The ULTIMATE Tonneau Cover Comparison | Truck Central

[@TruckCentral]

Let's kick off a brand new season with a question... What truck do you own right now? (or trucks if you have more than one!!)

[@pit81590]

2019 trailboss and love it

[@moosc]

2016 double cab z71.. you should look white automotive and the autosync unit. I prefer the roll cover.

[@donknicker8110]

GMC Sierra All Terrain. I have a Bacflip Rollex cover on it works great

[@sykwookiee]

'08 F150 bought brand new in cash...4.6 L, auto, crew cab, A/C, cloth, carpet delete...it's been the best all around truck I've ever owned...

[@matthews5502]

2020 Toyota Tacoma Off-Road

[@VAF84]

I purchased the retractable cover for my F250. Having used it for a few years now, I’ve decided I’m going with option 2 (hard/fold) for my incoming pickup. The retractable version ended up being impractical, heavier, and took up too much bed space. Option 2 makes the most sense, especially with the ability to fold it all the way up while driving. Great review btw, you helped me firm up the decision.

[@enjoylife7030]

I was convinced I wanted the second cover and kept trying to stash away extra money for one. After awhile I simply purchased the a model like the first one you installed in the video. It has been great. Never an issue, only leaks slightly in a high pressure car wash, never leaks in rainy situations at all. When I want full use of my bed it just comes off in like 5 minutes. One day I did an unplanned furniture purchase. Took off the cover behind the furniture store, put the two piece sectional inside, threw the folded cover in the back, and strapped everything down. So simple, flexible and easy. I would totally do the first option again and again knowing I never leave any valuables in the bed anyway.

[@travisa1326]

How has it held up, also is the material thicker than it appears

[@enjoylife7030]

@@travisa1326 Mine has held up very well in my opinion. In my neck of the woods we see High 90's in the summer and sometimes below freezing in the winter. It is starting to look a tad dull but I am sure a good cleaning and some treatment would make it shiny again. It is still leak free which amazes me. For the cost it looks like it will last over two years maybe closer to four. At that point if it got too weathered I would buy another one.

[@SQTierHog]

What model was it? Thanks!

[@enjoylife7030]

@@SQTierHog It was a Tyger brand ordered through Amazon.

[@michalp2362]

I was sold on a hard trifold until I saw how easy the soft one is to take on and off without any tools

[@Crosby4hyg]

Just pick up a Diamondback SE. If you want to put a quad or something heavy on top of it, get the HD. You'll never want another cover.

[@quadguy1470]

Yeah nothing else compares to the Diamondback, 1600lb capacity

[@cwb2992]

@@quadguy1470 Renegade supports 2,000 lbs with integrated track system.

[@koontzman123]

This video is worth so much more than a thumbs up and subscribe.

[@ryanalan6545]

I purchased the fx Gator tri fold hard cover and I like it on my truck I don't have to pack the cab with groceries and tools 👍

[@TheRannMann]

The $250 Gator trifold soft cover has been on my 2017 F250 for 3 years. It's been a great product and value

[@josealgaba4083]

The gator FX looks like the best of the 3. You can fold it all the way and you don’t sacrifice any space, great in depth review of the 3 options!!!!

[@biker1958]

@@oscarpacheco6838 any issues with the rubber on the sides weather cracking over time or folding it?

[@JTRSpartacus]

Nice to see Gator products - USA made. Thanks for posting! #JTRSPARTACUS

[@laneblount9888]

I love my tri fold soft cover. It’s definitely worth the money and very affordable. I’ll probably the the hard folding for my next truck

[@MitchB.]

Is your tri-fold water tight?

[@laneblount9888]

I have the gator soft folding (I think it’s the same one in the video) and it seems to be pretty water tight. I went on a 5 hour road trip and it was pouring rain the entire way and my luggage was dry when I opened the tailgate. There’s probably a couple spots where a little water could get in but it stays dry for the most part

[@McFED2U4JC.]

.7 mui

[@ryanr6240]

I've had a couple Truxedo soft roll up covers, never had any issues. I like the roll up kind because you always have easy access to the whole bed.

[@66skate]

I'd pick the Gator ETX over the the tri fold model. It's at about the same price point. The thing I like about that one is it doesn't cover the stake pockets. I want to add bed rails to mine. The other 2 are made by the same company as BAK and Truxedo. If you watch videos for those, you'll see all of the rails and hardware are exactly the same.

[@ckarnis2418]

Extang makes a lot of these behind the scenes.

[@Sheepleton]

I had the cheap gator trifold on my Ram and it was great, goes on and off in a couple minutes once you get good at it. Recently I bought a really cheap Tyger soft roll up cover for my Tacoma and it's way better built, easy to install, and never has to be taken off. I'm never spending $500-$1000+ on a bed cover, I'll stick with soft rollups from now on.

[@sunlite9759]

Got it. Before spending $1500 for a bed cover I would rather buy a cap.

[@prestonbowen2825]

Every time he claps, take a drink

[@GR018]

I'm wasted.

[@redneckingenuity9376]

You be dead within the first minute

[@dmaxdiesel4x4]

The middle one is a backflip knock off. Nice cover. Those are the only ones I use.

[@rockportbob1210]

An exact copy.

[@ford1chevy2dodge3]

I don’t understand all the complaints when the cover is all the way open and blocks the rear window. Like guys, if you need that much space, chances are that the cargo is blocking your view anyways.

[@benjaminhurst8207]

I love my roll n lock. I keep tools back there at costed twice the bed cover so it’s nice having the security

[@francososa638]

I agree with you 2ND bed cover is the better choice, thanks for sharing this 🤜🏼🤛🏼

[@lenjames]

The dick who buys the $2000 cover will brag about spending $2000. The person who like me who would buy the $200 cover would just use it and be happy. My choice in "Cheap Covers" are made by Estang. The cover comes off without a fuss and the truck bed is used like it should be. I have the original one I bought for my 2010 Ram and for my 2018 Ram it still looks new. So in ten years I spent less then $550 and I have two bed covers on two different trucks!

[@jacob61541]

Love the video. I am looking for a bed cover, I would probably go with the first on.

[@danfuller9871]

Great video man. Very informative and helped me decide which cover is best for me. Thanks

[@cheesegrater231]

I bought a new garage door for my small shop in my back yard. Weird size 20x18, got a new opener for it installed too, grand total 2100 bucks. 2 years ago now. Let that sink in

[@ajjackson2385]

Hey bro great video extremely helpful 👍🏻👊🏻

[@ricktokle5848]

😎🇺🇸 Hey Nick great review👍 I have the 3rd option that rolls not that basic model but mine is not water proof it will leak. I like the one you installed on your truck, have a great day ✌️

[@paultech9385]

I have the 2nd cover on my Chevy Colorado. Use it constantly and it works like a charm. I can choose not to latch the last section or mid and last for bulky loads. Since you need access to the release cords once the tailgate is locked it's secure and out of sight gives peace of mind. Thanks for the review.

[@unknownsamoan01]

Awesome review brother. Thank you👌🏾🙏🏾👊🏾

[@4ehardy]

Thank you for you views on these tonneau covers. I'v been wrecking my brain on which one to get and with your help I have chosen the FX model. I think that will be my best option for daily use. i wish you had an active discount code lol.

[@aubreysmith3009]

One thing I'd like to point out, is, for the hard folding cover, because it can only be opened from the inside it doesn't need it's own lock. The lock on the tailgate protects the latch, and therefore if your gate is locked so is your cover. It is plenty secure.

[@TingTingalingy]

Sounds like your idea of plenty safe matches my idea of plenty safe. That works for me.

[@jacobgray3746]

Cheaper one is the best imho you can take it off if you need to on the fly by yourself usually someone isnt goin to cut into your top just to see what you have and it's 1/4th the cost my 2 cents

[@SweetStat]

Soft covers don't last, specially not if you open and close it every day. I've had 3 covers so far. My soft truxedo cover is the only purchase I regret

[@IndianMC-jf3cp]

Gator makes excellent covers. I've had a couple. Even the least expensive is American made and high quality for a reasonable price.

[@UnkkonditionalLove]

Thanks for this review. It has made my decision a lot easier for which one I want installed on my truck. Definitely going with the 2nd option. I love how sleek it looks and still allows me to have bed rails installed. 😊

[@possleaholsteinspossbrofar8429]

Doesn't say much about the company when the cheapest cover has the best warranty. For 1700 it should be at least 10 warranty.

[@galvanizedgnome]

Freemason

[@tviperjester3978]

the mid grade second option one looks to be the best option, full access to bed and looks sleek. the third option is expensive and losing full access to the bed (especially on 5ft beds) is a non starter in my books.

[@dontblameme6328]

If you have anything less than an 8ft bed, then you don't really have a truck.

[@D-blaze]

I really enjoy my hard top trifold on my 5.5ft f150. Definitely the most convenient for my needs and with a locking tailgate, it's plenty secure.

[@dionmorehead2911]

This ws a great video on a full description of the covers pros/cons. I like his honest opinion and not just selling the most expensive cover.

[@jeffreydepaolis5109]

Hand grips? They’re called stake pockets.

[@tonyalicetatakis915]

Not stake pockets.

[@eby2257]

He's deffinately a city boy!!

[@dontblameme6328]

It's not even a real truck to begin with. Looks like something a yuppie girl would drive.

[@roberthudson4440]

If you look closely, you'll see that they have been reshaped, there are only two at the rear (not six), they are indeed "hand holds" .

[@doclobster]

They are stake pockets. Front two are accessible by cutting out the marked area on the rail covers. They also accommodate bed rails.

[@nathanbeard513]

Those aren’t “hand grips”, lol. They are for stakes to put side rails on the bed.

[@mattltech]

"Anti theft proof"? I don't like the sound of that.

[@ignatiusd4562]

Thanks for the details. I had a low end soft cover that lasted about 4yrs until it blew off while driving high speed on a highway...yea, that happened. Fortunately, no one or thing was hurt. Now finding the "better" products on the market today are making it challenging to be satisfied due to a lack of them being 'simple'. Also, finding deck rail systems from the truck manufacturer are playing into the install and functionality of these current covers. May just stay with a cheap cover again. Easy install, full use of the stock deck rail, and easy to remove when needing the full bed....

[@vmac5421]

2nd one the best for sure

[@Zhurak]

Ive had the first option for about 3 years now, its held up really well and doesnt leak at all. Its by Tyger but functions the exact same as the one you showed. Lightweight, cheap and easy to use. You cant go wrong with any of the three, just depends on your budget,

[@michalp2362]

Is it pretty solid at highway speeds in terms of flapping in the wind? I never even thought of getting one of these but the ease of taking it completely on and off can be a huge benefit.

[@amandamcgruder5074]

Thank you for this video!! I really needed to actually see how they really work !!! Thank you thank you!!!

[@NainaiDNG2024]

Great reviews with all information that clearly to understand. Thank you

[@RecklessHM]

Excellent review. I actually bought the second and it was fantastic but after about 7 years the material between the metal sheeting started to get water logged to the point that it was extremely heavy to use. Framing also started to loosen up making it tougher to align to close. I do admit it was fantastic up to that point. Worked great for my fifth wheel and was easy to use and secure.

[@GeorgiaStorm3417]

Great video! You really helped make my decision. I'm downsizing from a Tundra to a Tacoma. I was really considering the retractable cover, however you really hit home the room I would lose if I did that. I'm already losing a sizable space from downsizing to a smaller truck. I will definitely be going with a tri-fold hard shell cover. Good job on your video and I'll be looking at the rest of your videos because of the good job you did on this one!

[@TruckCentral]

Glad it was helpful and thanks for watching! *Here is the follow-up video:* kzbin.info/www/bejne/npbMlZephK1ppck

[@mikebruegger8249]

If not the best how to one of the best how to videos I have viewed on KZbin. Also an unbiased evaluation of the products . I ended up with an SFX since I do not want a full time cover. Saved me money and installation time getting a product I can take off when not required which is my situation most of the time. I am a supporting subscriber of Truck Central.

[@longface6045]

I like the second one because you can use the full bed

[@rongrieve9700]

Excellent video guys! You’ve helped me pick option #2 for my first truck.

[@robertflores477]

Thank you for your hard work! Loved the video and I agree on your choice. I have a 2017 Titan I have to cover because I tow my RV and need protection from the elements and the greedy common public!

[@HubersRanch]

For me it would have to be the 2nd one also because I have a toolbox in my 8ft bed so I need to have access to that plus it already limits what kind of cover I could put on.

[@bc_usa]

I have #3. I love it. Yes it's expensive but I can leave things in the back of my truck and not have to worry about something getting stolen. I don't like #2 because it blocks your back window if you have it all the way up.

[@JPOC226]

People on Facebook Marketplace: Tunel Cover, Tunno Cover, Tunna Cover, Tono Cover,

[@TruckCentral]

😂 …tuna cover

[@thinkingimpaired5663]

Id take a number 2 over any of the others. I like to be able to place a motorcycle in the bed as forward a possible to the cab and be able to possibly close the tailgate.

[@gregoryf9299]

Good comparisons! I like that you cover install/uninstall times. Don’t have a truck yet but still shopping and looking at various cover/rack options (and how much they weigh).

[@kevinthomson6324]

The hard folding covers are the best in my opinion. If you have a locking tailgate they are very secure. Easy to open close and offer the most available bed space.

[@enterprise59]

Seems the 3rd cover would work for a towing a 5th wheel when it's open, and closed for shopping trips.

[@TopWaterAssassin78]

I've had varies covers for different trucks. I had a snap on cover for my Dodge Ram. That one was nice because it was easily removable. But in the winter months you had to take it off or on, I had to put it in the sun so it would stretch to snap it back on. My 2nd cover was a roll top cover I had on my 2011 Silverado. It also was easy to take on and off (open and close). But I had issues with it leaking. My 3rd cover I love the best, I bought a Diamond Back cover for my 2016 Silverado and this thing is tough. It's the most expensive but no leaks, and it's indestructible. It comes in 3 pieces, and it's held on with 4 clamps. There is video's out there that this cover is nearly impossible to break into. The HD Edition can hold up to 2500 lbs on top and you can still open your tailgate. Great video guys. I've ordered from Real Truck before, and they are amazing.

[@eutimiochavez415]

Thank you for the great information ❤❤ I will go with the second tonneau cover !

[@paulheffley]

How hard was it to take off the MX if I wanted full access to the bed and back window visibility?

[@TruckCentral]

It doesn’t have quick release clips like the soft cover but it’s not difficult. It’s not designed to be taken off daily but doesn’t take longer than a few min to connect/disconnect from the rails. I’d definitely rather do it in my driveway than in a store parking lot though.

[@miasage35x45]

The cheapest one is perfect for the quick cover needed for here and there

[@Oldgold_right_here]

Any recommendations on different price levels of covers for a 5'7 bed with RamBox and Mutifunction tailgate? I would really want to see that video!

[@Ron2838]

Not sure about the rambox, but you can swap out the brackets in the bed and be able to install any cover with the multi-function tailgate. rightonbracket.com/product/ram-truck-bed-brackets/

[@malcolmsovani1275]

thank, i'm sold, getting that Gator, and i click on your link

[@retiredfire2013]

Door number one ease of install plus you can destroy it 3 times for the price of the next door

[@17noneya]

Did the price jump recently this year? I swear the mid grade was in the $600 s not to long ago.

[@houndsmanone4563]

Nicely done. I too prefer the 2nd tonneau cover b/c of price and ease of installation. Have a fine week. 👍🏽🙂

[@richardreser150]

The lower tri-fold optionI bought for my wife’s 1500. It was great except be careful as a gust of wind flipped it back causing damage to it just as she was folding it back. It still seals well and works, but you can definitely tell. One of those freak things , but just FYI.

[@Maybelove88]

Hi Richard, I'm leaning towards gettung the soft tri-fold! Did your wife experience any attempts at theft? Just a bit concerned about security.

[@GeroldHarbin-oj2zr]

It's definitely the second one for me also! Thanks! 👍🏾

[@Josh-zy3lq]

This video was great. Thank you helped to make a purchasing decision

[@rangersmith4652]

I just purchased a 2020 GMC Canyon and, lucky me, it came with the REV trifold cover, essentially the same unit as the Gator FX. It's a very nice addition to the truck: not waterproof, but definitely keeps most of the water out. Secure enough to guard against the casual thief. I will probably use it either fully closed or fully open, the latter when carrying a bike or two. Still have some experimentation to do in that regard.

[@TruckCentral]

Definitely a win when your truck comes with the exact mods you want! Enjoy your new truck 🍻

[@fritty9927]

I had the middle one. It was great but the stabilizer bars to hold it in full open position get sticky. I had to use pliers to loosen them up on occasion

[@rickt2419]

Thank you for the video! I appreciate the well explained intro of each model 👍 ! My comment to the manufacturer: 1. The basic version can have a better folding design, instead of the existing tri-fold design make it a Z-fold design so the inside/under side of the cover never face against the outer/upper side collecting dust... 2. The middle MX model, instead of the two clearly visible "manual" rods to prop the cover open, they can be relocated to the end of the cover (behind the rear window) so the mechanisms (rods & secure screws) are less visible. 3. The most expensive version, for the price, the design could at the least also include a self retraction (i.e. spring loaded like a roll-up window blind and cab stop at any position etc.) function so make it more worthy of $2k. Sincerely.

[@1989tico]

Really well done video and that compliment is coming from a true asshole that never gives out compliments.

[@CSltz]

I had a hard cover tri food I hated it so much that I wound up just giving it away.? The roll up covers just seem like a easy invitation. I’ve had them all on my trucks thru the years camper shell included. In my opinion the roll n lock was probably my best choice.

[@TruckCentral]

Curious what your experience was with the camper shell - would you ever go that route again?

[@CSltz]

@@TruckCentral it sure kept the weather out. But it was always in the way when I needed to haul something. Fire wood,rock mowers etc. plus I was always bent over to get anything out that had slid past the back of the wheel well. This wasn’t that big of a deal 40 years ago, But now…..

[@hosea1320]

Retract Pro MX is a much better roller than the Gator. Better warranty.

[@brettmichael9570]

And >$800 more

[@kpbizzle_gaming]

Good review bro! 2nd one will be the one for me as well.

[@35057]

Excellent idea for a video. I’ve been wanting a Locking tonOh cover or at a minimum a theft deterrent for stuff in the back if I have to stop en route to a customer. But I like the GatorFX one best. The #2 It’s a great compromise of loss of bed area and a hard shell cover.

[@dionmorehead2911]

Forgot to tell you the truck I own. I have a 2013 Ford F150 tuxedo black limited. I have the hard cover that the rivets have broken 2x. So I'm shopping for new cover. Thanks

[@eby2257]

I'm a fan of the looks price and ease of use of the soft tri fold.

[@jeandaigneault6667]

do you have a hard tri-fold cover that fits Honda Ridgeline 2024, how many clips hold the rail on the truck, do installation requires drilling and is there a vidéo about the installation specific to Ridgeline. Thanks !

[@flip8714]

Bought me one today off your video. That’s great video

[@davidwoods6391]

I have that Gator tri fold. It is awesome!

[@mikeduron5315]

We hang out outdoor kids family is there a tonneau cover for f150 2018 that can handle weight on top ?? You watch fireworks, uh shooting stars tailgate standing on top ?? Does one exist??

[@jeffp2001]

So is the gator fx decent quality I’ve been looking at the Bak flip mx4 but it’s over 1k I dont want to spend that much but do I don’t want junk. Thx

[@djadrian9318]

Hi bro where do you get that acrylic tailgate applique please tell 🙏 that's the same material as the light covers in the back it's like a smoked tinted acrylic

[@moushunter]

The two covers that have tracks with drains are interesting. Do they look like they will trap ice and snow accumulations that could potentially freeze and distort the tracks? I don't have the luxury of a garage. All the weather mother nature throws at us here in New England finds every possible way to destroy the nice things we have.

[@kmik5682]

Excellently done video! Explained each one thoroughly!

[@Jamfogerty]

What ir they make one of those soft top cover in that cut proof material of backpacks?

[@seanpuello]

I'll stick to the 1st one. Cheaper. Easy to put on. If a "thief" rips it, you got a 10 year warranty Plus I like that you can't fold it up to the window like option 2, because I got a rear dash cam. It'll cover it up along with my vision.

[@limpfinger12]

I had the soft tri fold gator and it was great

[@Vic-zp5ft]

In my case 14 tacoma short bed i have a bakflip trifold and im upgrading to a usa roll on beacuse my truck has a sport rack on the bed and with the backflip cant use the whole bed and with the roll on i will be avle to. taking off and putting on the trifold because of my sport rack finally got to me and also will be able to use the full bed for mi bikes

[@contrerasmarciano90]

What is the weight capacity of the 3rd cover?

[@ripjohnson2121]

Had a bakflip on my gmc and down sized couple weeks ago and got a gator for my new tocoma ? Bakflip for sure. JMO

[@unlawfullettuce798]

Every system is overpriced for what it is. Furthermore not a guaranteed weather proof system. Better price or guarantee is in order. Brand names meannothing when the all provide same...

[@shannonbrooks8834]

It's Easter 2022.....My back cap hatch glass busted. $300 too 500 for a replacement glass hatch ? I think I'm going with this. I drive a Ford,but that's a good looking CHEVY. Thanks you guys ☺️

[@gobucs3146]

I got the Gator soft one and paid less than $200 from real truck. Nissan Titan. Its held very well, no water gets through despite living in a rainy climate. Definitely worth it if you don’t want to spend money. I’ve seen vids of expensive ones that leaked water. I also purchased it because it’s easy to take off and on. If I need to move furniture or something, take off, then put back on.

[@Maybelove88]

Hello, good to hear that it doesnt leak! I'm leaning towards the Gator soft one too. I plan to nomad out of my truck (sleeping in driver's seat). Do you think the soft cover is secure enough to hold some not terribly expensive tools, clothes and some foods? Or does it feel fragile and will easily razor through like this youtuber mentioned?

[@gobucs3146]

@@Maybelove88 no, it’s definitely not for security. You need something hard for that. You can easily cut this if you want.

[@Maybelove88]

@@gobucs3146 ok thanku

[@jd218]

I put a revolver bak on in 2016 cloth fell off underside vinyl peeling back.BAK offered half of a new one and flat 54 dollars shipping. I just ordered a gator sf from real truck. chatted and they gave me 264.41 total tax shipping purchase 10 years warranty vinyl lifetime hardware.thank you fellas

[@quxizl1061]

Last one is dog shit, it freezes in the winter so u can’t push it in. Had this problem all winter and even had it crack in a bunch of places. Best one is the 2nd option

[@hugotrevino2565]

Thanks for the video... I´m in for getting a bed cover and I had seen the Gator models on Truck Central´s website... I thought I wanted the trifold but after your review now I know I want the trifold! I mostly want it to keep the leaves out of my bed and the occasional grocery run with my wife... (yes, if given the space she will fill a pickup at Costco). Great video!!! Oh, and I have a 2005 Chevy Silverado with 62k miles and 2 light character scratches.

[@yoboye7518]

The last one comes with problems we were working in 28 degrees one morning and that cover didn’t want to open 😂 it was frozen, so i got rid of it and got the 2nd option

[@Zednix]

Tonneau is pronounced Tonn-oh btw, french words are funny

[@TruckCentral]

We prefer tuna

[@b737driver8]

Oui

[@regortex3364]

Improper pronunciation of both French and English by Americans, is indeed funny.😀

[@getsome1384]

Would like to see how Peragon stacked up against these three.

[@Marco-fi6gv]

That's what I'm going to get. I have an old vinyl cover with snaps and it's been a great cover for me, but I'd like something more secure and something that looks good too. I bought it off my buddy for $50.00 when he sold his truck. Best $50.00 I've ever spent. But those peragon covers are awesome, can't wait to get mine

[@getsome1384]

@@Marco-fi6gv after weeks of KZbin advertising from them, I broke down and bought one. I'm still deciding if the cover or my Morimoto headlights are the best sub $1000 purchase for my truck. I'm leaning towards the cover.

[@Marco-fi6gv]

@@getsome1384 sweet! I'm glad u are happy with it, because I'm leaning that way too. I'm going to have to break down and do it😁