This or That ep 22 Moisturizers | Aestura, Illiyoon, Beauty of Joseon, Purito, Pyunkang Yul

[@aitsudubs]

This or that "all-in-one" serums. Ones that target multiple skin concerns. Have a great day Kelly !😁

[@hottstepher]

This is a good 1!

[@Iron_Sea]

This or that antioxidants. Don't remember if you have something like this already. For example it would be interesting to compare products from The Ordinary, Niod and so on. Doesn't have to be Vitamin C.

[@RachelDee]

And peptides!

[@KellyDriscoll]

I do have an antioxidant and peptide focused videos but I'll consider a this or that too, thanks for the suggestion!

[@auroraptry]

Finally someone gave comparison between illiyoon n aestura😭😭

[@KellyDriscoll]

Glad this helped!

[@amriddless]

The red bean gel has been a favorite for me since it came out and I tried it on a whim! I have sensitive acne prone & combo skin, and I feel like gel creams are so great for sensitive skin because they are just so cooling and calming, so I love using them even in the winter over a thicker moisturizer. BOJ has a longtime customer from me for the red bean gel now! I'm curious about the amount of research vehind the red bean ingredient but the experience and feeling using it is enough for me

[@fjp9]

please do a video comparing all of the pyunkang yul moisturizers in it. thank you.

[@Sharif487]

After seeing your recommendations i have purchased red bean water gel two week ago,, and after using two week of this gel now i'm reviewing this gel. It’s a good water gel for oily acne prone skin. Literally it gives me matte finish and it feels nothing on my face. No oiliness, no greasiness, and no tacky feeling. I will repurchase it again and Again❤. Thank you so much maam..🥰

[@Iron_Sea]

Thanks, Kelly! "This or That" videos are my favourites on your channel💙

[@KellyDriscoll]

Glad you like them!💜

[@rangolijain9684]

Please do a comparison of krave Beauty makeup re-wined and isntree chestnut lha jelly cleansing oil.

[@RachelDee]

Oooo. Good idea.

[@KellyDriscoll]

Thank you for the suggestion!💚

[@stephb1377]

I love the Purito Oat Gel! I have used both the BOJ Red Bean gel and the Purito Oat Gel. I have dehydrated combination skin that is oily in the summer. The BOJ Red Bean gel was nice, but it did nothing to calm down my rosacea. Purito’s Oat Gel has those soothing qualities I need in my moisturizer. I find that using it during the day with a sunscreen over it is enough for my skin. At night I either use a cream or mix the oat gel with a cream, depending on what my skin needs that day.

[@katkatkatz]

I also find the new illiyoon much lighter than the aestura! How interesting. For me the oily ingredients of aestura sit in top of the skin and never really absorb, whereas my skin seems to drink the illiyoon in, and what’s left on the surface is a super thin and luxuriously soft feeling dimethiconey veil

[@niklaus009]

Omggg so many epic battles!🤩 I’ve been wanting to repurchase the reform of Illiyoon (did not like the prev version) but you’re also selling me on the Aestura cream. This was the battle I’ve most been waiting for so thank you!! PKY Blue Label was so lovely and soothing in the harsh winter but it gave me closed comedones within 2 months. Based on that, I’ll have to pass on the PKY Black Tea but it looks divine. One of my key learnings from last year is to really understand which ingredients my skin loves and hates and stick to ones I love and have a minimalistic routine centred around that. Thank you for your hard work Kelly!!

[@czechmatey]

I'll have to pass too on PKY because of their coconut use. It has a tendency to break me out and both products use either Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride or other form of coconut. I learned this the hard way with Joseon's Dynasty cream. Illiyoon might be something to try and not just on my hands! lol

[@BarbaraT.]

I've recently started using the Aestura Ato Barrier and it feels divine on my skin. I'm combo/sensitive and I feel like this particular moisturiser is taking care of all my needs. I also slather it on my face after my retinal serum in the PM with great results. I hope this helps a little. That said, I'd be lying if I didn't say that I'm curious to try the Ilyoon cream too, although, after Kelly's analysis of it, maybe I feel a little less urgency to buy it.

[@syddharlequinmakeup]

The old formulation of illyoon wasn't enough for me. I live and breathe for the new formula!

[@a49-n2o]

These comparisons are just what I needed! Thank you Kelly ❤

[@sarascott8912]

Love these comparison videos. Would love one on facial mists!

[@kristinekerr3688]

Kelly… have you tried the “newer” moisturizer by Dr. Sam’s? It’s called flawless moisturizer intense. It has a lot of good ingredients in it and I thought you might really like it. I do. I’m 58 y/o so I’m looking for anti-aging supportive ingredients along with hydration & moisturization. Thx to you I’ve been able to put together a routine that I love…not that this stops me from trying new skincare lol. Sometime could you elaborate on the difference between hydration & moisturization? I just can’t seem to grasp the difference.

[@BarbaraT.]

Apart of how informative and well-made your videos are, I really enjoy how you come across: you seem so personable, nice and down-to-earth. That's a major plus for me and it makes me a loyal follower of your channel.

[@mymeikisis]

Finally! I am so curious how Aestura ato compares with the Illiyoon Ato. What is stopping me from buying the Aestura is the price. I'm from Canada so eveything is tends to be pricey but there is a $10 difference between them. If they are very similar then price is my deal breaker.

[@noirca]

I'm using the beauty of joseon red bean water gel, it's 1/2 already but i really love it even to reapply, it doesn't last very long but it's great for my sensitive acne prone skin, because sometimes if i use thick cream it made my skin breakout.

[@rainebowbright]

Dang it! I just ordered the Purito Oat-in! Wish I had watched this sooner. 🤷🏻‍♀️ I am hoping the oat water provides a soothing effect when my skin is feeling a little irritated.

[@fairujudita]

Update???

[@JJ_913]

I just started using Differin which made my skin really dry and the Illiyoon is perfect so far despite our humid weather ❤

[@cannibal_turtle]

Omg, yes! This is the comparison I've been waiting for. Are you a mind reader Kelly? You seem to always find out which items in my checkout cart I'm split about. Am looking forward to trying the aestura but the illiyoon is taking forever to finish lol (my wallet and I both love this cream so much). Also got the PY black tea cream in sample size since you liked it so much and am partly hoping that I won't enjoy it so much cause.. you know.. $$ On a side note, BOJ never disappoints!

[@KellyDriscoll]

Yay I'm glad this was right on time for you! I'm trying to empty my illiyoon right now too, so much product!

[@cannibal_turtle]

Okay, an update on the PKY black tea enriched cream. I like it. It's divine. I'm crying. My wallet is crying.

[@mooninaries4397]

Looove the packaging of the blue label one! (One of the reason it's on my "want-list"😅)

[@idisruiz9982]

Love ❤️ love 💗 love 💕 your videos. It’s obvious you take so much time and effort in your videos. I want to express my appreciation for this, and that you are not shy to admit when certain luxury products live up to their hype. Even more impressive is your suggestions to alternatives. Thank you!

[@KellyDriscoll]

Thank you so much, it means a lot to me that you see and appreciate the work that goes behind the videos and so happy to know they help!❤️🙏

[@melissatrottier709]

Not a this or that idea, but I’d love to see a video on your skincare prep tips for a big event (wedding, prom, etc.) Love your videos! Thanks for sharing your knowledge and opinions!

[@lavayuki]

Ive used two of the illiyoon ones and recently got the Aestura after a Japanese kbeauty KZbinr Kayo recommended it and I love Aestura. I also got the cream mist which is similar to the Laniege cream skin mist but a bit lighter which I prefer

[@czechmatey]

This was such an informative video. Thank you for putting up the labels and discussing small key points like what Ato means or the different peptides and price differences. This was a very well done video and you also seem nice and informative. Instant sub!

[@ybs161]

So happy you're reviewing the Aestura cream! I've been curious about it

[@RachelDee]

Be forewarned, it smells like straight up craft/Elmer's glue as you're putting it on. But it's a very comfortable effective cream for colder months without being too thick and heavy.

[@KellyDriscoll]

Happy this was right on time for you!💚

[@marynjesh]

What about this or that of the pyunkang yul ato blue label and Aestura cream?

[@sarahleandrasutton2834]

Thanks, Kelly! I ordered the black tea cream when you fell in love with it a few weeks/months ago. I haven’t opened it yet (trying to use up the last of another cream), but this video makes me even more excited to use it! The last couple months of winter really dry out my skin so I think I’ll be opening it at the perfect time and though I do have sensitive skin, I’m really focused on well aging these days. Thanks again!

[@KellyDriscoll]

The black tea cream is perfect for winter! I just emptied mine and miss it already! Hope your skin will enjoy it too!💖

[@BarbaraT.]

Just thr video I needed. I'm currently using the Aestura Atobarrier moisturizer and I'm enjoying it. The Illyoon one is definitely on my list though. I can never have too much skincare 🤭🤗

[@lauramacdonald1989]

Oooh id love the time revolution serum and the manyo bifida serum please! Both “dupes” for Estée Lauder ANR xx

[@lil4n9e1]

Thanks, Kelly! Great comparison. I would love to see your thoughts on the Purito Oat-in Intense Cream! :)

[@KellyDriscoll]

Glad you enjoyed! The oat cream is nice, but not quite enough occlusivity for my skin right now. I'll have to try again in spring but right now it's not doing it for me!

[@lil4n9e1]

@@KellyDriscoll thanks!!

[@marvyeap]

Hi Kelly, can you recommend a moisturizer that has a matte finish on the skin? I heard Paula’s Choice Invisible Finish Moisture Gel is very matte. Many thanks

[@angelinebiswas7611]

My favorite part in my routine every night is my moisturizer which sounds bizarre but man since I’ve discovered Korean ones I have like 5 on a constant rotation depending how I feel. I love it. I never was able to use illyoon because the ceramide capsules just stayed on my face and never melted in which drove me nuts 🌰 my favorite texture is the Pyunkang Yul ATO cream. I keep the ATO lotion at my kitchen sink. The 2nd or 3rd ingredient in the lotion is Urea so I’m assuming it’s at minimum a 5% urea if not a bit higher. I love so many of your recommendations I’ve bought nearly all of them! Biggest fan over here!!💜💜💜💜

[@sf8196]

are you talking about the blue label one that's talked about here? or a different one? not seeing urea on the ingredients list, but would love one with that!

[@amriddless]

Thank you for your reviews Kelly! I feel like we have such a similar skin type so I really relate to your thoughts. I'm combination but def lean dry in winter and oily in summer so my routine changes dramatically for the season

[@Tasnu07]

Was waiting for the Illiyoon & Aestura. Thank-you 💗

[@watchingreviews528]

Can you compare the Purito oat toner to the First Aid Beauty oat toner?

[@churrho]

Can you review and do a comparison of Dr. Different 311 Moisturizer vs. Aestura Atobarrier 365 Cream?

[@d.on.in.a]

Hi! Di you prefer the illiyoon to the recent aestura reformulation?

[@beastily2]

Thanks for the viddie! I'd like to see you do a this-or-that w/ Aestura Hydro Cream vs Dr.G Clear Soothing Cream or something similar to the aestura! Might have to try the ato365 cream once my illiyoon tubs spent

[@KellyDriscoll]

Thanks for the suggestion!

[@aurora6763]

Love your videos. Please can you discuss petrolatum in terms of how it differs to mineral oil. I use the Cerave Moisturizing Cream based on your recommendation and it contains this ingredient as an occlusive. Thank you for your amazing content💗

[@christined.7292]

Actually I'd be interested in this too.

[@starryeyed2511]

Would love to see a comparison between pky black tea vs BOJ dynasty cream!

[@beastily2]

hi anjunafam

[@blee8607]

Loved this or that videos. Please do more. Will try the black tea cream sometime this year.

[@awkwardgenxer1023]

I love this or that! Thank you. I can’t get enough of these!

[@sirtsupirtsu]

I agree so much with your review of Purito Oat gel-cream. I have very oily skin. I used this product during the summer. And even then - it just was not enough by far. It is more like a thicker gel-serum than moisturizer. It is definitely NOT a gel-cream. It is just a gel. It feels wonderful when first applied to the skin - so hydrating. But it immediately disappears and your skin will start to feel tight and lacking any moisture. I ended up using it this way - I took half and half this gel and another regular moisturizer, and used that mix. That was I was able to make it work. But I hate when brands use misleading product names. Just name it a gel. It is not gel-cream. One drop of squalene for this tube does not change a gel into a gel-cream. I certainly did not feel the oil in that gel, it must be miniscule amount.

[@Winnie_Bago]

Love your content Kelly! This or That is sooo helpful when I’m deciding which products to try. Curious - how do you narrow down products to the ones you compare??

[@KellyDriscoll]

Usually just products that strike me as similar to something I've already used. Either in how they are marketed or the ingredients. Like aestura is so similar to illiyoon in how it's marketed and the ingredients so that one just made sense to do!

[@ilylavender8014]

thank you so much for being so educated and sharing your thoughts on all these products it is so helpful for someone trying to get into skincare and i just wanted to express how much you deserve appreciation 💟💟

[@KellyDriscoll]

You're so welcome, I'm really glad my content is making skincare less stressful!

[@kathleenwarner4046]

Great video Kelly! Did not love the black tea enough for the price. Aestura is excellent for my dry, mature skin. One product I seldom see reviewed is Round Lab's Soybean cream; lovely texture and more richness than their Dokdo cream.

[@chbujhjkiuhjnn]

The nourishing cream? Do u likw it moren than the illiyoon

[@kathleenwarner4046]

Yes, the soybean nourishing cream. I haven't used the reformulated Illyoon, but the Round Lab has the silkiest texture and is very moisturizing although maybe not as occlusive. The soybean serum is also terrific. I am 62 with very dry skin living in an area with a harsh winter climate.

[@Anni-Ka93]

Would love to hear your opinion on the pyunkang yup calming line they came out with. Haven't really seen anyone talk about it.

[@jadelightsword]

It's so interesting to me that you call new illiyoon too emollient, but blue label "medium" weight. Old Illiyoon is def medium, but I hated new illiyoon bc I thought it wasn't moisturizing enough, I think maybe not occlusive enough on my skin. But I love PKY blue label bc of how thick and emollient and occlusive it is. (Gonna try the black tea one next bc of your previous video). I guess even different skin perceives the weight of products differently. Like you and a couple other skinfluencers think cream skin is too oily/thick but Dr cerucle is lighter, and I just have the opposite experience! Dr cerucle to me is hydrating and oily, but without the moisturizing/hydration locking benefits of being oily. So then I'm like, why did I just put that on my face......

[@Autumn567]

Yay!!!! The video we’ve been waiting for😍 Pyunkang Yul black tea cream caused an allergic reaction :/ waiting for the new Illiyoon to arrive and hopefully save my skin from this winter!❤

[@kilipaki87oritahiti]

The Beauty of Joseon has Saff flower oil, which is probably why. I tried the oat, and my sensitive Rosacea fungal acne skin hated it. The bean gel isn’y fungal avne safe due to the oil, but ordered it anyway to try.

[@heathersargent289]

Have u tried using the BOJ or the purito as a primer step before makeup just a thought but it may make a good foundation primer . I already know u could layer it before a thicker cream if wanted . I just notice alot of hydrating primers are somewhat similar but not as good ingredients and it might be good as that step.

[@KellyDriscoll]

I haven't tried that, will have to see! Thanks for the suggestion!

[@mattywood7294]

Thank you so much for comparing these K-beauty brands! My Yesstyle cart with full of products from different brands that were similar and I just couldn't decide on which! Now I do! 😁

[@KellyDriscoll]

Happy this helped!!💖

[@syddharlequinmakeup]

Oh! I also wanted to ask if you had tried the Then I Met You moisturizer. The barrier-supporting ingredients plus the ginseng complex has me like 👀

[@emilytran7433]

Aestura vs Soonjung Barrier Intensive Cream pls!

[@roliepandey162]

Can PY blue label cream be used for oily acne prone skin ? Or it will be too heavy ??

[@bhumimandera2515]

Want to know the same

[@WandaLeee]

I can't see copper tripeptide-1 on my PKY ATO cream's ingredients list. I can't also see it in the ingredients list you put on the screen. Please can you point out where it is? Am I really going blind for not seeing it 😄? Or is my brain having a brain fart moment and can't comprehend what I'm reading 🫣😄😄. All I see in PKY ATO cream blue label's ingridients list is acetyl hexapeptide -8 as peptide vise 🤔.

[@PR78193]

Hi if you had to choose either arstura cream or black tea cream as night cream which one will you choose??

[@SHFMIA]

Great video. Are you also reviewing French/European/western skincare because I’m finding the k beauty isn’t suiting me.

[@nfi6080]

Can you please review the etude house soon jung cream moisturizer

[@Dasming]

Kelly, why would they use a synthetic form of ceramide compared to using real ceramide? Is it more cost effective?

[@SA30.137]

Hey can u pls do iope brand review??

[@Jkslsb]

hey ...can u pls review the illiyoon gel cream plzz

[@NatalieG427]

Gothamista has a video reviewing the Pyungkang Yul line.

[@mysty09]

Does the Purito Oat-In gel cream goes well under makeup?

[@katymawson3701]

Thanks Kelly this was so interesting!

[@faridakabul6111]

I’m confused 😕, I’m using cerave for mature skin at night my skin is dry . I want a thick moisturizer like cerave probably better consistency! Therefore, I was waiting for this video to update my moisturizer at night from cerave to illyoon or the blue pyn cream. I still don’t know what to buy for fatty ceramide and moisture cream 😢

[@zahir8493]

hi Kelly! love your vid so much.. now i confused to choose beetwen illiyoon cream or purito unscented cream? for combine it with tret.. i have a combo skin also dry patches around lips under the lips.. still search about this versus product but still cant find. plss need your help what your pick?

[@zahir8493]

and more actives like aha bha. may i say all rounder cream that have multi-talented role..

[@jenniferlee9029]

Hi Kelly. Did Aestura change the formula. I noticed the original tube said for skin barrier strength on the front and now the tube say for dry and sensitive sensitive skin. I'm confused.

[@enkhmurun1886]

What eyeshadow do you use. It’s so pretty

[@KellyDriscoll]

Thank you! It's the huda beauty rose quartz palette!

[@laurawarden6036]

Kelly, I'd love to see what the hype over SKII is about. Do you have a this or that for products like that? A cruelty free dupe, perhaps? 🤔 Either way, you're the reason I've tried almost half of my k-beauty products. ❤

[@nikki2178]

The Jin Jun sung essence is a great dupe for SKll

[@mignonalverson2475]

How do you find Illyoon’s ingredients? I can never find them.

[@khushijain4611]

Can I use this red bean gel cream I am 18 year old 😢 Actually I have use snail mucin essence since 5 days and now my face has so many little pimples😢 So it is good for me or not???

[@annikaknoche6362]

I love love love your channel ❣️

[@ephidd290]

i really don't know which one I have to buy either BOJ red bean water gel or pyunkang yul balancing gel.. I find soon jung emulsion doesn't give much more hydration that I need.. 😔

[@haminguyen9598]

OMGGGG yes! So many fav moisturizers❤

[@okashi10]

Has anyone tried the Purito Breeze Water Gel Cream? I'm curious how it compares to the two gel moisturizes in this video.

[@komaljethi9453]

Can i use red bean gel with vitamin c

[@KellyDriscoll]

Yes ofc!

[@smileyjollybean507]

Hello, I want to know is it the atobarrier 365 doesn’t contain any steroid? As I am trying to refuse steroid :)

[@angelicareynosa8052]

What about if you get closed commodones from almost everything and you cannot find the right moisturizer especially at night. My skin is suffering. I used niacinimide a yr ago and ever since it seems every thing is giving me commodones. I am stuck to a very minimal skin care routine sooo gentle I'm sure nothing is even effective. Kelly I need help. I'm watching all of your videos hoping I find something that won't trigger the commodones. I swear even squalane gives me them. Especially capryl triglycerides and even too many ceramides. I have tried rose hip oil a light layer on over my panthol water cream but nope closed commodones. Have you ever heard of this. ?

[@angelicareynosa8052]

I forgot to add. I've used adapelene for almost 2 yrs and even after going slow I destroyed my skin barrier. I ended up with more texture and commodones. I stopped the adapelene and many of the commodones went away . I now use by wish trend pha and I percent salysilic acid wash the pink bottle and benzoyl peroxide 2 times a week leave on short contact for 15 minutes to affected area. My skin looks better but its not as hydrated or plump as it used to be I use the make prem hydrating toner I use mineral 89 hyloronic acid I use be plain ceamide serum and top off with aveeno oat serum and b5 water gel from skin n lab. This is not enough.

[@annin4002]

@angelicareynosa8052 hey there, using adapelene also broke my skin barrier. I dont use it anymore. The illiyooon ato cream and the ample N ceramide shot ampoule rescued my skin. I also used to get closed comodones and little white heads all the time. I started using Neutrogena advanced acne serum, and my skin soooooo is not congested anymore and hardly any kind of acne. It is very gentle, been using it for 2months everyday . I can't believe Neutrogena fixed my acne! Anyway, I hope this helps. Also, i dont wash my face in the morning with anything besides water in order to not strip my face. Using oil cleanser or a Jojoba seed oil massage a few times a week helps to melt blackheads and congestion, too. So at the end of the day if my skin is not moisturised enough (stripped by too many actives) or moisturised too much i will break out. We have to find a balance, please use few products at a time to figure out the balance. care

[@izabelresende4987]

Cerave x Illyoon??

[@sheremainsbiblical]

I’m genuinely deciding too much between Beauty of Joseon vs Pyunkang Yul 😩 like I don’t know what seems better for my skin and I just want to stick to it & all 😭 PLS. HELP. MEEEEE

[@BongoReaction10]

Can someone tell me, is this red bean moisturiser good for winter night? My skin is Combination type more on oil side

[@celeste8157]

Somebody give me moisturizer recs for super dry skin! The Illiyoon is not enough for me in the winter. I want something super thick and heavy. Like something that most people would hate lol

[@KellyDriscoll]

PKY Black Tea Enriched Cream or La Roche Posay Triple Repair Moisturizer!

[@cameoong]

Aestura & Illiyoon are on the same company

[@bestproductforyou]

Nice

[@rick-kg2fk]

I bought the red bean water gel moisturizer and it's sticky and tacky after 20 minutes after applying. Is that normal, and how do I get rid of the stickiness

[@KONN1182]

Mists! 🙏

[@janesmitson7404]

Battle of the cica serums...

[@Siberius-]

15:58 - Oh, no urea... what the hell. OH, cream vs lotion. Different ingredients.

[@sunidhi29]

❤❤

[@iqraaimtiaz2673]

FIRST!!

[@afrodykeeism]

You should try the Easter’s lotion, hydro soothing cream and essence next