Testing 8 of the Best Color Correctors on the Market | Demos, Swatches, Comparisons, and Reviews

[@TooMuchTash]

What do we think of the 'gloop test'??

[@tanyab78]

I'm still confused by it, but it's a great video otherwise!

[@Tracylyn42]

The entire comparisons were amazing for me. I appreciate the gloop test because I don’t like mine to be so called gloopy. Lol so it really helped me

[@losermillie]

I love it! So helpful to k ow the texture!! And cute

[@MelissaPaccagnella]

Oh my god girl, I had to stop everything to say THIS HAIR COLOUR LOOKS PERFECT ON YOU

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you so much, Melissa! ❤️

[@IAmAndjelka]

Agreed 😍

[@fussbrain9161]

Love finding smaller beauty KZbinrs y’all are always honest and so in depth in the reviews 🥰

[@TooMuchTash]

❤️❤️❤️

[@SH-wk6po]

Wow the effort that went into this video!! 👏👏👏 Thank you for the shade comparisons in different lighting (both applied to your face and on your hands), price differences, and the gloop tests lol!! 😆 It’s definitely tricky when a fave is suddenly discontinued or a brand becomes too controversial to buy from. I am also in the process of trying to find a blush shade that’s the closest to my all time fave.

[@nataliamruz]

I would have loved a ranking!!! great video!!

[@TooMuchTash]

Oooh I don’t know why I didn’t think to do that!

[@earlgreyknits1178]

Thank you so much for this video! I’m in my 30s and never had to worry about under eye circles until recently. This video was so incredibly informative and I really appreciate you taking the time it took to test, film and edit as well as making the financial commitment to purchasing all of these products for us. Wishing you the best!

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you so much! 💖💖

[@Reiliferei]

Such a great video! I always wanted someone to do a video. I have a lot of veins under my eyes so I've been wondering which is best. The Tarte, Pixi & CT look the best, the most coverage of the vein & darkness but still look nice alone. Thank you Natasha!

[@Tracylyn42]

Definitely exactly what I was searching for today and you did an AMAZING JOB on the comparisons. I really appreciate all the work you put into this video. Thank you so much

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you so much, Tracy! 💖

[@staceyb3007]

This video was exactly what I needed. Would also love to see how each performs side by side with concealer over top. Amazing video. Thanks!

[@linduzka]

I appreciate that your reviews are so thorough. Now I know which one to get for myself.

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you! I really wanted to highlight the slight differences between each one! 😊♥️

[@jenellejensen5393]

I've used the Pixi one for years and I love it. I've tried others such as the Tarte, and Bobbi Brown. I always go back to the Pixi. I'm intrigued in trying one of the pinker-toned ones, though!

[@lena7623]

I've been using the LA Girl concealer in pink and it's been working alright for me, but now I'm very curious about the Flower one. Even my undereyes are greasy, so something a little drier is something I appreciate.

[@Greeneyedgeny7]

Ive used so many different ones and I always go back to my Tarte! Its the best for me personally

[@TheStyleStumbler]

This was a great video! Thanks for putting in all the time and effort to be so thorough. My favorite has long been the Tarte corrector, but now that I’ve almost finished it, I’ve been comparing it to a couple of other correctors I just happened to have: the one from Kokie, from Becca/Smashbox, and from Bobbi Brown. So far the Tarte is still my favorite because I like the high coverage - but I do wish the finish wasn’t quite as radiant. The finish of the Smashbox corrector is far too dewy, emphasizing my undereye hollows, and the Kokie is a bit too dark for me in the winter. The Bobbi Brown one was too dry, so I wasn’t a huge fan of the finish. But the way you described the finish of the Charlotte Tilbury corrector intrigued me. That sounds like it might be in my “Goldilocks” zone.

[@TooMuchTash]

Hi, Stephanie! I love the "Goldilocks” zone 😂 that's a great way to describe it! ❤️

[@barbaraquevedo7528]

I've been looking for a video like this for ages! Thank you so much for this precious video 🙏🏻

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you for watching, Barbara! 💖

[@alexandra109]

I’ve been on the hunt for a great color corrector for the past 2+ years. About 1 month ago I settled on trying the Flower Beauty. I like it, but it is too stiff a formula for me and not moisturizing enough. I ended up mixing it with the Undone concealer and now love the consistency.

[@LizzyC-nf1sv]

You look so pretty with your natural hair color!

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you!! ❤️

[@maryamski]

Such a helpful video and her hair colour is so gorgeous ❤

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you so much! ❤️

[@SlackSlackSlackSlack]

Great vidéo !! I was looking a replacement for my CT one. I think that I will try the Pixi one.

[@eligefashion]

I just got the CT in shade 1 Fair and I really really like it! I think it could have more coverage but its buildable so I think it does a great job, I have oily skin so I need products that perform well. I love the size of this component and I absolutely love using it!!

[@TooMuchTash]

Same, I'm loving it the more I use it! ❤️

[@chelseafretz]

I NEED TO KNOW WHAT BLUSH YOU'RE WEARING OOOMG 🥺😍

[@TooMuchTash]

I'm so sorry, I wish I remembered! 😭😭

[@blogreaderyvo6558]

I tested out the corrector by Catrice. In came in store for fall and I think it is very similar to the one by NYX before they diacontinued it.

[@TooMuchTash]

Oh I didn't realize they had a color corrector! There are quite a few things I'd like to try from Catrice, maybe I should place an order soon and add their corrector. Thanks for the recommendation! ❤️

[@MsTiffichic]

@@TooMuchTash did you happen to try the Catrice one? I found this video looking for a comparison of Pixi and Catrice, and was so happy to see your face again! I followed you for years before taking a big break from Beauty YT. :)

[@FullxMoonxMelody]

Your descriptions and visuals were sooo helpful! Thank you❤❤

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you for watching! 💜

[@MODELBODYINTL]

This is extremely helpful! Thank you!

[@NoFeArChiC2]

Extremely well done on the video. I really appreciate all the details and comparisons given, thanks so much!

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you!! 💜💜

[@BrookelynnesBeautyCorner]

Brilliant video. I’ve ordered the Revolution one and can’t wait to try it ❤❤

[@TooMuchTash]

Thanks! I hope the Makeup Revolution one works well for you! ❤️

[@BrookelynnesBeautyCorner]

@@TooMuchTash you’re welcome and thanks 💖❤️

[@laurendempers1315]

Such a well done video especially the closeups, I could actually see the difference in products on your face! Curious, have you tried the Bobbi Brown corrector? It’s one of the OG correctors and has a great shade range. Thinking about getting it bc the Pixi is too dark for me. But am now considering the CT as well!

[@TooMuchTash]

Thanks! I haven't, but I've heard people raving about it for years, so it's stood the test of time! ❤️

[@thecrystallibrarian]

Love this video! I am looking to replace my discontinued color corrector and purchased the Smashbox Becca one. It is a great product, however I am having trouble with the texture and "wet" look. This video gave me some better options. I would like to mention that Chanel has a new one you might want to try for fun if you can find a sample.

[@TooMuchTash]

Oooh thanks for the recommendation, Andrea! And I'm glad the video was helpful ❤️❤️

[@suzannetaylor6285]

My holy Grail is the Smashbox x becca, I purchased both the light and medium and depending on the time of year a rotate between the two of them or mix them together. It looks beautiful under the eyes it brightens and conceals the darkness that I have underneath my eyes and to me I haven’t found another color corrector that beats it

[@TooMuchTash]

It is a really nice product! I like the idea of buying 2 shades of your favorite formula so you can customize the shade, thanks for sharing! ❤️

[@lavayuki]

I like the Becca and Sigma the best. Others I like are the Nars and Bobbi Brown colour correctors

[@aujzahra]

This was an amazing video but I have to stop, and tell you, you're sooo beautiful 🥺💕 also this hair color looks so pretty on you, can you tell me which one is it and what should I tell my hairdresser if I need this one?! please, pretty please 🥺🥺

[@TooMuchTash]

Thanks! I have been bleaching my hair for years and asked my hairdresser to make it match my roots (a dark, ashy blonde) so that it would look less apparent while I grew it out. My hair was a warm, yellow blonde to start. She put a glaze on my hair, but I'm sorry I don't remember more, it was a while ago! ❤

[@aujzahra]

@@TooMuchTash thank you 🥰♥

[@ashleypatrick2111]

Just fyi I have a corrector palette from nyx I’ve used for years. It has like 2 diff pink/peachy a green and I think 3 others included. I’m pretty sure it’s still sold at ulta

[@kaburzynski]

My favorite is the Bobbi Brown! Have you tried it? Your eyes look the best with the CT, it covered the most

[@TooMuchTash]

I haven't tried the Bobbi Brown one, but I always hear such good things about it!

[@SusieQ1971]

Have you tried Bobbi Brown's or Beauty Pie's color correctors? I have BB skin corrector stick in extra light bisque which goes on easy and blends easy, but I wish I would've gotten a darker shade. I was going off their website suggestion based on my skin tone but I saw a Sephora tutorial that said choose a color corrector that is just as dark peach or bisque as your undereye circle in order to properly neutralize it rather than just lighten it. So I'm going to try a darker shade next time. But I love the formula it is creamy and glides on and blends easier than any of the pot correctors. I got Beauty Pie's in their lightest shade and it did not completely cover but it brightened and was luminous like the Becca. It was difficult to spread and blend without using a silicone based primer or eye cream underneath. I too wish I would've gotten the medium more peachy shade instead, maybe it would've neutralized my dark blue/purple circles better. It definitely covers better than just concealer alone. I'd say out of all of the cc I have ever tried, the BB skin corrector stick is my favorite formula. I just wish it was fuller coverage and less expensive or has more product. You don't get very much for $30+. I got BP for only $15 due to 50% off sale. Thanks to your reviews I won't waste money on the C.T. or Sigma ones since neither are full coverage they won't be worth the $30 price tag to me.

[@TooMuchTash]

I haven't tried either but I'm interested in Beauty Pie! I'm sorry to hear it wasn't what you needed/ expected. ❤️

[@mh6107]

I’ve been looking for a new color corrector, thank you for your thorough reviews!

[@TheaIsabell]

Impressed by this video, and really usefull info! My first color corrector that I bought was the Charlotte Tilbury one, and I really liked it and used it up fully. What I really enjoyed was probably the color (fair) that I could put on without anything Else if I was in a hurry and just wanted a little brightness under my eyes Even if I was at my palest or a little tan. I then earlier this year bought the smashbox/BECCA one since that has been so hyped for years! Definitely more «wet» than CT, but also more pink and very light reflecting. Could have a lot to do with my undertone, but that one I more so use if I’m putting more makeup over it. It’s a little Too pink to where I can use it by itself all year, but definitely do the job and I do like it! Will however probably not repurchase it just because I have a more light warm undertone and it’s not as universal for when I have a tan due to the pinkiness, but will keep this video in mind for my next purchase 😍 Maybe I will go for the CT again (that btw looked so good on you in the footage I would say), but I also love testing new thing so maybe one of these other ones instead!

[@TooMuchTash]

I do the exact same thing with the Charlotte Tilbury one! It's close enough to my skintone that it isn't too brightening, while the Becca one would look weird without concealer and powder on top ❤️

[@bellajfk]

This was one of the best videos on correctors on yt .i have purpleblue undereyes and hollow under my eyes .can you please give me advice on which one to choose? Someone made my picture the other day and i was shocked how my undereyes look😂 thanks❤!

[@TooMuchTash]

Thanks! For purple/ blue, hollow under eyes, I would recommend a orange-peachy color corrector with higher coverage, like the Pixi one! ❤️

[@susanwangcfa3685]

Thank you so much for this very thorough review and for up-close/in-focus imagery (extremely rare these days). Between the Becca and Makeup Revolution, do you have a strong opinion as to which provides both good coverage and an undetectable appearance? (I'd love to be able to use the Flower Beauty or Pixie, but both are probably too peach for me.)

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you! I would say Becca is more skin-like than Makeup Revolution, but if you're looking for something that matches your skin better without being too pink or peachy, I'd go with the Tarte, Charlotte Tilbury, or Sigma ones! 💖💖

[@dr.kiralyagnes4981]

THANK YOU SO MUCH for this video! I too, loved the NYX one and just recently ran out of it, RIP, so I was trying to reasearch what colour corrector to buy next and found so little useful content on the topic. I have a question, which one do you think is the most like the NYX one? Both in colour and formula. It was pretty much perfect for me (used shade Fair) and I can't really afford to try them all and see for myself unfortunately, plus some aren't accessible to me. In the meantime, I'll add my review of the 2 I bought since then (for context: I am 25, minimal tiny, fine lines, have mostly oily skin, but my undereyes tend to be drier, skin tone is light to fair yellowy (maybe olive?), I wear Maybelline Fit me in 100 and NYX Bare with me in Vanilla Nude): Catrice Ultimate Camouflage Cream shade 100 C Brightening Peach: this one's quite waxy and thick, has a tendency to look almost chalky if not properly moisturized prior. The colour is pretty peachy, as the name suggests, but a slightly pinky peach, the depth is about medium, it's almost the same shade as the cover of the Juvia's place Magic palette, just a little lighter. Coverage is medium I'd say, has a mostly matte finish and if I add concealer and powder on top it looks very dry by the end of the day. Overall not very happy with it. 3 grams of product for 3.49€ in Germany, would rather not say in my local currency as it changes day by day. 1 shade available. Catrice Under eye brightener shade 010 Light Rose: this one is very creamy, very emollient, very shiny-looking, almost doubles as an eye cream. The colour is lighter and pinkier than the other one, the coverage is on the light end, but it's dewy so optically it seems more brightening. My biggest problem with this (beside the low coverage) is that it makes my waterproof mascara melt, no matter how much I powder it and it also often creases. It's nothing like the NYX one was, I'd say going off your demonstration it's more like the Revolution in texture, but has the shininess of the Smashbox. 4.2g of product for 3.99€ in Germany. 1 shade available.

[@TooMuchTash]

Hmmm now that I think about it, the Charlotte Tilbury one is probably the closest if I’m looking at formula and shade! Most of them are either too pink or too peachy, while the NYX one was very close to my skin tone. I would recommend looking at potted concealers instead of color correctors - sorry I don’t have an exact (and more affordable) answer!

[@TooMuchTash]

I gave it more thought and I think the sigma one is also very close! I wore the darker side of the duo and no other makeup and it matched me really well!

[@samlab2935]

please try the bobbi brown one and let me know how it compare 😅

[@kyradray4938]

Wow !! Great review and comparison

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you so much! 😊

[@lesleygoldberg3304]

I really miss the Urban Decay correctors. They came in a plastic tube with a doe foot applicator. The peach was perfect for me. I am using the Smashbox x Becca one and it’s okay but I hate the packaging of these products.

[@TooMuchTash]

I remember hearing good things about that, I wonder why they discontinued it! 💔

[@JoParson290]

I'm not sure I understood which product is best for more mature skin. Also what is the difference between concealer and color corrector?

[@pnevlud]

I use just the Sigma in light and a little CT flawless powder to set and I’m done!

[@TooMuchTash]

Oooh that sounds like a great combo!! 💛

[@kerrygreen5342]

Thankyou this video has really helped me xx

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you for watching! ❤️

[@OhMGtoo]

I thought you will do a RANKing; that would be helpful

[@TooMuchTash]

That's a good point! They are all good in their own way so luckily, there were no duds. After using them for so long, I would say the Charlotte Tilbury one is the best for me, but really the best one is going to be different for everyone - and hopefully I gave enough information in the video that you can decide which one will be the best for you. ❤️

[@aquatofanax]

Thank you for this video!

[@miish15]

Thank you for this video! Can I ask - what do you think of the MILANI SUPERCHARGED BRIGHTENING UNDEREYE TINT?

[@TooMuchTash]

Thanks! I haven't tried it, I just assumed it wouldn't be very high coverage since it has the word 'tint' in the title ❤️

[@maryrose7842]

I have the pixi but I find it too drying and hard to blend

[@TooMuchTash]

I can see that being an issue! It's definitely not the creamiest one in the bunch haha

[@jagritisolanki5581]

Hi I have oily skin but dry under eyes I’m just 33 but under eye has fine lines I used nyx stick correcterr in dark peach but it settles into lines cracks I’m confused now between tarte cc corrector or liquid huda peach corrector? Which one will be less cresing plz tell me

[@sayantaniist]

Awesome thanks for the video..pl suggest me a Best corrector for dry mature under eye with lines😊

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you, I recommend the Charlotte Tilbury one for that! ❤️

[@sayantaniist]

@@TooMuchTash tysm dear ❤️

[@sanaahanaa5475]

Hi, what skin type are you? I’m interested in the Charlotte Tilbury one but I’m not sure if it’s good for dry skin?

[@TooMuchTash]

I have oily skin but normal to dry undereyes - I think it would work well with most skin types because it's a thinner consistency. ❤️❤️

[@HD-eu3zg]

Have you tried nars and the la girl corrector? If you have, is there any reason you didn't like them.

[@TooMuchTash]

I haven't tried the Nars but I did have the LA Girl one long ago. It was much creamier and not very high coverage, but it was nice! ❤️

[@marlenegomes4008]

I love the signa But i go trough it so fast. The makeup revolution is too creamy for me. Between the CT and the sigma which one would you choose?

[@TooMuchTash]

I would say I prefer the CT one. It's more expensive but seems to last longer and I like the level of coverage and how it looks on my skin! ❤️

[@jagritisolanki5581]

I have oily skin but dry under eyes hv fine lines under eyes I’m just 33 I tried nyx peach correcter but it settled into my fine lines cracked I’m now in between to decide between tarte cc corrector or liquid huda peach corrector or CT correcter can u plz help me 😢please

[@TooMuchTash]

I haven't tried the Huda one but I do think you'll like the Tarte one better than the NYX one for fine lines!

[@jagritisolanki5581]

@@TooMuchTash thanks for responding I heard that tarte also settles into fine lines?

[@iMelvina]

Great video 😃

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you!!

[@nzgirl2105]

Hi. Which one you would recommend for drier under eyes and more mature skin?

[@TooMuchTash]

Definitely the Tarte one! 💙

[@nzgirl2105]

@@TooMuchTash thank you🥰

[@KyleighOfficial]

Thank you for the shade comparisons because that’s one of the things I look for. Also, I appreciate you linking every product. 🤍

[@TooMuchTash]

Thank you!! ❤️