Twice - Next Page (Vocal Analysis) (Background Vocals, Lead Vocals, Ad-libs, etc.)

[@ravenlam6215]

Reasons to convince everybody that Sana sings the whole verse after Chaeyoung's: 1. The voice sounds exactly like how Sana would sound in that lower range 2. The way they pronounce the word 'eojjeom' is just too different 3. Sana sings it in the Twiceland concert (For some reason she didn't sing the whole thing during the Twiceland Encore tour) 4. Yes, Dahyun is seen lipping the part, but a) she lips pretty much everything and b) her lip-syncing seems off in that part as if she wasn't really paying effort (especially in the Encore tour where her mouth was not really moving that much to enunciate) 5. It doesn't make any sense that Momo sings the full verse while Sana needs to share it with Dahyun and that Dahyun sings two verses

[@CHAEJI_]

I agree with everything except the last point, k-pop line distributions usually make no sense, something like this is very likely to happen, especially in bigger groups

[@nighthunter3372]

There's Snsd distribution for you. They have 2 parts in the 1st verse but in the 2nd verse they split up into 4 parts.

[@nighthunter3372]

​@@CHAEJI_true

[@gabrielwaitzoker5730]

​@@nighthunter3372Stay Girls moment

[@ravenlam6215]

@@nighthunter3372 I mean if it is like half-half, then it makes sense. But if it's like this case where people thought Sana only did those random adlibs. That's a bit too weird. But I would agree that it's is a good point to acknowledge that sometimes it doesn't make sense.

[@the_jollyvisi0n]

I love how we figure this out 7.5 years later

[@zachyzxchzach]

Just like one more time lol😭

[@nighthunter3372]

I hate JYP and SM for hiring BG Vocalist while they have member sound the same as Bg vocalists. Yuri can take the bridge harmony in Mr Taxi meanwhile dahyun also can do the harmonies. Dahyun also can take the like crazy and like baby lines.

[@spkpop]

YAY SANA HAS A WHOLE VERSE THIS GREAT.

[@miam_k]

i knew one of the dahyun verses was sana, i commented it somewhere like around 2 years ago

[@sat0_shiht735]

I was deceived my whole life thinking that Dahyun sang two verses.

[@eumesmo5533]

Y'all believe in anything those channels say... It's clearly Dahyun

[@nighthunter3372]

Petition for Twice to have a lyrics monitor. So that its easier to know whose parts is whose and it's official.

[@sooji_thesnowBIGGESTfan]

wha's a lyrics monitor

[@stacysmom3]

⁠@@sooji_thesnowBIGGESTfanduring concerts they have the monitor and it has the lyrics to the song their doing and says which member sings what (sorry if this doesnt make sense im bad at explaining)

[@henlo.o.o]

suddenly sanatozaki's next page video is the most accurate one out there currently 😭

[@nighthunter3372]

It's the accurate and all correct I think.

[@zbkvolgren]

sanatozaki got everything else correct minus not counting the "like crazy" and "like baby" parts

[@nighthunter3372]

​@@zbkvolgrenlike crazy and like baby is full of Bg vocals. So it's Best not to count.

[@zbkvolgren]

it depends on whether the uploader is doing with or without bg (no hard and fast rule) for the with bg category it's still counted because the members put in effort to record the lines

[@lukec2129]

@@nighthunter3372i disagree, they are very clearly nayeon and jihyo respectively

[@snsdgivemetwice]

OMG 😲😮 I already expected it, it's impossible for Sana to only get so few parts. Because I've always been muttering "Dahyun, Chae, Momo got all the verses" even Dahyun got 2 verses, it doesn't make sense. And I always heard the difference between verse 1 Dahyun and verse 2 Dahyun, but I never thought that verse 1 was Sana. Because the first time TWICE performed live, Sana didn't sing the full verse 1 and shared it with Dahyun (whether Dahyun just lipsynced or not) But it doesn't make sense, all the members sang their parts in full but only Sana didn't. 😅

[@ServingVocals]

SO CLEAN !!!!

[@cuongnguyenhuu712]

The older the line distribution, the inaccurate it is is not right for Next Page lol Sanatozaki's Next Page line distribution is just the most accurate . AND MY BIAS SANA T_T finally

[@eumesmo5533]

It's not Sana lol

[@M-MF-F]

0:32 IS THIS SANA?!?!

[@eumesmo5533]

No

[@_ajimoyie9822]

​@@eumesmo5533yes*, did you even watched the analysis 💀

[@eumesmo5533]

@@_ajimoyie9822 Analysis = literally opinion

[@Lucas-jw4fy]

​@@_ajimoyie9822 it doesn't even sounds like Sana lmao

[@ratking6407]

the background vocals in the chorus sound like nayeon and jihyo

[@ravenlam6215]

I feel like the 'mam' has the residue of their vocals.

[@mariri710]

SANA!!!

[@cyrlvn04]

Now this is plot twist. Sana in first verse shocked me literally.

[@eumesmo5533]

It's not her

[@-BigVocaling-]

Help wth I hear dahyun’s accent but sana’s voice 😫

[@Koo_k75]

So the line distribution would be like this (? Mina - 26.4 Tzuyu - 18.8 Jihyo - 16.3 Nayeon - 15.8 Jeongyeon - 14.9 Momo - 9.9 Sana - 9.5 Chaeyoung - 9.2 Dahyun - 9.0

[@eumesmo5533]

Nah it's still not Sana

[@DDP121]

@@eumesmo5533like you said in other comment, is only your opinion

[@eumesmo5533]

@@DDP121 I meant analysis is just the creator opinion, not an indestructible truth, but people take the analysis as if it were something official and irrefutable, when in fact it is not

[@DDP121]

@@eumesmo5533 in MR Removed Sana sing some words in live and Dahyun only lipsync, that is a fact, i prefer believe in who sing it in live than the who only lipsync imo

[@sooji_thesnowBIGGESTfan]

@@DDP121 what is mr removed meaning

[@sebastianpalko6664]

You ate this

[@lightofdawn7291]

0:37 this is def Dahyun, the part before that may be Sana

[@nightskpop]

Thank you, I don’t hear sana here either..

[@corneiz_bp_tw8240]

Thisss! Are people just playing along to the creator of the video or do they genuinely hear Sana...

[@HahaHaha-jx4le]

I agree.

[@GabrielAlves-ig6wh]

The ending sounds a lot like sana's low register, in handle it people also said sana's low line was dahyun

[@Dahyunfan-xo4bg]

​​@@GabrielAlves-ig6whwhat You said is right, but in FFW Dahyun line in Chorus sounds a lot like Sana.

[@pablo3679]

It doesn't make sense Dahyun was the only one who sang those lines in the song presentations, not Sana... for me it's Dahyun but it sounds like Sana and/or harmonizes with Sana

[@ravenlam6215]

Sana did lip the whole thing in the very first tour.

[@lukec2129]

dahyun never sang it, she lip-synced some of it, but you can listen to the mr removed provided in the video, only sana ever sang any part of it live

[@eumesmo5533]

​@@lukec2129 She literally sang it

[@lukec2129]

@@eumesmo5533 listen to the audio in this video, she only lip-synced it, which she does for other member’s lines in countless performances

[@eumesmo5533]

@@lukec2129 But there's no motivation for robbing Sana's lines in live performance. If she was lip syncing, she would lip sync Momo part for sure

[@cosmicld]

exactly😭

[@sooji_thesnowBIGGESTfan]

If the "oh-oh-oh-oh-oh-oh"'s ain't Nayho, why do they both sound so different?

[@ravenlam6215]

There are two background vocalists doing bg vocals for this song.

[@darkslice679]

I’d love to believe that sana actually got a line but it’s really not THAT unbelievable that their early songs weren’t distributed very well (example: truth) it really just sounds like dahyun to me

[@nightskpop]

I desperately want to believe you because sana is my bias, but how to you explain this? : kzbin.info/www/bejne/mXu4gayfjdGGf6csi=00nXZgz1QW9Jxg0x Sana is only sing the adlibs here..🤔

[@ravenlam6215]

Please refer to no 4 of the pinned comment.

[@nightskpop]

but if you pause at 0:20 or 0:21 and zoom in on her, she stops lipping after “pang pang”

[@ravenlam6215]

@@nightskpop Yeah, for some reason, Sana only sang the adlibs in the Encore tour. But she did sing the whole thing in the first tour.

[@nightskpop]

okayyy.. I just find it weird that she wouldn’t try to lip her ONLY line in the song..😐

[@ravenlam6215]

​@@nightskpopmaybe she does not like to sing in that range?

[@reidavi2323]

So Mina is first?

[@luvingleewonhee]

dahyun is the second verse