Thunderous low notes from Geoff Castellucci! Bass Singer Reaction & Vocal ANALYSIS | "Unshaken"

[@PeterBarber]

Back by popular demand, the bass king graces this channel with his epic Western outlaw presence in "Unshaken" -- how many pit vipers will this man earn? Put your guesses in below...

[@ColtonRMagby]

Geoff will earn every Pit Viper he gets. The number is irrelevant.

[@sefa_demirkaya]

You are the king of reaction. I bow before you. Thanks 😁🔥

[@matthewLokeMaverick]

Geoff will earn all the Pit Vipers. The number will be equal to the number of low notes he hits.

[@anymous1485]

Yes.

[@CynicalTesuji]

You've more or less said it yourself- Geoff hits those lows with such regularity and accuracy, with such a full tone (a variety of them, to be honest!) that it's almost redundant to give him the vipers. I think, by now, we ought to acknowledge that Geoff simply IS a Pit Viper, or maybe THE Pit Viper, as he epitomizes them so well!

[@Starrynightdiner]

I’m sure you have been told, Geoff is not in this video. Darryl, Jeoph, Goff and Jeff. First time they have been able to record unsupervised. Geoff said Darryl was in charge. I think Goff should have been in charge. He is the most responsible close. He is the onlty one who didn’t go to prison. ❤❤

[@Badger77722]

I would give this comment several "thumbs up" if YT would only let me! 🤣😆🤣

[@marshayoung9387]

Geoff has such a great sense of humor.

[@crystalinahenry4104]

Haha! Awesome! 😂

[@DravenGal]

True, but Goff obviously did go to Hades, for he too is a Ghost Rider! 😉💙

[@marshayoung9387]

@@DravenGal lol

[@cherylsmith3291]

I would love seeing you and Geoff singing together.

[@MaKettle111]

Or maybe Geoff with the Bass Gang. 🤔

[@shelbywells7650]

OH, and forgot to add, would LOVE to see you and Geoff sing together!!!!!!

[@sarawlindgreen3115]

Did Peter just suggest a duet between himself and Geoff Castellucci? If so, then YES PLEASE! 😍😍😍

[@DravenGal]

Oh HECK YEAH!!!!

[@MathiasStraight]

Definitely

[@briannepartington946]

THE PIT VIPERS ARE BACK!! 😎

[@margiestevens2384]

New song by Geoff is one of my favorites. Can’t wait to hear your reaction 😊

[@PeterBarber]

Thanks, Margie!

[@iamsquatty]

Geoffquakes for days in this one 😂💜

[@jessewright7945]

Geoff Castellucci and The Bass Gang would. be amazing.

[@ElizabethHurst-Waitz]

Peter, you are so much fun to watch! Yes, it's grand that you educate and enhance, but to watch you ENJOY adds Entertainment. Oh! And thank you, too, for Enthusiasm! 😘 Th

[@ColtonRMagby]

Geoff's low notes are worthy of their own role in a movie.

[@pzycho_reclas1794]

ok one more comment... I love Mason's commentary, it had me laughing so hard....also could you say that in this song and all the satisfying notes that Geoff really found that G spo... sorry lmao i can't lol

[@tompeavy8254]

Awesome reaction. Very happy to see Geoff back on. Special shoutout to Mason, for the killer editing. The dialogue and info boxes add so much to the final product.

[@rhov-anion]

Mason is always hilarious.

[@barbarakennedy2667]

Gotta love Mason.

[@Tech16-z1k]

The costumes may be the ones used in his cover of "Ghost Riders in the Skies" Also i love all the jokes that could be made, i made several "That's what she said! hahaha" jokes, and i love how often you can be taken out of contexts on this video also HE GOT THE DEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!

[@RemWinchester]

I love that Geoff self-conducts, and does it so consistently that the two in the middle were perfectly in sync with their hand movements! Great analysis as always!

[@christinestromberg4057]

Can't remember if you looked at his Ghost Riders but these are the same guys who did that, but without Geoff himself. They also did a mock ad for the coffee shop. I think it was Huldra Draco who put that out. On a different theme Geoff's Shenandoah has some lovely riffing from him. Or one of him anyway.

[@felicitymcdonald24]

He's done reactions to both Ghost Riders and Shenandoah, though I don't think the Shenandoah got put in the Reactions playlist

[@michellemoreland3783]

I absolutely love how much you share your appreciation of other's talents. Thanks for all your reactions and analysis. Keep them coming, Peter!!

[@jennifercadarette4898]

I've determined that one can rate the level of Peter's excitement about a song based on the number of arched eyebrow scrunch faces he makes whilst analyzing. 😂 Geoff's songs always gets the best expressions!

[@moriahwhite1188]

Mason FTW! 😆🫶🏻

[@lachimiste1]

Mason is my favorite! Ever since I saw him geek out over Vivaldi on Mortius’ channel, I knew he was my people. Love his sense of humor.

[@MarieDesJardin]

16:57 Love your eloquent commentary on having all these octaves: Plplplplplplp! Well said. I get tired of all these pissing contests. Listening to 3+ octaves of beautiful chest voice is what keeps me coming back to this fantastic singer. Thanks for posting this lovely analysis.

[@steby123]

Great Peter; a bass reacting to Geoff whio can actually reproduce Geoff's notes as well as understanding the technique of the singing !!!!

[@edmitchell528]

Love the way you break down Geoffs vocals and his arrangements. It’s great to learn from someone who has the ability to comment not only from a technical side but also ability.

[@marshayoung9387]

Did you happen to see Jeff's coffee commercial at Daryl's Cafe ? He is too funny.

[@DavideBaroni]

This is why I love your analysis. THere's ALWAYS so much to learn, in many "fields": music theory, singing techniques, even mixing techniques, things from your experience, fun moments, and more. You say "I love making these analysis videos", and believe me, it's easy to perceive... And it is a nice part of the enjoyment. 🙂 Thank you for this particular analysis. I admit this is one of my favourites songs among Geoff's production, together with the Hobbit pair (especially "I see fire", I have to say...) and "Till then". And now I can appreciate it even more. Thanks again. See you next time!

[@amberfuchscia709]

Loved your final pit viper!! Truly do enjoy your analyses. So informative and interesting, even to a non-musical person.❤❤❤❤❤

[@windbringer9890]

"3 octaves in chest is very very hard and only something really low basses can do" says the man was G#1-A4 in chest lol you really are a incredible singer

[@paula0721]

Those sounds from the depths were just Geoff testing the structures of my house. 😂

[@thomasfarr7934]

Geoff is my favorite vocalist. You are one of my favorite analysts! There is another that I really like tied with you... (Charismatic Voice). You are probably my favorite at critiquing Geoff, because you are are a bass evaluating a bass. Personally, I would love to hear you as a guest vocalist in VoicePlay! That would be awesome!!

[@rebeccamay6420]

Charismatic Voice! 🤗 ... the way she gets the giggles when Geoff's bass drops to the 1's -- or anyone else's bass too.😂 I've learned a lot about the structure of the vocal tract and recognized that I do some of those things, but now I'm also learning about anatomy and growing my vocabulary. 🤓

[@WhateverDeluxe2012]

Check out those freaking guns, Peter! YOURS!! Love your R&D, as always. There's always something to learn about the song from you ❤

[@rhov-anion]

I now want to hear how Geoff would mesh with one of your EDM arrangements. I think it would be a totally new avenue for him, and it would sound awesome. Duet??? One can hope, right? Love your analysis. Awesome subs. I remember when you struggled with those. You've been practicing, and it's really paying off.

[@sharihibberd2545]

Always love a good Geoff low note!

[@barbarakennedy2667]

We know you are busy, and we do appreciate it when you can find time for a Geoff reaction. Thank you.

[@MarilynLloyd-f6c]

Love this one. Did you notice voiceplay just released Black hole sun? It's truly amazing.

[@reallollabunny]

I must give props to Mason - dude, you enhance my experience of every video you edit! keep up the good work ^^

[@MagicMason1000]

Thanks so much! I'm glad you like my additions :)

[@itsmegs98]

Great analysis as always, Peter! Good to see another one with Geoff. Your reactions are awesome, and I love Mason's commentary 😂

[@Broomrider1492]

Ghost Riders before they became The Ghost Riders In The Sky. Geoff let the boys do this on their own unsupervised. Counted on Daryl to keep them roped in. L to R Goff, Daryl, Jeoph, and Jeff. I think they did Geoff proud. Don't forget to check out the ad for Daryls' Cafe.

[@FLNatureGuy]

How dare you start a Geoff song without the Pit Vipers! (lol) This song was full of Geoffquakes and needed your recognition. Great analysis. Thanks.

[@eirintowne]

I really appreciate the awe between singers that truly recognize and respect the skills of a colleague, the joy in experiencing them doing well! Geoff is nothing but a phenomenon (that sure spikes some pheromones), but you have a brilliant way of pointing out that he is not just a freak of nature, but has built up the skills over years and years of training and learning not just technique, but some really deep musical understanding. As someone more fond of opera than country or game music, I often find myself underwhelmed by the quality of the songs chosen, but the renditions never fail to impress me! I hope for a little break from at least country, perhaps the two of you could cooperate in making a brand new Sarastro?

[@jryanp]

Hits G1: ✅ now to stop coughing from peppers 😂

[@Dawn54811]

Fantastic reaction! Would love to hear you and Geoff do a collab!

[@carinarodebak9419]

You always give pleasure with your R&A, intentionally or not.❤ Plus, love to Mason.❤

[@karenzak6627]

Great reaction, thank you!

[@JakeWolfenden-p8b]

bru finally! I checked this chanel for like a week straight every day after this song came out.

[@ronsbrat525]

Voiceplay released their new video Friday the 19th..... Black Hole Sum. It is absolutely amazing. Warning.... Keep those Pit Vipers ready.

[@bjspeck4337]

Lord this one seems to refer to all that is going on in this world - it felt like the problems were not resolved. I'd like to hear you and Geoff!

[@etrain757]

I can’t wait, I’ve been missing the Geoff reactions

[@ljt974]

The fire emoji is exactly right for your new release. I cant wait for the album and a Geoff collaboration would also be a dream come true for a lot of us fans of you two!

[@danirwen5790]

The bass gang should do something with Geoff, the rumbles 😮

[@karenkincaid5569]

Loved this review. You were soooo funny and seemed to really enjoy hearing Geoff again. Please talk him into doing a project with you..

[@annel6265]

Always a pleasure to hear you analyse Geoff's cover! Thank you! (You cracked me up on that one :))

[@NakeyaeStreet]

If you and the Bass King collab. I will need the following: 1) new headphones. 2) one week pay cause I will need to have time to digest what just happened... 3) the right drawer of dresser will be nothing but threads....IYKYK

[@pzycho_reclas1794]

I glanced through the comments and didn't see this but Darryl, Jeoph, Goff and Jeff are playing the roles of the ghost riders from the previous ghost riders video however this is before they passed on over to the other side. Love your reactions and the analysis you give. Can't wait to see if you react to Black Hole Sun by VP.

[@mindywiese7610]

Love Geoff ❤❤ miss you analysing him.

[@MiladyMacabre]

Left to right we have: Goff, Daryl, Jeoph, and Jeff - the Ghost Riders before they died and were cursed to eternally ride. One of the plug ins for this cover was labeled "Tubular Bells." Most of the costumes from Ghost Riders in the Sky were in storage and Rick Underwood still had most of the hair pieces saved. This is the first time this particular background set at PattyCake Productions was used. The percussion you mention around timestamp 19:14 also reminds me of a heartbeat.

[@benjaminlitter512]

@PeterBarber I really enjoyed this Video. For me, your whole Stuff, Analysis, Music is outstanding and I’m glad I found your channel. Greetings from Germany

[@margiestevens2384]

Love your new intro❤

[@judybrowning1463]

I love how animated you are listening to Geoff!! Great job!!

[@Taytodude]

Hey Peter, great analysis! Some recommendations for reactions are: We're Good and Whiskey in the Jar both by Voiceplay. Thanks for the great content!

[@susanfulbright4898]

Thoroughly enjoyed your analysis and Masons's contributions as well!

[@gilliandrysdale5306]

so you were definitely shaken ..and stirred!

[@ambermiller7690]

❤ love you and Geoff

[@CardmakerNr1]

That would be ace to hear you and Geoff together. Always enjoy your analysis!

[@user-scott-pearce]

Never played the game either, had to look up the song. Geoff more than nailed it

[@RWHansen]

I always love your reaction and analyses. Please keep them coming!

[@jankates1274]

Thank.s PB - you put so much fun into this one

[@Filiz_E]

Definitely one of my favourites from Geoff.. Thanks for the r&a..

[@lkayh]

Oh, man, that’s great! I wish you could frame that fire emoji! And YES to a collab with Geoff. That would be amazing!

[@bopemuworty3163]

All 4 Jeff's haha. Love it

[@marymulligan3053]

Great reaction as always, Love the song Geoff did. Mason you did an awesome job too!

[@tiffymcconkey]

Loved your analysis as always❤ Also, VoicePlay covered Black Hole Sun by Sound Garden

[@r3adrpro811]

Please do Geoff's cover of Wicked Game. It is glorious! I've been waiting for your take on it and all the Pit Vipers.

[@bonniewells9208]

Thank you for the great analysis! Would you ever consider giving voice lessons? That would be awesome!! Geoff is absolutely amazing! You guys should collaborate with each other!! Love to hear you guys sing together! ❤

[@itspetos2107]

This one was fire. I think you should check out the new vp song "Black Hole Sun", that one is fire too

[@MichellleOwings-Christian]

My Daddy used to watch classic Westerns -- and this is it

[@AngieCurl]

I honestly only watch your Geoff and VP reactions.. So it was nice to see you again. :-) ❤

[@Eileen_in_Vegas]

This might have been the best R&A yet! 😂 So much fun!!

[@marlaatml]

Your reviews are always great.❤❤❤

[@rmdewberry2482]

Yay! I knew this one by Geoff was the one for you. Fun video with you (and Mason)! I figured the vipers would only be in the 2-3 range otherwise you'd just have to keep them on for the whole video. XD

[@nikkijung1970]

I learn so much from your reactions. I think it would be awesome for you and Jeff to sing a song together, or for you to sing with Voiceplay. Great reaction as always.

[@axelsilverdal1163]

I just love your reactions and how you go in depth of the hole thing. Love, love, love. Best of luck with the chanel from sweden.🎉🎉🇸🇪

[@shelbywells7650]

Amazing video! I loved Geoff's cover of this (don't know the original at all), and also loved your analysis. I think I've commented before that I roomed with a music major in college; it was a small college, a small music department, and my roommate had the best stereo in the department. I can't count the number of times I came home to our apartment to find all the music students sitting/lying in our living room, gathered around the speakers, analyzing compositions. You teach me something new every time I listen to your analysis! I'm definitely looking forward to your new album :)

[@davidjohnston2902]

He's pretty much using the instrumentation and vocal arrangement from the song in the game with a style and flair only he brings to songs. If you haven't played RDR2 and you like essentially open world games you can explore as you please and follow the storyline when you want, I highly recommend it. Be forewarned, though, your actions in the game determine a lot of things (trying not to give it away too much). When this song is playing in the game, your character has seen friends gunned down, barely escaped himself, ended up shipwrecked, helped a group rebel against those in control of the island he landed on, finally made it back, and he's riding back to the hideout in a cutscene while this is playing.

[@Wildecat10]

I realize your time is tight, but there is SO much in Voiceplay’s Black Hole Sun that would like to hear you analyze. Please?

[@pzycho_reclas1794]

ok one more comment I absolutely love the movement that Geoff has in this piece, his voice and his control of it have matured so so much. Idk why but one of my favorite parts is at 11:42 in your video, it's the, idk what to call it, but the little hitch in the word water. It just sounds so nice. (And I obviously left this before you made your comment on it lol)

[@qcrew2938]

Geoff will be in a Bass Gang video by the end of 2025.... that's my prediction

[@petraharwin9670]

Love your analysis, as always. Also, Mason, love your work!

[@freddiestudio7668]

Begging for whiskey in a jar Voiceplay

[@pacemaker6882]

We been waitin

[@cherylsmith3291]

Glad you did this reaction. Always love your reactions. I learn a lot and appreciate the song even more.

[@ashbii7632]

Geoff's so cool YOURE so cool.

[@R989D]

You needed pitviper contact lenses for this track 😂😂

[@MC_Fournier]

🔥🔥🔥 Thanks Peter for the wonderful review and analysis! I hope Wicked Game (from Geoff, of course) is somewhere on your list too!

[@andreak4130]

Waited for you to do this one. Such a great reaction, and funny.

[@dianeschluter9995]

🎉🎉 was eagerly waiting for this one!

[@MelodieRose727]

Love your analysis! ❤

[@keydemoore]

I would love to hear Geoff do something with you and the rest of the Bass Gang.

[@wesgarden74]

Really enjoy your analysis work and am looking forward to more of your own work.

[@marge2548]

Great reaction. I am so glad you did something of Jeff again. As for his range, I think he started high and then went on to learn and sing lower, not the other way round. Now, apparently not anyone can do this - however, I think that's the reason why he sings even the higher parts in comparative ease (?).

[@gigi3242]

Have an awesome week.

[@laurenkop1019]

Mason deserves a bonus 😉

[@Bubba_Deluxe]

I would absolutely love it if You would make a hoist the colors cover with Geoff

[@PeterBarber]

That’d be nuts