TRAMWAY ENGINES (RWS vs T&F) (Spot the Differences)

[@TankEngine97]

5:35 I find it kind of strange that Daisy was replaced with Diesel in the episode. Especially when the narrator says 'Diesel knew nothing about trucks.' With Daisy it makes more sense though I guess you could say Diesel doesn't know how to handle trucks probably given his previous experiences.

[@EssexAggiegrad2011]

It makes sense considering Daisy's arc in her debut

[@pukenmg284]

I think the reason is because Shining time station because the producer has problem with Daisy's design and both her episodes in season 2 were never premiered on the series

[@eastlancsesteem]

A common shining time L

[@andydoms2001]

I’ve always been confused about the location wise in the shed scene from Percy’s ghostly trick. It’s unclear weather Percy was coming into the shed from in front or behind Thomas and Toby, I mean when Thomas leaves it looks like his shed door behind him is the one Percy was coming through, but still it’s hard to tell.

[@permvw]

All we can say is thank you soo much Jeremy and I hope we get a few extra videos in the future. Like the Adventure Begins / The Railway Series comparison

[@deadchannel8262]

Can't wait for book #27

[@isitredormaroon2196]

You forgot the part that Toby saw everything in the books! That farm lane can be seen from the sheds, and vice versa

[@Terrier55Stepney]

Very good. Is this the final one of these? I believe Percy travels backwards through the shed in Ghost Train as he has a tail lamp on the front and the steam in the illustration suggests it is moving towards rather than away.

[@Mr.toasterandclay]

Its funny because Mavis is stuck and toby it's at the sheds and then the next page you can see a glimpse of the shed do that means toby see Mavis struggle it's a funny moment

[@killdozer7792]

Y'know, I was thinking about how the only female engines in The Railway Series (Daisy, Mavis and later Pip & Emma) were all diesels, and I couldn't help but wonder if it was all a very deliberate nod to modernization - y'know, how running a railway was likely perceived to be a male thing, but just like diesels were proving their worth, so were female workers? Maybe I'm overthinking this, but it does still strike me.

[@russellgxy2905]

I don't think it was intentional, especially since all except Mavis are DMU's rather than full engines, but that's a good theory!

[@kodabear2856]

There actually is a female engine in the railway series. In the book Thomas and the great railway show there’s a red engine on the right side of the illustration. Her name is duchess of Hamilton and she’s a real engine

[@techcraft869]

You forgot Nancy!

[@nicholasscardinanewandimpo3387]

Pip is a girl?

[@jsut2654]

isn't Victoria female?

[@sleepybean9668]

The one thing I can really appreciate about this book is the fact Wilbert didn’t phone it in. He gave one last instance of world building before retiring.

[@BagelsGuy]

2:49 I’ll chuff and I’ll puff and I’ll break your door in! OHWOWOW-

[@KekoGaming1]

I can't wait until you say in the 30th book. 'Three books were made into episodes two days after they were made

[@FullArcher05]

Wow, you covered all of Wilbert's books now. Feels like you breezed right through them.

[@terencewilliammckenna6121]

If you'd ask me, I'd say that Percy's crew might've jumped clear in the episode just before Percy run into the cart of lime

[@javielalvarez5459]

Don’t forget Thomas laughing at him in RWS where he was disgusted in TV Series

[@tre-engines]

The end of an era

[@Ryder-a-Blaze]

5:35 who is that next to Daisy? Is it meant to be Annie and Clarabel?

[@HugeGarnetFan]

Yeah actually (annie and clarabel were bogie coaches in the rws)

[@Ryder-a-Blaze]

@@HugeGarnetFan they’re faces are so low down

[@HugeGarnetFan]

@@Ryder-a-Blaze oh i guess a drawing error then idk

[@M.P2608]

Love these videos, Keep up the great work!

[@conductorcarson]

“Really useful engines” is the 27th book of the railway series and was first published in 1983. It was the first to be written by the son of the Rev .w. Awdrey, christopher Awdrey, and the first to be illustrated by Clive Spong. Eleven years later two of the books four short stories where adapted during season four of Thomas and friends. How faithful were these adaptations? Let’s spot the differences. You should definitely try that one!

[@YourAverageRailwayFan]

ummmmm im not so sure that it was published in 1983

[@conductorcarson]

@@YourAverageRailwayFan it was. I looked it up. See for yourself.

[@YourAverageRailwayFan]

@conductorcarson oh wait poop i just relised you said "son" of rev .w. awdrey oops your right my mistake sorry for doubting you :(

[@conductorcarson]

@@YourAverageRailwayFan no harm done! 🙂

[@YourAverageRailwayFan]

@@conductorcarson thanks for that! and also yea he should do that! christopher awdrey needs some attention in this series!

[@kodabear2856]

In ghost train I know how Percy glided through the sheds(in front of Thomas and Toby). Percy reversed from the front of the sheds and glided through it to the other side behind Thomas and Toby. And Toby’s crew quickly shut the door right after. Hope that helped clear things up Also in wooly bear, I think Toby was glaring at Percy and not Thomas. It makes sense that Toby would be annoyed with Percy in this story because he teases him for his accident later on. It wouldn’t make sense for him to be mad at Thomas and then tease Percy in that story

[@Ryder-a-Blaze]

4:56 Toby looks like a creep who wants Mavis dead

[@inimitablestoo]

The TV adaptations also omit the part in the books where Percy's boiler shape changes for no apparent reason between the first two stories...

[@SparklingJam]

Wdym he looks the same

[@FlimFlam08]

7:42 i see a hand pushing the trucks

[@LMS-7412]

I never noticed that. I find it hilarious.

[@isitredormaroon2196]

Omg yessss XD

[@eastlancsesteem]

lol What an L! 😂

[@eastlancsesteem]

@@LMS-7412 ikr 😂

[@storiesfromdifferenteras]

7:02 the green controller classic series version.

[@trainmancorey7469]

I don't know why they didn't use Daisy in the TV adaptation but my theory is because Daisy and BoCo used the same chassis and BoCo was being used a lot in season 3 they just had Diesel take Daisy's place.

[@Emerald-764]

The whistle that you played at the end of the segment of the first story sounds like WW&F #9's whistle

[@swtransport099]

54th lol, great story to end the Wilbert era, on come the Christopher era!

[@thetrainmaster968]

And thus wraps up Wilbert’s books. Chris’s books are next.

[@nibbles6675]

So, the Christopher Awdry books next?

[@tigriller9727]

Maybe but I don't most of his stories were adapted on TV.

[@Zacman1123]

5:35 Seriously, why'd they replace Daisy with Diesel?

[@Thebreakingbadthomasfan23]

Idk

[@JoshProductions07]

Probably because Diesel is more evil.

[@RingoandCarlin]

Rick Siggelkow thought she was sexist

[@eastlancsesteem]

Male feminists 😂 That’s why

[@eastlancsesteem]

@@RingoandCarlin Pfft! 😂

[@ARobloxremake]

Can you do really useful engines please

[@AJsBusVideos]

Really Useful Engines was the final video. After book 27 no other stories were adopted into the TV series. You're welcome

[@sirwelcome]

Toby Trucks and Trouble

[@gregkiteos1936]

7:42 You can see a hand pushing the trucks.

[@eastlancsesteem]

😂

[@garywyn]

I love these videos. Shame Christophers stories never made it to TV Where can I watch full episodes with the Willie Rushton & Starr/Angelis narration please?

[@AlejandroFlores-Ibarra]

A number of Christopher's stories got adapted like "Better Late Than Never" and "Mind That Bike".

[@juanpablo.a]

The only stories that Chris wrote that made it to TV were: 1. Thomas, Percy and the Coal 2. Thomas and Trevor (annual story) 3. The Runaway 4. Better Late Than Never 5. Fish 6. Special Attraction 7. Mind that Bike 7/578 episodes is not a lot

[@jonfranklin18]

⁠@@juanpablo.aThomas & the Missing Christmas Tree as well, so making it 8 out of 578 or 1.4% of his stories being adapted.

[@juanpablo.a]

@@jonfranklin18 right, confused that one with "Thomas' Christmas Party"

[@jonfranklin18]

@@juanpablo.a it’s ok. It’s a shame more of his stories weren’t adapted tbh, yes his stories weren’t as good as Wilbert’s, but some must have been better than the crap churned our after series 5 onwards to adapt.

[@eastlancsesteem]

Britt should have based Mavis’s facial design on her RWS one.

[@evanclarke5561]

Both the book and show would've been better if there was a scene where either Thomas, Mavis or Toby banged the trucks. Either engine could've said: "You trucks/cars never learn do you??"

[@mrsquarewheels333]

Percy is actually gliding through the door backwards, here's some evidence: 1.At the front, you can see a red lamp, and not a white one 2. You can the steam coming from the funnel and pistons in front of percy

[@forrestdupre87]

This is also the last book Willie Rushton narrated.

[@blw26]

Wait, what's going to happen to your channel once all of the railway series books that had been adapted have been reviewed of the differences?

[@thomasfune3383]

Awesome

[@ARobloxremake]

More about Thomas the Tank Engine is the 30 book of The Railway Series first published in 2010 it was the fourth to be created by Christopher Audrey 7 years later all of the 4 stories we're adapting into 3 short episodes Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends how faithful War their habitations when it comes let's see if we can spot the differences

[@tsoiyumanthomas3291]

Audrey final story

[@theburpman8006]

I did like how Mavis used fudge in the railway series and fiddlesticks in the tv series. Due to fudge is a strong terminology to F word and inappropriate for a children book. Fudge is a common word to censor the F word. The railway series was from the 1940s to the 1960s and the tv series, when railway series stories was adapted into tv series, was from the 1970s to the 1990s.

[@terencewilliammckenna6121]

Then again, Wilbert Awdry wrote mini-books in the 1980s.

[@theburpman8006]

It is quite strange to have used Diesel instead of Daisy for the tv series. Daisy didn’t appear in Series 3. The tv creators probably didn’t see a valid reason to use Daisy for a small part of one episode in Series 3. Diesel reappeared in Series 3 for Diesel does it again. Thomas, Percy and Toby should have been skeptical, when Daisy and Mavis arrives in the island, due to the engines encounter with Diesel.

[@eastlancsesteem]

Diesel wouldn’t have replaced Daisy if it for those meddling yanks.

[@NeilTheRWS]

I SEE YOUUU

[@hobbestiger123thetankengin7]

First commment nice video man

[@terencewilliammckenna6121]

A green caterpillar with red stripes

[@ARobloxremake]

Its at grumy Thomas

[@ARobloxremake]

Not at cheeky Percy

[@FazbearEntertainment414]

The engine in the ghost story is Timothy

[@sirwelcome]

No

[@eastlancsesteem]

Reported for terrorism 😂

[@FazbearEntertainment414]

@@eastlancsesteem wrong comment little nicka

[@eastlancsesteem]

@@FazbearEntertainment414 Reported for spam

[@FazbearEntertainment414]

@@eastlancsesteem i didn’t spam

[@superalsters3484]

THE DIP!

[@Kylefan2012]

Second

[@ewanfawkes2708]

First!

[@kylethedestroyer1117]

Here comes the mediocre series

[@kylethedestroyer1117]

Next book btw

[@eastlancsesteem]

lmao