Suitcase Killer | Melanie McGuire Case Analysis

This video answers the question: Can I analyze the case of Melanie McGuire?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Subscribe to the Bella Grande Media Podcast: / @bellagrandemedia
Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
www.amazon.com...
Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/...
References:
caselaw.findla...
www.scribd.com...
abcnews.go.com...
www.nj.com/led...

[@Geebopgrabup]

I'm always amazed at these types of stories, wherein one partner murders the other in order to avoid (in part) shared custody. Now you get NO custody, and your poor children have one parent in prison and the other in the grave. I cannot wrap my head around that kind of shortsighted selfishness. Great analysis as always, Dr. G!

[@DonPeyote420]

There's a psychological/economical experiment called the ultimatum game. It goes like this: two parties interact anonymously and only once, so reciprocation is not an issue. The first player proposes how to divide a sum of money with the second party. If the second player rejects this division, neither gets anything. If the second accepts, the first gets her demand and the second gets the rest. Usually when people are offered less than 20% of the sum, they reject the offer and nobody gets anything - even though they would get free money anyway, they would rather the other party get nothing. People aren't always concerned with what they gain. They're concerned with what's "fair".

[@thereal4113]

I feel so sorry for the children. 🙁

[@rebekahtinker9486]

Selfish arrogant and utterly blinkered infatuation! She sounds like a woman that has got all she wanted on her terms and a husband that pampered her but it was not enough and she then crossed over into thinking she could do anything! A dangerous mix indeed.

[@Somegirl811]

Right, if you love your children, you don't kill the only other person they love and loves them unconditionally. I don't even badmouth my ex husband around my son, even though it is tempting sometimes. But what does she know about love, anyway? Remember she actually destroyed two families.

[@kathyclark8274]

How can any parent be oblivious to how the death of any parental figure in childhood will harrow up that child's soul for the rest of their life?

[@maureeningleston1501]

She should have just opted for divorce !!......no dismembering required.

[@bthomson]

Then you can let the lawyers do the cutting!

[@maureeningleston1501]

@@bthomson Lol....exactly.

[@Koozomec]

Or don't get married at all 🤔

[@RowanWarren78]

Well that's no fun.

[@tabittheha]

Melanie’s search terms essentially boiled down to: “I’m guilty… very, very guilty. How can I ensure the police know I’m super, duper, ULTRA guilty of murder? Bonus points if I can unnecessarily dismember my victim. 😎👉👉”

[@bthomson]

That's pretty cut and dried. No! No!

[@makepeace234]

🤣😆🤣

[@Somegirl811]

Haha! Well maybe it was necessary if he was super heavy. But 😂

[@ursodermatt8809]

she is really something

[@fetus2280]

Countless cases of which the killer had their search history utterly loaded with Guilty Guilty Guilty .... I dont get it .. How ignorant can you be?

[@serenerose8440]

"Concerns about being stuck in NJ are not uncommon for residents of NJ" 🤣😅👌🏾 Shade level: ultimate

[@michaelbohenek272]

I'm from NJ and it was great. Four seasons and great Diners and restaurants. Lakes, forests and nature. After 4 years in Syracuse New York for work, I ended up in the Los Angeles area of CA. So, of course I miss New Jersey and White Castle hamburgers, etc. But having gotten older I understand the benefit of not having winters and how that is being being able to do more outdoors.

[@rem97881]

I needed that laugh today. And he said it with such a straight face. 😂

[@BiancaBabe]

That lavendar is popping Doc! You're the most stable thing in my life atm. Funny not funny. Thank you for sharing your awesome videos! 🐿💚💚

[@derstoffausdemderjoghurtis]

Try daily meditation/prayers. Keep it up and you'll harvest soon.

[@dub2536]

@@derstoffausdemderjoghurtis I have heard many positive things regarding meditation!

[@bthomson]

Harvest? maybe reap the benefits? Strangely there is a Harvest Moon!

[@GastedFlabber]

I read, "You're the most stable thing in my ATM." 😂😂

[@samuelsprings7245]

@@derstoffausdemderjoghurtis Prayer to God*

[@abdisamamedia]

I always gather my friends and family around my phone here in Nairobi,Kenya to watch Dr Grande's speculations and informative analysis. Thank you Dr G!

[@darkcrystalmagik3369]

It's awesome to do things as a group/ community like that. You'd never see that many ppl watching a single cell phone to enjoy a show together or for any other reason here in the U.S.

[@humblescrumble737]

that sounds like a good time

[@CatsArePeopleToo]

I seriously can’t comprehend that even if someone were to commit “the perfect murder,” they then expect to just enter into a blissful state of unending happiness with their new partner, never to suffer from unspeakable nightmares or unwanted horrific images at any point thereafter. “Oh, that dismemberment? I prefer not to dwell on the past. Pass me that butcher knife, would you, sweetie?”😳

[@maryelizabeth6797]

Imagine knowing the other person killed someone but says ‘you’re safe, I would never harm you’. It’s like the Jerry Seinfeld comments about a cannibal not been able to get quality sleep.

[@fona33]

lmaoo 😭

[@snarlajeen5901]

​@@erdelegy maybe ulysses was a violent psychopath

[@KittenBones]

Narcissism is one hell of a drug

[@lindap.p.1337]

Reminds me of Don Wells not wanting to talk about his past transgressions.

[@singechamberlain2967]

"ignominious treachery of infidelity" - oh boy, I'm just not worthy

[@katelaloba8243]

Oooo I'll have to remember that to use oneday

[@skyro222]

Honestly had to Google that word 🤔 igno....who? Lol

[@christopherhogue2310]

@@skyro222 qa

[@BilgePump]

You ignoramous ignominious doer of treachery and infidelity. I bid you adieu good sir. (whew that was allot of big words looking up.)

[@MostHighDwelling]

ignominious: /ˌiɡnəˈminēəs/ deserving or causing public disgrace or shame. treachery: /ˈtreCH(ə)rē/ betrayal of trust; deceptive action or nature.

[@davidbrienlantry8760]

"Ignominious Treachery" is my favorite new phrase!

[@sekenamcmurren2217]

Haha Me too!🤣

[@tanyaroza1134]

Or a great band name !

[@ohdear2275]

I can't pronounce ignominious. Must practice.

[@betterbee1304]

"concerns about being stuck in New Jersey, are not uncommon for residents of New Jersey" Can attest as I live in North Idaho and am from New Jersey 🤣 thanks for the video, Dr Grande!!!

[@D0RYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY]

theres good things about NJ. for one, its not California.

[@johnkearney2513]

This story hit close to home. A close friend of mine was a patient where this nurse was employed. When the nurse was arrested my friend thought there was no way she could possibly have committed such an act. You never know what people are capable of.

[@johnkearney2513]

You are better off in Idaho. I’m a lifelong NJ resident. The only thing keeping me here is my family. Otherwise I would have bailed on NJ a long time ago.

[@betterbee1304]

@@johnkearney2513 I still have family in Camden County. I don't miss the traffic though!!! 🤣 Or the potholes...

[@Ceerads]

Idaho is far below NJ in so many ways. I’m not a Jerseyite, btw.

[@cleopatra791]

Hope you found my analyses of this topic better than tax free shopping 😂 brilliant

[@amandafranklin1914]

Using matching luggage for your husbands body parts. Really? This is the time to go to the thrift store and get the ugliest non-matching suitcases you can find!

[@Observe555]

I’m familiar with this case. She thought they would sink. She was wrong.

[@ED80s]

Can't believe she used her own luggage. May as well have left the ID tag with her name fill in while she was at it.

[@ghosttowntomato]

Not funny. An innocent man was dismembered

[@wavyremix]

@@ED80s It was luggage he would've taken with him when he packed and left. That was her claim.

[@melisentiapheiffer3034]

It was his suitcases. It belonged to him, not her. Don't be stupid 😮

[@gdubs1693]

She kinda favors Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio on the younger pictures.

[@Obladgolated]

"She had a face... that would let her get away..."

[@JennyT101]

"Undoubtedly that will be a time of much celebration. She turns 100, that's special....." The dead pan delivery nearly made me spit out my coffee laughing. As for tax free shopping, all day everyday. I live in Oregon!

[@elavke5441]

Don't pay taxes there?

[@anonymousstrangeness7348]

@@elavke5441 No sales tax is charged on shopping in Oregon, but I have heard that Oregon property owners pay higher property taxes than most other states. ( I've heard stuff about Oregon as I grew up in Northern Calif.).

[@EarlGray007]

I don't know how he says that with a straight face all the time! 😆

[@elavke5441]

@@anonymousstrangeness7348 oh okay. Did you hear bad things about Oregon while growing up?

[@elavke5441]

@@EarlGray007 dry sense of humor.

[@pennyc7064]

Dr.Grande, your comment about how some people do really well in their professional life but suck in their personal life. This is so true. I've seen this with coworkers. Maybe you can do a video on this topic and explain why this is so. Can this have roots in childhood and our upbringing?

[@ghosttowntomato]

Simple: One is easy, the other is hard.

[@DirtySanchez943]

Both r hard af...

[@Mary-momof8]

You'd think by now, people would realize the odds of getting away with murder are not in their favor. Yet, time and again, the murderer feels he/she will succeed. Melanie left a trail that could only point to her as the killer. For someone so well educated, she made some pretty dumb mistakes.

[@sexyskittles6822]

What??? There are millions of unsolved murders!!!! But you cant just murder who you want..you gotta murder who you can get away with

[@lyndrasangabriel8948]

You have a point there Mary 👍

[@ED80s]

@@sexyskittles6822 spouses are always considered as suspects. Killing your spouse while having an affair, you pretty much have an arrow pointed at your head.

[@Jimmy911ism]

Such a perfect trail that it looks like she was framed.

[@Mary-momof8]

@@Jimmy911ism for what motive?

[@TheKatieLea]

0% chance he's the first person killed for trying to get someone to move to Virginia Beach

[@wintercomesearly]

Pardon my ignorance but is it worse than Jersey?

[@craeddock]

What happened to my birth town? people still hate rowdy sailors?

[@LDiamondz]

You are definitely right about that. I lived in both states. Lived right on the Eastern Shore Va when/where this happened. Well, where the body washed up.

[@ivangreat6606]

Do you mean new jersey, Virginia beach is an awsome beach own near Potomac great crap fishing

[@joedokes7710]

"So easily intoxicated by the fleeting pleasures and ignominous treachery of infidelity." Very poetic.

[@olgatrilogymartin3143]

Lol 😆

[@natalielawyerchick]

If there’s anything this channel has taught me, it’s that cheating and excessive drinking can lead to some very bad things

[@penelopehughes-jones5265]

Sometimes I have a hard time forgiving myself for things I've got wrong. I'm just back from visiting my dear old Dad in hospital, berating myself for the last few years where illness and shame for my own uselessness made me see less of my Dad than before. I put this video on and remembered that, at my most useless moments, at least I never drugged, killed or dismembered him. Thank you, Dr Grande.🙏

[@bthomson]

We are all guilty of not doing as much as we can. Pat yourself on the back for doing what you do!

[@penelopehughes-jones5265]

@@bthomson Bless you, Bruce, that’s awfully kind. You definitely deserve one for that, bless you.😭🙏🖖

[@annebruecks7381]

We can only do the best we can everyday, and some days we fall short of our best. As long as you wake up every new day and try again, that’s all that is asked of us! Don’t be too hard on yourself, dear!

[@annebruecks7381]

Bonus points for not drugging, killing, or dismembering anyone, of course 🤣

[@penelopehughes-jones5265]

@@annebruecks7381 Hehehe! Thanks Anne! That's as funny as your other message is kind and both are much appreciated. I do try to remember that I was useful prior to being struck down, it's just comparing the before and after, even though I'd understand anyone else in that situation, I can't forgive myself. I think most of us are harder on ourselves than we are on others. The thing is it is counterproductive as it saps the energy in the now, you know? Maybe I should focus on these drugging/killing/dismember ing cases, in order to create a more positive comparison?! Thank God for Dr Grande! Very best to you and yours and many thanks for being so kind.🤗🙏🥰

[@julievorensky8250]

Hope she makes it to 101 just 2 days b4 her release! FYI, at trial, the gambling evidence only showed that he gambled legally and was at that time ahead. The defense tried to exaggerate the level of his gambling. As for his felony, it was for trying to lie in one of his car-related convictions. He actually wasn't a reprobate at all. I agree w/you that she's 100% guilty. It's only her "persona" (nurse, good-looking) that baffles some people but killers come in all styles.

[@MrDizz]

Thank you!!! All of the negative stories about Bill McGuire came from his wife Melanie including the story about his alleged “gambling problem.” People that knew Bill McGuire, realized that she was painting a false narrative of Bill and so did the jury. Without a doubt they put the right person in prison! Thank you Dr. Todd (and you too Julie) for nailing it!

[@kimberlygould5659]

Ugh! That woman was NEVER good looking

[@sammy3712]

I was thinking the same thing, how can people be so smart as far as having great education and jobs and earning good money yet be so stupid and evil. Boggles my mind 😣

[@jesussaves7973]

They have no common sense

[@derstoffausdemderjoghurtis]

Bcs school checks compliance, not your skills, knowledge nor spirit.

[@recardo5862]

You will never understand what a person is going through in their life not because they have a good paying job or their life seems perfect.I agree with your statement people who do these kind of stuff are evil and they should face justice.

[@TheGrmany69]

Schooling is NOT education, you dummy.

[@jesussaves7973]

@@TheGrmany69 that was not very nice

[@BurroGirl]

Omg you were ON it with this video Dr. Grande - I did find your analysis better than tax-free shopping AND I learned a new word - ignominious! "Ignominious treachery" - wow!!!

[@The_Red_Pill__]

I come here for entertainment, education and to improve my sarcasm skills. 😅😂☺️

[@MolyBDenum-lh3wy]

With the frequency which he releases videos, I sometimes think that Dr. Grande would in fact like to diagnose someone instead of just speculating about what could be happening in a situation like this! 🤔

[@wrmlm37]

He gets to do THAT in his dayjob;) I get the impression he still mentors psychologists and social workers, as well as his own client list. That's WHY I secretly believe there are 2 Dr. Grandes. And that EVEN HIS WIFE and family havent twigged to it yet;)

[@LDiamondz]

@@wrmlm37 No. In a video he did recently, he said he no longer does any of those things. This channel is his job.

[@TheTam0613]

Why on Earth would she use her own computer to search for terms that immediately cast the guilt directly on her??? Thank you for your effort in producing all these videos, Dr. Grande 💜 (I love that shirt on you!)

[@LDiamondz]

She should have searched on what to do AFTER a crime, too. What a super genius, she was. 😤

[@Ceerads]

She’s not alarmingly intelligent.

[@TheTam0613]

@@Ceerads Lolol. Yes, that's very true 👍

[@Koozomec]

Book and school smart =/= street smart

[@peggypeggy4137]

I was looking for this comment. It astounds me the amount of research people do on the internet before they commit a crime. Even something as serious as murder. This happens every day and the dumb criminal gets caught every time.🙃

[@elainearchibald9020]

Amazing story Dr. Grande, thank you for your analysis! I think Melanie was smart and planned the whole thing long before it actually happened. She certainly deserves to be in prison until she turns 101! Evil hides within her. Divorce would have been too easy, she knew she would lose custody and finances if she went that way. I can't imagine the horror that her children had to endure. TFS :)

[@a.harrington1634]

When Dr. Grande calls out a murderer who dumped bodies in your home town! This happened when I was in high school, and it was so creepy.

[@rebel4466]

The delivery of your jokes is just perfect. Absolutely no reaction whatsoever while throwing all available shade in her direction. Had some good laughs again

[@dub2536]

Google" "Can the police find my search terms" LMAO.

[@Ceerads]

Unless an enemy of Melanie was excellent at framing her, she’s guilty - and pretty stupid, too: using her luggage, towels, etc., in disposing of her husband. Doesn’t she know that the spouse/partner is always Suspect 1, and she’ll be investigated?

[@DirtySanchez943]

She did everything she could, she gave her best, can u blame her???

[@Kash_Monay]

I would love if you could do a video analyzing the 2019 Northern BC murders. It’s a really strange case of two teenage boys killing 5 people and going on the run across Canada, eventually ending up across the country with the hopes of stealing a boat and crossing the ocean. They ended up taking their own lives.

[@lyndrasangabriel8948]

By killing themselves is an act cowardliness.

[@Anita-k]

"...I hope you found my analysis better than tax-free shopping!..." Hahahahaha, I'm dead, this joke caught me totally off guard - but it's highly appreciated, when discussing such a tragic case of a wife (and mother) senselessly murdering her husband and orphaning their kids, who're now having their father dead and their mom in prison forever. Some people really suck with their problem solving abilities!

[@bryanzvolanek8129]

Finally. Out of the blue and years later I know whose half of a body we found on Fisherman's Island belongs to. We had finished nest searches for gulls/terns/peregrine's. We split in half afterwards to beach comb for dolphin and seal skulls. One of the girls found the gruesome suitcase. Now we know who was in there.

[@leahdresser2290]

That's insane!!! I'm sorry that you and your family had to go through that, although it's a heck of a story to tell!

[@christinabernat6709]

Seriously? Holy God!

[@wrmlm37]

Holy sh¡tster! How weird for you!

[@wintercomesearly]

How horrifying. And you never knew the identity til now?

[@micheleparker8123]

😳😲

[@rebekahtinker9486]

Your videos have enlightened me that intelligence, conscience, a person's standing in society/class or even those that love them... cannot stop someone committing the most evil, selfish and heinous crimes and atrocities against another human being. A terrible choice made that nuclear bombs families and makes us that bit more saddened by the depth of human depravity. I hope you experience people that make you have hope for humanity too Dr Grande. Thank you again for your insights.

[@johnfraser8116]

I can see combining murder and tax free shopping as a reasonable combination for smart consumers.

[@thegreenmanofnorwich]

I do love when you get deadpan funny, like with the bit about search terms

[@pillarandground7949]

People always throwing shade on New Jersey. Friends, it’s called the Garden State for a reason. On all kinds of “most desirable places to live in America” lists. I’m opposed to misdiagnoses of NJ!

[@bthomson]

Good thing you don't live in Arkansas!

[@christinabernat6709]

Pillar and ground - I know, right? But maybe we should let these insults continue, to prevent more people from moving there!

[@SarahDunlap]

The NJ tea spills have been an ongoing theme in Dr G's vids. We are talking about true crime after all! Haha

[@elavke5441]

@@christinabernat6709 I wouldn't move there. My neighbors are from there and they have no plans of moving back there

[@elavke5441]

@@SarahDunlap I don't get it

[@auggiedoggiesmommy1734]

PLEASE look at the case of Neil Entwistle who murdered his wife and 9 month old baby. I’d LOVE your take on him and his actions after their murders…. totally depraved.

[@BucketHeadianHagg]

It's cute how Dr Todd always opens with "Hello, this is Dr Grande" as if he doesnt have almost 1M subs who totally know who he is!

[@BucketHeadianHagg]

@@curbozerboomer1773 A Boy Named Sue!!

[@Throatzillaaa]

I don't get out much nowadays so I actually respond "hi Dr grande!" out loud 🗣

[@BucketHeadianHagg]

@@Throatzillaaa omg, how cute! Me too!! 😁😛 (and hes not waering a mask!)

[@vball19]

Would you consider giving your take on historical European monarchs or nobility that have committed crimes, sometimes in the name of state and church? Elizabeth Bathory who is an infamous noblewoman that was a serial killer would be interesting, as would all of the sufferings of Protestants and Catholics who were the wrong religion than that of their monarchs.

[@lilafeldman8630]

Or, some of the Protestant reformers, themselves. Some of the greatest theologians had mental health issues.

[@m.f.richardson1602]

Always interesting. True crime has always been my favorite. Love the humor❤🇺🇸 I agree with your analysis. Peace

[@natew5593]

Can you do a video on Sleep Paralysis? Definitely an interesting field that I feel doesn’t get a lot of attention. Love the channel!

[@winros]

I was just talking about that I experienced that at least three times in my life! That a horrible feeling! You know where you are you know you're home you just cannot move your body however, someone said, concentrate on moving your pinky!

[@thinktwice8860]

I think that Melanie was innocent…of the charge of having a normal range of intelligence. Many people think that people with low to no empathy must be brilliant! I’m thinking that is unproven. 🤤

[@johnfraser8116]

Anyone who could clean a crime scene that well is welcome to take on my apartment. :)

[@christinabernat6709]

Good one! Just remember to not leave any living entities (humans - including yourself, pets and maybe even plants) in your apartment while they clean! 😁🤣😁🤣👀👀👀👀👀🧐🧐🧐 🚫🚫🚫🚫🚫🚫🚫🚫🚫🚫🚫

[@mickeyphillips6603]

I work in Woodbridge, and read all about this case in the newspapers. Investigators said that while examining the apartment no fingerprints were found anywhere in the residence. People have claimed that she scrubbed the place because she was moving to the new house. I don’t believe that.

[@SarahDunlap]

Maybe she did it Dexter style

[@sharondawson-coates8531]

She worked in a hospital so she knew what type of cleaning liquid to use just not so smart as to wipe her shoes

[@cottontails9003]

John your comment was great ,it had me in stichtes from laughing so much.

[@Cordoba82]

"Ignominious Treachery", ooh using big words Dr. Grande. Now, seriously, you have provided us another great analysis as always. You have spoiled us beyond rotten. Thanks.

[@Megan.eco-Instinct]

*_ignominious treachery of infidelity_* Ignominious is on my *favorite* words list. I love it used here...like this. Words and phrasing is literally awesome to me and this is a great one! Anyway, incredible story; I hadn't heard of this one. With all that rage, perhaps there wasn't an accomplice but I feel there likely was. I am sure they looked long and hard at the doctor she was having an affair with.

[@wchurchillflippingthebird3545]

On the subject Dr Grandes one liners, Have u watched his Zodiac killer vid?? He's talking about the Author of one of the letters the cop's/media received, sorry I forgot, I don't wanna mess it up, I'll be back with full transcript 🙂🙂

[@wchurchillflippingthebird3545]

(Hiya pal, I'm back) it's his Zodiac Killer vid at 6:36 and goes like, "here we see our 1st look at the ZKs ability to murder grammar & he didn't have any respect for the rules of grammar" Probably doesn't sound as good, because it's not first hand🙂

[@cottontails9003]

Brilliant analysis Dr Grande .I don't get why people murder their partner. My husband and l had this discussion before, we were married .if one of us fell out of love,we would leave ,and try too remain friends, for the sake of the children. Thank you Dr Grande, great topic.

[@kaze_cat]

Great point 🤔…I believe everyone should have the same conversation with their soon to be significant others. Maybe a lot less cases like these would occur .

[@emjones7698]

I would always rather be watching a Dr. Grande video than shopping tax-free!

[@kayhawkins5925]

She wasn't very good at packing a suitcase lightly.

[@cottontails9003]

Kay that was a funny comment. Thank you so much.

[@enigmag9538]

I haven't been watching Dr. Grande's videos for very long but have become addicted to them and i get a bit cranky if I'm not able to watch at least 1 per day. He's very thorough and i love the subtle dry humor.

[@rejaneoliveira5019]

It’s truly amazing how seemingly intelligent people are willing to destroy their lives by acting on their emotions. I think this case speaks to the power of emotions, some people may be able to refrain from acting on it, but many do not. On another note, being a resident of NJ I can attest to the fact of feeling stuck here.😒Although, Virginia Beach is not that much better either, I lived there too.😄 Thank you for the analysis Dr. Grande, this was way better that tax free shopping.❤️

[@PHlophe]

when i was growing in Germany. My neighbour literally next door . murdered her kids and killed herself just so the partner won't have shared custody. she was a Phd candidate. so this widespread.

[@rejaneoliveira5019]

@@PHlophe That’s horrific.😰

[@ghosttowntomato]

What does intelligence have to do with compassion??? I sense your relationships have been quite dull…

[@MegOtto4268]

Looking awesome in lavender Dr. Grande. Excellent video. Melanie’s computer search😱. Your response 😂. Your sarcasm 🏆. First to last line in video…👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@DerangedMerger]

Dr. Grande, you almost killed me with the last sentence. I nearly died laughing 😂☠🤣

[@dianeolson8449]

My daughter has that concern about being stuck in New Jersey!

[@LDiamondz]

Can't she move to another state?

[@christinabernat6709]

I know! She really wanted to be a doctor but her dad was too old fashioned and thought girls should only be nurses... BUT as a nursing student she never got to cut up a real cadaver ... so this was her chance to get that medical school experience she had soooo longed for! (I am finding it necessary to joke about this case because otherwise it all just does not fit into the mind! Soooo unreal!) And were the children possibly by her lover? Did they test for parentage or just assume they were her husband's?

[@marymorris4779]

This was one of his great analysis but he forgot she’s sneaky, manipulative, arrogant and self focus.

[@maureeningleston1501]

Delighted you're covering this case Dr Grande thank you so much.

[@brianpratt3224]

And I assumed this was about a woman that murdered suitcases.

[@bthomson]

You know the old "saw" about assuming!

[@kathyclark8274]

That's hilarious!!! 😂

[@LDiamondz]

You're too much. Love it! 😁

[@annal7364]

Wait, Delaware is home to tax-free shopping and Dr. Grande? Here I come. Just let me know what toppings you like on your pizza Dr. G, for when I creepily stop by with a slice for you and your wife! 😆😜 🍕

[@erikparent8176]

That's an inside joke! 🍕🍕🍕🤣

[@annal7364]

@@erikparent8176 It is. 😉

[@LDiamondz]

Ooo that stalker he had. 😉

[@annal7364]

@@LDiamondz haha, poor Dr. G!

[@recardo5862]

I like the way in the video he gives a little joke saying when she reaches the age of 100 she can celebrate her 100th bd and get release the year after😂Dr.Todd plz

[@omayrasdemesne]

"How to commit murder" Geez. be careful what pictures you take of yourself and send to people, be careful what you google

[@dianabeurman364]

No kidding

[@d_hurl]

Ah yes, the intoxicating shopping in Slower Lower/All of Delaware. Nice trip before discarding your husband's remains.

[@LDiamondz]

lol. Somebody from DelaNOware poking fun at NJ. I had to chuckle at that one. 😁

[@Geebopgrabup]

Dr. Grande's videos > tax-free shopping 😂

[@ED80s]

If you are terrified of your husband, last thing you do is drive to where he is and prank him by moving his car.

[@BurroGirl]

LMAO!!!! I haven't watched your video yet but I know this case and when I read "Suitcase Misuse " I was truly lol!!

[@AMM3.]

Please analyze the case of Gabriel Wortman (or what might be happening in a situation like this lol). he went on a mass shooting here in Canada in April 2020, it was the deadliest in Canadian history. he dressed as RCMP during the shooting, killing 22 people. Very scary while he was on his rampage.. would love to hear your thoughts!!

[@LDiamondz]

That's a great suggestion.

[@AMM3.]

@@LDiamondz thanks.. it's a crazy case.. he didn't just go shooting.. he went through rural areas, killed people hiding in their homes, set fire to most crime scenes.. over a 13 hour period, covering over 30 miles dressed as police, driving a police car replica.. we don't see much gun violence here.. especially not like that.. I have a degree in criminology.. but I can barely wrap my head around it

[@LDiamondz]

@@AMM3. I remember hearing about this case. It was horrifying. That he wore the RCMP uniform made it even more disturbing, somehow. Didnt he use the fake police car to flag down motorists, and then shoot them? How horrible. He killed himself, too, right? Coward. I wonder what set him off. It's an odd case, That's for sure.

[@AMM3.]

@@LDiamondz I think police actually killed him in the end, and yes the whole dress like a cop/ drive a replica cop car was a huge problem.. police officers almost shot each other, and then they had to warn the public that he was impersonating an officer.. so nobody knew who to trust in the police response.. huge scary mess

[@AMM3.]

@@LDiamondz hey! I just noticed Dr Grande already analyzed this case 😂 I'm not sure how I missed it (maybe I'm not a true fan! 😭) but he covered it about 5 months ago.. great perspective as usual!

[@dextermorgan1]

Do people actually believe they're going to get away with things like this?

[@christinabernat6709]

You took the words right out of my mouth! But the other day I heard in a vid a statistic that police solve only 3% (I believe I heard that correctly) of all their cases, which made my jaw drop ..... I believe that applied to all cases, not just murders, but still, that probably leaves a LOT of room for characters contemplating murder to think they will be one of the ones that WILL get away with it...

[@dextermorgan1]

@@christinabernat6709 I hope that's not true. Exactly like you said, people like this will think they're able to get away with murder, and anything else they can get themselves into. It's just crazy to me that people actually believe they can outsmart all of the Detectives, Scientists, Forensic techs etc. Hell, people are now being caught because of TV shows. It's actually really sad. The upside is, we wouldn't have all these wonderful videos if nobody ever broke the law! Lol

[@christinabernat6709]

@@dextermorgan1 so true. It's a bizarre world. Thank heaven for the many wonderful moments.

[@seanbaugh3239]

*Dr. Grande....* I think the number of views on an objective analysis of the infamous Bill Cosby saga would be "killer" Although the subject matter may be considered highly controversial by some, you don't seem to be the type to shy away from difficult discussions of emotionally charged topics. 🤔 *"NUFF SAID"™*

[@sekenamcmurren2217]

Facts!🗣

[@annalisegiovanni7032]

Speaking of bill Cosby, it reminded me that the 1st MAN has come forward about a sexual assault by R Kelly.

[@annalisegiovanni7032]

I think that'd be fuckin awesome if he covered the bill Cosby shit. Wuts y'all's opinion on dat shit anyways? I'll admit dat at 1st I put ALL THE BLAME ON HIM, but then I started thinkin hmmm, if ANYBODY invites you up to their hotel room for a "Business meeting" @ 2am, NOTHING about dat smells good. Especially bc he's a celebrity. I dunno. I hope I didn't offend y'all at all.

[@LDiamondz]

That's a great video suggestion. I hope he does it. He might not want to do it due to the nature of the case, though.

[@wchurchillflippingthebird3545]

Also I think from a British perspective "Jimmy Saville" he allegedly hoodwinked a Nation, he wasn't just a sex predator, he had (& I'm not diagnosing him) Psychopathic traits going on all over the place, attacking even disabled orphan's in state care & openly admit it in a sort of (did/didn't he just say/mean that) confession, twisted guy clearly, everyone loved him even HMQ Elizabeth II & PM Thatcher, this story could actually provide Dr Grande with material for a mini series or an extended episode, as it spanned over half a century & so many influential folk's were all took in.

[@marilynmcmahon5932]

I wonder what happens to the children in cases like to.

[@LDiamondz]

I always wonder the same thing. I wish that information was included in the videos.

[@kkilliyyahh]

I love a cut and dry case, when the killer presents themselves on a platter with an apple in their mouth.

[@fishface123ism]

So I always thought Melanie far-set eyes made her look like an Alien Lizard Humanoid...I think this is why the good Dr. Grande did this story really.

[@SharonH11100]

Ha ha ~ a good New Jersey ding, but nowadays every State deserves it. (Said by a Californian) 🙋🏼‍♀️

[@cecilr7986]

Hello Dr. Grande, can you analyze the murder of Scott Fricker and Buckley Kuhn-Fricker of Reston, VA? They were both shot and killed by their teenaged daughter's boyfriend (Nicholas Giampa,19). The Frickers heard noise in their daughters bedroom at approximately 5am. When they opened the daughters door and demanded Giampa leave he shot and killed both of them. It was a horrific and senseless tragedy and I would appreciate your analysis.

[@kangjunga2185]

Documentary “Deadly obsession” on KZbin is about Charlie Brandt. I want to watch your analysis on him. This is a mysterious one.

[@maureeningleston1501]

That's a great suggestion.

[@karenovalasiti7538]

To this day Melanie has not ever been curious about who murdered her husband. That speaks VOLUMES. If someone murdered and dismembered your husband and you were locked up for it after 13 years you would expect her to be HORRIFIED THAT YOU WERE PAYING FOR SOMEONE ELSE"S CRIME. That would be all you'd think about. If she was innocent she would be HANGING ONTO THE DAY THE REAL KILLER GOT CAUGHT. She considers no such notion...................

[@JustDr.S]

Dr. Grande, August 29 through September 4 is National Overdose Awareness Week. Perhaps you could do a video on that subject? You have a ton of subscribers. You could help a lot of people, and teach some others about this problem. Thanks for reading this. 💜💜💜💜💜

[@JustDr.S]

I saw E.P. had a comment in here. Hmm. It disappeared! 😪

[@winterbalm]

Dr. Grande please analyze Seinfeld characters

[@bthomson]

Isn't it a story about nothing?

[@winterbalm]

@@bthomson nothing and everything

[@biscuitthecat8285]

I thought they did find some evidence in one of the cars-it was on the floor on the drivers side. I believe it was small body tissue from the victim. Investigators believe it came from her shoe. I am puzzled as to where she cut him up-I don’t think she could have cleaned up that good after cutting up a body.

[@kaze_cat]

Hmmm, just wondering…as a nurse she would know how to drain blood from a deceased person. If that was done (in the bathtub), I believe dismemberment may be a lot less messy. Plus, she knows anatomy for certain “cuts.” I know this sounds horrible, but just thought about what you said and that is what came to mind.

[@kimberlygould5659]

Human Sawdust

[@Slytherinarmy]

Bill was known to get aggressive with Melanie, him usually being known to start arguments and known by others to have quite the temperament, such as him shoving that laundry dryer sheet in her mouth. So, if was abusive towards her physically if not verbally/mentally. In her mind she would probably see her murdering her husband as an act of self defense and may have worried for her's and their childrens' lives. However, with all of the evidence provided, there is no doubt that she murdered him and did so to get him out of the picture so she could go on with her life and continue her affair/relationship with Bradley Miller.

[@AedanGUnit]

I watched her trial in it’s entirety. She was guilty as hell and tried to play the damsel in distress with her attorney. Despicable. She’s exactly where she belongs IMO.

[@henrybalke8510]

Yeppers. …..

[@tricianorling9898]

I knew her. I lived with bill and she was there daily. She did many bizarre things. I was afraid of her. I moved out in the middle of the night after she smeared menstrual blood on my toilet seat. The following day she put a fork in the microwave on her way out the door. She was DANGEROUS back in 94. Can confirm.

[@mrs.reluctant4095]

Lol... Over here we say "Pack up your husband* and go on a trip somewhere" but I think this isn't what this woman was up to by using her suitcase.... * invite him to go with you

[@winros]

Ok .. Killing someone but to cut them up! It's so despicable you have to be such a sick person! I could never comprehend that she's like that ICE MAN!

[@kristinesmart9932]

Thank you for posting this Doctor. I find it amazing how people can do the most heinous things, but still not take it a step further, and own up to their evil act. Who are they kidding? Who else would've done it? She's a very scary monster. No matter what one had done to their partner in life, no one deserves their life snuffed out without repercussions. I'm sad for Bill's parents and family. I had to edit this and add that Bill & M. had children. I forgot or didn't know about that from the news programs. They will suffer the most from their Mother's cold, thoughtless murder. Killing is bad enough, but they will deal with media scrutiny and nightmares from knowing their Father was mutilated and thrown away in the Atlantic. No words. Also, I notice you give your "stamp"of approval with your thumbnail photo mostly when you are complimented 🤔. Why do doctors lose their humility?

[@MrGazzara]

This was my reply: I get very upset when one of the two cheaters in an affair gets away with no consequence of cheating hiding lying and participates in breaking up a family. The punishment may not be severe, but there should be a consequence for their action.

[@aarondavis8943]

You put way too much emphasis on love affairs in your videos. It's lack of empathy that matters. Killers like Melanie McGuire would just as likely kill her parents to inherit their estate or kill her neighbour because she was sick of their company. The affair is not a critical factor.

[@Richard.Hybels]

This was a very interesting trial that was on TV at the time. I believe there was testimony that Bill was not losing money in his gambling endeavors.

[@janefrost1856]

In the UK we have a charming colloquialism bang to rights. I believe that Ms Maguire is definitely bang to rights, her behaviour shows that really she's as mad as a box of frogs.

[@kimberlygould5659]

Haha!!! Great comment

[@Onus6688]

Wow, for once we got excellent police work/crime scene investigation. Nice, glad they got her.

[@robertmurdock8164]

When a murder trial is conducted in the press is it any wonder there are so many falsely accused people in prison It’s easy to analyze behavior after the fact or crime has been committed When a person is accused every aspect of their behavior is recognized as proof of guilt or of a dark personality

[@girlygal098]

OMG. Even hiring a celebrity attorney didn't help.

[@annalisegiovanni7032]

If anybody in here is from Louisiana, my thoughts & prayers are with y'all🙏💖 I live in Houston so I know how devastating hurricanes are. Sending y'all love and healing vibes as well 🙏💖🙏💖🙏

[@bthomson]

Did I mention yet in this video that I ❤ Dr. Grande's fans!

[@i-chelevisionmusicalove5123]

I love your dry sense of humor woven into your informative, and intelligent analysis of these scenarios.

[@mickeyphillips6603]

I work in Woodbridge Twp. Everyday I pass by the place where they lived.

[@LDiamondz]

I grew up in Woodbridge. Lived there most of my life. Small world. What apartments were they? I can't picture them living in King's Gardens or Cloverleaf.

[@mickeyphillips6603]

@@LDiamondz Woodbridge Center Plaza Apartments

[@HandleHandled]

Doc G’s sense of humor so sharp I’m bleedin’!

[@tstjstlikecandy]

I would love for you to analyze Kanyes listening party for his Donda Album.

[@user-cs1un6sp1wRennata]

Yes, your analysis is excellent Dr. Grande, way much better than tax-free shopping ✌

[@emmanuelbeaucage4461]

the case remind me a joke from 'tango & cash': "great job for the arrest... no one could have guessed the husband that came of his house with a knife, cover in blood and screaming 'i killed my wife' did it..."

[@azaleasmart6455]

Great analysis. Thank you. It's hard to believe that this women used her own matching suitcases and towels. “A time for much celebration” 😂 love it.

[@beachboy0505]

The worst way is to be killed by a person you love. A person you never suspected. If you can be betrayed you will be betrayed. What ever you do with some one , ask them, present your proposals. You only live once.

[@Ceerads]

And what’s the best way to be killed, pray tell? 🤠

[@beachboy0505]

@@Ceerads respect 🙌, got me.

[@HMGarth]

When dismembering your victim's body, never forget -- STYLE, FASHION, CO-ORDINATION! Keep that luggage matchy-matchy, murderers! 👌😁👍😉

[@ED80s]

Imagine when they first bought the luggage...never imagining One day he would be cut up in pieces and thrown in that same luggage.