Well while the new sion is a lot more interesting and is played a lot more, I sometimes miss the old sion. His kit was just hillariously broken in so many ways. He was not only an ad-livestealing menace, but also an ap-one-shot champion with a stupidly large shield. But he deffinetly was a troll-pick, a fun one mind you ;D
@calvinwinner9 жыл бұрын
Linke Sei i agree, sion would be my go to pick for a 100% fun time. No matter where you go its fun to play him, from a crazy top laner that uses his e to boost your autos to a burst mage in mid
@crepesbrule87519 жыл бұрын
I would of mained Old sion
@Pincsi019 жыл бұрын
CrepEs BrulÉ Then why didn't you play him more before the rework?
@graywolfclaw9 жыл бұрын
Pincsi01 Maybe he is newer to league and never got the chance??
@coolchrisable9 жыл бұрын
Linke Seii personaly loved old ad sion this is all you had to do for him Farm with E get blade of the ruin king keep farming with E get phantom dancer, hydra, and shiv you would never have to buy tank items you would already be at 3-4k health XD
@_Galaxymuffin_9 жыл бұрын
RIP Old karma, my friend used to main her when she had her old kit, it wasn't weak, you just needed to be good with it!
@NakazoraGen9 жыл бұрын
khaosjoker909 Indeed. Another thing people seem to miss is that she went from a combination support/burst to a... burst. Her shield gives a speed boost, sure, but her old kit had one too. She got a snare, sure. But it uses the same mechanics as her old W... with the same affect as Leblanc's E. Q went from being a combination burst (weak but still kinda bursty if built right) and heal, to... burst and slow. Granted, after I finally simmered down and started playing her, I still love playing Karma, despite the complete overhaul, but I still to this day miss that old Karma I used to main.
@WarperBlade9 жыл бұрын
khaosjoker909 Very true look at that time she was played in competitive and dominated.
@TheMarkBeers9 жыл бұрын
khaosjoker909 Yay another OG Karma fan. I miss her soooo much. She was my favourite champ pre-rework. I always felt that people never understood how to play her really well. It also made me sad, because her biggest gate to effectiveness was her gold dependence and her change came a few months before they introduced all the new support gold income items which would have made so much difference.)Her rework took one of Riot's most unique champs and turned her into a generic mage. I also hated the visual rework that came with the changes as it tarted up the classiest lady in LOL. Her old Sun Goddess skin was awesome. How much did I hate the Karma changes? So much that I wrote to Riot after playing a few games to try her out and demanded a refund for the skins that I had purchased. They refunded me the costs in IP for both the skins and the character. She will be the only champion I will never own again.
@TheMarkBeers9 жыл бұрын
I just went back to my first LoL loves Janna and Soraka. But those wounds have never healed. Sience each version of Karma is so drastically different in play style I'd be beyond the moon with excitement if Riot were to make her a "dual mode" character where you could pick which version of the character you want to play. That would make me squee!
@jckauffman60049 жыл бұрын
Karma's rework is honestly my favorite. I'm a supp/mid player, and Karma is a champ that went from someone I hated to my main support pick. Her Q now can destroy ADCs who build armor and her ultimate allows good decision-making between shield, stun, or damage. Also, new animations and skins are 1000% better.
@Evilriku138 жыл бұрын
+JC Kauffman also her new Q does tons of damage if done correctly and is one of the strongest AoE spells in the game if the third impact hits correctly!
@boefteopumule9 жыл бұрын
I used to jungle the old karma, dominating every single game, she was so underrated
@Xerathiel9 жыл бұрын
that akward guy old karma was so much more fun ^^
@boefteopumule9 жыл бұрын
I know right :D
@leetri9 жыл бұрын
that akward guy I never saw old Karma in-game and I've been playing since early S2. D:
@boefteopumule9 жыл бұрын
Machine Herald You really have to look it up, you'll find some awesome clips ;)
@Gamingpandacat9 жыл бұрын
that akward guy Yeah like with other champs even to this day, karma was ruined for me, I used to go midlane and stomped a couple of times.
@greg54358 жыл бұрын
No, Xerath was a monster before the rework. His W gave him 40% Magic Pen, plus his ult hits were easy to hit and did a 60% ratio so 180% total on ult. Back in the day late game mages were usually close to 1k AP with; Deathcap, Hourglass, Voidstaff, Archangels, DFG, CDR item. Xeraths ratios were no joke. 60% on Q (75% now). W gave 16-40% MR Pen and bonus range. It also gave you a speed boost when you exited it.(Now damaging AoE slow on a 60% ratio). E was a targeted hit and the next spell you landed stunned on an 80% ratio (45% now). And Ult, oh the memories. 3 Hit just like your current W but with high base damage and on the 60% AP ratio per hit.(Now 43%) If you add up the AP ratios in each kit you will find his current kit has a 309% Total AP Ratio (Plus Mana gain passive) His old kit had a Total kit AP Ratio of 320% + 40% Magic Pen (Not to mention passive 15% of AP is gained as Armor) His new kit has more mobility and balance with stun and q charge up slows you but i still feel the damage he had before was insane and wayyy better and the changes were done as a nerf.
@legitnamewhichislegit8 жыл бұрын
Well he was a true monster back then. I think he needed a rework to not make him broken...
@hawarths2948 жыл бұрын
i actually think that xearth was cooler before the rework
@mipfel80659 жыл бұрын
Maybe many will disagree, but I liked the old Xerath more. I was new to LoL and he just looked very stong . He still is ofc but I miss the old, he was kinda more fun imo.
@ND-er1bo9 жыл бұрын
Michi Meh i like the new xearth :) ; 3:55 script of doom
@xSTATOKEx9 жыл бұрын
I hated the Xerath rework, he was such a good support champ, I loved him.
@pyrojinn9 жыл бұрын
he was crazy good in midlane too. You have a guaranteed stun and full burst combo right after level 6.
@primetyrant28919 жыл бұрын
Pearce Aiden And thats the problem. Thats why he was reworked. Some tards sterted to play him as another mid range assasin (like there wasnt enough of that shit)...
@pyrojinn9 жыл бұрын
yeah his long range at that time is pretty unbeatable. Jeremy talks about the immobility when casting? Screw that shit, he has guaranteed stun! With his abilities alone! Like wat
@dunsparceislife21569 жыл бұрын
Pearce Aiden I remember him pre-rework: bitch was hitting enemies from under his turret and then got a sweet MS boost to compensate for the self-snare.
@GoldenAce908X8 жыл бұрын
Okay missing two big and good ones. Gangplank and nidalee. Nidalee - used to have a little broken and boring gameplay, relying on 1 shotting people with spears. Rework kept the importance of the spear at the same time added more utility and value to her cougar form (which used to be useless) and turned her into a top tier pick, as well as opening her up to more roles other than midlane. Gangplank - like the nidalee update, kept the importance of his q and added a new mechanic (barrel) that turned him from a weird pick into a good champion which added a high skill high reward gameplay as opposed to the old point and click q.
@FireGamingUltima8 жыл бұрын
At point when video was made nobody knew about gp rework
@moustxche9 жыл бұрын
Sion rework was like: "ok, dont play that champion, it was a mistake making him" i miss the pentakill tower dives
@xanadu47658 жыл бұрын
I personally hate current sion,old one was one of my favorite champions,dominated top lane easily,now its just "team fighter" tank.
@levobertus9 жыл бұрын
Am I the only person who mained the old Xerath and saw him as the most unique champion in the game, until they made him a mixture of vel'koz and lux.
@Skarfar909 жыл бұрын
Levobertus More like an AP-version of Varus, with a shorter cooldown on his stun..
@Mirro188 жыл бұрын
+Levobertus Not most Unique but yes, I did as well. He was my go to midlaner. The new Xerath felt awkward in comparison. Also Velkoz did not exist back then ;P
@levobertus8 жыл бұрын
+Michael Böck (Karukos) uhm, I remeber Vel'Koz and Xerath rework being released in the same patch (February 2014)
@Mirro188 жыл бұрын
Levobertus Then either my or your memory is wrong... TO THE WIKI! Edit: The Xerath Rework (10th February) happened before the Velkoz (27th February) release.
@levobertus8 жыл бұрын
+Michael Böck (Karukos) oh you were right. Both February patches tho
@RandomRageDude9 жыл бұрын
RIP AP tristana and AP sion
@vialgyy9 жыл бұрын
***** It's not fun anymore since you have to autoattack in order to do enough dmg. You can no longer jump-e-r-zhonia-jump
@RandomRageDude9 жыл бұрын
***** so much effort. Get outta here
@TheSpiritedFendron9 жыл бұрын
***** It doesnt
@TheSpiritedFendron9 жыл бұрын
AP trist doesnt , just doesnt
@TheSpiritedFendron9 жыл бұрын
You play her ad you play her ap (the new one) you get mad because nashor tooth is too expensive for your little score..
@dilloppy3338 жыл бұрын
I used to love the old Sion, man. AP Sion with movement speed and you just one shot squishins with your shield haha
@felipenunesmelendes9 жыл бұрын
biggest buff eve biggest nerf eve best rework eve best champ thresh
@mattheusspoo8 жыл бұрын
i used to like the old xerath more too. he was like a sieging tower with pure raw damage and insane damage, and now he is like a catapult, idk. he deals less damage and his damage is way more unrealiable, very easy to dodge(expecially his new ult). The channel time on his W and ult before the skill actually landing on the ground are too big and people will have a easy time not getting hit by anything. His E became a skillshot too, so you can't stun people behind minions, and his Q has to be charged up to be usefull. Overall, he has NO reliable way to deal damage to a enemy, similar to Ziggs, and you can pretty much lose to a 1 hp yasuo/riven/ekko(and the list goes on) with 100% of your hp. I know he is a sieging team mage, and should be played with his team to be protect while doing damage, but all of his skills are easy to dodge and his damage isn't that good either. not saying he's a bad champion now, just liked the old xerath more. The EQ combo, the real ability to snipe people with his ult, the 75% magic pen to melt people, and stuff like that.
@lissandrafreljord79138 жыл бұрын
why the hell would you wanna give a champ annie type of burst in that type of range. theres no point of picking up other shorter ranged champions with burst then. the more range the less bursty the damage should be and the harder to land the skill shot considering the safety they get
@mattheusspoo8 жыл бұрын
cofluxcof
@legitnamewhichislegit8 жыл бұрын
And they made it do that now, it takes real skill to aim and land his abilities. it's so that it's more rewarding when landing an ult, and makes you a much much more importance to the team. His role now is to stay at the back of the team while dishing out massive damage.
@mattheusspoo8 жыл бұрын
exept the fact that you won't be doing massive damage at all, his damage is pretty low for a mage.
@legitnamewhichislegit8 жыл бұрын
+Máttheus Spoo if you build him right, he can really be a beast. trust me. I know, I'm a Xerath main.
@JustGhertomp8 жыл бұрын
Really surprised that Gangplank was not in here. He went from completely useless to dominating competitive play. But I understand it's only a top 10 and there are a ton of reworks. Anyway, great video as always, Jeremy.
@joachimo.g.29669 жыл бұрын
The xerath rework was shit, before he was so much more fun to play
@sigibaes9 жыл бұрын
As a Cassiopeia player I believe you should have included her in this list, it really was a big shift. 3:55 Very nice :O
@98NoiD8 жыл бұрын
Poppy is the new best rework
@Jessica-oq7ld8 жыл бұрын
She just got nerfed like a week ago. Now she kinda sucks. Coming from a Poppy main.
@ineffableesprit69188 жыл бұрын
+Ryan Bowman No because old Poppy was much stronger
@ineffableesprit69188 жыл бұрын
Shen The Eye Of Twilight Yep
@KalakauaGodHimself8 жыл бұрын
her old ultimate was way better
@ineffableesprit69188 жыл бұрын
Ptrol-Omega Yep
@AzadShaik8 жыл бұрын
I think Trundle rework deserves a spot in this list. He was a top tier pick for quite sometime after his rework and dominated top lane
@theitalian4569 жыл бұрын
Really surprised you didn't put maokai in this video. The update/rework on his kit made go from mediocre jungler to god tier top lane.
@UsingGorillaLogic9 жыл бұрын
***** Yeah they only changed the ultimate to make it stupidly broken. These other reworks completely changed a garbage champion into a top pick champion, when your 10 spot is the ashe update, then you know maokai isn't getting on the list.
@BunnyWitchcraft9 жыл бұрын
***** It still really changes how the champion was played as a whole, much like several other champions in this list it was just a tweak they needed to go from mediocre to viable.
@epee11c9 жыл бұрын
Alma Elma He's just saying that maokai would be #11 or 12 and therefore not in the vid.
@Baittz9 жыл бұрын
theitalian456 mediocre jungler? I had around 80% win ratio with him in around 50 games.
@theitalian4569 жыл бұрын
Arthur Mortari well mediocre in the sense that he wasnt a tier 1 or 2 jungle and no one really played him when looking at the higher elos. I mean even you have to admit there were better options for jungle.
@oORoxas13Oo8 жыл бұрын
"People say caffeine makes you crash later what **** all it does is make you sleepo who ddoesnt want that?" GaurdKnight - somewhere around 2014-2015
@Sheenulus8 жыл бұрын
+Zero Skill Spamus Are you drunk?
@oORoxas13Oo8 жыл бұрын
Shayan Siddiqi Read the chats in the video.
@carstenpetersen4089 жыл бұрын
Dont really think the old karma was that bad really.. High dmg, heal, shield, permanent movement speed to herself and an ally/permanent slow, and fairly low mana ratio.. She could really do some ridiculous things.
@jdh3nz9 жыл бұрын
Worst rework is prob Rengar rework.
@TheSpiritedFendron9 жыл бұрын
Zebra Rhino *Fiora's death and the reborn of a new champ
@EvilShadow77779 жыл бұрын
Why is Katarina so high? Or on this list? Like literally all they did was create a massive balance issue with her which ended up forcing Riot to gut her then buff her ult. Sure it was great for Katarina players but if that's a good one you might as well put Ryze's latest update on this list at number 1. Literally before that rework she had about a 50% winrate at solo q and despite being a one trick pony was considered relatively balanced. The update nerfed her ult slightly and added more damage to her combo just straight up making her unfair. Sunfire cape toplane katarina was actually viable just because of how absurd her base damage was. If you watch the patch notes afterwards they changed her numbers to make her w weak, her q her primary damage, her e lost burst, and her R damage went up. Basically they've balanced her into old Katarina because it was, you know... balanced.
@coolchrisable9 жыл бұрын
Jeremy West how to nerf kat add mana it would make her more easy to poke down and she cant get away so easily (im both joking and speaking alittly truth)
@FoxHimura9 жыл бұрын
Jeremy West The Katarina rework was one of the funniest things Riot did. At release they stated that ''she relied on her ult too much, so they shifted that power throughout her kit instead'' and then some time later they nerfed her saying ''her kit was too strong and she should rely more on her ult''.
@Uroboro_Djinn9 жыл бұрын
Jeremy West Pretty much this and what Qrowe said. I don't know why people can't see this. The new Katarina was so bad they pretty much changed her back to the old Katarina with ult reliance and medium-damage but easily spammable combos.
@alecbalasko60159 жыл бұрын
But her W before the rework was just a giant mess. I remember taking forever to learn how to use it at all, and even then it was just so confusing to use effectively. While her Q was more powerful before the rework, I think she did need something done about her W because it was just useless.
@EvilShadow77779 жыл бұрын
Alec Balasko Buffing your Q/E isn't really useless, especially when its a tool to determine your positioning. Its definitely a burden of knowledge situation but look at all the passives champions have these days, there's plenty of burden of knowledge in kits. It definitely wasn't worth maxing since its just a minor amplifier to her other skills, but adding damage and movement to her kit that was already pretty solid wasn't a good idea just for the sake of making a button more attractive to press IMO.
@Dib4209 жыл бұрын
Where is the huge Master Yi rework the one that remove AP yi LMAO
@pelataan699 жыл бұрын
+El Fedora yes its counr
@TehStupidBish9 жыл бұрын
+El Fedora His q mechanic was modified, switched to ap, w changed as well from the 400 armor/mr boost or whatever the ridiculous ammount it was to a set % I believe, e completely changed from magic to true dmg and % bonus instead of flat ad, ult has new interactive proportion to it. I somewhat consider that a rework ;p Not as extensive as most but still a big one.
@Genicillo9 жыл бұрын
Kat and Eve both were extremely strong before the reworks. Eve was nerfed into the dirt pre-rework because she was so strong and Riot didnt know what to do with her. Eve would just sneak up with Lich bane and two shot you because then ravage was a nuke spell that shreded armor and mr.
@k5nn6828 жыл бұрын
karma was good even before her rework heck i miss that heal mechanic hahaha
@para1111118 жыл бұрын
+Kennedy Del Rosario no.. she was ONLY good before rework! now just some generic mage... :/
@k5nn6828 жыл бұрын
you got me there that %missing health heal is the thing I miss the most...
@Netbase20008 жыл бұрын
+para111111 This. Exactly this. I play her so much less, almost nothing since rework. Old karma was underestimated by everyone which made her so much fun. :(
@UndecidedDenouement9 жыл бұрын
I love your analyses on many videos, but on half of these, I'd care to disagree. I was a Xerath main pre-rework, and was fairly involved in the discussion of his rework (as well as the reasons why). It was because his kit didn't match his theme (he had Too much Move Speed from the WQ poke, armor from the passive that just didn't make sense for a ranged mage), and he had a low play rate (BUT STILL HIGH WIN RATE, which Riot said was an indicator of some base problems). From memory, Pre-rework Katarina was merely a niche pick, not an unviable one. Very few people knew how to use her, but she was still very strong. (Many of these were actually infuriated at her rework early afterwards, but I will admit this has increased her viability by QUITE A BIT.) I'd also like to disagree with the bit on Sion. Pre-Rework he was a strange champion, whose main role was "awkward" as you said, and yes, largely due to his "awkward scaling" (All AP). But he didn't really have trouble fitting into a team comp too much (He was the beginning of the Roaming mages, those Mobility boots, though). Lastly, for Evelynn, I'd just like to stress your emphasis on "after her nerf". Prior to the nerf she was really OP. That stun and perma-invisibility paired with the healing was insane.
@ZekDrake9 жыл бұрын
The Sion rework is my personal favorite, my god did they do an awesome job, he became one of my favorite champions with it
@yasuomain32678 жыл бұрын
Sion was better before the rework ( Q: targetable stun , W : shield , E : passive ad , R : The best ult ever , Passive : Gaining 3 health from every minion that you kill )
@TyrDoge9 жыл бұрын
SIVIR STILL HAS MANA ISSUES XD
@TyrDoge9 жыл бұрын
"new" if you're on about essence reavr it has been in the game a while.
@ravitempelaar37408 жыл бұрын
If you spellshield a ability, you get mana back from it, so that kinda makes up for it in my opinion.
@TyrDoge8 жыл бұрын
Ravi tempelaar not reallyKappa
@ravitempelaar37408 жыл бұрын
if you use it proberly it does, trust me.
@TyrDoge8 жыл бұрын
Ravi tempelaar hypothetically they use no spells on you, just auto attacks, then what?
@doomblackdragon9 жыл бұрын
I have to disagree with this list. I remember many games where Kat pre rework would just wreck face as an AD champ. Her Killer instance passes was very good. She snowballed very hard and fast back when she had it. Often times enemy team would GG when they saw Kat back then. This as also when we hast stats like dodge and other things. So Kat was a real beast. Dodging all the enemy skills and critting like a beast. Also no Cassiopeia rework? Come on. That rework while not changing her kit to much was a major improvement to her game play.
@Charcu28 жыл бұрын
Someone who says Karma, Sion reworks really helped them... Has not truly played as or against a truly good Karma, Sion... Karma raw numbers in skills were totally broken and her passive gave her a good chunk of free ap. Sion, yeah I agree he was a mess between AD and AP, however you could built ap or ad whether you chose and you would be really broken. He had 2 Ap skills with 1.0 ap ration and high base damage and only 8 seconds cooldown to dominate mid-game. His other two skills were the best AD steroids the game has ever seen, combining the best extra AD skill and the highest attack speed & life-steal the game has EVER seen. Once you had decent crit & damage, you could chop the ENTIRE enemy team one by one. While some of the reworks were needed to make the champions viable, some also brought the idea of making them fair to play against.
@olafandreasstrand80029 жыл бұрын
Reworks, like the Karma and Sion ones, are a bad thing. Yes, they were maybe not played much and arguably bad, but even if their kit was weak, some buffs to stats or a change to say one of their abilities would bring the champion back up. There is no worse feeling than having your main removed, like my friend had with Karma. And even though the new champion are good, why don't just create a new champion and save the old one? For Karma, Sion, and maybe even Xerath, they really removed them and replaced them with someone with the same role and name.
@Khora9 жыл бұрын
Jeremy , are you talking about most "healthy" and good reworks , or talking about most "OP" champions after the rework ?
@myriadofcolours98618 жыл бұрын
Reworks happen for a reason guys! Just because YOU LIKE PLAYING THAT CHAMPION doesn't mean it's a healthy champion. That champion can get pretty frustrating to fight against, and not because out of skill but because of mechanics. It could be the other way around too. Some champions could get frustrating TO USE YOURSELF, which will definitely call for a rework or at least a buff. You guys should stop complaining about the old champions, unless they did something absolutely incomprehensible. Like make a tanky assassin . . . (Looks at Akali). Seriously though, for some reason she still destroys squishies while getting several tank items.
@angrypirate10949 жыл бұрын
The Xerath rework sucked. Before he was a very unique champ, he was immobile which is exactly what made him special. If you didn´t like that you could pick lux, which he resembles far too much now. So what if he got buffed? If you think a rework is just good because it increases the power of a champion, well then, ehh I disagree. A rework should make a champion more fun and unique otherwise Riot should just change stats to buff/nerf champs. More or less the same can be said for the sion rework. He was such a unique champ as an AP carry, what is he now? A tank. Literally a tank with some CC. Nothing special about his kit, probably the worst rework ever.
@BeatsForAngels9 жыл бұрын
Heimer patch 3.13 was such a nerf for heimer - the old one was way more powerfull and i am not talking about release heimer
@salffds9 жыл бұрын
+BeatsForAngels you mean the 6 turret death bush xD long time ago I played vs heim pre nerf and pre nerf ap shaco jungler , well let's just say that if you enter a bush you died xD
@BeatsForAngels9 жыл бұрын
jfk1 yeah that was fun 2 but i mean the latest rework (trurrets at 5 dont do everyhit aoe dmg or can slow with ult)
@salffds9 жыл бұрын
BeatsForAngels I know but what I liked the most about the old heim is that his W had insane ratio and insane base damage and most people don't expect that. I told my friend that if heim's W can only be targeted on champions or prioritize champion we would end up with the most broken champion we've ever seen
@BeatsForAngels9 жыл бұрын
jfk1 the old heimer could kill with swag ;D just walk and use w :D
@salffds9 жыл бұрын
BeatsForAngels best thing about new heim is you can use his old walk xD if they didn't use that he would be unplayable xD
@Uroboro_Djinn9 жыл бұрын
Sivir is my main. I love everything about her. And I'm also gold division so she's very OP here because nobody knows how to counter her for some reason. I always dodge and bait with my shield and I always clean an entire lane full of minions in 4 or 5 seconds. Yeah. I'm one of those geeks who giggled when the patch "Sivir's passive 'fleet of foot' now activates with 'boomerang blade' too" came out. I also have all her skins because money is never enough for the glorious battle mistress. I would spend as much again for her if need be. ^_^ And then it gets weird. My Disqus name, for Surr@20 is "Sivir's foot". ._.
@RoastedPheasant9 жыл бұрын
Karma was my favorite character to ever be released. Her "rework" (which destroyed everything that made her unique and interesting) is a slap in the face that still stings to this day. It made me quit League for almost 2 years because I was so thoroughly disgusted by it.
@Flailmorpho9 жыл бұрын
not only was Sion the best top laner for a while, but the best midlaner if one built AP and focused his E
@tianarmas16658 жыл бұрын
4:50 I'm Thresh and I'm helping
@pyrojinn9 жыл бұрын
I played pre-reworked Heim once. Its pretty terrible. After that he became more potent to play. And for Viktor, I also played him both before and after rework for a long time, and before, his kit really involving upgrade the hexcore to laser and AP, nothing else. Now he's more of a utility champ with upgradeable skills. And he's got to keep his silent. Like how many champion left with silent these days.
@koumparos19959 жыл бұрын
i miss the old xerath so much :3 the magic pane from w..the movement buff..the 1 sec q the 2 sec w the great stun … the fast falling of ult.. …. the armor passive :p went from bronze 3 to gold 2 cause of dat carry… :'( i miss you my friend….
@levobertus9 жыл бұрын
The Viktor update was sooo disappointing in my eyes... It didn't change much, but made the laser less reliable, his builds less flexible and his items more expensive.
@shankywantsyou9 жыл бұрын
The sivir update butchered her honestly. Her old W would almost 1hit people in lane and late game. She used to be really strong, now going back to the 3 bounces is cool, but losing that extra damage on the first bounce really hurts
@Mooseplatoon9 жыл бұрын
Oh, okay. I was a bit confused as the video progressed by how you were judging the success of the reworks. Defining success via win-rate and competitive play to judge this list is probably the most objective way to do it, but my personal interest is more in how the reworks faired in terms of design goals. For instance, the Karma and Sion reworks are horrible failures as far as I'm concerned, as they more or less deleted the old characters and replaced them with entirely new ones with the same name. These new characters were better for the game, undoubtedly, but it's a stretch to even call them the same champion. Karma in particular stands out to me as a failure because her rework did little to retain her old identity or playstyle in the slightest. Sion never had much of an identity to begin with, so retaining his scaling health and shield was really all that was needed to keep the standout features of the kit. My personal opinion is that a true retooling of Karma's original kit (or at least the core idea that defines it: duality) should be implemented in game at some point as a new champion.
@alexandermiltenburg43599 жыл бұрын
TheGuyThatDoesTheThing With Karma i agree 100% i used to main old Karma but after the rework she just wanst fun to play anymore she is way to bursty and requires you to just hit your Q to faceroll Riot decided that a champion who can burst someone with 1 abilty is way more fun to play then someone who actually required skill and was rewarding when done right. Sorry for the rant i am just so sad that they removed Karma :(
@PaigeWillows9 жыл бұрын
Karma and Evelyn were great pre-rework. I really wish they had kept karma's fans and the original look she had. Traditional Karma was a saving grace visually. I still love Karma but i liked her old passive better. Evelyn was not weak imo. I still have screenshots of me going 30+/-10/+15 honestly i can tolerate her rework however i don't like how her stealth works now.Can't go back i guess however i'll survive.
@Darkerxz9 жыл бұрын
Any Visual Updates? I really liked Karthus'.
@ascvb39 жыл бұрын
Darker xz I didn't. Why you may ask? HE NO LONGER HAS SKITTLES!!!!!!!! jk its really nice but i do miss calling them skittles T_T
@Skarfar909 жыл бұрын
I prefer Evelynn as a high-mobility AD-caster rather than a mage.. Both ways can be good, but after the removal of the DFG (R.I.P.) Eve was found to be better with a strong and bursty AD-build
@reiryghts6399 жыл бұрын
Ashe can destroy tabks with the correct build Last whisper, phantom dancer, infinity edge, and the bow that gives 70% attack speed, blood thirster try it out you guys are going to like it just get the five stacks (you can kill a fed yi with this build if you have 5 stacks on q and the shield of blood thirster even if he has the new smite) i killed one
@Digggyyyyy8 жыл бұрын
There needs to be a worst reworks list and Shen needs to be at number 1. I'll never forgive Riot for ruining my favourite champ.
@Fod-xw2kr8 жыл бұрын
What about fioras?
@Digggyyyyy8 жыл бұрын
foda mohamed She's at least much more useful now though. Shen only lost out from his and it totally ruined his established playstyle
@bloodmaster53158 жыл бұрын
+Digggyyyyy i agree tooo he was much easier before same for fiora
@Fod-xw2kr8 жыл бұрын
+Digggyyyyy no no no no no that bitch is Fucking broken. but at least her old ult is gone
@juantanamo74858 жыл бұрын
Shen rework was great too. Should be number 1
@kevinbecker63819 жыл бұрын
back in the day, about season 1 evelynn was arguably the most overpowered champion ever seen in league of legends
@thehunk239 жыл бұрын
I don't think Evelynn became super strong after her rework. She was a weak champ and the rework made her a bit balanced and decent. What made her OP was the vision/warding changes in season 3 which also made Rengar and Khazix and pretty strong. Other than that, Trundle should have been on the list.
@zodiac3399 жыл бұрын
Vishal Sinha Trundle? He had a visual rework and lore change for Freljord, but the abilities are pretty much the same.
@ryanvance17679 жыл бұрын
OId Kat>New Kat, the re-work is a huge nerf to her, I'm not sure how you don't see this.
@kevinzki219 жыл бұрын
Pre-rework katarina was so stromg, scaling off AD so things like BT was actually built on her b4 she was turned ap she had so much sustain and burst damage crazy.
@Zetre179 жыл бұрын
old sion is so power full we make him a fucking offensive tank and an AD build with fucking 100% lifesteal
@xcow78787 жыл бұрын
For me the old Katarina was super easy to play, I even used to main her. I think the new splash art is cool, but the ability changes made her definitely harder to play. I used to get Quadra Kills in almost every game but since the new Katarina I stopped playing her.
@themonkeys969 жыл бұрын
Uh... new ryze rework disappointing? It actually has mechanics like passive management. Know how and when to proc your passive is HUGE to the playstyle. Do it correctly and you can have your root on someone for the majority of a fight. His passive is actually really fun to play with instead of just saying "Here, spam." Like his old one did. The new one is more of "Plan out how to get 5 stacks... now spam correctly and utilize the shield so you can win the fight." Also, I 100% disagree with the final comment on Eve. While, yes, the rework was amazing to bring her out of a state so bad you could get reported for playing her, she is hardly a powerhouse. In season 4 she was in the trio of jungle gods (That being elise, lee sin, and evelynn) the change to the jungle heavily restricted her power. She can barely survive through a clear and if a pink ward is left unchecked she can easily lose her stealth advantage. She is no longer tanky since they nerfed her. (Around post season 4 I believe.) With the change to the jungle and direct nerfs, eve really is lack luster at the moment.
@gavinfrings109 жыл бұрын
Top 5 Best/Worst Meta's
@ArcaneAzmadi9 жыл бұрын
I contest the inclusion of the Heimerdinger rework because it ultimately ended up pretty pointless. Yes the new model and voice was great and he's a lot more fun to play and arguably a lot more viable- but he's still a joke and a troll pick because, on a very fundamental level, Heim sucks. Admittedly this is because they gave him a slew of nerfs after the initial rework (that almost ALWAYS happens, unless the rework comes out crappy in the first place) but when the reworked champion is ONLY played for the short period where he's blatantly OP because they're still tuning him, the rework was a failure. I probably would have replaced it with the Soraka rework from 4.17 (somewhere high on the list) or possibly the Master Yi rework from 3.10 (somewhere low).
@Compa_Doom9 жыл бұрын
honestly still hate the new xerath. i hate how just super clunky he is now. i always loved how they would say that it's " too hard " to land his old stun.
@purbmeister9 жыл бұрын
Karma was a flop, Soraka and Veigar were pretty bad too:)
@dantewolfe68099 жыл бұрын
Yani Genev Soraka was a very good rework and is a pretty damn good support with a healthier and a lot more entertaining kit.
@dantewolfe68099 жыл бұрын
Pawlok 13 Hitting her Q isn't a matter of luck rather how good the Soraka is at predicting and baiting. Their is strategy involved with her heal. When to use it, who to heal, and when to heal a minion to screw opponents cs.
@dantewolfe68099 жыл бұрын
Pawlok 13 Soraka is a really good support for solo que and is very easy to play. She has a niche others can not fill and she has great zoning tools in her Q and E. If you can't land your Qs then you should get better at aimin and predicting. Spend some time with Soraka and you will see why she is good and if you can't you probably not that good to really form an opinion on the matter...
@dantewolfe68099 жыл бұрын
Pawlok 13 She is better if you build ap. Sightstone and Zeke's is a must. Lucidity is the go too boots but since Soraka will end up with over 40% CDR Mobility, Mercury, or Ninja boots are good too. For the gold item the coin line is the best as it will help you get in and out plus the 100% health/mana regen. Frost Queen's claim is alright if you want to play a little more aggressive and for the ap scaling. Any combination of Ardent Censor, Thornmail, Frozen Heart, Abyssal Scepter, Mikeal's Crucible, Rabadon's Deathcap, Locket of the iron solari, and Zhonya's Hourglass depending on what you and your team needs. Ap and support items are best for her as she scales better with them than health. If your teammates are also building Spirit Visage your enemies will have a hard time killing them. You only need to learn how to kit, position, and land her Qs to do good with her. She was very strong in the Tank Meta but she should still be good as assassins still haven't taken over the game yet.
@alicebehrens99298 жыл бұрын
Soraka now is more than a mage than anything else, but people seem to don't get it. AP, Cdr, mana regen and Magic pen are the MOST important itemizations on her. If you just build raw life and tank status, she will scale nothing from it, and mostly become useless. She needs the AP, she can be very agressive, she have very good poke, CC, zoning and AoE damage, not to mention the HUGE heals (for herself, with her W passive, and allies) and the global assists and saves. Soraka mid/top ftw
@cyriszx9 жыл бұрын
Ashe rework , was unneeded IMO Victor went from awesome , to super awesome Karma rework was by far the best thing ever (My FAV4 CHAMP) Forgot to mention Kayle rework ,
@dingil20528 жыл бұрын
Background Music????
@bradyrewell61309 жыл бұрын
Did he say the new Ryze rework was a disappointment? It was disappointing how Riot can't rework a champion without having to nerf them a lot after. But none the less new Ryze even after the nerfs is God Tier.
@schrio46538 жыл бұрын
Xerath update was the worst ever
@tarkin8438 жыл бұрын
Why?
@schrio46538 жыл бұрын
SpaceCow did you play the old xer?
@tarkin8438 жыл бұрын
Shrio He got reworked when Vel'Koz came out right? I started then...
@pixeldoom92988 жыл бұрын
I mean, his rework made him mor viable and stuff...but I felt that his old kit was more fun to play as.
@x3XDiablo9 жыл бұрын
This channel is very quickly becoming the "top 10 videos" one.
@cheeto99 жыл бұрын
I wish you told us what they were like before the update, like actually show us some ability descriptions
@action-wurm44749 жыл бұрын
Viktor wasn't a bad champion, in fact, I used him in pre-update to tryhard in rankeds when I was in midlane, since you couldn't lose with him. I am pretty bad the the new Viktor since his passive Item works only later in the game. Miss the old AP Tristana too :/
@DangerNoodless9 жыл бұрын
Maybe you should have mentioned more of the skills the champions had in their previous version in comparison to their current playstyle ;D
@YoNicePaprika8 жыл бұрын
i used to hate old karma bc one time i played against her and the other team was winning rlly hard so she just sold all her items and went full tank and i got rlly salty for some reason?
@intem3339 жыл бұрын
i can understand the karma rework making her a better champion, but it also made her boring as all get out... she lost her feel, and unique qualities... She may have been kinda weak, but that was mostly because the meta didnt favor her whatsoever. That was back when suppports weren't allowed to get any real items, and she was a very item dependent. I feel like old karma would be possibly over powered in todays meta. AOE % heal, great scaling with tank and ap items, and her old e, while extremely hard and quite frankly underwhelming, would be much better with the mobility creep we've seen since. I am, and will forever be, one of those traditional karma fans.
@salffds9 жыл бұрын
please don't read from wiki and talk here, kata was insanely good in lane that it was a bit too silly .Her Q did full damage on hit so she was able to farm harass with around double the damage on Q on live now and the bouncing was random which was harder to predict, her W when used with Q had a healing debuff so long that you can prema debuff with 10% cdr so any sustain champion was bad vs her. her E did around the same amount of damage as her W live and you couldn't just catch kata ever, since the cd was so short that she had it around 85% of the time in the lane. all of the is ok by me but when her Q was triggering spell vamp as a single target damage it was fuckin insane. really insane I mean really really insane. Q at level 7 heals her for around 80 hp her Q and she had it on a 7 sec cd was insane all these were post dodge removal funny how kata was an ad assassin but turned into an ap assassin, she had all of her spells ad scaling with a magic damage except for her E which scaled from ap. 1:1 but she was funny as hell now that I think about it xD
@vincentdarkrosrayne9 жыл бұрын
i'm so glad Soraka wasn't on this list. i feel like she's no where near as good due to the hp % damage heal. and her Q is really bad compared to what it used to be and the fact that it has a delay on the heal even at point blank range cast makes it hard to kite and take damage. the only good thing is the buff to her ult and her passive. i wonder if you'll do a top 10 worst champion reworks/updates.
@Durge2059 жыл бұрын
I remember when I heard news about the Viktor rework. I loved Viktor straight from the start when I was browsing the champs for a pick to play. I loved his former kit and mained him as I do now, but the current kit is better. Annnyway, I heard about the rework in the forums and it didn't sound too exciting to me. It definitely caught my eye, being he was a very unpopular champ at the time. When they officially announced that they are going to see this through, I had a serious case of nerd boner. It brought a lot of things that was wrong about his kit to the table and actually fixed them.
@hoopstar52549 жыл бұрын
Best rework so far is poppy she has everything she needed she needs to outplay someone to kill them but also needs to be outplayed to be killed
@Fabritox58 жыл бұрын
Was i the only main katarina pre rework that liked old katarina better and thinks her kit was way more powerfull?
@overnightsiren9 жыл бұрын
The Sivir update should have been much higher, IMHO.
@alextheodosiou8748 жыл бұрын
Yesterday I buyed Evelynn. And people told me she was good as a jungler. So after level 6 and so, in the bot lane I saw that the adc was super low. 29 hp. So I got down there and said "yeee heed I'm gonna get first blood!" And pop ult thinking only ult will be needed to kill her. So I pop ult, and the adc didn't die. I chased the adc and didn't get him/her, and the jungler killed me. Then I went afk the whole game and we lost.
@joshgreen45218 жыл бұрын
+Alex Theodosiou When she was reworked back then she her ult did up to 25% Max HP damage which was broken when it's AoE + it gave her 300 shield for every champion hit. So if she hit 5 she got 1500 in shield for 6 sec (I think it was). She was so ridicoulus and thankfully she got nerfed. Her ult is now dealing CURRENT health damage in stead of max health damage. It didn't ruin her, but it nerfed her potential of being a cleanup teamfighter (as you saw in the video). Her passive (the same today) made it nearly impossible to prevent her ganks/roaming - unless you invested in pink wards all the time. She got fed too easily and snowballed too easily as well.
@ZeroTheLelouch9 жыл бұрын
Heimgerdinger rework was on 3.13?
@jay_corncob77529 жыл бұрын
That katarina update was a bug. She was supposed to be deleted
@myrdin92169 жыл бұрын
Xerath? Are you kidding me? Before this pathetic update he was a beast. His stun was much, much better. His ulti had one of the highest dmg in the whole game and it was much wider. His W was one of the best skills in the whole game, no amount of mres could really affect him. You said that he had to be immobile to cast at long range. Yes, but W had a very short cd, so it was not a problem he had MS boost after it. Overall he was really great and they destroyed him by removing his mres penetration and giving him this shitty ulti which is very hard to land and which is not really usable in teamfights. Nowadays he is stronger in laning phase (which was still not bad), but much, much weaker in late.
@ajrocks9539 жыл бұрын
holy shit that thresh from the sivir clip was so good
@Ozhanseyhan269 жыл бұрын
R.i.P old gragas q does 1.5k damage ulti 2 k same time using pentakill fcking riot
@skullbro73489 жыл бұрын
***** thats fair XD
@1313eable8 жыл бұрын
I still like the old Xerath more
@justinjakeashton9 жыл бұрын
The new Ryze rework is good. People just dont know how his passive works and whines about losing to him in a 1v1.
@travisdavis1217 жыл бұрын
old xerath was really fun. New one you have to script to have as much fun and his new ult is pretty boring. little rain drops and shit
@LamunesADV9 жыл бұрын
For me, the BEST rework is for Rengar. No, for real, that was a total nerf, but a Rework sometimes is not for a champion to be new and edge. Old Rengar was STUPID to play, totally broken. When Riot rework his kit, well, he still do pretty OK till this day
@onegonearm9 жыл бұрын
Carlos Bacchin actually you only lvl'd Q once until you had nothing left to max because it had horrible scaling. The Rengar you're talking about is after they fixed his Q. He was total crap on release date. Went god-mode like 2 patches later.
@andrewzhang66689 жыл бұрын
The old Sion is way better lol. He use to be so good ap and even ad is good. His ult use to bring him so much life steal and attaxk speed. God I miss the old Sion :(
@Shaiking208 жыл бұрын
Old heimer was broken as shit... the rework is what pretty much made him a troll pick....
@vincenzomorelli27698 жыл бұрын
in case noone noticed it....thats a double ace right there ._. 3:57
@legitnamewhichislegit8 жыл бұрын
Yups! At that point the only ones playing are the minions
@maxbrown34189 жыл бұрын
is Sion still a good pick as of currently?
@HoDANG9 жыл бұрын
I prefered the old Sivir and the old Karma. I'm surprised Tryndamere isn't on this list.
@lukehanzon51768 жыл бұрын
1:30 I saw that Thresh auto...
@fanficologist66218 жыл бұрын
I only played against the old Karma once and the guy was stupidly strong.
@KindOldRaven8 жыл бұрын
+ĐỨc Phạm Karma's a dude? Mind blown...
@fanficologist66218 жыл бұрын
I meant the guy playing her =_=
@KindOldRaven8 жыл бұрын
ĐỨc Phạm This explains it all xD :D
@fanficologist66218 жыл бұрын
I was Ezreal at 2/3 of my health remaining while he was just 1 Q away from death. He flashed at me and used his shield thingy. I was left staring at the gray screen with mouth hanging open. Old Karma was the ultimate baiting champion.
@para1111118 жыл бұрын
+ĐỨc Phạm loved those baits!!! :D
@bexa33139 жыл бұрын
B4 eve rework, any eve player gets reported cuz she was so op -.- I rly hated her, I am so happy they reworked her , strong but not as b4 X_X
@matthewbache16398 жыл бұрын
"We are reworking champions to breath new life into them. What? Oh no, Yorick and Galio are fine..."