Two Jews Speak on Being Jewish Catholics w/ Roy Schoeman

Joing me as I speak with Author Roy Shoeman on being Jewish within the Catholic Church

[@innerhealingcoach]

Same with me Roy, my most attacked moments are on the way to mass or adoration. Sometimes crazy stuff during mass too. I just refocus back to Yeshua! My journey to Catholicism has been nothing short of His miraculous love and grace!

[@nathaliemooredoyle5168]

S

[@mariandogma6466]

Welcome home ❤

[@eleanatopp1]

I'm a craddle Catholic from Perú. My husband converted from Judaism to Catholicism after 20 years of marriage. His grandparents from his mother's side had a hotel for Jewish and kosher restaurant in the Jersey Shore. It was called Hotel Altman.

[@mmeyerdc]

Perhaps the best and freshest Roy Schoeman interview I’ve seen. Cradle Catholic that I am, I am grateful for both of your witnesses.

[@tony1685]

will pray you study Scripture n see how catholicism isn't God's will.

[@maryloomis8075]

Gentlemen, welcome to the Church which was started by your Messiah, by Jewish apostles for the salvation of your people and then for us Gentiles of which I am one. I lost my Jewish brother-in-law to cancer in 21 and then my dear sister in 23 almost 2 years to the day after her husband.She was devout Catholic and he an agnostic Jew. I pray both are in heaven or at least purgatory. He was able to talk for several hours to the family's rabbi before he died.Their daughters are both agnostic or maybe atheist. I plan to get Roy's book for them ( one is my God daughter), and maybe they will understand the continuation of the Jewish faith as it flowed into the Catholic Church. I watch the One for Israel site occasionally, and praise God for all the Jews who are coming to Christ/Yeshua. Praise be Jesus Christ for the conversion of your parents, Roy! God bless and keep you both!

[@myronmercado]

"Post Messianic Judaism, Pre-Messianic Catholicism" is the excellent and perfect descrption for our faith!

[@erroljacobs4555]

Thank you my brother Daniel and brother Roy for sharing the Faith. I love being catholic. Love from south Africa cape town. 💒💒💒💒♥️♥️

[@imonterocorzo]

This is wonderful! I am also going to the Traditional Latin Mass. It is so beautiful and there are the Jewish elements in it that, to a certain extent, you feel like it is a continuation of the same religion. As a Catholic, I was taught that our Jewish brother and sisters need to be protected by the Church because the will accept Jesus as their messiah at the end of times and that the Catholic and Jews will become one. God bless you all!

[@sammyrnaj]

When I know that Jews are for Jesus, I feel FULFILLED, & WHOLESOME. Retrieving a cousin I know is of my lineage but I never met & we are now united. (I am Maronite from Lebanon).

[@darlameeks]

"Christianity is Jewish to the core." -- N.T. Wright, "Revelation for Everyone". The Incarnation of the Messiah was Yahweh's answer to the prayers of the faithful Jewish matriarchs and patriarchs. Thanks to both of you...I'll check out your channel, Roy!

[@sammyrnaj]

This is beautiful. As Jews in Catholicism, maintaining your Jewish traditions brings you & Jesus closer to us Catholics, exalts Jesus & glorifies God! You are confirming that you have accepted Jesus & His Mother. But never forget Yosef, The Man God Himself chose as Jesus'Father on this earth! If you go through all our Holy Mother's Apparitions, you will observe that every time she was asked questions by young seers, She ALWAYS confirmed She IS Jewish! ❤

[@sammyrnaj]

Roy has our Lady of Rosa Mystica! How lovely!

[@mercyalabi4927]

I love you, my brothers, it may be difficult, our mother is always there with us, her immaculate heart must triumph.

[@amparohonaker5973]

Dear Jewish brothers, praise God for your conversion and I want you to know my husband wishes so much he was Jewish!!!! My husband is Protestant please pray for his conversion!

[@susanamargaritagarciadelga5643]

Roy and Daniel, thanks for loving our blessed mother. ❤❤

[@karinclarkson4398]

God bless you both and please continue to teach others how to be great Catholics! Shalom

[@TheJewishCatholic]

Thank you!

[@gilbertbloomer586]

Thanks for an interesting discussion-it is always great to hear the opinions and perspectives of other Catholic Jews.

[@deusimperator]

Br. Gilbert, you might know me from the facebook from about 4 years ago, from the Hebrew Catholic group. I got kicked off FB for posting a hadith without any commentary to a Islam Christian debate group. That is why I am no longer in the group, I did not leave the group, was kicked off FB. If the followers of that religion think their own trustworthy sources indicate possession of the founder, and consider posting their own sources hate, there is a problem with that religion.

[@markv1974]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/g6mafpefnauZotE here is another jewish catholic

[@wms72]

​@@deusimperator obvious problems with it

[@kiryu-chan577]

Mr Schoeman had an amazing experience. Wow

[@MrPeach1]

I would like to hear you guys speak about Jewish purgatory. I feel like modern people don't realize this is a Jewish teaching.

[@deusimperator]

See my comment on the subject

[@deusimperator]

@@manuelsanchezdeinigo3959 Get lost protty troll

[@wms72]

He made a video on it

[@heavenianseye2228]

Please research about the Original Mass of Catholic Church. Traditional Latin Mass. And share it with fellow Catholic Jews. Thank you and God bless! 🥰🙏

[@SaintCharbelMiracleworker]

You finally go Roy Schoeman. Excellent. 🙌🏾

[@ilil813]

Praying for convertion of jews

[@myriamc.]

Yay!!! It is great that you had him on your podcast!!! You are both awesome testimonies of the Church!😀🙏🏾❤

[@beatrizhomeyplace4084]

I have read Mr. Schoeman’ book “Salvation is from the Jews” 2 times. It’s one of the most insightful books I have ever read! Amazing book!

[@SaintCharbelMiracleworker]

I would suggest a series of interviews on Jews who become Jewish Catholic. Debbie Herbeck has a great conversion story. Born and raised in a highly successful prominent devout Jewish family, when she went to college she became more exposed to the person of Jesus and "discovered" He was Jewish. She came home from college and announced she wanted to become Catholic her shocked parents had their Catholic business colleague come over to the house to talk her out of it.

[@williambullard9599]

Alhamdu'lillah I am an Antiochene Maronite too. We are "the" most Jewish of ALL rites in the Temple. The Temple's resurrection will come from out of a Jewish resurrection and reaffirmation of the Messianic Judaism that is Catholicism; Yeshua haMashiac the Jew, the Rabbi, the greatest of ALL Rabbis that were, are now, or ever will be, possibly a Hillelite Pa'rush [Pharisee] must be restored to the Temple if Catholicism is to make any sense. MashAllah Mashiac em haqqan qamc Allah mach

[@ChrisEAdlay]

​@@williambullard9599maronites are the heart of our church in Sydney. You are the little pillars holding us up

[@Nazarene_Judaism]

No. you need messianic judaism.@@williambullard9599

[@sammyrnaj]

I wish to thank you very much for this profound discussion. God bless you both & protect you.

[@leojmullins]

I am born in Rhodesia of Irish Catholic parents grew up along side Jews, and Protestants and did miltary service with Hindis Muslims and Buddhists. I never saw Jews as anything but non-Catholic and it puzzled me greatly why after the centuries Jews still did not accept Jesus. Seeing your work now is edifying and uplifting for me.

[@angelicaevelynvalles7250]

Que impactante este canal, saludos desde México. Admiro muchísimo la historia de Roy Shoeman, nuestra iglesia es hermosa y ahí está la verdad. Si pudieras hacer un vídeo sobre la historia de Edith Stein, también conversa. Dios te bendiga, saludos.

[@user-ju6gj8jf3l]

May Almighty God continue to bless you abundantly; I now include the conversion of Jews in my daily prayer petitions of the Holy Rosary, and also when I attend Catholic Mass. Thank you very much for sharing; God bless.

[@williambullard9599]

Thank you. I know that I am not alone now. Glad and happy to hear these things that I have always "secretly" believed.

[@NassauOngalewuPukapuka-hg4zt]

Very proud brothers in Christ 🙏

[@MrJoebrooklyn1969]

We love you brothers.

[@deusimperator]

One has to remember the covenantal Judaism transformed into covenantal Catholicism. One has to enter through the covenant into salvation. I have been told by someone not Jewish that Catholicism is against the Torah as well and I have asked them as to what exactly they meant, they meant and they never could articulate what they meant. The fact is that in the Olam Haba the some of the laws would be suspended and the Gentiles would enter into the covenant. However, there is something even deeper in this fore-understanding regarding the Messianic Olam Haba. The pig will return to the covenant. Who is the pig in Judaism? It is Rome. It is also about exile and the return from it. The pig is the symbol of Rome in Judaism. The pig becomes acceptable when Rome enters into the covenant. What is this covenant? It is the Catholic Church the sign of the covenant is the Eucharist - a thanksgiving sacrifice that would not shed any blood. Everything in Judaism is pointing towards Catholicism.

[@deusimperator]

Just to add, the first non-Jew to enter into the covenant was the family of Cornelius, a Roman. It was not a Greek, but a Roman. The Jews had far more dealings with Greeks and many Jews were Hellenics. Greeks were everywhere in Judea. But it was not a Greek to become the first Gentile convert. It was a Roman centurion. Read Acts 10. ONLY WHEN CORNELIUS IS READY TO ENTER INTO THE FAITH DOES THE PIG BECOME CLEAN READ ACTS 10....

[@deusimperator]

Those who are interested as to why the pig is Rome can read this www.thetorah.com/article/why-rome-is-likened-to-a-boar

[@deusimperator]

I just typed in pig rome and Judiasm to find that article, just reading it... it mentions Esau who rejected the birthright... which I mentioned in my other comment, regarding Catholciism as the birthright, hmmmm.

[@deusimperator]

Well I thoguht I found something new for a while now but reading that article... the writer is another Jewish Catholic at the Catholic Theological Union writing for a Jewish website.

[@deusimperator]

@@manuelsanchezdeinigo3959 So you are SDA.... LOL LOL LOL Following American Gringo religion funny clown... LOL LOL LOL🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@kimfleury]

3 Aves for each of you 🌹🌹🌹🙏🏻 🌹🌹🌹🙏🏻 Thank you for the discussion on "Replacement Theology." That's always puzzled me since I first heard of it. The message that seeped into my mind since childhood in the Catholic Church is that the Jewish people are chosen forever, and we Gentiles are the adopted sons and daughters of God granted into the Body of Christ and nourished by His Blood. Forgive me for not being able to quote the Scriptures, prayers, and Catechism passages verbatim, let alone chapter and verse or the setting of the prayer. I only wish I could for the sake of rebutting the irrational anti-Semitism I've come across in some Traditional circles. Alas, all I can do is offer the summary and pray for their souls.

[@ashwith]

I didn't know that the intercession of the saints had Jewish precedent. A few months back I learned from another channel (Pints with Aquinas) that chant was probably something that grew from temple musicians becoming Catholic and bringing their practice and talents to the Church. Hope you do more of this. Outside of Dr. Brant Pitre's books, I don't know a lot about the Jewish roots of the Church.

[@YardenJZ]

Matthew 23:29 Is implicit evidence that these tombs were sites of pilgrimage even in Jesus' time.

[@ashwith]

@@YardenJZ that makes sense now that you mentioned it. But most of us Catholics don't read Scripture with Jewish eyes so we miss out on all these connections unless we can link it to the OT through typology (I didn't even know about typology till I was in my mid twenties). I'm beginning to see a lot of connections between the NT and Jewish practice not explicitly mentioned in Scripture thanks to Dr. Pitre's work. Seeing that helps makes sense why St. Paul, as Dr Andrew Swafford says, didn't see his life as a conversion but rather a fulfillment (I'm missing the precise word he used) of the faith of his ancestors.

[@deusimperator]

Jewish roots.... most of us who are Jews would say that Catholicism is Judaism in the Olam Haba, The Church does not have Jewish roots, it is the Jewish Faith. Cantors are those who chant at shul. Synagogues even today continue to have cantors. The Tehilim are supposed to be cantored.

[@deusimperator]

Concerning the tombs of tzaddiks and the mention of Matthew 23:29... Type in tomb of Simon haTzaddik in google search. The Hassid run guild tours, like Catholics, to the tombs and shrines of the tzaddikim *rightous/saints). The early Christians were merely following Jewish practices. They held the Liturgy over the tombs of the martyred persons. They were not inventing something new but following an ancient tradition. That tomb of Shimon haTzaddik has been there for 2200 years.

[@markv1974]

@@ashwith thats why bibles are and should be read at mass. The first, second readings and psalms are structured based on typology

[@joelmontero9439]

God bless you ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

[@Sheilamarie2]

I have watched Roy's testimony several times, it's so beautiful, alot of us would love to have that experience! God Bless You both!

[@shortmashins4031]

For Catholic faith, the Virgin Mary is the new eve

[@fredharvey2720]

I wish everyone in life had what Roy went through.

[@bornbranded29]

Roy is a great testament to the truth of our faith. He is snatched by God almighty, without any training in the Christian faith.

[@kimfleury]

Seek and ye shall find. Knock and the door shall be opened. Praised be God forever, He is faithful to His promises.

[@bigbearn1383]

Roy welcome to the Church. What matters is how we love each other. " A way to God..". Right on. God takes us where we are. Let's not wait to be a Saint to become a Saint. God bless you

[@williambullard9599]

It is entirely possible to be a Jew and "BE" a Catholic; it is likewise possible to be "Jewish" as a Catholic without being a "Jew" because the faith is "Jewish". We commonly share our Judaism, pre and post.

[@campurcampur2997]

im catholic too, greeting from indonesia

[@myronmercado]

O my. I've just discovered your live streams. They're amazing. They're people I follow on KZbin. God is really at work on your ministry. Please keep up the great job your doing.

[@karolinakatanowska5960]

Love from Polish Catholic to our Jewish brothers , praying for all Jewish to find the way to our Jewish messiah Jeshua 🙏❤️

[@ilsekuper3045]

One of the main reasons why the old Latin Mass has been replaced by Novus Ordo beside the replacement of the Latin Mass to the local languages, was the prayer against the Jews! As long as most people did not understand what the priest was declaming, most did not even know about this anti-semetic attitude. But, watching this from Germany, I fear that the extreme right-wing has found a hole and a wave to instrumentalise religion for their weird and dangerous politics! This is the reason why the Pope does not want a political movement declared as religeous service. There has been enough prosecution in the name of God. BTW, our Pope has called the Jews as our elder brothers! Continue your good works; I see both arms of the Vatican court as the OT and the NT, Jesus being the corner stone holding everything together. Greetings from Germany 😻🇩🇪🇮🇱🙏🕍⛪

[@fuzzznutt]

May the Lord bless you.

[@marjanaavsec8392]

Glory to God❣️🎺😊

[@frankreading5110]

GOD BLESS YOU DANIEL and ROY xx

[@jamesmeyer4596]

Man. Great videos. Right On!!!

[@asteriaococi2607]

In the devotion to the precious blood we pray for the conversion of the jews. The chaplet consists of 12 beads that represent the jews

[@argelbargel7680]

Schoeman's intro to the Church via the Blessed Mother is fascinating; I don't think I've heard even a gentile convert who came in exactly this way.

[@deusimperator]

Hello AB :)

[@argelbargel7680]

@@deusimperator Hello.

[@deusimperator]

@@argelbargel7680 Have you read The Unintended Reformation by Gregory?

[@argelbargel7680]

@@deusimperator I've heard of it, but I haven't gotten around to it. Most recently, I read a solid discussion in Grafton's The Making of Early Modern Europe.

[@deusimperator]

@@argelbargel7680 What is the starting age of the book?

[@lrose1076]

As a Catholic in Novus Ordo I have not found antisemitism there and have witnessed our priests praying for our Jewish brethren and even acknowledging the Jewish holidays. That said, I'm sure there is and has been antisemitism throughout Church history.

[@vecturhoff7502]

​@po18guyhe held hate against the Jews after failing in convert them

[@user-tz1fd1hl8t]

Abraham was A semite NOT the semite. There are more than on Semitic language. Anti smite is a lie and a trick. There has ALWAYS been jewish attacks on Catholic. Just like the Novus Ordo took away the prayer for conversion of the jews.

[@domidumdum4051]

Hi Daniel! 1) I have a request for You. Could You PLEASE make a video about Apostolic Fathers? I would like to know which writings were important for You and convinced You to join Catholic Church. It can be spiritually beneficial also for those who are not knowing the origins of the Church and who are viewing the Catholic Theology as the effect of later councils (like Nicea, Trent Council etc). Please consider sharing with us Your experience with Apostolic Fathers. You can even make a series on that, because the topic is broad and probably cannot be covered in one video. Maybe You can share passages that were important for You? I mean, learning the very beginning of the church is a great adventure. 2) Roy said that he considers collaboration with One for Israel. I hope so! This group has contributed to my spiritual life and love for Israel as well as for biblical archaeology. BUT, sadly, I discovered they are soooooo anti - Catholic in their rhetoric. Their talks are full of the criticism of the Catholic faith.... I am huge fan of their passion for the Messiah, but I'm also heartbroken that in the SAME time they bring people to faith in Jesus and they hate Catholicism... 3) As a Polish person I would like to show You some polish worship music (yes, Catholic) that is a prayer for the Jews. It is rock-styled, with some Jewish inspiration. It was released on year ago, yet published a week ago on the KZbin. kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4mmg4t4nK6Ih7M The music will be - I hope - Your favorite, it's all immersed in the Scripture, with Jewish symbols, and the Church praying for the Israel to recognize their Messiah.

[@williambullard9599]

Very aware of trolls. I reply once and ignore them. The thing is not to let yourself be trapped into hatchet fighting; reply be respectful and walk away.

[@yeshuadvargas5552]

I'm a cradle Catholic; gentile as far as I know. Though I'm happy that according to my ancestry report it seems I have some Jewish ancestry, praise be to God! Yet, I've always had love and admiration for the Jewish people. I don't understand how you can love Our Lady, or Our Lord for that matter, and have any antisemitism in your heart. It simply makes no sense. I don't mean to "virtue signal", I just sincerely don't understand it. I always remember when a Jew asked St. Josemaría what he thought about him and he said: "The love of my life is a Jew". I believe that should be the answer of every Catholic, Jew or gentile, if they know their faith.

[@onewholovesvenison5335]

Being hateful towards any ethnic group is anti-Christian, because Jesus taught to love your neighbor, and even your enemy. Also, look at 1 John 4:20.

[@kasiaseubert]

I feel the same way. I love Jewish people because my Lord and Savior is Jewish 💛

[@fooberdooge3103]

Yeah, I think it’s important to distinguish between hating someone’s people vs being against the kind of rabbinic Judaism which is antichristic and anti Catholic. Secular society regularly mixes up the two. In my opinion, because the Jews were elected by God to bring salvation to the world, those Jews who vehemently rejected the Messiah and their spiritual descendants ended up becoming the inverse of what God created them for. There have always been two sides of the Jewish people, those who worship the golden calf/Moloch, and the faithful remnant who cling to God and His truth.

[@beverleypettit3577]

Wow Roy, I had no idea that traditional Catholics were so vehemently opposed to Jewish Catholics. My apologies for such madness. Blocking them sounds appropriate. I don't know how I missed this video but thank you. I thoroughly enjoyed listening to both of you. Shalom 🤍 🕊 🤍 Veni Sancte Spiritus Tu 30 April 2024

[@WhiteChocolate74]

That's what's insane and completely illogical. They're Jewish. They're the same race as Jesus, the Apostles, and all the prophets. He died for them first, before us Gentiles. Out of all the people in the world, it's most logical that they be Catholic. Thinking anything else is antisemitic nonsense and completely against the mission of the Church

[@Lucithekiller]

Love this one stay up brotha

[@YardenJZ]

Actually, Jews do have a "St. Anthony"! When losing something, Jews say "Elaha D'Meir, Aneni". Which is Aramaic for "God of Meir, answer me!" It is a reference to Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes (the miracle worker).

[@deusimperator]

That is only for the first part of it. When you have found the object, you have to pay an indulgence.... You have to give to a charity in the name of Rabbi Meir for his soul!!! Can you say indulgences ... 😁😁😁

[@YardenJZ]

Interestingly, the idea of indulgences is not at all foreign to Judaism!

[@deusimperator]

@@YardenJZ of course, almost all Catholic beliefs. customs and practices protestants disagree with are all from Judaism.

[@williambullard9599]

"Nes"!!!!! The miracle. We are ALL "nes", if only we stopped to think on it. It is not the microsurgeon who saves the life with his wonderful surgery skills, from cancer. No!. It is the Man who dreamed the vision of microsurgery that made it possible for that to happen. Man is "the miracle". B'tzelem Elohim.

[@JamesSmith-ge2sg]

Andrew Klavan is an author and screenwriter. He wrote "The Great Good Thing" about his conversion from Judaism to Christianity. He joined the Episcopalians. He waited for his father to die "If you convert I will disown you." before he was baptized.

[@paddyearly]

A wonderful interview with two fantastic converts🙏 God is awesome and conversion stories are a great means to encourage others to follow the path to truth🙏 Ultimately every person must come to know Jesus and when all are in communion we can bring heaven to earth🙏 And of course Jesus is a Jew and yes salvation comes from the Jews🙏 Greetings from Ireland🙏🇨🇮

[@ksiriscool]

As a convert from Buddhist religion, I also experienced rejection from family. It's very heartbreaking

[@CorazonHenares-ov7tj]

In the catechisisof the neocatechumenal way we have been taught the the source of the mass comes from the paschal Seder of the Jews and I feel so grateful to the lord for inspiring the initiators of the way to make this a part of our experience in our understanding the roots of our liturgy.

[@myronmercado]

2 Jewish Catholic converts.❤

[@deusimperator]

"We own the Catholic Church" I have said this a few times dealing with some difficult persons of a particular persuasion. Unfortunately, this is what we are going to do when we have to pull out the ace of spades in the Catholic deck of cards. Many of us, due to our heritage, believe this at some level. This is also the reason why Jews were blinded because the Gentiles who came in would be regarded as second class citizens. The fact is, Catholicism is OUR natural Faith given to us as our birthright. As Jewish Catholics, we have refused to reject (or subsequently reclaimed) our eternal birthright, unlike Esau who did. Catholicism is OUR religion which is practiced by Gentiles because some of us rejected that birthright.

[@sammyrnaj]

My best friends are Israeli Jews. I'm mostly proud of them. When criticized, I vehemently take their defense. I have much more in common with them than my people. My grandfather was Ignatius. Unknowingly, I always used Ignatius of Antioch's reply! Sorry to have disturbed you with all my observations. I'm looking forward to the next vlog! ...to disturb you more! 😅

[@BERNARDOLopez-ic4bk]

I Love Roy he comes from a different point of view of Catholicism. I seen some of his talks and I love them

[@lordofmiracle9307]

May GOD Bless you Both. ST. LUKE 1 (39-56) “THE VISITATION”

[@jacobrahe8726]

Wow I’ve never thought of that the Catholic Church was founded by the Jews! that’s wild

[@thedude4594]

What?

[@sammyrnaj]

Jesus IS the Truth & Salvation. The Light came into the world through the Jews & through David's lineage: Jesus, Mary & Joseph. Though He came through them & for them, thank God they rejected Him so He will come to all the Gentiles. Paul, a Jew also, was pivotal in His zeal to spread the Good News to the world. God, Who so loved the Jews, raised our Jew from the Dead to send Him back a 2nd time to them! 😊

[@romgtr]

Both Jews and Catholics are brothers. The Bible often talks about the conflict between the big brother vs the little brother from Cain vs Able to Esau vs Jacob to the parable of the Prodigal son. The blessings from the Father always go to the little brother. In our case, the Jews are the Big brother and the Catholics are the Little Brother. We are both Jews. Catholics are the Jews that accepted Our Lord Jesus as the Messiah.

[@gatogati2281]

Interesting view! All my life questioning why Jacob stole birthright and why his mother help him to success in stealing? Thank you for providing some answer.

[@romgtr]

@@gatogati2281 Jesus’ story parallel that of the Joseph whose brothers put him into the well for 3 days then sold him to the Ishmaelites for silver and took him to Egypt and subsequently became its ruler. Jesus was sold for silver and was in the tomb for 3 days and His Kingdom became the ruler of Europe. The story ends with his brothers recognizing him and I believe this is how the story of Our Lord will end also. 😊

[@antoniethbennetts4713]

I was born Catholic, and i will die Catholic. When I was young, I remembered my parents would say Jewish are the chosen people because of our beloved Jesus Christ was Jewish, and our blessed Mother Mary was a Jewish too.

[@tony1685]

very, very sad. so much pride and confusion in that statement.

[@williambullard9599]

Studied in a Reform Temple; could not make sense of anything in debate with them; they were facile and flaccid. Ultimately I got the impression that it was "roll your own".

[@mariandogma6466]

Im a traditional Catholic in the “right wing fringe” and I do not condemn you at all. So happy that you are “home”. God bless you both. ❤

[@janettedavis6627]

Tell those antisemites in the Latin Church that the first half of the Tridentine Latin Mass came over from the Apostles. The Lamb without spot and wrinkle that prayer is said in the Tridentine Latin Mass. Jesus Christ and His Apostles attended the Temple in Jerusalem for Passover Prayers every year the symbolic lamb was sacrificed but special prayers had to be said called Passover Prayers (Death of Messiah). We are told On the night He was betrayed He and His Apostles attended the Temple in Jerusalem for Passover Prayers. His Death Prayers are in the Tridentine Mass.

[@francescaderimini4422]

Salvation is from Jesus Christ!

[@christianstephens7213]

As someone who is British descent I wish could find a way to folllow the Celtic Write

[@josephseppe4473]

Great interview! It would also be interesting to invite well-known Messianic author Rabbi Jonathan Cahn to share and perhaps even invite him to consider coming to Catholicism… also have either of you considered Orthodox Christianity?

[@femaleKCRoyalsFan]

Why would they go from Catholic to orthodox?

[@mikaelacash3791]

Being Jewish? Hard. Being Catholic? Also hard. To be both? Even harder! I'm constantly wrestling with my identity as both a Catholic and a Jew. The fringe right-wing Catholics will hate you for holding onto your Jewish identity. The Jews will hate you for "abandoning your Judaism" (even though we haven't. We've fulfilled our Judaism). The Association of Hebrew Catholics helped me a lot with reconciling that you CAN be both, but it's still hard. I'm grateful that at least most Catholics and Jews I've personally met don't mind. A lot of Catholics I meet actually think it's cool that I'm Jewish, though that could just be the particular Catholic circles I stick around. The Jews are just indifferent, especially because I'm involved with the Jewish Federation and they (as an organization, at least) welcome interfaith relations, and welcome Jews of all backgrounds when it comes to participation in events. All in all, no matter how many people wanna protest, I'm honored to be able to call myself a Hebrew Catholic.

[@jeffreydsouza7273]

🙏🙏🙏

[@jessebryant9233]

Basic question: What is the Gospel of Jesus Christ according to the Roman Catholic Church? "...what must I do, that I may be saved?" (Acts 16:30)

[@njohn6995]

How could any christian says loves Jesus and be anti Semitic. I don’t get it.

[@r.c4914]

The devil the father of lies thats how 😄

[@djo-dji6018]

They are ignorant and sinful.

[@augustinetukas3562]

Share some thoughts on the Shabbat

[@auggiekitty-uy6pz]

QUESTION: ROY Can you speak to Roma Catholic or Eastern or Orthodox ctholic? I notice the icon on your wall.

[@heavenianseye2228]

I hope Jonathan Cahn will be converted into Catholicism

[@contrasedevacantism6811]

I'm going to start calling Daniel, "The Cardinal".

[@TheJewishCatholic]

Lol.

[@terrylm235]

Good talk, thanks both. I'm cradle Catholic and have always believed and the apparent lack of fervour and urgency of the Church to evagelise Jews is best explained, I believe, by the Siri Thesis, which I have held to, since 2012.

[@user-uy5lc1zb8g]

Terrible comment

[@brucebarber4104]

At 27:23 something went across the screen from right to left over Roy.

[@TheJewishCatholic]

Never noticed that. Interesting that it happens just as he concludes his Marian apparition.

[@anthonycastan524]

🙏

[@nonfecittaliter4361]

Saint Paul adressed clearly the subject in his letters on the need to leave behind the old precepts of the Mosaic Law and embrace the new freedom of the Children of God by means of the Faith (faithful belief and full obedience like the one of our Father Abraham) in Jesus The Messiah and Son of God. So, being under the New and eternal Berith in the Messiah (messianic times we live in) imply a new relationship with God with new rules for His new and eternal Kingdom (which starts in the Earth in His Church). As a matter of fact, Christ explains that the Law will be now in the hearts of the faithful and accomplished as a work of the Holy Spirit, not by the effort and merit of the person but by the Grace (Gift) from God and the fidelity and obedience to Him from the believer to make it fruitful in good deeds.

[@heavenianseye2228]

Can a Non Jewish wear Talit when saying prayers? Or reading the Bible? Is is Bad? I do it for the reverence for God. Thanks in Advance!

[@djo-dji6018]

I don't see why you would want to wear a talit, your reverence doesn't increase when you wear it.

[@sammyrnaj]

The original Church started in the Levant. If Christianity survived in the West is because of our resistance against invasions & persecutions & genocides up to the last century, to preserve our Faith...like the Jews. You belong to OUR CATHOLIC DENOMINATION, where we've continued the Jewish rights & chant & pray in Old Syriac.

[@jacquelynwhite500]

It's shameful that some Catholics are anti-sematic, and even directly to your face. These people forget that our Lord and our Lady are Jewish!!! All of the Apostles were Jewish. The Catholic Church is a continuation of the Jewish faith. It's the fulfillment.

[@luzdemoore7070]

To the Harvard professor ,something important is separate church and politicians. God is only justice, politicians are the Caesar.

[@BERNARDOLopez-ic4bk]

Flash News, all the apostles are jews, Our Lord and God, was Jewish and we are the gentiles that came into the Church. I agreed with him even though I was in the church since birth!!!

[@janettedavis6627]

That's a shame that the Traditional Tridentine Latin Mass followers would be so Anti Jewish. When I was a child in Ireland pre Vatican11 we had great respect for Jews they were the Chosen People of God still and that God revealed Himself to the Jews only not the Gentiles for 4,000 years and Jesus picked up on Jews to continue God's Salvation History. Luther started his own Church he abandoned the Jewish side of the Church.

[@wms72]

Isn't it insulting to Jesus and Mary to say you have to hold your nose to join His Church?

[@jackharris6036]

Nothing from him on Audible?

[@myronmercado]

What are you doing in Tokyo?

[@danicacosic909]

Bravo, thanks be to the Lord God Messiah, Jesus Christ, He moves jews hearts with His mighty love and Salvation. He surely intends to save, save, save in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit. Amen. Pre Messianic and post Messianic are both in Christ our Lord.. Laus Tibi Christe! Laus Maria! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🤴

[@bornbranded29]

Daniel seems like a Hispanic, so I'm guessing he is Latin American Jew. I know a few from Latin America - whose parents or grandparents came during the Holocaust.

[@bornbranded29]

@Jerin George im puerto rican - and we have a sort of radar for one another, so i figured. I have a friend from Uruguay who is a Jewish South American. It's an interesting situation, when living in the US, because they have both these identities.

[@bornbranded29]

Just watched the video you cited. He has a very heavy Puerto Rican Spanish accent - which he says comes from his family having lived in Puerto Rico. Interesting. But ultimately, he is Sephardic (granddaddy Jews, so to speak).