WHAT IF Erwin had the COLOSSAL TITAN (Part 6) | Attack on Titan

[@TurtleQuirk]

Thanks for the continued support on this series, let me know your favourite moment from this part down below! Also yes.. I have been watching HOTD 😂

[@promikeconner9891]

Have a good team versus attack on Titan Gundam versus attack on Titan Gundam

[@bobafett1911]

Did not see a dragon titan coming nice

[@dratic9567]

hi turtle. i have made secnario for you called what if eren did not inherit the war hammer and i think you may want to have a look at it i sent you a email with the word doc attached and i hope that you use it

[@barnabassebesteny1490]

No offense but Historia probably wouldn't act like the way she does

[@rkton8988]

Pls do a part 7

[@Joumae_Saori]

A friend of mine was thinking what if there was a dragon titan in AOT. And this is the best "What if" about not just erwin surviving, but a "what if" about titan we should've got! :D

[@omnid.slayer7244]

Historia's dragon Titan is so fascinating and has a very awesome design. I really like how it looks and how the whole spit fire ability works as well. she has to burn muscle mass in order to create steam and then she stores that steam inside her where it becomes hotter and then she fires from her mouth. Everything was so awesome!!

[@Splash_husky]

POV Erwin is in game of thrones. 😂

[@Rosemary_bae]

@@Splash_husky Lmao😂

[@ayu8994]

It kinda reminds me of the Flare Titan fanfic where the OC gets a final Titan form as a dragon in an alternative timeline. Coincidentally Erwin also gets the colossal Titan in the fanfic. I highly recommend reading it, it begins pretty roughly but in the Return to Shiganshina Arc it gets pretty good.

[@dameonblackthorn9453]

Also the fact the a medieval period ruler gained the power to turn into a dragon fits really well thematically

[@omnid.slayer7244]

Floch detonated a bomb while historia was about to make contact with Eren It was insane. Also the fact that he saw a bit of the future adds even more impact to his actions because he knows he has to make sure Eren stays alive so that eldia doesn't get destroyed in the future. I love that both Eren and Erwin were shocked by this. This is a very interesting and fun to watch fan made timeline of attack on Titan!!

[@MilliFroggo]

Eren when he finds out Floch (potentially) killed Mikasa 💀

[@sheilalima9991]

Io

[@tahsiniqbal8871]

@@MilliFroggo Eren : Flock,you bastard.How dare you hurt Mikasa. I am gonna eat you now.

[@DonnaPinciot]

That's assuming he interpreted his vision right. It could just as easily be a far-future post-Rumbling world, where Eldians have repopulated and split in to their own factions, leading to civil war and the same old destruction as always.

[@samuelcaloracan]

I can already imagine Erwin screaming “Shinzo wo Sasageyo!!!” before Historia fires at the Wall Titans and the epic music starting in the background

[@Splash_husky]

I think this episode might be the most surprising and epic out of all of the episodes. I mean a dragon titan, seriously!? That’s epic af! 🤩🤩🤩

[@TurtleQuirk]

😁😁

[@PabloHernandez-gl5ij]

20 bucks says Eren going to knock the living hell out of flock for hurting Mikasa and historia.

[@hightower2141]

As much as it hurts you floch was correct no matter what paradise does the world would have wipe them out, and steal their resources for their own benefit as the final panels show floch also said Paradise will sink in a sea of blood.

[@Metaknighttheloneswordsman]

@@hightower2141 Even Kiyomi was a traitor. In a sea of their own blood

[@skinny19978]

@@hightower2141 Yup

[@SENGAMING77]

Bet

[@Dark_Trap998]

I'd expect less from a bird-nested haired guy...

[@brothers_of_nod]

I didn't know how this would go, but dayum now I want even more. I expected Floch to be on the side of Eren through and through, and his choice here was in perfect character, though I have to wonder if Eren would stop marching out of fear of killing Historia and Mikasa.

[@fl3m1n9o4]

yeah considering the whole point of the rumbling is to protect the people he loves, it would make a lot of sense to stop for a moment to avoid trampling them.

[@99waterblade]

@@fl3m1n9o4 love for freedom>his love for friends

[@brunomenezes9011]

@@99waterblade I don't think so. If that was the case, he'd never have told Armin to kill him, and wouldn't stop at 80% either

[@skybattler2624]

@@brunomenezes9011 Even if you take account the possible AOE scenario, Floch hurting both Mikasa and Historia here would change Eren drastically, especially without Armin here. In the original timeline, he placed his trust on his friends, and his friends failed to deliver it. In a potential AOE timeline, he choose to sacrifice Mikasa and Armin because he saw them as traitors, as he formed a family with Historia instead, and valued it more than his friends. In this scenario of Erwin becoming the Collosal, Historia and Mikasa are both equally important people to Eren, and having Armin out of the picture, this could lead to either (1) a selective Rumbling where only Eldians of both continents remain (2) Eren turning rogue and annihilates everyone except Mikasa and Historia (3) Stopping the Rumbling before Marley was trampled. The important detail here is that, for some unknown reason, the MidEast Alliance and Hizuru was trampled first before Liberio. This is a major plotpoint that cannot be ignored. Also, Erwin needs to succeed in negotiations. However, right now, we know that Erwin doesn't have the correct bargaining chips to convince Eren.

[@PK-Radio]

This is genuinely the coolest fan story I have ever heard Honestly I like this more than the original story

[@mehitablestorm8877]

I agree, this is really a great idea. Maybe there can be a remake down the road. Why not, they remade everything else! But this time Erwin lives and WE GET A DRAGON!

[@percygekkouga2151]

Armong really took a toll on the story, eh?

[@GPSHomes]

You do not cease to surprise me. The plot on thickens as we move ahead. Can’t pinpoint a specific moment. This is a brilliant retelling overall.

[@fl3m1n9o4]

in case you don't realise, the comment above is a scam.

[@Metaknighttheloneswordsman]

"Ai without the I" - Sophist

[@sprinter1773]

Me: about to go to sleep so I won’t be tired Turtle quirk: *Posts Part 6* Me: “What’s one more video?”

[@brothers_of_nod]

Literally me it's 1:45 AM here but worth it.

[@ilivnart]

Man, I hope Erwin will scream next to Eren these haunting words again; "EREN, WHO DO YOU THINK THE REAL ENEMY IS!". This powerful words will now come in full circle from Eren's first association with Erwin Smith.

[@machodgdon]

Isayama works hard, but Turtle Quirk works harder

[@BoogieWoogie...]

But isayama laid down the blocks for this side universe

[@davismagata8025]

Turtle Ouirk deserves more subs

[@denizen5764]

Armin: Thank you for becoming a genocidal monster Isayama: perfection

[@sainaparbin5389]

No

[@THEBIGGESTOFMAN]

the children are fast but big bird is faster

[@febinjohn2030]

This has been a phenomenal series so far! It's not often that you get a what if that is this believable and have the characters act naturally, as hyped for the next episode of this as I was for the episodes of S4!

[@TurtleQuirk]

Thanks so much 😁

[@tywilson2948]

This series is what I would’ve wanted the actual show to do.. your a great show runner lol can’t wait for part 7. (The art work in the video was amazing too)

[@TurtleQuirk]

thanks :)

[@robbieglen7423]

Dude, again with another banger. I love it. And so you know since you're so eager to know my favourite part, it's got to be dragon, almost griffin like titan you gave Historia as well as both of the last Ackermans dying(I think). I love the Strength given to the titan but with the massive trade off with the burning of it's own muscle mass. And now you've got Erwin looking like a knight in shining armor riding a firebreathing dragon, I honsestly can't wait to see Eren's reaction to The Ackermans' deaths and seeing what he's gonna do with the rumbling after. Thank you, Can't wait untill the next part

[@Starbuckace]

Im glad the explanation for the Dragon titan makes sense, just makes this story that much better.

[@anotherhuman8173]

Wow, deaths like Premier Zachary and Willy Tybur actually had more of an impact than I realized

[@big_meeks-0]

they are leaders in very important position

[@Essendiinanis]

I am FOAMING at the mouth for the next part. Your cliffhangers are going to be crucial to killing me. Also this gave me so much inspiration I have to leave now.

[@ikeepmovingforward3979]

This just keeps getting better and better!! But man this cliffhanger is even worse than Final Season part 1 finale, can't wait for the next part!!!

[@PakistaniSenpai]

This series is absolutely amazing. I binge watched it in 2 days and the artwork really brings it to life along with your narration. Only complaint I have in this episode is Floch's dream. While it is cool that he got a vision of Eldia's destruction in 139.5 and I hope it is addressed in a later episode since it is implied that Ymir was also present so was it Eren influencing Floch to make sure the rumbling is completed? Anyways, an amazing cliffhanger yet again. Cannot wait for part 7!

[@Dark__Epic]

Manga Spoilers Floch's dream really highlighted the result of what happened when they stopped Eren at 80% so Floch's dream and him intervening to stop the scouts really stood out to me

[@justabrokezombie6252]

King Floch

[@Tahkaullus01]

So your solution is to promote genocide?

[@kimmarch90]

Wow. I can't imagine all the prep and research you've had to do to even make these. I am impressed.

[@TurtleQuirk]

Why thank you

[@ReaperTheSav7]

I love this series! I like seeing Erwin being revived instead of Armin. I like the fact that you go in depth with this and you do mostly by yourself. Good job, Turtle Quirk!

[@TurtleQuirk]

Thanks 😁

[@ReaperTheSav7]

@@a.m_04831 IDK, but I am a bit curious.

[@mgmor05]

I like how you give more thought to Floch and Willy

[@bigchad60]

Man this is the best series of what if aot

[@RandomBlackGuyisrandom]

This needs to be an anime what if. I'm at the edge of my seat intently listening to all of this

[@sultankulbassov5604]

The world needs part 7!!!!

[@joshdotstuff902]

I love this series, this has been so helpful to my mental health in between seasons

[@L_I_V_E-]

I think your theory is better than the actual show, SERIOUSLY!!!!!

[@4Slugo]

OMG this is so good i can not wait for part 7 this is such fun series you should do more.

[@skiller9699]

Bro i swear this series is the best series so far! You are a really cool youtuber and i like your content so much! Thanks for this awesome series!

[@rachavinvitayakovit1408]

More what if series needed from this guy:)

[@anaspoher]

THE WAIT WAS WORTH IT

[@youllknowme2079]

Always has been

[@brothers_of_nod]

So glad I saw the immediate notification!

[@wdnathmark5058]

I really wish someone would turn this whole series into an anime that would be so fire

[@Compressedmocha]

Not the ackermans noooo. This is such a great story i'm so hyped for the upcoming parts

[@ThePurpleFoot]

Really excited to see the next part!

[@lyme1030]

MAD RESPECT! You truely outdid yourselves with this one! 💯

[@subhashkapur4148]

Completely on board for this series - can't wait for part 7 💥💥💥

[@isaacbabb6910]

Damn dude, if this is how the series went, it would definitely be 10x better. You're such a talented writer!

[@greetings3071]

17:58 Had this been a movie or side manga, people who loved 139 would now be glad that Erwin wasn't chosen just because of that part

[@reddjack340]

This has been my favorite fan AU since I found it,please keep up the great work

[@derick_ab]

I love all of the series of What if Erwin got the Colossal!! The way things came together just reminded me of Isayama sooooo much!!! I hope you can do more What it’s for AOT or even other animes!!! Fan-freaking-tastic job!!!!

[@That1StickGuy]

I like Eren like this, he still has his hatred as well as having some emotion

[@darvinakachulo1998]

I’ve been waiting for this!!!

[@jdent4544]

I like how Willy tyber and Erwin came face to face with each other for the first time and what shocked me is floch betraying Erwin and the rest because of his paranoia got the best of him. The canon made me root for him but this timeline his betrayal devastated me.

[@jw-ws8dz]

in this timeline his stance is the same as his stance in the canon timeline: protect Eren and let the rumbling continue

[@jdent4544]

@@jw-ws8dz but betraying the man he trust more than eren. Remember the Yeagerist were never formed in this timeline as he believed in Erwin choices. That's what shocked me from watching this.

[@skybattler2624]

@@jdent4544 Question is: why did Ymir decide to show the vision to Floch? What is her message? I have a feeling that Ymir showed 2 different scenarios and has other plans, and she is betraying Eren at this point. Remember, Ymir can show whatever memories she wants across different timelines.

[@jdent4544]

@@skybattler2624 i think ymir actually believed that Erwin might have been the one to change this timeline.

[@romansalgadojr2727]

Good video. Historia’s dragon looks like the dragon from a never ending story. Also is it inevitable of the fact that floch betrays everyone except eren?

[@mehitablestorm8877]

It think it's Floch's nature.

[@romansalgadojr2727]

@@mehitablestorm8877 I mean in this situation is understandable but still always betrayal

[@littlesneets8026]

holy shiiiiiiii.... How is a fanmade what-if scenario like this written so well??? this is actually a really awesome concept, and it utilizes the side-characters and pushes them front and center in such a great way!

[@thatonesoul1211]

Can't wait for Part 7 ❤️

[@TEENASSASSIN]

Gahdamn this series has been going strong for a YEAR bro

[@Ratio-b6g]

Interesting video do part 7 please it's so interesting

[@l.o.gfauzan1877]

Coming from the last episode, I was thinking that Eren actually eliminate ALL titan abilities including Erwin's, Historia's and Floch's, but he didn't. So this is either a plothole (which I don't mind really), a setup for future plot, or I'm completely missing something

[@TurtleQuirk]

Sorry for confusion on that! It was more that Eren reversed their transformations in that moment, but he didn't permanently remove titan powers. I'm not 100% sure if Eren could permanently erase powers anyway, cause if it was possible you'd think Karl Fritz would've done it during the great titan war (probably)

[@l.o.gfauzan1877]

@@TurtleQuirk ahhhh I see, thanks for making it clear. Keep up the great videos👍

[@Blood_Casual_Gaming]

the fact that this is still going is awesome

[@EthanPHX]

Can’t wait for the last part!

[@randomuser1713]

damn was not expecting the two ackermans to die so excited for part 7😀😀

[@lerneanlion]

With this video featured Maria, Rose and Sina, it made me thought of why they followed their father's command even after he passed away. I mean, don't they get to decide things on their own when they are freed of their King Frtiz's influence? They can created a policy of using Titans for defensive war only. But no, they continued their father's conquests despite the fact they do not have to. Also, I got an idea inspired by BFG for you. I called this idea as the Dream Titan. This Titan is the smallest but is equipped with a horn and a number of jars that contained glowing and colorful dreams while glowing red ones are nightmares. If wanted to, this Titan can unleashed nightmares to every single person on Marley to stop Marley's expansion and conquests. However, this Titan has a mind of its own and can choose and refuse the potential hosts. It will chosen the one who understands "what it means to dream" only.

[@altair_ezio01]

buddy I loved this version, far better than the original

[@rainsrailer3011]

Please continue I need a part 7

[@doh-nc8ku]

You’ve done great work I have a high interest in this never would I would think I’d be saying that about a fan story

[@thedino805]

i am adicted to this type of content and i need MORE!

[@GenericProtagonist7]

Floch you absolute fucking CHAMPION

[@aradhosseini387]

great as always looking for part 7🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@meghanyingling8133]

They need to make a WHAT IF for AOT. I would love it

[@luqmanulhakimproduction1951]

This timeline make aot more perfect

[@bullymaguire2061]

This is actually pretty good

[@thalmoragent9344]

Low key, a Beast Titan back in the day was DEFINITELY a Dragon. Or at least a Founding Titan. The concept HAD to have come up eventually. Although I feel it would be a Wyvern, with 2 wings and 2 legs, so 4 limbs and not 6, just to follow the "humanoid" look of Beast Titans, since it's animal/human hybrid mixed most often. And no point in giving a Shifter a Titan with extra limbs to worry about.

[@cooperstanford1407]

Good job love the content

[@andreslealjasso2237]

Pls continue this series its sooooo goooo

[@therealbarackobama3946]

After this phenomenal series is over you should do another what is series like what if other titan shifters betrayed Marley like Annie staying on the island and helping in season 1?

[@mtscout636]

this is so awsome please keep up the great work bro ill share ur videos with my friends

[@TurtleQuirk]

Thank you!

[@kraywvyx]

that dragon titan looks so cool

[@Metaknighttheloneswordsman]

Me when Turtle Quirk uploads: *T H E O N E P I E C E I S R E A L*

[@jekaireed3495]

CONTINUE ITS SO GOOD

[@Pugoey]

Wow. Amazing work

[@thatoneanimekhorkid]

THE TIMELINE OMG 💯

[@alternativehistoryandfutur6786]

Eren: rumbles to save his friends Floch: kills erens friends to save the rumbling

[@nsg_kuunda4786]

Eager for this series. But I also fell asleep this time. Lullaby was super effective.

[@bradypasquet6891]

So stocked to watch this love this series!

[@wortbenistopmotions6744]

Floch did them with the "As a warrior..." ass transformation

[@wojtekreliga3881]

Could you make an episode "What if Marco survived?". If he was calmness, he could easily escape Titan though broken window and ran to his allies.

[@mehitablestorm8877]

Hmmm....but if Marco survived, then you'd lose a prime motivator for Jean because Marco's death particularly affected him deeply and led to him joining the Scouts instead of the Military Police.

[@wojtekreliga3881]

@@mehitablestorm8877 Exactly. And how Eren's court could end if people knew there were other hostile Titan shifters?

[@hightower2141]

@@mehitablestorm8877 so let the guy catch a break atleast let him enjoy his life.

[@mehitablestorm8877]

@@hightower2141 Who, Jean? Jean needed to accomplish something instead of wasting his life with the MPs. The MPs were dragged into the fight eventually anyway, but it was an opportunity for Jean to show leadership, which he did very well. I attribute that to Marco's influence.

[@NonuGamezRobloxE]

that would have a LOT of parts since that happened all the way back in season 1

[@samueldelatorre8560]

We must protect this mans beautiful mind at all cost

[@radbox2287]

AHHHH new episode😄😁😁

[@LazerPotato7]

basically the same thing happens only more confusingly. also levi keeps his fingers

[@HomeOfClipsII]

I don’t know how Eren would exactly react to Floch’s betrayal, I mean sure he knows that Floch did it for him… but he also indirectly injured Mikasa. (I don’t know if she’s dead) Can’t wait for Part 7

[@Metaknighttheloneswordsman]

If she didn't die from the close transformation, then she probably died from falling from a high place

[@ujwalkomaravolu9619]

@@Metaknighttheloneswordsman unless eren decides use his hand to decrease her fall

[@Hollowmello1285]

@@Metaknighttheloneswordsman and historia he cares for her too

[@knightzilver4696]

@@Metaknighttheloneswordsman I mean all they need is to wake up and use their odm gear to grab onto any near by Titan. Sure it’s gonna hurt them still with the whiplash they’ll get but they’ll survive. Maybe paralyze them both. Wheelchair Levi is inevitable

[@Metaknighttheloneswordsman]

@knightzilver4696 True. Though they likely would pass out from the heat that the wall titans emit

[@ianoliano2057]

Giving Historia a bigger role is always nice. She didn't really do much after becoming queen not going to lie

[@CaptainphoenixofficialYT]

I really love this series and what I say next may show that I take it too seriously. (For real, I could see this being an Attack on Titan "What If...?") Buut... 1. How is Eren able to continue the rumbling? In the manga, we explicitly see that Eren needs continous contact with royal blood in order to "keep moving forward". It's why he absorbed Zeke AND why killing Zeke was the only way to stop the rumbling. 2. Why would Eren be shocked about his friends (especially Mikasa) attacking him? We know that ever since the end of season 3, Eren has had the knowledge of the future (with some exceptions of course; like he didn't know Sasha would die) but he had enough to piece together the end. And he knew Mikasa would be the one to kill him. But I guess, since in the show, he only knew of the future when he kissed Historia's hand which happened AFTER Armin got the colossal, maybe this time he saw a different future? Maybe you planned that out...? 🤔

[@TurtleQuirk]

Ahaha thanks for the support, I'm glad people are invested in this so I'll try to answer these (apologies in advance for the long answer 🤣) 1. I took inspo from ch.138 when it came to this. Up until that chapter we _thought_ Eren needed to maintain contact with a titan of royal blood to do the rumbling, but eventually it became clear that what really matters is Ymir's will. Back in ch.137 Eren lost contact with the only titan of royal blood there was, so in theory the conflict should've ended at that moment. If Eren truly needed to maintain contact with a titan of royal blood for the rumbling to continue, then chapter 137 would've been the end of it. However as we saw, in 138 Eren used the Founders power to transform into a giant colossal body and then he tried to restart the rumbling by reaching worm-Kun. Gabi even has a line here when she outright says Eren might "restart the rumbling" once he makes contact with the worm. That was Isayama letting us know that a titan of royal blood isn't the only factor when it comes to using the founder... the will of the Founder is what's actually important, especially after Eren freed her. On a related note, in the original story Eren was going through the motions to reach an outcome that would make his friends look like saviours; Levi attacking Zeke to supposedly "stop" the rumbling plays into that. It makes Levi a hero in this legend. But in this alternate timeline Eren's not playing that game, he doesn't want to be stopped. So he had no reason to absorb Historia or anything like that 2. He saw a different future, I actually mention this in the part 1 video (at the end)!

[@CaptainphoenixofficialYT]

@@TurtleQuirk Thanks for responding. 🤩 A lot of creators don't normally respond to their comments so thanks for that, I don't really care about the wait. 😀 1. I didn't realise that, I took worm-kun as its own identity, seeing as when it touched Ymir, they were completely different beings. So I actually didn't interpret it as Ymir's will. I just thought that by Eren touching it, he'd start the cycle that Ymir began 2000 years prior. Good catch and why I love watching your channel for analysising details like this. 2. I think I missed that, welp, time to restart this series. 😅❤

[@cnlmrl8951]

Come on plot armor, protect Levi one more time 😰

[@sistersofblood2816]

That's one badass titan ngl.

[@That_One_Person_Idk]

we need a part 7!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@mrpotch]

Kiyomi just loves switching sides 😆

[@sherkhancsr]

Ur dedication is just 🔥🔥🔥

[@joylynbateman4015]

I like historia’s dragon Titan, although I would’ve also liked to see an entire video telling us about it

[@familiedjoko4143]

WHERE IS PART 7 MAN IVE BEEN WAITING SO LOOOOONG 😭😭😭

[@therussiangod8619]

Turtle quirk this is a awesome sires for attack on titan keep doing it man I love it you are awesome 😎 keep up the great work

[@narellehall378]

Please make part 7

[@madiesihle1373]

Floch said I'm bout ends their hole careers

[@madiesihle1373]

Thanks

[@Ezol1]

This story is so fascinating! 👏😃

[@wamaschawama5178]

That Thumbnail really caught me off guard 😂

[@bearodriguez1572]

i want part 7