TIER LIST: Every AEW PPV So Far

[@chernobylhobo7793]

I feel I would have rated All Out 2022 lower. It had some massive highs with stuff like the main event, trios championship, and tag championship, but there was a bunch of matches that were disappointingly short or had weird booking decisions. It didn't feel anywhere near as consistent as some of AEW's other PPVs.

[@TheReedy92]

😅

[@gbrooks2]

three of those, including one you named, were hindered by early injuries (yes, sure, rank it lower but just FYI did not go according to plan)

[@diabeticman2194]

I would've put it at alright, couple of great matches but for me a lot of the hype matches underdelivered and some matches were grand but not special. I don't think it's the worst AEW ppv, but it's not the best either

[@JambleBramble]

Ironically I thought it was one of their most consistent yet

[@DomDeVille]

😅

[@pjsw]

I love these long tier lists

[@coryreinhard4519]

You guys should do a tier list of all the commentators in WWE and aew

[@TheThird1977]

Would prefer it to be a ranking of the commentators as collectives (e.g. Michael Cole & Tazz, Heenan & Monsoon, Jesse & Vince, etc) to see who comes out on top.

[@matt8258]

They did a wwe commentators tier list a few years ago

[@StevenScodes]

Great job to Ross and Jack, the Gary KZbins, for this awesome Tier List video!

[@jamisonlamkin5576]

Wikipedia says that The Young Bucks won versus The Brotherhood at Fight For The Fallen 2019.

[@natetv671]

Revolution 2022 was the best ppv in Aew in my opinion then all out 2021 then forbidden door then all out 2019 then revolution 2020 my top 5 ppv shows

[@VorpalBender]

Ross' J.R. impression throughout this video is just fantastic.

[@thehawk515]

Great tier choice! Enjoyed the history lesson King Ross. You and Jack still have great chemistry.

[@GingaWolf]

Some context on Fyter Fest '19 It felt like the whole concept (beyond the parody name) was intended for a crossover between wrestling and fighting games. My guess this was probably a Kenny Omega idea as he loves fighting games, with half his signature moves being video game references. The 2019 Fyter Fest was ran in collaboration with CEO (Community Effort Orlando) one of the larger fighting game tournaments ran in the USA. CEO is ran by Alex Jebailey which is likely why he had the silly match on the card, more than likely to get a reaction from the people in attendance who were attending CEO. The involvement of fighting game commentators joining the commentary team for the matches and the use of the arcade stick from Justin Wong in the front row, and the Elite dressing up as Ryu, Ken and Akuma were all intended to try and mix the two demographics together. Sadly it didn't seem to have the desired effect of cross pollenating audiences, which is I guess why future events have had limited video game connections with only Golden Boy showing up for commentary on later Fyter Fests. I believe Jebailey and Omega are real life friends and Omega has been on to promote stuff with Jebailey on a number of occasions. Additionally he is also the face of the Jebaited global emote on Twitch.

[@jxirocxmpos]

I got bored, didn't finish reading

[@AceTrainerRaf]

CEO is a wrestling inspired tournament. Top 8 entrants are given wrestling style entrances, top 8 has a wrestling ring as the stage, and the 1st place for every game has custom made full sized wrestling belts as the trophy

[@BrendorTheEndor]

One of my favorite AEW events ever for this reason. Huge FGC fan, so seeing a wrestling match where Justin Wong gave Jebailey an arcade stick to use as a weapon was the greatest thing I've ever seen.

[@theharv1490]

All Out 2021 was the first AEW PPV I watched and it was great, even if I was relatively new to AEW

[@diabeticman2194]

Before watching this video, I’ll say that All Out 2021 is my favourite, closely followed by Revolution 2022 + 2020 and Full Gear 2021

[@namo9690]

I'm biased for all out 2019, I was there and the atmosphere was something else. Met jungle boy and Marko stunt, smoked bud with Marko lol. And ate food at ODBs food truck and snuck into joey janelas after party. Felt like a surreal dream and just a cool vibe from everyone there. Internet toxicity doesn't show actually going to the shows. Love eachother and support all wrestling!

[@clarkejoseph49]

My top three… 1) Double or Nothing 2021 2) Full Gear 2021 3) All Out 2019

[@coolnerdyates29]

For me: I started watching AEW PPVs back with All Out 2021. And I'd say All Out 2021, Full Gear 2021, and Revolution 2022 all go into the best category. They were all so good in different ways. Just a great stretch for AEW. DoN 2022 was the start of the fall I think. The second half carried the show. I would put it in LLL Forbidden Door was just a miracle for how the show turned out for how cursed the build was. So riddled with injuries from big stars. Matches were pretty good, but I would also put it in LLL. Just wasnt as great as the Big 3. All Out 2022...I struggled with this one. I would have put it at alright if it was just for the show itself, but I hate to say it, but the media scrum and the resulting fall out made the PPV kinda pointless to watch. I would have dropped it to JAB, but I now put it back in alright because MJF kinda saved that PPV. But man, what a drop from last year...

[@Tractall]

Jack was wrong, but the video was still really good.

[@clliip]

Cool list idea, been a fan of aew until a few months ago, looking forward to thos

[@adrianofgold]

So you’re not a fan anymore ?

[@vincenzolaughoff5038]

aew ppvs are invariably good from time to time

[@mackenziereeves8494]

That anarchy in the arena double or nothing 22 was so beast🔥😂

[@hitmonlee8180]

Funny story about DoN 2021. about half way through the show someone started to smoke weed in the crowd. The whole crowded started to chant "Whose not sharing." It was aweaome.

[@joeywrestling9536]

I really miss that series… Officially beginning the petition to bring back the “Straight to Hell” series. ☝🏼

[@CraicPype13]

The people need an every AEW tournament tier list!

[@thefiggamehunt6946]

Why has the narrative become that aew ppvs are too long now when they've always been this length?

[@SkeeterMcMeatBeater]

Best: All Out 2021 Worst: All Out 2020

[@soundwave80s26]

I went All Out on my Revolution in Full Gear and it’s Double or Nothing on Forbidden Door.

[@lindahaynes2620]

Best Comment!

[@bobthekow7547]

I was at Full Gear 2021 and holy heck did I love that show! MJF vs Darby deserved the Dave Meltzer 5 star rating but it only got 4.5

[@Nbflowers1989]

Big Elite fan here, but I gotta disagree about the Full Gear 2021 Hangman finish. I didn't see Matt coming down to the ring and nodding to Hanger as giving him his permission.. I saw it as it was Matt's way of apologizing for not being there for his friend when he should have two years earlier.

[@thefiggamehunt6946]

How about a TEAR list of betrayals and weddings or moments that pulled on the heart strings

[@ZaggaZye]

Finally, real news and content... Thank you Cultaholic! All Out 2021 best and full gear in 2020 right behind.

[@JaimeD.]

Hey, same with me. ✌🏻

[@ZaggaZye]

@@JaimeD. LOL actually, I am gonna do a replay of some of these on this lovely drama free Sunday review. Note, if you guys are gonna shit on Punk, please shit on Swerve as well and ask someone from the tag division to kick their door in and throw a punch LOL.

[@scotttaber7008]

How long until every WWE PPV ranked? One to rival the ranking of every wrestlemania match marathon.

[@sizablekoala6879]

Before AEW, I hadn't been to a live wrestling show since I was a kid. I was very lucky to have been to Revolution 2020 and Full Gear 2021.

[@saulbadman5705]

Not gonna lie, Double Or Nothing 2019 is still my favourite AEW ppv.

[@Steeldragon493]

Well that child has made it official: Gary KZbin now and forever!

[@HotshotShum]

Disregarding everything that happened after the show, other than Swerve/Acclaimed I was bored to death during All Out 2022. It would be on par with All Out 2020 for me.

[@RGF91]

my top 5 favorite aew ppvs: 1. All Out 2021 2. Double or Nothing 2019 3. Revolution 2020/2022 (tie) 4. Forbidden Door 5. Full Gear 2021

[@ComeatMEOW]

I liked this, however with so many, maybe have sub tiers to the main tiers. Like top of the tier Middle of the tier and bottom of the tier, for each main tier.. Also should do this with all the talent. If it hasn't already be done.

[@eviled33]

I almost forgot Jimmy Havoc was a thing. He was one of my early favourites in AEW (along with JB and Uno and Grayson). Its a shame who he turned out

[@ComeatMEOW]

Thanks guys. Especially jack!

[@TheMysticCastle42]

All NXT takeovers tier list (including UK takeovers) would be fun!

[@JawaPunter]

Best part of Revolution 2021 was Kenny saying "69 me Don" on dynamite after

[@nathanthewrestlingguy]

A nice trip down memory lane Some great memories as Ross and Jack go through the history of the aew ppv's Some notes so far Young bucks did beat Dustin and Cody at fight for the fallen 2019 Just another thought cause I've heard this all week With all the news with cm punk and the elite situation do we really think it's wise on the same show for Tony to call an audible to have the acclaimed win the tag titles and potentially angering more of your stars in aew Probably a bad idea there Ross so no I disagree

[@Tmack034]

I think you should count ALL IN as a AEW ppv. Technically its not but its the spiritual successor.

[@TheThird1977]

2hr+ tier list malarkey from the Brothers Gary? Sign me up, son. Absolutely positive the rankings here won't cause any grumblings in the comments.

[@billybowers5850]

My opinions of all of the AEW PPVs so far: AEW Double or Nothing 2019-The Best. AEW Fyter Fest 2019-Alright. AEW Fight for the Fallen 2019-Alright. AEW All Out 2019-Lovely, Lovely, Lovely. AEW Full Gear 2019-Lovely, Lovely, Lovely. AEW Revolution 2020-The Best. AEW Double or Nothing 2020-Lovely, Lovely, Lovely. AEW All Out 2020-Just Above Bearable. AEW Full Gear 2020-Lovely, Lovely, Lovely. AEW Revolution 2021-Alright. AEW Double or Nothing 2021-Lovely, Lovely, Lovely. AEW All Out 2021-The Best. AEW Full Gear 2021-The Best. AEW Revolution 2022-Lovely, Lovely, Lovely. AEW Double or Nothing 2022-Lovely, Lovely, Lovely. AEWxNJPW Forbidden Door 2022-The Best. AEW All Out 2022-Lovely, Lovely, Lovely.

[@itsaIIgoodman]

Always love hearing Gary KZbin

[@joshuaali1940]

You could do a tier list on all of WWE’s 5 star matches

[@liamversionone6491]

Jack was wrong but the video was still really good

[@zubrhero5270]

Jack was wrong. But the video was still reeeeally good.

[@MrMonstaNoodle]

So ready for this!

[@codymb15]

Fyter Fest and Fight for the Fallen were free "PPVs" for the US, so that's why they were a step down from DoN.

[@alanbonesjones1847]

Hope Stadium stampede is a future aew ppv maybe their first stadium ppv

[@PorkTips]

AEW PPVs are invariably quite good from time to time 🙂

[@JaimeD.]

I consider ALL OUT 2021 as the best AEW PPV, followed by FULL GEAR 2020.

[@funnybone6149]

Speaking tier list and AEW Can you make a tier list of all backstage fights?

[@tonythomas2391]

I think Forbidden Door had the potential to be at least 2nd best if Danielson, Ishii and Hiromu had been able to compete.

[@hello1721]

Still don't know how Tony ruined it with Christian. Said it was a HOF worthy talent and one of his favs. Literally both are true

[@aaronliu3201]

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE do this but for NXT Takeovers! About 30+ of them but cards are way smaller!

[@Thomas-der-Zweite]

nice one

[@TheSubZer0HEro]

All out 2020 would've been in the bin for me because of the hardy situation, I get it is a bit unfair to the other matches but it was inexcusable given what we know about head injuries these days. I couldn't get invested in anything else for the rest of the card.

[@ChrisFactor]

Fyter fest was on broadcast television here in the states. At least in Oklahoma and California it was

[@joshuahurtado9359]

AEW ppv's are generally really good

[@chimpmasterflex]

Considering Jack is the co-host for this, I'll consider anything under lovely lovely lovely a win. Felt like they could do no wrong in Jack's eyes for the longest time.

[@cymraegpunk1420]

to be fair when it came to ppvs (not week to week tv) for a long time they really couldn't every show was good to great

[@chimpmasterflex]

@@cymraegpunk1420 I don't want to make it sound like I thought they were "bad" shows, I just think a few more could've maybe slipped into "alright". Like honestly even all out 2022 I'd probably consider nearly "bearable", but probably is alright. Just opinions, and even then basically all of these shows took place before Jack was back on the wwe train a bit.

[@StillChewy]

ROSS AND JACK ARE SO FREAKIN CUTE!

[@jordanwalker365]

AEW PPVs are invariant good from time to time

[@hauntingtheshadows1331]

I love you guys… but let’s be real this video did NOT need to be 2 hours hahaha

[@hi-5004]

forbidden door wasn’t that great, they’d boulder held it off for a later date with better matches

[@seansmall5069]

Who was the person they can't mention from fight for the fallen 2019

[@diabeticman2194]

I think it was Jimmy Havok (he was apart of the Cracker Barrel match at All Out 2019 as well)

[@TheMysticCastle42]

All Out 2022 a cut below the rest for me

[@LaughinggCattGiggles]

AEW pay-per-views are invariably quite good from time to time.

[@davefogle7747]

Gary and Gary Rule

[@7dream7scape7]

Nice! 👌👌

[@Crasky1992]

Jack was wrong. Something about the video being good though!

[@BillMoss97]

All Out 2020 can get in the freakin bin! One of the most boring ass ppvs I’ve ever watched

[@ChrisFactor]

Who else watches this whole video cover to cover?

[@roryalexanderm]

aew should give their pay per views better titles

[@ShowdeQuetzal]

I liked this video

[@andreweaster4700]

Ross or anyone? How come straight to hell isn't a thing anymore? have i missed something much love xx

[@verbal_backflips9493]

Cause it doesn't get views unfortunately

[@andreweaster4700]

@@verbal_backflips9493 thanks, that sucks so much

[@kadrianspruill9656]

Fight for the fallen ain’t a ppv

[@dansafc4492]

STOP SAYING HUCK

[@JawaPunter]

Ishii vs Kingston was literally just chops. Literally just guys smacking each other boring af.

[@kadrianspruill9656]

Fyter fest ain’t a ppv either

[@diabeticman2194]

It was in 2019; it as well as Fight for the Fallen become Dynamite specials since then

[@yadielenielbellecolon982]

🏆💞❤️😍

[@AT-il2ej]

They're all S tier. Why even bother ranking them

[@glennb6020]

Lol

[@phumudzoTM]

Bs AEW

[@TheMysticCastle42]

All NXT takeovers tier list (including UK takeovers) would be fun!

[@Brithulhu]

Jack was wrong, but the video is still really good.

[@3Leg2]

Jack was wrong, but the video was still really good

[@TheMysticCastle42]

All Out 2022 a cut below the rest for me