This ancient philosopher knew why empires fall. And America is next.

[@amareto5772]

"At the beggining of empire, the tax rates are low, but the revenues are high. At the end of empire, the taxes are high and the revenues will be lower". Ibn Khaldun

[@DynamicUnreal]

This sounds like self inflicted death of empires on the side of politicians/leaders who usually complain about corporate/private “greed” meanwhile slowly over time increasing taxes and their own power.

[@kalajari1749]

​@@DynamicUnrealIts jews

[@thedarkknight6159]

Norway, Sweden, Denmark have the highest tax rates on earth, how are they fitting into this theory? Or are they excluded from the theory since they dont act like an empire?

[@overvault]

@@thedarkknight6159 1. like you said they dont act like empires. 2. what he said it is one argument but of course it is not all the arguments, the countries you mentioned have high taxes but also they have a lot of laws to secure citizens life.

[@DynamicUnreal]

@@thedarkknight6159 They have high income taxes but relatively low property tax, and no inheritance tax. They tax the people heavily, but they don’t tax their productive capacity heavy which prevents them from becoming sinking ships. They’re still not darlings though. The European darling of the last 15 years is Ireland and they have a much lower corporate tax rate.

[@TeamNova80]

A wise man once said: The strongest empires always crumble from the inside slowly...

[@Broccoli-m9h]

"Nothing lasts forever"

[@bonaanayaga]

Rome to many wars and orgies

[@kingcatx2]

You can’t compare old empires with new nations. It’s like racing an old car vs a new one full with technology…

[@AaliyaBasheer-xe6uy]

Just like Israel

[@TeamNova80]

@@kingcatx2 But eventually that new car will get old and crumble. Nothing lasts forever

[@khalidkorjieh]

As A Lebanese citizen this completely correct assabiyah is the only thing that allows my country my people to fend off the current invasion of Israel and the constant airstrikes that has took the the life of thousands of citizens and it's the same thing that allows Palestine and Gaza to still exist

[@alib9824]

Allah y7mekon

[@matahari8673]

❤

[@Squeeko639]

What is Assabiyah in Arabic? Is it like الصحابية؟ عصبية؟ Someone help me out here.

[@khalidkorjieh]

@@Squeeko639 عصابية

[@almami1599]

@@Squeeko639العصبية

[@Octa-x5m]

Some Americans and Europeans keep joking about 'send them back to stone age'. Thing is , less technology = stronger asabiyyah because dependency on technology means less relationship with people.

[@user-if9pp4vg7g]

Tell them to get their own numbers first.

[@ranapriliaful]

Well If Im not wrong, during WW2 it does happened. A modern gun at the time, sub machine gun, rifle, grenade, tank? They lost to a people using bamboo to fight. They won their freedom by blood instead given. Now their nation known for having bee-hive community. Something that you wont see in other country.

[@AbdulSamad-dz4vw]

@@ranapriliaful which country?

[@nafeesrashid668]

Well defined, backwardness is strength

[@daoudaba1628]

​@@AbdulSamad-dz4vwa fighter with bambou is certainly not a Taliban, he is a ...

[@mohaglade4892]

Finally someone discussing this philosophy by mentioning the philosopher behind it , i watched so many videos where people use IBn Khuldun philosophy without giving credit to him

[@ghst4487]

Are you an Arab. That's why you're so happy someone mentioned ibnu khaldun? Lmao

[@huus5682]

because his name and background

[@Katniss_cosmos]

Isn't this almost always the case ? Even in sciences.

[@daoudaba1628]

​@@huus5682Because he was not hew,he was Arab.

[@huus5682]

@@daoudaba1628 the correct explanation is because he's a muslim.

[@Redone488]

I'm here because a friend of mine said that Muslims are barbarian and have no participated in both history and science for humanity, I watched a lots of Videos and one of them is this, it seems like they brought even the modern science which European claim it theirs . Awesome video

[@abofatma2171]

What your friend said applies to him, he has to read history, because ignorance in this form is really funny.

[@borkistanon4194]

Your friend is somewhat right, Arab nations nowadays tend to be backwaters compared to the West. I feel this isn't because they're Arab; more that most Arab nations embraced theocracies, theocracies which suppress scientific advancement for the sake of dogma. I worry the US is headed the same route, but instead of Islamic fundamentalism it's Christian Fundamentalism

[@saveUyghurs]

God help your clueless friend

[@woodybrando9665]

the islamic golden age would disagree with your friend lmao

[@artemis-arrow3098]

​@@woodybrando9665man, the islamic golden age makes the european golden age look like the medieval times it is said that not even the birds felt hunger in the muslim lands, due to the sheer abundance

[@mr.squanch]

A Kurd dude dropped this sentence about 820 years ago. “If you want to destroy any nation without war, make adultery or nudity common in the young generation” - Salahuddin Ayyubi 12th century - I'll leave that uncommented. Let's just hope he's wrong...

[@KD400_]

​​@Rakibrown111 well because they know that leads to a corrupt society. I'm sure they love naked women but they also know it's the gateway to evil too

[@MorabitAbderahman-Berkane]

Salah u edine was kurdish, Ibn Khaldun even atated in his book that his family was of Amazigh (Zenata) tribe

[@AshikurRahmanRifat]

​@@Rakibrown111 still better then a whore house ,Only fans...

[@abdullahalajmi880]

@@MorabitAbderahman-Berkane You're a lier. Ibn Khaldun states in his own introduction he's Arab of Hadhramite descent from one of the Hadhramite Sahabis.

[@freeman37]

RIP the West 🪦

[@arminiuszmazowszanin2670]

The way afghan talibans survived american occupation and later took over so quickly was also strong asabiyyah. Pashtun klans are very united.

[@iamKristianBell]

Yep. I had removed a section of this video that talked about that actually. Didn't want to be flagged by govt lol

[@thetraditionalist]

@@iamKristianBell fair but I also thought the same thing

[@SomeOne-xm5mq]

They survived because it was meant for them to survive the play of international cynism in which America was playing the major role. They later took over quickly because they were allowed to. If there existed different interests by the deep state, those so-called tribes would be exterminated systematically in one way or another. Those wars that America waged are complete science fiction.

[@Joe-sg9ll]

there used to be a hundred of them all fighting each other. now there is one that is somewhat answerable to NATO for continued funding

[@Joe-sg9ll]

​@@stevestackpole6817only the ones on our side

[@goldenibby]

Khalid ibn Walid (R.A) said: "I bring you men who desire death as ardently as you desire life."

[@thedrbat9572]

Those same few hundred men are now 2 billion and growing strong.

[@lastnamefirstname2390]

This is a bar. Hard asf

[@azizvarlikli9395]

​@@thedrbat9572 but sadly we arent following sunnah and islam as they did...

[@artemis-arrow3098]

​@@thedrbat9572 you mean 2 billion?

[@mxhsvn_b7866]

you mean the man that raped and murdered innocent people?

[@ayoubzahiri1918]

Netanyahu : 'America Is a Golden Calf and We Will Suck It Dry', the military anual budget was never about the US

[@ciaranReal]

Did he actually say that?

[@Goku467-w3i]

​​@@ciaranRealyeah he also said something about making america the world's biggest welfare state.

[@MangaBear]

Link it.​@@Goku467-w3i

[@klawockkidd3426]

@@ciaranReal no. It's attributed to Gordon Duff, a well known anti-semite pro-Kremlin with ties with the Iranian state media. Don't take my word for it, look it up.

[@nawab141]

Its obvious

[@taylenvila3915]

Americans in general don't have asabiyyah, but the tribe that rules them definitely does.

[@str7413]

Haha AIPAC will report this comment for anti semitism

[@haziq0007]

Fr the whole congress has their money😂 USA is F'ed up the moment they killed JFK

[@highonncert4160]

Lmaooo ​@@str7413

[@VGK4TRUTH]

Like it matters🤣. Cat's already out of the bag🤦🏽‍♂️. 2 Corinthians 13:8 - "For we can do nothing against the truth, but for the truth." All praises 🙌🏼 to the Most High God the Father and Christ Jesus His only begotten Son.

[@LoBo-o6w]

Damn

[@zazugee]

As a Muslim from north africa, or rather Algeria, i'm quite surprised by this video, bc i find westerns often look for wisedom in greek or asian cultures. But as someone who's dad bought him the book "Al Muqadimah" on the day he was born and read it as a kid. i'd like to shed some light about what he was really looking at when he talked about Assabya The view that an empire or civilization raises and falls in one single entity is not really as accurate as it sounds like the reason Ibn Khaldoun wrote that was his observation of the rise and fall of smaller kingdoms and dynasties inside the muslim world, like a single civilization will have many cycles of raise and fall and not one single one, like how it was thought by westerners who are fascinated by "why did Rome fall?". I made this quote on the spote, this is my own saying "Rome didn't fall in a single night." no pun intended. But this is exactly what i think how Ibn Khaldoun thought about the many raises and falls of Muslim dynasties in the Middle East and North Africa. And he righfully thought that people from the outskirts, not always nomads, but they could be villagers or farmers often rise because they have a strong kinship and believe in a single destiny. In the past, it was nomads really bc of the reasons you pointed out, but also recently in the past century the raise of socialism and communists and revolts by farmers and working classes bc nomads aren't as relevant

[@tytania3545]

But Rome DID fall in one night. Ask Mehmet II.

[@Kenshiroit]

​@@tytania3545Rome fell many times if we actually go deeper than a slogan and always came back

[@tytania3545]

@@Kenshiroit 🤡🤡🤡

[@zazugee]

​@@tytania3545 that's not a factual statement. 1st it was a city called Constantinople and is the capital of an empire considered by most historians as a different one from Rome.

[@Elgourari]

مهم حنا نبغو كي يجي ابو عيون زرق يقلنا واش ديرو واش مديروش ،كون يقولهالك طالب فالجامع تقولو عليه متخلف رجعي ردكالي

[@jamm_affinity]

We live in the United States of Money. No one cares about principles, only making the most money. This is where our problems stem from. People act like they are religious today but they aren’t. They are money and politics worshippers. Money is not bad but it always must be secondary to meaning.

[@akhsanarrazi7825]

The sad part is, many innocent people bear the consequences of their greed

[@ДанилАбдибеков]

"How much a dollar really cost? The price of a spot in heaven, embrace your loss..."

[@jamm_affinity]

@@ДанилАбдибеков Money isn’t evil

[@eatfrenchtoast]

​@@jamm_affinitystupidity and greed is what we perceive as "evil".

[@golamrasul9887]

@@eatfrenchtoast yea, money is not evil as long as you use it responsibly

[@sammygoodnight]

Asabiyyah is an impossibility in a society where racism is the worst sin. Modern American society is literally built on the dissolution of organic communities.

[@ercaner_buzbey]

Well exclusive racism leads to destruction of asabiyyah as well before it reaches its goal to flourish a nation to statehood. You can't build an empire solely on corpses. If you try you only limit your potential to reach a higher position with cooperation. Even Mongols cooperated with Turks in the steps and cities. Their quick co-op made it possible for them to reach the biggest land anybody could ever hope to conquer in the middle ages.

[@temptemp4174]

Nations are monocultural. Empires are multicultural

[@saveUyghurs]

Don’t try to push for racism you little 💩

[@Oogaboga22]

​@@ercaner_buzbey Cooperation dosen't mean no racism, the mongols treated the turks with contempt and didn't allow them to climb the social ladders, and were kept in lower status, since the turks were originally mines slaves of the proto-mongolic Rourans, so the mongols never considred the turks as their equals. They cooperated with them as auxiliary just like they did with armenians and georgians. Also the mongols were a huge overstretched empire that they could barely manage or administrate, built on a frenzy of pillage and conquest not a real proper nation, they didn't leave anything with substence, they didn't even multiply how many ethnic mongol or mongol speaking population nowadays in the world ? Barely any and they are under threat of the han chinese who are occupying half their country and going to replace them in outer mongolia with chinese investors and workers, the mongols are a bad example of a great nation.

[@sgtanous4782]

just like russia

[@mrpk1719]

Every Single Empire has fell. America is no different it will fall and fall hard.

[@GRY890]

Same for Russia and China you pig.

[@freeman37]

We've all lost to bankers (banksters).

[@Salt-Oil]

Im writing dark sci fi, where banking clans propping up a post cultural marxist authoritarian dictatorship control the galaxy. One of the main characters is a disgraced detective who discovers cosmic horrors underlying the oligarchic govt.

[@NotClosedMinded]

We have all won with Jesus.

[@mohammadalam9936]

Who are banisters? 109 country kicked them out for suffocating their economy. Germany had to fight back

[@Dzeividz]

​@@NotClosedMindedShut up dude

[@zakadams762]

Jews

[@Salt-Oil]

Ben franklin said the republic would end when americans/congress realized they could just vote themselves money.

[@aisha7643]

When you talked about asabiyah. The first thing that came to my mind was the companions of Prophet Muhammad Saw, Arabiawas such an insignificant part of the world, no one cared about it, no one looked at it twice but with the asabiyah forming and the leadership of Prophet Muhammad saw those few people brought both Roman and Persian empires to it's knees. Which was so impossible that even the enemies of Prophet would laugh at but that became a reality.

[@ageedtahir3128]

Wasn’t it prophesied and it came true 6 to 9 years later.

[@thedictationofallah]

@@ageedtahir3128 yes

[@aisha7643]

@@ageedtahir3128 yes it was

[@ahmedmohsen5886]

@@ageedtahir3128 the prophecy of the "6 to 9 years" was told by Allah in the Quran in Surat AL-rom this prophecy was about: the Romans will defeat the Persians in 6 to 9 years at the lowest land on earth not about the fall of both empires at the hand of Muslims that was another prophecy by the prophet in a hadith

[@ahmedmohsen5886]

@@ageedtahir3128 and of course both did occur

[@razzledazzle15]

We aren’t a nation, we’re an economic zone. And nobody wants to fight and die for an economic zone. Our military is at best an overpriced mercenary force and at worst a welfare program/money laundering operation masquerading as a fighting force. Our military technology is serviceable, but not invincible or superior to Russian or Chinese systems, and in many cases, decisively inferior. Our military has succumbed to rot, its most capable members purged in favor of political loyalists, and our doctrines are outdated. If we want to retool ourselves for a 21’st century conflict, it would take an economic cost we aren’t prepared to pay and reforms we aren’t equipped to undergo.

[@titolovely8237]

I’d definitely challenge that. Yea there’s been rot in the US military system but if you think it is anywhere close to comparable to how bad the Russian and Chinese system is then you’re dreaming. The Chinese just launched their brand new first in class nuclear attack sub and it sank in the harbor. The Russians can’t beat a ragtag army of untrained 45 year olds and lost their entire surface fleet 2 months into a conflict with a minor regional power. Tea the US is in decline but there is still 0 parody between the US and other nations. If the US were to get into a conflict with the Chinese it’s be over in about 4 minutes

[@themaninblack5022]

😂 much of what you just said is in fact false. The money laundering happens through defense contractors. Take the funds allocated to Ukraine for example. Our military equipment is far superior to China and Russia. Hell, Russia couldn’t even source equipment to convoy into Ukraine. They are literally opera out of vans and trucks 😂 gtfo son

[@partymariner]

Well put!

[@bruceyawen6160]

Its "Shopping Mall Nationalism"

[@Canis_dirus300]

💯

[@jessespencer1019]

We will go down for the same reason rome did. Hubris, ego and pride will be our downfall.

[@ahmadalastal5303]

+ Adultery, LGBT and Usury, a lot of bad things in America, I had a friend who studies PhD in US and told me that people there are full of sins

[@VGK4TRUTH]

Really for all the wickedness you've committed all over the earth against nations/peoples who did you no wrong. Chattel slavery, usury (think IMF/World Bank), resource theft and g£nocid€ (in Haiti, Congo, Nigeria, Iraq, Puerto Rico, Somalia, Sudan, etc), unjust trade rules (NAFTA, WT0), bi0w£ap0n$ (H1V, C0v1&, c@nc£r, "b1g ph@rma") etc. Habakkuk 2:5-8 & Revelation 18 is a perfect description of Am£riKKKa/EU and the judgments thereof. The saints will rejoice greatly when this wicked kingdom finally crumbles. All praises 🙌🏼 to the Most High God the Father and Christ Jesus His only begotten Son.

[@siluda9255]

But unlike rome you will leave no Mark in this world angloid

[@TaLeng2023]

And "immigration" too I guess

[@lolazal1]

And greed

[@TheSilverSultan]

"لَا إِلٰهَ إِلَّا الله مُحَمَّدٌ رَسُولُ الله" 🏴

[@yad9778]

There is no god but Allah and Muhammad is measenger of Allah

[@pepik121]

fake messenger

[@suleyman38]

​@@pepik121 read books and inform yourself

[@pepik121]

@@suleyman38 i did, i can also see with my own eyes that Islam is not a religion but totalitarian ideology aimed at conquering whole world by sword. After all, thats how it spread around the globe. Not by preaching gospel but by murdering, conquering and forcefully turning people into so called believers.

[@TaLeng2023]

non-canon

[@OwmyLumbar]

I have literally watched the army decline before my eyes. New regulations under the guise of equality and being nice (more professional) excellerated the corruption. I got DEMOTED from an SGT because instead of filing paperwork on a soldier and getting him kicked out FOR WAKING UP LATE 3 TIMES, i decided to take him on a nice TWO MILE RUN with 10 sets of 10 PUSHUPS! I GOT IN TROUBLE FOR HAZING. that was barely a warm up for an actual workout someone make it make sense

[@DuRagnia]

What unit did this happen at? 😂😂😂 I knew I was getting soft but damn I've only been out for 2 years

[@Leonhart_93]

Yeah, exactly as intended by the enemy. Prepare to be conquered at some point.

[@OwmyLumbar]

@DuRagnia I don't need this coming back to get me somehow, so I'll just say hunter army airfield and you can guess the unit. I'm getting out next month 🫡🇺🇲

[@righteousmammon9011]

Same here man. Did 10 years and couldn’t do it anymore

[@titolovely8237]

It’s like this in corporate America too. You can’t manage bad employees because you could get sued. When we lose the mechanisms for rooting out bad behavior then it just proliferates.

[@thefinne6737]

You think America is bad. Wait till you here about canada

[@ciaranReal]

I'm british and it worse here

[@cas343]

Canada is having a decline without the benefit of a golden age.

[@shakey3306]

​@@ciaranRealno it's not, the immigration is a bigger problem there

[@Newlinjim]

@@cas343or a reserve currency.

[@marysartr]

​@@ciaranReal it isn't. Trust. Me.

[@springwellssw]

It's messed up that America is selling out it's own but would rather serve Israel

[@Nur1234-mp7sf]

Big time mess up for US but also for the all the people on the receiving end of this ideological stance: Gaza, West Bank, Lebanon today (many other countries in the past... let us not forget that people attribute US going to Iraq because of the insistence of Net at the time....).

[@stenyethanmathews945]

You know what's funny. I recently went back to my hometown in India for 3 week trip. I felt more freedom there than I did upon coming back into the USA.

[@JJ-xo3bc]

Probably better to just live there. If you feel more freedom. (Not being a racist, genuine comment). Why live somewhere where you don’t feel free. Doesn’t make sense to me.

[@dv9239]

I live in India and I'd say we are a nation in decline too just like the US but without the money so it's even worse for us

[@lers0305]

@@dv9239at least you guys have a space program

[@ShomoGoldburgler]

​@@dv9239India should have reverted into the principalities and kingdoms that existed before the British arrived, too big of a country with too many people to ever be functional or prosperous. Too much ethnic and religious differences as well.

[@theinvisiblewoman5709]

Probably because the people show you respect. In the US if you don’t look and act and believe what the majority group believes then you are isolated. India just gained their freedom from those people yet you come to the US with more of those people who just went around abusing people different from them.

[@DelradeTraining]

This is a great point Kristian. It’s so obvious as well. Not just in America but in most of Western countries

[@Rakibrown111]

you forget AI and robots... especially humanoid robots will boost rich ageing demographics societies massively. It will solve the immigration issue as well. Imagine a country doubling it's work force via robots at $10,000 a piece, total transformation.

[@valiantone395]

​@@Rakibrown111 wall-e is that you 1101111000110101111001

[@AzizAmri-l5d]

*Ibn Khaldun was born in Tunisia and as a Tunisian I love him and I'm proud of him*

[@Scott-s5j]

His family was originally from Muslim Spain. They moved to Tunisia after the deterioration of Muslim rule in Spain.

[@LoBo-o6w]

He was born in Andalus

[@hamzahammami22]

​@@LoBo-o6w his parents are from al andalus, he was born in tunis

[@hamzahammami22]

​@@Scott-s5jI don't see how that changes the former statement

[@Scott-s5j]

@@hamzahammami22 It doesn’t change it; it adds extra info to it. That’s all.

[@Rivershield]

So you are telling me there's a good reason our ancestors were nationalistic and religious...

[@ziyadrgb9584]

yeah all humans are like that or atleast was like that

[@rcommando1107]

​@@ziyadrgb9584 nothing but demons and automatons ( fleshy golems) now

[@sasi5841]

Nationalism was invented in 19th century in the aftermath of the liberal revolutions. It didn't exist before the 19th century. Pretty much all people identified themselves based on their lineage, religion, hometown, social class, and profession.

[@Nigerosaurus420]

Nationalism is stupid.

[@araworn2141]

Yes. There was a great example of what could be accomplished by a Nation during the early 20th century.

[@fidorfsmf6349]

Not aayyy raaab It’s Arab

[@greypsyche5255]

a rapper

[@ITLERR]

@@greypsyche5255 we just rape the jweis

[@Ghazi682]

@@greypsyche5255 nice

[@abolfazlabasnatj2319]

Its not uyrayn It is iran

[@treeghoulmob]

wait till bro figures out hes pronouncing it in english because hes speaking english

[@adila2442]

I am impressed that a European person is aware of Islamic philosophy. May Allah guide you to Islam.

[@FKS1946]

no, stop doing that. Why are you so pushy about your religion?

[@boespook2070]

In the west more and more people will get curious about the religion. The dubble standards of the european leaders are getting more visible. And the support of the last european colony(Israël) is dropping now that they can see whats going on since europe started Israël. More and more people will come into contact with what the religion truely is about and start to ask themself why it needed to be so villified within europe. (they plan and allah(swt) plans. And indeed allah is the best of planners❤)

[@fenerkropotz9879]

I'm european and I know the Islamic philosophy. :) Many, many others know it. Never forget that we shared MiddleAges; all the World shared MiddleAges, all but U.S.A.

[@adila2442]

@@FKS1946 there is no compulsion in religion. We are human and have free will. It's natural to wish God Willing (Inshallah) that people convert to Islam. There are Christians that wish Muslims convert to Christianity all the time. Many people who were the biggest Muslim haters end up converting years later.

[@lazb6761]

He's not European... He's American!

[@jmabee]

This is a good example on the success of homogenous societies. The more cracks appear in a nations culture. The more fragmented the populace gets. Given time those different groups will be at each others throats. This doesnt necessarily mean racially homogenous, but there must be a unified culture. That culture must be nurtured and rewarded by the state.

[@manueljonathancaceres1265]

The state, wich means the people who lives under common laws, not the goverment.

[@Magnetic1884]

It does mean racially homogeneous. The founding fathers understood this.

[@manueljonathancaceres1265]

​@@Magnetic1884 No. You´re wrong. It´s not about race, is about values and education (not academic scholarship). There are many good americans in different colour skin.

[@TacitusR]

It most differently requires race homogeneous. Race is yet another fissure which in time opportunist grow into a great fracture in the foundation of a society, which inevitable results in conversion from monoculture into multi-culture further fracturing the society. Those who fail to understand what has been well understood throughout all of human history are the victims of seventy years of focused propaganda.

[@sasi5841]

​@Magnetic1884 the eastern roman empire was made up of many different groups. But it is one of the longest lasting empires.

[@hebanker3372]

I highly suggest the complete, three-volume version of Ibn Khaldun's ''Muqaddimah''. A far better representation of his work and observations. You can find them online on Internet Archive.

[@abdulkaium1199]

Bro spoke real knowledge. Hope this video doesn't gets deleted considering it promotes general awareness.

[@davidglenn2739]

Tough times make strong men-->Strong men make good times-->Good times make weak men-->Weak men make tough times. Rinse and repeat

[@Al-Azdi]

If I’m not mistaken Ibn khaldun also said that

[@samesaiwan]

Asabiyyah will stop or slow that

[@احمد-ك2ص1ر]

This is the saying of the Arab philosopher Ibn Khaldoun

[@zakayow]

Hard Times create strong men Strong men create good Times Good Times create weak men Weak men create hard Times 😂

[@swagiioncarter2996]

America's issue is greed and evil not weakness

[@noahmoore334]

Asa-biyyah is interesting and it can be translated as tribalism. The thing about it is it has a way of preventing the tribes from progressing because they tend cling to old traditions even if they are destructive. It wasnt asa-biyyah that made the islamic empires so vast and powerful but rather a sense of religious brotherhood that goes beyond the familial. To a country with weak familial ties asa-biyyah is truly salavating but what is beyond that is what creates empires.

[@D__Ujjwal]

People living in harsh climate are stronger physically and somewhat mentally, it true also because. Good times create weak men and hard times creates strong men. Indeed tribalism is very destructive in this globalised world with population of 8 billion. Top comments are very funny, blaming women, Jews and what not. Their emotion has taken over their minds. It's true that religious figures do better for uniting people, like shivaji from india, he was seen as incarnation because he United Hindus against foreign islamic invaders and ended 800 year rule of islamic empires and converted small empire as Belgium into whole Indian subcontinent (equal to size of Europe)

[@enesutkuozdemir7335]

We translate in turkish similar word to solidarity in english.

[@harrisiskandar8356]

​@@D__Ujjwalfrom tiger mouth to crocodile mouth. India better remember your BRITISH rule and remember what hunger is. You India don't know how Jews corrupted the world because im India corruption is a norm.

[@greypsyche5255]

Yeah literally it's close to tribalism, but it's a term he used to describe positive concepts and values. It's not what tribalism means in the general sense. It's similar to conflating nationalism and patriotism. You are talking about nationalism, Ibn Khaldun about patriotism.

[@noahmoore334]

@@greypsyche5255 well said!

[@JoseyWales93]

"Indeed, those who disbelieve spend their wealth to avert [people] from the way of Allāh. So they will spend it; then it will be for them a [source of] regret; then they will be overcome. And those who have disbelieved - unto Hell they will be gathered." Quran s8:v36. This verse was quoted by Oussama Bi_Lad_n in one of his speeches in the late 1990s/early 2000s, he was talking about America and its immense military budget.

[@robertsontirado4478]

I’m learning Italian and Arabic I experienced more closeness within those cultures. I volunteered at Ground Zero I’ll never do that again.

[@Gaggerlotion]

Ok

[@MuyassarMostafa]

Welcome friend, I'm Egyptian living in Qatar.

[@OmarOsman98]

@@MuyassarMostafahe’s not going to give you a visa

[@MuyassarMostafa]

@@OmarOsman98 visa to where? I'm the one who is welcoming him. غريب انت

[@gr3ndizer97]

I suggest you a book by Hans Belting : Florence and Baghdad: Renaissance Art and Arab Science

[@SithGod]

Emasculation, Feminism, Inflation, High Tax Price, Greed, Anger, Ignorance all at an alarming rate. Disgusting. Dukkha

[@youremom2198]

Israel

[@Nigerosaurus420]

What dose feminism have to do with this?

[@MohdHilal]

Strange how each item you mentioned contributes to declining birthrates

[@araworn2141]

​@@youremom2198Stop noticing

[@araworn2141]

​@@Nigerosaurus420Please tell us you're not asking that as a serious question.😮

[@Katniss_cosmos]

True, Asabiyyah = عصبية ، is a magnificent factor when being for the right cause and embodied by wise rightfull people.

[@RussellAlami]

“Shared group feeling” was destroyed when you let-in the wanderers that roam the planet ( having no allegiance to any country they inhabit )

[@easternequinox9324]

You talking about those dual citizenship group that also happens to be deeply imbedded in politics, corporations, big pharma, the entertainment industry and pretty much the bank?

[@HustleGrind-ff1xv]

​@@easternequinox9324 did you mean (((them)))?

[@araworn2141]

​@@easternequinox9324sounds like it

[@easternequinox9324]

@@araworn2141 They are legitimately terrifying. That amount of influence and control behind the scenes of literally everything as we know it isn't even funny at all.

[@araworn2141]

@@easternequinox9324 Yes, you're correct.. It can be intimidating.. If we let it. Numerically, they are less than us. I personally wouldn't have an issue cooperating with other ethnic gen.tile groups temporarily to deal with this issue. Too many in our group believe we can overcome Perpetual Victims alone. We can't. If we could, it would have been done already. Like when we were 80-90% of the US population.

[@brianbadonde8700]

countries are based on shared ancestry, genetics, culture and history if the people within a country don't have that they've no reason to stay together and every reason to actively fight and compete against each other

[@2livenoob]

What you wrote has never happened in this history of mankind. Soviet Union didn't fall because "the people were fornicating", neither did the Nazis, the Ottomans, Napoleon, Caliphates, Mongols, Ming Dynasty, Roman... all of what is said is false and an ignorance of history.

[@ThriftyCHNR]

I disagree. As long as the loot/prosperity is realized by all citizens they will fight. The problem with the USA is that 80% of citizens are not receiving a reasonable share of the spoils. Nor do they feel properly represented by the government.

[@brianbadonde8700]

@@ThriftyCHNR you can disagree all you like but multiracial societies will always return to being homogenous, it's the natural order, it's not organic or natural for different ethnic groups, religions and cultures to share the same space, it causes tension and conflict and makes it very difficult to govern over so many different peoples

[@partizanofficer24]

Usa was literally founded multiculturaly. Majority are germans, english, irish, spanish (mexican), native, french. Nation is a social construct. Here in europe, the kings just draw the lines and “nations” were born. Hard to comprehend for a simple mind yes.

[@centercannothold]

@@partizanofficer24 They were white, after sometime pass you can't tell the difference. But skin color, now that hard to get rid of.

[@nimomemre6550]

I assure you it's not just US or West (as a whole) but there's many other countries facing lack of Asabiyyah. You are so right about Muslim Ummah too. In recent bloodbath in Gaza, lack of Asabiyyah came out clearly in Muslim nations 😕 My country is facing the lowest point in Asabiyyah nowadays. There's some left but people are quickly loosing their faith in state/nation !

[@alitubealt6185]

We only need assabiyah through Allah 🤲🏻

[@Techtalk2030]

Cohesion, discipline, strength and loyalty is what creates and maintains civilization.

[@FazeParticles]

feminism erodes that. and progressivism is the political vehicle making that happen.

[@ipullabsolutlly0huzz]

@@FazeParticles eh feminism only starts to erode society when its core values like genuinely trying to help women's rights starts to lose its meaning. progressivism also is a bit of a stretch it only fails when the idea's of progressivism start to move to far as in like the values can not be compatible because the idea's are not compatible if that makes sense

[@joe_mox]

I'm from Argentina but I've always visited the US since I was 14 (I'm 34 now) I always wanted the social aspect of live of Argentina but with the wealth and freedom of the US. I think nowadays both are gone. Argentina has lost a lot of economical power since the begining of the 20th century but now it suprises me while watching this video, that it hasn't lost its asabiyyah completely, but we are not I'm good shape neither. The US on the contrary it's just sad, that fine nation I felt in love when I visited it when I was 14 years old is totally gone.

[@manueljonathancaceres1265]

Americans define themselves through the race. In Argentina, we define ourselves through the culture. That's the big difference.

[@redrumrabbit]

@@manueljonathancaceres1265 Americans define themselves through race ?

[@manueljonathancaceres1265]

@@redrumrabbit What other country do you know where the category "ethnicity" appears in the people´s ID´s ?

[@kosmalaanimations2864]

Argentina is nice it has a very low crime rates compared to the rest of Latin America

[@kosmalaanimations2864]

Looking at you guys and then looking at Haiti both of you have the same economy and one doesn't exist anymore and the other is still around

[@cottonabrian]

This young man crushed it. As a veteran, what he says has divine wisdom. Hostory says it will fall on deaf ears.

[@rexnemorensis8154]

You need to read Decline of the West by Oswald Spengler.

[@iamKristianBell]

Just bought it

[@longydongy1004]

Why waste my time with the book when I watched it in real life? 😂

[@christianvincentcostanilla8428]

Everyone going to say people going to watch 1980s movies

[@christianvincentcostanilla8428]

1980s was a Golden Age of movies Like high middle ages

[@christianvincentcostanilla8428]

Why there is success movies in 1980s It's was simpler time Good and evil Right and wrong 1.Aids 2.crack epidimc 3. Yuppie 4. Cold war 5. Satanic panic. 6 boundaries broken 7 Reaganomics

[@samiman5606]

" There is no doubt that enabling women to mix with men is the root of all misfortune and evil. It is one of the greatest reasons for the introduction of public punishments It is also one of the reasons for the corruption of public and private matters It is one of the causes of general death and deadly plagues." Al imam and the big scholar Ibn al-Qayyim may Allah have mercy on him [Judgmental Methods (1/724)]*

[@Goku467-w3i]

So true

[@_waybeom_]

Misogynistic

[@FromValkyrie]

Lol. Such nonsense which one can only expect from a muhammedan mind. 😂 😂 😂

[@beefy1728]

​​@@_waybeom_ Stop destroying civilizations.

[@Ustilldown1]

@@_waybeom_fuck that shit woman weren’t allowed to vote till the 20th century. Out of the 12 thousand years of civilization…

[@PickleRick-t6b]

It was foretold in the prophecy that the Muslims will take over the world along side with Jesus. That time seems to be the time we are in now.

[@haziq0007]

We are in the phase to enter 1st malhamah, which means ww3..

[@Wolverine_Workout]

Build a Brotherhood and a Tribe you can rely on eachother in Hard Times ahead then you'll be a king in the NeoFeudialism of a fallen nation.

[@SomeOne-xm5mq]

Forget about it.

[@Joe-sg9ll]

'be a slum lord' what's that other term? kingpin or something. we're definitely going back to that

[@faza553]

Estimated global population: 1000 BCE: 50 million 0 : 170 million 1800 CE : 1 Billion 1970 : 3,695,390,336 2024 CE : 8,181,324, 660 >

[@tomtravis3077]

Tribe and train. Find a local active club.

[@TaLeng2023]

​@@faza553that's gonna fall sharply. It already is with higher disease rates in young people all of a sudden. 🤔 Many more will not survive the actual collapse.

[@thetraditionalist]

Great video as always man! I have felt this so deeply my whole life but it's so hard to communicate with others. I will tell people that I lack a sense of belonging and community and people will tell me that I have friends so why should I care. But it goes so much deeper than that. I have a decent amount of friends but they're literally scattered around the world. I grew up moving from country to country so I never felt like I belonged anywhere and even when I came back to my homeland I had no real roots or connection to people there. I am tired of being told that working a job I hate and having all my friends in different cities is satisfactory and while I m not saying I have the worst life possible, I have gone through way worse times and felt better because I had community to support me at the time. Life is materially easier for me but mentally much harder because i go to work every day having no idea why I am there and when I finish I have nobody to go see or spend time with. Remember that you guys are not alone and we are not insane for noticing how superficial most human connections are these days. Having a brotherhood is what I desire more than anything else and I hope I can find it one day

[@jamesolivito4374]

Most people gloss over the longer comments. I myself appreciate them because the person conveys a deeper thought process than the popular one liners . Our problem today is that we have no time . Most of us have to spend 60 hours a week at work just to meet our basic needs . Our marriages and families fail because our spouses have to work . The lack of time spent with our wives and children weakens any chance of cohesion . The same can be said for friendships. I have a daughter who moved to Spain for a few years after college so that she could travel Europe working teaching English. She said it was so different. They do not work as much, usually 32 hours a week, and have a mandatory one month vacation . In America, we have been groomed into a culture of consumerism. We all try to fit in by having the latest shit . I think you are on the right track with a brotherhood, but it requires sacrifice and goes against the norms of our society. Maybe less is more, and keeping up with the Jones' is the biggest lie we have been fed by our corporate leaders .

[@lolschneider5056]

Democratizing the workplace can give you a voice to at least decide the length of the work week. For that however you might need a revolution in order to abolish the private ownership of the means of production (your workplace) and turn it into common ownership of the means of production. This can create a sense of community and belonging where you live when the workplace hierarchy has been abolished. You'd also need to to abolish the market economy and instead plan the economy locally. Supercomputers are powerful enough to do that. Capitalism is the main reason for all the problems we have. It no longer works and we have to replace it with the System I mentioned at the beginning, democratic socialism (it's the better option).

[@thetraditionalist]

@@jamesolivito4374 totally agree. Thanks for the comment!

[@thetraditionalist]

@@lolschneider5056 socialism and communism aren't the answer and have been proven to be disasters for decades

[@islamicschoolofmemestudies]

Americans had to hear it from muslim philosophers. Why? Because their people were once like America, a superpower in every sense of the words. Ottomans, Muwaiyah, Abbasids etc. They have seen their massive empire rise...and fall

[@ahmednasrulla4766]

Islam is what america needs

[@GoingToAFuneral]

Hell no

[@ahmednasrulla4766]

@@GoingToAFuneral hehhehe

[@Ohsoheil]

muhammed is gay hehe

[@zenderman3495]

Fuck sharia law and hell no this will not happen not even European people liking these desert maniacs and traitorous government.

[@AMIsmail22]

Americans need to stop fighting for Israel 🇮🇱 and focus on their own country

[@Yazan_Majdalawi]

It's not Americans that rule America

[@Ab-fc2cf]

True , I found that mentality when I visited SAUDI ARABIA last year. It was great to see everybody has solid bonds with their own tribe members and all tribes united behind the king. This creates deep loyalty between government and people

[@springinfialta106]

Our celebration of the individual is our tragic flaw: it contributed to the creativity that allowed our economy to grow exponentially but ultimately resulted in a bunch of individuals seeking their own separate goals and meaning unrelated to the nation as a whole.

[@tetrabromobisphenol]

That's actually not the issue. We have a crisis 100% caused by the decoupling of individualism and individual accountability. For decades the elite in the West have fought to eliminate financial and personal accountability by any and all means necessary (2008 crisis, wokeism, etc.). When the individual does something stupid, and it doesn't hurt, all of a sudden you're going to get a tsunami of stupidity, which is where we are today.

[@springinfialta106]

@@tetrabromobisphenol Blackrock by-and-large follows the law (after all they helped write a lot of them!) so they are accountable. However, they are still screwing with the American people because they are globalists rather than Americans.

[@Ryan-pi4go]

I am a middle aged American man. I feel very isolated.

[@Piden-l4b]

It’s not our time. It’s woke time !

[@ArabianPrincess1998]

At least knowing who you are will make you feel less depressed, because the next generation of men and women will suffer more.

[@virginie7752]

Why don't you vote with your feet, i.e. go somewhere else, somewhere where humans still have human values ? Personally, me and my family went to Türkiye 4 years ago, and we regret not having done it sooner. Courage my friend, there is a better world elsewhere waiting for you with open arms.

[@MA-ld5lr]

Anas ibn Mālik (rA) narrates that the Prophet ﷺ said, “Once my nation considers five things permissible, then destruction will befall them: when cursing one another appears, wine is drunk, silk is worn, musical instruments are played, and men suffice themselves with men and women suffice themselves with women.”

[@MA-ld5lr]

“The nations will soon invite one another to devour you, just as diners are invited to a dish.” It was said, “Will it be because of our small number on that day?” He said, “No, rather you will be many on that day, but you will be weightless foam, like the foam on the river. And Allah will remove the fear of you from the hearts of your enemies and will cast weakness into your hearts.” Someone said, “O Messenger of Allah, what will this weakness be?” He said, “The love of this world, and the hatred of death.”

[@emirefe5452]

​@@MA-ld5lr like you guys so much right now, thanks for these

[@emirefe5452]

​@@MA-ld5lrsorry it was just one dude, sentiment still stands though

[@MA-ld5lr]

@@emirefe5452 I like you as my brother in humanity♥♥I think there is a slight misunderstanding lol. The reply above was a continuation point of my initial comment. Nothing to worry about.

[@ahmethakancoskun899]

A country of 300+ million not being able to yield a semi-decent presidential candidate in the last 10 years is the only sign you need to realize that it's fate has been sealed.

[@ayonibrahim9985]

I recently felt that in America, to many people in leadership roles falsely assume the state of the nation is self sustaining, that it is to big to fail and therefore they can take advantage of it as much as they want.

[@lifeisa.smalllesson333]

Central banking killed Rome and the USA as well.

[@DipayanPyne94]

Jews did

[@eatfrenchtoast]

It wasn't all those emperors assassinating each other huh? It was like six in ten years. Or the burning their people for superstition. Or treating outsiders as slaves who rebelled.

[@eatfrenchtoast]

Bro you learned about banking from an ancient aliens episode not a law book. 😂

[@lifeisa.smalllesson333]

This guy

[@lifeisa.smalllesson333]

@eatfrenchtoast just stop... "TV", "law book"?? Are you on drugs?? Did you forget the topic at hand?? Get off the internet and go read some quality books. Your brain is fried!!

[@datprawn4850]

John Glubb no doubt was inspired by that Arab philosopher when he wrote “Fate of Empires” which describes the pattern of the rise and fall of empires and how it’s a constant cycle. What he describes what’s happening in the west is called Decadence and its end is terminal.

[@michaelbouillon1241]

Bingo ! We are in the last stage : age of decadency

[@likeabossk4055]

Asabiyyah is basically just another word for unity i feel like.

[@JamesBond-uv9nn]

Difference is unity can not descirbe the way the arabic word means it.

[@likeabossk4055]

I feel like you can describe unity in different ways and mean it differently depending on context. I don't know to the exact definitions what that word means, but to me how it was described sounded like unity.

[@maatiz_akbiara]

It means strong social bond with shared values..

[@saidzihmmou6426]

i believe it has a sense of might. they are not just a unit but one that strive and push and shakes hurdles for their objective.

[@anon-iraq2655]

Yes, can be translated as unity but it won't do it justice, it also means social cohesion and willingness to sacrifice for the group, with a measure of bigotry for the group

[@fabiobauleo]

In Latin, we call it MAIESTAS, one of the principal virtues of the Mos Maiorum

[@Yusuf-ep5mw]

Hey man I'm a Muslim and I truly agree with you I hope we can meet face to face some day thanks for the vid!

[@Abdirahmanahmed-s2k]

Same

[@Yusuf-ep5mw]

@@Abdirahmanahmed-s2k yeah

[@Abdirahmanahmed-s2k]

@@Yusuf-ep5mw ok

[@bald-benis]

You have alot of knowledge people are soo racist this days they dont even read books written by Muslim. Keep the good work ❤

[@idahoskook]

Wow! Great message. Concise and extremely informative. Mahalo my brother! 🤙🤙 You are definitely an “ Old Soul” my friend. Your Wisdom is evidence of that fact. Look forward to seeing more from you in the future and will definitely share with others. Especially young people who instinctively know things “ain’t right” right now and they are being lied to in many ways by many people.

[@meatloaf5772]

Part of the problem of our low asabiyyah is due to our country being gripped by a terrible identity crisis. Because Americas worst enemies aren’t external, they’re internal. It’s a “cold civil war”. Until it’s resolved, we will never be strong. At least not as strong as we can and should be.

[@alienasoul]

Dude, this video was amazing! I am Subbed and I Liked.

[@InfiniteCuriosity1210]

@04:40 you keep failing to mention the early arab nomadic tribes united by prophet Muhammad (pbuh) that exploded out of Arabia, destroyed two major global superpowers against huge numerical odds and within a few decades conquered all the way from Spain to Pakistan the greatest empire the world had seen to date. Even though it's very relevant to this subject. I have a feeling you haven't read up on early Islam. Even Dune you are talking about got a lot of inspiration and terminology from islam and how it began

[@vip-yr9jc]

Money or military technology doesn't win war, strong men do.

[@Lost_soul_0021]

That's a wonderful video great work

[@ardinhajihil5011]

its true, thats why afghanistan is sooo hard to conquer for long, they always resist even with lower technology and less man power.

[@Goku467-w3i]

That's because the tribes in Afghanistan have something to fight for america is finished the men would not even want to fight because feminism and the laws are destroying them let alone the whole country.in america if your wife cheats and gets a baby by another man you would still have to pay for it 18 years what man would fight for the ones who created that system.

[@SP-vg5gm]

Foolish to conquer They have nothing

[@faleilham8334]

@@SP-vg5gm yeah where's your father??

[@zenderman3495]

That’s because of geography, Afghanistan is extremely mountainous which is why most empire find it difficult to conquer.

[@-Gorbi-]

We let corporate culture and their ideology take over everything. We must take back what is ours and exercise the latent power we have that they’ll NEVER have - the authentic collective human spirit. What is Good True and Beautiful cannot be faked, and when that spirit vibrates through all of us together, it is an unstoppable force

[@djladzer]

As a tunisian, I'm very proud of all ower warriors and scientists, ibn khaldoul is one of the best. Ower history is full of events and individuals success. We are not a big country but ower contributing to humanity and science have to be more commonly known. Thanks for your video and your efforts telling the truth.

[@Vallhalia]

This was amazing information. Thank you!

[@greenthunder1000]

5 minutes in and you’ve just given me overviews and a historical timeline.

[@gerri577]

Our country was founded in part on the idea of individualism. The idea that we are individuals on our own. If we screw up, we must pick ourselves up by our bootstraps. Nobody is responsible for us, and we are responsible for nobody. In the end, this idea leaves us feeling alone and disconnected. Our empire was well aware of the power of individualism when america was built. The idea of disconnecting ppl was used to devide the multitudes of tribes that existed when the crown aimed to conquer the new world. Tribes were isolated from eachother which left them feeling alone and left them easy targets to conquer. This is how we have all been coquered by our own government. We are left feeling defeated with the idea that one person has no power to do anything, other than to get up and go to work and make money. Our families are falling apart under us, but we have no power, so we just get up and go to work. The only solution is to........

[@ihin2005]

Glad to hear from you again, Brother!

[@orionxtc1119]

Mass immigration is a huge issue....

[@orionxtc1119]

Tribalism is NATURAL.... one rule...NEVER bring someone outside the tribe in as they can destroy from within

[@thisguy7976]

​@@orionxtc1119 Go back to Europe then?

[@downtostandup]

It's to late for the west

[@NightsideOfParadise]

​@@downtostanduponly change is certain be it for better or for worse.

[@manueljonathancaceres1265]

@@downtostandup Not yet. The west will survive, but we gonna change into something new and stronger.

[@Likenobodybro]

During the war in the 90s, -Serbs had the strongest army (people, tanks, planes) -Croats had the best organization And the Bosnians...had the bravest heart, allowing them to defend themselves from all sides, in which they succeeded As said, it doesn't matter how strong your army is, what matters is that your army is brave

[@Jtx620]

Bosnians also were not religious before the genocide.After the genocide they became comparatively more religious.

[@TabooRevolution13]

America ended 10 years ago... That was because I'm so smart guys!

[@orionxtc1119]

OBAMA

[@TabooRevolution13]

@@orionxtc1119 Not Obama himself.. Because the majority actually wants the smartest to lead and no one understood the Right to life from the Declaration of Independence America's entire duration! Cascadia broke away in 2014 and I was president of the west coast. Now I'm the 1st King of the continent! Welcome to Amexa! It's a Noocracy Republic!

[@LillianMot]

I think it was 2008, then obama, taylor swift.

[@TabooRevolution13]

@@LillianMot I started a new country in Cascadia in 2014. Then in 2020 it became a one nation continent called Amexa. The boomers don't talk about our historical timeline in in generation X they only represent themselves.

[@zlovmumixam8273]

It's purpose as a nation, and what made it unique, died when the civil war ended. (State rights) The already-spiritually-dead nation officially died in 1913 when the federal reserve (Global banker mafia) replaced the constitution and Supreme court as the highest ruler of the land. (As the Confederates predicted) And immediately started 2 world wars. (As the Confederates predicted) Albert Pike could of told you about all 3 of the world wars in 1860. American ancestors called him racist (Sound familiar) and swarmed him and his men with foreign mercenaries AKA "The Union". This "country" hasn't officially existed in over a century. 111 years. It's a global headquarters not a "country".

[@ArabianPrincess1998]

«من سوى هؤلاء من أهل تلك الأقاليم المنحرفة جنوبًا وشمالًا، فالدين مجهول عندهم، والعلم مفقود بينهم، وجميع أحوالهم بعيدة عن أحوال الأناسي، قريبة من أحوال البهائم» - ابن خلدون

[@grimish_tunes]

Man you truly whispered words I've missed so much, in my country I used to think I could eventually find people to create a strong bond with but as you said without this feeling of unity, families get dismantled by the wicked desires that consume each individual.

[@TheGalacticIndian]

Technology... looks like Unabomber was on to something after all🤔

[@manueljonathancaceres1265]

He was right about many things, besides he was a terrorist...

[@SpeedDemon_Editzzz]

Truer words have never been spoken💯

[@Fireslanga1]

Im going to survive. I know it

[@zlovmumixam8273]

Your going to regret you did.

[@Fireslanga1]

@zlovmumixam8273 why? I survived a tbi and in a coma then getting stabbed 5 times the nest year. I had meningitis twice. Im a survivor

[@zlovmumixam8273]

@@Fireslanga1 Your injuries and your diseases don't affect your friends, family, and community. When all of that is gone, you'll wish you were ded. You'll probably survive the newks too. I just don't know what life you think you are going to have in a radioactive desert... (Try harder KZbin)

[@haziq0007]

bro you need to seek asylum in muslim country trust me!! You won't regret it!

[@the_ham_man70]

@@Fireslanga1 that's awesome, God bless you bro!

[@BrahmaDBA]

This is why the Indonesian forefathers always emphasize "Bhinneka Tunggal Ika" (Unity in Diversity". Indonesia should've been Balkanized decades ago. Our nation is too big, the people too different with one another. However we persevered and united under one language, one nation. This is why we reject vernacular schools and always talk about national culture, national unity, national identity. It doesn't need to see far to see how weak "Asabbiyah" wreak havoc than to just see Malaysia. Vernacular schools and the division amongst Malay, Chinese and Indian is so palpable. The cracks is showing. Unity is really needed. That's why a common enemy and a common goal is needed.

[@keongmania69]

Because despite of being multicultural, Indonesia do have strong sense of unity and shared identity. Unlike in the West or other regions whenever the population demand independence everytime the government disappoint them, this is not happened in Indonesia. The same reason why our founding fathers rejected federalism. The population were always know and aware (despite of being indoctrinated from young age), if they were about to be separated again, foreigners were always ready to influence and take advantage from it. They learn from history.

[@rawsguide]

Bro you talk about something that a lot of Islamic lecturers and schools don't talk about, you just gained another subscriber, love from BD

[@curtispuetz6379]

This was very insightful

[@skblack5050]

No it's not. What it is in the norm which doesn't mean it's good. young men fighting and dying for " God & Country" results in country profiting while god is spoken at funerals and then not again until another war. You have to give reason for young men to fight and die, even if it's not true.

[@scottlewis1479]

Any neighborhood that resembles a European close-knit community where people live, play, and work in a tight-knit area is completely unaffordable for the average American citizen. The best way for America to have Asabiyyah ideals is to do away with long spread house farms in the suburbs, and come back to a time of mixed use neighborhoods. You know, like when you cared about shopping at the market you could walk to because the owners or workers were your immediate neighbors.

[@thetraditionalist]

yes! As someone who lived in europe this is so hard to explain to others

[@ciaranReal]

​@@thetraditionalistI'm british and we're just as bad

[@thetraditionalist]

@@ciaranReal you guys have become very americanised unfortunately

[@SaniaKhan-sk4kg]

You just articulated something that has always been on my mind but I’ve never had the words to express. Thank you!

[@howardmencini3040]

I don't see how America would fall. It seems to bounce back from every problem, even massive problems. It updates and reprograms, then it carries on. It would require something extremely powerful, huge and long-term for America to collapse, but even then it would bouce back as long as people don't forget it.

[@Scott-s5j]

It would bounce back as something else, though.

[@M7ner08]

If USA falls it will be pretty slow like Roman Empire. It might even fracture

[@ak101farhan]

You should convert to Islam brother ❤

[@Unitedsteaks.]

Bro no offense why would he follow a pedophile (no offense)

[@0xm3trix]

​@@Unitedsteaks. You need to educate yourself more, islam is the true , the last standing religion against evil, but dont take my word for it, jus look around and you will see.

[@Unitedsteaks.]

@@0xm3trix well I've read the Quran and Hadiths it's far from that (respefully) it allows child marriage in Surah At-Talaq (65:4) it says women testimony is half of a man because they are deficient in the mind according to Sahih al-Bukhari (Volume 3, Book 48, Hadith 826) Islam also permits polygamy (even if the wife doesn't consent) and slavery (I know it's a different kind of slavery but forcing someone to be your slave is honestly sad and cruel) it also allows intercourse with captives even if married in Surah Al-Mu’minun (23:5-6) Muhammad approved of it in Sahih Muslim (Hadith 3432) Muhammad also married a 9 year old you probably know that and other bad thing's he did like telling Aisha to throw dust at women grieving the deaths of their husbands in Sahih Muslim, Book 11, Hadith 30 Also the Quran gets Alot of sceinfic things wrong or has scientific knowledge that were known in that era by greeks recycled the signs of judgment are vauge it gets the Trinity wrong it says Jews say Ezra is the son of God which is false (I'm neither Christan or Jew I'm an agnostic theist) yea I don't really think it's standing against Alot of bad thing's in it

[@suzumi111]

@@0xm3trixchristianity is because you work so hard to kill us in the middle east

[@jacquesjohnson1387]

Very important message my friend. I believe you’re onto something.

[@ThePhatFilosopher]

Manifest destiny, as a concept, is not something to aspire to. Once you justify your senseless violence what’s stopping the next person from unaliving your entire settlement from the map? Perpetuating violence is never the answer. Smh just sickening.

[@zlovmumixam8273]

How ironic. Considering 'Manifest Destiny" was the conquest of primitive grapists, being replaced with peaceful high-morality society. Hence why the natives conquered by white people get casinos and private property. While the the natives conquered by other natives get egg-sex-cuted, graped, and enslaved into non-existence. Don't forget to take your TED talk to the Apache tribe and remind them that scalping people isn't justifiable...

[@easycall69]

What!? Are you saying that when countries prioritize individualism over collectivism, it leads to a weaker society where self-interest is valued more than caring for the community as a whole? Oh no, who would have guessed?

[@IntegrityEquities]

This is by far the best video I’ve seen all year… THANK YOU. 🙏

[@Mattilainen45]

Same thing in Europe

[@ciaranReal]

Especially britian

[@HappyHermitt]

The influence of Ahriman has taken its grip on this nation.

[@JoeBidet-yb5er]

Ahriman The devil incarnate I'm Zoroastrian

[@shafaitahir4728]

Russia provides a strong example of this. The people of Moscow have collectively left their homes and evaded enemies multiple times throughout history. For instance, when Napoleon took Moscow, its residents willingly left with the army to perform a tactical retreat and deny Napoleon resources.