1. The variety, the raw emotion, power. Made in 38 hours. True stait from the soul. Number one album of any group

[@michel_g]

Thank you Bethany. A classic performance with Robert in his prime. Watching the expressions on your face as you experience these songs is priceless. Keep discovering new stuff!

[@Incomudro1963]

Past his prime. His voice is damaged here.

[@lyndoncmp5751]

He developed nodules on his vocal cords in late 1972, which got worse through 1973. He had to have a throat operation. He's still bloody great here though, with an amazing stage presence which every woman reacting to it seems to be in awe of. I've literally watched dozens of them.

[@johnwalsh9144]

@@Incomudro1963 I would agree he had damage here that limited his full range displayed between 68-72. His voice alone in the early videos is worth a reaction from people like Bethany. They were extremely loud, and with that ultra pro rhythm section pounding behind them, Plant and Page up front in your face literally overwhelmed audiences, especially seeing them for the 1st time.

[@johnyoung5014]

At 70 I’ve been listening to to this music for over 50 years. Great reaction. Robert Plant still has the voice and stage presence as evidenced by his recent tour with Allison Krause.

[@kathiek4239]

Funny story about Led Zeppelin: growing up we ALWAYS had music playing in our house. Always. My dad had wired the entire house with speakers to our stereo (I’m talking early 80s) so we could put an album on and have it playing throughout the house. My mom played mostly Irish & country music. Us kids played everything from hard rock (Zeppelin, AC/DC) to disco to singer/songwriter (Cat Stevens, James Taylor). To her credit, my mom just loved music & never told us to take anything off. Anyway, my sister had Zeppelin playing & mom was enjoying the music. She turned to my sister and said “I like the music. Too bad the singer can’t sing.” !!!! My sister looked at her in absolute horror. “ That’s Robert Plant, mom!” We still laugh about it & say “Too bad he can’t sing” every time we hear Robert Plant. Also, I so enjoy your reactions to the music. You can tell you feel music in every bone in your body. It was a true pleasure seeing you discover Led Zeppelin. 🥰

[@noahshue5579]

As a Zeppelin fan of like 20 years it is SO AWESOME to see someone discovering how truly awesome and unique Zeppelin is.

[@roseannepryor7220]

Led Zeppelin is the soundtrack of my teenage years in the 70’s! Best band ever!

[@rockyjones4727]

What always impressed me about Robert Plant live is his way of converting a song we know from a studio album and tastefully cheating, not hitting the high or intense notes on the album. He's masterful at it. He certainly goes for some of the high bits, as shown here, but is very smart in saving his voice.

[@johnwalsh9144]

That is experience and knowing what he has in the tank to get through the night or the upcoming schedule. It comes from doing 700+ 2-4 hr shows.

[@bobadams179]

Led Zeppelin is known most as a blues rock band. If you want to hear a great example of this listen to "When Levee Breaks" which is a cover of an ancient blues tune. In my opinion they are the greatest rock band that ever was.

[@gotangirl]

Just phenomenal , brilliant performance . Page's guitar is from Heaven . Best ever , love it ❤

[@goldenboy140]

Page is so overrated and totally botched the second guitar solo here. The man couldn't keep in time to safe his life. Maybe it's all the drugs I don't know but yeah he played horribly here

[@peterbluesman]

@@goldenboy140lol, I bet you play guitar, and pretty badly I’d imagine. You probably also love to listen to lukewarm players, lol. You have no concept of how tone deaf you are . 😂

[@joepoulos4081]

The studio version has the most incredible blues guitar solo ever recorded. I was fortunate enough to see Zeppelin live in 1971, 1973, and 1975. In Florida. Their live performances were incredible.

[@jetd9716]

This song just nails it for me in terms of emotions, page's guitar work is the centerpiece of this masterpiece and how he just weaves in and out of his notes. Definitely one of the best work page has done.

[@roxannekabotsky2997]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@EdA1]

Just discovered your channel, great reaction! That is an iconic performance and I was fortunate to be at that show July 29, 1973… The original version of the song was released in 1970. Believe it or not three years later as powerful and high pitched Robert Plant sounds, from all the touring he lost a good amount of power and range since three years earlier. If you want your mind really blown, please listen to the original studio version!

[@johnwalsh9144]

Great reaction .... LZ did about 80% of their 700+ 2-4hr concerts/shows between 68-73. They did not release singles (very few and always forced by the label) and promoted the albums this way, as they also did not use TV or other media methods of the time (ie: interviews ect ...) to promote their music. Plant had vocal surgery not long after these tours. They took a full year off and worked on the double album release for 75, but Robert Plant was never the godlike phenom he was when he broke in and shocked the industry. Listen to studio or live from 1969-70, you will not be disappointed!

[@lyndoncmp5751]

Plant developed nodules on his vocal cords in late 1972, which got worse through 1973. He later had to have a 'secret' throat operation to get rid of them. He still hadn't fully recovered when Zeppelin recorded Physical Graffiti, and you can hear a cool raspiness in his voice on the songs recorded for that album in 1974.

[@johnwalsh9144]

@@lyndoncmp5751 Several tracks that were added to PG were earlier recordings and studio work that did not make it onto previous albums. This accounts for the variances in his vocals from track to track on this (what turned into) double album (15 tracks). The albums and other musical ventures that came afterward were tremendous efforts and produced more timeless music. I don't want anyone to think I am saying Robert was not fabulous going forward! I (and apparently others here) are just stating facts about his sound having to evolve as the years went on.

[@lyndoncmp5751]

@@johnwalsh9144 Indeed, and you can tell the difference in Plant's vocals. The raspiness on Custard Pie (recorded post operation in 1974) vs the high pitch on Houses of the Holy (recorded pre operation in 1972) to name just one example of the different voices he had.

[@snakeinthegrass7443]

Yes, the coordination between all members of the band but especially Robert (singer) and Jimmy (guitar) is spectacular. You can see in so many of their live performances how they use call and response back and forth with each other - much of it, I assume is improvised!! That's why they are the greatest rock and roll band to ever exist. Great reaction. Please keep going. Studio, live, it doesn't matter. They are masters wherever they go.

[@shelleynogle5422]

There's also a great symbiotic relationship between Bonham and Plant that blows my mind.

[@jonofalltradesmasterofnone832]

Bonham and plant knew each other before the band was formed. Jimmy page was a session musician in his teens and JPJ was the real musician in the band playing Bass sometimes foot bass whilst playing the keyboards Jimmy page invented many guitar production methods including pedals. Many of their albums were recorded at Headley Grange a few miles from where I live.

[@EddieReischl]

This song is so much fun to play guitar along with, and it's because Robert is so totally feeding the guitar. It's a beautiful chord progression too, and how it descends at the end back down to the tonic chord. It's a fantastic conversation.

[@rknotz187]

I've watch this performance 1,000,000,000,000 times. Love it more every time.

[@rupowell2821]

I’m with you here bud..I watched it probably every day (a few times) for about five years in the early 90s..had it on the old VHS cassette..every single day..over and over, the whole show, still pure magic ✊🍻

[@williambissell5943]

ME Too!! CAN'T GET ENOUGH!! HA HA HA!!!

[@blaiseutube]

This is beyond rock. It's blues/jazz, these guys are real musicians flexing mastery way out on the edge of being. One tiny misstep and everything would fall apart.

[@Jude_196]

This has to be one of the best performances of all time, in my opinion. The talent, tightness of the band, and vocal range are all just astounding. I've watched it hundreds of times and am almost brought to tears, every time he hits that last apex, near the end: SO THRILLING! Has to be one of the most mesmerizing, erotic, AMAZING performances I've ever seen! Really showcases their cohesiveness as a band. The call and response is amazing, as it always is with Led Zepplin...and, you add JPJ's bass and Bonzo's amazing drumming (usually in a very different time signature than the rest of the song with their catalog): you just CANNOT get much BETTER THAN THIS! LOVED your reaction. It matched mine, the first time I heard this song, years ago!! JUST INCREDIBLE. Thanks for your channel - I've really enjoyed watching your reactions! HUGS! ❤

[@chrishuntze3446]

Thanks for your appreciation of this band. All the members are amazing. You have opened up a door that can lead to Robert's life time of work, along with all the commentary Jimmy Page gives on creating the music. As said below, you need to check out studio versions too. There is so much emotion in this song that it helps me to cry when I need to get it out. Thanks again for your appreciation.

[@Tango9mm]

If you really want to hear the progression of this song over the years they’ve been playing it live (and all their songs) go to a sight called Black Beauty. Site has 99% of all their concerts since 1968. I am especially keen on the period between 69 and 73. They’ve played it perhaps 60-70 times and each time they play it it’s different. The improv from these 4 guys are breathtaking. They are loose in their artistic freedom but tight in that they always find and feed off each other. Not too many bands can achieve this each and every time they go on stage

[@brenthorn2475]

I was introduced to Led Zeppelin’s debut album when it came out in ‘69, from an older brother when I was 16 years old. Now, at 70 years old I go back to it often. It’s classic music that will never grow old. Love watching this young woman’s expressions. Tells it all! Led Zeppelin music is the Mozart of the 1960’s & 1970’s. My grandkids are now listening to it with me in awe. I have the cd collection of all their music.

[@zeroyum1473]

Every time I watch one of your videos I think "I love how you nerd out". Your expressions show how much you love figuring out every little detail of how the artist accomplish such amazing sounds...

[@marko2873]

Rock and Metal are an evolution of Blues, so it's not unusual for early bands to have an obvious blues tone to some of the music. And Led Zeppelin and Black Sabbath are probably the two most influential founding members of those genres.

[@roadrunnergtx68]

Don't forget Deep Purple now.

[@jesusgonzaiialez8223]

There was 3 monsters in the beginning... * Led Zeppelin * Deep Purple * Black Sabbath

[@crashandburngaming5103]

Yep..no blues...no rock

[@CollaterlieSisters]

​​@@jesusgonzaiialez8223but not necessarily in that order ;)

[@CollaterlieSisters]

IMO, even acknowledging a very early bluesy influence, Sabbath were extraordinary because in retrospect the alleged connection with blues now seems tenuous. They sound almost completely unrelated to anything preceding.

[@77MrRd]

At one point you asked "what kind of rock do you like" , with Led Zeppelin you get a rock variety , from this bluesy track to rock and roll and the song "Thank You" which is a brilliant love song , so please listen to some more , you won't be disappointed . Great post by the way , I enjoyed that

[@targetshootr]

Great choice. The first time I saw Zep I wanted to see if his voice was for real. And it was. But I never understood how they could play every night or two and not be deaf. They were extremely loud. And mind blowing.

[@shelleynogle5422]

Absolutely! The first time I saw them was 1971 at the Fabulous Forum in Los Angeles. My ears rang for a week. They were, and still are, my #1.

[@margaretarchambault6139]

There is so much incredible music from Zeppelin, this of course is epic, but "Ten Years Gone" is my personal favorite Zeppelin song. The best of all 4 of them.

[@LordEagle]

Led Zeppelin is for the ADVANCED music listener. 💥💥💥👍😎

[@susanpalmer8931]

Wonderful reaction! Robert is in a class all of his own - his range; phrasing; emotion and his lyric writing- so good. Led Zeppelin has a large catalog with so many different genres - but definitely blues based. FYI - Robert did have vocal issues around this time and for a few years after. I believe he eventually had cord surgery. He is still performing and has moved to traditional American music. Saw him with Alison Krauss last year - fabulous. If you're interested - here are some numbers that show other types of deliveries - studio recording- Thank You - softer/sweet kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z2Ouk4J3mJ2po80; Babe I'm Gonna Leave You - live 1969 - he was 20 years at the time - kzbin.info/www/bejne/rYCZk4WgmN6EhJo and live 2007 - about 30 years after the band disbanded - reunion concert - at their first full concert since 1980 - Robert was 59 at the time - glorious - Kashmir - kzbin.info/www/bejne/hnWQfpefitJklbs Maybe you'll take a look. Thanks for the reaction!

[@williambissell5943]

they did a masterful job at that live reunion, Jason was stunning. But I get why Robert never wanted to get back together. To disappoint the audience is not what he would ever want.

[@cherylmontgomery9753]

Yes, Robert Plant had nodules removed from his throat. Fortunately it didn't affect his amazing voice.

[@McLeod2022]

Plant seduced the audience with his presence, physically and vocally... that command of the stage at 13:28... how the band holds back and gives him that space to roam... take time.. build tension. This is a great video. Seen it many times and love it every time. *** edit - and what an intro... patient and not a note wasted

[@jeffm1896]

Back then, every woman wanted to be with Robert Plant, and every man wanted to be Robert Plant.

[@wedoithardandwemakeithurt]

Jimmy freaking Page!

[@McLeod2022]

@@wedoithardandwemakeithurt four legends... hurt my heart to see plant tear up at the kennedy center honors when Jason Bonham took the kit, the choir came out from behind the screen, and Ann Wilson belted out Stairway with Jason looking up to the sky... and Jimmy was smiling the whole night, appreciating the honor, the musicians, and his work on display. *Jack Black did them justice with his intro

[@Tarkus_]

So awesome to see you dive into Led Zeppelin and the legendary Robert Plant! They were heavily blues-influenced, especially early in their career. And in that blues/blues-rock genre, this is certainly one of their most popular tracks. It's probably my favorite live performance of them, for any song, and it's a favorite of many Zeppelin fans. I'm so glad you talked about the band chemistry, but particularly between Plant and Page. I've been watching/listening to this forever (or at least since it was put on the big screen back in the day), and I've always marveled at how well Plant and Page play off each other, especially in this song. I don't think I've ever seen it done any better, between a singer and guitarist. The way they flow back and forth is just ridiculous. It's like musical telepathy!

[@TB-zw7dt]

Just one of so many great performances. It's fun to watch people look at it closer so many years later. Same with many artists.

[@jmssun]

16:39 in the album version, when Robert sang the part “oh my tears that fell like rain.. don’t you see them fall”, the drum actually followed with the beats that imitated the emotional impact of tears falling! Love it!

[@BCxBOSS]

I’m only 26 years old and the only person in my peers who have seen Plant perform live albeit with the band of joy but still a sight to behold and one of the most cherished memories of my life ❤

[@katyharrs278]

Yep that is absolutely Roberts voice at the end,best blues/rock vocalist of all time 😊

[@marcies3789]

The interplay between Robert and Jimmy is simply amazing. Keep in mind much of this is just improvised on stage. And of course the backing can't be beat. Simply the best rock band ever.

[@davidcooper3871]

You are touching on the magic of the 4 most astute musicians/singer in rock, I’m tearing up watching this video (and your reaction) having seen this so many times over the past 45 or years. I’m a diehard Zeppelin fan and will go to my grave playing their music over and over in my mind…

[@pattyraczynski9566]

You cant explain it, there are no words. Zeppelin was visually , physically, and mentally life changing. Outstanding…! This woman looks like she’s in love…like all of us! Haha…shes needs a cold shower!

[@chesterm883]

My first reaction to watching you listening to the video here, and a few other videos you commented on, is I love how your facial expressions, eyes, eye brows are like watching one of my favorite actors, Meg Ryan in Sleepless in Seattle and You’ve Got Mail. I know you’re commenting on these videos, but there’s something captivating about how the music/voices/songs touches you and it adds so much more to your comments because I can see it, feel it in your whole face and even the way you turn or twist your head as your searching for the words to say is very Meg Ryan-like. 👏🏼👌🏼👍🏼😎😉 Keep doing what you’re doing, it’s you … 🤗

[@srt8rocketship241]

There is two versions of this as it was a 2 night show. You picked the best of them. My opinion. These ARE the Masters. Timeless. They had a special ESP that most bands can never achieve when performing.

[@LukeNukem82]

A lot of people rag on his vocals later on in his career, and its mostly justified, he did lose a few steps, but in the early 70's I don't think there was anyone who could compare to his soulful stage presence. Legitimately the greatest frontman of his generation.

[@McLeod2022]

Time tears all of us down. He burnt both end of that candle gloriously.

[@rylinhansen9019]

I wish he hadn't been a smoker! ☹️

[@williambissell5943]

I saw Plant in the 90's a few times... He had that Elvis vocal change. And has lived with those changes since. So NO, not many can keep those screams up. Paul Rogers, Tom Jones, Robin Zander and Elvis got better as years ticked by.

[@Wrench7532]

I just ran into your channel tonight and I love your reactions to some of the best music of all time and to see your absolute appreciation and precise breakdown of this famous Masterpiece from the Great Led Zeppelin. And you have just barely scratched fhe surface and there is So much more. I would love to hear more of your thoughts you make me like appreciate this performance so much more myself Please keep doing what you do

[@2filos]

What a beautiful moment I have spent traveling to my childhood listening to Zepellin. Beth, you are the best! Thank you for this. The sharp sound that you mention is Robert's voice, the guitar is making a tremolo (mandolin type). Both Plant and Page were the pillars of this band. All his compositions revolved around the voice and the guitar. Page created great epic hard rock riffs.

[@SomeOneNew1029]

When they played live, the structure of the song became a simple framework. Everything else just flowed along that framework and was different each time. Yet it all held together. True masters of their craft!

[@BaliSurfHunters]

Led Zeppelin's brilliance was the constant improvisation between the 4 musicians. The drummer played off the guitar licks just as much as the vocalist. They pushed themselves everynight, never playing it safe.

[@bradleyluft7428]

Those of us who loved Led Zeppelin have always considered them a blues/rock ballad band. One of the best bands ever. I played for my wife on a road trip who really had never heard them and is now a huge fan.

[@JohnGriffith-w2w]

This woman has no idea whatsoever that she’s listening to four Absolute Master Musicians to ever assemble ever! Enjoy !

[@randallcox6573]

A friend that served In the Marines with me called me up and had gotten 4 tickets from a promotion. I flew up from Dallas and crashed at his place. His girl introduced me to her cousin. What a weekend. We had Saturday night tickets. 3 months later I flew her cousin to Dallas. Been married 50 years to the same damn women, and would do it over and over again.

[@goncalotavares3805]

Amazing story!

[@jmar7631]

Excellent reaction, thanks. The band members really played off each other, did a lot of improv during live performances. If you want to explore Plant's voice more in-depth, I suggest also listening to studio versions (the first two albums have a lot of blues rock tracks). Keep in mind if you do that there was no auto-tune back then. Although you won't be able to see his muscle action, you'll hear some absolutely incredible singing, as well as musicians who were beyond compare. Page on guitar is something to behold, but Jones on bass/keys and Bonham on drums really held down the fort. ;) Edit: As far as what type of rock music I like to listen to, it depends on my mood, of course. But Led Zeppelin has always been my "go-to". They were so diverse (blues, folk, English country, rock, punk, jazz, a bit of metal, etc.) and creative that one can set the needle at the start of an album and not have to lift it until it's over. They were no one-trick pony band like so many others, thus will hit all vibes. ;)

[@mndoci]

The studio version made Robert Plant my favorite singer ever a long time ago. Great way to start, especially since Led Zep have such a wide variety of songs.

[@Mr.Ekshin]

If you followed them on tour, you'd never see the same show twice. Every show, every set list, every solo, and every vocal choice you hear is improvised on the spot. These guys went out there night after night and just JAMMED.

[@michelm306]

That ending chord played by the guitar and organ bring such breathtaking final notes to the song. It's so beautiful I almost can't wrap my head around it

[@martinbynion1589]

Fascinating to watch a singing expert screw up her face when the camera switches from the vocalists abdomen to the 5-star lead guitarist. That is FOCUS! I love this so much in your reactions.

[@Bluewizard7131]

Greatest improvisational band of all time! Greatest live band of all time! They performed most songs differently each time they played.

[@BoyRalphie]

Grateful Dead are the masters in that category but Page and Plant are amazing

[@juliemanarin4127]

@@BoyRalphie yeah...no. I disagree

[@garrygrasinski]

Another great reaction video! Listen to current Robert Plant and realize he hasn't "blown" his voice and can still sing that big head of hair off. He's still so vocally expressive and can still dig into that wild range of his.

[@chriswebb7822]

Just saw him and Allison Krause 2 months ago...Amazing!!

[@patwilson2546]

He lost his ability to hit certain notes by the mid 70s. You can see the transition happen on Physical Graffiti. Since then his voice is still the same. He can do all of the later Zeppelin stuff just fine. The earlier stuff he does differently, but not really much differently than he did in 1979.

[@garrygrasinski]

@@patwilson2546 Agreed. And he’s aged more gracefully than a lot of rockers. His arrangements of Zeppelin songs played live now are just awesome.

[@patwilson2546]

@@garrygrasinski I never saw LKZ live but I did see Page twice and Plant three times. The last time I saw Plant was around 2005. He played one Zep song to one new one throughout the concert. The Zep songs he rearranged with a North African feel. it worked.

[@juliemanarin4127]

Greatest band ever...especially live! They did every genre!! I prefer to hear any Zeppelin song!!

[@luisescalante6766]

Your technical comments give a much clearer idea of the depths of Zeppeling s songs and unique skills of his members.Being an inconditional fan of Led Zeppeling i enjoy this video a lot .Thank you

[@michaelrainbow4203]

It always amazes me the things I take for granted. My childhood was so steeped in Led Zeppelin, since my Dad was (and is) 60s and 70s music junkie. I sometimes forget that it is possible for people to not even be aware of the things I am so intimately familiar with. It truly shocked me when you said that Stairway to Heaven is the only Zeppelin song you know! Shocked and positively delighted, also. We all have such different childhoods and experiences. It is marvelous!

[@jodypena8378]

Looks like Jimmy impressed you as well as Robert! Kudos for picking this legendary band to analyze!

[@chrisbanks6659]

One of the greatest exponents of 'Sprechgesang' and structural improvisation in live performances (live performances were always subtly different) - and a lot of people never realised it. No auto tune in those days either. Take that on board, younger people!!!! LOL. Thanks for the input Bethany. Every day's a school day for us mere mortals. 😊 Fun fact: The 'hooded' lady in the audience at 19:00 was Robert's then wife, Maureen.

[@ilovenaps1297]

definitely was NOT his wife, there is a viddy on here somewhere of the girl talking about being in the movie and she saved the hoodydress and all that. Her name may be Ana Pearce. Can't find the viddy now

[@WalterRiley-e6e]

This is probably the greatest rock band of all time

[@mikebunner3498]

O.K. lady are you ready for four men from England performing American BLUES??? They do an outstanding job!!!!! Since I've been lovin you.!!!! The blues Zeppelin style!!! Timeless............ One of the most talented rock bands of ALL time!!! They have sold over 300 million units worldwide. I recall reading that they walked into a studio and completed an album in just four hours. Epic talent!!!!! These skills is the reason they could do these shows and albums so well.. Take care and have a safe New Year!!!

[@James-c2g1k]

The communication between guitar and Vox is unparalleled

[@ajhoyt2552]

Consider that they had done this song as a standard staple in all of their live shows, there was a vast evolution of the guitar improvisation and the vocal embellishments from the studio version, correctly called sublime in another post. The band "grew together" in that no two performances could ever be exactly alike. They play in harmony taking cues from the others in a well-developed performance presentation that is easy to track over the years. This performance is a masterpiece but the studio version (and all live versions) make me cry EVERY time (I excuse myself because it IS the blues). I love watching your enthralled gaze while listening to it! You really can spot the best of one of the best performances of any group.

[@carmelaruck7116]

If you are liking the Bluesy side of Zep, one of my favorites that they did was " Tea for One". This band, you will find, has a song for every mood that you have.

[@jimbyron7706]

I’ve always said Tea for One is on the same level as SIBLY…jimmys solo is mind bending on TFO

[@MrT67]

Wonderful to hear an expert commentary on what we have been hearing all of these decades. Thank you, you've helped me to appreciate Robert Plant's voice even more. 👍🙂

[@robertstoner8244]

I love how you do your homework. Zep is the best rock band ever. Roberts voice is unique. Amazing stuff. I remember when zep came out. And wow. I'm so glad I got to grow up listening to Zeppelin. Very special ❤

[@kimzwolinski9919]

This is the best live I have heard of this song. I love watching the live performances.😊❤

[@culturebreath369]

One of the best vocalists ever. ❤