Treasure Planet Deleted Scene - Jim meets Ethan [VOSTFR]

La Planète au Trésor Scène Coupée - Jim rencontre Ethan.
Version originale sous-titrée en Français.
Video © Walt Disney Pictures

[@christiancelis4642]

Although the voice actor didn't get the role as a cute little alien he did get a role of a cute little bear in Disney's next film Brother Bear

[@isaiahadams1208]

His name is Jeremy Suarez

[@amyburkum7602]

I thought it was him! 🥺 i love Brother Bear and Treasure Planet

[@moviefan99]

@@isaiahadams1208 He was also in The Bernie Mac Show.

[@nickthepick8043]

And he NAILED it.

[@Skull_Introvert]

Bernie Mac!

[@cara_macchi]

it's a shame they deleted this scene. this alone shows how hard it is for Jim to live without his father, and his father-son relationship with Silver would've been more heartwarming than it does in the actual movie.

[@luisjaime2567]

It's sad growing up my dad would always work out of town and I never seen him for months but now that he's retired I'm actually bonding more with my father

[@hobomike6935]

what they should have said to the editor who decided to cut this from the final movie 0:00

[@MrJoeyWheeler]

Huh. This really would have added to Jim's character in the final product, making it much clearer that he was damaged but had the potential.

[@kevinvu5432]

Damian Freeman agreed

[@andrewmalinowski6673]

It also would emphasize what both his mother and Silver tell him; that he has great potential. It would also have added to the scenes with his father

[@minzu03]

Love this movie and this scene is OK but this scenes explanation of missing daddy is too much extra

[@mikedicewrites]

This would have added so much more depth to Jim and Silver's already great father-son dynamic. Remember that scene where Silver helped Jim make his emergency surfer at the end? *That* would have been the most satisfying contrast in Disney cartoon history to this moment here.

[@kevinvu5432]

Michael Miller agreed. It's such a good scene.

[@princessthyemis]

OMG you are SO right! That would've added an amazing punch!

[@ArynBacklogDragon]

not really, the scene is good, but all tit does is further rub in the fact that "Jim has no dad" which I think was already clear in the final cut of the movie.

[@kevinvu5432]

OttoeCamn it also adds that Jim wants to do good and has potential

[@inigoaramburuarnaiz9154]

Absolutely true

[@AipomDLuffy]

I love the fact that a bug eyed elephant monster is called "Ethan."

[@brockragni1053]

Really, you love that his name is Ethan.

[@doczirebeka8312]

Not gonna lie, this scene punched me right in the heart. When I first heard the "We got it", it made me feel hurt immediately. It's the small note of happiness and eagerness in his voice as he's eager to help but then his drive to help is immediately shattered - that's what gets me. 😭

[@danielr3149]

As a writer, I have to say that this scene gives Jim so much more dimension. And it's not like it's that long. So why cut it?

[@OmegaPictures318]

Maybe it didn't flow as smoothly

[@sulli1189]

Too much resentment across the board. Sarah being combative in this scene makes the Billy Bones crash scene feel weird, it makes Delbert's involvement feel weird, and it makes Jim's bonding with Silver very weird. Jim doesn't know what he's doing and the cuts of this scene make it appear as if he does when he shouldn't. The contextualization of the characters here would ruin the movie, that's probably why they were cut.

[@rosapayne5660]

The directors said because they changed the introduction.

[@Hyena-t4r]

two words: Jeffrey Katzenberg

[@SolarBrain4128]

It's sad when you've got a good idea for your story. It says a lot about the world and characters, but after another rewrite, you realize, "This takes up too much time; it's not relevant to the rest of the story; there are other ways we can get the point across throughout the story." A classic tale of killing your darlings so that the finale product can turn out better and on time.

[@Squad2SoiFon]

I really like how this adds dimension to Jim's character (he's brilliant and helpful, has passion) I agree that the hint about his father's absence is too blunt but the words 'wow, you're so intelligent, dad' are quite clever. Jim is exceptionally intelligent but his mother neglects it in favor of worrying over him getting into trouble. His dad's not around to praise him. It's not so much longing for a father that I get from this scene, but longing for someone to appreciate him, which just makes me love Silver's speech at the end even more. 'Glowing like a solar fire.'

[@desertwanderer2412]

I'm kind of glad they kept this scene out of the movie. It seems a bit too blunt and forceful. I like how the movie handled it with showing the loss of his father in his character and the music scene. This just seems like shoving a sign in the audiences face like "Hey! Jim lost his father, just wanted to remind you!". Seems to easy and bland by showing his problem right at the start, making the audience think everything Jim does after is do to his father. While for the most part that is the reason I like having the audience truly understand his struggle during the music scene, where all the main conflict and Jim's loss starts to show after it.

[@TheFirstHurrah]

Yes!!! Everyone's saying how much it adds to his character, but it actually doesn't add anything at all that we didn't already know. In fact, it just does it in a more in your face way , and introduces some very minor characters who would have seemed out of place in the movie. I will say though that I agree with what someone here pointed out: that it would have made the scene at the end of the movie where Silver helps Jim create the make-shift solar surfer more powerful, but even so I'm entirely happy this was cut.

[@TheQuaadFather]

He's written so well, even if they had never directly shown it through that musical flashback, we could just assume from the way he is he probably didn't have a Dad, specifically through his relationship with Silver

[@jayhollow2936]

I now see why this is my favorite disney movie, Jim is the first and so far only disney character that I can relate to.

[@mlynnbutler3691]

Aw dang. Thar was really cute and really sad. Jim just wanted to helo not be reminded his dad didnt love him

[@daddysaso]

Holy shit you must have a really bad relation with the English language.

[@mlynnbutler3691]

Tommy yes. Two typos equates to zero understanding of the english lamguage. Good for you. You won the internet.

[@daddysaso]

M Lynn Butler Dude, chill, I was joking. Besides, I've said "you have a bad relation", not "you don't know shit about English".

[@marfin4325]

These deleted scenes are so much better than the Lion King's, no comparison really.

[@isaiahadams1208]

I don’t know about that.

[@davidruiz9744]

That kid sounds like koda from brother bear.

[@davidruiz9744]

But why isn't he added in behind the voice actors?

[@jozinek876]

It's the same voice actor, so of course he does.

[@MrGabeanator]

It is how do ya think he got that job

[@FudgemintGuardian]

Damn, that's sad. Wish they left it in.

[@kotaro07]

I hate it when they delete scene that give character development.

[@lunarose698]

I love this scene. Mostly because you can see the hurt in Jim's eyes when he saw the kids dad helping him. I guess it made him think of how his dad wasn't there for him.

[@shindiregitasyali9248]

why did they delete this scene argh

[@F0nkyNinja]

Pacing

[@AmieEss]

I think I can see why. All it does is obnoxiously rub Jim's fatherlessness in his face; it's already established that he's been deeply affected by his father's absence by his delinquency and apathy towards his future.

[@jonryder7269]

Shindi Regita This is basically, hey Jim has no dad, the scene.

[@kevinvu5432]

Amie S. I think it also shows how Him wants to do good. I think it should've been in there.

[@Alaryk111]

Probably it was to early in the movie to show he has no father

[@MidnightXnoXhana]

I kinda wish they had kept that scene in there though....

[@isaiahadams1208]

I’m glad they deleted this scene cause in the final film they straight up show us that Jim had daddy issues.

[@leepleiades8624]

As someone who's scoured the internet for everything treasure planet related, I'm shocked I haven't come across this before. Generally when it comes to deleted scenes, I think they give fun extra insight into the story, but can understand why they were cut. With this one though, I'm actually a little sad it's missing from the finished film. I think it adds a tenderness to Jim right away that doesn't really come through until the second act of the movie without this moment. Would've liked to see the whole thing colored and finished as well.

[@Southern_Crusader]

Dang that was cold.

[@rosapayne5660]

I think it would've been kind of interesting to have a scene like this. We hardly ever see much of Jim's softer side except with Silver and his mom, it would've been nice to see someone else get his softer side and show he wasn't just an angsty teenager.

[@hyperspaceoddity7805]

Well, that was sadder than I thought it would be..

[@gadisGrim]

I wish they making the Treasure Planet 2 ;____; i love this movie so bad

[@alyssabullock6421]

Aww, I would've loved this scene. It shows that even if Jim is rough around the edges, he still has a soft spot for others, and is intelligent. It also teases/hints at how hurt he still is by losing his father.

[@prisoner__24601]

Kodah!!!

[@KickinSapphire]

Yay!! I’m not the only one who thought this :)

[@thetwelfth9987]

As someone below pointed out, this scene seemed try too hard like *“look here Jim is fatherless look”* breaking the subtleness of the other scenes where it is just implied, despite showing us all we needed to know about Jim’s character, this was a perfect “show don’t tell” moment and I believe his mom’s quote “he built his first solar surfer when he was 8!” Was added because this was taken out. And that’s just boring exposition. This scene could’ve worked and further developed Jim as character if the kid’s dad had been eliminated: imagine Jim turning around and seeing that the kid fixed his scooter without his help and drove away; Jim looks at his tools, then gets gloomy and flies away, maybe he sees himself in Ethan and remembers he had no one to help him out. We actually saw that Jim has passion and knowledge instead of being told he’s smart, and by not being needed we get an introduction on what will be his theme of self-doubt, he tells himself he’s valuable but secretly doesn’t believe so, which ties to his abandonment issues. Imagine if Jim also saying to Silver stuff like “when you’re on your own you have to become your own grown up.” That would say so much about him without feeling like exposition.

[@crazyXninjaXfishy]

"How come you're so smart, dad?" Me: Idk.. maybe cause he decided to stick around..? TT ^ TT

[@if91100]

Jim always reminded me of myself, and not just because of our lack of dads XD

[@zmoneytmnt]

Whoever deleted all these scences to this movie deserves a punch to the face

[@laurenboyd1331]

I'm glad they put this in the DVD version of this movie. but it kind of broke my heart when Jim is reminded of his dead beat dad.

[@JackieHallam]

Nobody deserves to be fatherless.

[@EmmanuelleLunada2010]

To be honest, I'm glad they took this scene out. Mainly because this scene is rubbing the issue in to the audiences faces in a quite overt way. In a too overt way, actually, that it makes it off-putting. So I'm glad they took this out. Sorry to those who likes this scene.

[@percivaldesertmoon677]

EmmanuelleLunada2010 too me, I’m in between it’s okay and yes I’m glad they took it out

[@Daniela3969]

I actually like the movie withouth this scene, I think that makes the I'm still here sequence much more powerful, and it makes the journey Jim and Silver go through much more smooth and natural, it wasn't expected but as I'm Still here shows, it was just what they needed.

[@paleodude2768]

Same voice as Kota from Brother Bear.

[@Es_Tay]

Koda*

[@littleblues8886]

This adds so much to Jim’s character omg

[@heiheireidee]

What, dislikes ?! But I'm actually searching all pieces of my broken little heart !

[@martinmarmalade1651]

Ow my heart

[@ezplang]

I really wish this was in the movie. It would have given alot more to jims character

[@princessthyemis]

Sounds like the cub from Brother Bear! :D This is a good scene!!!

[@MovieMation]

princessthyemis I know this comments really old, but yeah it's the same voice actor!

[@twist58]

Jeremy Suarez's role was reduced to a minor cameo in this movie, but got "costar" status thanks to Treasure Planet's following canon film Brother Bear.

[@JP-1990]

The "we've got it" really hurts for some reason.

[@tylersmith9465]

Poor jim

[@StarsGrimm]

This made me cry omg! WHY DIDN'T THEY PUT THIS IN THE MOVIE?!

[@Rikegile]

I knew that little elephant kid sounds so familiar. I hear him as Koda from Brother Bear

[@Alacaelum]

22 years... 22 years later and this movie still finds ways of being even more amazing than i thought... which makes the travesty of its fate even worse. Nowdays i know... this movie "flooped" because Disney was scared, scared of the cost, so the started to kill any creativity movies could have and little by little the became what it is today. There is a world out there where the management of Disney had more vision, where they saw what this story really is and gave it a chance, and more movies like this were made... I want to live in that world.

[@animationbird9440]

Koda!!!🤩😍🤩

[@emmavance6818]

im not crying you are

[@blueberrymcphuckerson9821]

I know it's still sorta in the concept stage, but I completely understand why this scene was deleted. There are so many things wrong with it. To get straight to the point, it's just really bad filler that wastes the audience time and sorta ruins Jim character.

[@actualteddybear891]

What they decided to put in the film worked better for the flow, and the are bunches of scenes that did what this deleted one did.

[@BabsChannel]

I see why it was taken out.

[@straightjacket308]

Oh this would have made the movie so much better! I can tell why they cut it out because it contradicted what happened earlier with the solar surfer, but seeing how he wants to try to do good only then to lose the opportunity to someone else would have had it so much more to just how his father left him would have affected him. Such a great movie!!!

[@JordanAntonic]

I can see why they cut it. Too early to reveal, and doing it this way would reduce the impact of the "I'm Still Here" scene. And too on-the-nose. Well-written interaction though. I like that his struggle with fatherlessness isn't obvious in the movie because that's how we encounter individuals with single parentage in the real world.

[@bijoukaiba]

I haven't seen this movie in a while, so I may be forgetting some things, but I'm seeing good arguments in favor of "should have kept this scene" (the contrast to Silver helping Jim build the makeshift surfer at the end, and showing that Jim isn't *just* a "delinquent" because he is intelligent enough to understand mechanics and he's willing to help out a curious kid that just walked up to him out of nowhere) as well as a good argument in favor of removing it (shoving it in the viewer's face that "Jim doesn't have a dad, do you get it now?"). But - and here's where I might be forgetting something in the movie - we start out the prologue with Jim's mom coming in to finish the story and tuck him in bed, no dad, but he might just be off-screen. Then we cut to the future, Jim's brought back to the Inn, his mom is there, and we're starting to get the idea that yeah, his dad's not in the picture. But we also don't know *why*. Did he die? Was it before Jim ever got to meet him, or was it at some point where Jim would be old enough to remember? This scene would confirm that yes, Jim's father is not in his life, AND it has left an impact on him. I think to fix this scene, we could cut out the extra father-son dialogue after the "We got it"/"No problem" exchange, and then cut to Jim speeding off as the dad repairs the scooter. I'm also not saying to scrap the scene during the "I'm Still Here" segment. One thing I love about that scene is it shows us that no, Jim's dad didn't die or mysteriously disappear; he LEFT, and at a point where Jim would be old enough to remember. And the implication is it's not a "I'm doing this to earn the money to save my family" leaving, it's a selfish "I want material riches and I don't want to take responsibility for my wife(?) and child" leave, straight-up abandonment. Whenever one or both parents are out of the picture in a Disney movie, it's because of death (or at least implied). I think this might have been their first (or possibly only) time they had a parent walk out on their responsibility (the one exception could arguably be Aladdin, but emphasis on the "arguable" due to the "King of Thieves" sequel)... and even if it wasn't the first/only, it's still a testament to how rare it is.

[@theramdomchannel8329]

Everyone in the coments saying how this developes the whole father son thing, yeah, thats right but also this shows another aspect of Jim: he is not just mean and proud, he does like to be useful and he has a lot of potencial If Jim hadn't become a sailor he could have allways worked at a repair shop or something, he talks about not having a future literaly while he's fixing something very impressive and he's good with kids and willing to help.

[@amazingturtle5075]

I mean I wanted to feel the emotion in this scene but I kept being thrown back by little Brother Bears voice over there

[@arciks11]

Well that explains the Ethan NPC in PS1 game.

[@dpsktmdbzkxk]

Oh... Deep...

[@INTERNALSERVERERROR500]

Damn, I kinda get why it was cut. It kinda feels a bit of overkill but it does gain context with the mid turning point of the second act.

[@solangegriffin5894]

Poor Jim, feeling so sad and anger to see a little boy and a father having a good time together. I bet he wish how come his father didn’t care about him

[@sandramercado6585]

They shouldnt have deleted this scene! Watching Treasure planet made me understand now.

[@briannapauls3420]

Oh, my heart! Right in the feels

[@harryotsuka3157]

how cloud they have deleted that scene!!! OMG that adds so much depth early on oh god why were we robbed of this!

[@edain6918]

This scene make me think that Jim would've been a great big brother

[@morganeviry5501]

I can't decide. It would be really nice if this scene would have been in the original movie, it's so heartbreaking and can give another element about Jim's feelings, a psychological aspect! And the Kid is so cute. But the scene is not really necessary. We have the same aspect in the song I'm still here, and in other scenes in the movie. So I can understand why they cut it, but it is interessing to see this scene. And... I'm so sorry, it is so sad but the end of this scene is funny "Regarde comme je vais vite" and Jim goes soooo fast! (Sry if you can't understand some sentences, I'm french and not really good in English...I hope you can understand my ideas...)

[@7Brokenpieces]

I still love this movie 😌

[@intertop10]

Fan even after years

[@TheQuaadFather]

I think the issue isn't the length requiring this scene to be cut, the next scene has Jim on the landing bay looking out, it just doesn't make sense how they write him from fixing his board to helping an alien pirate from a crashed ship, plus we never even see the surfer again throughout the movie so we assume he fixes it. I agree its a great scene tho.

[@blackbun130]

I treat this like the jackpot, a secret treasure UwU

[@mmlarsonlarson2312]

Why was this deleted ....such a beautiful momemt

[@UndeadGhostGirl]

Considering how *everyone* seemed to have picked up on Jim's trauma in the theatrical release, I really don't think this scene was needed like everyone says.

[@sebs-shenanigans]

I grew up on this! And i've watched it a t least a dozen times

[@--..-...-..-.--....]

Dang, that's a great scene

[@nickdudek6527]

My first thoughts when I heard his voice I blurted out and said “Koda!?” 😅

[@user-oe2fl4vr9j]

I thank you for your wisdom.

[@riotbreaker3506]

This movie is amazing. I want more like this.

[@mcbonkin3091]

*I want to be that kid and meet Jim Hawkins! :'(*

[@sunnylilacs]

I like what this scene adds, but I’d also say it’s unnecessary. The way the final product turned out felt like more mature storytelling. We didn’t need to see a juxtaposition of a father-son relationship to understand that he missed his dad-the absence and never talking about him did that more deeply. The biggest we get to an outright addressal of Jim’s thoughts and feelings on it are in the song “I’m still here” during his flashback, and he doesn’t even say it out loud there; it’s all internal. I think including this scene would’ve pulled focus away from the movie’s main theme-Jim finding his empowerment. The movie isn’t about a young man looking backward at the dad who abandoned him. It’s about him moving forward to discover his sense of self and potential. By keeping the dad situation vague (never giving him a face or discussing him in the script, & lacking scenes like this that point him out), it enabled viewers to better apply the concept to themselves-recalling griefs from our past that we’ve had to live with and move forward from. And it feels more like real life. As kids and youth, we don’t usually sit down and define the events of our past and reasons for our present; we just keep living day by day like Jim did. So when saving moments come, like Silver accepting him and expressing his belief in him, it resolves a dissonant chord that’s been playing underneath the whole time, right at the depth of storytelling where if you needed to get it, you got it.

[@paintkim9211]

1:00 Ethan looks like Baby Tantor from Tarzan

[@mitchyb7070]

they had rough lines done and certain parts were fully colored and animated already, i wonder why they cut it. it's such a small but important scene for Jim's characterization, it's a shame

[@lucasmouraquaresma]

Ethan and his father are scrapped from the film.

[@vannieroxas3317]

Why denie us Jim fangirls more screen time of him anyway

[@issakjimenez5600]

Best soundtrack

[@albireotheredguard1599]

Why did they leave such a great scene out of the movie?!? Please tell me there's a Director's Cut or do Animated Films not get those?

[@samperry5383]

Ethan is very cute

[@negainsectwhite]

DAMN, this was really nice

[@classiccutie916]

I would've honestly loved this scene if it was added :(

[@nickhighland799]

Welp... Right in the feels ;_;

[@UnexcitingChris]

Fuck, this scene is great.

[@PikminandOatchi]

So that's who that kid from the PS1 game was.

[@actualteddybear891]

See this is a nice scene, but what made it into the movie works better I think because the scene in the movie reveals more about Jim's relationship with his mother, and there are plenty of scenes that do what this one did. There's even one where Jim watches his father abandon him.

[@neytan9799]

Ooou... :c

[@hpttx_nin]

Essa cena teria doído💔

[@cbobadilla72]

Hey he didn’t get his bit in the movie but I know brother still got paid for the voicing.

[@amyburkum7602]

Actor of Koda right? 🥺 omgg

[@moonchild2788]

Man, i really wish the editors added somewhat of a friend to be there by Jim's side, but again there's Mr.Silver so i guess he completes Jim by giving him advice and being that father figure Jim never had😭😭😭😢😢😢Buuuuuut i kinda wanna see what it would be like if Jim didnt have Mr.silver and instead have a friend.....but i guess Mr.Silver was part of the original movie Treasure Island so they had to include him in this movie......i have to go back to thinking!

[@JenamDrag0n]

Jim at the start of this movie is not at a point where he would be able to make and keep (good) friends. He's so emotionally closed off from his own mother (who he's presumably always been close to before his dad left) that she can't even hug her own son goodbye once it's decided he's going to Treasure Planet. If you pay close attention throughout, you can see how rarely Jim chooses to reach out and touch someone, and he becomes much more willing and unreserved about doing so by the end of the movie. You can even see his mother's surprise when the first thing he does upon meeting her at the dock is give her a full hug.

[@AndrewDavis-sj6mb]

Treasure Planet was a ehhh film,but SWEET film art

[@domocracydestroyer8219]

For me, This scene was very forced and unnecessary. I am glad they cut it.

[@johncontreras2327]

Is that the same kid who’s voices koda in brother bear?

[@llunavermella_bloodmoon]

I think this scene is not necessary to understand Jim. It doesn't really add dimension; you see his hurt already in the movie as is.

[@DeadlyNightShade60]

I think this guy appears in the video game.