Christian Confronts Rabbi Tovia Singer over the Doctrine of the Trinity Live on Air!

Let’s Get Biblical Study Guide (Volume 1 & 2) outreachjudais...
Help us combat aggressive evangelization in Israel: outreachjudais...
outreachjudais... www.toviasinger...
/ tenaktalk
Music: www.purple-pla...

[@mostafametwally1]

As a Muslim I completely agree and found this to be a very logical discussion. But just to clarify to some of those who may have listened to this, Islam is absolutely clear on the single nature of the creator and goes to great extents in the Quran to argue against this trinitarian logic. However you often find Christians trying to find parallels to the doctrine of the trinity in other religions including Islam (possibly to make it more acceptable logically). The attributes of God that the caller referred to are the names of God that are mentioned in the Quran and describe God’s nature (eg. The most merciful, the most Compassionate etc..) and in no way describes different personas.

[@alfianbanjaransari4096]

Preach!

[@julianmontoya428]

I have always trusted and believed the Muslims and the jews worship the same God! I had believed like brother argue or fight, that's how Muslims and judiasm has been, while God spoke of esau and Jacob, I believed 🇮🇱 Israel is like Jacob and Islam like esua, ...Muslims submit to only God, they worship with such loyalty and devotions, their women cover themselves! And when their tongue flows when the mention a name of a holy prophet or holy king they say "peace be upon them!" My heart feels what their tongue saids! When they mention God and words "the merciful and compassionate!" My heart fills with joy! And I know 100% they love The one true God! ..while ✡️ Jewish nation reason, and they have knowledge and truth, they have celebrated the holy sabbath, and kept the laws of G-D through the holy prophets and rabbi's! ...when they say "Hashem" wow they speak of whom they know! And more importantly whom they know ,knows them ! ...when I speak to Christians? They seem very active , they don't know who they worship, I get confused and have doubt and sorrow and grief! I don't feel the power and authority of the true God! I fear God more for spending time with them! I feel lost forever worthless and.useless! I try to have faith! But I feel fake seeking God in ways Christians think ? I have to say they seem to be hypocrites! I used to think I have to humble myself like Jesus did when he went to get baptized, but when does it end? They all claim they will be raptured? How can they be raptured ? Only two were raptured Enoch and Elijah two holy prophets! Loved by God! None can compare to those whom G-D has declares his love for! They are jn the holy bible, and.more importantly they are in the heart of G-D! I hear testimonials of Christians like G-D helped me find my keys, or G-D gave me a job and gave me money? They ask me what do I want? I want to worship and praise God and pray effectively! They say that doesn't matter! ...its confusingly Christian churches!

[@interstategar]

Question about Islam: Why does Islam claim Mohammad is a Prophet when he never made a prophesy that matches the Torah's Prophets, which is how you can single out false prophets? Also why do so many Muslims despise the Jews that live in Israel today? God promised that land to live in.

[@8xXcoolbeansXx8]

@@julianmontoya428 it sounds like you might be on the path to becoming a Bnei Noah. It sounds like you revere the Jewish Bible, the word of God. I would follow that instinct to finding your personal relationship with Him. Keep the Noahide laws, and tell yourself that you are obeying God’s laws because He wants that from you. We serve Him, because we want to please Him, not because we are buying credits for the afterlife. Once we are not on this Earth, we are souls who cannot serve Him any longer by keeping His commandments, so we have to serve Him now as best we can.

[@qaisarajaz2771]

@@interstategar Muhammad SAW is the prophet for all humanity not just for Jews even Jesus was send only to Jews not to Romans and his disciples spread it to whole world so Jews don't believe in him so it doesn't matter whether roman believes in him or not because they are gentiles islam is the religion which indicates the false teachings of Judaism and Christianity but it's main focus is on Christianity because they mix truth with falsehood

[@thearbiter6350]

You KNOW it's going to be good when he tells the caller to stay on the line."he rarely does that" This is perhaps my favorite Tovia singer breakdown of the average Christian claims.

[@fessali5726]

@@thearbiter6350 being an expert he should look for bigger fish to fry. Christians are not that hard to expose. Maybe he should explain why you disrespect and hate the blessed Mary and her son.

[@hamidab7167]

Every time I watch a caller ask my rabbi a question, I notice that he listens with so much concentration and answers with so much respect. I have to say that I am a Muslim but I absolutely adore my rabbi and have so much respect for him

[@hamidab7167]

Thank you rabbi for taking the time to read my comment , by sending a ❤️ you just made my day !!!

[@abrahamskaria4645]

Please see the videos of Christian Prince

[@invictusOne]

Another fantastic conversation and teaching. Thank you both for the great insight you are sharing with the world.

[@SonOfASilverStacker]

Thank you, Rabbi. That was a very thoughtful and insightful response to the caller.

[@rollingknuckleball]

To the Christian caller, when responding to "Only the father knows the hour", you said the hypostatic union that Jesus was in limited his mind, in a sense, saying his true divine form would know the hour. To that I would ask, what about the holy spirit? Why does the holy spirit not know? Isn't the holy spirit co-equal with the father and co-omniscient? Last I checked the holy spirit was not limited by a human form.

[@rollingknuckleball]

@Abraham Mani Isaiah 53 isn't about Jesus. Jews don't need a sacrifice to atone.

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@joycegreer9391]

@@rollingknuckleball So you are rejecting the sacrificial system commanded by God that was practiced by Israel?

[@rollingknuckleball]

@@joycegreer9391 That sacrificial system was also abrogated by God in the Tanakh itself. It is there in the Tanakh, look and you will find. Granted, those verses will not be taught to you in a church, because it must be awkward for a church to admit that God Himself, in the Tanakh, not the NT, abrogates prior laws, given circumstances, abrogates sacrifice to sincere repentence, significantly prior to the birth of Jesus. So no I'm not rejecting anything, because that system itself was abrogated by God, so to believe that the method for forgiveness is sincere repentance and the changing of ways, is to believe in the commandment of God.

[@evantechgroup]

Rabbi, you have absolutely changed my life. I've read your two volumes and researched EVERYTHING. I've been mislead so much before and my adherence to what I thought was right has cost me everything. Now I am a Noahide. I'd convert but I know how weak I am. I am so grateful to you!

[@Pasture_Prime]

Congrats on being able to. May Hashem bring you all the blessings you can take

[@paulawallace8784]

How wonderful for you!

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

Noahides are considered like a High Priest. What can possibly be higher than that?

[@sonofblessed]

There's nothing weak about becoming a Noachide. Leaving your circle of friends, your religion, your way of life and opening yourself to ridicule is the epitome of strength. At least with Judaism people are familiar with it, but your adherence to something that most people haven't heard of before shows a dedication to truth. May God bless you.

[@swaterman2017]

Congratulations

[@davidd.c.9545]

Thank you so much dear rabbi!! Great teachings!

[@rollingknuckleball]

To the Christian caller, when responding to "Only the father knows the hour", you said the hypostatic union that Jesus was in limited his mind, in a sense, saying his true divine form would know the hour. To that I would ask, what about the holy spirit? Why does the holy spirit not know? Isn't the holy spirit co-equal with the father and co-omniscient? Last I checked the holy spirit was not limited by a human form.

[@eduardo_fbarbosa]

@@rollingknuckleball each person of the Trinity has a different role for our salvation, this may be the reason why only the Father knows the day and the hour

[@rollingknuckleball]

@@eduardo_fbarbosa Yes but that breaks the trinitarian clause of co-equality. All three are co-equal in omni-presence, omni-potence, and omni-science. Not knowing the day and the hour by definition makes a being not omniscient, because omniscient is by definition the knowledge of all things. The trinitarian formula has a distinction of person but an equality of nature. Omniscience is part of the nature of God, to believe that some of the person's are relegated to having lesser knowledge or power due to the roles they fulfill is unacceptable according to Trinitarian clauses, that belief is modalist, which is heretical to all Trinitarian churches. Also, you say all these things about the trinity, but who came up with this? Did a prophet say this? Did Jesus himself explicitly explain the trinitarian formula and its clauses? What gives a human, much less ones similar to the early church fathers (some were murderers and most had characters below that of most modern saints) the right to determine, without scriptural backing, the nature of God?

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@eduardo_fbarbosa]

@Shoshana Jones But I didn’t say Jesus forgot the time and the hour of His return

[@bneihaneviim]

Great clip! Glad to see that people like this caller can be well-informed, disagree, and still have a level-headed discussion. Thank you Rabbi!

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@bneihaneviim]

@@dlight1999 Everything that was needed to reveal to us about the 'nature' of God' was done so in the Tanach. The Navi Malachi (who gave us the last of the authentic Prophecies included in the Tanach) told us NOT TO FORGET THE TORAH OF MOSHE / the commandments he brought to us from God. The christians cancelled out the Mitzvot, and even instituted statues and forbidden images in their churches of which God said (in the 10 Commandments) 'You shall not make for yourself images of any being in the sky, earth or water'. The christian sources you quote to us have no validity. Thanks

[@bneihaneviim]

Clearly, you never read the Torah once in your life, and take everything the church tells you by hearsay... The Torah Commands to be fruitful and multiply - The church values celibacy (apparently preferring child molestastion as an alternative). The Torah Command 4 times (Book of Exodus & Deuteronomy) that you shall "Bind my sign on your arm and on your head" referring to Tefillin which ALL observant Jews still wear. The Torah Commands that one "Shall NOT make any image of a creature on land, in the sea, or in the sky", yet the church places their disgusting idols of jesus and his comrades in all the churches. The Torah ALSO commands in the book of Deuteronomy to KILL any false prophet who tries to convince the Jewish people to NOT observe the commandments, even if he comes in the "name of God"... The Prophet Malachi (the last prophet) told the Jewish people to "Remember the Torah of Moshe" and to observe it. The church has only promulgated the opposite. Get a life, thanks :)

[@noahgoldsworthy1159]

בייה Thank you for such a respectful discussion, as always. May HaShem continue to bless you with this mitzvot everyday :)

[@jennifersilves4195]

@@thomasmagnum6588 Yo, Thomas. JESUS DID NOT FULFILL MESSIANIC PROPHESIES. That is the point.

[@jennifersilves4195]

I love Jesus. Don't misunderstand. He is not nor did he claim to be the messiah. He's still a christ.

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

​@@thomasmagnum6588 The falsehood of a prophet is established by even the slightest divergence from the original words of the Torah. Jesus taught the idolatrous doctrine of the trinity in Matthew 28:19.

[@noahgoldsworthy1159]

@@thomasmagnum6588 He didn't fulfil a single messianic prophecy found in Tanakh

[@noahgoldsworthy1159]

@@jennifersilves4195 christ and meshiach have the same meaning. So your comment is an oxymoron.

[@annamaria3038]

As usual, dear Rabbi Singer, you are a true teacher, the way you explain things so beautifully. Thank you! Hashem bless you

[@wordwordful]

Why do you call the Sovergein of the Universe Ha Shem. The Name sounds very impersonal.

[@interstategar]

I'm a Conservative Jew, went to Hebrew school, got Bar Mistvah'd, but most of my friends were Christians, not church going, so to fit in never knew much about Judaism, only to pray to God and never Jesus. My two brothers and sister all married Christians, and always felt a pressure by my two brothers to covert to save my soul UNITIL I started watching Jewish-Christian debate here online. I find Rabbi Singer to be the most knowledgeable. The pressure to convert to vanished and gave me great joy. They are afraid to even watch Rabbi Singer's videos because they are so deeply programmed, their brain would just explode. (my opinion)

[@interstategar]

Thank you Rabbi. It means a lot to me that you read my comment. God blessed you to spread the truth to the world and I think He's by your side always.

[@Roberto-yc4dc]

You dont think it was strange that you just said "never Jesus"? Does Jesus touch a nerve?

[@martharaymond698]

Rabi Tovia thanks for your teaching very good we are blessed with what give us we need to learn Torah very much

[@Jelena.Derosa]

I bought your books rabbi and I am mindblown. Thank you for your great effort to include so much in them, all in one package. I’m trying to help other Christians see the truth as I was one and pretty sucked in. Thank Hashem that he opened my eyes to the truth. I pray he does for all others too.

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@Jelena.Derosa]

@@dlight1999 the father is in all of us. So? That quote doesn’t mean anything and is always used to justify the trinity and that Yeshua was “God” There are over 90 verses of Yeshua saying he is NOT God. “Why do you call me good? There is only one good and that is the father in Heaven.” “I can do nothing apart from the Father.” “The father is greater.” How can he be greater if they are the same..? Why did Hashem say “well done my good and faithful servant with whom I am well pleased when Yeshua was baptized?” Why didn’t he say good job to me if he was God? Why did Jesus pray to God to save him before he died? “It is your will not mine.” When Jesus taught people how to pray he didn’t say “pray to me” he said pray like this “OUR FATHER WHO ART IN HEAVEN…” “ and Jesus fell on his face and prayed” to who?? Himself?? Why didn’t he know when “he’d return”?? Doesn’t God know everything? Right then he wasn’t God. He hasn’t link back to kings David either because he was of a “virgin” birth like every other pagan God that was before him. His own “birthday”is a pagan day. Come on. God said “he’s not a man”, and “no man shall die for another mans sins.” Please do yourself a huge favor and read rabbi tovias books. They cover everything possible and will clarify all your questions. 🙏🏻🙏🏻 may Hashem bless you

[@dlight1999]

@@Jelena.Derosa Shalom. I don't think you understand what i am saying here. Let's make it simple. Just forget about nefesh,etc. Ok, Trichotomy holds that humankind is a composite of 3 distinct components: Body, spirit, and soul. Do you have a body? Do you have a spirit? Do you have a soul? Ask yourself, Are you a trinity or echad? Then, please read genesis 1:26. I hope that you would understand. (Revision: Father, Torah , Ruach hakodesh = Yeshua) May Hashem bless you!

[@Jelena.Derosa]

@@dlight1999 not the same thing at all. You’re claiming a man to be God in order for us to receive his spirit. The father can give us his Holy Spirit without the help of anyone/anything else (Jesus) If he needs the help of Jesus to give us anything he wouldn’t be God. May he open up your eyes to the truth. Worshipping Jesus is idolatry and a huge sin and punishment.

[@dlight1999]

@@Jelena.Derosa No that's not my ques. My question was are you a trinity or echad? Simple question.

[@mohamedfahimsaidoo4269]

Peace be Upon You all Rabi Tovia Thank you for Always putting understanding and Acceptance before Arrogance and Agendas . You are a inspiration and I give you full respect . May you be blessed with health and wealth of knowledge to keep up your good work . Respect Peace be upon you Mohamed Fahim Saidoo

[@BalskyFunk]

As a muslim i am appreciating you rabbi tovia singer. Love from ur muslim brother in indonesia 😉

[@Random.sachen1]

You think he is your brother? 😅

[@Isaac5123]

Alhamdulillah

[@Isaac5123]

@@Random.sachen1 why do you ask?

[@Random.sachen1]

@@Isaac5123 because he is not your brother 😉 He would roast islam at any given chance.

[@Isaac5123]

@@Random.sachen1 he says brother because for the Jews and Muslims there is only One God

[@developer101]

Fantastic lesson Rabbi, thank you!

[@jefflynch3946]

Great video Rabbi -thank you!

[@ahmeds6421]

If the caller is reading my comment, I want to tell him: brother, at the end of the day, it's about you. Seek for the truth and the truth shall reveal itself to you. Never sugar-coat anything if it's religion you are talking about. You should know idolatry when you see one. And you should NOT defend it at all costs. I am your Muslim brother in humanity and I wish you well.

[@ahmeds6421]

@@hegagi839 I would like to have a cup of tea with a Jewish brother or sister, but I have never had a Jewish friend because there aren't any in my neighbourhoods. I am sure me and you agree on one thing; that God with His absolute power and reign, is great. And the question of how God prefers to be worshipped and how He wants us to live our lives is a point of discussion, not division and enmity.

[@wadiwafifatehahmed1211]

@@hegagi839 In Islam according to Al-Qur'an we got the purest +clearest knowledge about The One Creator. But, where even in Old Testament it has failed when saying God rides a cherub , God is forgetful + regretful+ Not all knowing + Not all seeing etc.etc. The Creator knows best & perfect about HIS creation & everyone who believe there is a Creator , will be agree with this. Now , ask yourself (1) If there is a Creator , will HE not provide us some kind of guidance providing along some kind of convincing proof to assured us this guidance is indeed from the Creator ? (2) We know there are thousands of religions & hundreds or few may be have some kind of books & they claim them their " Holly books / scriptures" from the Creator . But, except from Al-Qur'an is there any other Scripture claimed to be direct words from the Creator ? So far I know , the answer is NO ! Since only Al-Qur'an claims from the Creator & if the claim is true , than Everyone except the true followers of Al-Qur'an will be ending up in eternal hell especially those polithiestic idol worshipers .Don't you think you should atleast genuinely examine the claim instead of taking any risk out of ego / prejudice / blind hatreds ?! (3) How can you verify the claim of Al-Qur'an whether it's true or false ? You see in science anyone comes up with any new theory or discovery must also provide a " Falsification Test" to others to verify if that new theory is wright or wrong .Al-Qur'an also provide Falsification Tests , more than one , So, far I know Al-Qur'an provides you Six different kind of Falsification tests, you can examine them & prove wrong if you can ! Those tests are -->> (A) Find a contradiction (B) Those informations about Universe along with our Earth & whatever in it , prove them scientifically wrong with science facts not fictions (C) Any of the Historical event prove from the valid History to be wrong (D) Al-Qur'an in it's authentic language is made easy to memorise for any one speaking any language (E) Al-Qur'an will be preserve in it's pure form till the end of this Earth . (F) Produce a Book like Al-Qur'an!

[@scars73]

@@ahmeds6421 where are you from? I’d love to sit down and talk with a Muslim and Christian.

[@joycegreer9391]

@@wadiwafifatehahmed1211 Yes, The Bible. The Bible is God-breathed, the Word of God. Statements you made about OT are inaccurate and contrary to what Quran tells you about The Book, so you are then falsifying Quran.

[@SPQR748]

I grew up Catholic. One day in the fourth grade after morning prayer a nun that I was fond of asked why I don’t pray like the other kids? I said that it bothered me that Jesus is nearly naked. She looked at me with a smirk 😏 on her face for what seemed like an eternity. Then she announced that I could pray 🙏 to the Blessed Virgin Mary and she will intercede before her son for me. I was satisfied with that response. Idolatry leads to the worship of the human body which is God’s creation. This bodily fixation has lead Christians to call their church “The Body of Christ” If this is NOT idolatry then perhaps I don’t know the meaning of the word. 🌞🌞🌞

[@edwardmiessner6502]

Well the Protestants and Evangelicals try to get around worshipping a nearly (or entirely) naked man hanging from a cross by swapping out crucifixes for unadorned crosses. But now they have a greater problem: they're worshipping a cruciform execution stake! (They even have a song devoted to "The Old Rugged Cross") But if you were to tell them what Roman crucifixion was *really* like, they'd stop their ears and shout, "Lalalalala we're not LISTENING!" Why? Because they would know it was an abomination, which they should but don't!

[@mimianwar5448]

Hi my favourite Rabbi it's good to see you well and healthy

[@fidelcatsro6948]

even my Hindu cat loves him!

[@exposingtv9903]

@@fidelcatsro6948 🤣🤣lol. Your cat

[@fidelcatsro6948]

@@exposingtv9903 🐱👍🏾

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@dlight1999]

@ZN are a trinity or echad?

[@BigToeify]

Rabbi your ability to express a thought and convey it in simple language is staggering. To be able to take something as large as the Xstian claim and break it down to such simple terms in order to understand how flimsy the argument is is quite remarkable. You have such a gift and I for one am grateful to you.

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@mohamedabuzaid6538]

That guy studied English Aramaic Hebrew Arabic Studied Jewish Bible Muslim Quran and of course Christian Bible And still believe in Trinity Even he is the most blind man in the world or most con man in the world trying to justify something will you never understand Thank you rabbi for that amazing discussion god bless you

[@nasser20092009]

This Rabbi is absolutely gorgeous man with a great attitude, may Allah guide him to be a Muslim

[@Asdfhjkl998]

He is Muslim convert I believe or Arabic Christian and he believe god get human body and die for human sin 😀

[@AbdulGani-bb9xj]

@@nasser20092009 as salamu alaikum. What is the meaning of the word Muslim

[@nasser20092009]

@@AbdulGani-bb9xj you are a Muslim You know the meaning. A Muslim is any one who submit to the will of God and follow his messenger, Worship God alone, no partner no son Believe in all of his books, angels and messengers, never distinguish between them.

[@ryanardan09]

Probably he's having Religious Trauma Syndrome, a cretin. Someone said deeper one gets into Christianity deeper one gets into the insanity.

[@twobirds1817]

Thank you Rabbi.Nice to see you and hear you.❤

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@AgesthaHendra]

Both are truly amazing guy...very patient and smart guys

[@saadrathore4408]

This was a wonderful response.

[@dcrelief]

thank you.

[@laylaali5977]

I appreciate the Rabbi explaining to the Christians ridiculousness of the trinity doctrine with out calling them stupid.

[@ONEFAITHofJESUS]

It’s ignorant or wicked to associate Christians with the antichrist dogma of a “trinity” as JESUS nor His apostles, nor His followers ever uttered the word. JESUS taught The SHEMA as the 1st commandment.

[@rayansupremacy7624]

@@ONEFAITHofJESUS but the 1st commandment didn’t teach that a flesh will be god

[@ONEFAITHofJESUS]

Amen -GOD is a Spirit and they that worship Him must worship in Spirit and in Truth.

[@rayansupremacy7624]

@@ONEFAITHofJESUS we should worship God, not the spirit , we should worship the God of Jesus pbuh ,ameen

[@clickbaitosaurus1977]

@@ONEFAITHofJESUS Please tell that to your fellow Christians that insist that God would create something then equate that thing to himself.

[@davidm5662]

If one is honest with oneself how can one make an argument against Rabbi Tovia Singer or Jew for Judaism channels. Truth is truth. Once I discovered these channels and their teachings how could I stay Catholic? I couldn’t. It is very tough but truth is truth. Starting to study The Seven Laws of Noah. May G-D Bless us all.

[@Pasture_Prime]

You hit the nail on the head "honest with one's self"

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

The best explanations of the Noahide laws in English are the Divine Code and Seven Gates of Righteous Knowledge by Rabbi Weiner and Dr. Schulman. Good luck.

[@davidm5662]

@@hrvatskinoahid1048 Yes. Believe it or not I just ordered Divine Code and The prayer book. Can’t wait for them to be delivered. Thanks for the recommendations

[@patkervin5931]

@@davidm5662 what is the prayer book you reference?

[@davidm5662]

@@patkervin5931 Prayers,Blessings, and Principles of Faith by Rabbi Weiner

[@andrewfine2576]

Listening to you rabbi is sweet deliciousness. Baruch HaShem. Hazak hazak!

[@russelislam6135]

Justblove you and respect you so much. As a muslim i am just grateful to you for spreading the truth and honest explanation. You just stopped the man as he was unnecessarily tried to bring muslims into discusstion when question was so straight.

[@jennifersilves4195]

Thank you so much.

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@bb1111116]

I studied Christianity for years (I was once a Christian many years ago). Rabbi Singer in his videos has gone into detail of a gradual change in the beliefs of the followers of Jesus starting from Mark & Paul which had a split in beliefs. * Jesus in Mark is more like a prophet similar to David. Jesus in Paul is a divine being, but not quite God. * There was a hostility between Paul & the followers of Jesus who continued to practice Judaism (See Galatians & Acts). - Paul’s Gentile church would dominate the Jesus movement especially after the defeat of Israel by the Romans. This Gentile dominance in Christianity led to the books attributed to John where the line between Jesus & God was further blurred. * But even after that, the majority of Christian leaders in the first 3 centuries believed that Jesus, while divine, was not = to God. This was labeled Arianism. The Arians had the majority in some church councils after Nicene. But they eventually lost & were declared to be heretics. * Knowing this history is one of the many reasons why I am not longer a Christian & eventually came to a faith which is consistent w/ the Noahide laws.

[@mahmoodali1533]

Try to study Islam and tell me what you think.

[@wbjsle7379]

Islam? As far i know according to the dead sea scrolls the messias was meant to be a levite and not specifically a descendant of david. Jesus was a levite. Islam considers him to be the messiah and a prophet of god but merely just a human being without any divine attributes.

[@adelow]

@@mahmoodali1533 I would guess that he did revert to islam Alhamdulillah, islam is the only religion that is consistent with the noahide laws with the exception of judaism

[@rollingknuckleball]

To the Christian caller, when responding to "Only the father knows the hour", you said the hypostatic union that Jesus was in limited his mind, in a sense, saying his true divine form would know the hour. To that I would ask, what about the holy spirit? Why does the holy spirit not know? Isn't the holy spirit co-equal with the father and co-omniscient? Last I checked the holy spirit was not limited by a human form.

[@Pakos425]

Look into Islam, islam is pure monotheism

[@fidelcatsro6948]

Worshipping a man is haram!

[@fidelcatsro6948]

@@CriminalJusticeExpert Im sorry God already told you *I AM NOT A MAN!!!* So are you telling me God played a monkey hat trick on us by coming as a man after sending scriptures saying his modus operandi wont be like that? God is not an author of confusion!! Jacob could have wrestled with an angel, 3 men heading to Sodom could have been angels.. The term God is commonly used in the Jewish bible to describe Judges, God fearing men and even angels! Even Prophet Jesus told you in the Bible (John 10:30) when he said ''“Is it not written in your Law: ‘I have said you are gods’? If he called them gods to whom the word of God came - and the Scripture cannot be broken >>example of 'you are gods' used in scripture.... Psalm 82:6 I said, "You are gods, And all of you are sons of the Most High. Psalm 8:6 angel called god, Isaiah 7:10 prophet called god, Exodus ch7 moses called god, Judges 33:16 jerusalem was called god, Exodus 21:5 judges were called god I can disprove your claim from Pauls own book! - *We see Jesus who was made a little lower than angels!!!!!!!* Hebrews 2:9 (I didnt sneak inside your church and write that in the NT bible yesterday night while you were sleeping amigo!) Anyway Prophet Jesus didnt die! He was raised up alive! No one dies in 5hrs on a Roman Tbar! He was supposedly put on a bar in the afternoon and brought down before sunset...

[@Pakos425]

Worshipping a man is shirk

[@yoan6345]

worshiping STONE …Halal 😅🤣😂

[@yoan6345]

@@abdul-hadidadkhah1459 so why 5times a day you bowdown to kabbaa?? Explain!

[@yoan6345]

@@abdul-hadidadkhah1459 so who can forgive sins? ONLY the creator right?? did that stone can forgive sins???? 😏

[@WillScarlet1991]

The trinity is the most nonsensical belief I've ever come across.

[@bondys-video-kucing]

The caller is a good person. I wish all of us have God's guidance

[@metsiebestie]

It’s hard to defend Trinitarian beliefs and praying to saints/angels, veneration of Mary as cointercessor with Jesus, etc. as monotheistic

[@fazbell]

All religion is poison.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

haram haram haram! shirk! shirk! shirk!

[@StellaMontenegro]

@@priasejesus8692 *Eastern Orthodox Christians, as well.*

[@testalltruths2045]

Sory Michael but this is a straw man...We Christians are not the Same as Catholics...

[@blitzbees890]

@@testalltruths2045 but you pray to Jesus cuz you guys think hes a god or son of god ( depends which Christians you ask ) . With that being said its fair to say all Christian be it Chatolic or Evangelical or whatever its pagan cuz their root of belief is based on paganism that such human can be god or son of god . Praise to true God the one and only without partner that He never died especially dead on the cross that i am not Christian or be part of that confused & paganism belief . Never !

[@mohamedidrisshaikh4153]

This is what wisdom form GOD looked like, Thank you sir.

[@sonofblessed]

One of the most interesting things I've ever heard from a Christian about the Trinity came from Dr. William Lane Craig. He said that God is a remarkably simple Being because He has no parts. What's interesting about that is that Craig absolutely believes in the Trinity, but the Trinity indicates that God is not simple, but complex.

[@jewulo]

Dr. William Lane Craig is a master of the word salad. He is very good at linguistic sophistry.

[@kevingorayah705]

@@jewulo he is also brainwashed blind and all other universities of the church around the world are blind in real time and also in the slight of eye went god said let's us make human in ours image the church put that reference on the trinity but the treu outstanding and authority of this verse is he was alone went he created everything and all things and before he closed the chapters of his university of creation the meaning of let's us make he was revealed he was speaking to his universally multitude superior archangels that where went he discovered the tower of babel let's us decent and then confused their's language did he decent no but he used his archangel at the superiors level and other angels at the second grade honors level but let's us he was speaking to his Supreme mighty archangel and angels the corupted blinds church put that in the corupted interpretation and the counsel of Niciea roman

[@gaelicreaction1049]

Why wouldn't God be complex from the point of view of a human? He is beyond our comprehension? Even a unitarian has to admit that.

[@kingofdetroit358]

It a shows how delusional these people are. Their brain sees the evidence but they don't want to comprehend.

[@justarshad8354]

No matter what as soon someone cant explain the trinity yet believes in it then that person is purely bias..cant listen or take him serious.simple as that!

[@scars73]

That was a really good call. Much respect to that man.

[@glenanleitner2606]

Stop the idolatry in the world

[@swaterman2017]

Ameen

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@glenanleitner2606]

@@dlight1999 nice harmonization Too bad that's not true

[@dlight1999]

Do you have a body? Do you have a spirit? Do you have a soul? Ask yourself, Are you a trinity or echad? Then, please read genesis 1:26. I hope that you would understand. May Hashem bless you!

[@glenanleitner2606]

@@dlight1999 god says he is not a man God says he has no form I believe what god says You can harmonize and reconcile your belief all you want I choose to listen to god's voice May hashem bless you and help you hear his voice

[@meirgreen2188]

Great teachings!! Like always!! Thanks!

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@kingofdetroit358]

We love u our blessed n caring rabbi.

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@malkahzahmehretyah5831]

Wonderful teaching

[@abdullahaljalil5218]

I guess that Jews and Muslims have the same argument to prove that Jesus could not be divine, otherwise you woul be considered as an idolatress I couldn't agree more with what Rabbi is bringing to the table(his answer)

[@wbjsle7379]

@@entername_ Doesnt the Bible only say that prophecy stopped to come for bani israel? Other nations still could have prophets.

[@CriminalJusticeExpert]

So I'm guessing you think this frees you to eternal security in everlasting bliss of heaven? I tell you the Truth, there will be birds that glorify G-d in heaven before you! Unless you Repent, and trust in Jesus you will not see His Kingdom! You searched the scriptures and in them you think you have eternal life, but as I mentioned to you before, unless you Repent you do not and will not! REPENT!

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

​@@wbjsle7379 Gentiles are obligated to keep the 7 Noahide commandments specifically because God commanded them in the Torah through Moses.

[@wbjsle7379]

@@hrvatskinoahid1048 That wasnt my question lmao

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

​@@wbjsle7379 It answers your question, but you don't see it.

[@JohnBrembo90]

The most sincere and accurate answer... as a Muslim .... i find it very interesting argument hope it will enlighten the milky water. Tq. Malaysia.

[@----f]

My friend, what's going on in your profile picture?

[@ai7593]

Whenever Christianity is proved wrong by Rabbi Singer they always wanna bring Islam into the mix. 🤣 It never fails and shows their desperation.

[@leebarry5686]

Clear answer given

[@muhidinatik3064]

Thankx Mr Tovia,you always set things straight....about trinity there's always a contradiction

[@skidaddler6293]

Love it!

[@joeycan6801]

Hi Rabbi Tovia, I was a catholic and became an Atheist, you can say that I’m a re-born and happy Atheist. I just want to tell you that I love your videos, and subscribed to your channel, keep them coming and stay safe.

[@Truth_Seeker1]

This is an religious channel if you don’t believe in god why are you here? 😂

[@zackmano]

After listening to this in more detail, it sounds like this caller possibly is a Christian from a Muslim country. If I'm correct, this would be a good example of how Christians try to formulate their theology to attempt to fit with the strict "Tawhid"/Oneness of God that is central to Islam.

[@peacefulworld9832]

Why is he targeting Islam? The christians always misinterprete Quran. Here is the definition of Allah in Surah Ikhlas. "Say: He is Allah, the One and Only; 2 Allah, the Eternal, Absolute; 3 He begetteth not, nor is He begotten; 4 And there is none like unto Him." Rabbi, do you agree with this definition. Is it applicable to the Hashem of Judism?

[@eddiemonesti5671]

😁😁😁

[@wbjsle7379]

@Just Tama But the Bible only says that prophecy stoped for bani israel, not for other nations or folks?

[@barakmoss1691]

Rabbi Singer never disappoints

[@aminedamil]

Thank you Rabbi Tovia for this beautiful speech!🙏🏼 May Allah/Hashem bless you for your great work. For all the christians that tries to attack Islam, it won’t benefits you. So why all this hatred? The Quran say "O you who believe! No people shall ridicule other people, for they may be better than they."☝🏼

[@dlight1999]

For example: Obviously i have a body, as well as an "animal" soul (nefesh HaBahamis) and a Divine soul ( nefesh HoElokis). When i die my spirit and body separate, but i am NOT a trinity. I am 1 (echad). All people are created in the image of G-d. G-d : Father, the living torah (yeshua), ruach hakodesh are 1 (echad). Yochanan 10:30 I and my Father are echad. Yochanan 14:8-10 Philip said, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Yeshua answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me, has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me?

[@magiccccmetalhammer]

Can I see, a gospel before 150 ad in its original language please? Ofc all 4 gospels would match and will have some differences, not many people could write then.. those who wrote were considered to have the "holy spirit" Now, we have to stop with this "nice man" propaganda.. Obviously, jewish man, arameic speaking, but not a single gospel in his language, not a single word spoken in first person and from Jesus himself but spoken in 3rd person, who saw who and who said what.. To me 4 gospels PROVE that Jesus existed, but the logic that contradict itself, is thanks to polytheist greeks.. constantine would not have a monotheist religion dictate the rules and overshadow theirs. So I believe in Jesus, I believe that the gospels are guidance to do good and inspire you... But I do not believe they have the complete truth and are reliable. But they are inspired from a jewish nation and in 1 verse Jesus says that he came to fulfil the torah.. Jesus also said I in the father and you in me... This is all figure of speech. Your spirit and body separate? Do you have any observable evidence for that? or is that just what you "believe" ?

[@originalunoriginal4055]

@@dlight1999 This is just so so confusing and i think it would take very intelligent person to understand or comprehend! Meaning, a child taught this stuff you wrote.... Would be taking the material passively and not with true conviction and understanding!

[@rustyray420]

@@dlight1999 is jesus' soul the same as God's? No they are seperate so can it be one? Why would God come down as a human to sacrifice himself instead of just forgiving through his mercy? God says in your OT that He is ONE and does not change then all of a sudden out of nowhere He's a man?

[@ronahijau3749]

What is man that you are mindful of him, and the son of man that you care for him? 5 Yet you have made him a little lower than the heavenly beings and crowned him with glory and honor. 6 You have given him dominion over the works of your hands; you have put all things under his feet, Psalm 8:4-6

[@paulawallace8784]

4When I see Your heavens, the work of Your fingers, the moon and stars that You have established, דכִּֽי־אֶרְאֶ֣ה שָׁ֖מֶיךָ מַֽעֲשֵׂ֣ה אֶצְבְּעֹתֶ֑יךָ יָרֵ֥חַ וְ֜כֽוֹכָבִ֗ים אֲשֶׁ֣ר כּוֹנָֽנְתָּה: 5what is man that You should remember him, and the son of man that You should be mindful of him? המָֽה־אֱ֖נוֹשׁ כִּֽי־תִזְכְּרֶ֑נּוּ וּבֶן־אָ֜דָ֗ם כִּ֣י תִפְקְדֶֽנּוּ: 6Yet You have made him slightly less than the angels, and You have crowned him with glory and majesty. ווַתְּחַסְּרֵ֣הוּ מְ֖עַט מֵֽאֱלֹהִ֑ים וְכָב֖וֹד וְהָדָ֣ר תְּעַטְּרֵֽהוּ: 7You give him dominion over the work of Your hands; You have placed everything beneath his feet. זתַּמְשִׁילֵֽהוּ בְּמַֽעֲשֵׂ֣י יָדֶ֑יךָ כֹּ֜ל שַׁ֣תָּה תַֽחַת־רַגְלָֽיו

[@ronahijau3749]

@@paulawallace8784 So what's your point'?

[@bobbyberlianto]

After almost 2000 years... trinitarian still difficult to understood by most human being.... God wants to prank us or playing with us... impossible...something must be wrong with this religion.

[@firstlast1357]

Why Christianity is a pagan religion? It didn’t used to be. But the moment trinity was introduced it became pagan. When one puts different attributes / knowledge to father, holy spirit, , or son you create a separation, not unity, thus god is not one. That’s exactly is the root of the problem - paganism .

[@CriminalJusticeExpert]

My friend, the problem is that you are trying to understand G-d by human wisdom and with this logic, you only get human intelligence, so how can you understand? With spiritual intervention or intelligence. How do you get Spiritual intelligence, through G-d giving you His Holy Spirit! Do you have Facebook and what is it so we can talk more

[@semmunn8322]

everything wrong with all three barbaric religions

[@timothy9360]

@@firstlast1357 trinity wasn't introduced it has always been taught. Jesus himself taught the trinity in Matthew 28:19.

[@joycegreer9391]

@@CriminalJusticeExpert Exactly right, and the basis of Singer's argument.

[@dlight1999]

Praying for you Rabbi

[@ONEFAITHofJESUS]

But be not ye called Rabbi: for one is your Master, even Christ; and all ye are brethren. 9 And call no man your father upon the earth: for one is your Father, which is in heaven.

[@adellaadams8018]

Watch the pagan xtians who will come to attack! They do not believe the words of GOD! "I AM HASHEM, that is MY Name; I will not give MY Glory to another, nor MY Praise to graven idols!" Yeshi'yahu/Isaiah 42:8.

[@CriminalJusticeExpert]

Adella, I'm so sorry that you are mistaken. You do not know G-d, and you cannot know Him, because to know Him is to know Him who sent Him. Yeshua Hamashiach is the Way, the Truth, and the Life! No man comes to the Father, but by Him! You know it's really tough going back and forth and I say I won't, but geez is it hard! My dear, I did not listen to a sermon or ask a preacher or anyone. I can tell you my testimony but you won't believe. Let's say this. (What I'm going to say didn't happen, but I can tell you similar stories and my own testimony which is different of course) Okay, so You have a vision and you see a path, and suddenly a voice speaks and tell you who He is. Now, knowing what Christians seek, would you really say Satan cleans someone up and make them Christian? For example so a man beats his wife, drinks, does drugs and has a rapid death waiting , until the vision and turns to G-d immediatelythe next day of carrying out these activities. Now, would you say Satan deceived the person to become Christian, when Satan already had his soul leading to death and hell? Now be honest, that would be foolish thinking if you believe, Satan turned a very evil and sinful man into a good person who cherishes, loves and takes care of himself and family, wouldn't you? So, what makes you think being a Christian is not the truth? Unless you Repent, this message will be used to judge you on the day of judgment. Repent, the Kingdom of G-d is at hand!

[@fidelcatsro6948]

ameen sister ..God of Abraham akbar!!

[@fidelcatsro6948]

@@CriminalJusticeExpert stop putting God into lego image of man! God is not a man!

[@anthonyderosa7730]

@@CriminalJusticeExpert when Jesus was baptized by John. What happened.

[@anthonyderosa7730]

@@CriminalJusticeExpert they heard gods voice right? ""Behold, my faithful servant""?. Jesus was not speaking.

[@dark_attack7896]

Shalom Aleichem Rav. BARUCH HA'SHEM.

[@shalomalcheim7402]

Rabbi Tovia is such a mensch

[@patrickkluivert1547]

Meaning

[@האריההנסתר]

Thank you rabbi

[@Dawahdude0]

Rabbi destroyed the TRINITY logically and beautifully

[@joycegreer9391]

No, he didn't. He gave human understanding reasons, not supernatural/divine.

[@avalerie4467]

I don't understand how it's not OBVIOUS that so called relics collected by the RCC, statuaries of saints martyrs et c, little and enormous crucifi that people carry around or kneel in front of or flagellate themselves for is not understood as idolatry. . . Little by little, I think those of us willing to see the Truth, have it revealed. Thank you, dear Rabbi, for your very important role in this project. May HaShem bless you, your family and your crew.

[@preussenuberalles1682]

Christianism seems to me a reduced Hinduist belief: Vishnu underwent 9 avatars and the Christian god just 3.

[@4321grp]

I am a Christian and I agree with Rabbi Singer 100 % in regard to the trinity! the trinity is Christianity's(Catholicism's) self-inflicted wound.

[@stevenjohnson8319]

Does anyone know what the music is that Rabi Tovi Singer plays at the end of his lesson? Tovia is great!

[@mozart9991]

Rabbi, I have recently discovered your videos and have very much been enjoying them. I myself am a scholar of religion(s), albeit my area of expertise is China (and Asia more broadly). I wonder if you can speak to the history of Judaism regarding the times when there were other gods besides G-d. Why did people think these other gods existed? What is the nature of these other gods with respect to G-d? Hopefully you will know of what I speak. I enjoy your teachings very much. Congratulations and blessings on the new members of your family!

[@abdullahalrai]

Salute to Rabbi, for his very crystal clear yet humble response to this gentleman. Secondly, Muslim believe and Worship the same Divine Being as Jews does. In fact, every Chapter of The Holy Qur’an start with the name of HaShem Eloh’m that Muslim recite in their 5 daily prayers. בשם אלוהים הרחמן והרחום BeShem Eloh’m haRakhman haRakhom بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم BeSem Allah Al-Rahman Al-Raheem Rabbi is right leave the Muslims out of your ambiguous belief in Trinity , Allah (Eloh’m) is one and only God without any partners.

[@sonofblessed]

That may be true, and that is good, but the issue with Islam is the belief in updated revelation. Once revealed, the truth cannot change, morph, or evolve into something else. Islam's theology is correct, but it adopts a doctrine similar to Christianity's progressive revelation, which of course we Jews have to reject (as you do regarding your own texts).

[@abdullahalrai]

@@sonofblessed we don’t believe in progressive revelation but rather it is the same core belief system (Deen) that was first given by Hashem to Prophet Noah and then to Prophet Abraham and all his Children (i.e both Ishmalites or Israelites), Purpose of the Final Revelation I.e Holy Quran is to Revive and Reenforce the same Deen that was once uphold By Banai Israel and Benai’ Ishmael.

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

​@@abdullahalrai Islam is obviously a new religion with new commandments.

[@truthseeker9183]

@@abdullahalrai No, you have a different deen.

[@sonofblessed]

@@abdullahalrai I respect your religion, but I have to respond in this way. That’s just a different way of saying the same thing: it can’t be the same core belief if each revelation is inherently different. How do we measure “difference?” One good way is to see if the commandments are different. For example, the Torah has 613 commandments, the Christian Scriptures only have a handful, and the Q’uran has about 100, some of which are similar and some of which are not. In other words, you _believe_ that it’s the same stream of _deen_ from Abraham to Muhammad, but when you analyze the content you’ll see that it’s different. This means that either a) today’s Judaism is not the original truth and Islam corrects it, or b) Judaism _is_ the original truth and _Islam_ is different than Judaism. The Jews had no motive to change their revelation any more than you have the motive to corrupt yours. The Jews resisted hard against idolatry in every generation, and were killed for it, so it’s hard to believe that they would simply and casually corrupt their own religion for who-knows-what reason. You realize that the entire time this was happening that God didn’t replace them, which indicates that it didn’t happen. It’s more of a belief that you need to justify your faith more than it is something that can be demonstrated. Again, I respect your religion, but the things you believe about Judaism are not true.

[@travel4JC]

Thank you Tobia Singer for all your knowledge and helping me understand the contradictions of the New Testament, I'm no r certified anymore by many of my Christian friends or family due to my research for truth, and they are shocked when I say I no longer wAnt to be called a Christian although I believe Yeshua existed and was a great teacher and they called him Rabbi in his time..they really don't like me when I tell them their holidays are Paganism, hoping to find a group of people that I can relate to

[@Yvghhnkoo]

Ur belief is similar to Muslim who consider him a teacher and a prophet , maybe u should research about Islam , I suggest reading books not from the internet

[@sholompraver4348]

I feel for you. I hope your journey has become less lonely. May God's blessings be increasing apparent to you as your life becomes evermore fulfilling, genuine and happy. Keep growing, caring, and giving. Chazak u'varuch (be strong and blessed)

[@sciologist]

Ex 20:2 “I am YHVH, thou shalt have no other YHVH, no other Elohyim before me…” Tanakh Deu 6:4 Hear, O Israel; “YHVH is our God (ELoHYim), YHVH is the only one”. Tanakh Isaiah 42:8 I am YHVH, that is my name, and my glory I will not give to another… Tanakh Isaiah 43:10 ..I am YHVH; “Before me there was no other god formed, neither shall any be after me”. Tanakh Isaiah 43:11 I am YHVH and beside me there is no other savior. Tanakh Isaiah 44:6 Thus saith YHVH... I am the first and I am the last, and besides me there is no other god. Tanakh Isaiah 45:6, I am YHVH, and there is no one else… Tanakh Isaiah 45:5, I am YHVH, and besides Me there is no other God… Tanakh Ps 146:3, Put not your trust in princes, nor in a son of man, who cannot save you. Tanakh Hosea 11:9 I am YHVH... and not a man… Tanakh

[@ronahijau3749]

In my vision at night I looked, and there before me was one like a son of man,[a] coming with the clouds of heaven. He approached the Ancient of Days and was led into his presence. 14 He was given authority, glory and sovereign power; all nations and peoples of every language worshiped him. His dominion is an everlasting dominion that will not pass away, and his kingdom is one that will never be destroyed.

[@sciologist]

@@ronahijau3749 Daniel 7:13, vague, no one named Jesus in Daniel or any of the prophets. Moreover, Jesus did not fulfil Daniel 7:13 or any of the prophcies of a Messiah. When the messiah comes he will deliver Israel and bring peace to the earth. Jesus failed to bring peace to the earth. From 70 AD, the christians were killed, the girls rapped and children were put into slavery. Jesus Failed.

[@ronahijau3749]

@@sciologist what is man that you are mindful of him, and the son of man that you care for him? 5 Yet you have made him a little lower than the heavenly beings and crowned him with glory and honor. 6 You have given him dominion over the works of your hands; You have put all things under his feet,

[@sciologist]

No Jew will bow to the mamzer son of a roman soldier. Jesus failed to produce Supernatural Public Miracles. Jesus was just a pagan sorcerer. read the "Bible Codec".

[@ronahijau3749]

@@sciologist ‘You will be ever hearing but never understanding; you will be ever seeing but never perceiving. For this people’s heart has become calloused; they hardly hear with their ears, and they have closed their eyes. Otherwise they might see with their eyes, hear with their ears, understand with their hearts and turn, and I would heal them.

[@doldier]

Good job rabbi, it’s very difficult debating Christians about this doctrine. Logic is usually thrown out and it becomes this fantastical explanation of something that makes no sense and contradicts the entirety of scriptures.

[@Armando7654]

Yes, bc the only explanation you accept is that of equivocations. But what exactly do you equate God to? Why don't you learn to draw distinctions instead of equations and perhaps you'll stumble over "explanation"

[@rapturebound197]

Good exchange so far on both sides. Im going to comment early because I think the Rabbi has done a very good and intellectually honest & fair job of outlining the Christian perspective on the trinity. He actually describes it better than many Christians are able to do..and his sincere work at portraying it clearly is evident and sincerely appreciated. I think we can all agree that the scope of who and what God is cannot be fathomed. And therefore - Only God knows God! Its an understatement to say God (Hashem) is complex. How could He NOT be?! And its in that unsearchable complexity for me as a follower of who I think is the Messiah that I must live by faith and accept that Hashem is indeed ONE. Its like He is 1/3 Water..1/3 Blood and 1/3 Oil which when added up equals ONE. Each part is very distinct, serves a specific purpose and yet would be incomplete without each component. Sh'ma Yisrael Adonai Eloheinu Adonai Eḥad: "Hear, O Israel: the LORD is our God, the LORD is One." What words do you use to explain the unexplainable.? I've tried very hard as a Christian to grasp the composite unity of Hashem but every time I do it always comes down to the 3 way juxtaposition that I cannot put infinity in a finite jar. If "God" and all that He is could fit in a mans 3 lb. brain He isn't much of a God! The just shall live by faith. It simply has to be that way. And I'm ok with that. ✡ = Promises foretold ✝ = Promises fulfilled Baruch Hashem Adonai! Amen! Added later: Those catholic images you put up on the screen during the discussion tell me you don't get it perhaps as much as I thought rabbi. Those images were not only a complete distortions of biblcal Christianity but were disappointingly unnecessary. Thats not who we are. Catholicism and mormonism drives us as crazy as it does you. Catholicism is an abomination. Mormons think they will be gods..never mind who they think jesus is. Neither of these religions speak for nor represent Yeshua in any way. The "jesus" of catholicism & mormonism is not the Jesus of the bible. The adversary uses these religions to obfuscate and purposely distort the being and work of Messiah. This discussion took a nose dive at the 9:40 point..which is somewhat predictable but never the less always deflating and really sad. I am reminded of Hashems words to Moshe - “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.”

[@rollingknuckleball]

To the Christian caller, when responding to "Only the father knows the hour", you said the hypostatic union that Jesus was in limited his mind, in a sense, saying his true divine form would know the hour. To that I would ask, what about the holy spirit? Why does the holy spirit not know? Isn't the holy spirit co-equal with the father and co-omniscient? Last I checked the holy spirit was not limited by a human form.

[@paulawallace8784]

@@priasejesus8692 Nonsense, the moshiach will marry and have children, his heir will take his place, as he is mortal man, not a Man Made Pagan Greco Roman demigod.

[@7XjakelX7]

Rabbi Tovi is the best

[@VigilanteMian]

Rabbi explained it very clearly.

[@princenameless]

“Could we not put Muslims in this… else we’re going to go off the rails”. Woahhhh there 😂.

[@Post-Trib]

Trinitarians are not Christians. Their doctrine began with Tertullian & was then voted into doctrine by the Nicene Council of 325AD. The doctrine of one God is an absolute numerical one. Not 3 or more.

[@shadbakht]

Actually trinitarians DO believe G-d is a man. They say Jesus the physical person is 100% man and 100% G-d.

[@Pasture_Prime]

Guess he giving 200 % also 100 percent ghost

[@eddiemonesti5671]

Not anymore. They say completely God and Completely man. They stop using Numbers.

[@shadbakht]

@@eddiemonesti5671 I heard this Christian pop song for kids that says “1+1+1=1” 🤯

[@Pasture_Prime]

@@shadbakht lol xtian math

[@avalerie4467]

@@Pasture_Prime yep, nothing seems to add up, ever !

[@I77RAELAURA]

Great question. Many Christians literally Pray to jesus and/or in his name. This is what can be seen as idolatry.

[@R.B.891]

Great video, but the title of the video is shameless click bait. The man didn't "confront" the rabbi. He respectfully asked a question and the two men engaged in thoughtful debate.

[@savtamarlene]

The caller sure sounded like he was confronting Rabbi Singer to me. He was definitely confrontational. Not nasty or obnoxious, but confrontational. Only because Rabbi Singer asked him to remain on the line and discuss the question with him, did it then NOT become confrontational.

[@R.B.891]

@@savtamarlene Just curious, are you the person who chose the title for the video?

[@savtamarlene]

@@R.B.891 NO! Just my opinion. If I don't agree with your observation, then I must have chose the title? SHEESH! You're the only one allowed to have an opinion?

[@R.B.891]

@@savtamarlene What? I asked because I made a comment once and someone from the rabbi's staff answered. I thought maybe you worked for the rabbi. Yikes.

[@josephmoncrief865]

All below said in love. I don’t pretend to have all the answers. Bless you!

[@chriskell4019]

Even when I was a Christian (Baptist), I could never stomach the trinity doctrine. I knew it was insane, and was quite vocal about it. Possibly it was because I was a Mormon for many years before being a Baptist. It simply made no sense. It wasn't honest. Claiming something nonsensical is true is disingenuous, nothing more. The more I protested, the more I was told to have "faith". Twain put it well when he said "Faith is believing in what you know just ain't so." Then I read probably the best description of the trinity by Robert Ingersol. Once I stopped laughing, it all made perfect sense. If you keep repeating the same lie over and over, no matter how preposterous, people will believe it. Now, what country was famous for using such tactics.....Just sayin'.

[@Pasture_Prime]

@@thomasmagnum6588 he did not fulfill one

[@alekssalkinrkc]

@@thomasmagnum6588 which prophecies did he fulfill?

[@simplicityistheultimatesop6571]

@@thomasmagnum6588 what went wrong with the fig tree?

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

I hope you already accepted the 7 Noahide commandments. Good luck.

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

​@Claire Khaw Your false religion is forbidden by the Torah's Noahide Code.

[@lejenstudio]

God is unique. He is The Eternal, no begets nor begotten and nothing alike the Only One. God is beyond imagination. Those who potray the look of God will ruin themselves. In the end they will make a shape and worship what their hand had made.

[@ganuv]

There is nowhere in the whole Hebrew scripture where it’s mentioned that god is manifested in the flesh, nowhere that it’s mentioned .. not from the writings and not from the prophets.

[@sickmsmokey]

Abraham had dinner with Him. Did Abraham cook dinner for three ghosts or see-through spirits with no real stomach? Did the prophet Isaiah not foretell of the coming Messiah?

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

​@@sickmsmokey Abraham had dinner with the 3 angels.

[@sickmsmokey]

@@hrvatskinoahid1048 scripture clearly states it was God almighty talking face to face with Abraham... two angels are present with Him... two angels went toward Sodom but Abraham stayed in the presence of God

[@paulawallace8784]

@@sickmsmokey No, Gd sent 3 Angels to Abraham, 2 of those Angels He also sent to Lot. Just as He sent an Angel to speak to Moses in the Burning Bush, He sent Angels to interact with Man and He revealed Him to Israel and they saw No Image, No Form, as He made certain His Son Israel/the Jews would never think of HIM as the Heathen Pagans do their Man Made deities like yourself.

[@sickmsmokey]

@@paulawallace8784 you are refuting what scripture clearly and plainly states.

[@briancordero7674]

The enormity of the claim must be match with a solid answer,not merely unconventional terms that contradict the simple basic meaning of oneness.

[@JoeMova]

Think about this if you say all 3 are one why pray specifically to Jesus? You cant go to father without the son!? Sounds separate to me. To me ONE God and no other makes more sense. If you truly believe they are all in one. Why not just pray to the source and not make it separate. People can say many things but actions in what they do prove differently. That is why christianity doesn’t make any sense to me, you cant pick and choose whatever fits your narrative. Example: ask a christian person why they don’t pray to God directly if they say they are all the same 3=1 ? Why cant u go to father without son if they are all technically the same. Would love to hear an answer

[@JoeMova]

@@bt-lt4os dont know what passage this is what my neighbor always tells me when i ask him why cant you just pray to God himself. I just searched and its john 14:6 John 14:6 Jesus said, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.” John 3:5 Jesus answered, “Very truly I tell you, no one can enter the kingdom of God unless they are born of water and the Spirit.” So if this is the case its not 3=1. Seems seperate to me and goes totally against what the OT says.

[@JoeMova]

@@bt-lt4os so different places say different things thanks this even proves my point more appreciate it. Which is it if u cant go to father without son? Or your passage? You cant have both. Think about it If you cant go to father without son and in essence they are all the same how does that make any logical sense?

[@JoeMova]

@@bt-lt4os so what does it mean u cant go to father without the son? What is it you have to do with the son if you can pray to father? U know it doesn’t make sense so there is no answer and is written by people who never even met the man.

[@JoeMova]

@@bt-lt4os but arnt they the same? So if u accept God alone Whats the difference?? Why do you keep avoiding my question. Jesus a solution so now hes not God anymore? Which is it is he or is he not God? Now this is more confusing then before

[@JoeMova]

@@bt-lt4os so he is not God anymore. They are not 3=1 anymore? What you just sent shows thAt. How can the father be greater if they are technically the same. Thanks for sending all these passages appreciate it. Now i can show my neighbor all of this. And for you. Read this 1. Deuteronomy 4:35,39 - Unto thee it was shown, that thou mightest know that the LORD he is God; there is none else beside him. (39) Know therefore this day, and consider it in thine heart, that the LORD he is God in heaven above, and upon the earth beneath: there is none else. Seems like he doesn’t need anyone else. What does no one else mean to you?

[@michaelhenry1763]

I think the caller agreed with most of what Rabbi Singer said, but disputed the use of the term idolater. I agree that term is a little harsh.

[@rutbrea8796]

It doesn't make sense that the Almighty, Creator of the universe, would need to become a human being just to save His creation! Jesus, if he really existed, how could he ask our Creator to help him if he was all mighty and miracles maker? This caller seems to know Hebrew very well and have been brain washed. And dying to save His creation, that philosophy is so preposterous that only the mind of a child can accept just because of innocence and ignorance.

[@boriszakharin3189]

Don't we as Jews believe that it is impossible to comprehend the nature of God? Doesn't that make it a mystery too? Isn't the very existence of God an extraordinary claim? How do we answer that if we don't understand what God is?

[@GallumA]

I would love to see Rabbi Tovia Singer at Speaker's Corner in london clearing up some of the debates going on between the Abrahamic speakers.

[@GallumA]

yes but specifically at speaker's corner, because it would be amazing to see him within the culture of the park, talking to Bob, Hamza, Shamsi and so forth. I just think it would be incredibly valuable and he'd thrive in the situation with his energy.

[@GallumA]

@Just Tama aw yea, very sad to hear of what happened with Hatun. No excuse at all. But I don't think anyone at speaker's corner supports it at all, and it's very rare that anything escalates so far. I think when we start to avoid discussing freely in public because of fear, we really are quite lost. But your point is understandable.

[@GallumA]

saying that, I am actually a total hypocrit I suffer an anxiety disorder I can barely leave the house without taking a deep breath let alone turn up at speakers corner

[@FrankNStein-pf9rr]

@ 16:25, Re: John 1:1. That's odd indeed WHEN we are ALSO taught that "God" is without beginning" BUT here in John 1:1 In the beginning God was?? In the beginning of WHAT, since God is WITHOUT BEGINNING!! Now which it B Hose A.

[@ninaovadia7965]

G-d is timeless.

[@FrankNStein-pf9rr]

@@ninaovadia7965 R U saying in the beginning is the same as timeless?? My question WAS/IS > IN THE BEGINNING OF WHAT???

[@VandalIO]

Christian put in his place !

[@VandalIO]

@Claire Khaw I heard him claiming to be Christian calling from England in the beginning , 0:05

[@VandalIO]

@Claire Khaw he also claimed that he’s studying Judaism ✡️ :)

[@eddiemonesti5671]

I'm not Christian, but the rabbi knows very well that, there are a lot of things that can not be explained in the Torah. He said himself. To say that all religions have answers is not true.

[@simplicityistheultimatesop6571]

You’re not a Jew or a Muslim nor a Christian,then what are you and what do you know?

[@bawa_jani]

Dear this is not all the wisdom that you know all the answers but the wisdom is you know what you can not know..... Human has its limitations so just learn this

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

The Oral Torah explains the Written Torah just fine.

[@eddiemonesti5671]

@@hrvatskinoahid1048 Not true. Any rabbi can't explain why they can not lobsters and many others things, I do believe in the Torah, but stop the lie, there are lot of things that the rabbis have said they can not explain. They can not explain why God order to kill the innocent children of Canaan. Please.

[@eddiemonesti5671]

@@simplicityistheultimatesop6571 I'm just a simple Human being who believe in God. That set.

[@komarchucky3456]

If God becoming a man, that's no God anymore

[@paulawallace8784]

Exactly!

[@latifzaman830]

all the verses that rabbi mentioned starting 15:41 is the same verses highlighted by deedat and zakir naik for people rethink why the verses doesn't reflect the divinity of Yeshua.

[@CriminalJusticeExpert]

Rabbi, you weren't fair. You asked the caller not to takj about Islam, but you mentioned Catholics and Mormons. You and I both know that those 3 are not a part of Christianity. I'm sure you're educated enough to know this, especially through many years of debate. Then you also know why they aren't Christian. If you don't know then let's agree you're not qualified to speak on Christianity.

[@isidoreaerys8745]

Christian apologists will in the same debate argue that their god sustains the order in the universe creating the laws of logic, such as identity and non contradiction. Then state 1=3

[@putrajs6423]

I'm muslim from indonesia. I must admit it... Jews is also granted knowlegde from ALLAH.... how rabbi singer rejects the theology doctrine of christianity is amazing...

[@alfianbanjaransari4096]

Mantap saudaraku

[@putrajs6423]

@@alfianbanjaransari4096 🙏🙏🙏

[@ruthietaylor8756]

Judaism existed thousands of years before islam and christianity! They took much from judaism and twisted most of it!

[@turkmagidoo2732]

Jesus is the human form of god the son. God the son is eternal and from the Father. Like the sun and its light. İs not the light sun also?

[@CriminalJusticeExpert]

So I'm guessing you think this frees you to eternal security in everlasting bliss of heaven? I tell you the Truth, there will be birds that glorify G-d in heaven before you! Unless you Repent, and trust in Jesus you will not see His Kingdom! You searched the scriptures and in them you think you have eternal life, but as I mentioned to you before, unless you Repent you do not and will not! REPENT!

[@paulawallace8784]

Jesus is found only where his sidekick the Devil and his lake of fire are found, the Greek Tall Tales of Man and the Book of Mormon, NOT the Bible. You are the one who needs to Repent, as your beliefs come from Man, they stand in OPPOSITION TO THE CREATOR AND THE BIBLE! THE CULT OF JESUS IS THE LAST BEAST!

[@CriminalJusticeExpert]

@@paulawallace8784 what is your belief? You see you do not know what you believe, and your worship is the worship of your pride. Pride leads to destruction and your heart is deceitful and riddled l wicked. I don't trust in man, I'm not a believer because of man. If I'm following man, then why would Satan divide his kingdom by pulling mmr away from sin? You see most people turn to "religion" hoping for whatever. I didn't turn to anything, Jesus turned to me. It is not you that does it, it's Him. Remember you believe whatever you believe because of your family, I believe because of Christ. You learn this and Repent! The Kingdom of G-d is at hand! Repent!

[@CriminalJusticeExpert]

@@paulawallace8784 also all sin will be forgiven men, except the blasphemy of the Holy Spirit!

[@CriminalJusticeExpert]

@@priasejesus8692 you have answered correctly, Amen brother!

[@paulawallace8784]

@@CriminalJusticeExpert GD IS THE ETERNAL ONE, EHYEH ASHER EHYEH/I WILL BE WHAT I WILL BE AND HIS HOLY SPIRIT IS HIS DIVINE PRESENCE, NOT ANOTHER DEITY! HE DECLARED ISRAEL IS HIS SON!