Top Premier League Strikers Of All-Time RANKED | The GOAT

[@LADbible]

Thanks to Rory and Buvey for taking part

[@OG1987__]

Rooney was the greatest player.

[@OG1987__]

​@GIBBO4182 Rooney was topping the PL assists charts, and made the top 3 assists in 5 separate PL seasons. He was the best player.

[@justinpolotan4185]

Buvey was terrible. Whoever he is. “Why Wayne Rooney over Henry?” “I’m taking Wayne Rooney” “Good point. Thank you sir”

[@danbivio]

Henry - not only has the best goal to game ratio.. he also has the most assist in one season … and all you need to do is listen to ex-pros say Henry scared them 🤷‍♂️

[@jimjogger306]

Rooney didnt just scare ex pro's, Rooney scared ex pro's parents.

[@timhansejordet9056]

Both Kane and Aguero have basically the same goal to game ratio mate

[@jimjogger306]

@@timhansejordet9056 Alan Shearers not even top 30 if you go by goal to game ratio. Stupid argument.

[@Metali-tin]

KDB not only equalled the most assists in a PL season, he beat it but they robbed him of at least one of his assists... Even KDB has commented that it should have counted(he's adamant with it) and he's normally quite humble and reserved on personal accolades.

[@kurtsudheim825]

Sergio has aarginally better strike rate, but yes, take into account style, & Henry played at arsenal for a few years at the start of their wane whereas Sergio came in as man city betrayed to dominate, his first year was their worst (not in terms of place finished but where they were)

[@cliffdanielito4298]

These men didn't have Ruud van Nistelroy in this list...madness!

[@thetruth4654]

Cantona isn`t even on this list.

[@Matolcsibenedek]

So true

[@Outklassed7]

I came to comment that lol

[@aaronaldo14]

No Dwight Yorke either. But they’re gonna put Haaland in. Nonsense list

[@kurtsudheim825]

Ya he should be there, but not enough time in pl. Plus he was never going to win

[@carlkelly4524]

How’s Henry not won this😂

[@OG1987__]

0 finals goals. Rooney scored 9 final goals. Rooney also won more PL titles. Rooney also more CL KO goals. Rooney also better record when they went head to head.

[@trashed4005]

@@OG1987__ "Greatest Premier League Striker" list. I didn't know the Prem had finals but "okay" Rooney went head to head vs a declining Arsenal. Stop the cap, no one would rather have Rooney over Titi.

[@oneshak]

Rooney is the reason Arsenal declined you muppet, he ended their invincible run and ran Henry out the league lmao@@trashed4005

[@aaronaldo14]

@@OG1987__there has never been a premier league final

[@joewhite22]

Because the tall guy is an idiot.

[@Robmc0381]

The moment Rory says he's putting tribalism to one side I laughed my arse off. He will pick a Chelsea player every single time

[@DS-dw3pz]

He won't always will...he ain't biased towards Chelsea actually but then sometimes he can be abit delusional...

[@jonathanj2666]

Right. By the way he argued for Kane you just look like you lost the plot mate.

[@Robmc0381]

@@jonathanj2666 huh?

[@jonathanj2666]

@@Robmc0381 did i stutter?

[@Robmc0381]

@@jonathanj2666 no but your point makes no sense in relation to mine

[@boxman9862]

Wayne Rooney over Henry is up there with Rory’s haaland take 😂

[@what9331]

Exactly! See how they both criticise Henry for not scoring in the UCL final and not winning the cup in comparison to Rooney who did, but they conveniently forget to mention that Henry won the world cup but none of their picks did?

[@Pastas666]

@@what9331 Oh he won the WC by being in the bench on the final and not even being sub on lol

[@kingluis6360]

@@Pastas666replace it with Euro 2000 then.

[@user-qs7wx5sc5z]

⁠@@Pastas666Was also Frances top scorer at the World Cup 98, bet you never knew that did you? Clueless.

[@Setherson_15]

It’s closer than given credit

[@carloschianca3389]

Absolutely pathetic how Henry isnt the winner possibly the greatest premier league player of all time not to mention striker. Insane

[@pazuzu2068]

Rooney though

[@YTykh]

These two are genuinely clueless mugs. The streets know Henry is the prem goat

[@what9331]

​@@pazuzu2068it's hypocritical how Buvey and Rory mention that Rooney won the UCL and criticise Henry for not scoring in the final, but forget to mention that Henry has a World cup to himself

[@gafak47]

dont forget euros and got robbed of ballon d'or😅@@what9331

[@Scuttleftw]

@@what9331 Both arguments should be irrelevant imo, both have nothing to do with PL.

[@ermericcarolissen694]

Henry could finish and create a goal out of nothing.

[@EwanP27]

And Rooney couldn’t??

[@ermericcarolissen694]

@@EwanP27 How many solo goals has Rooney scored where he dribbled past a number of defenders?

[@aranyaism]

@@ermericcarolissen694how many long passes and assists had Henry got. Rooney has the second most assists in the premier league history.

[@ermericcarolissen694]

@@aranyaism Henry has the highest assist total ever in a Premier League season in 2002/2003. TWENTY in case you didn't know. 411 goals and 207 assists in his career.

[@pauliyonas3576]

​@@aranyaismHenry is far better assister than Rooney

[@choughed3072]

Ronaldo is far better known as being a winger in the prem. He played like one season as a striker when he was like 38.

[@danyarsalar8184]

he has been a striker since he was 30

[@raphael_2252]

33*​@@danyarsalar8184

[@johnmolloy1034]

@@danyarsalar8184yeah but was a striker in the premier league for 1 season

[@joaquimsantos9750]

Was 38? He is 38...lol

[@ubaidmalik2517]

A better striker than Kane

[@joewhite22]

"Henry won the Golden Boot 4 times, scored over 20 goals in a season 5 times, got 20 assists in 1 season." Buvey: "Yeah but Rooney scored in a CL final"

[@billywynne7951]

And top goal scorer for england itself , Top goal scorer for united , 3rd top goalscorer in the prem , he didn't only play striker too he was a baller and Henry was an athlete

[@rajangrewal7423]

People forget that Shearer had 2 big injuries in his career where he missed practically the whole season, so to still get that amount of goals is insane. The question isn't who is the better footballer its better striker and anyone that thinks Rooney was a better striker than Shearer must not have watched him play. I'd put Henry number one btw but the disrespect Shearer gets at times is baffling to me.

[@kurtsudheim825]

Ntm he plated a dew years before pl, so it's a bit more than 260 goals really. But ya, the argument was pl, then start talking about playing wing & cm, but the debate is about striker

[@JayVerdad]

in terms of individual ability Henry is clear. other strikers mentioned were practicing thierrys moves in training 😅 (disgraceful not to mention tuck master van nistleroory)

[@JNM781]

They kept saying Rooney on his overall game. What does that even mean, they then went to say passing while Henry has held the premier league assist record for like 20 years

[@OG1987__]

Rooney was way better on ability.

[@OG1987__]

​@BDGCapo45 Rooney was better passer, he was getting MOTM in 2016 FA Cup Final as a DM, he was pinging it for fun. He had better workrate, he could tackle, he could run, he could shoot, he could head, FKs etc.

[@JNM781]

@@OG1987__ I actually agree he was a better passer but I mean there was no clarification which is what I was alluding to. Why do you need to be better at all of those things. It would imply that Rooney is better then messi? elite players would choose Henry in their team over Rooney. I’m not trashing Rooney he is phenomenal but Henry was so good at being a complete forward and dominant winger that it doesn’t matter whether he could tackle or not

[@JNM781]

@@OG1987__ most Man Utd fans would put Henry above him

[@ap24101988]

I’ll be open I’m Liverpool fan through and through but seriously how is Henry not number 1? The guy was a machine scored goals out of this world and mugged off so many people. Kane over Rooney any day imo.

[@stillthebest2521]

avg liverpool fan ball knowledge

[@oscarc7017]

@@stillthebest2521 you've only shown yourself as delusional with this comment. Given the fact you have SAF as your pfp it is no surprise

[@stillthebest2521]

@@oscarc7017 1 league title in 30 years remember that when you mention the greatest manager of all time

[@smoothcheeky8910]

​@@oscarc7017 Henry winning is a very acceptable opinion. However Kane over Rooney "anyday" is just a madness. Rooney is literally the better version of kane

[@manunited1235]

Kane over Rooney? Another deluded Liverpool fan.

[@lestokays]

Someone needs to remind you that you said striker... The final should be Henry vs Aguero... After that you can take your pic. This argument that someone can go into midfield is irrelevant

[@Visual_Ghoul]

Aguero? Ahaha

[@khyrngabriel8138]

Final should have been Henry vs Kane

[@senafahri9987]

How Henry didn’t even make the final is crazy. It’s called the best striker IN THE PREMIER LEAGUE, and all their points were about how Rooney plays different positions and win champions leagues. It’s literally a striker debate🤦🏻‍♂️

[@ashconbeats8414]

And he still has the 3rd most goals in premier league. That’s why Rooney wins a lot of these. Because he does so much for the team and still scored goals.

[@senafahri9987]

@@ashconbeats8414 I understand that and also agree. However it’s a striker debate, and Henry was the best striker the league has seen. Rooney overall as a player was better as he could do more and play more positions, however it was a striker debate

[@pauliyonas3576]

​@@ashconbeats8414even sir Alex Ferguson doesn't consider Rooney world class player

[@manunited1235]

@@GIBBO4182but then again it’s because he’s never played most of his career as an out an out striker. He’s played in various positions a lot during his time at Man United

[@manunited1235]

@@GIBBO4182 I agree. I do think the likes of aguero and Thierry Henry are better strikers. I was replying to why he has his ratio is not as good as the other strikers. Yes it’s because he’s played a lot more games but it’s also because he’s played in various positions.

[@user-ol5yb8sj2p]

So you gave the '''Greatest Premier League Striker Of All-Time" title to a striker that hasnt won the golden boot nor has a better goal to min ratio then the others strikers on this list? Well done lads, you done a "great" job.

[@oneshak]

means absolutely nothing, Rooney is the most successful and the BEST footballer on ability out of all of them.

[@trashed4005]

@@oneshak On what planet does he have better ability than Thierry? Like I hear ability used so much but it's such an umbrella term and at this point I'd argue that ability is subjective to what your eyetest tells you. Anything Rooney could do Thierry could do. Better Striker. Better second striker, holds the season-long assist record still after 20 years while still also scoring 24 goals that year. Holds 4 out of 5 golden boots in his prime. Sorry, Henry wipes the floor with Rooney.

[@bewoulf94731]

surely , Rooney defending , passing and ability to score goals while being played in different positions , rather than the striker position as he was signed for .. is what makes him have a better all round ability and when he did become the main guy he has 30+ goals a season countless number of times . with Henry it'd be questionable if he could have handled such position shift without affecting his tally . hence a well rounded striker adaptable to any change that keeps a goal scoring tally consistent .. definitely would rank higher than you normal pacey talented striker merchant... jus saying

[@oneshak]

all Henry has on rooney is dribbling and finishing everything else rooney dominates in, its why rooney was and is capable of not just being a striker but also a midfielder. @@trashed4005

[@oneshak]

exactly, rooney was that good he was still considered the best player in the league out of position for years and that one season he actually played as a 9 he was by far the best striker in the world leading up to his injury that ruined his season vs Bayern @@bewoulf94731

[@TheCrispyBits]

Henry. That's it.

[@Young_Brumm15]

It is insane that Haaland is already in a debate about the greatest Prem strikers already. The guy has only got 1 full Prem season under his belt. It's disrespectful to have him in the debate, and leave off players who had done great things in the Prem for a longer period of time, like Ruud Van Nistleroy, Ian Wright, Jermaine Defoe, Teddy Sheringham, etc. Absolutely crazy🤯😅

[@aaronaldo14]

He’s not in the debate for serious people

[@Iam_andredan]

But Suarez had one good season and he’s on most peoples list tbh.

[@georgeallison6528]

@@Iam_andredan because Suarez was the greatest striker of the previous decade.

[@konadu__]

how did ronaldo, suarez or henry not end up in the finals? 😂😂

[@andrewclifton185]

Look who was judging - says it all

[@Animalistic9]

Ronaldo had one season as a striker no? 🤔 Henry is the correct answer...

[@kw695lh]

Ronaldo didn’t really play up top for United during his earlier time at the club so it wouldn’t make much sense

[@Bhavishya_ydv31]

Suarez didn’t play long enough. Ronaldo was mostly a winger.

[@tbrreptiles4779]

The mad disrespect for salah is crazy What more does the man need to do?

[@3allthefckinmanugetme464]

Play regularly at striker and not RW 🤔

[@savage1717]

What kind of illiterate doesn't understand the difference between a striker n a winger n still calls him a football fan?

[@tbrreptiles4779]

​@3allthefckinmanugetme464 plays 99% of his games at rw 😂

[@tbrreptiles4779]

He shouldn't be on the board if he's immediately disregarded as a winger simple

[@Abdullah-t9c8f]

For me, he’s best premier league player of all time. And by the way they’re talking about strikers not wingers. They just used Salah’s name👍🏻

[@jakehowie442]

Suarez would’ve been up there with Henry and Augero as greatest ever strikers, if he didn’t keep biting players

[@Dan-tr5kw]

Seems harsh not putting Cantana on this list. Hasselbank, Van Niselroy, Sherringham, and Les Ferdinand all deserve shouts as well

[@kurtsudheim825]

All great players but bar Eric, not pl legends, but that elite level, or didn't spend enough time in England

[@simpleflaw2450]

'best STRIKER of the premier league era' "Rooney could do a job at CB" Jesus Christ these Muppets honestly.. Henry is in the conversation for one of the best players in the Prem of all time, he was absolutely magical. Congrats Sport Bible on ragebait 😂

[@shaheryarmallick6459]

Rory's fixation on Drogba consistently influences his decisions. Additionally, his persistent focus on Henry's failure to score in the Champions League final seems to stem from a deep-seated disdain. However, across the Premier League's history, no attacking player has instilled as much fear as Henry, a sentiment echoed by numerous respected defenders. Henry's remarkable goal and assist statistics throughout his Premier League tenure further solidify his standing. The unequivocal answer, supported by evidence, is Henry, with Aguero trailing closely as a contender.

[@jtthegoat459]

The fact that Ronaldo went out to kane is Shambolic and the fact that Haaland went through over Fowler is madness

[@kingluis6360]

Who cares who the better ‘total footballer’ is, and what other positions they could play. It’s a striker list, and as a striker Henry undoubtedly clears Rooney.

[@JWalksClips]

Wishing Buvey all the best in his ongoing battle against gigantism

[@newgorkcity]

Fowler should be ahead of Haaland, he will get there but not now currently

[@realxcraftsam]

What is this? Why is Salah there? He’s a bloody winger! And Drogba over Henry???

[@dollabills5824]

Because when they do “best winger” lists, they don’t let salah take part because “he’s more of a goal scorer than a winger.” Starting to seem like he’s not really allowed in either conversation because he’s too good for both.

[@Peter_file]

Henry is so clear of drogba

[@grantdrivas1025]

We’re gonna talk about Premier League players and their Premier League accomplishments! *keeps referencing Champions League goals*

[@haroldtackie4290]

There’s no way that Rooney is better striker than Henry, Aguero, Kane, Shearer or Cole. Henry, Aguero and Kane are the only strikers to have won 5 golden boots in the premier league- that in itself means only one of those three can be the goat in the premier league

[@martynrockell6033]

Henry - 4 Kane - 3 Aguero -1

[@corygiddings3722]

Rooney is top 5 even tho he didn’t even like playing upfront scored 35 goals in a season when Ronaldo left

[@MichaelDavis-kf9lk]

Not putting Suarez through was a fucking war crime

[@tonyrobson6457]

Henry has been named greatest premiere league player of all time by nearly every ex player and pundit. Yet Rory and bouvy name Rooney as the greatest striker whilst greatest prem player Henry is a striker 😂😂 that literally sums them 2 up🤦

[@HonestWatchReviewsHWR]

They need to make these questions more specific and stick to that. It doesn't matter how many Champions League goals they scored, what other positions they played etc. What is the main job of a stiker... Scoring goals. It's that simple. To determine who "The Greatest Premier League Stiker Of All-Time" is you have to be talking about who was the best at putting the ball in the back of the net.

[@realmadridcdfcook]

If you ask which striker had the best season in the BPL era it just has to be Luis Suarez 13/14. Almost dragged a bang average LFC team to the title, 42 G/A in 31 games with NO pens. Oh and some of the goals were out of this world.

[@RBNS-football]

I don’t think augero is the winner but he’s surely better than Rooney as he was way more consistent and his goal record is far superior to that of Rooneys

[@Abdullah-t9c8f]

They still think that Salah is a striker🤡 Mohamed Salah is a winger. He plays as RW and sometimes as RM. as Liverpool fan I’ve never seen him play as ST.

[@filmonberhane4255]

Henry is the only correct answer. And i remember Buvey said in one Video Henry is better than Rooney and here picking Rooney over Henry Lol

[@chrisa2090]

They just say whatever is controvirtial and gets people arguing in the comments

[@granth1238]

If you are truely basing off as the title says "best Premier League STRIKER" then it's Aguero, then probably Kane and Cole after that. Best all round footballer, best technician, best attacker, whatever other descriptor, then its Henry or Rooney. But as an out and out striker, Aguero is clear, and it's not even remotely close.

[@JNM781]

If you were to speak to all the best centre backs itw and ask them which striker would you fear playing against they would all say Henry . A striker isn’t just striking the ball its being a complete forward and Henry was that’s. A complete forwards possesses technical qualities of a Deep Lying Forward, the goal scoring ability of a Poacher and the strength and power of a Target Man. He is equally adept at playing in others, fashioning chances for himself and getting on the end of team moves. That’s HENRY

[@granth1238]

@@JNM781 if thats your definition of a striker then so be it, you'd be correct, all about personal opinion on what defines a striker. I don't classify Henry as a striker, but maybe thats just me.

[@granth1238]

How on earth did Berkamp make it that far? Lost all credibility with that. Buvey actually right for once.

[@xanderpacino97]

Henry without a doubt. He not only scored goals he also assisted a lot.

[@jeywastysports8853]

0 ball Knowledge herny the best ever!

[@fcbarcelona5044]

💀 Salah as striker? And this is all time best as a Striker not multiple positions player like tf 🤧

[@johnjones8026]

the disrespect on fowler is a joke

[@peterf08]

Fowler is the 2nd worst player on this list behind Vardy

[@TobyIM738]

How is Salah in the striker list, he's a winger. And Ronaldo's best years in the prem was as a winger

[@thomasjames456]

No Ruud Van Nistelrooy? Scandalous

[@jeffreypalfini6706]

Aguero was the most lethal finisher in the Prem era. By far the best goals/min at 108 min per goal (Henry 2nd at 122). The stats don't lie. Still, Henry is probably a more complete striker, and had all those assists as well. 1. Henry 2. Aguero 3. Kane 4. Shearer 5. Suarez 6. (tie) Drogba and Cole 8. Van Nistelrooy... Rooney, Ronaldo and Salah don't belong on this list as none of them played regularly as a striker.

[@JNM781]

Best comment I’ve seen

[@snapskillz1908]

nah kane is by far the better finisher

[@jeffreypalfini6706]

@@snapskillz1908 Ah the age-old battle between objective proof and baseless proclamation!

[@kurtsudheim825]

Ya it's a good stat to see how lethal you were But not the only one, I've just put Harry above him now, because, esp weh you look at last year, what he did, having to play for spurs l, going deep into mid, when you take style into account... Rooney dod play as a striker regularly, it was his most common position, just changed at the end because he couldn't run anymore, so he's my 5. As I say, swap Harry with Sergio & I agree

[@kurtsudheim825]

​@@jeffreypalfini6706yes because the game is more than stats numptey. Mustafa & romero have wc medals, does it mean they were better than vvd & silver? Stats can be manipulated to help your argument, so you can use one & I use another, they conflate, so did right?

[@Jimbobiscuit]

Amazing that the greatest ever Premier League striker wasn't even a striker 👏

[@gabrielguerrero3404]

Leave it to people to criticize haaland about numbers but then conveniently proceed to forget he got the record of most goals scored in a premier league season in his first season. It’s either about numbers or it’s not

[@NRussLFC]

This shows how underrated Salah is, 1% of the votes? The answer against aguero was Salah. But buvey completely disrespected him. Thinking it wasn't even close. Classic. Salah again underrated

[@Buvey]

Thanks for having me on lads 💪💪

[@LADbible]

Always a pleasure

[@oa149]

Did you actually watch football growing up? 😭

[@zaynahmed122]

This is a strikers list and salah and Ronaldo are on it? Where is Ruud? Cantona ? Surely the ending is off aswell.

[@realTdarT]

There’s 2 big differences/miscommunications when a question like this one is asked. Either people answer “The best striker to play in the Prem” and say Rooney/Aguero. Some people say CR7 (even tho he was a winger) because he’s been the best PLAYER to play in the prem, although his years there was not his true prime years, like Madrid.

[@officialpingo]

these guys forgot cr7 at 36yo outscored a 28yo Harry Kane in PL with a dysfunctional Man utd

[@dmh5220]

Not putting Henry is just goofy, Rooney himself put Henry as best premier league player OAT

[@kylo9534]

Even Rooney reckons it’s Henry 😂

[@what9331]

This is utter nonsense, Henry was a silky footballer who did everything and often found himself playing for an Arsenal team that couldn't compete with the high spending Man UTD behemoth and later on, a Russian oligarch backed Chelsea. As much as Rooney is better overall than Kane, Henry is better than them all. Him not scoring in the only UCL final he appeared in, shouldn't be held against him. Henry also won the world cup and was key to winning it. Why do Rory and Buvey leave that achievement off the list? I tell you why, it's because none of their picks won it.

[@Johndoe-gf7eu]

High spending man united😂stop lying, got outspent whole of 90s😊

[@thernandez0206]

You guys didn't do justice with this video. Henry is the only answer.

[@leeneale8159]

Soon as Henry went out turned it off wow wow wow convinced when this video started it's was Henry 😮madd actually mad

[@justinpolotan4185]

This man never gave any reason other than “Well he’s Wayne Rooney so I’m picking him”

[@rubeshrana]

The fact that Rory has made a career out of football opinions is crazy. This guy tries so hard to be unique but just ends up looking like a clown. Crazy.

[@louiswithers4589]

I will never understand why people take trophies into account for a player’s individual brilliance, if anyone was on that pep city team they also would have won as many trophies

[@adarbarrush]

English- Shearer, Foreign- Aguero, overall its aguero

[@GH0ZT77]

Over Henry and Rooney? Not a chance.

[@adarbarrush]

@@GH0ZT77 shearer would have double the goals if he played for man united ,and aguero was crucial in big games while henry never scored in a final

[@adarbarrush]

@@GIBBO4182 who scored the most memorable title winning goal in PL history? Hint, it wasn't henry nor rooney

[@lfclfc5683]

Shearer... fair. Aguero over Henry is a criminal take. Henry is the prems best ever player. Awful ball knowledge

[@adarbarrush]

@@lfclfc5683 I watched henry since he started at monaco and aguero at atletico madrid. Aguero is a better striker

[@giorgoskyriakides4428]

They put Rooney over Henry. 2 clowns

[@EditorStevo]

We all know who people would rather in their team. Rooney was a force

[@amma9518]

Rooney waz a better footballer than Henry

[@Khalid-gm1qo]

How was Rooney better than Henry LOOOOL that's some joke Rooney ain't even the best from Manchester united ​@@amma9518

[@amma9518]

@@GIBBO4182 Rooney was a better footballer than Henry

[@amma9518]

@@GIBBO4182 Rooney in My opinion was a better footballer than Henry

[@justinpolotan4185]

Buvey was terrible. Whoever he is. “Why Wayne Rooney over Henry?” “I’m taking Wayne Rooney” “Good point. Thank you sir”

[@spade5752]

Only correct answer is Wayne Rooney

[@Lignumhominis]

I turned this video off as soon as Henry was taken out.

[@GoonerJonesy]

It’s Henry & not even a debate anyone who says otherwise needs to put their bias aside

[@ashconbeats8414]

For me it’s between Rooney and Henry. Henry had a better prime but Rooney has the longevity and more titles.

[@calastyphon3414]

Rooney didn't have Henry's longevity imo. He was playing in the championship and for Everton when Henry at that age had just won a UCL with barca

[@ashconbeats8414]

@@calastyphon3414 what u talking about Rooney was playing at the top for man united between 2004-2017. Only the last 3 years of that wasn’t good. He had longevity in the premier league.

[@ashconbeats8414]

@@calastyphon3414 also he sacrificed himself for the team and played midfield at times and still scored 208 premier league goals and has 3rd most assists. Let’s not forget he also won 5 premier leagues.

[@oneshak]

yeah because they both peaked at two different times mate, Rooney was already world class at 16.@@calastyphon3414

[@calastyphon3414]

@@ashconbeats8414 that's not a better length of time than Henry

[@MPandJamles]

Shearer always gets so disrespected in these debates. How does having the record for most goals scored in the competition never seem to matter? It's literally the purpose of a striker. You lot ('pundits' & commenters) are sweating it to try and have hot-takes/seem intelligent

[@westsidewinners3330]

Henry is the only right answer. He has the goals assists titles Golden boots And to top it all off, he done it all with the style no one else on this list has. Period.

[@Joshwaheazo]

Alan Shearer is criminally underrated. People forgot the injuries he had they remember the player he came back as and he was still that good. Only player that I'd even debate it was Rooney on that list.

[@NOXONFC]

No one touches Henry on this list

[@القناةالرسمية-ع5ه]

The correct answer is RONALDO 🐐

[@Ragnar850]

Every time i watch Rory talk about football i question his ball knowledge

[@ItsHoang_Truong]

He said Haaland would flop. Tells you everything

[@IanBorbon-s3e]

Buvey knows nothing about football. He is from bristol and supports man city

[@pranavhkul]

Everytime people start talking about team titles while discussing the greatness of a player, I just lose all interest in the debate.

[@ZeekoRamen]

Salah and Aguero shouldn't be together. One is a striker and the other is a winger. Unfair on both players.

[@CoryJT]

Ronaldo was a winger at United.

[@ClintWestmetal88]

Is everyone on acid? Outrageous disrespect towards Shearer here. Blackburn don't win the league without him and he scored 112 goals in 138 games for them- unlikely Rooney would have got near those numbers for 4 seasons on the bounce. Rooney definitely a better footballer but we're talking strikers and prime Shearer is scoring more for sure.

[@platinumjangus]

The pair of them are absolutely clueless. How they are talking about football for a living baffles me.

[@danielrichardson4868]

In no way is Kane better than Ronaldo, not one, the man has 30 trophies and 873 goals

[@De3dSh0t]

Why the hell is Ronaldo here😭 He played as a striker for ONE season as a 37 year old

[@pratikpuri220]

bro salah and rooney was a winger

[@De3dSh0t]

@@pratikpuri220 Agree about Salah but Rooney at least played as a striker for 4 ish seasons

[@DanH-u3f]

It's Shearer. Not even close.

[@we5t5id3gunn]

1. Henry 2. Aguero 3. Rooney 4. Shearer 5. Kane

[@tonywu2045]

how did fernando torres not even make the shortlist but jamie vardy did

[@Visual_Ghoul]

League title

[@tonywu2045]

@@Visual_Ghoulluis suarez?

[@hennyspiderman9974]

Rory should be banned from any football talk. Drogba over Henry, Bergkamp over Suarez and Kane over CR7 😐 ffs

[@COYB2393]

Why’s Salah here? Lmao

[@grandcanyon8184]

I dont know whos voting here, but the audience has had multiple shockers here. Haaland over Fowler, mental! Kane over Ronaldo, ABSOLUTE MADNESS! This reaks of shocking ball knowledge.

[@bog314]

In the prem Kane Is a far better pick

[@NathanGlass95]

It's for Premier League STRIKERS, the answer is definitely Kane (Arsenal fan)

[@grandcanyon8184]

@@NathanGlass95 ronaldo won three back to back prem titles, a champions league and a ballon d’or, breaking the all time scoring record. Kane has won one golden boot and zero titles. The only thing going for Kane is longevity every quality of a striker Ronaldo was better at.

[@NathanGlass95]

@@grandcanyon8184 PREMIER LEAGUE strikers, Ronaldo also played as a winger for those prem titles, only played as a striker when he returned to Man Utd years later... All achievements outside of the Prem are irrelevant because they're basing it on the Premier League. Harry Kane was a better PREMIER LEAGUE player than Ronaldo.

[@grandcanyon8184]

@@NathanGlass95 the striker point I get, Ronaldo played mostly as a winger in the prem, but they have established earlier in the video that that really doesn’t matter. Ronaldo was best player in the entire league for that three year period winning almost every possible title. Then he came back 12 years later and out scored Kane in his first season back, in a worse side. Saying Kane is a better pl PLAYER is crazy. Nothing that Kane is better than him at.

[@ChEBoii1]

Buvey making the case of Rooney better total footballer, to then say Cole over Bergkamp but hes the better total footballer just shows the flip flop nature of his takes 🤣

[@NOXONFC]

Rooney over Henry is absolutely stupid I’m sorry. Rooney is fantastic but Henry 🤣

[@alkitgugalia9370]

No Ruud and Cantona is criminal

[@TVFlix]

Rooney over Henry? That's blasphemous. Also, Salah is a better player than Aguero was, is it just the 'Striker' label that wins it. And to put Haaland through against the 8th all top PL top goalscorer is scandalous also. It's been one season.

[@JaymzZeppelin]

FFS first hurdle and you've eliminated someone who should have finished in the top three.

[@Ricardo33-]

Greatest striker to ever play in the prem: Thierry Henry. Greatest footballer to ever play in the prem : Cristiano Ronaldo.

[@ArjunVaish]

footballer is still Henry he played longer in the prem and every season he played in the prem he was world class ronaldo played 5 seasons in the prem the first 3 he was not world class or dominate it was the last two where he was amazing so to me it had to go to Henry

[@alexikyriakides-xr7jl]

These guys have no ball knowledge, please dont get them on again!

[@sidwell4959]

How they picking bergkamp over SUAREZ 😂😂😂😂

[@Tsgunners]

Clowns the lot of them, Henry was and still is the greatest player to ever play in the prem, and those of you who are little boys and girls that wasn’t old enough to see this guy, then just watch his highlights

[@FabulousKilljoy22]

Shearer never played in the Championship. What the fuck is he on about?