TOP 5 NYC Pizza in 2024! (MUST TRY)

When you think of food in New York City, pizza is the first thing that comes to mind. After living in the city for 10+ years and trying hundreds of pizzerias... these are my TOP 5 that you must check out!
New Videos will go live every Monday at 7pm EST! Make sure to subscribe to not miss any future videos!
► FOLLOW ME
/ mattjames919
/ mattjames9191

[@sazparker8849]

Just started watching your videos as it's been one of my dreams to come to New York primarily for the food!! Love your content and I've now got a long list of fire places I really wanna visit 😊😊

[@goflolo]

I just ordered a pizza watching this video lol Food Network needs to give you a show Matt because the content is top tier!

[@Mattjames919]

where did you order the pizza from??

[@brandonmoore2237]

Found your channel last week and I'm blown away by the quality of your videos. You made me want to hop on a flight to NYC and try some authentic NYC pizza for the first time!

[@claudialee4987]

Your love of food is such a joy to watch!!!🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕

[@winterkasworm8299]

Emmett’s pizza is 1000% underrated! That hot honey and the crispy thinness is something else!!

[@Mattjames919]

have you tried anything else at Emmett’s??

[@Lo-jh3so]

The first place you went to and the sound of that crunch 😍😍 YESSS

[@alexm2244]

off topic but what camera was this filmed on? the quality is top tier

[@FionaDolan-kz5fs]

I love pizza! We need to get some pizza in NYC @Heather Peacock! Next trip bring me and we’ll try these places!

[@jolovesjune222]

Yessss! Another video I’m pumped!

[@Mattjames919]

any places to add to your list??

[@LondonBroilSandwiches]

Yeah baby 9K and growing !

[@avecplaisirmusic]

Please keep doing these top 5s!! Burgers next?

[@briannaqbowers]

thank you!!!!!!!! visiting this weekend for the first time. do any of these have a dessert you recommend??

[@jeniferkenney2984]

Wrote down all the restaurants. Gonna check these places out when I go visit. Thanks for the tips! ❤

[@samigriffin19]

would love to see your favorite sushi recs in LA!!

[@Mattjames919]

check out some of my YT shorts! 😊

[@loreebreen3580]

Who else is craving pizza?🍕

[@Mattjames919]

🙋🏾‍♂️🙋🏾‍♂️ do you have a favorite?

[@troyrobinson8642]

Me and I'm eating tacos

[@hannahmorris7683]

Anyone else watch A Quiet Place Day One?? Her goal the whole movie was to get a slice of Patsy's Pizza!!! How cool!

[@Greenmanjim]

This is a treat!

[@ligi1090]

Yummmm. I definitely gotta try the honey on 🍕😊

[@Mattjames919]

the honey is KEY!

[@Itsfabfoodie]

These all look so fire 😍🍕🔥

[@allisonm8743]

best food videos everrrrr

[@Mattjames919]

what spot looks like one you would visit??

[@heatherk6445]

I have not heard of Emmett's but that is 100% a Chicago pizza! We call it "party cut!" Very curious to try next time I'm in NY.

[@Mattjames919]

Good to know! you gotta let me know what you think!

[@venusvelez8115]

You need to go to New Park in Howard Beach !! 100/10 !!

[@nikollbenford1199]

OMG 😋 I live in Houston & I need all these places in my life!!!

[@Mattjames919]

bookmark this for when you make it to NYC!

[@nikollbenford1199]

@@Mattjames919 definitely

[@sophiamonet7350]

I tried John’s of Bleeker Street yesterday and it was okay but personally I’ve had better - but then that’s the beauty of opinions and tastes. We are all different. In fact I preferred Bleeker pizza around the corner haha - probably because I’m from London and so I like that NY style crust and topping style. I’ve had so many pizzas in Italy and Europe and know what I like now. 😬

[@Ashersl0vesNessa]

I love thin sliced pizza and super dangerous haha! Yes!!

[@gabs3765]

I literally was just asking myself whats the best pizza in nyc?! perfect timing!

[@angelozarola6863]

Just had rubirosa w my mom this past weekend! So good, gotta try more next time

[@sunnydification]

Gotta try L’Industrie next time!! Thats my fav new spot

[@LondonBroilSandwiches]

Prince is better on the reheat …and when I say better I mean phenomenal. Put a spicy spring slice in the fridge for at least a day and then pop it in the toaster overnight for a crispy crunch bottom…it will Change your life .

[@Mattjames919]

we will have to agree to disagree! 😂 have you had village square pizza?

[@Beachbabe51]

Damn looks Hella good. Im.not living a good life. Never been. 😊

[@Casual246.]

Honey on pizza is something I gotta try 🙌

[@Mattjames919]

you’re gonna LOVE it!

[@majessasanchez8573]

I NEVER comment on videos so this is important: THANK YOU ON YOUR COMMENT OF PRINCE ST. PIZZA. I do not understand the hype at all.

[@falconcara]

I was about to comment the same, it's so bad / overhyped!

[@Mattjames919]

Respectfully!!! I always encourage people to form their own opinions (good or bad) 😁😅

[@Mattjames919]

@@falconcarawhat’s your favorite pizza place??

[@mohippa7478]

People who hate on PSP are the same types who trash places like Luger’s and JG Melon. Also, Scarr’s has been hit or miss, with way more misses lately

[@tracybonay4350]

I am so excited!!!!

[@Mattjames919]

have you been to any of these??

[@tracybonay4350]

@@Mattjames919no sir, been to New York once, but stayed on Long Island. I haven’t get back, when I do I will check these places out. That pizza 🍕 tho. Especially this Culture cookie, 🍪 Hubby has a cookie business do we are always checking out other cookies . Maybe we will run into y’all,

[@jewelcaro6545]

Spot on!!!

[@Mattjames919]

have you been to any of these??

[@La-iu2xf]

I thought Emmett's was an interesting choice for NYC since it's Chicago thin crust. lol

[@AlyviaGranillo]

Do an version for LA please lol

[@Mattjames919]

I can do that! Any recs??

[@donp5039]

Leaving out l’industrie is crazy lol

[@Denise-y9e]

John’s pizzas with extra pepperoni looks how a regular pepperoni pizza should look like.

[@sportstyler50]

Yummy!!

[@Mattjames919]

which looked like it could be your favorite??

[@Football-jo1tm]

Banger video

[@jodyharris9731]

You gotta fold your pizza like authentic new Yorkers do yo!

[@Mattjames919]

I can do that for you going forward 😂

[@cuhson]

I'd have to agree with that Prince St. comment. Ever since it expanded all over the universe, that same hype, quality, and luster just isn't the same anymore. I'm from LA, and they have almost a dozen locations from here to San Diego. I still like the pizza (as it's my first official slice I've had from there) but it's definitely overrated nowadays. To me, it's "LA" pizza.

[@dalvin-re4iq]

When you meet your fans invite them for bites it will be fan. Good job. Watching from Africa.

[@Mattjames919]

if I invited you from Africa, would you come??

[@dalvin-re4iq]

@@Mattjames919 Yes l would come thanks for asking. I am a young man from Africa tall like you l followed you and you inspire me. I am 19 years old plays basketball. Yes l would love too. I want to give back to my parents for sacrificing to give me and my brother good education. Thanks I don't have a phone I go to the cyber to watch your videos maybe I give you my papa phone no if you could like to contact me. Thank you sooo much........

[@dalvin-re4iq]

off course l could we don't get to eat such in Africa. Pizza is for the privilege ones is not for everyone here in Africa.

[@danathomas7302]

Scarr's: you're totally right. Lucali's is overrated though.

[@LondonBroilSandwiches]

Lucali is decent but definitely can’t reheat … too thin .

[@Mattjames919]

if you wanna reheat pizza, might as well get digiornos! 😂

[@LondonBroilSandwiches]

@@Mattjames919 pizza reheat is essential when you are 1 person buying a whole pie and not a 6’5 male with 9 percent body fat or whatever the heck are your stats marathon man 🏃🏾

[@JTA8130LV]

Hot honey on pizza you might as well put pineapple. You were are right about Patsy’s even the trek to Harlem. To me it’s special.

[@Vinsanity-ud3wj]

Joes in Times Square over rated compared to other NYC spots but better than most pizza joints everywhere else in the world.

[@K-wx6ki]

whats w the hats lol

[@MegaJacques1234]

Biggest sin is underdone pizza..in cheese, crust or flop. Way too many in the city serve it this way, or too doughey and they need to lighten and crisp everything up.

[@Yams7]

I can't trust a man who won't fold his pizzas.

[@ID_Kevin]

I got scarrs the other day and I have to say I was heavily disappointed with the hotboi

[@xsamus223x]

Joe's is very overrated. It's a 5.6/10.

[@Denise-y9e]

Prince st pizza and Joes pizza are very overrated!!

[@winterkasworm8299]

Also I get the hype of prince st 😬🫢

[@Mattjames919]

what about it!?