I Tried The Top 20 Tubing Mascaras And Found the Best One... Tubing Mascara Showdown!

[@CobraDove1111]

I have been using tubing mascara ( L’Oreal beauty tubes) for about 20 years (before they became trendy), and you have to use the primer if you want to get the volume! It’s not unfair, it’s meant to be used that way, I’ve recommended that drugstore fave to anyone that would listen for decades. And as far as your first place pick, the Maybelline Sky High seems to be exactly the same as that Tartlette first pick you chose, half tubing with a little bit of smearing in the removal, however, the mascara looks beautiful and it’s super cheap. I hope that helps anyone out. I tried the Caliray mascara and I love it

[@03Marisab]

I've been using the L'Oreal double extend for 15 years! I love it too 😀

[@deann3621]

Totally agree with you!!

[@melissakearns7971]

I also used to love the Caliray but have changed my favorite to Maybelline sky high washable! I don’t think it’s labeled as tubing but it is

[@gilmotier]

Totally agree. It makes no sense to use it without the primer. She said it would be unfair because "of course" a mascara will look better after applying a primer, but come on. 🙄 It comes *with* the primer. You can't buy it without the primer, so why not use it as intended? Deduct points just for the fact that it's a two-step process, if you want, but give it a fair shake.

[@kaeliheartsmakeup]

I tried it with the primer. For me it was terrible.

[@rachellopez8357]

The rigor with which you test products is so impressive ❤

[@AbbeyYung]

thank you so much 💗

[@jessicalevina4118]

Would love to see brown mascara showdown. Just wanted to say thank you for the video and all the effort you put into this ❤️❤️

[@fbmbassist]

The L’Oréal NEEDS the primer-it’s not optional. That’s what allows you to get length without it ever clumping. You apply the black mascara while the primer is still wet (do one eye at a time, all coats at once before it dries). It may seem unfair, but they did that on purpose and it makes the formula unique. Glad to keep gatekeeping this one though so it doesn’t sell out or increase in price! 😂

[@LL-ku8cr]

I have it and I didn't realize you had to use the primer with the muscara immediately after on one eye and not doing both first. I'll have to try that

[@elentam2042]

It's discontinued here in the UK 😭😭😭😭

[@jenniezarna1959]

To remove tubing mascaras you simply need to wet the lashes for like 15 seconds then swipe down with a cotton pad or wash cloth. It’s the water which releases the hold on your lashes not rubbing around in circles.

[@wismeiry31]

Right, I was so confused what she was doing?

[@SixtiesWoman]

I was cringing at how rough she seemed to be being with the delicate eye skin

[@q5130]

@@SixtiesWoman Me too!

[@teresalundholm3254]

I wet my fingers and swipe up and there are the tubes, on my fingers. I never ever rub my eyes.

[@kelly1ish]

I like the Thrive better than the Tarte. For the price point I have been using Elf.

[@melissakearns7971]

My favorite is the Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Eyelash Mascara in Brownish Black .. I was recommended this as a brown tubing mascara as Beaubble doesn’t ship to Canada .. it’s great and has replaced my previous faves 💕

[@AbbeyYung]

I had no idea they had a tubing version of that!! Must try

[@nataliegundersen9673]

Does it come off with warm water?!

[@q5130]

@@melissakearns7971 Sky High smears for me 🫤

[@candi6642]

@@AbbeyYung It's not truly tubing, more like the Tarte it looks like, will smear with water.

[@thepoteetteam]

@@AbbeyYungI was actually shocked it wasn’t included in this video! It’s an amazing tubing mascara!

[@vidatalab8301]

Glad that the elf tubing mascara made it so high up on the list. I have a hard time paying for a high end mascara when it’s not 50% off 😅

[@AbbeyYung]

It's a great option!! can't beat that price

[@ericakershaw4705]

I wanted to love the ELF tubing mascara. My tube felt really dry

[@cathleenrichards3841]

I love it too, and it comes in brown! Big yay!

[@phyllistallent4149]

@@ericakershaw4705 the Elf was a fail for me. I discarded it. Too dry-and did very little for my lashes.

[@daisy_rh]

I LOVE the elf! I have in brown and black, love the brown for every day

[@cs-yq5ed]

I tried a mini of the original Tarte Tubing mascara. I wasn't overly impressed, but thought it was just ok. I just tried the Elf and was greatly disappointed. It was dry and so I couldn't layer it. Basically, got no length or volume. My favorite is the Caliray Tubing. I am able to layer it easily. It also holds the curl. Thanks for doing this indepth analysis, Abbey! ❤

[@CobraDove1111]

I love the Caliray too

[@Megan___]

I got the mini of the tarte as well and HATED it. Believe it or not it smudged. As a tubing mascara. I didn’t even know that was possible. I will need to try this one you are talking about. I need one that can hold a curl.

[@kerrifiermonte2143]

I totally agree about the mini Tarte. I was soooo unimpressed and couldn’t figure out why people liked it so much. I bought the mini mascara value set from Sephora a few months ago. It comes with a coupon for a full size of one of the included mascaras in the set. I have always liked the Rare beauty mascara and was leaning towards getting that one. Maybe I will try the full size Tarte instead? I know sometimes the way the mini and the full size may perform differently…

[@mohmlet]

@@Megan___ the Tarte mini was one of the worst mascaras I've ever used. It flaked, it smeared, and it clumped. I was so disappointed in it because I've loved some Tarte mascaras of the past.

[@andresfamily3560]

I was very disappointed in the Elf too. I actually returned it.

[@kelceynicole]

3:16 - i honestly LOVE this mascara; Milani Highly Rated Lash Extensions. I live in Louisiana and we have HEAT + humidity here (if you know, you know🥵) & maybe it’s just me, but I swear it doesn’t transfer after wearing it all day like most mascaras do. I also layer it with Milani Highly Rated Anti Gravity bc it separates better (anti gravity first & then lash extensions). I will say that I do wish Milani Lash Extensions wasn’t as dark & SOMETIMES I don’t like the how clumpy it can be, but it doesn’t always bother me. I just go in with a mascara brush & it looks fine! it’s my fav mascara. I really don’t see myself switching anytime soon. oh and I have short, straight, but curly/wacky, stubborn lashes, so I truly mean it when I say these mascaras have tamed my lashes a lot when I wear them.

[@jennifermolina4396]

Thrive is my all-time favorite tubing mascara. I've tried a bunch, and I've found the Thrive formula is superior to the others. I have naturally longer lashes and love length and volume. The Thrive is amazing and gives me length but no volume. So I use the L'oreal Lash Paradise over the top of it to achieve what I want! Great video. But I do really enjoy the Tarte mascara as well. It'd be rated as my 2nd favorite. And I agree about the removal of it.

[@danalichvar3460]

OMG my favorite mascara made first place!! I have straight lashes that wont hold a curl and this does a pretty good job for something that isnt waterproof. & now they make it in brown too!

[@Lesaly]

Ooh thanks for the info! I have straight lashes myself & didn’t know about the newer brown option, but I personally love the softer brown look for softer lash look!

[@AbbeyYung]

OMG I didn't know they had it in brown?!

[@user-iq2cc7jt1j]

This might be my favorite video ever!! I have only ever tried the L’Oréal and Blinc tubing mascaras, and have only just discovered Elf! Hated Blinc, L’Oréal is only OK, as I feel like when you use the white primer, it leaves a weird white cast that you can’t totally cover up, and it gets flakey for me. Elf has been a GAME CHANGER! I am not a big fan or user of Wlf products in general because I feel like the products don’t really jive well with my skin chemistry, but the Elf tubing mascara is IT!!! Maybe I should expand my horizons and try some of these other tubing mascaras from other brands. I had no idea there were so many options!!! Thanks Abby!! ❤😊

[@sunkissed7377]

I have been using the L’Oréal Double Extend for at least 15 years now- I’m tempted to try out other formulas but I keep going back to this one bc it’s such a tried and true affordable and easily accessible drug store product for me. I even wore it to my father’s funeral and crying didn’t ruin it or smudge it. I agree that the primer does add to the experience of the product - and I love that I don’t have to fuss with 2 separate tubes to get my lashes done in the morning. Last year I tried the KVD one and I agree the brush is AWFUL and it doesn’t wash off well. I also find it disappears throughout the day so your review was spot on! Thanks for this video, I might try one of your top recommendations!

[@DenaliMarina]

I am obsessed with tubing mascara!! So hard to go back to regular mascara after trying it 😎

[@charlotte-m5d]

What is regular mascara, I’ve never used anything but L’Oréal.

[@DrReedB0928]

Yay🎉 I think we've all been waiting a long time for this video and always appreciate all of your hard work❤

[@AbbeyYung]

thank you so much for watching 💗

[@evonheffken6552]

Thanks for the good information, Abbey. I would love to see a cream blush showdown with one criterion in the grading system being how long wearing it is.

[@cf8595]

2nd comment for algorithm: I subscribed because of this video! I generally only subscribe when I feel a youtuber has really earned the support, because I just don't want a super busy feed and I find a lot of channels repetitive. you work so hard on these videos!

[@AbbeyYung]

aww thank you so so much! 💗

[@lindaclements6639]

Suggestion: Ponds Cold Cream makeup remover - the one with the green lid - + a cotton round for easy EASY eye makeup removal.

[@AbbeyYung]

omg I forgot about ponds cold cream it is so good!!

[@CaliforniaBabe0525]

Tubing mascaras, yes!!!🙂😍🥳 I love the Thrive mascara.

[@wilfullyobtuse]

'I love you this is the most important video of my life I am so excited' - the hyperbolic screamy excitement running through my head when I saw this video come up. I love tubing mascaras. I will never buy a non-tubing mascara again. I like a natural lash, and they are so gentle. Thank you for doing this, time to take notes!

[@janebilleter5299]

Hi everyone....Thank you so much for the thorough review. The Ulta Brand New Heights is actually not a tubing mascara....The Ulta Brand Lash Flash is their tubing formula and I think it is really good. It has a little ball on the end that helps to separate each lash. I have also tried the Elf and Tarte(they are both really good) and the Ulta is also great!!!!

[@AbbeyYung]

LOLLL that explains it. I wonder why it came up as a tubing mascara in my searches... maybe because they say it has film forming technology?

[@janebilleter5299]

@@AbbeyYung That makes total sense....The verbiage they use to explain products is so fun sometimes...Lol. You really do such an amazing job at reviewing products and I hope I didn't come off as ungrateful. Thank you for everything you do!!!

[@maybe800]

Would love to see a showdown with cream blushes and powder blushes

[@Fortunekuke13]

Please try the Estee Lauder Zero smudge tubing mascara. It’s so underrated under the radar.

[@tinafriis3122]

Yup, the Tarte is one of my absolute faves as well! However, I actually prefer the ELF, as the Tarte transfers a tiny bit, whereas the ELF does NOT budge! Great video, thanks! ❤

[@jowiens32]

Thank you! Calliray has been my ride or die for a couple years, but I’m willing to try a new one!

[@jenniferr5934]

Me too

[@AprilSo]

Love the depth of this video! I think the Ulta Lash Flash is the tubing mascara, and New Heights is a typical mascara. I’d love to hear your thoughts on the Lash Flash!

[@katester7]

Wow!! Okay based on this I went out and got the tartlette and HOW IS THIS MASCARA NOT TALKED ABOUT MORE? I was shocked I’d never even heard of it and it’s so so so so good!! Thanks for sharing. I love that it comes in mini sizes!

[@jembear888]

I can’t believe the elf made it so high! I had to return it it was not layering well and it literally hurts to put on lol. Either way love the video! Some other good ones to try is the L’Oréal panorama and the brown essence one! I have yet to try the tarte one and I would love it in brown!

[@Lesaly]

Is it the Essence Princess lash in brown?

[@allisonpingel5577]

No 7 stay perfect mascara is a thrive dupe and I love it!

[@tinat232]

Saw the teaser on Instagram and got super excited! Love tubing mascara for my hooded watery eyes. I can't stand waterproof

[@moanablogger]

big fan here of your showdown vids. looks like they take a TON of work. just wanted you to know that love these!

[@AbbeyYung]

thank you so much 😊

[@labibamahabub4859]

Girl, whenever I want to buy new mascara I watch one of your videos. Thanks for your content. Saves my hard-earned money.

[@mackenziemikel2074]

Been looking forward to this one!! I’m due to replace my Merit mascara and glad I held off until watching! Thanks for all your hard work ❤

[@AbbeyYung]

of course 💗

[@zoww13]

Sweed and Victoria beckham are both fantastic tubing mascaras, would have love to have seen them compared. I have the Tarte one but these other two are definitely way better for me.

[@reformingbeauty]

Good to know! I'm a luxury beauty lover!

[@charityhodges1]

Yesssss I’m obsessed with the VB Vast Lash!

[@ash_wts]

I flipping love your showdowns, you provide such thorough insight into all aspects of each products review - from the formula, component packaging, application, wear and removal - thankyou 👏👏👏

[@AbbeyYung]

yay I'm so glad you think so!! xx

[@lolwhat2628]

Yay thank you! Maybe its just me but for the weartime pics i have a hard time finding the right eyes to compare, theres just so many eyeballs 😅 The red rectangle was super helpful but additional dividers between the different times would have helped a lot too ❤ or maybe just the initial and final wear would be less cluttered too 😊

[@Pinkflo363]

I still love my Loreal air volume mega mascara. But it’s nice to see what’s out there and what I may consider trying. Thanks for the review.

[@heidilongman8128]

No L’Oreal Panorama? I was expecting that one! It’s really good. I also love the Caliray (that one is my gym mascara; I never have the wear issues you did and it performs better than my old favorite waterproof during a workout), I just really wish they had a brown version!

[@wendyash6915]

I have been sandwiching non tubing mascara in between coats of tubing mascara for years. It allows me to build volume while keeping length and durability.

[@q5130]

I'm so thankful to find this video! You have saved me a lot of time and money! As someone born with heavily hooded eyes, regular mascara, even waterproof, smudges horribly under my eyes and I constantly look like a raccoon! Tubing mascara solves all of this and I wish I'd known about it long ago! Why is it such a secret? It is mostly not in the name or advertised, so reading the ingredients is often the only way to know it's tubing. I love the ELF Lash Xtndr and the L'Oreal. You should have tried it with the primer separately, as it greatly improves length, volume and wearability. The only drawback is the texture of the primer, it's like Elmer's glue! But it's ideal for special occasions and wears really well. I also really liked the brown (amazing colour) Wowcombo mascara, but it is expensive outside of the USA, so I will not reorder. Added bonus, I tested mine in the middle of 40° weather, so I can say both the L'Oreal and ELF are sweat proof. I have yet to see a review or try the newer L'Oreal Panorama mascara, so that will be next, along with your top selection ☺️

[@Aellaraven]

My eyes smudge like crazy with all mascaras unless they're tubing, but fair warning that some of these don't fully tube so they smudge. I hated Tartlette, it gave me raccoon eyes, and ironically the no panda eyes gave me panda eyes. I also hated LA Girl and Caliray, they smudged a lot, and Maybelline Sky High was pretty bad right away. Best for no smudging, true tubing, has been L'Oreal Double Extend, ELF, Clinique, Blinc, and Milani (but not a big fan of that formula). Hopefully that helps from a fellow person with smudging issues! 😆

[@q5130]

@@Aellaraven Thank you! Your list is very helpful as well ☺️ Are you saying you didn't like her #1? I have seen that many of others 'Top Picks' have mixed reviews, so I have been hesitant to try anything on the more expensive side.

[@Aellaraven]

@@q5130 Yes, her #1 smudged on me. It took longer than others like LA Girl and Caliray (I threw those out within a couple days) but it only lasts a few hours before smudging under my eyes and I don't even wear mascara on my lower lashes! I kept it as backup in case my other one wrecked, because it did give great volume and I liked the brush, but I just can't use it as my main mascara. I even tried layering a better tubing option over it that doesn't smudge, but it still have me dark eyes by afternoon. Hope this helps! If you could find a mini, you could always test it out. I'm a huge fan of true tubing mascaras, and it just wasn't one! My go to is ELF and I still will always love L'Oreal for the extra volume when using the primer.

[@q5130]

@@Aellaraven Thank you! I concur on the ELF and L'Oreal!

[@LeeWender]

I love that you did this comparison! I have been using tubing mascaras for 20+ years (!) when I was introduced to Blinc because I ALWAYS get smudging, then used L’Oréal for many years, then thrive, and Tarte! I have tried most of the ones you did here, and had high hopes for the Tarte XL because I LOVE Tarte. Right now I am sticking with Tarte and Elf, because you can always get fab discounts on the Tarte site :) and Elf is, well, Elf! Love the way you tested ALL of them here!

[@ivonnehansson4938]

Yay 🙌🏼 finally 🎉I have been waiting for someone to do a video like this. Thanks for all your hard work on this one. I use a tubing mascara from IDUN minerals. I’m never going to go back to a normal mascara.

[@venenumletalis]

My favorite ones are Essence and Heimish. I'm surprised Essence didn't last on you, it is my go-to, and it gives me really fluffy and very long lashes that last all day- sweat, rain, you name it. And I do like it better after the tube has been open for a couple of weeks. Heimish is more intense black, but doesn't give as much volume as Essence, imho, and you need to use hotter water for it to come off.

[@kimberlysh88]

Couldn't agree more! Love the tartlette and thrive mascaras. Tower 28 make waves rounds out my top 3 mascaras.

[@elizabethhofmann8476]

Excited to see this pop up on my feed, I've been looking forward to it! Thank you for the hard work to do these show downs! If you want an idea for a future showdown, have you thought about Asian mascaras? They come in so many more colors than US and in my experience of the few I've tried, they don't flake.

[@marlawehrheim4844]

Tartlette tubing mascara has been my fav for over a year. It’s amazing. By far my fav. Great find!!

[@laurenjabco9096]

I’ve been waiting for someone to do this! Thank you!

[@AbbeyYung]

💗 thanks for watching!

[@mom-wife-teach]

I did a video recently on my channel with a new tubing drugstore mascara- it's really good! I've been using it daily for a month now.

[@marianna6926]

Loved this tubing mascara review. Thank you for the great info. I think you eyelashes really do look best in the #1 😌

[@christinagreer4409]

I've used a lot of tubing mascaras and I have to say my favorite by far has been Tower 28 Beauty MakeWaves Lengthening + Curling Clean Mascara. I am obsessed with it!

[@hconf]

I’ve been WAITING for this!!! Thank you!!!

[@AbbeyYung]

thanks for watching 💗

[@evamirikantor]

Love the tart one...ot actually curls my lashes so beautifuly❤

[@carolinegarrett3542]

I’ve been using Milani for the past year or so and I love the concept of tubing mascara but this is the only one I’ve tried so far. It’s super inconsistent and doesn’t hold a curl!! This video is so so helpful in picking a new mascara. Thank you!! :))

[@MyLadyGodiva]

I have been using the Ooh la Lash Length & Lift Tubing Mascara from ZOEVA and it is amazing!

[@FarhanRzman]

I actually love Loreal ones as a topper. I use it to top coat waterproof formula which usually tends to smudge under the eye. Also, imo the Judy Doll is not a tubing but a waterproof type.

[@lizjarvis7292]

Hands down, best tubing mascara I’ve tried is the No 7 Stay Perfect Mascara. My GOAT, everyday mascara. Not necessarily the one I’d use for glam, big event mascara, but if I could only have one mascara for the rest of my life, that is the one I’m grabbing.

[@ashleymeyers-petro9609]

I got a two-pack of the original Tarte tubing mascara -one brown, one black- and I found that for some reason the brown formula removes more easily. Maybe the black is just more pigmented, but the brown tubed very well vs the black partially tubed but also smudges a bit with removal.

[@melf8609]

That “you’re still pretty” at the end 😂

[@AbbeyYung]

hahahaha

[@summerrose1545]

​@@AbbeyYungI'm late in commenting but I never knew the Judy Doll is a tubing type? AFAIK it's marketed as waterproof (at least where I'm at in Asia) and the only way I've removed it all these while is how I remove waterproof mascaras.

[@TA09386]

We’ve all been waiting!! Thank you ❤

[@janeentroy]

I have been using the Loreal tubing for years and years, it's the only mascara I like to use.

[@hannah9595]

I've been waiting for this video! Apparently heimish makes a version without a curved wand - I think called "volume" and it anecdotally has better separation. I really like the Heimish one you showed (have to use lash separator) and it cleans off like a dream, but I'm going to try their one with the straight wand next!

[@awesomeaj9454]

Love ❤ this video, I have IT Cosmetics Superhero, Lancome Idole, and Tate XL. After your review I think Tubing mascara are the best for length, I did notice the Tarte XL clumps but I find it playful and very easy to remove, in 3-4 months I'll try the Original Tarte. Thank you again for a very detailed review 😊

[@k.hebert]

The elf has been my FAVORITE lately! It’s probably the best I’ve personally tried. I haven’t tried them all, but I’ve tried quite a few! And the elf has definitely been my new “Go To” lately! I even packed it in my hospital bag for when I go into labor! 😂 I personally do no like the heimish mascara AT ALL! I found it to be entirely too wet and sticky and mad my eyelashes clump together horribly. I had such high hopes for it, too!!😕

[@roberta9428]

I’ve been looking for a natural looking mascara ever since Clinique discontinued their naturally glossy. I’m so glad to hear the Loreal tubing mascara looks natural. I’ll definitely try it out.

[@kirstymckenzie1253]

Thank you so much! I love the hourglass one but will def be trying the Tarteless one to compare!

[@caitlinabusamra1265]

Yay! Been using thrive for ages but just got the tarte one in their makeup bag sale so excited to try it now!!

[@lizl6078]

I LOVE the Tarte tubing mascara. It’s the only mascara that really helps my flat lashes stay up and gives them incredible length.

[@96estelle69]

I'm one of those people that likes the easy removal with tubing mascaras, if it doesn't fully come off in tubes I don't think it should be called a tubing mascara. I had bought the Maybelline sky high mascara since people said it was tubing and imo it is not, just because it has little clumps in it while smearing all over your face and into your eyes. Thanks for this vid though, this actually shows the removal and that is super helpful!

[@catherinesiu4100]

oh my gosh you should totally try more japanese fiber lash mascaras they are my OG

[@TracyD2]

Any in particular? I love a more natural lash not globbed on like the Thrive.

[@catherinesiu4100]

@@TracyD2 Browlash EX Volume Lash Fiber Black is the one i use, it lengthens very nicely and is buildable but it will not make your lashes thicker tho

[@nataliegundersen9673]

@@catherinesiu4100Are these tubing? Do they come off with warm water?!

[@victoriavasilcovsky646]

Yes, for natural look I love dhc

[@lsaz4378]

On a whim I bought the Tarte bundle on TikTok and it had the tarte mascara..I was stunned at how amazing it is..my lashes are long naturally and this was just insane..best mascara for sure !!!

[@dionline88]

"You're still pretty"!!! He's a keeper girl.... excellent video in SO many ways!!!

[@msbmmc]

Yes!! My fave is #1 😍 one day I just picked it up for no reason, all I knew is that I wanted a tubing mascara and clearly I picked well because it's amazing. Makes my tiny lashes look stunning.

[@julsg123]

Perfect timing, I was just ordering mascara and this was in my cart as I loved it the first time I purchased!

[@lichtwuermchen]

you absolutely need to try the Sensai 38 degrees Volumizing Mascara. it's the best mascara (and a tubing one) out there 🤞🏻

[@readwithroxy]

Surprised you didn’t include the Maybelline Sky High Mascara! That has been my go-to mascara for about five years now. I’ve tried to venture away to others, but always find myself coming back to that one for the price point and results☺️

[@christina5516]

Is this one a tubing mascara? I never realized that

[@readwithroxy]

@@christina5516 yes it is ☺️

[@thefreshmaker001]

Never liked that one. So clumpy on me

[@kelsyervin9039]

Same! Love that one ✨

[@CMarie2415]

​@@thefreshmaker001agree. I tried it and went back to my tried and true, Loreal Beauty Tubes (with the primer!!).

[@Alohaalondra]

I’ve repurchased the heimish one so many times she’s one of my fav tubing mascaras that i like recommending. The elf mascara has gotten me compliments on my lashes at work so i give it more points after that

[@Lulu-kt6gr]

I tried the XL and it’s actually in my purse right now because I have been planning to return it to Ulta and get the original instead! Same thing you found: I didn’t like the XL. It’s too hard to remove, looks dry and clumpy. But the original Tarte has always been great. Great video.

[@saltylimes9953]

Yesss the one I’ve been waiting for!

[@723snoopy]

Omg you did it!❤❤❤❤ have been waiting for this and I am so excited

[@723snoopy]

At the end of the video and just have to thank you for the super thorough and amazing mascara comparison! Would love to see asian/japanese/korean mascara show down in the future!

[@oliviaoxley]

Gosh I love your showdowns! I’m ready 🥰🩵

[@AbbeyYung]

yayyy thanks for watching!

[@jennysoderlund527]

SO GOOD!!! I have been waiting for a comprehensive review like this. You are the ONE to deliver!!!

[@AbbeyYung]

💗💗

[@Rachel-gy3gm]

Bye bye panda eyes and MilanI flaked bad on my. My favorites so far are the caliray and heimish. Excited to try the tarte.

[@jordanashtonsmith5436]

you look super pretty at 22:11 !! i used to use the tarte tubing but switched to tarte maneater. i think i’ll switch back 🤔

[@someonerandom256]

As someone who loves the Clinique tubing mascara and has used it off and on for the past decade, but just can't justify regularly paying $26 for mascara, I absolutely LOVE the ELF tubing mascara. Super similar, also comes in brown, and only $7. It's my holy grail!

[@squidney4807]

Wait, so how do your top tubing mascaras compare to your regular mascaras? Tarte over Maybelline Lash Sensational? That’s what the people want to know!

[@CelesteGarcia71991]

I know you're asking her but I'd say that her top tubing mascara isn't really a true tubing mascara, since it smears when removing and comes off in flakes rather than "tubes". It's closer to the Maybelline Sky High (which is also not a tubing mascara but is pretty easy to remove). If the top 2 "tubing mascaras" are hardly tubing at all and are better than every true tubing mascaras on this list, I would have to conclude that the non-tubing ones are better. My opinion, obviously. Personally I haven't tried any tubing mascara (and I've tried her top 3) that outperformed my other drugstore favorites like Maybelline.

[@AbbeyYung]

Maybe I can do a showdown of all of the best mascaras I've ever tried next lol

[@simonepatrice6008]

@@AbbeyYungyes please

[@ginan974]

Definitely agree with your number one. I double cleanse and it comes off super easy with an oil based cleanser.

[@Br1ttany1992]

Maybelline Sky High is my favorite!

[@Mariakayc]

I have loved the double extend for over 20 years as I hate the messy removal of mascara. I actually wear it without the primer most days unless I’m glammed up. I feel my lashes are heavy when I use with the primer. I just wish L’oreal would offer a dark brown. I tried the dark brown Thrive and it made my eyes itch and it’s clumpy. Wish I had returned. Excited that elf offers brown!

[@peggys7585]

I get it! Mascara is soooo personal. I absolutely love Tarte XL and you didn’t. It’s so fun to see other’s favorites.

[@joyceyamamoto1088]

Thank you for such a comprehensive comparison. I’ve been on the hunt for a flake free formula that isn’t too wet & smear proof for contact lens wearers. I have tried many & failed. Currently using Elf, it’s ok but not the best. Avon had a washoff waterproof mascara that was great but was reformulated and now has negative reviews so your video was timely. 😊

[@mom-wife-teach]

I love the original Tarte one but I recently tried a new drugstore one and love it- I shared it on a recent video on my channel.

[@ivetteg874]

Goshhhh I been waiting for this !!!! Love it

[@AbbeyYung]

yay so glad! 💗

[@lanigal]

The heimish volume one is way better than the curling one! (It separates your lashes more) And Kimuse has one that has the silicone bristles that’s really great!

[@witchhunt6387]

Thank you for this Abbey! I have been using the Cali-Ray tubing mascara for a year and can’t imagine anything better but I’m excited to try the last 2 you mentioned bc I also prefer brown :) really appreciate your work, it’s so helpful!

[@kimc7376]

This video is awesome! I only use tubing mascara & this video is very thorough, great job!!

[@barbbandurski3679]

As a content creator you go above and beyond! Truly enjoy your content beautiful soul.

[@martelangeland]

I am currently using the Tartelette XL, and I agree the original is better. I’ve heard good things about the Victoria Beckham tubing mascara, so that’s next on my testing list - need to find the perfect one 😄

[@AmirAlternativemusic]

This is the best Tubing mascara videos ever. Thanks for showing the detail how to remove it coz this is sooooo important for me and before watching this video my top 1 was hourglass now I will buy tarte or milk coz from I can find it

[@yolandashaw370]

Just came to comment on the excellent hard work you’ve done on this video! I’m impressed and appreciate your showdown and reviews.

[@jacelynnyong6392]

This mascara showdown is great! I think you'll like the Clio Kill Lash mascara even more than the Tarte mascara you picked as the best one. Love ya!!

[@Thetinyfit]

Wow I was about to reorder my Milani and maybe I won’t. I loved the Thrive forever and then switched to Milani (easier to get) and I had liked it more. I have no issues with the Milani but I didn’t realize there were so many other options. May have to pick up something new to try!