Tribal India Can't Be Fixed. Savagery and Barbarism is Inevitable. Jayant Bhandari Discusses

In our interview with Jayant Bhandari, he tells us that, "3rd World countries and especially India are imploding and falling in tribal units which means war in inevitable."
This video is an extract from an interview with Jayant Bhandari, investor and analyst, and Crux Investor.
We ask him about his investment strategies and philosophies. And he tells us it is about understanding human behaviour.
In this extract, Jayant tells us his thoughts about the politics and nationalism holding back his home country of India; and his beliefs about the future of '3rd world' countries such as Pakistan, Syria, Venezuela...And why nationalism & fanaticism will lead them to certain financial and moral decline reverting them to a new dark ages; His wish for a return to the colonial past and if Donald Trump can bring sanity to India.
www.jayantbhandari.com
Twitter: @JayantBhandari5
Make smarter investment decisions, subscribe here: www.cruxinvestor.com
For FREE unbiased investment information, follow us on Twitter and Linkedin:
/ cruxinvestor
/ crux-investor
Take advantage, hear it here first: / cruxinvestor
~-~~-~~~-~~-~
Please watch: "CRUX Investor - Better Investment Insight & Understanding to Make Intelligent Investment Decisions"
• CRUX Investor - Better...
~-~~-~~~-~~-~

[@Alleur]

First time have I seen a guy whose analyses is very near to the truth.He doesn't sugar coat the ugly realities.

[@chris10hi]

Yes it is, but its starts to get boring constant talk and no action in these poor countries, I read and watched quite a few videos and its really getting boring. These talkers, make nice statements and show logic, they have been talking this stuff for decades, yet India is an overpopulated polluted disaster. They keep talking but nothing is done, They should be taxed for nonsense. The reason India is in poverty and chaos, is that Indians are relaxed, talkative and complacent, just like Africans, and South Americans, these countries always will be poor, the more complacent the poorer and chaotic they will become as they overpopulate. This is the truth and its that simple. Chinese on the other hand are highly frightened, and thus focused and hardworking, they were able to copy West and make the products cheeper, India cannot do that, that is the reason, if you want to understand how it works and how to fix it see kzbin.info/www/bejne/fGrLp5mCna1koLM or read the book :Frighten the World into Prosperity.

[@reubanrajan2679]

As an India, its hard to listen to such brutal remarks but had to agree to all of it completely.

[@yushpi]

Evangelist bunkum. Such a self loathing fraud this guy is.. Absolutely sick.

[@JMiskovsky]

Read Hoppe! Hans Herman.

[@freddymercury2259]

Why is this hard to listen to? I am Indian and drew the same conclusions, I would have thought it was obvious. The problem with Indians, in India, is that they do not believe that the gvt is there to work for them instead of working against them or enslaving them. There has been no focus on creating tech giants to compete with the US companies to provide jobs and retain our skilled, no investment in infrastructure, no investment into the military, no investment into housing, no investment into healthcare (Which would also provide jobs for our skilled doctors and nurses and stop them going abroad)... yet nobody holds the govt to account and the govt know they can get away with it. The issue is INDIAN people themselves!

[@harshgirsa8289]

You are agreeing that we need Winston Churchill as a prime minister can you be a less asshole plz

[@sandintpc]

really . Colonizers were god sent to the 3rd world countries ??

[@dasgupta9288]

His judgment on India is very cruelly true

[@dasgupta9288]

@Raghav Dadhich but what he said is quite true.

[@sharons2405]

@Richard Madden true the fact he himself is a south asia if he can change everyone can change we need renaissance thats for sure...china disregarded all these western bastards now they are developed into a better country

[@corazoncubano5372]

@Richard Madden He is telling the hardcore true.

[@srinivasarao7145]

So, you want India to send 25 crore Muslims living in India to concentration camp to learn constitution of India ?

[@antiracistbaby1085]

@Richard Madden And your job is to keep screaming ajd complaining about why India is not China, and then do crap about it

[@devasharma5478]

I feel angry initially but after listening to him carefully i realise he is right

[@nightmare5614]

India is a fucked up country which will never rise under such shitty system where political leaders are crime lords. No vision and rule of law as he puts it perfectly in this chat.

[@nightmare5614]

Here in this video at last he said about south-east asian countries like indonesia, malaysia are fanatics and in his other talks he said south-east asia is the future. His perspective aren't same always. When India tries to enact with a good system he will say, west has lost it and asia is the future. As he would be alive for next 30 yrs (the time when India builds it's economic bricks internally). Hence priorities changes according to it's nature. Can't trust anybody, just live a happy life. In present scenario, he is on point (precise) about India.

[@indiandaredevil7497]

@@nightmare5614 Agreed

[@shantanusathe8233]

He is right

[@amitcarbyne3635]

@@nightmare5614 he has never said south-east Asia. he has said north east asian countries such as china, japan, south korea are the future.

[@venom-kc7ri]

This type of Indian should be in India media interviewing

[@saviop7529]

India has made notable advancements in various aspects of human development, with initiatives and programs that have had a positive impact on the lives of its citizens. Here are some key accomplishments in areas such as UPI (Unified Payments Interface), Ujjwala, health, water, housing, and infrastructure: 1. Unified Payments Interface (UPI): - UPI revolutionized digital payments in India, allowing seamless and instant money transfers between bank accounts through mobile devices. It has facilitated financial inclusion and empowered individuals to conduct secure and convenient transactions, promoting a cashless economy. 2. Ujjwala Scheme: - The Ujjwala scheme, launched in 2016, aimed to provide clean cooking fuel to rural households. By distributing LPG (liquefied petroleum gas) connections to economically disadvantaged families, it has reduced their dependency on traditional cooking fuels like wood or coal, leading to improved air quality and better health outcomes. 3. Health Initiatives: - India has implemented several health initiatives to enhance access to healthcare and improve health outcomes. Programs like Ayushman Bharat have provided health insurance coverage to millions of vulnerable families, ensuring affordable healthcare services. Vaccination campaigns, disease control programs, and maternal and child health initiatives have contributed to overall health improvements. 4. Water Management: - India has taken significant steps towards water management, aiming to provide clean drinking water and ensure efficient water usage. Initiatives such as the Jal Jeevan Mission focus on providing piped water connections to households, reducing water scarcity, and improving sanitation facilities. 5. Housing Initiatives: - The Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) aims to provide affordable housing for all by 2022. It has led to the construction of millions of affordable homes, addressing the housing needs of marginalized communities and promoting sustainable urban development. 6. Infrastructure Development: - India has witnessed substantial infrastructure development in recent years. Projects like the Bharatmala Pariyojana, Sagarmala, and the development of smart cities have boosted connectivity, transportation networks, and urban planning. These efforts have enhanced accessibility, promoted economic growth, and improved quality of life. These accomplishments reflect India's commitment to human development and addressing crucial socio-economic challenges. While there is still work to be done, these initiatives have played a significant role in improving financial inclusion, access to clean energy, healthcare services, water availability, housing, and infrastructure for millions of Indians.

[@pinderjohnson208]

Indians are too proud to admit that colonization was better than current and last governments. There’s a reason 90% of India wants to settle in the west, they cannot manage themselves. Westernized Indians like myself are ostracized for this view, but it is true.

[@johnjames5779]

Really? Why did famines like the one in 1943 only stop after the British left and how is India a food exporter today? You never see these self hating statements about colonization from China. The foreign policy of India is shrewd when it comes to managing good relations with multiple power blocs, but its internal policy is a different story and has much to do with systemic flaws and corruption.

[@amalsooraj4256]

Only Ppl like u Agree on that, because u left India & eager to prove it was the right decision. There r many Indians who remained in India, ppl who actually made a change unlike him whos entire modus operandi is to abuse India & other democratic nations. Maybe ur western country doesn't teach u about their history, but modern day western nations grew from the exploitation of Asia & Africa, they exploited Countries like India, Created Artificial Famine, killed millions, all the while treating them as second & third class ppl in their own land,That is real colonization. This guy himself is fake and doesn't know what he is saying, One day he will get up and say praises for European administration and governance, And on other days calls it a failing and dying nation.

[@pinderjohnson208]

@@amalsooraj4256 Give me a fucking break with this colonialism BS. India has been an independent nation for over 70 years and still can't get its shit together. The problem is that the Indian people do not understand how to lead a country and are morally bankrupt. 99% of Indians would leave India and come to the west if they had a choice. Most NRIs never go back to India, because deep down they know it is a shithole. India needs westernized people to rule over it again to avoid collapsing.

[@betadevb]

​@@amalsooraj4256 no he is correct. Find me one place in India where you can go and easily buy land and setup something nice. Even with money you can't do it. Our people are unskilled and don't follow the law. Most people don't think of the larger country or issues of governance. Vast majority of Indians don't even marry outside their community. I am of Indian origin. Every year I try to invest in India. I have even tried to invest in Indian companies. But there is literally no rule of law in the country. Our people are mostly unskilled. The domestic market is poor. You cannot find me geographies in the World that are worse investments. Something has gone woefully wrong.

[@amalsooraj4256]

@@betadevb I have no idea Hw difficult is it for u to invest in India, when last yr only India received $74 billion in foreign Investments which itself was lower than the yr before that of $87 billion. Even the Chinese figured out hw to Invest in India but not U. 2 weeks back Amazon also figured out hw to Buy land & setup a fine looking Office, that too second one after they built one 2yrs back, but apparently not U. I ain't a guy with a lot of knowledge in business, but i do understand this much that unskilled people won't become Ceo of Microsoft or google or Twitter. Unskilled people don't make 80+ unicorn companies & i am quite sure that a country with literally no rule or law & unskilled ppl don't get GDP of 3 Trillion Dollars. So as i said before Ppl like U May Agree that, Ppl like u will always agree on that.

[@1jh963]

Giving free stuff is always the battle cry of politicians during democracy elections

[@thecomment9489]

Well giving free stuff is to gain power anyhow. And that's because gaining power basically makes you like a feudal era overloard in this country.

[@richie3205]

Me as an Indian fully acknowledge what he's saying is true

[@jasperhaokip9570]

Finally I meet an Indian who think like me who sees India as what it is..You should accept Constructive criticism.

[@Antony_Shamarjit_Lee]

Where's constructive criticism in his any speech regarding India ? He's nothing but a cynical man, who can only vomit venom about India. We've a long way to grow there's no doubt about it. But that doesn't mean we're stuck, we're not the shithole as implied by him. We're trying whatever we can to bring out millions of people out of poverty and people like him have done nothing to help it.

[@anti-leveled142]

@@Antony_Shamarjit_Lee Please go and speak to anyone living in the slum, they'll asssure you they have not seen any progress in years. Infact alot of have become even poorer. Talk to any rich person and they'll tell you they are becoming richer and getting more opportunities. The wealth gap is only increasing and if thats your defintion of progress then good for you.

[@toocooltocare1444]

Constructive criticism doesn't mean bias. He talks as if there is no poverty in western countries and the wealth gap there is equitable

[@sudheerkumar4421]

the same country this moron says is barbaric,tribal,superstitious and corrupt has grown on avg 6 percent a year for the last 30 years,has a half a trillion dollar reserves and is a giant in IT services in the world...will become 3rd largest economy in 10 years when japan shrinks and china slows but we will still be having the world youngest working age population of any country...dont believe this idiot's nonsese...he ahs been saying the same stuff for the past 20 years...

[@Ashish-ss5nt]

@@toocooltocare1444 look at their per capita income

[@bmujeeb]

His words really hurt but must admit and agree with the premise.

[@kushmaskara5296]

India is struck in vote Bank politics......we elect leaders in name of religion....if people vote in name of religion then why will the leaders focus on development.

[@allinonetube3387]

You are the same people who after saying these words vote for BJP

[@user-rr7ox9le5h]

Hey man just search him online you will see what he is all about, don't be a victim.

[@thecomment9489]

Then why didn't the leaders of China go for this kind of arrangement where they too could do such things?

[@muhammad-bin-american]

I really want to disagree with this man but I can't. His brutal honesty is refreshing.

[@rafalpedros7360]

Yeah it would refresh you. Your name says it all.

[@fettuccine794]

​@@rafalpedros7360, saar saar plijj Saaar

[@vivekvs9678]

Yes, I agree with him, India is very chaotic, unclean, unmannered and dirty . Cities like Mumbai and Delhi have very poor civil infrastructure, people begging, crying and shitting on Railway platforms, near airports and public transport places is very common. Leaving few commercial places entire cities are poorly planned. No wonder, China even though being a communist country is more cleaner and well infrastructured than India. GDP per head is also 5 times of a Chinese than Indian. All electronics, electric, mechanical items are imported, India lacks manufacturing. It will take almost 50-70 years to make India similar to China, Singapore, US.

[@jaibehind6298]

As soon as India manages to be like China and the US today, those 2 countries will have developed far beyond that level. So it's really difficult for India to catch up :)

[@indiandaredevil7497]

ok bread

[@killermachine6454]

All the communist countries are clean if you don't know that

[@nomad7317]

"Environment influences the mind". When the Environment is so littered and polluted, no wonder their mentality is so savagely.

[@nightmare5614]

@@jaibehind6298 nope because technology is more accessible and world had much better connectivity than before and India can adopt it faster. Note - India is also considered race in AI and space tech.

[@alvinol9003]

Everybody seems to knows to problem but the real problem is no one have a solution. India have so many talents but they eventually leave the country when opportunity arise.

[@shyamchabra5355]

Jayant Bhandari is right. The nation has regressed into medieval religious escapism and it does not want to come out! Fractures are appearing in the social fabric, torn apart by religious nationalism that is directed by political opportunists. A sad predicament for India.

[@saviop7529]

India has made notable advancements in various aspects of human development, with initiatives and programs that have had a positive impact on the lives of its citizens. Here are some key accomplishments in areas such as UPI (Unified Payments Interface), Ujjwala, health, water, housing, and infrastructure: 1. Unified Payments Interface (UPI): - UPI revolutionized digital payments in India, allowing seamless and instant money transfers between bank accounts through mobile devices. It has facilitated financial inclusion and empowered individuals to conduct secure and convenient transactions, promoting a cashless economy. 2. Ujjwala Scheme: - The Ujjwala scheme, launched in 2016, aimed to provide clean cooking fuel to rural households. By distributing LPG (liquefied petroleum gas) connections to economically disadvantaged families, it has reduced their dependency on traditional cooking fuels like wood or coal, leading to improved air quality and better health outcomes. 3. Health Initiatives: - India has implemented several health initiatives to enhance access to healthcare and improve health outcomes. Programs like Ayushman Bharat have provided health insurance coverage to millions of vulnerable families, ensuring affordable healthcare services. Vaccination campaigns, disease control programs, and maternal and child health initiatives have contributed to overall health improvements. 4. Water Management: - India has taken significant steps towards water management, aiming to provide clean drinking water and ensure efficient water usage. Initiatives such as the Jal Jeevan Mission focus on providing piped water connections to households, reducing water scarcity, and improving sanitation facilities. 5. Housing Initiatives: - The Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) aims to provide affordable housing for all by 2022. It has led to the construction of millions of affordable homes, addressing the housing needs of marginalized communities and promoting sustainable urban development. 6. Infrastructure Development: - India has witnessed substantial infrastructure development in recent years. Projects like the Bharatmala Pariyojana, Sagarmala, and the development of smart cities have boosted connectivity, transportation networks, and urban planning. These efforts have enhanced accessibility, promoted economic growth, and improved quality of life. These accomplishments reflect India's commitment to human development and addressing crucial socio-economic challenges. While there is still work to be done, these initiatives have played a significant role in improving financial inclusion, access to clean energy, healthcare services, water availability, housing, and infrastructure for millions of Indians.

[@mrinal1129]

These are scumbag,they will not realize they have destroyed for 65 yrs,in the last 10 yrs,their is a discussion comparing China with india,we could have never imagine under corrupt congress rule.

[@mengsiongkheng113]

A bit harsh but brutally honest.

[@maitiaru]

Although his opinion view are quite narrow minded, but his forecast about the countries that would face into economic crisis has indeed come true.

[@ftft98]

Wow, rare honesty and insight!

[@corazoncubano5372]

Yes it is and quite painful to hear. I always say that it will take India a 4 decades to recover. He however gave the country a couple of millennial, and this interview was recorded well before the pandemic.. I believe deep down that a populations adherence to superstition along with non existent or poor education, helps to impede the progress of any nation.

[@adithyadanaj9768]

@@corazoncubano5372 recover?

[@chaitanyasharma3921]

@@adithyadanaj9768 visit a village or talk to some uneducated, rural people. Any sample of people. Then try to extract their thoughts and believe, they will act in the start to show an image but when you go deep enough into their beliefs you will know how damaged our society is. Hate against women, rich people and intellectuals is extreme in india. Plus most people don't want to change themselves.

[@balasaravanan500]

100% Truth 💯. This is exactly what I am experiencing now.

[@vinjed]

People here keep asking for solutions and not just call out problems. Lol, we can’t even agree on the problem without constantly defending that it is in fact not, and actually is a strength. If you can’t agree that there is a problem, why would you even think of solving?? Also he is clear that a secular society that pays more value on economic and scientific progress, rejects irrational man made concepts like religion, caste, tribal affiliations, can grow significantly. Just because you don’t like that doesn’t mean you ignore it.

[@mattcardin1796]

Not exactly evaluate his perspective again

[@paragbhattacharya943]

Now you know how Brits managed to rule India for 2 centuries straight. 😁

[@seanras4046]

Yeah, they had supporters like this guy. Complete sell out. India doesn't need European management. Every development (whatever little) happened after they left.

[@ChristAcolyte]

@@seanras4046 Seethe. India will never be a superpower under Indian rule. Smart and competent Indians tend to leave India to western countries to live much better lives. This is the so called 'Brain Drain' of India.

[@seanras4046]

@@ChristAcolyte Yes, and there will come a time of reversal. It's already happening - people going back to India to set up a better country. And it will inevitably happen more and more because Indians don't feel a sense of identity in foreign countries. And I never spoke to being a superpower. In the near future, like 100 years from now all countries will be militarized enough and that point we'll realize there's benefit in working together, not against each other. Weapons will also become deadlier and this whole superpower business won't appeal really. We'll come to see that, maybe 100-250 years from now.

[@randomyoutubeuser3184]

@@seanras4046 I agree with you that India's future is bright. Jayant Bhandari is a typical self loathing Indian who does not appreciate the profundity and sophistication of his own culture out of sheer ignorance. I would disagree that war will go away. You are assuming that humans will grow wise enough to understand their own power. I don't think they will, we will still be irresponsible and wage war because tensions build up over time. How we fight these wars and whether or not they turn nuclear is a more important discussion. The current conflict in ukraine shows the shift towards economic and cyber warfare.

[@thecomment9489]

And before that rulers from West and Central Asia.

[@ankur20010]

I disagree at one point. Nobody colonised another country becaise they wanted to change something. They abused and also increased hatred. But they did bring in the tech and scinece which was just happy accident.

[@tommysanders3638]

One truly honest Indian

[@moinakbhattacharya878]

Sorry, he is US citizen

[@nsaurabh25]

Such a smart guy

[@amaantk109]

@Richard Madden true

[@devasharma5478]

@Somil in india PM is a person who was key figure in Ram mandir riots in 1991…and gujrat 2002 riots…..majority of Indian population supports him for very same reason….India is a poor country because indians prefer imaginary gods over their personal well being….

[@Little-bird-told-me]

In India if you are fair, it is taken as a weakness. Its dog eat dog world in INDIA

[@monoranjandora]

Do not give ur bullshit statement here if you do not like India shut ur ass there are millions Europeans and westerners comes living their life in both spritual and material space to develop their spiritual and material life respectively ..

[@amrinderbahl]

Burnol for bhakts 😂👌 Absolutely correct explanation of the state of affairs. People have been reduced to sheeple

[@MythicEcho]

He said India not bhakts, grow up. You, me, bhakts, chamchas all are Indian's.

[@vult07]

@Rahul Pavan he mentioned bjp and cong .. so stop

[@bosedk122]

Hmm. And I'm guessing India was better 20 years ago under Congress? Clown

[@amalsooraj4256]

Chamchas like u should also feel same because he mentioned all of India.

[@rudrajeet814]

Bhakts ko kyu gaali de rahe ho? Yeh un colonizers ki taraf daari kar rahehain jinhone tumhari maa beheno ko rape ki aur famines create kar maardiya Burnol tumhe zaroorat hogi abki baar yeh bhadwa kya bol rha hai smajho

[@MrAntonychong]

What he said is the truth. What the top echelons of leaders should do is admit the truth and remove any state of denial and move forward with plans and actions. Further debates won't help you. Learn it from the Japanese if you have hard time swallowing what the Chinese had achieved.

[@abyyy490]

Chinese are no Christians neither are Japanese . Lol

[@nightmare5614]

India is a fucked up country which will never rise under such shitty system where political leaders are crime lords. No vision and rule of law as he puts it perfectly in this chat. Here in this video at last he said about south-east asian countries like indonesia, malaysia are fanatics and in his other talks he said south-east asia is the future. His perspective aren't same always. When India tries to enact with a good system he will say, west has lost it and asia is the future. As he would be alive for next 30 yrs (the time when India builds it's economic bricks internally). Hence priorities changes according to it's nature. Can't trust anybody, just live a happy life. In present scenario, he is on point (precise) about India.

[@liho1738]

Yep. India is hopeless.

[@nightmare5614]

@@liho1738 India is not 3rd world, it is beyond 4th world!

[@raghunathang8584]

The speaker did not understand in what context Mr.Modi promised to give Rs.22k US dollars to each Indian. He said if the money that has been illegally remitted abroad brought to India he can pay that much. This is just show the level of corruption prevalent then.

[@thecomment9489]

Well yes he may have his own agenda to interpret things in his own view but many of the things he says are actually correct and realities of our savagery filled society. There no concept of rule of law, no morality, no sense of justice, no sense of right and wrong, no sovereignty of an individual and no sense of privacy of an individual.

[@nafeesahnaf2387]

Totally agree with you.

[@SAMARTHSAMANT]

His regular business on twitter is to bash india regularly . Criticism isn't a bad thing . Constructive criticism is necessary but this guy litrally speaking trash with no sense . India is poor has hungry people but dosnt mean it is not improving . A recent report from Morgan Stanly states that india has sucessfully removed nearly 0.413 billion population from poverty . He is glorifying foreign colonialism and calling india as tribal society . While in reality British regularly exploited india and its resources . Today middle east; Afghanistan; Iraq are results if western colonialism only.

[@vladtheimpalerofd1rtypajee316]

Let's be realistic. India will never be a developed country in it's lifetime. Even if India grows, it will get stuck in the middle income trap forever. India will also face major resource shortage due to overpopulation and face the wrath of climate change. India's resource base isn't large enough to support an economy too large either. Also the West and China can sabotage India in a jiffy if it grows too much. Also most Indians don't have unity and are still backward minded and tribalistic. Corruption and being unethical has become so deep rooted that it's become impossible to fix it. Also, the number of talented Indians leaving India is increasing at an alarming rate every year and many of these Indians who left India brag about India being the next big thing which is extremely comedic. The most mind boggling thing is that even if God comes down from heaven and says that India will never be a developed country, pa jeets will call him anti Indian and continue living in their fantasy of India being a developed country. Moreover, countries that actually became developed bragged less and did more. India brags more and does less. To conclude, India may improve in some areas, but it always stay a corrupt 3rd world uncivilized sh8hole. Hence, forget your dreams of being a developed country pa jeets. India is an utterly failed experiment. Adios

[@fuzzywuzzy0549]

what are the resources? when were you going to use those resources? British discovered your tribal ancestors walking bare foot living in mud huts. there was nothing

[@bw2442]

They can’t manage themselves: This describes most of the world right now. They will all soon look for a savior when things get more degraded. A dangerous time

[@agarwalamit8604]

harsh but true

[@alvinspodcast]

He is absolutely right.

[@MrAmhara]

This guy says Singapore and Hong Kong are the only countries outside Western World that have improved since colonization. What about, South Korea, Japan, Malaysia, UAE, Panama ect?

[@mariamlanah904]

Japan was pretty much like British who invaded many Asian countries .South Korea was never colonised by any foreign power for significant time .I have no idea about Malaysia and UAE .

[@ranadhirdebnath3012]

He actually did mention south korea and japan in an interview but I don't know which one

[@killermachine6454]

Malaysia is developed cuz of Chinese people and Panama is a small country situated in a strategic location east to mint money japan is a civilization all together had high literacy rate higher than Victorian England and good culture of mathematics that is responsible for fluid intelligence!

[@fuzzywuzzy0549]

@@killermachine6454are you implying that Chinese people are better ? well I agree

[@502964924]

they are frugal, hardworking people .Look at singapore and HK. The richest people in SEAsia are often chinese. Better? in that sense, yes.

[@thecomment9489]

As I said already, only some kind of genetic mutation has any hope to bring these people out of savagery and create any resemblance of a civilised society and country. But then that's like wishing for a miracle to happen.

[@SioneFolau]

The only way to grow and better than before is to know what to do and do it. If only thinking about it and talking about it but not doing it it will end up with no results.

[@junaidkhan-vz5br]

Becoming a fan sir

[@kevinj2261]

What a bold statement: When colonizers departed, colonies deteriorated; ...need management similar to colonial time in the past.. OMG, just by saying this this guy should be put on court

[@indiandaredevil7497]

😂

[@fuzzywuzzy0549]

He is not wrong. India is a huge mess

[@davidchou1675]

It's hard to take him seriously when he imagines colonialism to be a good thing and that it would take thousands of years to change the culture of India...no doubt India has massive problems and no doubt it's ultimately "cultural" in a very important sense but colonialism was good???? Colonialism only deepened societal divisions -- intentionally -- so as to better rule the subjugated....

[@NaseerAhmad-ty4ds]

Tribal India CAN begin to fix itself...as a first step it has no choice but to carry out a massive decentralising of the country into autonomous States...and let these States run as countries...the South East of the country...Kerala etc...are already proving that this is possible...while UP with a population of, I believe, 240 million can do the same. If this is not done, then Dr, Bhandhari's scenario of savagery and barbarism will almost certainly emerge.

[@911Sept]

Next PM of India

[@maoclone2110]

Let me repeat what I had posted here and there: 2 kinds of narratives to explain hindustan problems: 1)The well known:"Its complicate"---like they've 16 official languages, racial/caste apartheid pyramid, hindu-muslim antagonism, 'aryan'-dravidian divide.... 2)The seldom known(@least to non-indians):"It's simple"---Hindustan is an old civilisation, yes, but Hindustan as a larger political entity with a central gov is a juvenile and an emotional one at that a)take a look at the india flag: many mistook that wheel shape at the centre as Gandhi's weaving wheel; NO, it's the emblem of Asoka, a BC 3rd century king; Why Asoka? Ans: It was under Asoka India(@least the northern part)was unified the last and only time before the muslim Mughal conquest. b)The ancient hindus were more interested in fairy tales like Mahabharata than writing history and they've poor pre-mughal historiography. Example: Travel logs of Faxian and Xuanzang are the most valuable history records of the buddhist kingdoms they sojourned to .......... Overall post-1947 india lacks governance experience as an independent country, sense of planning and sense of prioritisaton of objectives. EXamples abound. And china is quite the opposite. Compounded by emotional hype and urge for optics, u got a hijra slap dildo theatre,like Rome was actually Rama(according to a joker 'historian' P N Oak), Ganesh was the outcome of xeno-transplanting an elephant head to a human torso(confirmed by Modi himself)..... Fun to watch at a distance

[@jerrysingh9152]

Mr,J B..you should be an advisor to indian government.

[@arkopal09]

And do what? Bring in foreign colonizers?

[@williamcheong1536]

Excellent Jayant

[@vishalmahadik9067]

You are correct sir

[@VaibhavSharma-zj4gk]

He likes Donald Trump

[@aa-hb3tg]

So u have issues with it ?

[@sumanneogi2679]

every country in the world has problems but if you point only problems then I will tell, there is no 1943 famine after independence during British raj famine is regular occurrence.

[@user-hz6cn9bh4g]

He is a fool. I'm sure of it. Else he's grossly uninformed about colonial history. Worst case, he's driven by an agenda

[@user-hz6cn9bh4g]

Really alarming to see the amount of people who agree with him.

[@user-hz6cn9bh4g]

Looks like it. It's shocking that an Indian is suggesting a return to colonialism (Our freedom fighters would be turning in their graves if they listened to what this sell out said). How someone so morally bankrupt and uniformed gets an audience is beyond me. Shameful.

[@bgblight]

Learn an very interesting viewpoint: Savage and barbaric people become more savage and barbaric because easy money have them get more time to create problems. However, still feel ashamed for the Indian seeing an Indian elite deny his motherland in a nearly humiliating manner.

[@MrMirville]

I don't believe any guy pissing on his own country. I understand what he says and I agree somewhat. It is true for instance that friendships in India are never very serious. But... when a people lacks money the same shortcomings that are pardoned to richer people are judged to be catastrophic. India is a morbid social distance seeking society, that's true. France has actually always been worse. Paris is a city where truth and falsity don't exist, only what is fashionable or quaint. India on the other hand admits the existence of truth but don't bother for it. This guy believes in Thatcher and Churchill as insurpassable levels of seriousness. No : Thatcher made the British common people poor again. Churchill killed nearly as many people relatively to the size of the country he governed as Stalin and Hitler and moreover he also impoverished Britain irrevocably. The world would be a better place without those two. It is not true that a pleasure-seeking society shall fall into savagery.

[@saurabhdixit1987]

@@MrMirville Guy who pisses are the guys who made changes. Gallilio for example, einstien, etc. Noone is pissing on a country but belife system. Whether you believe or not, who cares like who cares what this guy is speaking.

[@alokkher4242]

There was no human rights abuse in China? Indian economy can rise from 3 Trillions to 5 Trillions, and 5 Trillions to 10 Trillions. That will mean better quality of life for a lot of poor people.

[@sourav2124]

This is the same guy that says democracy doesn't work

[@sourav2124]

@@chaitanyasharma3921 and said british should capture india.....stop licking his foot like he's some sane intellectual guy....he's not

[@sourav2124]

@@chaitanyasharma3921 chuthiye ki tarah baat kar raha hai....mera pehla comment ka matlab samjha kar

[@Alleur]

He is ablsolutely correct that democracy doesn't work in a country like India where people vote on the basis of caste, religion, community and a bottle of alcohol

[@sourav2124]

@@Alleur authoritarian regime is also dangerous... look at china, iran moron.....despite all those flaws.

[@Alleur]

@@sourav2124 u have absolutely no idea what China is.just spend a week here and u fill forget ur own village

[@sitoudien9816]

Wow. Such harsh condemnation. Recolonize the poor? Really?

[@emailshe]

India is good, it just needs some footpath and better infrastructure for people who walk

[@shallusharma6132]

He calling everyone in india 'tribal'. I have one word for him. But I will not write it. It will be very inappropriate.

[@indiandaredevil7497]

write it do not worry YT is an open platform Feel free to express your thoughts

[@liho1738]

True. India is tribal.

[@oxymoronindian]

Hahaha ha 📲📯🎵🎶🎶

[@eg4933]

And Jayant should be india's next leader, no question about it.

[@saviop7529]

are you higher than a kite? whatever you are smoking is really astronomic stuff

[@wilfhigginson465]

Western [former] civilization is on the same trajectory, we just started falling from a higher height.

[@sagoKarthik1980]

Correct

[@harjinderbharaj2055]

You are right Sir, India 🇮🇳 is a rich country with poor people. The poverty lies within the pre- dominant Religion, and that is?….. People are given false hopes in the religious stories. People at large still believe that some personality of God resides in the Himalayas, and millions of people spend Non- product hours chasing them all the year around.On the contrary Chinese citizen is a Non- religious production citizen. Every year billions of Indian hours go to waste.

[@HengAh7384]

Jayant Bhandari 👍👍👍

[@lokechanmun8587]

What saves Chinese society is Confucianism.

[@bw2442]

If God himself would come down and run India or the world, even if he made the correct choice in every matter can you imagine how many people would argue and fight and rail against him? For the problems of today it would require a strong strong knowledgeable, wise leader who would stay the course for decades .

[@fawa.z]

It’s true

[@kevinj2261]

LOL after listening to the guest the host are speechless...

[@rajnaik4192]

Modi should be ashamed what outlook India carries to the world. Under Congress regime India was never looked down upon. This leader has given a bad name to India. We have gone back 100 years.

[@sachinpant8075]

Congressi 😆😆😆😆

[@MythicEcho]

Please keep posting more jokes 😂😂😂

[@subhashishbagchi3191]

EMERGENCY OF 1975 AND THE GLORY OF INDIAN SOCIALISM IS KNOWN WORLDWIDE UNDER CONGRESS RULE.

[@RB_INSIGHT]

Congrres's pet 🐶🐶🐕

[@praz7]

Dude he literally said after British left, india was taken over by rabble lousers. Now who took over after British left? Congress

[@sonumbaeng]

He is obviously very angry about the current state of affairs in India and 3rd world. I however disagree , Literacy rate in India and Africa is rising and will reach EU levels by 2035. Once voters are literate, around 20 % vote on Tribal lines, however most people do start to recognize the enormous importance of economic issues and by and large start voting on economic lines. India may not be a China but its a democracy due to which things do work slowly, but eventually societies get it right. Europe took 250+ years to develop. India and Africa will need approx 100 to 130 years from their independence to reach good standards.

[@randomyoutubeuser3184]

In 50 years we will already be solidly a middle income nation. It wont even take 130 years to get rich. India is already semi industrialised. There is also nothing wrong with Indias culture. this guy is racist towards his own people.

[@liho1738]

It will take India more than 500 or longer.

[@saviop7529]

India has made notable advancements in various aspects of human development, with initiatives and programs that have had a positive impact on the lives of its citizens. Here are some key accomplishments in areas such as UPI (Unified Payments Interface), Ujjwala, health, water, housing, and infrastructure: 1. Unified Payments Interface (UPI): - UPI revolutionized digital payments in India, allowing seamless and instant money transfers between bank accounts through mobile devices. It has facilitated financial inclusion and empowered individuals to conduct secure and convenient transactions, promoting a cashless economy. 2. Ujjwala Scheme: - The Ujjwala scheme, launched in 2016, aimed to provide clean cooking fuel to rural households. By distributing LPG (liquefied petroleum gas) connections to economically disadvantaged families, it has reduced their dependency on traditional cooking fuels like wood or coal, leading to improved air quality and better health outcomes. 3. Health Initiatives: - India has implemented several health initiatives to enhance access to healthcare and improve health outcomes. Programs like Ayushman Bharat have provided health insurance coverage to millions of vulnerable families, ensuring affordable healthcare services. Vaccination campaigns, disease control programs, and maternal and child health initiatives have contributed to overall health improvements. 4. Water Management: - India has taken significant steps towards water management, aiming to provide clean drinking water and ensure efficient water usage. Initiatives such as the Jal Jeevan Mission focus on providing piped water connections to households, reducing water scarcity, and improving sanitation facilities. 5. Housing Initiatives: - The Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) aims to provide affordable housing for all by 2022. It has led to the construction of millions of affordable homes, addressing the housing needs of marginalized communities and promoting sustainable urban development. 6. Infrastructure Development: - India has witnessed substantial infrastructure development in recent years. Projects like the Bharatmala Pariyojana, Sagarmala, and the development of smart cities have boosted connectivity, transportation networks, and urban planning. These efforts have enhanced accessibility, promoted economic growth, and improved quality of life. These accomplishments reflect India's commitment to human development and addressing crucial socio-economic challenges. While there is still work to be done, these initiatives have played a significant role in improving financial inclusion, access to clean energy, healthcare services, water availability, housing, and infrastructure for millions of Indians.

[@kamaljoshi9748]

His most of forecast are true that he made in 2014

[@randomyoutubeuser3184]

Oh really? How so?

[@studentfriendlydilse4821]

I can imagine situation of educated class during 1857 revolt

[@gitendra0605]

India has its problems and nobody would disagree with that. But somebody like him has to get involved with the change that is taking place rather than detrimental criticism in front of the world. The majority of the problems has been caused by the colonial powers including the moguls all the way to our political governance by Congress

[@JayeshP-in4jz]

The problem with Indians are that we are whinners and don't take responsibility for the downfall of our country even after independence. We always blame the Mughals and Britishers for our poverty which is partially true but we have been given a span of 75 years to grow much better and better civilised in terms of sanitation, business and civic sense. Countries like Hong Kong, Singapore, Japan and South Korea didn't complain like us and instead learnt western ethics and morality and applied in their lifes.

[@AshishBagade-hv4el]

He has such vengeance in his vice...but the reasons are too simplistic...i mean true but not the cnclusions at all

[@mdhvsnkr2657]

"Europen colonizers were god sent!"......hmmm okay

[@drakezone5213]

He is suffering from stolkhom syndrome.by saying such things he is justifying goa inquistion and genocide of native americans,and australian aborginese.

[@shvetyaprem2932]

not GOD SENT for sure but they were an advantage. Cause' well they united the diverse masses of the country under one cause and also introduced their then quasi secularism.

[@jerrysingh9152]

Leaders must address the problem now.The media has a roll to play In bringing this to the light.But too busy talking about bollywood garbage.

[@cb9461]

Cultures change by previous learnings . east Asian changed themselves so would south Asia and Africa.

[@nikhilkewate9178]

Check Make in india initiative its results india times article 2) check no of rail network and highways done in last 10 years in india india 25 years back and now is totally different

[@lad_elusive]

God the comment section is obvious proof of how easy it is to fool the public by simply being demagogic and anti-establishment. I am no Modi fanatic, I try to see reality as it is. Of course India has a myriad of issues to deal with which has been hampered by decades of bureaucratical corruption, among many other reasons such as lack of strong educational institutions, lack of infrastructure, a lagging manufacturing & services sector, and prioritization of religious nationalism. These issues plague all "third world nations", and that is why they are called as such. They are both part of the same package. ANY nation on Earth can degrade into one, and any one can get out of it, depending on facilitation of the government. It is not as cut and dry as this narcissistic quack purports. I could point many other loopholes in this guy's arguments, but I have made my point.

[@user-rr7ox9le5h]

Remember a military boot is always waiting there to crush balls when things get out of control, I am talking about you man not people.

[@PrashanthKrishna-se8fc]

you can read comments here to see who those people are who do not want India to develop kross toons and hollow skull kapped wearing more-ons

[@bw2442]

Having colonialists run things well gives an opportunity for the population to see and experience what it’s like to live in a well run society but it takes a long long time to lift a whole society out of a bad place, and if the colonizers begins to exploit the country for gain and quit teaching and governing well and decide to keep the status quo in order to manipulate better then it’s a terrible thing to live thru.

[@litanmarak8929]

Well said Sir👍

[@nikhilkewate9178]

Talking about FDI india has launched PLI scheme and incentives for foreign companies 2) Apple launched indian made iphone in market 3) Tesla inks 5 year office deal in pune india its hindistan times article 4) currently india is ranked 5 th in the world according to nominal GDP soon by 2029 india is projected to become 3 rd largest economy

[@subhash9150]

A babasir(piles), giving gyan

[@rhiannonwilliams2521]

I disagree with his hypothesis. Colonialism is never good for any society. A nation has to be the architect of its own evolution into a more civilized society. In fact if you look at Kerala compared with the rest of India you will see by adopting a communist system of government it succeeded in improving the way of life of its people without any colonial power.

[@praful6890]

No communist system works anywhere in the world, not even China, which is communist in name only. Kerela's salvation ws the middle east. People working there sent theri remittances to sustain it's economy. They still do. If not, it would be a basket case. It is the least investment friendly state in India. One thing I can commend is its education and relative lack of corruption.

[@cscsp]

Rubbish. If India stopped playing racial, language and caste issues and adopt a Chinese development model of governance, I am sure India will become a superpower within 40 years. But how to get there without violence and collateral damage???

[@1pasupaty]

Guys making s living on criticizing india.h e has valid.points though but can't find any solutions to any problems but.just referring history .we need more people like him but only with half his brain the rest for problem solving.

[@abcdpqrs1281]

He has given his solutions in case you didn't know.

[@communistcat6006]

Butt hurt

[@1pasupaty]

@@communistcat6006 does critics make u feel happy 😊

[@deepakaswani972]

@@abcdpqrs1281 what solution he has given to support colonization and dictatorship?

[@abcdpqrs1281]

@@deepakaswani972 yeah I don't agree with those solutions.

[@kunalgusain6321]

This guy is absolutely nuts he is saying the 3rd world countries would bring Chaos to this planet and can someone please give me one incident where India being a 3rd world country has ever brought Chaos. I don't think anyone can find one and about him praising China , we all know where corona virus has originated from and it did bring Chaos , so maybe if he had taken the example of Pakistan or Bangladesh I would have agreed with him a wee bit but being an Indian I would never think of bringing chaos in the world because my religion doesn't teach me that. At the end things may not be right in India but it is progressing and one day it will reach the zenith but this criticism will not be tolerated.

[@liho1738]

Coronavirus originated in Dharavi slums, Mumbai, India.

[@Jodoe243]

India is divided into 3 major ethnicities, the Aryan North, the Negro South and the Mongol East. There are many subgroups among the major three, each with their own dialects or languages or religions. The boundary of India today is the result of Imperial/colonial sphere of influence. India inherits the landmass, its peoples after INDEPENDENCE.

[@observer0222]

All indians mostly have the same gentic makeup. If you look at a random indian you can't say where he is from.

[@Jodoe243]

@@observer0222 You are under informed.

[@observer0222]

@@Jodoe243 I am Indian and have travelled across the country to different regions. I know what I am talking about.

[@wishfulguy4819]

India with huge population shud hv emulated China style of administration if they want to grow faster. Cut off all the red tapes n hv fast decision making thru a special council body that comprised of mostly Technocrats n Proffesionals. Too many Tom Dick n Harry only make Indians look like Comedians. There were too many lawyers trying to express their geniusity in almost everything rather than getting things moving for the benefit of its peoples. They hv to unite n speak one language. Their patrioticism has to be enhanced. Reliance on leaders with Religious n Celebrity background doesn't seems to work in India. They need Technocrats to drive India to modernisation. Huge human capitals are distinctive if they being well trained to produce results. India will hardly achieve anything if the bickering among its peoples n leaders kept humming. The Indians hv to start to sacrifice for the future Generation.

[@thecomment9489]

The system developed in China after 1949 revolution is native Chinese system to benefit the Chinese. The type of system we have in India was created by the colonial masters who obviously wanted to benefit themselves.

[@AshishBagade-hv4el]

Whoy do i always get the feeling that he is voicing same exacyt prejudices as Chinese common man...is he on payroll of CCP...you never know because the same time he always praises China

[@JMiskovsky]

Read Hoppe!

[@swapnilsinha3507]

Constructive criticism is necessary...infact even harsh criticsm is fine but what this guy is doing is similar to that of katherine mayo type .... author of mother india .....they come up with face of brutal friend who tells harsh truth ...but infact are just racist infact if u read this guy article it starts with problems and criticsm of india and ends with indians should not be allowed in us....gandhi called such people as drain inspector whose job is to search and opening for gutter and drains and give details and will conclude that whole drain is india

[@killermachine6454]

Because we indians deserve to be hated because vast majority are insanely uncivilized

[@KAN443]

Especially North Indians 😫🥴 Refusing to Taking Ticket While Travelling in Indian Trains

[@nikhilkewate9178]

Sir you said Indians doesnt have skills 2) many Indians do schooling from India and BE or Btech engineering graduation from India and then masters or MS from US 3) Indians ISRO successfuly landed on moon only 4 countries have done before without skills you can't do it

[@angelomicallef3916]

Socialism Mao Tse Tung

[@harissn27]

Jayant Bhandari was brimming with bile juice. He misses his colonial masters very much. His grievances on Indian politics is understandable and I agree with that part. But his contempt towards India and other colonized countries is unbelievable, and he sure needs psychiatric counseling. Look at his contempt for "TRIBALS". His poor judgement is exposed when he began to glorify Colonialism and Christian missionaries. Does he mean that there is no nationalism and pleasure-seeking in the West? Nationalism in the West led to the two most gruesome wars in the last century. Pleasure-seeking in the West led to slavery and exploitation of natural resources in Africa and other colonies in the last 3 centuries. He neither knows history or current events. He must have watched a fiery TV debate and hyper-ventilating here. Anyway, who the heck is Jayant Bhandari and why is CRUX interviewing a nobody?

[@linzierogers5024]

Does he want colonialism to return to India?

[@suffeeirshad]

No he wants indian culture to become open, tolerant innovative, investment attractive and leader for mankind. This is why he is attacking the root cause of the problems

[@krushnadeepsonu3552]

Yes I want it too

[@monarchnoo8561]

you mean Christianity is not superstition?

[@samjr7926]

This guy clearly has issues !! 🤦

[@nikhilkewate9178]

You touched topic of ration cards free food now it has reduced drastically 2)many countries have free govt school education 3) you touched topic corruption now many things are online you dont have to go to govt offices and because of digital transactions you have proof of money transactions

[@samjam1992feb]

Perhaps the most biased person i have ever seen .. utterly biased

[@luv2touchpink]

Exactly 👍🏼

[@nikhilkewate9178]

Indians ranks very high in It skills 2) indias own Tata and Mahindra have business plant in many countries including US and UK they are still indian citizens 3) you said many indians dont have bank account india has launched Qr codes many indians use paytm gpay without bank account u cant use it 3) shop owners and some vegetable venders use it

[@MythicEcho]

His modus operandi is quite sophisticated. Go to his tweeter handle. His each tweet is India bashing only. He compares China with India. He conveniently forgets India have too much freedom to prosper unlike China.

[@ayushjain7884]

China used to be poorer than India 40 years ago , but is Now 5 times better off . My father went on a couple business trips to China and he was compeltey suprised by how developed it was , I belive that India will not be able to catch up to China I the next 100 years . I feel sad about this too , but its reality

[@MythicEcho]

@@ayushjain7884 To build a simple road you will need countless NOC's from various departments in India. Would you like to apply communism in India? I will personally guarantee you the development in next 15-20 years. Would you like to dethrone democratic freedom? I'm not denying China's progress but at what cost would you like to catch up?

[@ayushjain7884]

@@MythicEcho China builds infrastructure faster and better than India . people don't care whether they live in a Democratic country or not , as long as they are financially well off , and government dont interfere with their day to day life .

[@MythicEcho]

@@ayushjain7884 I don't mean to argue, that's not my intention at all. But people don't care?, hmmmm. Jack ma merely said government restrictions are a bit stringent and we were not able to see him for 2-3 months. And he was the richest person in China. Do you really believe FOE is possible with out democracy, I don't think so. The CCP is and was interfering in people's day to day life. You cannot have any faith system. You can not have more than 2 children's. And these are iota of restrictions we were able to see. And it's blatant interference in people's day to day life. If you go to Chandigarh, Nagpur mihan, Ahmedabad, lavasa, gift city etc, surely you will find the development but that doesn't represent whole Indian scenario, same applies to China.

[@varunpreetsingh5440]

@@MythicEcho Facts.