TOP 3 Best Members Who Owned Each AESPA Era (Until Girls)

[@KimLFKpop]

This is special video for Aespa Comeback 🥳 The ranking in this video is based on your votes If you haven't voted yet, you can vote here forms.gle/cgXcLT3pjpyWzDTj7

[@dububerry1412]

Okayy💖💖

[@jenniekimvideos4258]

Yeahhh

[@Xiner.oya0704]

Do WJSN please! You are my fav IDOL! You are so successful and I love your opinion!

[@yszeeiahlorraynnequintero4494]

Giselle shine in every era, karina shine in every era, winter shine in every era and ningning shine in every era i love all of them❤❤

[@Sour-Rosy]

Ikr

[@AiMegumi2005]

Totally accepting it

[@YusufBahadrDemir-pq9hu]

Everybody is fell in love with Giselle's voice in Black Mamba

[@Kai-ow4ek]

Giselle’s voice in black mamba’s bridge was 🤯 so goodd

[@supershyhaerin]

@@Kai-ow4ek that was winter not giselle

[@supershyhaerin]

I agree her voice is amazing

[@rey7402]

@@supershyhaerin i think she was talking bout the backing vocal, cause it was Giselle (;

[@supershyhaerin]

@@rey7402 oh

[@blacktothepink3571]

For me Black mamba : Karina Forever : Winter Next level : NingNing Savage : Giselle/Winter Dreams come true : NingNing/Giselle Life’s too short : Giselle/Winter Girls : Winter Winter is not my bias but just how versatile this girl is she can own any concept 💕

[@DancingZincaOfficial]

I have the same opinion except for Life's too short I would put Karina/Winter

[@KPOPBIASES]

Samee

[@sweetcandystan8493]

sad that Giselle doesn't have an era alone

[@Iloveyouruikamishiro]

I think Ningning shines in every era, she is so perfect

[@markitandD.O.it1]

True

[@robertoruiperez4085]

My bias

[@mayalaya5281]

Right !!

[@akarshitthakur462]

Yuk Ning ning bitch 😎

[@akarshitthakur462]

Plastic version of jennie

[@abdulmomin8506]

Karina actually shine's in every song🤩

[@gamerlyga1994]

*aespa actually shine on every song ♥️♥️😎😎

[@Ukmmmm]

Yes, Karina

[@lolll6310]

@@gamerlyga1994 agree, but there are so many comments like this on other members too, but when there is this comment for Karina, people like you pop up from nowhere and say this

[@boyyyo]

IN FACT, WINTER NAILED EVERY ERA BECAUSE SHE IS SO SHINING AND TALENTED.

[@Fernando-op9to]

True

[@bread3987]

more like because she have the most lines and center time along with karina 👀👀

[@zhariffa]

TRUEEEEE

[@sencone.9674]

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@boyyyo]

@@bread3987 she will be forever shining in every situation, no matter what

[@TristanLoh4200]

Winter's voice is extraordinary one of my fav voices in Kpop!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@SmeomD]

All members are perfect in their own... Giselle and winter owns maximumly Well so Giselle got less lines but still she have some things that she own herself 💗 she is well perfect her rap is in all,her vocal is stable, her dance is good,her visual is insane and the only member who is fluent in English. Savage - Giselle owns 😭 Life too short - Giselle owns 💗

[@hyunlixxie2662]

giselle definitely didn’t own savage

[@frantcareer]

@@hyunlixxie2662 the voting says giselle owned savage. Argue with the wall okay.

[@MoonlightSwiftie1989]

@@hyunlixxie2662 facts

[@richachauhan3189]

@@hyunlixxie2662 it goes from opinion to opinion, but i think she does own it

[@markitandD.O.it1]

@@richachauhan3189 i agree with u

[@mybmyacc]

I think they all shined in their own way in every era. I can't really rank them, because It'll be biased because Winter has my heart every time.

[@СумаяХусенова-и9е]

Agree with you, she's amazing

[@MoonlightSwiftie1989]

Ningning and Winter’s vocals are amazing

[@thaonguyenphan9012]

In fact, Karina just shines in every songs of Aespa

[@thedivinefemininev]

Perkod✨💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻

[@seulmiseforever9603]

My opinions did change a bit: Black Mamba: *1. Karina* 2. NingNing 3. Winter Forever: *1. Winter* 2. NingNing 3. Giselle Next Level: *1. NingNing* 2. Winter 3. Karina Savage: *1. Winter* 2. Giselle 3. Karina Dreams Come True: *1. Karina* 2. Giselle 3. NingNing Life’s Too Short: *1. Winter* 2. NingNing 3. Karina Girls: *1. Giselle* 2. Winter 3. Karina

[@wwrtiyu]

Actually Life's too short Giselle's era but i agree

[@lilofication]

girls ?? Giselle?? 😭 what

[@myab866]

@@lilofication yes i love giselle and winter in this era

[@myab866]

@@lilofication do u have any problems? You can tell

[@lilofication]

@@myab866 no you can not... karina, ningning & winter outshined her

[@s.l5905]

For me: Black Mamba :Karina Forever :Winter Next level :Ningning Savage:Winter/Karina/Giselle Dreams come true:Karina Life’s too short :Giselle Girls:Karina/Winter

[@jsthee]

I think giselle's shine and owned each era,she's a goddess.

[@Sour-Rosy]

Ikr

[@AnzzCheatedOnMarkWithHaechan]

Agree 🔥

[@thinkabouttzu7460]

Ningning and Winter voice really soft, Karina and Giselle rap so amazing♡

[@khushig8692]

I think winter shined the most in next level imo

[@_sunoocutie_8796]

agreed, her fancams got so much views during next level era. Her lines is also iconic

[@ValentinaFlowers]

​@@_sunoocutie_8796 well cuz she gets like second most lines, most center, even though she has no stage presence

[@itzykep1ianonceteume28]

Let's all agree winter shine in all era's

[@illegaluser69]

Yeah, the producers don't have to push her to shine bc she'll shine anyways with her talents

[@Basdoesdropout]

No

[@supershyhaerin]

Yeah

[@itzykep1ianonceteume28]

@@Basdoesdropout you need to get life cause life is to short

[@kimnoor6182]

yes

[@smh3388]

*According to the Kim LF Kpop* *Black Mamba* Winter - 1, Ningning - 2, Karina - 3 *Forever* Giselle - 1, Ningning - 2, Winter - 3 *Next Level* Karina - 1, Winter - 2, Ningning - 3 *Savage* Karina - 1, Winter - 2, Giselle - 3 *Dreams Come True* Giselle - 1, Karina - 2, Ningning - 3 *Life's too short* Karina - 1, Winter - 2, Giselle - 3 *Girls* Giselle - 1, Karina - 2, Winter - 3 Final Score: 1. Winter (13) 2/3. Karina/Ningning (10) 4. Giselle (9)

[@MeshaaL2000]

GIRLS for me : 1- NINGING 2 - WINTER 3 - KARINA 4 - GISELLE

[@anastasiia_zasiekina]

Giselle girls💚 rock part is incredible 💚

[@wroseblackpink1880]

In Black Mamba Giselle is at least number 3 cause she was so beautiful with her blonde hair and that was the reason she became my bias (my bias is now NingNing but I am talking abt the past)

[@lilofication]

when watching black mamba in my opinion giselle was almost non visible. yeah she was pretty, but honestly she the one who standed out the less, i don't even remember her catching my attention before savage tbh

[@wroseblackpink1880]

@@lilofication yes, maybe, but when I watched for the first time I wasnt impressed by her with the brown hair but when the blonde hair appeared I didn't ever recognised her and I am pretty sure that if she goes blonde again she will gain more popularity or smth

[@lilofication]

@@wroseblackpink1880 wasn't the blonde hair a wig 😭

[@wroseblackpink1880]

@@lilofication Yes, I think it was, Idk why I said "again" but I mean, she should appear with blonde hair again cause in my opinion she looks better

[@wroseblackpink1880]

@@lilofication I just find out it wasn't a wig;)

[@supershyhaerin]

IMO: Black Mamba 1. Karina 2. Ningning 3. Winter 4. Giselle Forever 1. Winter 2. Ningning 3. Giselle 4. Karina Next level 1. Ningning 2. Winter 3. Karina 4. Giselle Savage 1. Winter/Giselle 2. Winter/Giselle 3. Karina 4. Ningning Dreams come true 1. Winter 2. Ningning 3. Giselle 4. Karina Life’s too short 1. Giselle 2. Karina 3. Ningning 4. Winter Girls 1. Winter 2. Karina 3. Giselle 4. Ningning

[@twicemisbebes8589]

My opinion the era Black Mamba: Karina Forever: Winter Next Level: NingNing Savage: Giselle/Winter Dreams come true: NingNing Life too short: Giselle Girls: Winter/Giselle

[@lioness6995]

Winter really is the ace of this group and shines in every era

[@gachaspaceangels5154]

Karina? Isn't she a ace?

[@jeannedemba6120]

The ace is karina winter is all rounder

[@cutiebunny8890]

@@jeannedemba6120 it’s her opinion and I am agree with her But i respect your opinion ^^

[@ValentinaFlowers]

well cuz she gets like second or first most lines, most center, even though she has no stage presence

[@Lixoki]

I think winter own life too short era and giselle/winter own girls era

[@MYBLINK_w]

Winter being in every era happy for her pretty vocal, Dance Skill, Iconic, Rapping skills and also all member shine alots too happy for all member shine and era

[@arxxdy9465]

Winter shines in every era❤️‍🔥

[@lunarsaystostanloona]

my opinion: black mamba era- karina runner up- winter forever era- winter runner up- giselle next level era- ningning runner up- giselle dreams come true era- ningning runner up- karina savage era- giselle runner up- winter life’s too short era- karina runner up- ningning girls era- winter runner up- giselle i personally think that both savage and girls era are interchangeable and that both winter and giselle slayed both eras 😁

[@daisy_u520]

Agree, except life to short, i think giselle (1), karina (2)

[@Lixoki]

I think in girls 1)winter 2)giselle 3)karina 4)ningning I cant choose between winter and giselle

[@myab866]

Totally agreed

[@k-day1]

Finally someone who appreciate Giselle in Savage

[@yuqisae]

For Me (It can be same :) ) Black Mamba: Karina (She has so much shined in this song, we can see her vocals, dance skills so much in this song. She was in all of in dance parts and she was in EVERYWHERE in MV.) Forever: Winter (She has so much line in this song. Her voice color is so much matching in this concept. We just can see what good her vocal are.) Next Level: Ningning (OMG her lines was addicted and her voice was so good. And her red hair is EVERYTHING, she is really looking like Ariel.) Savage: Giselle (OMG her raps are so good and actually her adlibs in the last chorus was godly, and her first rap was … OMG!) Dreams Come True: Karina/Ningning (Ningning has the hardest parts and godly adlibs and most lines and she used her deep voice. And also, Karina has a so much iconic raps and so much good vocals in this song. How can I choose one from this duo, they are so good when it’s coming to own a era.) Life’s Too Short: Karina/Giselle (Giselle has great adlibs and vocals, also a “Some people are so mean, all behind a phone screen, when we tryna live our lives”. Also, Karina having perfect high notes and vocals. How can I choose?) Girls: Winter (One word for this comeback: WINTER. Her outfits in this era is so good, her lines, high notes, raps, adlibs, vocals and also center in the dance break is enough for having the era.)

[@adxrebella8028]

i think winter got first for savage

[@sourcandy8806]

I do totally agree that Ning Ning owned next level era for two reasons 2 . Her amazing vocals 1 . Her red hair 😀 Really she was too stunning with red hair literally she is too beautiful with it and i knew aespa for the first time in next level era bcz Ning Ning attracted me with her beauty in red hair 🙂🤍

[@Hritwik007]

My Aespa bias is Giselle

[@miakayuki1068]

Me.. Black Mamba- Karina Next Level- NingNing Savage- Winter Dreams Come True- Ningning Life's to Short- Karina Girls- Winter

[@azzahralubnaayofarra7387]

Me too

[@midori26]

BM - Karina, Ningning, Winter Forever - Winter, Giselle, Ningning NL - Ningning, Karina, Winter Savage - Giselle, Winter, Karina DCT - Ningning, Karina, Giselle Life's too Short - Giselle, Winter, Karina Girls - Karina, Giselle, Winter Is era just based on mv or the whole promotion period? Because I think if it's based on the whole promotion period Ningning and Karina are the constant in it.

[@wysse_beats]

Agree with everything but I feel like in Dreams come true Winter really shined more and was given many highlight parts

[@daniellxnder]

I'm just getting into aespa and this is exactly the type of video I'm looking for! Their evolution in each era

[@louvreangel]

Top 1s for me for every era is: Black Mamba: Karina💫 Forever: Winter🌼 Next Level: Ningning 💯 Savage: Bruh, come on like... obviously Giselle💯 Girls: All of them equally because daaaamn that song goes hard💥💥

[@kimnoor6182]

WINTER IS THE ACE.

[@niniekim7757]

Facts Black Mamba - karina Forever - winter (the members also said it was winter who shined the most here) Next Level - ningning Savage - giselle (everybody look at me) DCT - everyone LTS - everyone (fight me) Girls - winter

[@srizasutradhar2532]

In my opinion Black mamba: Karina Next level: Ningning Savage: Winter and Giselle Girls: Ningning

[@taemin626]

winter she is ace show her skills

[@shouqsalman63]

IMO: Black mamba: Karina (her lines were the most memorable for me) Forever: Winter (all her lines were amazing imo Next level: Ningning (Her hair that era says it all and her lines were I C O N I C) Savage: Winter (Savage fells very robotic and winter moves and acts almost like an AI) DCT: Ningning/winter (I was wrecked by Ningning here but winters lines are all memorable) LTS: Giselle: (She is the only English speaking member so she mostly stood out to me) Girls: Giselle/winter (Giselles raps were so good and winters lines too)

[@K_Megaverse8721]

IMO Top 1 in each era Black mamba: Karina Forever: Winter Next level: NingNing Savage: Giselle Dreams come true: Karina Life's too short: Giselle Girls: Winter

[@MadaraxUchiha]

Yes they all shined in each era and MV lol

[@Hee.ariiishiii]

For me Black mamba : Karina Forever : Winter Next level : Karina Savage : Giselle Dreams come true : Ningning / Winter Life's too short : Giselle Girls : Karina Illusion : Ningning / Karina ❤️🌙🌟🦋 Aespaaaaaa

[@Lixoki]

I think in dct 1)ning yi zhou 2)kim min jeong 3)aeri uchinaga 4)yu ji - min

[@volzkaiya]

Girls is for sure Winters Era

[@jedzamir601]

My bias is Giselle and I felt really bad for her because when her first era (savage) came out that's when her issue about the n word came, i felt so bad for her. And you where right that life's too short was her era because she received the most hate and she is also being mocked and bad mouthed by so many cruel people, so she bring a message about her haters, Giselle never gives up! Fighting! 💪

[@minakumari5824]

I think Gissle shines in every song

[@Khadti]

I want Giselle’s part for more 😢

[@carlosflorentin5524]

Imo Black mamba: 1- Karina 2- Ningning 3- Winter Forever: 1- Ningning 2- Winter 3- Giselle Savage: 1- Ningning 2- Winter 3- Karina Drems come true: 1- Winter 2- Ningning 3- Karina and Giselle Next level: 1- Winter 2- Ningning 3- Karina Girls: 1- Winter 2- Karina 3- Ningning and Giselle

[@lailiecarrillo]

for me, black mamba:karina/ninging (tbh they all shined in this era too) forever:winter (i love her voice in ballads) next level:they all shined so much in this era but i’m leaning towards ningning savage:same with next level but i’m leaning towards giselle dreams come true: they all shined so much😭 i’m just going to say winter/ningning/karina (actually all of them tbh i can’t chose) life’s too short:winter illusion:again they all shined so much but i’m leaning towards winter/karina girls:karina/winter

[@jisooyaa2329]

I'll be biased, but Winter always stood out in every era

[@Moonwalkmj]

My opinion :) Black Mamba = 1) Karina 2) Ningning 3) Winter Forever = 1) Winter 2) Ningning 3) Giselle Next level = 1) Ningning 2) Giselle 3) Winter Savage = 1) Giselle 2) Winter 3) Karina Dreams come true = 1) Ningning 2) Karina and Giselle 3. Winter Life's too short = 1) Winter 2) Ningning 3) Karina and Giselle Girls = 1) Ningning 2) Karina 3) Winter (even though Winter have a lot of good parts)

[@fallenking9752]

It's so hard because they literally all ate and left no crumbs in each era but for me with a warning of being a struggling NingNing/Giselle bias Black Mamba: NingNing the high note period. Forever: Giselle really surprised me with how amazing her voice is and made me want to hear her singing more. Next Level: NingNing with honorable mention of Winter, Ningning had me hooked after the "Naevis Calling" switch, Winter just because of the way she said *"Nexst Levul"* 😂 Savage: Giselle/NingNing honorable mention Karina Giselle just ATE with her rapping no questions asked, everything combined with high note on bridge just screamed sickening. It was Karina's "I'm a Savage" part she sang with so much soul, I could feel it.😭 Dreams Come True: NingNing/Winter honorable mention Giselle NingNing was just angelic throughout the whole video visuals and vocals everything, with Winter the switch after Giselle's heavenly "Twilight Zone" moment had me shook for a while. Giselle once again eating with her vocals. Life's Too Short: Winter/Giselle I'm sorry but combined with the vocals Winter looked way too adorable with the bunny ears. Even though imo Giselle didn't get that many lines wasn't too bad though, her part served and was so catchy to me. Girls: Winter/Karina honorable mention Giselle and NingNing cause it almost gave me a headache trying to decide. Winter just plain devoured. I'm very sure it was Karina with the last run of "We them Girls" and her part with Naevis my goodness, at this point just take my wig. With Giselle I just loved her attitude and oufits in it, her first rap absolutely ate one of my fav parts, NingNing just gave me everything I needed, really tied the song together for me.

[@leotaman8555]

My Opinion: Black Mamba: 1. Karina 2. Ningning 3. Winter Forever: 1. Winter 2. Ningning 3. Giselle Next Level: 1. Ningning 2. Karina 3. Winter Savage: 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Ningning Dreams come true: 1. Winter 2. Ningning 3. Karina Life's too short: 1. Ningning 2. Karina 3. Winter Girls: 1. Winter 2. Giselle 3. Karina Poor Giselle but this is my opinion

[@TWICE__Ot9]

For me: Blackmamba:Karina Forever:Winter Next Level:Karina Savage:Winter Dream comes true: Winter/Ningning Girls:Winter Spicy:Winter Drama: Winter/Karina Supernova:Karina/Winter Armmegdon:Giselle My bias is winter and you'll guys said it so biased but its my opinion❤ Im My and even before I know aespa I heard Winter's partsi n shorts/reels and tiktok so much so, I said that this girl shoud bbe my bias in their group thats why Love you

[@luiz-lu5ey]

for me Black Mamba 1. NingNing 2. Karina 3. Giselle Forever 1. Winter 2. Giselle 3. NingNing Next Level 1. Winter 2. Giselle 3. Karina Savage 1. Giselle 2. Winter 3. Karina Dreams come true 1. NingNing 2. Karina 3. Giselle Life's too short 1. Karina 2. NingNing 3. Winter Girls 1. Karina 2. NingNing 3. Winter

[@nehalshahriyar3426]

My opinion about the combacks Black mamba 1)karina 2)ningning 3)winter Next level 1)giselle 2)karina 3)ningning Savage 1)giselle/karina 2)ningning 3)winter Girls 1)karina 2)winter 3)giselle

[@saraciaoxd4751]

I’ll probably be the only one but in my op NL karina 1

[@annitacharalambous1421]

Lets just be honest we all love aespas mvs and concept

[@irene4705]

Imo Black mamba: ningning Savage: winter/karina Next level: karina/ningning Girls: giselle Dreams come true: winter

[@anapimenta2465]

Me : Blackpink: 1. Karina 2. Ningning 3. Winter Next Level 1. Ningning 2. Karina 3. Winter Savage 1. Winter 2. Karina 3. Giselle Girls 1. Winter 2. Giselle 3. Karina/ Ningning Drama 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Ningning/ Giselle

[@zepeto.princess]

My opinion 1. Black mamba : Karina 2. Forever : Winter 3. Next level : Ningning 4. Sevage : Giselle 5. Dreams come true : Giselle/Winter 6. Life too Short : Giselle 7. Girls : Winter/Giselle Don't hate opinion please.....

[@daisy_u520]

Agree

[@xoenthusiast6477]

Black mamba 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Ning Forever 1. Winter 2. Ning 3. Gigi/Karina Next level 1. Ning 2. Karina 3. Winter DCM 1. Winter 2. Giselle 3. Ning Savage 1. Giselle 2. Winter/Karina 3. Ning LTS 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Ning/Gigi Girls 1. Rap line 2. Winter 3. Ning

[@vim2339]

Nining and winter always shine in every era

[@xoenthusiast6477]

Karina is the real ACE of aespa.

[@woojin2229]

For me Black Mamba: 3. Winter 2. NingNing 1. Karina Forever: 3. Giselle 2. Winter 1. NingNing Next Level: 3. Karina 2. NingNing 1. Winter Savage: 3. Karina 2. Giselle 1. Winter Dreams Come True: 3. Giselle 2. NingNing 1. Karina Life's Too Short: 3. Karina 2. Winter 1. Giselle Girls: 3. NingNing 2. Giselle 1. Karina/Winter (Honestly I think it's everyone's era)

[@elenaryu_yawnzzn]

next level 1. Giselle 2. winter 3. karina savage 1. winter 2. Giselle 3. karina dreams come true 1. winter 2. Giselle 3. ning ning

[@azzahralubnaayofarra7387]

My opinion Black Mamba : Karina, Winter, Ningning Forever : Winter, Ningning, Giselle Next Level : Ningning, Karina, winter Savage : Giselle, Karina, Ningning Dreams Come True : Ningning, Winter, Giselle Life's Too Short : Karina, Winter, Ningning Girls : Winter, Giselle, Karina

[@vanshika2135]

Imo Next level: 1. Giselle 2. Ningning 3. Karina Savage 1. Karina 2. Giselle 3. Winter/Ningning Dreams come true: 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Ningning Girls: 1. Karina 2. Giselle 3. Winter Same ranking for Black mamba, forever and lts though

[@sanzu6697]

My Opinion Black mamba :Karina winter Ningning Forever :winter Ningning Giselle Next level :Ningning winter Karina Savage : Giselle Karina Ningning Dreams come true : Karina Ningning Giselle Life’s too short : Giselle Karina Winter Girls : Giselle Karina Ningning

[@yves4428]

my opinion - black mamba: ningning forever: winter next level: karina savage: giselle dreams come true: ningning illusion: karina life's too short: giselle girls: winter

[@dairynehyun2122]

Black Mamba: Karina Forever: Winter Next Level: Winter/Ningning but (W gets the hype the most) Dreams Come True: Karina Savage: Winter/Giselle Life's too short: Giselle/Winter Illusion: Winter Girls: Winter Tbh, Winter always shines on their comebacks, she's insanely charismatic.

[@itzykep1ianonceteume28]

Can you do top3 members who own each oh my girl era until Real love?

[@kitsovna]

MY TOP bm 1. Ningning 2. Winter 3. Karina forever 1. Winter 2. Ningning 3. Karina 4. Giselle nl 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Ningning savage 1. Winter 2. Ningning 3. Karina 4. Giselle dct 1. Ningning 2. Karina 3. Winter 4. Giselle lts 1. Winter 2. Ningning 3. Karina 4. Giselle girls 1. Winter 2. Ningning 3. Karina 4. Giselle

[@JustAnotherBlink]

Black mamba - karina & ningning (i didnt notice winter much back then) Next Level - Karina & winter Savage - winter & ningning Girls - winter & karina

[@mxmcelestine6210]

they're all talented but damn winter and karina are aces

[@zhonglieiskool9696]

Love u 😍

[@jennierubyjane9997]

My opinion Black mamba: Karina Forever: Winter Next Level: NingNing Savage: Winter Dreams come true: Karina Life's too short: I no have idea... OT4? Girls: Karina

[@ok-jl5ww]

dream comes true is winters era

[@em_mmeow]

black mamba - karina forever - ningning + winter next level - ningning savage - winter dreams come true - karina + giselle girls - giselle

[@AnzzCheatedOnMarkWithHaechan]

Giselle has been shining since NL era.. Am so proud of her growth and improvement.. She can really fit well in any concept 🔥

[@Alicia-mn1cn]

para mí lo pienso así Black mamba : Karina Forever : NingNing Next level : Winter Savage : Giselle Dreams come true : NingNing Life’s too short : Karina Girls : Winter

[@k_.explorer]

For me it's: Black Mamba - Karina Forever - Winter Next Level - Karina / Ningning Savage - Winter Dreams Come True - Ningning Life's Too Short - Giselle Girls - Giselle ____ Everyone has 2 eras for me

[@moo.0j]

imo (ot4): black mamba: karina forever: winter next level: ningning savage: giselle dreams come true: winter life's too short: giselle girls: winter / karina

[@petyay.2485]

For me all of the 3 girls - Karina, Winter and NingNing own an era but I cannot rank Giselle high because her presence is not strong like the rest of the members :/ Example is her part at 4:56 with a blank face stare at camera that she does all the time. This is my opinion I really love her but I want her to improve and shine more ♡

[@dishawale5588]

Giselle looks really different in every comeback don't know why

[@dishawale5588]

🔥🔥

[@vlovesvtw]

Mine Black Mamba : 1.Karina 2.Ningning 3.Winter Forever : 1.Winter 2.Ningning 3 Giselle Next Level : 1.Ningning 2.Winter 3.Karina Savage : 1.Giselle 2.Karina 3.Winter Dreams Come True 1.Ningning 2.Karina 3.Giselle Life's Too short 1.Giselle 2.Karina 3.Winter Girls 1.Karina 2.Giselle 3.Winter

[@karinano1stan]

black mamba: 1. ningning 2. karina 3. winter forever: 1. winter 2. ningning 3. giselle next level: 1. karina 2. ningning 3. winter savage: 1. giselle 2. winter 3. karina dct: 1. ningning 2. karina 3. giselle lts: 1. karina 2. giselle 3. winter girls: 1. winter 2. karina 3. giselle

[@dianamoreno5275]

For me Black mamba: 1. Karina 2. Ningning 3. Winter 4. Giselle Forever: 1. Winter 2. Ningning 3. Giselle 4. Karina Next level: 1. Ningning 2. Karina 3. Winter 4. Giselle Savage: 1. Giselle 2. Karina 3. Ningning 4. Winter Dreams come true: 1. Winter 2. Ningning 3. Giselle 4. Karina Life's too short: 1. Winter/Giselle 2. Karina 3. Ningning Girls: 1. Winter 2. Giselle 3. Karina 4. Ningning

[@sunflowikk]

for me: black mamba-Karina next level-Ningning savage-Winter/Giselle girls-Giselle forever - Winter dreams come true - Karina life's too short-Ningning

[@jorinax]

me black mamba: karina forever: winter next level: karina/ning² savage: winter dreams come true: karina life's too short: winter girls: karina

[@user-gu7sb4hu7c]

Black Mamba: Karina Next Level: Ningning Savage: Giselle Girls: Winter

[@zerlynmay3759]

For me: BLACK MAMBA - Karina FOREVER - Winter NEXT LEVEL - Ningning SAVAGE - Giselle DREAMS COME TRUE - Karina LIFE'S TOO SHORT - Ningning GIRLS - Winter

[@julesfoury9240]

Giselle deserves 2nd place in Girls

[@westangayidols]

My pics: Black Mamba: Karina and Winter Next Level: NingNing and Karina Savage: Winter and Giselle Dreams Come True: NingNing and Karina Girls: literally can't decide, they all slayed