TOP 10 GOLF IRONS 2017

[@RickShielsPGA]

Hey guys thanks for watching the video! If you enjoyed HIT that like button! As I mentioned in the video, this is a list of golf clubs I HAVE TESTED and are still available right now! Some clubs I have not tested so I can not rank them in this list. To watch the full videos click here! kzbin.info/aero/PLKnkfgDBi62l-aoKQlICk_lFdAyqSYa7b

[@sca4au]

Rick Please re make this video - its really misleading to say top 10 irons for this product cycle then including full product lines that aren't even directly related ie the entire titleist lineup.. oh and also it seems a few people are vocalizing their interest in srixon. SRIXON Send this man your Products!! your loyal fans of tired of not being represented!

[@lucas.5288]

Rick Shiels Golf ok

[@bradhartman1378]

hey Rick I was hoping you could help me out I'm 25 yrs old. high handicap golfer. I have learned alot from your videos and continue to improve. I've been thinking bout doing a bag overhaul and was wondering if you could give me some ideas on what clubs I should try. I'm currently hitting with Driver- Grenade 2 3 wood-Grenade 2 irons and wedges-Taylormade Rocket blades I do like a soft feel when it comes my clubs

[@shanejones8386]

Rick Shiels Golf id love if you’d include price in these videos

[@davidrichard4300]

Rick, great job. I love how you catered this list to include everyone. I would love to see a top 10 irons of all time

[@MrJtin69]

Mizuno mp18 blades

[@andybgolf9260]

Rick I got a set of ping i200 in April and I have to say they are the best clubs I've ever owned, your right the are suited for a mass range of golfers. Cheers and keep up the great work. 🏌️⛳️💪

[@bevanboth9125]

hey Andrew, BeV here, I'm getting back into golf after a 3,5yrs layoff and looking to get back at it. I had an official 5 hcp and played with Ping G range... and pointers on the i200? thx

[@timmacivor1963]

Astounded that there is no mention of Srixon on this list.

[@royhobbs2678]

Started playing again after a few years off and your vids have been refreshing. The Reviews you do for all clubs are nice especially the little things you mention like Spin rate. So much there to think about as I start my next chapter in golf. Thanks again for all you do to keep us up at night watching the vids...

[@hollywood1513]

So glad you showed some love to the one length irons!

[@michaelvanoss9531]

Rick, Just purchased the Mizuno JPX 900 hot metal. My fitter didn't really suggest them for me either, but after the fitting we found that they were the best for my swing. Thanks for the great content. Keep up the great work.

[@nrs_207]

Curious what you didn’t like about the P770. Just put a set with KBS C Taper Lite X in my bag. Absolutely love the look, and of course they’re not too forgiving, but when you put a good swing on it’s so pure of a feel and a nice ball flight.

[@crunchyblack2224]

Nick Sabatine p770s are excellent irons and I'm surprised as well.

[@amgolfer3591]

I've read mixed things about the P770 and P750. Now, there seems to be a lot of hype and good reports about the new P790s.....very curious .

[@raginasianinvasion]

I think he didn’t like them because he humiliated himself hitting them in front of those reps in his review, poor swing day and he blames the equipment

[@jayharris7015]

I'm a 5 handicap and just switched to the m1 irons from Taylormade Tour preferred CBs. While the feel and distance has taken some getting used to, these clubs have changed my attitude and confidence with irons. Highly recommended.

[@300LongGun]

i hit the i200 today as ping was at our course doing some fittings. I loved them and will be upgrading next year!!

[@Ryasis12345]

When I was getting fitted, I tried the Cobra's and I did not like that idea. I ended up getting the Ping G400's during my fitting. It felt the best with a lightweight head and increased my distance on the testing machine over my store bought set of Wilson.

[@aaronholguin4835]

Watching this now to see what I can afford in 2022

[@BIGBALDYBEAR1]

Me too 👍

[@djchudsteeldevils6179]

Haha me too, in 2024

[@riagnol]

I think the Wilson FG is the best looking club from any angle. Tested at my club range and the 7 iron carry distance in between my current 7&8 TM Speedblades. However, Wilson loft is the same as a modern TM 8 iron and I prefer the flight and feel of the FG forged. Great video Rick.

[@tjmaloney6339]

Just bought a set off the ping i200's before this video came out, LOVE everything about them and couldnt be happier with my decision! Was debating between the i200 and mizuno jpx 900 forged, but took the ping route! 100% agree with this list.

[@KevinIole]

I got the PXG 0311 irons. Love them. The feel of the face is incredibly soft

[@MegaStreet11]

Going on looks I think the Wilson V6 have the PING i200 by a MILE. Too bad he hasn't tested Srixon, but wait... how has that not happened yet?

[@mwaqarafzal]

Callaway Apex 16 not on the list, the beat selling irons of 2017.

[@nickludwig4072]

Muhammad Waqar Afzal I thought the steelhead XR's were?

[@dawsonlafferty9772]

I love my Apex CF16's but maybe because they didn't come out in 2017 and are a bit older he didn't include them on the list.

[@andrewwolf4963]

they are on the 2016 list

[@danielbasco5638]

Purchased the i200 after your review.... Incredible pick. I have probably improved my game from a 12ish to a 9ish hándicap... and improving...

[@c.t9323]

Why do you never test Srixon irons? The 765's and 965's look and feel awesome.

[@yadthink]

Awesome video, Rick! Production quality is top notch. Loved the exploding numbers!

[@JohanSantanaRox]

Bought the i200's earlier this summer. Absolutely love them. Great feel for not being a forged iron.

[@cliveg8350]

Soooo glad the Ping came top of the list. Tested most of the top ten on a simulator with a fitting pro and yes ended up buying ping i two 200. Keep up the good work Rick

[@scptguy19]

Can you talk about shafts? I have recognized how important it is to have the engine fit to my swing. Especially looking at bend point and torque.

[@lawrencemacdonald9454]

Great review rick as always you are number 1 in club reviews online

[@austinprice5722]

I can really understand why Rick put the i200s in on #1. I came into the season this spring looking for new irons and I don't typically like the look of PING irons, but these ones looked pretty decent for PING. I am also usually on edge about them because I like very soft feel. My golf coach/fitter set me up with demos of 3 irons that he thought that I would like with the profile that I was looking for. I tried the PING i200, Cobra King Forged Tour, and the Mizuno MP-25. I hit the Cobra and the Mizuno first, and loved the feel of them, which made me think there's no way I'm gonna like going from forged to cast in the i200. I was pleasantly surprised with the i200. I hit about 10 shots with it to start, and my coach noticed that I was hitting them incredibly straight and out of the middle consistently. He and I both thought I was hitting them better than my old RSI 1 irons and better than any iron I have ever hit. After testing for a few more range sessions, I decided that the i200 was the best iron that I have ever hit. It doesn't have the softest feel as others, but to me as long as it performs well and you hit it well, that is a bigger factor. Since I got mine this spring, I have hit the most greens in regulation that I have ever hit, and I am now able to consistently hold a green. Again, Rick I agree with you on your choice for #1. The i200s cater to a HUGE level of golfers, because they are definitely more forgiving than they look. I would also like to add that I have only been playing golf for 2 years, been through 3 seasons and have had lessons from the get go. That being said, I do not strike the ball amazingly every time and if I can hit an iron this size so consistently at my level, I'd say they are pretty good!

[@Tomatohater64]

I liked the Wilson FG Tour V6 irons best of all. Here in Pittsburgh, most places sell 4-PW and a Gap wedge, that's 8 irons in all, for right around a thousand dollars - 125 dollars per iron. I would pony up the money and buy them.

[@jwinaz]

Just realized I have watched like 30 of your videos without subscribing. That's settled now. Keep up the good work.

[@cameronlee3050]

You should test old iron sets!! would love to know how they compare to the latest models! I currently play the R9TP irons and would love to see what the difference is seeing as they came out almost a decade ago

[@cheezburger6130]

I tested and Mizuno won me over.....great thing that there are so many great choices.......now get the one that you like and go have fun.

[@davidforde2459]

Bought the Sr version to replace my old clubs in Spain. I also bought the PING G iron for home play. There is very little difference in performance between the two. A softer feel off the PING G

[@Play2Win1958]

My PING i200's came in ( white dot ) gonna play a round this morning to see how they do and the driving range not bad

[@darrenbennett384]

Great review I'm a 17 handicap golfer and use the i200, I won't be 17 for long

[@tyleregan]

Great Honest Review Rick! Look forward this this every year!

[@doubleeaglebbq2822]

Very fair assessment. Good Job Rick. My personal opinion is Mizuno DOMINATES Ping, but top 5 is again, fair.

[@damienforrest3225]

Hi Rick. ..just purchased M1's...can't wait to get into them...thanks for all your reviews etc

[@TheBigDaveGas]

Just watched this video Rick, a couple of hours after picking up my new i200 irons from Am Golf - Seems like an excellent choice. Great video and guide as always.

[@robgom777]

I know I'm am one person in a massive golf world, but I used to play Mizuno MP-4's. I now play Srixon 765's. I WAS one of those die hard "nothing feels like a mizuno" kind of people. Well not anymore! Height, distance, AND feel/forgiveness!!! Just hope they keep dishing these kinds of irons out for years to come!

[@Mjwest23]

Have you tried the MP-18 and MP-18 SC yet? I HIGHLY recommend. I've tried 765 and the MP-18 SC. The MP-18 SC felt even better than the 765 and hit both extremely well. I'll be trying the MP-18 and 965 on Saturday as well and I'm sure those will feel even better. Will probably make a decision between the two and blend them. I've never been a Mizuno or Srixon guy, but I feel like their irons are superior and I'll most likely be bagging one of them.

[@pwillemsen1000]

Really wanted to like the Ping i200 and had good numbers on the launch monitor and the course. However, I had a much tighter dispersion with the taylormade p770s (same shaft). I ended up with a combo set; 4/5 irons in M1 for forgiveness (bent weak for gapping as these clubs fly!) and p770 from 6i to PW. Everybody is different and thus why fitting is so important. What works for one person doesn't necessarily work for the other.

[@mattpurcellheadgroundsmen]

Rick,,,,,,, you've got to put srixon 765/945 in that list

[@dekwon2980]

matt purcell love the feel on that 765

[@nathangrimes11]

matt purcell M

[@mattpurcellheadgroundsmen]

Nathan Grimes m ???

[@tjhorn8639]

He doesn't have them

[@MrRafico84]

Your eyes look soooo red. Long nights editing (my assumption), but your work is class. keep up the great work

[@robertstarkey8952]

I own a set of Iblades, and let me tell you that they have to be the best feeling, looking and sounding irons out there! I know exactly why you picked them at Number 1!

[@tray5765]

Rick it would be nice to see you test the Srixon Z range irons.

[@bfgolf]

I think the Wilsons look awesome

[@02PSU]

Mizuno JPX 900 Forged for me. Thanks for all your videos and being so informative.

[@golfironsets1056]

Another great review! I hope to read more of these throughout the year

[@sergebanjac5917]

I got my self a set of m1 irons and have to say the are by far my favorite set of irons to date. Should be In number 1

[@johnbachman8908]

I found this interesting. You put in multiple Callaways, Mizunos. Titleist and PXGs on each number. Why not the King Forged Tours with the one length?

[@joemartinez2730]

Rick I love my Mizuno Hot Metals feel sound and oh yes the Project X Rifle Shaft are amazing thanks for reviewing them they are my second Mizuno and nothing feels like them.

[@Struieboy]

I was wasting time putting off buying the Ping i200 but you've ended any doubts I had. Great review!

[@markevans4617]

Mark Blair Ive had the i200's in 4 thru 9 since they were initially released earlier this year and let me tell you... they are fantastic irons

[@amgolfer3591]

And so are the iBlade's---fantastic feel.....

[@stevenhogan5720]

Hi rick. I still play a set of 2010 tm cavity Burner Irons. I get 7 iron right around 163 ... My driver swing speed is about 104 . I've got 6 lessons and my goal is to get more Club head speed. Do you think I need to change shafts or just work on technique. I have 95 gram shafts ... and also have a six iron that is a CB by Titleist. I never filled out that set ... but think the CB may be the best set for me after I get more Club Head speed.

[@davidbarraza9446]

Great video Rick, keep up the great work.

[@johnzelenjak]

I play 716 AP1 and SM6 wedges and love them.

[@chrish8419]

Rick, are the i200 irons a direct replacement for the Ping i irons? I got these around 2 months before the i200 were announced and I'm thinking of upgrading??

[@GolfingMalky]

Great vlog Rick; covered a lot of ground there and an interesting final result. Can't wait to see the other version coming up; driver, putter etc. Cheers

[@MrUnoMIkeo]

Great video Rick, nice to see Benross getting recognition because they do make some great clubs.

[@johnderington7998]

Taylormade p770s Feel and shapeability are second to none. Not to mention its counterpart 750s are probably the winningest club on all tours this year. Bottom line they're pretty and work amazingly.

[@louispounds7486]

Tried many of those, but decided on Srixon Zs... absolutely amazing clubs.

[@b.b.8204]

Can you review the Tour Edge Exotic XJ1 driver please! This driver was used to set the woman's longest drive this year 406 yards.

[@t.j.hodnett9658]

I'd have to say my #1 is the JPX 900 Forged followed by the i200's, then the Srixon Z series

[@IntrepidGolfers]

In hindsight would you put the Taylormade P790 ahead of the M1?

[@tjbise1145]

And that's one reason why I have the i200/iblade in my bag right now!!! They are sweet

[@darrylgoodchild126]

Awesome review Rick, will help me when selecting my new clubs soon

[@jlmorenoc2000]

how would you mix up the ping irons? Maybe 3-4 in G400, 5-9 in i200 and PW and Gap in iblade? does this make sense Rick?

[@jlmorenoc2000]

?? ;)

[@tomward2393]

You need to a video trying to hit a long drive driver the ones with 3.5 degrees loft would be great viewing

[@pacino8612]

Wilson FG Tour look great in my opinion Rick. My next set will either be The Wilson FG Tour or the Cobra One length. Great video Rick. Cheers

[@keithfinley2939]

I would love to see you do a 18 hole head to head i200/iBlade combo vs Wilsons. This is how I picked my last pings. Play every shot twice (not Driver, 3w, 2i) and compare the scores. I would be willing to bet it's the Pings☺

[@ekphotography]

I am about to buy a set of M-1’s but worried about all the face cave in problems. I am currently deciding between Callaway APEX CF 16’s or M-1’s. Any suggestions which would be a better buy? Where I live there is no way of shipping back m-1’s for repair. Thanks for any help...

[@therookiemistake9714]

Rick Shiels: why is the ping i200 at the top of the list but not in the bag? Would like to know that. Thanks from the Netherlands:)

[@johnbial]

I'm thinking of getting a new putter. Platinum Spider or O-Works 1w?

[@eastonmartin8700]

AvoidableChip o works 1w, thats what i have and i love it.

[@omaoileoinb9]

Do you have i200 in the bag? Thought you have the Wilson's in?

[@MrOwenagetv]

I think the Wilsons look really nice.

[@andrewnelson7219]

I've gone for a set of benross I think they are just quality and that's irons, wood, putter, haven't tried the wedges yet but I would really like to 🏌️‍♂️⛳

[@justinstephenson9360]

Will be changing irons shortly so this helped me narrow down the options. As a mid (but improving) handicapper I think I will go for either the m1s or the JPX forged: cannot get the srixon's, not prepared to pay for the Epic or PXGs, really dislike the look of the Pings. Apex is another option. Tried them a couple of months ago and stupidly long: probably 15 yards (ie a full club) longer than my old Yonex's - then again the lofts such that the 7i has same loft as my Yonex 6i. Rick: Will you also do a hybrid top 10? Am thinking about carrying 2 hybrids, 5-9i, 4 wedges, driver & 3w.

[@pb3xunleashed]

It's been a pretty shitty year for irons, with the only sets that appeal to low-mid handicappers being the jpx, the wilsons, and the srixon 765's. Everything else has been focussed on stronger lofts and massively wide toplines and soles. I'll stick with my old Hogan PTX's for another season thanks...

[@hamiltonmcnaughton4828]

Pb3X I agree, you should also consider titleist too. The ap2s and MB's are not exactly meant for high handicappers.....

[@howlingwolf125y]

Problem with the Wilson irons is that you can NOT custom order them. I need about a 3 or 4 degree upright lie angle w/ graphite shafts - and I looked but it seems like you can not custom order them like that. That is a really shame because I would love to order a set of Wilson irons.

[@bigdisme5622]

Maybe if your that good your Sponsors should be sending you a new set every year.

[@labarronroberts5080]

Can you do a review of the Cleveland HB Launcher Irons?

[@johndonohoe3778]

Are you playing the v6 or the i200's now Rick. I'm looking for new irons and have hit many on the list. I'm leaning towards the AP2. Now I have to try thy the i200's! 🏌️😎Thanks Rick outstanding

[@magicmike1122]

Can you do a review on the TopFlite XL.

[@home4ya]

@rickshiels - if you were a 6 and your current i25s were awesome when playing twice per week are now not so awesome only playing twice per month. What iron would you play that is NOT a shovel but more forgiving than the i25s? I don't mind med-thich top lines but don't like huge offsets, low-mid offsets ideal and a progressive set a must, easier long irons and less offset short irons. My guess is to try JPX900 Hotmetal, 716AP1, Ping 400, and TM M2? How would you rank those 4 by progressive, over all forgiveness as top 2 needs and feel/looks not as important? Cheers from AZ!!

[@浅井弘幸-g2b]

I enjoyed your video every time form Japan.

[@davgol97]

Callaway Apex CF16?

[@Mr621brown]

davgol97 in black!!

[@davgol97]

LB The Apex's are not only good in looks but performance aswell. Should've been in top 10

[@koaggie12]

Just need callaway to pump out probably 2 more sets of irons to lower the price of the Apex's and I'm getting those bad boys

[@matyunadauddaud6642]

Kyle O'Br

[@mikeykam1]

They're on his best list of 2016

[@deeperroots7112]

wondering if you're going to review the mp-18 irons?

[@jamesdann4298]

Any chance of getting your hands on and reviewing some Bridgestone irons? Just got the JGR Forged irons and they're superb!

[@MardyBum100291]

Absolutely right on the i200. What a set of irons they are, my Dad has bought some recently and they've changed his game completely, and he really isn't a raver about clubs. Hell, got me to buy a set, the turf interaction is like nothing else in history. Unbelievable.

[@bigdisme5622]

I call BS on this comment. The way you are so excited your dad has a set then all of a sudden you bought a set as well, it doesn't make sense. Calling a lie. sorry.

[@FloridaManRacer]

I feel like the Taylormade M2's and Epic Irons from a looks standpoint are VERY similar. I bought the M2's, never hit Epic's no clue if the feel is similar or not, but looks wise if you pulled the logos off them, I feel like you could confuse people...

[@aidanscott4954]

Rick, Have you tried hitting HONMA irons?

[@pdecker]

I have a few things to add. 1. I love the look of the Callaway Steelhead Pro irons. I've hit them in a simulator and they feel good too. But, they are no different in size than the non-Pro version. Side by side they are exactly the same size. Sitting behind the ball they do have a thinner top line, which I like. The specs also show them with a 1 degree weaker loft than the non-Pro version, which I also like, and a 1/2 inch longer shaft as standard. Yes, I'm saving my money for a Christmas present. 2. I'd like to see some Bridgestone irons reviewed. They look interesting if a bit expensive. 3. I haven't seen any ball reviews or comparisons. That's a very personal thing, but would still like to see some. Right now I play either Bridgestone B330-RX or TaylorMade Project (a). 4. One more thought. Do some throwback reviews. Hit some old wooden drivers and use a wound ball. It'd be interesting to see your reaction. I'm old enough to have hit those until my twenties. Thanks for the videos. Keep them coming.

[@mod1433]

Please review the Srixons rick. I game them and they are elite

[@johnmonteagudo8164]

I'd love to see the same list for Drivers and fairway woods.

[@peteconklin6781]

Hey Rick, just discovered your channel. Subbed immediately. Love the comparisons(shaft flex was an eye-opener) love the reviews ....and you've got a fantastic swing that lends credibility to it all. Nice work!

[@hamiltonmcnaughton4828]

Ping, Titleist and and Mizuno irons are great quality every year. They should be in top 3. The Wilsons and p770s are also great.

[@robbiehiggins3260]

Love these videos thanks Rick!!!

[@TheRealChetManley]

Supprised no srixon... personally I went JPX900...I like the pings a lot too...

[@GregBatten]

Rick, love your videos. Suggestion; make a Top 10 Irons video that first shows how the irons rate on performance, then adjust their final Top 10 ranking based on price and then looks. Some of us, are more concerned about performance than the other two factors and after watching your video, I'm not sure which irons are the best irons, regardless of price. Thanks!

[@williamrussell9114]

So it the i200s replacing the Wilson's in your bag?

[@Skitidetdennis]

Love this kind of videos!

[@gaffs82]

No Callaway Apex? Crazy! I know it wasn't released in 2017, but neither were the Titleist 716's. No Srixon love either? GolfWRX is going crazy about the 565's.

[@TheSportfane]

Strange list.. for example when you made your review about the Cobras, the forged Tour king standard length got a better review than the one length but they are not in this list..🤔.

[@jamesbieler9288]

Great video Richard

[@kevinfitzgerald7137]

Rick just watching kids at Agusta doing Drive Put and Chip do we have anything like this in GB . If not you should get it sorted people listen to you.. They are Brilliant